TORAS AVIGDOR - ENGLISH — Nitzavim Vayelech (2026-08-31)

VA
ZAVIM- YEILECH
NIT
RAV AVIGDOR MILLER ZT"L
BASED ON HIS BOOKS, TAPES & WRITINGS OF TALMIDIM
T H E P RO P H E T ’ S M E S SAG E
RAV AVIGDOR MILLER ZT"L
CONTENTS
Part I. The Criticizer - 1
Part II. The Exaggerator - 4
Part III. The Truth-Teller - 8
infraction and therefore they toed the line of duty.
Part I. The Criticizer They kept every smallest thing because they were
always thinking, “What will Moshe Rabbeinu say?”
Moshe Rabbeinu’s Final Words
Drilling Through Mountains
When we read in this week’s sedrah some of the
last exhortations of Moshe Rabbeinu — to the Am Because what happened when you crossed the
Yisroel, to the Leviim — we see that his words are line of din? Moshe didn’t stand for it. “The Will of
quite harsh: ˙י ∆‡˙ ∆מ ¿רי¿ ָך ¿ו ∆‡˙ ָﬠ ¿ר ּ ¿פ ָך ַה ָּ˜ ׁ ∆˘ה ≈הןƒּ ֹכי יָ ַ„ ¿עƒ ּכי ָ‡נƒ Hashem must stand! If we’re going to be the Torah
∆ ƒרים ¡היƒ ע ָּמ ∆כם ַמ ¿מƒ ּני ַחיƒ „∆ ֹ“ – ¿ ּבעוFor
˙יƒ ֹּכי ַ‡ ֲח ≈רי מוƒ עם ה' ¿ו ַ‡ףƒ י˙ם Nation, then the Torah must be allowed to drill
I know your disobedience and stiffneckedness. See through mountains if needed. „ּ ין ∆‡˙ ָה ָהרƒ ּ˜ֹב ַהƒ !יThat’s
that even while I am still alive with you, you have the way of the Torah Nation!”
been rebellious against Hashem; how much more so You know what it means to have a Torah Nation,
after my death!” (Devarim 31:27). He spoke with a nation that will be loyal forever? They have to be
teeth! Very harsh! forged in fire! And so it went into their bones, “What
And it wasn’t an exception — that's how he will Moshe say?!” Even a thousand years later, they
always spoke to the people. Moshe Rabbeinu, with were still thinking about it. You know, Flavius
his eagle eyes, was always looking over our shoulders Josephus lived at the end of Bayis Sheini — he wasn’t
and he was a very stern character. It was mentioned in the Midbar; it was more than a thousand years
here once that the words ¿˘ׂ ַמח מ ׁ ∆ֹ˘הƒ יare in the siddur, after Moshe Rabbeinu lived. But listen now to what
not in the Chumash. In the Chumash you don’t find he wrote in the book Contra Apion, a remarkable
that; it’s only ּי ¿˜ˆֹף מ ׁ ∆ֹ˘הƒ ַוand again ּי ¿˜ˆֹף מ ׁ ∆ֹ˘הƒ ו.ַ All the statement: “Every one of us, even today, if he's
time he was telling them that they have to keep the thinking about doing something wrong, he's
letter of the law, that they have to become better. thinking what would Moshe Rabbeinu say about
him.”
Don’t think it was easy for people to live with
Moshe. Everybody was afraid of him. They knew Now, Josephus, you have to know, wasn’t the
that he wouldn't keep quiet for the smallest most frum Jew you could find — far from it. He was
CHODESH ELUL
ltctechgroup.com
EasyPrint Sponsor
An aliyos neshama for our dear parents
R' Yitzchak ben Chaim & Frimsche bas Shraga Faivish z"l
Mark & Phil Halpern Toronto, Canada
WEALTHinsurance.com
an ordinary Jew at best. And so when he speaks, it from good sources. Every Friday night, you start
he’s telling us the thoughts of the regular Jew on right away in Lechu Neranena and you’re criticizing
the street. And he says that Moshe Rabbeinu lived them: עים ׁ ָ˘נָ ה ָ‡˜וּט ¿ ּב„וֹ רƒ “ – ַ‡ ¿ר ָ ּבFor forty years I
on in the minds of the Jewish people. When someone quarreled with that generation,” Hashem says. ָו‡ ַֹמר
was contemplating doing something wrong, his “ – ַﬠם ּ˙ ≈ֹﬠי ≈ל ָבב ≈הםI said they’re a nation whose heart,
first thought was, “What would Moshe Rabbeinu whose mind wandered away from the truth, ‡ֹ ¿ו ≈הם ל
think of me?” – יָ ¿„ע ּו ¿„ ָר ָכיand that they did not know My ways”
Now, such a thing doesn’t happen by itself. It (Tehillim 95:10). So there you are! Every week we
comes as a result of something. It was a result of become more and more convinced that they were
firmness. And that’s why at that time Hakadosh no good.
Baruch Hu needed the most firm, the most emphatic We? We are very good, no question about it. All
man that the world ever had — a teacher, a rebbe, a of us saying Kabbolas Shabbos are very good;
ruler who was the strictest in every detail of the nothing wrong with us. Whether you live in
Torah. It wasn’t always “sugar and spice and Williamsburg and you have a long beard and payos,
everything nice”; we needed a Moshe Rabbeinu to whether you live out in the Five Towns and you have
teach us what Torah means. no beard and no payos, whatever it is, everybody
knows he’s pretty good. But they were very bad.
Tough Love
That we know.
