Lamdanim Gilyon - English — Rosh Hashana (2026-09-07)

נדבת לז"נ רב גדלי' בן רב שמעון מאקס זצ"ל
HASHK AFAH SPONSOR TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SPONSOR Y E A R LY S P O N S O R דקות בעיון כל יום15 הוא היה רגיל לומר צריך כל אדם ללמוד לכה"פ
Are you a
HASHKAFA FROM HG"R GERSHON RIBNER SHLITA
Guilt-Riddled Over Cardinal Sins
Lamdan?
With Everlasting Consequences
QUESTION
?
I’m a yungerman learning in Beis Medrash Govoha for ten years. In my late teenage
years, two other friends and I went off the derech, and I’m embarrassed to tell you THIS WEEK'S LIVE SHAILA
how far that went. Baruch Hashem, I came back, and one of the friends did as well. פרשת האז ינו תשפ"ו לפ"ק
The second friend is still secular and is currently establishing a family with a
non-Jewish woman. I have no peace in my life knowing I had been the one to
introduce him to that woman as a teenager. Does the Rosh Yeshiva have any ideas PA R S H A H S P O N S O R לע"נ רבקה בלימה בת אברהם
or suggestions as to what I can do in this situation?
ANSWER
This is serious business. Some people may look leniently at the fact that you were מחלל שבת Harav Beinish Grossman Shlit"a, R’M in the Orchas Chaim
in the past as something that’s in the past, without lasting effects, yet look at this situation,
a friend marrying a non-Jew, as everlasting damage. I don’t see it that way. You were מחלל
Chabura, Asks This Week's Shailah B'Inyan Muktzah!
שבת, trampling on Hashem’s honor. Of course, it has a lasting effect. However, we strongly A Kli Shemelachto L’Issur may be moved on Shabbos for two purposes:
believe in the power of teshuva, that it completely separates you from the everlasting action
done. So why are you more worried about introducing your friend to this non-Jew than about
L’tzorech Gufo, to use the item itself for a permitted function, or L’tzorech
any of the other עבירותyou did? Do you not believe in teshuva? Mekomo, to use the place where the item is resting. Therefore, one may
When the Mesillas Yesharim brings down the concept of עקירת הרצון כעקירת המעשה, move a hammer to crack open a nut, or move it off a bed when he needs the
retracting your want and wish to do the עבירהequals retracting the actual sin, the mashal bed. Tosfos in Beitzah says that once the Kli was picked up B’heter, one is
given is that of a man who murders his friend. Can teshuva undo the action and bring him not required to drop it immediately when the permitted use is finished. He
back to life? No, but uprooting the desire to do such a terrible thing removes your connection
to the action itself as well, b’chessed Hashem, as though someone else did it.
may continue holding it and put it down in a convenient place. The simple
We need to believe in the power of teshuva. If you don’t believe in it, it doesn’t work, and you understanding is that once Chazal permitted the Tiltul, they did not require
won’t have a kaparah. If someone is tovell in a mikvah, would you have to work on your a person to drop the object the moment the original need ended. The
emunah to believe he came out purer? You might not have a depth of understanding of how difficulty is that the Magen Avraham extends this Heter even to a case
the mikvah waters purified him, yet you understand this is a חלותthat the Torah empowers where the item was picked up mistakenly, without any Tzorech Gufo or
the mikvah to accomplish. Why can you believe that, yet not teshuva?
Tzorech Mekomo. If so, the original Tiltul was not done B’heter at all. Why,
I don’t believe this is a bigger aveira than anything else you did back then. It looks to me like
either you never did teshuva on anything, or you don’t really understand or believe in the כח then, may he continue carrying it until he reaches a place where he wants to
התשובה. Why are you only bringing up this one thing you did? Everything else you did is put it down? Shouldn’t the Heter of Tosfos apply only when the original act
punishable with סקילה. of picking up the Kli was permitted?
R’ Moshe Shapiro zt”l believed that everything that happens is the will of Hashem, and the
מגן אברהם סימן ש"ח סעיף קטן ז ד"ה אבל כופה עליה כלי:תוספות ביצה דף ג
only thing up to us is free will. You chose to do this action. Once you do teshuva, you basically
undo the choice of your bechira. You are saying, “I am a different person now, and should
that situation come up again, I would choose differently.” And once you take your bechira out
of the equation, your action and its consequence are purely Hashem’s will, without any input
from you.
If you did true teshuva, you are no longer connected to any past aveiros, including this. You
should for sure daven that the relationship should disintegrate. But the real work would be
to ask yourself if you truly did teshuva or not. If you did teshuva, there’s no reason this
should be causing you so much agmas nefesh. If you didn’t, I don’t see why this issue is
weighing on you more than any other sins.
In addition to the עקירת הרצון, you can also do ‘’תשובת המשקל, and in place of this bad
shidduch, begin redting good shidduchim to people. Chavra D'Hilchisa Raffle!
