Kollel Lihoraah - English — Ha'azini - Shabbos Tshuva (2026-09-14)

Parshas Haazinu
5787
Ask the Rav
Wearing the Clothing of Non-Jews- The Prohibition of “You Shall Not Fol- In Igros Moshe (Y.D. I:81), Rav Moshe Feinstein further clarifies the parame-
low Their Ways” ters of the prohibition regarding clothing. He was asked about people from Po-
land who had been accustomed to wearing clothing that differed from the cloth-
Q: Does one transgress the prohibition of You Shall not follow in the ways of ing worn by non-Jews in Poland. After coming to America, however, they found
the goyim, by wearing clothing that is the style of the goyim? that there was no distinction between the clothing worn by Jews and non-Jews.
Were they required to continue wearing their former clothing because of Chukos
A: We find three pesukim in the Torah that relate to the prohibition of HaAkum? He writes that there is no prohibition of wearing the clothing of non-
“U’vchukoseihem lo seileichu”—“You shall not follow their ways”—yet the Jews in such a case, because virtually all Jews wear these garments. If so, who
Monei HaMitzvos count them as only one prohibition. The Rambam brings this says that these should be considered “the clothing of non-Jews”? Why not say
in Sefer HaMitzvos (Lo Sa'aseh 30) and in Hilchos A vodah Zarah (11:1), where that from the outset they were never designated exclusively for non-Jews, but
he writes: “We may not follow the practices of the non-Jews or imitate them, were also established as clothing for Jews? According to this, even according to
neither in clothing nor in hairstyles and the like, as it says, ‘You shall not follow the Vilna Gaon's approach, it would be permitted to wear such clothing, since it
the practices of the nation’... and it says, ‘You shall not follow their ways,’ and is not considered “the clothing of non-Jews.”
it says, ‘Beware lest you be ensnared after them.’ All of these are referring to It emerges that there are virtually no commonly worn garments today about
one matter: He warns us not to imitate them. Rather, a Jew must be distinct from which there should be a concern of violating “U’vchukoseihem lo seileichu.”
them and recognizable by his clothing and his other actions, just as he is distinct Today, most contemporary poskim have followed the reasoning of Igros Moshe
from them in his knowledge and outlook.
and permit wearing clothing that is also worn by non-Jews.
The Sefer HaChinuch (Mitzvah 262) explains that the reason for this prohibition
is because they have strayed from following Hashem and worship idolatry.
Hatzalah Volunteers Who Respond to a Call in the Middle of Shemoneh Esrei
In the Shu”t Maharik (Shoresh 88), he was asked about a particular garment
called a kapa, which doctors were accustomed to wearing, and whether a Jewish Q: I was asked by Hatzalah members who responded to a call in the middle of
doctor was prohibited from wearing it because of the prohibition against imitat-
Shemoneh Esrei and were away for approximately an hour, but remember exact-
ing their clothing. His ruling was codified by the Rema (Y.D. 178:1), who added ly where they were holding in their tefillah: Must they begin Shemoneh Esrei
to the Shulchan Aruch's ruling that one may not wear clothing that is unique to
again from the beginning, or may they continue from the brachah where they
them. The Rema writes that this prohibition applies only to something that non- stopped? They also asked about other interruptions that occur in the middle of
Jews adopted for purposes of immodesty—for example, wearing red garments, Pesukei D'Zimrah or Birchos Krias Shema.
