Vayomer Eliyahu - English — Rosh Hashana (2026-09-07)

ערב
By Rabbi Eli Meyer Smith Shlit”a
Rosh Hakollel of Bais Ulfana Lehoroa »
שנת תשפ "ז
«Email rabbi@yeshivasrebchaim ozer.com
בס"ד
Rosh Hashanah is a Time When One’s Life Can be Completely Transformed for
the Better!
›› Why are We Judged at the Beginning of the Year, different than the one before it and the one after it. Each
and Not at the End? year is unique in the sense that one’s spiritual mission is
different this year than in any other year.
Rosh Hashanah has several names. It is called “Zichron
Teruah” (the day of remembering the blowing of the shofar), “Yom Just like every generation has its own unique purpose,
Teruah” (the day of blowing), and “Yom Zikaron” (the day of so too every year has its individual purpose. In order for
remembrance). However, it is always commonly referred to the entire purpose of creation to be fulfilled, each year
as “Rosh Hashanah”. Additionally, the tractate that must be used to fulfill its objective.
speaks about this day is called “Maseches Rosh For this reason, we recite on Rosh Hashanah: “Before
Hashanah.” You is revealed all hidden things and a multitude of
The name of every holiday reflects the essence of the secrets from the beginning of time. Everything is revealed
day. This leads us to ask why this day is known as “Rosh and known before You, Hashem our G-d. You look and see
Hashanah”, which merely refers to the fact that this day until the end of all generations.” We do not only mention
is at the beginning of the year. This seems to be a small the events and occurrences of the previous year. Rather,
detail that is not as important as other aspects of the day, we speak about all generations, from the very beginning
such as the fact that it is the day when every living being until the very end.
is judged for the upcoming year. If so, why isn’t this day This is because in order to determine the purpose of a
known by a name that brings out its true meaning and specific year, Hashem looks back at every year of the past
importance? and ahead towards every year of the future, and thereby
We may further ask why we are judged on the first day decides if this year was used properly for its greater
of the year. Our judgment is on our past deeds. Therefore, purpose. This is how we are judged on Rosh Hashanah –
it would seem more appropriate to be judged on the last to determine if we properly fulfilled the purpose of this
day of the year, rather than on the first day of the next specific year so that it can be used for the grand scheme
year. of all of history.
These questions lead us to conclude that, in fact, the ›› An Accountant Always Looks Back at Previous
essence of the day is that it is the first day of the year, and Accounts
that being the beginning of the year is what makes it To better understand this idea, we may quote the
fitting to be the day of judgment. Therefore, we must words of Rav Chaim Friedlander zt”l (Sefer Sifsei Chaim). He
explain why this is so. explains that the judgment of Rosh Hashanah is not like a
We may first state that the mission of each generation human court case, where the court judges a defendant
is updated and renewed every year. It would be a mistake and decides what his reward or punishment should be
for one to think that each year is the same as the last. It based on everything he did in the past. We will be judged
would be wrong to think that the same cycle restarts this way at the end of our lives, when we face the
every year, and that one goes through the same four Heavenly Court. However, the judgment of Rosh
seasons in the same exact way that he did the year Hashanah is not like this. Rather, it is mostly a judgment
before. for the future.
The Maharal (Gevuros Hashem, Perek 51) writes He states that the day is called “Rosh
that the word “shana” (year) has the same Hashanah” because everything that will
connotation as the word “shinui” (change). happen during the year is already there in this
This indicates that every year is completely “rosh”, this beginning. That is why we say in
}{א
davening that this day is a remembrance of the first day ›› Why We Eat Honey on Rosh Hashanah
of the world. Just as the entire course of the world was
already there on the first day, so too, the entire course of The Gemara (Rosh Hashanah 11A) says that Sarah, Rochel
the year is already there on Rosh Hashanah. and Chana all conceived on Rosh Hashanah. The
Maharsha states that Rosh Hashanah is called “Yom
Thus, on Rosh Hashanah, Hashem judges which Zikaron” (the day of remembrance) because on this day, every
hashpa’os (spiritual influences) should be sent to the world living creature is remembered, and all their actions are
for the next year. That is why Rosh Hashanah is at the examined. These women had been barren for many
beginning of the year. The main judgment is for the years. Both due to their nature and their mazal, they
coming year – not for the past. could not bear children. But on Rosh Hashanah, they were
remembered by Hashem, and their nature and mazal
This can be further explained with an analogy of an
were changed.