Of course, we know that no one loved the Am
Yisroel more than Moshe. Moshe prayed for them Of course, it’s all wrong. Stick around till the
more than anyone else. You remember right after end and hopefully we’ll have time to explain the
he publicly castigated them for being mamrim, for possuk, what it really means, but first let’s hear what
being rebellious, what did he say? “I prayed for you people who know about the subject said about it.
for forty days and forty nights” (Devarim 9:25). He
The Tana’im Clarify
didn’t say, “You’ll suffer the consequences and too
bad.” He davened for them! For forty days and nights! In Sanhedrin (110b), we read: מ ¿„ ָ ּבר ≈‡ין ָל ∆הםƒּ „ּ וֹ ר ַה
That’s called ahavas Yisroel! ≈ It’s an opinion there that the
‡ח ∆ל˜ ָלעוֹ ָלם ַה ָ ּב.
Generation of the Wilderness has no share in the
And yet his great love for his people was most
World to Come. And he quotes the end of that
demonstrated by his strict and constant surveillance
possuk in Lechu Neranena: פיƒ ּ ‡ַ ˙י ¿ ּבƒּ ׁ ¿˘ ַ ּב ¿עƒ – ֲ‡ ׁ ∆˘ר נI swore
and stern rebuke, because it was that which caused
in My wrath, ˙יƒ ‡ם י¿ בֹ‡וּן ∆‡ל ¿מנו ָּחƒ – that this generation
the nation to achieve the superlative excellence of a
will never come to My resting place (ibid. 11). That’s
Torah Nation.
the opinion of Rabi Akiva.
And what was the result? The greatest
generation in our history! I told you the results But Rabi Eliezer says, ‡ין ≈הן ָלעוֹ ָלםƒ יﬠ ∆זר ‡וֹ ≈מר ָ ּב
∆ לƒ ‡¡ ּביƒ ַר
were felt a thousand years later, but that was only a ‡“ – ַה ָ ּבOf course, they’re in Olam Haba! ‡ ¿ספ ּוƒ ׁ ∆˘ ∆ ּנ ¡‡ ַמר
shirayim of what it was. A thousand years later the ס ָי„יƒ לי ֲחƒ – Like Hashem said, ‘Gather together to Me
nation was still running with that push of the My devoted ones, י˙י ֲﬠ ≈לי ָז ַבחƒ רƒ – ּכ ¿ֹר ≈˙י ¿בthe ones who
Generation of the Wilderness, but they didn’t made a covenant with Me with sacrifices.’” It means
compare to them at all. when they accepted the Torah; they brought
korbanos. “They are chassidai, My devoted ones,
Friday Night Misconceptions and I will gather them into Me.” “Into Me” means
You know, about the Dor Hamidbar there are with Me in the Afterlife. Those who accepted the
misconceptions because Jews are constantly saying Torah, that generation, will be with Me forever in
that they’re no good. And the truth is you’re saying Olam Haba.
2 / TORAS AVIGDOR . NITZAVIM-VAYEILECH . THE PROPHET’S MESSAGE
But what do I do with the possuk that says, “I Rabi Akiva said that the Dor Hamidbar has no share
swore in My wrath that they won’t come to My in the World to Come. Listen to his words: “ ּביƒ ׁ ַ˘ ¿ב ַ˜ ּה ַר
resting place”? So Rabi Eliezer says it means, “I ָ ˜ƒ – ֲﬠRabi Akiva has forsaken his piety.”
סי„ו ≈ּ˙ ּהƒ יב‡ ַל ֲח
swore, but I retracted. I changed My mind.” When He has thrown away his piety. You hear such a
Hashem swears to do good things, He never takes it criticism of Rabi Akiva? By Rabi Akiva saying such a
back. But when He swears to do bad things, He thing, he lost his piety. Of course, it doesn’t mean
takes it back if you do teshuvah. And the Dor he lost his piety altogether; it means he had done
Hamidbar did such a perfect teshuvah that Hashem something that’s a very great impiety.
retracted. – ׁ ∆˘ ∆ ּנ ¡‡ ַמרAnd Rabi Yochanan quotes a possuk
So we have now two opinions; we have Rabi (Yirmiyah 2:2) to show how great that Generation of
Akiva and Rabi Eliezer. Now, when there’s a the Midbar actually was. Hashem said to Yirmiyah
machlokes of Tana’im, we have to listen to what the ָ – ָהל ¿ֹך ¿ו ָ˜ ָרGo and proclaim
Hanavi, ם ≈ל‡מֹרƒ ‡˙ ¿ב ָ‡ ¿זנ≈ י י¿ רו ׁ ָּ˘ ַל
Sages who came afterwards had to say about it. in the ears of Yerushalayim; that means the Jewish
What did they decide? people, and tell them as follows: ' ּכֹה ָ‡ ַמר ה- Hashem
is speaking and He says, ¿ךƒ˙י ָל ¿ך ∆ח ∆ס„ נ¿ עו ַּריƒּ “ – ָז ַכ ¿רI
Rabi Yochanan’s Psak
remember for you the kindliness of your young days
ּבי יוֹ ָחנָ ןƒ – ָ‡ ַמר ַר ָ ּבה ַ ּבר ַ ּבר ָחנָ ה ָ‡ ַמר ַרAh! Rabi Yochanan
towards Me, ¿ךƒ – ַ‡ ֲה ַב˙ ¿ּכל ּול ָֹ˙יthe love of your bridal
is speaking. But before I tell you what he says, I want
days when you became My bride. At Matan Torah,
to introduce Rabi Yochanan to you. Rabi Yochanan
you became My nation; I took you to Me and I
is found on every page of the Talmud. He’s an Amora,
remember, מ ¿„ ָ ּברƒּ – ∆ל ¿כ ּ≈˙ ¿ך ַ‡ ֲח ַרי ַ ּבhow you went after Me
but he was a chief teacher of all the Sages in Eretz
into the wilderness, לֹ‡ ¿זרו ָּﬠהı – ¿ ּב ∆‡ ∆רinto a land where
Yisroel. The entire Talmud Yerushalmi is either Rabi
nothing grew.”
Yochanan personally or his disciples in Eretz Yisroel.
