Kollel Lihoraah - English — Nitzavim Vayelech (2026-08-31)

Parshas Netzavim-
Vayelech
5786
Ask the Rav
A Woman Suffering from Anorexia Who Needs to Enter a Facility Where halev, why should there be a concern of timtum halev in this case? Accord-
She Will Be Given Non-Kosher Food ingly, regarding a shoteh, there is indeed room to be lenient depending on
the circumstances.
Q: Unfortunately, a common question arises regarding girls who suffer from Our case, however, is different, since the girl is not a shoteh at all. Therefore,
anorexia, which is a physical and psychological illness. In some cases, the the situation is considerably more stringent. If there is another way to treat
condition is truly a matter of pikuach nefesh, while in less severe cases it is her, there is a concern of safiyah and lifnei iver in giving her non-kosher
certainly considered an illness, but there is no danger to life. Nevertheless, food. Nevertheless, in a case of actual pikuach nefesh—which, unfortunate-
nutritionists sometimes recommend that these girls go out with friends to ly, is quite common among girls suffering from this condition—it is certainly
restaurants as part of their recovery process, and sometimes, for the purposes permissible to be lenient for the purpose of her recovery, as is clear from
of their treatment, they’re advised to eat certain foods that do not have a O.C. 328:14. Even when there is no pikuach nefesh, there is some room for
kosher certification. The question is when and under what circumstances leniency when this is genuinely part of the necessary treatment for the ill-
they may be permitted to eat non-kosher food because doing so will greatly ness.
assist in treating their illness. In a case of actual pikuach nefesh, it is certain- It is, however, very important to emphasize that one should always seek
ly permitted, but what is the practical halachic guidance in these various alternative solutions, particularly since the Chasam Sofer nevertheless ex-
situations? pressed concern regarding timtum halev. Furthermore, the Divrei Malkiel
(I:28) writes that if kosher food can be obtained, even at a significantly high-
A: There are several points that must be distinguished when addressing such er cost, one is obligated to do so. Likewise, in every individual case one
questions. First, regarding the broader issue, I am not presently addressing must investigate the spiritual environment of the facility in question. Since
whether it is advisable to send a Torah-observant Jewish girl to a non-Jewish this is an extremely sensitive matter, no practical ruling should be derived
facility, where she may potentially be exposed to very negative influences. from this answer alone; a qualified Rav must be consulted beforehand.
Rather, I am addressing the halachic question from the parents' perspective: The practical ruling: If, unfor tunately, a gir l suffer ing fr om anor exia is
whether they may send someone in such a condition to a facility or restau- defined by her doctors as being in a state of pikuach nefesh, and as part of
rant for the purpose of treating the illness described above. the treatment process she needs to eat non-kosher food, it is permissible to
The words of the Chasam Sofer (O.C. 83) are well known regarding placing give her such food and likewise to send her to such a facility. However, if
a shoteh in a non-Jewish institution for medical treatment where non-kosher the condition is not considered pikuach nefesh, but rather an illness without
food is served. Although a shoteh is exempt from mitzvos, there is neverthe- danger to life that requires ongoing treatment, there is an obligation to seek
less an issue of safiyah—actively causing someone to eat a prohibited kosher food, even if it is more expensive. In every case, the family Rav must
food—as one is forbidden to feed even a shoteh prohibited foods, as stated be consulted in order to determine the proper course of action.
by the Pri Megadim (266 s.k. 4). Initially, the Chasam Sofer sought to permit
this based on several considerations: Swallowing Blood from Dry, Cracked Lips
1. Since the person was placed in a non-Jewish institution, it is the non-Jews
who are feeding him, and we are not the ones instructing them to feed him Q: I have been asked many times about a common situation in which a per-
non-kosher food. son's lips become cracked because of cold weather and the person suffers
2. The principle that it is preferable for one person to violate Shabbos if do- from dry, painful lips. He wishes to moisten his lips with his tongue. Is this
ing so will enable a sick person to recover. permitted, or is there a concern that there is usually some blood on the lips,
Safiyah may be permitted for the sake of a mitzvah. and by licking the lips he may swallow the blood, thereby transgressing the
Nevertheless, the Chasam Sofer ultimately ruled stringently that the shoteh prohibition of eating blood?
