Masah Vmatan - English — Nitzavim Vayelech (2026-08-31)

THE WERDIGER EDITION
BUSINESS WEEKLY
RESTORING THE PRIMACY OF CHOSHEN MISHPAT UNDER THE AUSPICES OF HARAV CHAIM KOHN, SHLITA
Issue #811 | Nitzavim-Vayelech | September 4, 2026 | 22 Elul 5786
לע״נ הרב יחיאל מיכל בן ר' משה אהרן אורליאן
CASE FILE Rabbi Meir Orlian
Writer for the Business Halacha Institute
BHI HOTLINE
לע"נ הרב אהרן בן הרב גדליהו ע"ה Submitted by the Beis Hora’ah
With Rosh Hashanah
ALIYAH
תשפ"ה
ערב ראש השנה
AMBULANCE Naftali, a 25-year-old kollel yungerman, was riding his bicycle to kollel approaching, we are
CALL
one morning along the quiet streets near his home. As he approached
a curb, his wheel suddenly skidded. In an instant, he lost his balance AUCTION entering the season in
which aliyos (and other
and went flying. honors) are auctioned
Naftali landed hard on the pavement. His leg hurt, but thankfully, he in shuls, often for large sums of money. Several
had been wearing his helmet, as he always did. The helmet had protected his head from what could scenarios have been presented in which bidding is
have been a serious injury! artificially inflated:
A neighbor, Mr. Neiss, helped him slowly to his feet. 1. Someone who is not planning to daven in a shul
“I think I’m okay,” Naftali said, examining his leg. “It’s probably just some bruises.” wants to purchase an aliyah for someone who is. He
tells the gabbai in advance which aliyah he would like
Mr. Neiss wasn’t so sure. to buy, and that he is willing to pay up to a specific
“You should get checked out,” he said, taking out his phone. “You could have a fracture, and you don’t amount for it. When selling the aliyos, although the
want to take chances with your head, either.” highest competing bid is far below that amount, the
Within minutes, Hatzalah and an ambulance arrived. Mr. Neiss encouraged Naftali to go to the hospital. gabbai continues bidding higher and higher, as though
“You may feel fine now, but sometimes you don’t realize that you’ve suffered a concussion,” he said. he has an actual bidder, until he reaches the maximum
“Better to make sure!” the buyer preauthorized.
Naftali went with the ambulance. At the hospital, the doctors examined him and quickly discharged 2. Someone present bids on an aliyah he does not
him, confirming that there were just some bruises. want to buy, with the sole intention of driving up the
Several weeks later, though, Naftali received a large bill for the ambulance. Naftali appreciated Mr. price so that the shul will earn more money, causing
Neiss’s effort, but was frustrated about the bill he incurred. the buyer to spend more on the aliyah.
“Why should I have to pay?” he asked his chavrusa. “If Mr. Neiss chose to call an ambulance, maybe he 3. The gabbai realizes that a wealthy member of
BUSINESS HALACHA INSTITUTE: the shul is set on purchasing a specific aliyah. In an
should be responsible for the cost?”
attempt to induce him to pay more for it, the gabbai
“The ambulance was for 1937 OCEAN AVENUE
you, though,” BROOKLYN
his chavrusa replied.NY 11230 pretends that others are submitting competing bids,
“But I told Mr. Neiss that I was okay,” Naftali countered. “He insisted that I need to be checked.” forcing the wealthy person to keep raising his bid so
“Yet, in the end, you agreed to go,” his chavrusa pointed out. he will win the auction.
Not convinced fully, Naftali decided to ask Rabbi Dayan: Q. Are these practices permitted? If not, is the buyer
“Who is liable for the cost of the ambulance?” nevertheless obligated to pay the inflated price?