It’s interesting to know that. The Talmud Yerushalmi Now, what is the possuk saying? What’s Yirmiyah
is all Rabi Yochanan. And in the Talmud Bavli he’s saying in the Name of Hashem? Hashem is telling
almost as prolific. The Bavli is almost all Rabi the Jewish nation that forever and ever He’s going
Yochanan. He’s found on every page. to give them credit for what their forefathers did.
“Out of love for the Dor Hamidbar, I’ll never forsake
And suppose there’s a difference of opinion
you. I’m going to always favor the Jewish nation in
between Rav and Shmuel, these great Sages of
this world and the next because of the merit of that
Bavel, everybody knows we follow Rav in issurim
generation who went into the wilderness after Me.”
and we follow Shmuel in money matters (Bechoros
49b). But when Rav and Shmuel are saying something And so Rabi Yochanan concludes, ‡יםƒ רים ָ ּבƒ ו ָּמה ֲ‡ ≈ח
together, it surely is authoritative. ריƒ ַרב ו ׁ ¿ּ˘מו ≈ּ‡ל ¿„ּ ָ‡ ¿מ ּב ¿זכו ָּ˙םƒ – “If others will come to the Next World because
ַּ˙ ¿ר ַוי¿ ה ּוis very authoritative! You can rely on that! of the merit of the Generation of the Midbar, ≈הם ַﬠ ¿ˆ ָמן
– ל ֹ‡ ָּכל ׁ ∆˘ ≈ּכןthen they themselves surely.”
Until Rabi Yochanan opens his mouth. If Rabi
Yochanan speaks then his words outweigh their So now we have the final verdict of the Talmud!
words. The halacha is like Rabi Yochanan even Rabi Yochanan is the voice of the Talmud. As I said,
against the great teachers Rav and Shmuel (Rosh, he’s the whole Talmud Yerushalmi and he is also the
Bava Kamma 5:11). So now you know who Rabi entire Talmud Bavli. That’s the verdict!
Yochanan is.
Final Arguments
The Talmud’s Verdict Now, just in case you're not convinced yet, so to
So let’s listen now to what Rabi Yochanan says close the case here’s a statement in Medrash
in this subject; what he said when he heard that Tehillim (119). It says, ימי ָ„ ∆ר ¿ך
≈ מƒ ˙¿ – ַ‡ ׁ ¿˘ ≈ריhow fortunate
3 / TORAS AVIGDOR . NITZAVIM-VAYEILECH . THE PROPHET’S MESSAGE
are those whose way is perfect. 'כים ¿ ּב˙וֹ ַר˙ הƒ – ַההוֹ ¿לAnd So now let’s picture the real picture. We’re
they walk in the Torah of Hashem. They’re perfect walking for three days in the desert. Forget three
and they walk in the Toras Hashem; who’s that? days — suppose you had to walk a half a day and
So the Medrash says: it’s talking about one there’s no water available. Also no Cherry Cola.
generation in our history: מ ¿„ ָ ּברƒּ י„ים ָהי ּו „ּ וֹ ר ַהƒ סƒ ימים ַו ֲח
ƒ מƒ ˙¿ּ Nothing. Would you complain?
– Those of the Generation of the Wilderness were But let’s go before that. Let’s start at the
perfect and were chassidim. It means they were beginning. You’re in Egypt and somebody came
entirely devoted to Hashem! along and said, “Look. I have a project. Let’s get out
And so you can put away all your doubts now. of this place. We’ll travel someplace better. Hashem
Forget about what you thought, what your rebbe in sent me and I’m taking you to a good land.”
cheder said. The Dor Hamidbar was the best! So you say, “Alright. I’m trusting you, however.
I’m taking your word for it so no shenanigans!”
Moshe’s Final Critique
And how did they become so good? It’s only And now he’s taking you for a long hike. And you
because they had Moshe telling them off all the walk and walk and walk and walk, and not a single
time. All the time, he was pointing out the smallest grocery store in sight, not a single candy store.
faults and criticizing them with the harshest words. “Hey, what’s this?” you start yelling. “Six hours
And so now he was saying goodbye, and it was walking, nothing to eat?!”
his last opportunity, his last chance to mold these Now, let’s say you didn’t walk six hours. Suppose
great people into the Torah Nation. The living you walked for three days. And forget about no
presence of Moshe had been an immense grocery stores. There’s nothing to drink! It’s a
inducement for proper behavior, and now that he miracle you could still walk. And not only you’re
was prepared to take leave of his people, Moshe walking there, but you happen to have a wife and
fully knew how very great the loss of his presence children too, little children. And their tongues are
would be. And so on his last days he criticized! He hanging out by the middle of the first day. And your
said, “ ּני ַחיƒ „∆ ֹ˙י ∆‡˙ ∆מ ¿רי¿ ָך ¿ו ∆‡˙ ָﬠ ¿ר ּ ¿פ ָך ַה ָּ˜ ׁ ∆˘ה ≈הן ¿ ּבעוƒּ ֹכי יָ ַ„ ¿עƒ ּכי ָ‡נƒ heart is breaking for them.
˙יƒ ֹּכי ַ‡ ֲח ≈רי מוƒ עם ה' ¿ו ַ‡ףƒ י˙ם ∆ ƒרים ¡היƒ ע ָּמ ∆כם ַמ ¿מƒ – I know your
So in the middle of the first day, you’re thinking,
rebellious nature and your stiffneckedness. Even now
“What’s happening here? Look at the children!”
while I’m alive you’ve been rebellious with Hashem,
and all the more so after I die” (Devarim 31:27). And your wife is saying, “Chaim! Look! Don’t
keep quiet! The children are dying!”
Part II. The Exaggerator So you say to her, “Wait. Wait. Moshe Rabbeinu
told us that it’s okay. We have to have faith in him.”
A Real Picture
So your wife waits another hour and then she’s
Now, the question is, if they were such a holy frantic. And the children are really fainting. It looks
nation like I am putting them up to be — not me; it’s like they’re going to collapse. And you understand it
the psak of the Torah — so what about all the stories because you’re fainting yourself.
that we know about how much trouble they made?