Submit your answer to 646-598-4703 for an entry to win a Sefer Chazon Ish gifted
Zechus Harabbim! by the Chazon Ish Zt"l himself to Yeshivas Beis Yosef-Novardok in Tzfas!"
Sponsor this week’s Lamdanim Inc newsletter or HaRav Gershon Ribner’s Hashkafa and connect to thousands of Lomdei
Torah. Dedicate L’iluy Nishmas, L’kovod a Simcha, or to share in the Zechus of the tremendous Rischa d’Oraisa.
Reserve your sponsorship today! (646) 598-4703
FOR COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS ON THE HASHKAFA MIMEON KODESH, TEXT 848-216-6466
TO HEAR THE SHAILA EXPLAINED CALL 917.810.2517
WANT TO BE MEHANEH YOUR OILAM WITH THIS NEWSLETTER? TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SUBSCRIBE TEXT "START" TO 917.810.2517 | HAVE A MEHALECH? SUBMIT IT TO "646-598-4703" BEFORE SUNDAY 1:30 P. M. EST
SEFER SPONSOR SEFER SHEMOS IS SPONSORED ר' חיים צבי בן ר' משה
Recent week's question & answer
HaRav Yeshaya Wenger Shlita, Rosh Chabura in BMG,
Asks this Week’s Shailah B’Inyan Mitzvas Shofar!
QUESTION
The Gemara in Rosh Hashanah דף כ״ח ע״בsays that Rav Zeira told his attendant,
Ichavein U’teka Li, have in mind when you blow the Shofar for me. Rashi explains
that Rav Zeira was telling the Ba’al Tekiah to have in mind to blow on his behalf
and be Motzi him in the Mitzvah. The difficulty is that the Mitzvah of Shofar
seems to be the hearing of the sound, not the act of blowing. This is also reflected
in the Berachah, which is Lishmoa Kol Shofar, to hear the sound of the Shofar. If
so, why did Rav Zeira need the Ba’al Tekiah to have specific Kavanah to be Motzi
him? Even if Mitzvos Tzrichos Kavanah, it should be enough for Rav Zeira himself,
the listener, to have Kavanah to be Yotzei when he hears the Kol Shofar. Why is
the Kavanah of the Ba’al Tekiah necessary if the Mitzvah is fulfilled through
Shmias Kol Shofar?
ANSWER
Reb Chaim gives two Terutzim. The first is that although the Berachah is Lishmoa
Kol Shofar, the Ma’aseh Tekiah is also part of the Ma’aseh Mitzvah. Therefore, the
Ba’al Tekiah is not merely producing a sound for the listener to hear. He is being
Motzi the Shomei’a with the act of Tekiah itself, while the Shomei’a fulfills the
Mitzvah through hearing that Kol Shofar. This explains why Rav Zeira needed the
Ba’al Tekiah to have Kavanah to be Motzi him. It also fits with the Mishnah that if
a Cheresh, Shoteh V’katan blew the Shofar, one is not Yotzei, since the Tekiah
must be a valid Ma’aseh Mitzvah. However, this approach is difficult L’halacha.
The Shulchan Aruch in Orach Chaim סימן תקפ״ט סעיף ח׳says that if a man already
fulfilled his Mitzvas Shofar and then blows for women, the women make the
Berachah themselves. Since women are not fully obligated in Shofar, the man
cannot make the Berachah for them through Arvus. But if the Ma’aseh Tekiah
itself is part of the Mitzvah, how can someone who already fulfilled his own
Mitzvah provide that Ma’aseh Tekiah for women who are not included in the same
level of Chiyuv? Therefore, Reb Chaim offers a second Mahalach. The Mitzvah may
indeed be only Shmias Kol Shofar, and the Ba’al Tekiah is not being Motzi the
listener in a separate Chelek of the Mitzvah. Rather, in order for the listener’s
hearing to be considered hearing a valid Kol Shofar Shel Mitzvah, the sound must
come from a Tekiah blown L’shem Mitzvah. If the Ba’al Tekiah has no Kavanah for
the listener, then with respect to that listener the Tekiah is like Misasek, and he
has not heard a proper Tekias Shofar. That is why Rav Zeira told the Ba’al Tekiah,
Ichavein U’teka Li. The Kavanah of the Ba’al Tekiah is needed not because he
fulfills the listener’s Mitzvah through the act of blowing, but because his Kavanah
gives the listener a valid Kol Shofar to hear.
:חי' הגר"ח על הש"ס )מהדו' מישור( ר"ה כ"ח []רא"ש שם פ"ג סי'י"א .רש"י שם כ"ט :גמרא ר"ה סוף כ"ח
Mussar
Moment
THE
"The promise of Hashem to respond to the סדרof the י"ג מדותdoes not refer to merely reciting
them, but to performing them and following in Hashem's ways as well."
- Alshich (כ, במדבר י"ד,)תורת משה
