gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

Einey Menachem — Rosh Hashana (2026-09-07)

Publisher: Einey Menachem

Week: Rosh Hashana (2026-09-07)

Einey Menachem — Rosh Hashana (2026-09-07)

Open the PDF Download

‫בס"ד‬ ‫עיני מנחם‬ ‫לע"נ הרב מנחם מנדל בן הרב אלטר שמואל אהרן זצ"ל‬ ‫שבת ראש השנה תשפ"ז‬ ‫ דברי תורה‬My Zeidy used to say: 1. The Rebbe, Reb Simcha Bunim of P’shischa would explain the words in davening: ‫ורוממתנו‬ ‫ מכל הלשונות‬- to mean that no language in the world can properly expressthe ‫– רוממות‬ exaltedness of the Jewish people. 2. ‫ והקל הקדוש נקדש בצדקה‬,‫ – ויגבה ה' צבקות במשפט‬the Sefer Hayashar V’hatov sasy that if Hashem were to judge us with justice – ‫ משפט‬then He would be ‘forced’ to depart from us (‫ויגבה – )ח"ו‬. Because Hashem judges us instead with ‫ צדקה‬memeila He is sanctified – ‫ונקדש‬. 3. ‫ עצתו אמונה‬- ‫ סתרו יושר‬The Sefer Tiferes Uziel writes the following explanation: Hashem Yisborach hides Himself from His creations. Hashem’s hiding Himself is upright – ‫סתרו יושר‬. Why? What is the ‘counsel’ of Hashem in doing so? In this way we come to ‫ – אמונה‬belief in Him - ‫עצתו אמונה‬. If Hashem wouldn’t hide Himself and He would be seen to all in His Glory, man wouldn’t need to make any effort to know Him and he wouldn’t get any reward for it. But, because He hides Himself, His council\advice to us is ‫ – אמונה‬for us to believe in Him and get rewarded for our choice. 4. ‫ ובן אדם יתאמץ בך‬,‫ אשרי איש שלא ישכחך‬The Sefer Kedushas Levi differentiates between ‫איש‬ and ‫בן אדם‬. ‫ איש‬refers to an ‫אדם חשוב‬. He doesn’t forget Hashem at all, ever. ‫ בן אדם‬refers to an average person. He will strengthen himself through ‫בך‬, through the torah that is written with the ‫ כ"ב‬oisiyos. 5. '‫ הריעו לפני המלך ה‬,‫ בחצוצרות וקול שופר‬The Sefer Turei Zahav quotes the gemara in Rosh Hashana that says: Any year that there are no tekios in the beginning [of the year] bad things happen (‫ )ח"ו‬happen in it. This idea can be seen in our posuk: You make sure that you blow those tekios - ‫בחצוצרות וקול שופר הריעו‬, before Hashem will blow His teruah - '‫לפני המלך ה‬. 6. ‫ באין מליץ יושר‬The Kedushas Levi explains that the more a person realizes his lack – ‫– באין‬ and asks Him for mechila, that will be for him a ‫ – מליץ יושר‬an advocate. Have a wonderful Shabbos! ‫בס"ד‬ Parsha Gems a small parsha gem written by lamed shin mem. ‫ה‬ð‫ראש הש‬ ‫כי עזה כמות אהבה קשה כשאול קנאה‬ It came the day of Moshe Rabbeinu’s waiting and he was afraid. Moshe said petira. Moshe Rabbeinu knew this to him, “Rebbe come with me.” because Hashem had told him ‫הן קרבו‬ Yehoshua left acompanied by Moshe ‫ימיך למות‬. Nevertheless Moshe on his left. They entered the ‫אהל מועד‬ Rabbeinu didn’t want to die. So, he and the ‫ עמוד הענון‬came down between figured, “If I can somehow survive the Moshe and Yehoshua and spoke only to day that I am meant to die, the ‫– גזרה‬ Yehoshua. When the ‫ ענן‬left, Moshe decree – will be ‫ – בטל‬annulled.” In asked Yehoshsua, “What did Hashem order to accomplish this he began to teach you?” Yehoshua was surprised, learn non-stop. He wrote 13 Sifrei “When Hashem spoke to you, Moshe, I Torah and the hours passed. It was knew what he said to you. “How is it time for ‫ שקיעה‬and Hashem motioned that Rebbe must ask me?” At that time to the sun to set but it refused. “I Moshe Rabbeinu called out: “A refuse to set as long as Moshe is alive. hundred deaths and not one Jealousy – (The time of Yehoshua to lead has ‫קנאה‬. As it says in ('‫ ו‬,'‫שיר השירים )ח‬: ‫כי‬ come and Moshe Rabbeinu must ‫ קשה כשאול קנאה‬,‫עזה כמות אהבה‬. Nothing depart)”. Moshe Rabbeinu turned to can compete to the love that Moshe Hakadosh Boruch Hu with the following had for Yehoshua and to the jealosy. offer, “I