Don’t we know they were always complaining? People Aren’t Angels
ּנ ׁ ¿˘ ּ∆˙הƒ ּי ּל ֹנ ּו ָה ָﬠם ַﬠל מ ׁ ∆ֹ˘ה ּ≈ל‡מֹר ַמהƒ – ַוThey complained And another day passes. A day passes without
to Moshe, “What will we drink?” (Shemos 15: 22-24). drinking water! And another day! מיםƒ ָ ׁ ∆˘˙ יúֹ ˘¿ ׁ – ַו ≈ ּי ¿לכ ּו
Right away, complaining. That’s our picture of them: They went three days! (ibid. 15:22). At the end of
complainers. three days they said something. What do you expect
4 / TORAS AVIGDOR . NITZAVIM-VAYEILECH . THE PROPHET’S MESSAGE
them to be, angels? If they wouldn’t have complained, other people, the Generation of the Wilderness was
we could say they’re lunatics. a perfect generation. They were crowded together
And what did they do? They offered a polite — at least two million people! Now imagine two
complaint. They should have taken stones and million Arabs for forty years. How many murders
smashed his head! That’s what you’d do! And not would there have been? Imagine two million Puerto
after three days! After a half day you would take Ricans crowded together in a small space for forty
stones and break his head! And they went three years. How many deeds of adultery would there
days and didn’t break anybody’s head. They have been? Two million Germans for forty years.
complained a little bit. How many crimes would have been committed?
So what about it? It’s a glorious nation. On the In the Midbar, nothing is reported about any
contrary, that episode tells you it’s a glorious nation! crime at all. What happened? One man was found
The trouble is when we learned Chumash, our gathering wood on Shabbos. In forty years that’s
rebbe put on his spectacles and the spectacles were the only one crime that was done. When the mann
as black as could be. And he was teaching, “Three fell they were told not to pick the mann, מן ָה ָﬠםƒ יָ ¿ˆ‡ ּו,
days and they went and they asked for water! Such and a few went out to pick the mann, to see what’s
a wicked people, hehe.” doing. But they didn't find anything so they didn't
Ask your rebbe to go two hours without water. do it. That's in forty years, and that's all.
Slabodka Chumash Lessons And therefore, it was a generation that was as
perfect as could be. Not a single case of committing
I once gave a speech about this. I was speaking
adultery! Not a single case of incest! That generation
to lady teachers. There was a meeting someplace
was the most perfect generation that ever existed.
and they asked me to speak to them. I said, “You’re
Never again did they have an equal. Not only they
teaching antisemitism.”
didn't have an equal generation; no generation ever
It’s the truth. Imagine a pious lady teacher. She came close to them in greatness.
knows Chumash, she knows Rashi. She was never in
the Slabodka shmuessen. She knows it like she Unsnagging the Snagged
learned it, superficially, and she puts in all the
However, it remains to be explained all the
venom, all the poison she can into these words:
bitter criticisms. That’s what snags people. They
“They asked for water and they rebelled. They were
read Moshe Rabbeinu’s words of criticism in Parshas
complaining and badgering and crying. Such
Vayeilech and many other places too and they’re
wickedness!”
snagged.
So if you teach Chumash that way, of course
you’ll raise up a generation of antisemites. And I remember years ago, I had a big argument with
that’s what the Jewish people have become by a man in my shul. He couldn’t tolerate what I was
learning Chumash in such irresponsible ways. saying that Hakadosh Baruch Hu loved the Dor
It’s not realistic! It’s common sense, after three Hamidbar intensely. I said that those who went out
days, if they’re still speaking polite words, then of Mitzrayim were beloved by Hashem, that He
they’re the most noble people that ever lived. called them yedidim. ˙ ֹ˙ ׁ ¿˘ ָ ּבחוƒ מירוֹ ˙ ¿וƒ י„ים ¿זƒ „ƒ ¿ – ¿ונָ ¿˙נ ּו יHis
They’re a perfect generation! beloved ones sang Az Yashir to Him. But he was
accustomed to what they learned in cheder as a
A Criminal Nation? child — that they made an eigel, they’re no good.
Of course there is no such thing as perfect They listened to the meraglim. They complained
among human beings. What it means is compared to about this and about that. “No good at all,” he said.
5 / TORAS AVIGDOR . NITZAVIM-VAYEILECH . THE PROPHET’S MESSAGE
And he liked to bring up that possuk, עים ׁ ָ˘נָ הƒ ַ‡ ¿ר ָ ּב Criticizing the Excellent
– ָ‡˜וּט ¿ ּב„וֹ רforty years I quarreled with that nation. And so the umos ha’olam, we give up on them.
Every Friday night, he heard that great lesson, ַﬠם But the Am Yisroel is the nation that Hashem is
– ּ˙ ≈ֹﬠי ≈ל ָבב ≈הםthey’re people whose minds wander trying to improve because it pays to improve them.
away from the truth, – ¿ו ≈הם ל ֹ‡ יָ ¿„ע ּו ¿„ ָר ָכיthey didn’t I always repeat a kabalah from my own rebbe,
know my ways, פיƒ ּ ‡ַ ˙י ¿ ּבƒּ ׁ ¿˘ ַ ּב ¿עƒ – ֲ‡ ׁ ∆˘ר נtherefore, I gave it zichrono livracha, in Slabodka. Hashem said, “I
to them, ˙יƒ ‡ם י¿ בוֹ ‡וּן ∆‡ל ¿מנו ָּחƒ – they’re not going to come quarreled with that nation, – ¿ו ≈הם לֹ‡ יָ ¿„ע ּו ¿„ ָר ָכיand
to Eretz Yisroel, they’ll have to die in the Midbar. So they didn’t know My ways,” it means, – ¿ו ≈הם יָ ¿„ע ּו ¿„ ָר ָכי
to him it was settled! they did know My ways. That’s a chiddush my rebbe
said. They did know My ways. You hear that big
Words of Washing chiddush? ו ≈הם יָ ¿„ע ּו ¿„ ָר ָכי.¿
I’ll explain why he said that. Who did know the
The answer is that the words in Tanach are
ways of Hashem? Was it the Norsemen? Was it the
intended to wash us. The nevi’im were washing us.
