Kollel Lihoraah - English — Ki Savoi (2026-08-24)

Parshas Ki Tavo
5786
Ask the Rav
A Younger Daughter Marrying Before Her Older Sister shidduch to fall through, the younger sibling does not have to
lose the opportunity because of the older sibling’s distress.
Q: Every day presents new challenges in many families when In the notes of Rav Yisroel Taplin shlit”a, he records that he
there are several children of shidduch age. At times, a shidduch asked Rav Yisrael Yaakov Fisher zt”l whether a younger sister is
is suggested for the younger daughter before the older daughter, permitted to marry before her older sister. Rav Fisher answered
and the question arises: Under what circumstances does halachah that it is certainly permitted, for must she wait until she becomes
permit the younger daughter to marry before the older daughter? undesirable? This is not a reason to delay her marriage.
In Shu”t Divrei Yatziv (Even HaEzer, Siman 9), the question of
A: First, we should mention several levels that we find in the whether it is proper to marry off a daughter before her older
poskim regarding when it is permitted for a younger daughter to brother is discussed. In addition to the various considerations, he
marry before an older daughter: discusses the daughter’s obligation to honor her older brother.
A) If the older daughter is mochel and agr ees that her young- Nevertheless, he concludes that it is certainly permissible to do
er sister should marry before her, even if she has some resent- so, especially if the older brother is mochel. See also Shu”t Min-
ment in her heart, “devarim shebalev einam devarim,” and we chas Asher (II, Siman 74). Certainly, it is difficult to establish
can rely on her expressed consent. one clear general ruling in this matter, since every case must be
B) The r equir ement to give pr ecedence to the older daughter judged individually. Therefore, it is necessary to ask a talmid
applies specifically when both girls have reached marriageable chacham for guidance in each individual situation. The Shulchan
age and are actively involved in shidduchim. However, if neither HaEzer (Siman 1, se’if 40, note 10) writes that whenever one
has yet become involved in shidduchim and a shidduch comes wishes to be meikil in this matter, it is proper and correct to do
along for the younger daughter but not for the older one, the so only through three talmidei chachamim who are ba’alei
younger daughter does not have to lose the opportunity. hora’ah, and through this, “tov yihyeh lahem.”
C) Some poskim maintain that the concer n applies specifical-
ly when the father is arranging the marriages of his daughters, Changing a Baby’s Diaper in the Middle of a Meal – Does One
but not when the daughters themselves are choosing their hus- Need to Wash His Hands Again?
bands. The source for this is brought by the Shach (Yoreh Deah
244:13), who writes that even though one brother or sister may Q: A very common question, especially on Shabbos, concerns
be greater than another in Torah knowledge, one should not ar- someone who changes his baby’s diaper in the middle of a meal.
range the marriage of the younger one first because he is greater When he returns to continue eating, is he required to wash his
in Torah, but should first arrange the marriage of the older sib- hands again, with a berachah, before continuing to eat?
ling.
In Shu”t Igros Moshe (Even HaEzer II, Siman 1), Rav Moshe A: The Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 164:2) writes that one who is in
Feinstein zt”l explains that the Shach is referring to a situation in the middle of a meal and remembers that he touched his thigh,
which both are ready to marry and the only question is which leg, or other normally covered parts of the body, or scratched his
wedding should take place first. In such a case, the older sib- head, or otherwise touched places where there is sweat and dirt,
ling’s wedding should come first because of the honor due to the must wash his hands again and recite Al Netilas Y adayim.
older sibling, even if the younger sibling is greater in Torah. The Mishnah Berurah (ibid. s.k. 12) adds that certainly if one
However, if the older child does not currently have a shidduch, touched an actual filthy area or used the bathroom, he must wash
the younger child does not have to wait for him at all, since the his hands. However, he writes further (s.k. 13) that the Ma-
younger child himself has a mitzvah to get married, and we can- harshal disagrees and maintains that one should not recite a
not tell him to delay fulfilling his mitzvah so that his older sib- berachah merely because he touched a sweaty area during the
ling can get married first. Certainly, if delaying would cause the meal. He even maintains that after using the bathroom in the
middle of a meal, one need not recite says ‘you shall fear’ in the plural, both are included. If so,
the berachah unless he left and was away why does the Torah say ish? A man has the ability to fulfill
from the meal for an extended period. The the mitzvah, whereas a woman does not have the ability to
Mishnah Berurah concludes that there are many do so because she is under the authority of others.” We see
Acharonim who discuss whether we should follow from here that a married woman is exempt from the mitzvah
the Maharshal, and in the Biur Halachah he rules that of Kibbud Av Va’em when her obligations to her husband
after using the bathroom, touching an actually filthy prevent her from fulfilling it, and this is brought as a hala-
area, or leaving the meal for an extended period, one chah in the Shulchan Aruch (Y.D. 240:17). The Shach (s.k.