will give Yehoshua my position, Once Moshe Rabbeinu accepted death as long as I can still live.” Hashem said upon himself Hashem consoled him to Moshe, “Act to Yehoshua as he has with ‫תחית המתים‬, that just as in this acted towards you in the past.” Moshe world you led My children, so too in the Rabbeinu got up and went to the door world to come – ‫ויזכר ימי עולם משה עבדו‬. of Yehoshua and waited. When Yehoshua came out, he saw his Rebbe ‫בס"ד‬ ‫ דברי הרב‬a short excerpt from the shuirim of Rav Zimmerman ‫ שליט"א‬on the Halachos of Bishul (Siman Shin Yud Ches). ‫ סעיף י"ח‬cont. from last weeks [‫ האלפס והקדרה שהעבירן מרותחין מעל גבי האור‬- You took a pot which is hot, and you took it off the fire, ‫ אם לא נתבשל כל צרכו‬- if it is not fully cooked, ‫ אין מוציאין בכף מהם‬- if it is not fully cooked, you have cholent that is not fully cooked and you take the cholent off the fire Friday night and it is not fully cooked yet ‫ אין מוציאין בכף מהן‬he shouldn’t take it out with a spoon, he should pour it out, he shouldn’t take it out with a spoon because: ‫ שנמצא מגיס ואיכא משום מבשל‬- because when you take it out with a spoon so it is like you are stirring the pot; whenever you take something out of a pot it just creates a shift in the pot and it is considered like ‫מבשל‬. Now the ‫ לשון‬of the Mechaber is: ‫ואיכא משום מבשל‬. So the Mishna Berura explains that if you do actual ‫הגסה‬, that is an issur d’oraysa. If you stir a pot which is not fully cooked that is an issur d’oraysa, if you just take with a ‫ כף‬out of the pot which is not fully cooked that is a d’rabonon, as it says in the ‫שער הציון‬ ‫ס"ק קל"ז‬. So the Mechaber is saying that if it is not fully cooked, if you stir it you are over a d’oraysa, if you take it out with a spoon you are over a d’rabonon. ‫ ואם נשבשל כל צרכו‬- but if it is fully cooked, ‫ מותר‬- then it is mutar. The Mechaber’s shita is, if something is cooked and it is hot so it is ‫ אין בישול אחר בישול‬there is nothing you can do wrong with a fully cooked pot. ‫ אבל צמר ליורה‬- but wool which is in a pot which is being dyed, ‫אף‬ ‫ – על פי שקלט העין‬even though the dye was caught already, ‫ אסור להגיס בו‬- to stir it, because you going to make the dye go in deeper and that is a melocho of ‫צובע‬. ‫ על כל פנים‬the Mechaber’s shita is rather simple, that something that is ‫ מתבשל כל צרכו‬there is no ‫ חשש‬of ‫ ;בישול‬something which is ‫ לא נתשבל כל צרכו‬you could do ‫ בישול‬on it. Therefore, ‫ הגסה‬is being ‫ מקרב בשולו‬and that is an isur d’oraysa, taking it out with a ‫ כף‬which is inadvertent ‫ מקרב בשולו‬that is an ‫אסור דרבנן‬. That is the Mechaber’s shita. Comes along the Rema and says "‫ "ולכתחילה יש לזהר‬- lechatchila you should be careful ‫אף בכל ענין‬. Now the Rema goes to a total other extreme; that you should be careful to not take out ‫ הוצאה בכף‬from a pot even when it is not on the fire. In other words you should always pour out pots. This is what the Rema says.This is what the Rema says. So, the Mishna Berura in ‫ ס"ק קיז‬says that even if it is ‫ אינה על האש‬- the Rema meant even if it is off the fire. Comes along the Mishna Berura and says: ‫אלא יהפך‬ ‫ ועין באחרונים דלא נהיגין להחמיר בזה‬.‫ הקדרה לקערה ולא יוציא בכף‬- we don’t keep the minhag of the Rema, ,‫דבאמת העיקר כמו שכתבנו מתחילה‬ ‫ דמבושל כל צרכו אפילו להגיס מותר‬- really the Mechaber is right, that even if you would stir a ‫ מבושל כל צרכו‬it would be permissible, because ‫אין‬ ‫בישול אחר בישול‬. ‫ והרוצה להחמיר יחמיר בהגסה ממש‬... ‫ וכמבואר לקמן סימן שכ"א‬- so if you want to be machmir you should be machmir in ‫ הגסה‬itself. That is the shita of the ‫ כל בו‬who says that ‫ הגסה‬that is ‫ מבושל כל צרכו‬is ossur; you want to be machmir like the ‫כל בו‬, do so. ‫אבל להוציא בכף אין‬ ‫ להחמיר כלל בנתבשל כל צרכו ואינה על האש‬- but don’t be machmir on the d’rabonon. However, when he says don’t be machmir on the d’rabonon he is saying don’t be machmir on the d’rabonon when it is ‫ אינו על האש‬it is mashma when it is ‫ על האש‬you should be machmir on the d’rabonon, and as a matter of fact, that is what he says in the Mishna Berura at the end of the Mishna Berura ‫קי"ג‬: ‫ אפילו עומד על גבי האור‬,‫ובנתבשל כל צרכו‬ ‫ אבל באליה רבה מסיק דיש לאסר בזה‬,‫ כן משמע בבית יוסף‬.