Africans? Was it the Mexicans? Was it the Greeks?
I’ll give you a mashal. Suppose you see a man walking
Who knew Hashem? They didn’t know My ways;
in the street with a bucket, with soap, with long
okay, so who did know? It’s so foolish to understand
brushes. He’s going to clean up someplace. Where
it superficially.
is he headed to? Is he headed to the city dump? No.
It’s too much of a job. He won't try to clean up the The Non-Cheit Ha’eigel
dump. He’s headed to some hall where people come The sin of the eigel? What was the eigel? If we
together. He’s going to wash out the hall. had time, I’d explain it to you, but you have to know
it was almost nothing. You need a magnifying glass
Now, the hall doesn’t have mud all over it. The
to recognize it as a sin. At the end, three thousand
hall doesn’t have wild animals there and leaves on
people were executed. But there were two million
the floor, just a little dirt on the floor. So he comes
Jews there. What about them? And the whole Jewish
to clean up that little bit of dirt to make it perfect.
nation is blamed for the eigel. And even the three
But where it’s all dirt, like a dump, there he doesn’t
thousand, who do you think they were? They were
go because it’s a hopeless case.
ovdei avodah zarah?
So the umos ha’olam, they're osek in tumah all Don’t make any mistake about it. We have to
their lives, so Hakadosh Baruch Hu didn't send any learn not with a childish mind. We have to learn
nevi’im to criticize the goyim. It's a waste of time for with the Rishonim. Look in the Ramban, look in the
a navi to go with soap and a pail of water to wash off Kuzari, and they both explain that the cheit ha’eigel
the goyim. But on the Am Yisroel every little speck was almost invisible.
is a tragedy. And therefore, Moshe Rabbeinu says,
The Non-Cheit of Korach
“Gevald! Look! You have a speck on you!” And he
makes a big fuss out of it. And we are reading it Korach? Korach committed no crime. Korach
today and we are so impressed with the gevald. We was accusing Moshe Rabbeinu that he chose his
think that they were very wicked people, chas brother. That wasn't a crime of immorality. He didn’t
v’shalom – !ל ֹ‡ יָ ¿„ע ּו ¿„ ָר ָכי commit any crime of murder. I want to tell you
people that Korach and Dasan and Aviram were the
That’s a big mistake! The nevi’im didn’t tell the nicest people. Never mind what your rebbe told you
gentiles, – ¿ו ≈הם ל ֹ‡ יָ ¿„ע ּו ¿„ ָר ָכיthey don’t know My ways, when you were six years old in Hebrew school and
because they don’t know anything! The goyim walk the rebbe wanted to make it interesting so he gritted
in darkness. his teeth when he was describing them. If Korach
6 / TORAS AVIGDOR . NITZAVIM-VAYEILECH . THE PROPHET’S MESSAGE
came in here, we'd have to get up for him; no and telling you, “Do not fear! ‡ ָּ˙נ ּוƒ ' !הThere’s a
question about it. Not because he comes out of the promise to us!” Isn't it easy to jump now? Imagine
Chumash; because of himself! If Korach lived in — what would you do? At least you’d hesitate a little
Boro Park and he would lower himself to come into bit before you jumped. You would need a tremendous
this place, we'd have to get up for him. amount of trust in Hashem. Even if Hashem is
So you say, “Well, they were swallowed up. Look standing there and saying, “Chaim’l, jump,” and you
what happened to them.” take a look down there… You just can’t do it.
They were swallowed up because they should
Big People, Big Sins
have been better. If somebody is in a kollel where
everybody learns twenty-three hours a day — So now we begin to see it wasn’t simple at all.
imagine such a kollel, they're studying day and night And if they are blamed, it’s like the Kuzari said in a
— and one lazy fellow decides that he wants to sleep different instance, their cheit was big because they
six hours every night. He breaks down the morale were big. They were very great personalities! And
of the whole institution! It's a letdown. He's a rotten therefore greatness was expected of them.
apple in a barrel that causes the whole barrel of
apples to decay. If we had been there and we had refused to
But if you take him out of that kollel and bring enter, there wouldn’t be any claim against us. We’re
him to one of our kollelim, he'd be the star! He'd be not big enough to overcome our nerves, our
the model. He sleeps six hours every night and all instincts of self-preservation. You think you would
day long he labors in Torah. Only that because they have jumped; you would have entered Eretz Canaan?
were not good enough for the greatness that
One of the kings of Eretz Canaan was the king of
Hakadosh Baruch Hu demanded, He rejected them.
Chatzor. Just one of the thirty-one kings. So it’s
The Non-Cheit Hameraglim related in Sefer Shoftim (4:3) that he had nine
hundred war chariots! Imagine a king of one small
The meraglim? They didn't kill anyone. We look
kingdom, nine hundred chariots! And the Bnei
back with embarrassment that this could have
Yisroel didn’t have any chariots! And now you want
happened to the holy nation. Hakadosh Baruch Hu
them to go ahead despite everything. Not only to
had foretold that they would successfully enter the
fight against Chatzor; all the malchei Canaan! There
land and conquer, and the meraglim, when they
were other, bigger kingdoms with even more
returned, discouraged the people because of fear
chariots. So you have to know that what was
that they would fail. And so Hakadosh Baruch Hu
expected of them was superhuman courage based
was so displeased that He sentenced them to be
on superhuman understanding that Hashem is in
forty years in the Midbar. That’s how we learned
charge of the world! And therefore, we cannot
when we were children, and that’s the most
blame them at all.
superficial pashtus of the pesukim.
