Masah Vmatan - English — Rosh Hashana (2026-09-07)

THE WERDIGER EDITION
BUSINESS WEEKLY
RESTORING THE PRIMACY OF CHOSHEN MISHPAT UNDER THE AUSPICES OF HARAV CHAIM KOHN, SHLITA
Issue #812 | Rosh Hashana | September 11, 2026 | 29 Elul 5786
לע״נ הרב יחיאל מיכל בן ר' משה אהרן אורליאן
CASE FILE Rabbi Meir Orlian
Writer for the Business Halacha Institute
BHI HOTLINE
לע"נ הרב אהרן בן הרב גדליהו ע"ה Submitted by the Beis Hora’ah
Q. An elderly couple could
A DELICATE
תשפ"ה
ערב ראש השנה
WHOSE TURN? After the legendary Rabbi Tokayer retired from serving as the shul’s not keep up with their
ba’al tekiah two years earlier, Rabbi Mandel began blowing on the first
day of Rosh Hashanah and his friend, Rabbi Stern, on the second.
DILEMMA mortgage payments, and
the bank foreclosed on
Both men were skilled ba’alei tekiah and were happy to blow on one their house and was about
of the days. to put it up for sale. One of their sons, Reuven, who
had not known about the situation until then, learned
“This year, the first day of Rosh Hashana is on Shabbos,” Rabbi Mandel remarked one evening during
what was happening and rushed to pay the debt, and
Elul. “We don’t blow shofar on Shabbos.”
the bank transferred ownership of the house to him.
“I know,” replied Rabbi Stern. “That means only I will blow this Rosh Hashanah, on the second day. Are His parents were relieved that, thanks to their son,
you OK with that?” they could now remain in their home rent-free.
Rabbi Mandel looked surprised. “Why should I lose out?” he asked. Several years later, the father passed away, and
“It’s very simple,” replied Rabbi Stern. “You have a chazakah for the first day, and I have for the the mother continued living in the house. Recently,
second day. The fact that the first day does not work out for you this year is no reason to change our Reuven accumulated debts of his own and is under
arrangement.” financial stress. He suggested to his siblings that
“I don’t look at it quite that way,” Rabbi Mandel replied. “Each year, I have the first opportunity. Since we perhaps she could move into an apartment that
can’t blow on Shabbos, I should have the first opportunity when it arrives on the second day.” he would rent for her, enabling him to rent out the
house for substantially more than her rent and use the
Rabbi Stern shook his head. “Whoever said that you were given precedence?” he argued. “We each took
difference to pay his debts.
a day, with its ups and downs. If you are entitled, though, I’m not going to take your right.”
They replied that if, according to halachah, he is not
“I also don’t want to take from you, if it’s your right,” replied Rabbi Mandel. “Let’s ask the Rov!”
obligated to allow her to remain in the house, they will
The two approached Rabbi Dayan and asked: cover the difference.
“Who gets to blow on the second HALACHA
BUSINESS day this year?”
INSTITUTE: What is the halachah?
“Panim Meiros (2:126) addresses this AVENUE
1937 OCEAN question,” replied Rabbi
BROOKLYN Dayan. “He compares this case to the
NY 11230 A. The parent’s other heirs apparently understand that
practice concerning a piyyut normally recited on the first night of Sukkos, but not when it falls on Reuven is the sole owner of the house. His parents
Shabbos. presumably understood that when he acquired the
Levush (O.C. 642) writes that prevalent practice is that the piyyut is postponed to the second night, and house from the bank, he agreed to “lend” it to them
the piyyut for the second night is omitted. However, in Posen they simply omitted the piyyut for the as a rent-free residence. Now the question is what the
first night entirely, following the principle of ho’il v’idchei, idchei — once something was displaced from terms of this agreement entail.