“In almost all countries, the person who alerted the emergency medical system and summoned the In the first case, the buyer is not obligated to pay
ambulance is not responsible for its cost,” replied Rabbi Dayan. “Rather, the responsibility is on the more than the lowest price for which the gabbai could
injured person.” have obtained the aliyah on his behalf. As the buyer’s
shaliach (agent), the gabbai was obligated to obtain the
“If the injured person declined to be taken to the hospital by ambulance, the ambulance company
aliyah at the lowest possible price, not inflate the price.
usually cannot bill him for the call. Nonetheless, if the medics performed physical tests or provided
When he acted contrary to his mandate, his shelichus
medical care at the site, the company may bill partially for these services rendered. (appointment as an agent) was invalidated (Shulchan
However, if the patient agreed to go in the ambulance to the hospital, his decision to go and avail Aruch, Choshen Mishpat 182:2). The buyer is obligated
himself of the service obligates him in the payment. He cannot shift the responsibility to those around to pay slightly more than the highest competing bid,
him who summoned the ambulance and/or suggested that he go to the hospital. however, because he did benefit from the purchase
It is true, in certain cases, that when someone relies on the professional opinion of another and (neheneh - ibid 264:4).
thereby suffers a loss, the professional carries liability for the loss. For example, if a vendor accepted In the second case, since the “competitor” would have
a questionable coin based on a moneychanger who erroneously vouched that it was acceptable, the been stuck paying the price of any bid he offered had
moneychanger is sometimes liable (C.M. 306:6) the buyer bowed out, the buyer is obligated to pay the
However, there are several limitations that are relevant to our case. full amount of his final bid, despite the competitor’s
THE WERDIGER EDITION - לע"נ הרה"ח ר' נחמי'ה בן הרה"ח ר' שלמה אלימלך ז"ל- DEDICATED BY HIS SON R’ SHLOME WERDIGER
BEIS HORAAH BUSINESS SERVICE DIVISION AWARENESS & EDUCATION
Ask the Rav, Email correspondence / Arbitration and Mediation Rabbinical Consultation / Banking and Iska / Contract Drafting Business Weekly / Hebrew Masa Umatan / Shiurim and Chaburis / Kollel l’Dayanis Choshen Mishpat
/ Small Claims / Wills and Estate Planning / Halacha Hotline / Shabbos Initiative / Industry-specific Seminars Curriculum / Seforim & Publications / Self-learning Program / Halacha on the Daf
CASE FILE BHI HOTLINE
First, the person must state to the professional that he is relying on him, or artificial inflation of the price. (See, however, Tzohar 13, p. 433.)
circumstances must indicate that he is relying on him alone, in undertaking the The third case is more complex, because the gabbai invented bids
potential financial risk (ibid; Shach 306:12). that didn’t actually exist.
Second, it must be clear the advisor erred in his advice. In this case, the fact that The Chida (Yosef Ometz 57) was asked about “a prominent yerei
Naftali was not admitted to the hospital does not mean that the trip was in vain. Shomayim” who wanted his shul to earn more from the auction of
the kibbudim (honors), so he informed the gabbai that he would bid
Often it is necessary to go to the hospital and be checked, even when there is no
against sincere bidders in order to entice them to keep raising their
apparent injury. It is hard to ascertain that the trip was frivolous.
bids, but if he would get stuck with an aliyah, he would pay the shul
Thus, if the injured person agreed to go in the ambulance, he implicitly accepts only half the amount he bid. (For example, if the bid before his “winning
responsibility for the payment. In some situations, when time is not urgent and bid” was $180, and he bid $200, he would pay only $100.)
medical care during transport is not necessary, it might be cheaper to take a taxi The Chida writes that this clearly constitutes geneivas daas (misleading
than travel in an ambulance, but one must be cautious in choosing so. another person; see Choshen Mishpat 228:6; cf. Tzedakah U’Mishpat 7 fn.
5; Titein Emes L’Yaakov 5:3). It also involves falsehood, so a person who
“In many cases, especially those involving traffic accidents, the car or health
acts this way transgresses the principle of “She’eiris Yisrael lo yaasu
insurance will cover much of the cost,” concluded Rabbi Dayan. “Regardless, if the
avla velo yedabru chazav — the remnant of Yisrael shall not commit
injured person consented to go, he cannot transfer the financial responsibility to injustice and shall not speak falsely” (Tzefania 3:13).