Now, the meraglim came back and said it’s And so, it’s time to put all of our childish
impossible. And don’t think that they weren’t right. interpretations aside. It’s time now to grow up and
It was impossible. Only that Hakadosh Baruch Hu realize that everything you read in the Tanach about
said it is possible. It was a very great test. From the our nation, all the criticism, it’s all not true, it’s all
viewpoint of the meraglim, to enter the land would exaggerations! Moshe Rabbeinu’s criticisms, the
have been just as logical as jumping out of the neviim’s stinging rebuke, Hakadosh Baruch Hu’s
window of a ten-story building. Let’s say you’re words of rebuke, it’s all exaggerating the smallest of
standing by the open window and a navi is standing missteps!
7 / TORAS AVIGDOR . NITZAVIM-VAYEILECH . THE PROPHET’S MESSAGE
Part III. The Truth-Teller to fulfill his mission. He raised up his eyes and ‡ַו ַ ּי ¿ר
ל ׁ ¿˘ ָב ָטיוƒ ¿˘ׂ ָר ≈‡ל ׁ˘ ≈ֹכןƒ – ∆‡˙ יhe saw Yisroel dwelling
The Gentile Truth-Teller according to its tribes (ibid. 24:2). He saw their tents
You know who told the real truth? A goy! Bilam and he became so excited that he went into raptures.
spoke up and praised us like nobody else ever did. If What was he surprised at? The tents were made
you look in the words of Bilam, it’s one long song of of silk? Of gold? Fur tents?
enthusiastic praise for Am Yisroel. יך יַ ֲﬠ˜ֹב ָ ַמה ּטֹב ּו ‡ ָֹה ∆ל
No; their tents were worn-out tents. They had
ָ ˙ֹ∆ מ ׁ ¿˘ ¿ּכנƒ – How beautiful are your tents, your
¿˘ׂ ָר ≈‡לƒיך י used the same tents for forty years. What was there
habitation, Yaakov (Bamidbar 24:5). Take out a in the tent to be surprised at?
Chumash and read the words; a nevuah, possuk
The answer is he saw that the tents were so
after possuk of the greatest praises of the Am
situated, so positioned that no one tent had its
Yisroel.
doorway facing the doorway of the next tent; they
Woah! That’s not what Moshe told us?! At the shouldn't look into the neighbor's house. There
same time that Moshe is criticizing, Bilam is were almost a million tents and yet Bilam looked
praising. What’s going on here? and he was amazed and he couldn't see any instance
The answer is that Bilam was sent for one where one tent had a doorway facing the doorway
purpose only: to say the real truth, that we are a of another tent. Because people so positioned their
nation that’s the most beautiful of all the peoples in tents that they shouldn't look into the neighbor's
the world. Now, Hashem didn't send Moshe houses.
Rabbeinu for that. No, Moshe kept on criticizing He saw more than that. He was a prophet; he
until the end of his days. It wasn’t the whole truth saw what was inside the tents. He saw through the
but it was medicine; it’s not the real emes but it's tents and he saw a very holy nation. And he became
useful, it's beneficial. Because Moshe Rabbeinu was ָ מה ּטֹב ּו ‡ ָֹה ∆ל.
so excited, he said, יך יַ ֲﬠ˜ֹב ַ Bilam exclaimed
telling us what was most important for us to hear that every single tent is going to be a fountain of
— our faults. When a person becomes aware of his living waters that will inspire all the generations
flaws of character, his chesronos, what’s wrong with that will come out of them. זים ֲﬠ ≈ליƒ לים נָ ָטי ּו ו‚ו' ַּכ ֲ‡ ָרƒ ּכנ¿ ָחƒ
him, that’s the very greatest benefit you can do to םƒ – ַמיHe compared these tents that he saw there in
him because Hakadosh Baruch Hu did not make the the wilderness as if they were springs of fresh living
world merely for us to exist and to live peacefully. water that would flow forever and ever (ibid. 24:6).
The world was made for one purpose for mankind: The traditions from those families will continue to
that they should exploit the potentialities within flow forever and ever.
themselves to become as good as they can become.
And so we need to hear our faults. The Lambasted Generation
Now, which generation was Bilam speaking
But in order that we shouldn’t get snagged,
about? He was looking at the generation that was
Hashem did something. He sent Bilam. One man in
blamed for “not knowing My ways.” And Bilam
history He sent to say the truth about the Am
became so excited about them that the spirit of
Yisroel.
Hashem came upon him and he couldn’t stop
Transcendental Tents singing their praises. What’s the pshat?
It was near the end of the forty years in the The answer is that Bilam isn’t interested in our
Midbar, after all the “sins” had been committed and welfare. Moshe Rabbeinu and all the Jewish nevi’im
all the criticism had been heaped upon the head of were our good friends and they wanted to help us
that generation, and now Bilam arrived on the scene get better so they criticized us. But Bilam wasn't a
8 / TORAS AVIGDOR . NITZAVIM-VAYEILECH . THE PROPHET’S MESSAGE
good friend of ours. He wasn’t interested in our Christianity maybe. But it’s not true. The campaign
becoming better — he wanted just the opposite — against the Jewish people has been going on from
and therefore he was allowed to compliment us. the earliest time. From the beginning, the yetzer
And once he’s telling the truth, so of course he’ll hara has conducted a tremendous campaign against
compliment us to the skies. the Jewish people; to vilify, to belittle, to defame the
And it’s in the Torah because it’s important to Jewish people. And he has harnessed all the nations
hear that. Otherwise you might make the error of of the world for this task. It’s being done on a
listening to Moshe Rabbeinu’s criticism and tremendous scale. A tremendous press! Many books
understanding it at face value. But it's a fatal error! and articles!