should be removed from the institution before reaching the age at which he
would become obligated in mitzvos. He was also stringent because of the A: The Gemara in Kesubos (60a) and Kerisus (21b) teaches: Blood that is on
concern of timtum halev, that eating non-kosher food can have a negative a piece of bread may be scraped off and the bread eaten; blood that is be-
spiritual effect and cause a person to develop negative traits. tween one's teeth may be sucked out and swallowed without concern. This is
Although the Igros Moshe (O.C. II:88) writes that in the case of a shoteh brought as halachah in the Tur and Shulchan Aruch (Y.D. 66).
who will not recover from his condition, there is room to be lenient, one Rashi in Kesubos explains the permission to suck out blood between the
must nevertheless carefully consider our case, since the girl in question is not teeth by saying that it is not visible. At first glance, this would seem to indi-
a shoteh at all and may very well recover in the future. cate that the entire basis for the leniency is that the blood is not visible. If so,
In fact, before focusing on our particular case, it should be noted that the blood on one's lips, where it can be seen, would seemingly be comparable to
Shevet HaLevi and several other Poskim raised a question regarding the blood on bread and would be forbidden. However, in Kerisus Rashi explains
Chasam Sofer's reasoning. If one is permitted to violate Shabbos in order to differently: Blood on bread, since it has separated, has at least an element of
obtain a benefit for a sick person, even where there is a concern of timtum perishah; blood between the teeth, however, is still attached to the body and
therefore does not even have a requirement of are several possible melachos that need to be considered, including
perishah, and one may suck and swallow it. Ac- smoothing, borer, makeh b'patish, and boneh. Is it permissible to pre-
cording to this explanation, blood on one's lips pare sushi on Shabbos? And if we conclude that it is prohibited, may a
would likewise seemingly be permitted since it is still caterer have non-Jews stand at a sushi station on Shabbos and prepare
attached to the body. Thus, the two explanations of Rashi sushi for a Shabbos kiddush and the like?
appear to contradict one another.
The wording of the Rosh also requires examination. He writes A: Since I am unable to elaborate at length at this time, I will address
that blood on bread must be scraped off because, since it has sepa- only the concern of boneh with regard to food, aside from the other con-
rated, there is a concern that people will come to confuse it with cerns mentioned above, which may be easier to permit.
other blood and conclude that other blood is also permitted. Blood Regarding boneh in food, the Rambam (Hilchos Shabbos, ch. 7), cited
between the teeth, however, may be sucked and swallowed. by the Magen Avraham (319 s.k. 18) and the Mishnah Berurah (319 s.k.
At first glance, this would seem to indicate that the concern is not 63), writes that one who makes cheese on Shabbos is liable for boneh,
maris ayin, but rather a prohibition enacted because people may come because gathering separate components together and joining them until
to mistakenly permit other blood. Nevertheless, even according to this they become one entity resembles building.
explanation, it would seem that blood on the lips should be permitted, The Magen Avraham (340 s.k. 17) explains that the prohibition of
since it has not yet separated from the body and there is no concern that boneh in food applies when one intends to beautify and smooth the food,
it will be confused with other blood. as is the case with cheese. Therefore, joining pieces of dried fig together
In truth, however, it appears that the Rosh's concern that one may come is prohibited only because of me'amer, and there is no prohibition of
to confuse it with other blood is itself included in the concept of maris boneh, since one does not intend to beautify or smooth them. Based on
ayin. Rashi explains regarding blood of fish that was collected in a ves- this, Rav Shmuel HaLevi Wosner, zt"l (Shevet HaLevi VI:29), ruled
sel that it is prohibited because an observer may conclude that eating regarding cutting foods into a particular shape, or preparing onions and
blood is permitted. Based on this, the concern is that someone observing eggs in a particular manner on Shabbos, that if we adopt the stringent
the act may conclude that the act itself is permitted. I subsequently saw position that making cheese is prohibited because of boneh even when it
that the Darkei Teshuvah (Y.D. 66 s.k. 68) cites a dispute among the is intended to be eaten that same day, there is room to be stringent re-
Acharonim regarding this matter, with several Acharonim remaining garding these practices as well, as they may constitute a form of boneh.
