Lamdanim Gilyon - English — Ki Savoi (2026-08-24)

נדבת לז"נ רב גדלי' בן רב שמעון מאקס זצ"ל
HASHK AFAH SPONSOR TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SPONSOR Y E A R LY S P O N S O R דקות בעיון כל יום15 הוא היה רגיל לומר צריך כל אדם ללמוד לכה"פ
Are you a
HASHKAFA FROM HG"R GERSHON RIBNER SHLITA
When Parents Deny a Child’s
Lamdan?
Worrisome Tendencies
?
THIS WEEK'S LIVE SHAILA
QUESTION
I’m a fifth-grade Bais Yaakov teacher, and I have a student who is socially
פרשת כי תבוא תשפ"ו לפ"ק
and emotionally not okay. She has made it through the system so far,
getting away with it since she was so young, but now it has become very
apparent that things cannot continue this way. Due to the structure and PA R S H A H S P O N S O R לע"נ רבקה בלימה בת אברהם
extra attention given to her this past year, she has grown in some areas,
but as her teacher, how far does my responsibility go upon her graduating
from my class and moving on to the next grade? I’ve spoken to the parents Harav Shmuel D. Bernath Shlita, Posek at the Bais Horoah
and principal many times, but they don’t seem to take it seriously. It
breaks my heart watching her struggle, and I’m afraid she is headed down of Lakewood, Asks This Week’s Shailah B’Inyan Chatzitzah!
a negative path. What more can I do? The Shulchan Aruch in Yoreh Deah סימן קצ״חwrites that an Ishah must be
ANSWER
Tovel her entire body at one time, and even if a small amount of hair
remains outside the water, the Tevillah is not valid. The Taz, based on the
You may be correct in your analysis, and this girl is indeed headed Toras Kohanim brought by the Beis Yosef, explains that this is learned from
towards something disastrous, has serious mental or emotional the Pasuk, just as Bi’as Shemesh occurs all at once, so too Bi’as Besaro
health issues, and, with the right help, can overcome them. However, B’Mayim must be all at once. The Sidrei Taharah adds another proof from
you must be aware that the parents’ inability to hear the issue may the fact that a Mikvah requires forty Se’ah, enough water for the entire body
stem from the huge financial strain that comes along with getting to enter at once. Since the whole Guf must be immersed at one time,
help in these areas. These kinds of therapies, and the fees that come anything separating between the body and the water can invalidate the
along with them, never end, and it’s a never-ending cycle that drains Tevillah as a Chatzitzah. However, the Gemara says that Mid’Oraisa, only
the parents. Rubo U’Makpid is a Chatzitzah, meaning it covers most of the body and the
Were you to tell the parents that you will handle the financial aspect, person is bothered by it. Mi’ut HaMakpid and Rubo She’eino Makpid are only
or put them in touch with an organization, there’s hope they won’t be Chatzitzos Mid’Rabbanan. The difficulty, asked by Rav Elchonon Wasserman
in such denial and may be able to hear it. in Kovetz He’aros and also brought by the Achiezer, is that once the
This comes up all the time. A child may need Kriah help, and the Rabbanan say that Rubo She’eino Makpid invalidates the Tevillah, the
parents deny it, saying he doesn’t need it. If it were offered for free, person should now be considered Makpid on it, since he cannot have a valid
I’m sure they would be more objective in their judgment as to their Tevillah with it there. If so, every case of Rubo She’eino Makpid should
child’s needs. become Rubo U’Makpid and be a Chatzitzah Mid’Oraisa. How, then, can
there still be a category of Rubo She’eino Makpid which is only
Considering how much she’s grown in your class, another idea would Mid’Rabbanan?
be to do all you can to keep up and strengthen your connection with ;" עם רש"י ותוס' ד"ה "דבר תורה," "מחיצין: מ"חציצין דאורייתא" עד דף ו.גמ' סוכה דף ו
her, even after graduation. You can have her come play with your .'שו"ע יו"ד סי' קצ"ח סעי' א' עם ט"ז ס"ק א' )סד"ט ס"ק א'(; קובץ הערות הוספות אות ד'; אחיעזר ח"ג סי' ל"ג סוף אות א
children, come for a Shabbos, etc. Your ongoing mentorship can be
extremely influential in her life.