its proper time, it remained displaced. The poskim discuss a parallel case regarding someone
Magen Avraham supports the prevalent practice from the Gemara (Sukkah 55a) regarding the shir shel who rents a house to a tenant without specifying a
yom recited in the Beis Hamikdah on Chol Hamo’ed Sukkos. When Shabbos occurs during Chol Hamoed, term for the lease. Some poskim rule that the landlord
the remaining sequence is postponed by a day, and the last song is omitted. may terminate the lease whenever he pleases (Sma,
Choshen Mishpat 312:6). Others maintain that he may
Panim Meiros applies this principle to the two ba’alei tekiah. He concludes, following the prevalent
not terminate it during the first thirty days, because an
practice, that the ba’al tekiah of the first day should blow, and the second ba’al tekiah is pushed off.
unspecified lease (stam sechirus) is presumed to be for
Shaarei Teshuvah (O.C. 581:7) and Beis She’arim (O.C. #270) question this analogy, though. It is logical thirty days (Shach ibid. 7. Shitah Mekubetzes, Bava Metzia
that the Sages initially arranged a sequence of shir shel yom or piyyut, perhaps related to their relative 103a cites an opinion that stam sechirus is for twelve
importance or relevance to the holiday. Thus, it is understandable that when the first item is postponed, months).
the last is pushed aside.
The Acharonim discuss whether someone who
Here, however, each person acquired his own day, unless it was initially established that the first-day “borrows” a house, living in it rent-free, is akin to a
ba’al tekiah should take priority. The fact that the first person is unable to exercise his right does not renter and therefore subject to the above dispute,
allow him to usurp the right of the second. or whether, in such a case, the owner may demand
Moreover, each ba’al tekiah has a distinct advantage. The first has the distinction of blowing on the the house back immediately (see Mishpetei HaChoshen
THE WERDIGER EDITION - לע"נ הרה"ח ר' נחמי'ה בן הרה"ח ר' שלמה אלימלך ז"ל- DEDICATED BY HIS SON R’ SHLOME WERDIGER
BEIS HORAAH BUSINESS SERVICE DIVISION AWARENESS & EDUCATION
Ask the Rav, Email correspondence / Arbitration and Mediation Rabbinical Consultation / Banking and Iska / Contract Drafting Business Weekly / Hebrew Masa Umatan / Shiurim and Chaburis / Kollel l’Dayanis Choshen Mishpat
/ Small Claims / Wills and Estate Planning / Halacha Hotline / Shabbos Initiative / Industry-specific Seminars Curriculum / Seforim & Publications / Self-learning Program / Halacha on the Daf
CASE FILE BHI HOTLINE
primary day of Rosh Hashanah; the second has the distinction that his day never 341:4). They also debate whether the owner must give the borrower
falls on Shabbos. the amount of advance notice a landlord must give a tenant before
evicting him, so he can find a different place to live (see Minchas Pittim
Igros Moshe (Y.D. 3:101) further writes that the first-day ba’al tekiah never 312:5).
established a chazakah regarding a year in which Hashana falls on Shabbos. He There is an important qualification, however. When a property is
therefore concludes that the second ba’al tekiah retains his established right. rented or lent for a specific purpose, the duration of the arrangement
Ketzeh Hamateh (on Mateh Ephraim 581:30) cites Parashas Mordechai (O.C. #23), who is determined based on the amount of time generally needed for that
use (Choshen Mishpat 341:2, 5).
concludes that the rights of the two are equivalent, so that the more qualified ba’al
In some cases, the terminology used in the agreement, against the
tekiah should blow. Ketzeh Hamateh concludes that if choosing between them will
backdrop of the circumstances, is proof that the owner intended
lead to dispute, or if the two are equally qualified, they should divide the tekios to grant the borrower the rights to use the item in perpetuity. For
(Piskei Teshuvos 581:15). example, if a borrower poses his request as, “Lend me this item
“I certainly hope,” concluded Rabbi Dayan, “that people worthy of serving as ba’alei betovas’cha” (i.e., in your kindness and generosity), and a kinyan
(acquisitional act) was made to formalize the transaction, the borrower
tekiah should be able to reach an acceptable arrangement without strife.”
may use the item indefinitely (Shulchan Aruch, Choshen Mishpat 341:6),
Verdict: Panim Meiros rules, following the prevalent practice regarding the assuming the owner is, indeed, known for his kindness and generosity
first-night Sukkos piyyut, that the first-day baal tekiah takes precedence and (see Sma ibid. 15; Nesivos ibid. 10).
blows on the second day. However, several Acharonim reject this comparison, If the borrower asked to borrow the item “betuvo,” for as long as the
item is “good” — i.e., remains usable — then the borrower may use it
and uphold the right of the second-day ba’al tekiah to blow on his day. Others
for as long as it exists, even if they did not make a kinyan. Furthermore,
consider the rights equivalent, so that the more qualified ba’al tekiah should
if the borrower dies and the item is still in working condition, his heirs
blow or the two should divide the tekios. inherit the rights to use it (Tzemach Tzedek, Choshen Mishpat 85).