‫ מותר להוציא בכף‬. So we come out as follows: According to the Mechaber there is only one issue, is it ‫ מבושל כל צרכו‬or not; if it is ‫ מבושל כל צרכו‬you can do whatever you want, if it is ‫ אינו מבושל כל צרכו‬then ‫ הגסה‬is a d’oroysa, ‫ הוצאה בכף‬is a d’rabonon. According to the Rema everything is ossur. According to the Mishna Berura where he says that the minhag is that ‫ הגסה‬is ossur, always ossur. You should not do ‫ הגסה‬that is possibly an issur d’oraysa according to the ‫כל בו‬, even if it is ‫מבושל כל צרכו‬. And to take it out of a pot with a spoon you shouldn’t do it while it is ‫על גבי האש‬.] Now what do you do with a pot for the whole yeshiva? What does the Rema want you to do? What even the Mishna Berura wanted to do? Now again, what the Mishna Berura would want you to do maybe, is, take it off the fire. There is a possibility at least what he want you to do, take it off the fire. The problem is when the laws of ‫ חזרה‬are going to be very complicated ‫עודה בידה‬, if you are going to hold the whole pot it is going to be very difficult. What the Rema wants you do is even a bigger question, what are you supposed to do, how are you going to get the cholent out of the pot, you should just turn it upside down what are you supposed to do so if you look in the chason ish the chazon ish says that what the Mishna brura says that our minhag is ‫ הוצאה בכף‬we are machmir on ‫ הוצאה בכף‬when it is ‫ נתבשל כל צרכו על גבי האש‬is only on a small pot, not in a large pot, a large pot that is difficult to move there there isn’t any chumra, there again we will be machmir on the ‫ כל בו‬of ‫ הגסה‬but we are not going to be machmir on ‫ הוצאה בכף‬so that is why in yeshivos you take it out off the fire, again once it is ‫ מבושל כל צרכו‬if it is not ‫ מבושל כל צרכו‬even the mechabir holds it is ossur but if it is ‫ מבושל כל צרכו‬you take it off the fire, but you should not do ‫ הגסה‬itself. ‫בס"ד‬ A Story: A small house with wide doors The Schwab’s house in Monsey was a modest four bedroom house with a living room\d0ining room and a small kitchen. Despite its size there was always room for visitors or guests. There was a woman, a widow who lived in a nearby town with a sparse Jewish population. She wanted to be in a a more Jewish environment for Rosh Hashona and Yom Kippur and what better place then the Schawb home. Out of respect for the religious sensitivities of her hosts she covered her hair with a doily, the kind that is customary to wear in Conservative Temples. After the Rosh Hashona meal there was a half hour break before Mincha. While the Rebbetzin took a much needed short nap, Rav Mordechai entertained his guest taking to her about her family. Rav Mordechai’s relative who was also a guest at the time observed his cousin and was astounded. On the way to Mincha he couldn’t restrain himself from asking Rav Mordechai why he spent precious time on the holy day of Rosh Hashona talking about mundane matters? “For two reasons,” explained Rav Mordechai, “Firstly, this woman is a an ‫ אלמנה‬and very lonely. It definitely was the ‫ מצוה‬of ‫ הכנסת אורחים‬to spend time with a guest speaking about matters that interest her. Secondly, I wanted the Rebbetin to take a nap and not need to entertain the guest,” A double mitzva. Have an uplifting Shabbos!