Chavra D'Hilchisa Raffle!
Submit your answer to 646-598-4703 for an entry to win a Sefer
Chazon Ish gifted by the Chazon Ish Zt"l himself to Yeshivas Beis
Zechus Harabbim!
Sponsor this week’s Lamdanim Inc newsletter or HaRav Gershon Ribner’s Hashkafa and connect to thousands of Lomdei
Yosef-Novardok in Tzfas!"
Torah. Dedicate L’iluy Nishmas, L’kovod a Simcha, or to share in the Zechus of the tremendous Rischa d’Oraisa.
Reserve your sponsorship today! (646) 598-4703
FOR COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS ON THE HASHKAFA MIMEON KODESH, TEXT 848-216-6466
TO HEAR THE SHAILA EXPLAINED CALL 917.810.2517
WANT TO BE MEHANEH YOUR OILAM WITH THIS NEWSLETTER? TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SUBSCRIBE TEXT "START" TO 917.810.2517 | HAVE A MEHALECH? SUBMIT IT TO "646-598-4703" BEFORE SUNDAY 1:30 P. M. EST
Therefore, by rainwater, intent is needed in order to define the water as having been captured
SEFER SPONSOR SEFER SHEMOS IS SPONSORED ר' חיים צבי בן ר' משה and drawn. Only the person’s Daas to collect it in the vessel gives it the status of Mayim
she’uvim. By a Ma’ayan, the water is already flowing from a definite source, and when it
enters the Kli, it is being drawn away from that source. Therefore, the Psul can apply more
Recent week's question & answer
readily. - D. Roth
• Even by rainwater, if the sky is cloudy, why is that called Daas? What if the person did not
explicitly intend for the Keilim to fill with water, even though he knew it was cloudy? It seems
Harav Daniel Glatstein Shlita, Rav of Kehilas Tiferes Mordechai, that since rain is expected, we view the result as included in his action, similar to the concept
Asks This Week’s Shailah B’Inyan Mikvaos! of Psik reisha. When something is effectively going to happen as a result of what a person
QUESTION does, that can be viewed as Halachic Daas. Therefore, when it is cloudy and rain is “on the
way,” placing the Keilim under the Tzinor qualifies as L’daas. But when the sky is clear, there
The Halacha is that Mayim Shu’uvim, water that entered a Kli, is Pasul for a Mikvah. is nothing presently in the atmosphere that is about to fill the Keilim, so we require actual
However, the Shulchan Aruch in סימן ר״א סעיף מ״אwrites that this is only when the awareness and consent. Based on this, a Ma’ayan is even stronger. The spring is already here,
water entered the Kli L’Daas. Therefore, if one placed Keilim under a Tzinor while already flowing, and all the ingredients are present
the sky was cloudy and rain was expected, the water is considered Mayim for the water to enter the Kli. Therefore, placing the
Shu’uvim, since it entered with his awareness and consent. But if the sky was clear Kli there is automatically treated as L’daas. - Rabbi
when the Keilim were placed there, and only afterward it rained, the water is not Dovid Meir Miller
considered Shu’uvim, because it did not enter the Kli L’Daas. The difficulty is from • The Taz in Se’if ches seems to learn that the case of
סעיף ח׳, where the Shulchan Aruch discusses a Ma’ayan and writes that if one placed the Ma’ayan is specifically where the Kli was placed
a Kli near the spring, and the water entered the Kli and then flowed out, that water there L’daas. The Shach, however, seems to
is Pasul for Tevilah. The Shulchan Aruch seems to say this without qualification, understand that even if he did not explicitly leave it
implying that by a Ma’ayan the water becomes Pasul simply by entering the Kli, there L’daas, a Ma’ayan that is always flowing or
even if it was not clearly L’Daas. This is the Stirah asked by the Shach in ס״ק צ״ב: overflowing is inherently considered L’daas. The
Why by rainwater is Mayim Shu’uvim dependent on L’Daas, while by a Ma’ayan it difference is simple. By rain, the person is not
seems to become Pasul automatically once it enters a Kli? placing his Kli next to a water-producing machine.