It's impossible to love the Am Yisroel under such a And the most important of the effects is not
misconception! And Hakadosh Baruch Hu is ‡וֹ ≈הב that the nations of the world should be enemies of
¿ ˙ƒּ – ַ‡ ֲה ַב˙ עוֹ ָלם ַ‡ ֲה ¿בwith an
ַ He loves us יך
¿˘ׂ ָר ≈‡לƒﬠ ּמוֹ י, the Jews. No, that’s not most important and it’s not
eternal love (Yirmiyah 31:2) and He wants us to love so difficult either. His main purpose is in order to
them, too. make an impression on the weak Jews.
The Yetzer’s Biggest Catch Now, to become a Christian, that’s too much of
an impression. Only a very weak-minded Jew,
Now, that’s a very important point, because the
maybe something is wrong with him, with his head,
yetzer hara is very busy in this world with just the
so the yetzer hara can entangle him with such
opposite. Everyone knows that there’s a malach
foolishness. But ordinarily, a virgin birth and Santa
called the yetzer hara, a supernatural force whose
Claus, three-in-one, one-in-three, jingle bells, it’s
job is to mislead people into all types of error. And
too stupid for a Jew. That’s too much, too unnatural
he focuses on that: ¿˘ׂ ָר ≈‡לƒּמ ¿˙ ָ ּ‚ ∆רה ¿ ּביƒ יח ∆‡˙ ‡וּמוֹ ˙ ָהעוֹ ָלם ו
ַ ּנƒ ַמ
for a normal Jew.
– The yetzer hara forsakes the nations of the world,
and he attacks the Jews (Sukkah 52a). He doesn’t The Ethnocentric Principle
want to waste his time urging gentiles to do wicked
But what the yetzer hara intends most with this
things, because they do it anyhow. It’s like a car
torrent that’s raining down constantly is to beat
going downhill; there’s no use stepping on the gas,
down on the Jew so that he shouldn’t be able to see
it’s a waste of gasoline. And therefore, he
the greatness in his own people. And that’s a very
concentrates on Yisroel because with them it’s an
big accomplishment for the yetzer hara, to impose
uphill battle. It’s unnatural for Jews to sin. It goes
on us an inferiority complex by finding ways and
against the grain of a Jew to believe in Christianity
means of us losing confidence in our greatness.
or to believe in evolution. It’s unnatural for a Jew to
Even a little bit of an effect, it’s a tragedy; and it’s
sink to unnatural lusts. And so because of that, the
especially so when this propaganda finds its mark
yetzer hara puts additional efforts to entangle them
even among bnei Torah, even among talmidei
— otherwise it would never happen.
chachomim. מ ּכו ָּּלםƒ מים יוֹ ≈˙רƒ מ ≈י„י ֲח ָכƒ – ו ¿ּב ַ˙ ¿לIf the yetzer
The Yetzer’s Big Function can snare a talmid chacham, ooh, is that a good catch
But you’ll be surprised to hear that one of his for him (ibid.).
biggest functions, one of his biggest successes, is to Because the first and most fundamental lesson
cause Jews to think less of themselves than they the Jew has to learn about his people is that we
should. And he’s been busy with that always. Some were not chosen for nothing. מיםƒּ מ ָּכל ָה ַﬠƒ ַ‡ ָּ˙ה ¿ ּב ַח ¿ר ָּ˙נ ּו
people who are not cognizant of ancient history – You chose us from all the nations. Why? Because
have the impression that antisemitism is a modern we were the choicest ones. There's no question at
creation; they think it arose together with all about it. Nobody could compare to us.
9 / TORAS AVIGDOR . NITZAVIM-VAYEILECH . THE PROPHET’S MESSAGE
And to think otherwise, don’t think it’s a small Moshe Fulfills His Role
thing. It’s one of the biggest errors, one of the very And therefore, our greatest navi, he especially
worst iniquities that a Jew can accomplish if he fulfilled that role. It says, – ה' ֲ‡ ׁ ∆˘ר ָﬠ ָ˘ׂ ה ∆‡˙ מ ׁ ∆ֹ˘ה
doesn’t think well of his people. A Jew must know Hashem made Moshe (Shmuel I 12:6). What do you
his nation is the best nation, that nobody can ever mean “made Moshe”? He created Moshe for that
compare remotely. ı ¿˘ׂ ָר ≈‡ל ‚ּ וֹ י ∆‡ ָח„ ָ ּב ָ‡ ∆רƒמי ¿ּכ ַﬠ ּ¿מ ָך יƒ – Who generation! He made a Moshe because that
is like the nation Yisroel, one people in the world generation was capable of a Moshe!
(Divrei Hayamim I 17:21). I'm talking about the frum
“If only we had a Moshe Rabbeinu,” people say.
Jews; the frum Jews who carry on the tradition, who
“Why doesn’t He give us a Moshe?” they want to
study Hashem's Torah, are unequaled and never
know.
were equaled in the history of the world. Nobody
You couldn’t handle Moshe! You would be a
can ever compare remotely.
thousand times more insolent than Korach! Don’t
you see what people say against the gedolim, against
Misunderstanding Tanach
the Agudas Harabbonim, what they say against the
And that’s the danger of learning the Tanach roshei yeshiva? There are chatzufim who speak up
k’pshuto. You hear the criticisms and you’re against the gedolei Yisroel today in the newspapers.
influenced. The yetzer hara is very happy with that. They ridicule them!
He likes when you learn like that because it means We couldn’t handle too much criticism today.
you’re easy pickings for him. And therefore, it’s so What would we do if we didn’t have a soft-spoken
important to be busy always studying the emes of Reb Moshe Feinstein? Reb Moshe Feinstein is soft-
the Torah, because if you don’t understand who the spoken, gentle. Suppose we had the Ridbaz, an old-
Am Yisroel really is, then you’re going to fall into time rav. The Ridbaz wasn’t soft-spoken! All the old
that error sooner or later. You’ll listen to Moshe gedolim, they told the truth! And they said it with
Rabbeinu say that we are disobedient and rebellious fiery words! I don’t know what would happen! I’m
and stiff-necked and everything else and you’ll afraid to think.
believe it.