the one who summoned the ambulance or advised him to go, unless he specifically The Chida also cites the Gemara’s criticism (Bava Basra 8b) of gabbaim
made this clear and the advice proved baseless.” who pressure people to give tzedakah. Certainly, he writes, one
Verdict: If someone was sick or injured and another person summoned an should not exert such pressure when the money is for communal
ambulance, if the patient consented to go in the ambulance, he (or the relevant needs, not for the needy, and the buyer may feel compelled to keep
raising his bid to a price he cannot afford. (There are certain instances
insurance company) is liable for the cost, not the person who summoned the
in which a community may force members to participate in tzedakah
ambulance or advised him to go.
campaigns. For discussion regarding whether deception is permitted in
such instances in place of coercion, see Shevet HaLevi 2:119; Ateres
MONEY MATTERS Moshe, Yoreh Dei’ah 189; and Teshuvos V’Hanhagos 4:216.)
MONEY MATTERS Onaas Devarim, Falsehood Returning to our third case, the gabbai’s fabrication of nonexistent
and Geneivas Daas #16 bids might involve a more serious sin than geneivas daas; it may
Based on writings of Harav Chaim Kohn, shlita Mistaken Presumption constitute actual gezel (monetary theft). The buyer continues
'לע"נ ר' יחיאל מיכל ב"ר חיים וזוג' חי' בת ר to raise his bids in such a case only because he believes that
שמואל חיים ע"ה a competitor is genuinely willing to pay the amount of the
competing bids, when, in fact, no such competitor exists. The
Q: My mother came by public transportation to visit. I was walking to the store, extra money he bids once actual competitors have stopped bidding
and happened to pass the bus stop just as she got off the bus. “How nice of you to might therefore be gezel.
come greet me!” she immediately exclaimed. How should I respond? The question then becomes whether the gabbai must rectify the
situation by informing the buyer that he is obligated to pay only the
A: If a person mistakenly presumes, of his own initiative, that you did him a favor amount he bid after the last actual competing bid.
or honored him, and should have considered the possibility that this was not done
Some poskim write that although this constitute geneivas daas, it may
for him – there is no need to alert him that his presumption was erroneous. It is not be gezel, reasoning that since the proceeds are going to tzedakah,
not considered geneivas da’as, since you did nothing to mislead him; he misled the buyer would presumably agree to pay the higher amount even if
himself (C.M. 228:6). he finds out that the gabbai was artificially raising the price. According
Thus, there is no need to tell your mother that you were on the way to the store to these poskim, since a person is not obligated to make restitution
for geneivas daas, the gabbai’s deception does not absolve the buyer
and met her by chance. You can simply say: “It’s always nice to see you!”
from paying his final bidding price (see Pis’chei Choshen, Geneivah 15
Moreover, even if the person had no reason to consider otherwise, some poskim n. 22).
maintain that you may remain quiet, and it is not a lack of truthfulness, since Others argue that we cannot make such a presumption; if it is possible
telling her that you were on the way to the store might insult or embarrass her that the buyer would not agree to pay the higher price if he knew
(Hilchos Mishpat 228:6[9]). the truth, then causing him to keep raising his bid does constitute
gezel (see Shaarei Tzedek, p. 411). Since the sale was conducted under a
Nonetheless, you should not respond or act in a way that would indicate that you
false premise, regardless of whether such a bid constitutes a kinyan
came to greet her, since that would constitute giving a false impression and be
(acquisition) or a neder (see BHI #678), it was made in error. The buyer
considered geneivas da’as. is therefore absolved from paying any more than the amount he bid
For questions on monetary matters, arbitrations, legal documents, wills, ribbis, & Shabbos, Please
before the gabbai began to artificially inflate the price (see Vayishma
contact our confidential hotline at 877.845.8455 or ask@businesshalacha.com Moshe 3:48-49 and Tzohar 13, p. 433).
PLACE YOUR LOGO HERE IT WILL BE SEEN BY 30,000 PEOPLE
NL@BUSINESSHALACHA.COM
(718) 233-3845 #201
Car Rental
718-633-2500
reservations@sensiblecarrentalbklyn.com
732- 886-5430
BHI | 1937 Ocean Avenue | Brooklyn, NY 11230 | 718-233-3845 | ask@businesshalacha.com | www.businesshalacha.com