Rain may come, or it may not come, so it is not
ANSWER
necessarily Oleh al daato. But by a Ma’ayan, he is
The Shach answers that there is a fundamental difference between rainwater and a placing the Kli next to a constant source of water.
Ma’ayan. Rainwater is not in a person’s control, and there is no definite way to Even if it is not overflowing at that exact moment, it
know that it will fall. Therefore, if one placed the Kli there while the sky was clear, is something that naturally enters a person’s
even if it later rained, the water is not considered to have entered L’Daas, since the calculations. Therefore, it is considered L’daas. -
rain was not expected in a definite way. Only when the sky was overcast and rain Dovid Shunt, BMG
was clearly anticipated can the water that enters the Kli be considered L’Daas. A • Perhaps the difference depends on what
Ma’ayan, however, is different. If one places a Kli in the path of the spring, the water qualifications the water needs in order to be used.
is already flowing in that direction, and it is clear that it will enter the Kli. Therefore, By a regular Mikvah, it does not matter where the
even without any further indication, it is considered L’Daas, because the water’s water originally came from, as long as it was not
path is predictable and definite. In the words of the Shach, by rain it is Shelo made into Mayim she’uvim. Therefore, we focus on
MiDa’as, because Lav B’didei Talya Milsa, it is not in his control. But by a Ma’ayan, whether the water entered the Kli L’daas. By a
whenever he places the Kli in a way that the water passes through it, it is always spring, however, the water must retain the status of
considered L’Daas, since B’hechrach the water will enter. Mei ma’ayan. Once it enters a Kli, it is no longer
viewed as ordinary spring water flowing from its
source. It is therefore disqualified not only because
ש"ך שם ס"ק צ"ב 'שו"ע שם סע' ח שו"ע יו"ד סי' ר"א סע' מ"א
Haaros
of She’ivah, but because it has lost the status
needed to be used as Ma’ayan water. - Yisroel R.
R’ Ariel Bryskier suggested a different P’shat. By rainwater, water becomes Mayim
Mussar
Moment
she’uvim only when there is Daas. However, in the case of the Ma’ayan in Se’if ches, the
THE
person wants to use the water that is still flowing after it passes through the Kli. Such
water can only be used for Tevilah while Zochlin if it retains the status of a Ma’ayan. Once
"A person could get so angry that if he could - he'd destroy the entire world! For his שכלis not in control
the water passed through a Kli, even if it does not have the full Psul of Mayim she’uvim
anymore and all sense has left him"
that would invalidate forty Se’ah of rainwater, it can no longer be considered spring water - ( פרק י"א,רמח"ל )מסילת ישרים
connected to its natural source. Since it is now Zochlin without the status of a Ma’ayan, it
is Pasul for Tevilah. However, this is a frightening P’shat to say as the main explanation,
because the Drishah, Taz, and Shach do not seem to learn this way. They understand that
the case of Se’if ches is either actually L’daas, or that by a Ma’ayan the placement itself is LOMDUS SPONSOR TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SPONSOR
automatically treated as Daas, since the water is already flowing toward the Kli. - Avraham
Halpern
Are you a
FOLLOW US
• Fundamentally, when water goes from its source into a vessel, it is considered “drawn”
Lamdan?
because it has been removed from its natural source into a Kli. By rainfall, however, the TO SPONSOR A SHAILA LIELUEY NISHMAS
water was not drawn from a source. It simply fell from the sky directly into the vessel. OR REFUAH SHELEIMA TEXT 646.598.4703