In our case, the exact terms of how long the parents — or parent
MONEY MATTERS — could remain in the house were not discussed explicitly when
MONEY MATTERS Onaas Devarim, Falsehood Reuven bought the house from the bank. To establish whether
and Geneivas Daas #17 the mother has a halachic right to remain in the dwelling, beis din
Based on writings of Harav Chaim Kohn, shlita To Increase Tzedakah would have to hear from the two parties exactly what was said at
'לע"נ ר' יחיאל מיכל ב"ר חיים וזוג' חי' בת ר that time in order to determine whether the agreement included
שמואל חיים ע"ה the right for her to remain there. Obviously, however, the entire
discussion is relevant only to whether the agreement would apply
Q: When the shul auctions off aliyahs, can I state a high sum with no intention to the mother once the father passed on; their heirs certainly don’t
to buy the aliyah, just to jack up the price significantly for the others bidding inherit the rights to borrow the property (see Tzemach Tzedek ibid.).
in earnest? Until now we have been discussing a case in which the bank had
A: Yosef Ometz (#57) prohibits this, since this unfairly forces those who want already reached the stage of selling the property, and the son
the aliyah to give more than they normally would have. Furthermore, it entails forestalled the public auction by buying it from the bank.
falsehood because the person does not want to buy the mitzvah. A more common scenario involves a son stepping in to pay off the
Minchas Yitzchak (3:97) also prohibits this. He mentions the Gemara (Sukkah 29a- debt at some point during the foreclosure process, before the bank
b) that harshly criticizes wealthy people to proclaim tzedakah publicly but do has proceeded to the sale stage. In such a case, the father is the one
not give. Maharsha explains that this refers to communal leaders who proclaim who transfers the property to the son, not the bank. Since it is within
publicly large sums, but later say that they only intended so that others will give the rights of a seller of a property to retain rights to live in it (shiyur
generously. zechus dirah; see Choshen Mishpat 212:3), the father generally makes
Similarly, the gabbai should not intentionally exaggerate the amount needed, so that condition. If he states that both he and his wife retain rights to
that people will donate more than they would if they had known the true need. live in the dwelling, the Rema rules that his statement is effective, but
However, he may state the goal for which the appeal is striving, even if aware that other poskim argue that if the wife was not listed as a co-owner of the
the sum is not realistic in practice. house, then her husband cannot retain dwelling rights on her behalf
Moreover, some allow announcing at a dinner for tzedakah a major donation, even with a verbal condition alone; they would have to make a kinyan for
if not in earnest, to encourage others to emulate without forcing them, provided such a clause to take effect (Shach ibid. 3; Taz).
that it is clear to the gabbaim beforehand that the person never intended to give If the house was owned by both parents, however, all poskim agree
this sum (Tzedakah U’mishpat 7:[5*], 5760 edition). This opinion is questionable. that each one can, individually, make the transfer of the home to
the son conditional on their retaining dwelling rights. Even so, those
For questions on monetary matters, arbitrations, legal documents, wills, ribbis, & Shabbos, Please
contact our confidential hotline at 877.845.8455 or ask@businesshalacha.com rights are not inherited by the other heirs (Choshen Mishpat 209:7).
PLACE YOUR LOGO HERE IT WILL BE SEEN BY 30,000 PEOPLE
NL@BUSINESSHALACHA.COM
(718) 233-3845 #201
Car Rental
718-633-2500
reservations@sensiblecarrentalbklyn.com
732- 886-5430
BHI | 1937 Ocean Avenue | Brooklyn, NY 11230 | 718-233-3845 | ask@businesshalacha.com | www.businesshalacha.com