accountant for a store or factory who
takes inventory once a year to know With these few words, the Maharsha
precisely how much profit was made, how encapsulates the sanctity of the day. He is
many expenses there were, how much saying that on this day, nature and mazal
“…Furthermore,
merchandise came in, and how much went can be changed, and one’s life can be
out. This is done in order to know how to there is a rule in completely transformed.
best run the business in the next year. In
order to plan for the future, one must halacha (see In this vein, the Chofetz Chaim zt”l
would say (see biography at the end of Chofetz
know the past. But the main purpose of Shulchan Aruch, Chaim al Hatorah, page 1118) that the reason we
accounting is for the future, not for the
past. Yoreh Deah 81:8) read the story of Hashem granting Sarah
the ability to bear a child on Rosh
That is what happens every year on that if any non- Hashanah is because this conception was
Rosh Hashanah. A man’s past deeds are supernatural. According to the rules of
reviewed and judged in order for Hashem kosher food falls nature, Sarah could not have children (see
to ascertain what to give him for the next into honey, it Yavamos 64). However, Hashem changed
year. Hashem “takes inventory” of all her nature to give her the ability to give
people to decide what tools a person becomes birth.
needs to fulfill his personal mission for the
permitted to eat. We read this story on Rosh Hashanah
new year, and to determine exactly what
because this is a time when nature can be
will be expected of him over the course of It is transformed
the next year. changed for all of us. Even if we have
from whatever it experienced many difficulties until now,
Thus, he is not judged in order to everything can change on this day, and we
reward or punish him. Rather, his actions was into honey. can begin the new year with a full
from the past year are inspected to see transformation for the better.
This symbolizes
what type of mission he will be given for
the upcoming year and what sort of tools how we can There is a common custom, cited in
he will need to fulfill it. Shulchan Aruch, to eat honey on Rosh
transform our Hashanah. The Shem M’Shmuel of
This means that Rosh Hashanah is a Sochatchov zt”l explains that honey is a
new beginning for the next year, which is lives completely kosher entity that is emitted by a non-
completely different than the previous on Rosh kosher insect. It comes from an impure
year. This is as Rav Yonason Eibeshutz zt”l source, but it is transformed into
(Ye’aros Devash, Chelek Bais, Drush 5) notes that Hashanah…” something pure. Furthermore, there is a
we recite: “Hayom Haras olam. On this day, rule in halacha (see Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh Deah
the world is created.” We do not say that 81:8) that if any non-kosher food falls into
the world “was” created, in the past tense; honey, it becomes permitted to eat. It is
rather, we say that it “is” created, in the present tense. transformed from whatever it was into honey. This
This is because on this very day, there is a new beginning symbolizes how we can transform our lives completely on
for the world. It is created anew. Because of that, we Rosh Hashanah.
stand in judgment in regards to what we will receive for
the coming year. The Shem M’Shmuel goes on to say (5674) that the
biggest transformation that could ever happen is for a
Having said all this, we can state that even if one’s male baby to change its gender and become a female.
mazal was bad in the past year, he can start anew in the This type of change has never occurred in the world.
coming year, as each year brings with it a complete However, it did happen once, and that was on Rosh
renewal. Hashanah. This is stated in the piyyut recited during
}{ב
Shacharis on the first day of Rosh Hashanah, when we say rich. Rashi explains that this means that everyone should
that Leah had a male baby in her womb, and it was begin the year on Rosh Hashanah by making themselves
transformed into a female – her daughter, Dina – on Rosh poor, by lowering themselves before Hashem with
Hashanah. heartfelt prayers and supplications. This is stated in the
verse (Mishlei 18:23): “The poor people recite
He writes that this is symbolic of how even the most supplications.”
unnatural transformations can occur on Rosh Hashanah.