uncertain about the halachah. He also cites the Yad Yehudah, who This is particularly the case when a liquid is involved that causes the
writes that when blood is dripping from one's finger there is not only a components to adhere to one another and further serves to smooth and
concern of maris ayin, but also an element of shikutz, as well as the beautify the finished product.
concern of the principle that whatever emerges from something im- On the other hand, the Maharsham (Daas Torah O.C. 321, s.v. u'mutar,
pure is itself impure. Nevertheless, it appears that even those who are p. 217), cited in Shevisas HaShabbos (Me'amer s.k. 12), writes that
stringent regarding blood on one's finger would agree that blood on there is no concern of boneh when preparing an egg with onion, since
one's lips is permitted. In the case of a finger, when a person places the connection is not strong and can easily come apart. Furthermore,
a bloody finger into his mouth, an observer may not know that the since the entire purpose of joining them is to eat them immediately, it
blood came from his finger; perhaps the finger was simply soiled does not resemble building at all.
with blood from another source, especially since one's hands are The Concern of Boneh
constantly involved in various activities. When one licks his lips, Accordingly, according to Rav Yisrael Belsky, zt"l there is reason to
however, anyone observing can clearly see that the blood came question whether preparing sushi constitutes boneh, and therefore the
from the lips themselves. This appears to be the intention of the recommendation is not to prepare sushi on Shabbos. Therefore, accord-
Kenesses HaGedolah, cited in the Darkei Teshuvah, who ing to the stringent opinion regarding making cheese, one should not
writes that even regarding a finger, despite the fact that it is prepare sushi on Shabbos because of the concern of boneh. Rav Asher
evident that the blood came from the finger, there is still an Zelig Weiss, shlit"a (Kovetz Or HaShabbos, vol. 29, p. 28), likewise
element of maris ayin. Therefore, it appears that at least in a writes that it is proper to be stringent and refrain from preparing sushi
case of pain or discomfort, one may be lenient and lick on Shabbos because of the concern that it resembles making cheese,
one's lips even when there is some blood on them. Alt- which is liable because of boneh. Sushi is not merely a matter of gather-
hough a person who is able to suck the blood out and spit ing and joining ingredients; rather, through the rolling process one cre-
it out certainly should do so, as cited in the Kenesses ates a new food product and a distinct form. On the other hand, it is
HaGedolah, when someone is suffering and needs to possible that the connection is not considered a true, permanent connec-
moisten his lips repeatedly throughout the day, making tion. He is nevertheless clear that there is no concern of tofer in prepar-
it difficult to spit each time, there is no need to be ing sushi, since there is no actual sewing or substantial bonding in-
stringent. Regarding blood that comes out of the volved. Rather, the moisture causes a certain degree of adhesion which
mouth during dental treatment: One need not be con- can easily be separated, and therefore it does not even constitute a non-
cerned when blood comes out during dental treat- permanent form of sewing. He further demonstrates at length (Kovetz
ment and is found on the instruments, even though Or HaShabbos, vol. 29, p. 39) that there is nevertheless a concern of
the dentist may remove an instrument containing boneh and that sushi should not be prepared on Shabbos. There is no
blood and then return it to the patient's mouth. Nev- requirement that the construction be a strong or permanent structure;
ertheless, at the conclusion of the treatment one joining one food to another can itself constitute boneh.
should make sure to spit out and remove all of the The practical conclusion: In light of all the above, one should cer -
liquid in his mouth rather than swallowing the tainly be stringent lechatchilah and not prepare sushi on Shabbos. Alt-
blood, and he should rinse his mouth. hough there are those who are lenient and permit a non-Jew to prepare it
at a Shabbos kiddush, as is done by certain caterers, one should never-
Preparing Sushi on Shabbos theless not rely on this leniency lechatchilah without consulting a quali-
fied Rav.
Q: I have been asked many times by people who
would like to prepare sushi on Shabbos. There
Take a part in spreading the light!
Email info@kollellihoraah.org for sponsorship opportunities.
To receive this weekly publication via email, Click here or email info@kollellihoraah.org.
This weeks Q&A is sponsored in blessed memory of
ר' הלל בן אהרן זצ"ל
May his Neshama have an Aliyah.