Moshe Rabbeinu’s Legacy
And so we must always come back to the truth.
And Moshe Rabbeinu, a thousand times more!
We are the best! And how did we become the best?
Hashem created a Moshe for that generation, a
Just because of that! Just because Moshe Rabbeinu
generation that understood ּיים ּ˙וֹ ¿כחוֹ ˙ מו ָּסרƒ – ∆„ּ ∆ר ¿ך ַח
never complimented us. He always criticized us
the way of life is instructions of mussar. That was
because ּיים ּ˙וֹ ¿כחוֹ ˙ מו ָּסרƒ – ∆„ּ ∆ר ¿ך ַחthe way of life is the
the way to get the most out of people. And therefore,
rebuke of instruction (Mishlei 6:23); that's the way to
that generation was given the harshest treatment
succeed, when people are rebuked.
of any generation in history. Not because, as we
Nowadays, don't try it. Nowadays, don't rebuke think, they deserved it; but because they were the
anybody because he'll run away and you'll never see ones who could produce the best wine if they were
him again. But in the good old days when people pressed most severely.
had some common sense and they knew the And they became our model forever! We try to
purpose of life was to get better, people went live up to that model generation! Such an attitude
looking for rebuke. They were looking for criticisms. changed us forever. We’re still running with that
And that's why in the ancient times there were push that Moshe Rabbeinu gave us with his criticism.
nevi’im. Nevi’im were sent because people That's how powerful was the influence of the one
appreciated them and the navi gave it to them. who said, “All my life you have been rebellious
10 / TORAS AVIGDOR . NITZAVIM-VAYEILECH . THE PROPHET’S MESSAGE
against Hashem!” That’s what Moshe Rabbeinu
accomplished; he implanted an attitude towards
the Torah that lasted forever, a model for every
generation. We know that we’re the best in the
QUESTION
world — no nation even comes close — but we know
also that we’re in the world to become even more What is Selichos all about?
perfect. And that requires sometimes to be told
what’s wrong with us under a magnifying glass, to ANSWER
be told ˙י ∆‡˙ ∆מ ¿רי¿ ָך ¿ו ∆‡˙ ָﬠ ¿ר ּ ¿פ ָך ַה ָּ˜ ׁ ∆˘הƒּ ֹכי יָ ַ„ ¿עƒ !כי ָ‡נ
ּƒ
Selichos means that a man must make some
Have a Wonderful Shabbos time for hisbonenus, for thinking. That’s what we say
in Selichos every day, – נַ ¿ח ּ ¿פ ָ˘ׂ ה ¿„ ָר ≈כינ ּו ¿ונַ ¿ח˜ ָֹרהlet us
search out our ways and investigate. All the frum
Feeling inspired & uplifted? Jews are saying that, but how many are doing it?
Help spread that feeling to Jews everywhere! How many frum Jews have stopped and given five
minutes to think over the past year? Believe me, very
Join this movement NOW!
few.
torasavigdor.org/give 732-844-3670
I read once about a gentile; a gentile, l’havdil, who
every Saturday night told his family, “Don’t bother
me for two hours.” He went into a room and he was
Let’s Get Practical alone for two hours. He talked things over, a spiritual
inventory, and it did him a great deal of benefit.
The Holiest, Most Beloved People It takes time. נַ ¿ח ּ ¿פ ָ˘ׂ הmeans to search out; not
In this week’s parsha, Moshe Rabbeinu continues to merely to take a superficial look at yourself, a general
castigate the Am Yisroel for not living up to the overview. No, you have to look into yourself with a
magnifying glass. And נַ ¿ח˜ ָֹרהmeans to dig in, like
highest standards of excellence. But we must always
excavating for something that is buried.
remember not to let all of the criticism leveled at
the Jewish people throughout the Tanach confuse Now, I’m not going to say you should be like that
us into thinking negatively about our people — a gentile — it’s too much to demand — but five minutes’
people accurately praised for its unique greatness inventory at least. And not every Saturday night like
he did, but at least this one, the first night of
by none other than Bilam Harasha.
Selichos. Five minutes of bookkeeping is very little
This week, bli neder, when I say in Shemoneh Esrei, for a whole year of business. But still, it would be a
˘ים ¿ ּב ׇכל יוֹ ם י¿ ַה ¿ללו ָּך ∆ּס ָלהƒ ׁ ֹ – ו ¿ּ˜„וthe holy ones praise you great thing if somebody could boast, “I did it! I
each day, I will think of our glorious Torah Nation, fulfilled נַ ¿ח ּ ¿פ ָ˘ׂ ה ¿„ ָר ≈כינ ּו ¿ונַ ¿ח˜ ָֹרה. I spent five minutes
Hashem’s holiest and most beloved people. thinking of the past full year.” It’s a very poor little
boast, but halevai v’halevai.
And it’s so essential — unless you want to continue
This week’s booklet is based on tapes: in your blindness until you fall over the precipice
260 - The People I Created | 687 - Plan of History when it’s all over and then it’s too late. At the end
830 - The Copper Snake | 956 - Bilaam’s Message
you’ll realize that your life has been wasted for lack
E-186 - Excellence of Israel
of using your mind. The golden opportunity of life
comes once in history — you won’t come back again.
Listen to the original lectures of Rav Miller zatzal
on the Mipihu Phone Line And that’s what Selichos is for; it’s meant to wake
USA: 718-400-7220 | Israel: 778509304 | UK: 3303505768 you up. February 1977
Mipihu is a project of Yeshiva Gedolah Beis Yisroel - Rav Miller’s Yeshivah
11 / TORAS AVIGDOR . NITZAVIM-VAYEILECH . THE PROPHET’S MESSAGE