He concludes by saying: “There is no better time to The Rambam (Pirush Hamishnayos, Rosh Hashanah 4:7) says
change from bad to good than on Rosh Hashanah. If this that the reason we do not recite the tefillah of Hallel on
is true about physical matters, it is certainly true about Rosh Hashanah or Yom Kippur is because these are “days
spiritual matters. One can experience a great revolution of service, self-annulment, fear, and quaking before
for the better on this day.” Hashem, and for all of these things it is improper to have
laughter and joy.”
Rav Pinchos of Koretz zt”l (Imrei Pinchos) compares this
to a tablet of salt that is cooked in a pot of hot water. The Brisker Rov zt”l is known to have remarked that
Every grain of salt melts and reforms in a new place, until we are running in fear from Hashem, and we are
it is impossible to tell which grains used to be on top and simultaneously running directly into His hands. However,
which ones used to be on the bottom. So too, we are only one who truly fears Him can find refuge by Him. One
reformed and rebuilt on Rosh Hashanah, to the extent who does not truly fear Him, cannot run to Him.
that we are almost unrecognizable from the way we were
before. The Tur (Orech Chaim 581) cites the Medrash that says
the way of the world is that when one is being judged in
›› The Gerrer Rebbe’s Encouragement to the a court case, he wears black clothing, grows his beard
Young Men Who Lost Their Money long, and does not cut his fingernails because he is
worried about what ruling he will receive. However, when
The Gemara (Rosh Hashanah, ibid) also says that Yosef Klal Yisroel is being judged, we wear white clothes, trim
was released from prison on Rosh Hashanah and that the our beards, cut our nails, eat and drink, and celebrate
forced labor of the Jewish people in Egypt ended on Rosh because we have faith that He will perform miracles for
Hashanah. We learn from this that every salvation, both us.
for the public and for an individual, is decreed and written
on this day. From the Tur’s words that “we have faith He will
perform miracles for us”, we see that this depends on the
This is as the Shoel U’Meishiv writes (Mahadura Revi’is, strength of our faith. If one has true faith, he can merit
Teshuva 125): “All good things and holy hashpa’os are having miracles performed for him. However, only one
created on this day. This is because this is the creation is who makes himself like a pauper because he fears
renewed every year at this time.” Hashem is able to have this level of bitachon, and thereby
It is related that the Sefas Emes of Ger zt”l once merit having his prayers heard.
traveled before Rosh Hashanah to give chizuk to a group This idea is also found in the Rabenu Yona (Avos 2:13).
of young men who had lost all their savings in a failed Rabenu Yona writes that one should utter his prayers like
business deal. He told them, “Yosef Hatzadik got out of a pauper who is supplicating and asking for what he
prison on Rosh Hashanah, and the seven years of plenty needs, not like someone who is asking for something he
then started immediately. This day is so powerful that it doesn’t really need, who isn’t begging with a lowly heart
can take a person from one end of the spectrum to the and broken spirit. Every man must make requests for
other. Hashem can certainly do the same for you.” himself because everyone needs mercy. Hashem
The Gemara (Rosh Hashana 26B) rules that the shofar withholds His anger and has compassion for people, not
used on Rosh Hashanah must be bent. Rashi says that this because of their virtue.
can be compared to a man. It is better for a man to be He adds: “One must supplicate to Him, for perhaps
more bent during tefillah with his head bent towards the Hashem will stop holding back evil that is caused by one’s
ground, in fulfillment of the verse (1 Malachim 9:3): “And my sins. For miracles do not occur all the time.”
eyes and heart will be there.” Therefore, on the yomtov
of Rosh Hashanah, which is meant for tefillah and for We see from the Tur and Rabenu Yona that one must
remembering the akeidas Yitzchok, the shofar must be trust in Hashem to perform a miracle for him. We know
bent. that we don’t deserve anything. Everything we have is a
result of His mercy and compassion. Therefore, we must
Chazal are teaching us how one should pray on Rosh daven on Rosh Hashanah like a pauper begging at the
Hashanah so that his prayers will be effective. The tefillos door. If we utter such prayers from the depths of our
must be said with self-annulment and complete hearts, we can have bitachon that He will perform
subjugation to Hashem. This is as the Gemara says (Rosh miracles for us and transform all our suffering into
Hashanah 16B) that every year which begins poor will end goodness.
}{ג