should wash his hands with a berachah. Accordingly, 19), however, writes that if her husband does not object, she
when one changes a baby’s diaper in the middle of a meal, is obligated to do whatever she is able to do, just like a man,
since he certainly touches a normally covered area, he must and this is brought l’halachah by the poskim.
wash his hands before continuing to eat. If he actually Furthermore, the sefer Mora Horim V’Chayim (ch. 7, se’if 5,
touches feces, then according to the ruling of the Mishnah footnote 5) explains that from the wording of the Chayei Ad-
Berurah, he should also recite the berachah. am it is apparent that the exemption of a married woman
The Rema (O.C. 170:1) further rules that even if one does from Kibbud Av Va’em applies specifically when she knows
not intend to eat any more bread during the meal and only that her husband objects. However, if she does not know his
intends to drink, he should nevertheless wash his hands, דעתand has no reason to assume that he objects, she is
since we are concerned that he may end up eating as well. required to involve herself in honoring her parents until she
However, Rav Shmuel Felder cites that Rav Moshe Feinstein knows that her husband objects. This is also how the matter
ruled that if one has finished his meal and intends to eat des- was ruled by the Harav Elyashiv zt”l.
sert, he does not need to wash his hands again, since dessert It is also very important that both the father and husband un-
is not considered part of the meal itself, but rather a kinuach derstand the proper approach in these matters. The Sefer
seudah, and there is no concern that he will come to eat Chassidim (siman 335) writes that when a father has a mar-
bread together with it. ried daughter who is occupied with the needs of her husband,
The Chazon Ish (O.C. 25:9), however, writes that it is dif- and the father needs her assistance, he should not instruct his
ficult to make distinctions that were not made by the daughter to attend to his needs while she is occupied with her
Rishonim, and that one who recites the berachah has not husband’s needs. Rather, if the husband is a proper person,
lost out. Nevertheless, he writes that one who is lenient he should tell her to take care of her father’s needs first.
because of the concern of a berachah levatalah, follow- As for the practical halachah regarding whether a married
ing the opinion of the Maharshal, should not be repri- woman is exempt from the laws of Mora Av Va’em, which
manded. Furthermore, I’ve seen many Acharonim who include the halachos of fearing ones parents, I have already
follow the opinion of the Maharshal and the Taz that written in my sefer Ohel Yaakov – Hilchos Kibbud Av
one does not recite a berachah even after using the Va’em that if her husband asks her to transgress a mitzvah of
bathroom. Among them are the Gra"z, the Devarim Mora, such as by asking her to sit in a place where her par-
HaChayim, and the Kitzur Shulchan Aruch. He ents are sitting, she certainly should not listen to him. Since
therefore writes that the common practice, both such matters have no connection to or contradiction with her
among Ashkenazim and Sephardim, is not to re- obligations to her husband, she remains obligated in the
cite the berachah. mitzvos of Kibbud and Mora Av Va’em.
On the other hand, if her parents ask her to do something that
The Extent of a Married Woman’s Exemption interferes with her husband’s wishes, such as asking her to
from Kibbud Av Va’em come eat at their home when her husband wants to remain at
home, or asking her to come visit them when she knows that
Q: A very common question concerns the doing so will cause her to neglect her responsibilities in the
obligation of a married woman to honor her home, she is not obligated to listen to them. Nevertheless, it
parents. Since there are many details of ha- is certainly preferable for the husband to make every effort
lachah in this area that are not always well to enable his wife to fulfill her parents’ requests whenever
known, I’ve been asked to write what is the possible, as we have brought above from the Sefer Chassi-
practical halachah in regards to this mat- dim. And surely one who has any doubt in regards to these
ter? matters should always get advice from their Rav beforehand.
A: The Gemara Kiddushin (31b) states:
“Ish—I only know a man; from where do
we know a woman? When the Torah
Take a part in spreading the light!
Email info@kollellihoraah.org for sponsorship opportunities.
To receive this weekly publication via email, Click here or email info@kollellihoraah.org.
Tremendous Mazel Tov to the Rosh Kollel Rabbi Skoczylas
on the engagement of his son Moshe Dovid. May we continue to
share in Simchas!!