which were the clothing of noblemen and similar forms of immodest dress—or
to something that they adopted as a custom or practice without any reason, in A: It is clear from the words of the Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 104) that if a Hatzalah
which case there is concern that it falls under Darchei HaEmori and contains a member interrupted his Shemoneh Esrei, if he did not remain silent for enough
vestige of the idolatry of their ancestors. However, something that they adopted time to recite the entire Shemoneh Esrei, he returns to the beginning of the bra-
for a practical benefit—for example, where it is customary that every expert chah in which he interrupted. In the first three and final three brachos, he returns
doctor wears a distinctive garment that identifies him as a professional doctor— to the beginning of that section. However, if the interruption lasted long enough
is permitted. Likewise, something worn for reasons of honor or another legiti- to recite the entire Shemoneh Esrei, he must return to the beginning of She-
mate purpose is permitted. moneh Esrei. The halachah regarding an interruption during Shemoneh Esrei is
The Vilna Gaon (Y.D. 178:7), however, challenges the Maharik: Why should more stringent, since there are those who rule that in every case one must return
this fall under the prohibition of “U’vchukoseihem lo seileichu” in the first to the beginning. This is also evident from the Mishnah Berurah (104:16). The
place? It is not a strange practice without a reason, nor does it violate the bound- reason is that any interruption during Shemoneh Esrei is considered a significant
aries of modesty. Thus, according to the Maharik, who maintains that the prohi- interruption. Regarding someone who left in the middle of Pesukei D'Zimrah, he
bition applies only when one of these two concerns exists, there should be no returns to the place where he stopped. See also the Mishnah Berurah (51:7), who
prohibition here. writes that if one interrupted in the middle, when he resumes he should recite
The Vilna Gaon therefore disagrees with the Maharik in halachah. He maintains the pesukim that precede V ayevarech David. He should then say:“Baruch Ha-
that practices adopted for the sake of idolatry are prohibited even if they are shem le'olam amen v'amen, Baruch Hashem miTzion shochein Yerushalayim,
already mentioned in the Torah, while other practices that they have adopted Baruch Hashem Elokim Elokei Yisrael oseh niflaos levado, u'varuch shem kevo-
remain included in Chukos HaA kum, even if there is a reason for their practice, do l'olam v'yimalei kevodo es kol ha'aretz amen v'amen.” Through this, it is
unless the practice is already explicitly mentioned in the Torah. considered as though he recited a brachah both before and after Pesukei D'Zim-
The Tiferes Y israel in Sanhedrin (7:3, Boaz, os 1) resolves the Vilna Gaon's rah.
question on the Maharik by explaining that since non-Jews punish murderers in It is important to point out to Hatzalah members that if they leave in the middle
this manner because they believe that their idolatry commanded them to do so, it of davening after Baruch She'amar, they may not engage in permitted conversa-
is prohibited for us to perform a mitzvah of burning in the same manner that tion that is unrelated to the Hatzalah operation, since they have already reached
they do. This constitutes a practice associated with idolatry. See also Shu”t Baruch She'amar, after which one may not interrupt with speech.
Maharam Shik (Y.D. 165) for an explanation of the Maharik's approach.
Catching a Mosquito or Bee with a Cup on it is effectively considered as though it is already on his body, and therefore
Shabbos it should be permitted to trap it, although it remains forbidden to kill it, as
explained in the Mishnah Berurah (316:38). This leniency is likewise en-
Q: I was asked a common question regarding Shabbos dorsed in the sefer Meir Nesivos (316).
Kodesh. A person notices that a mosquito has entered his
home. There is no concern of an allergy or anything similar; the Practical Corner:
only concern is discomfort to the body and disturbance of one's By Rabbi Nesanel Odzer from the Rabbanim of Beis
peace of mind. Is there room to be lenient and cover the mosquito Horaah KLY
with a cup in order to trap it until after Shabbos?
Can I Eat Dunkin Donuts During Aseres Yimei Teshuvah?
A: It appears that this question should be divided into several different
cases. First of all, if there is a concern of an allergy or something similar Q: Can I eat Dunkin Donuts, with a reliable hechsher of course, during
that could potentially lead to pikuach nefesh, then it is certainly permissi- Aseres Yimei Teshuvah?
ble to trap the insect, and it is also permissible to kill it in such a situation.
This is explained in the Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 316:10). See also Shemiras A: Before discussing the question, two clarifications are important. F irst,
Shabbos K'hilchasa (25:1). A mosquito, fly, or similar insect that is flying this discussion is not intended to advocate relying on pas palter. Rather, we
around the house and disturbing one's peace of mind may not be trapped on are discussing the halachah for one who generally follows the accepted
Shabbos. The reason is that the Sages did not permit a rabbinic prohibition lenient opinions regarding pas palter during the year. Second, we are not
of trapping when one's intention is merely to remove the creature from addressing the kashrus status of any particular Dunkin’ location or product.
himself, except in a case where there is bodily discomfort because the crea- The discussion assumes that the particular donut has a reliable hechsher
ture will bite him. This is explained by the Mishnah Berurah (316:37) re- and focuses only on the question of Pas Yisrael. The Shulchan Aruch (O.C.
garding a flea: because of the discomfort caused by its bite, the Sages did 603:1) writes that even one who is not careful about pas akum during the
not impose the rabbinic prohibition of trapping. However, when there is year should be careful during Aseres Yimei Teshuvah. Thus, even one who
only tza'ar hanefesh—mental distress—and not bodily discomfort, they did ordinarily relies on the heter of pas palter should preferably eat only Pas
not permit trapping, even though the trapping involved here is only rabbin- Yisrael during these days. But does this apply to a donut? The Shulchan
ic, since these creatures are not generally trapped for use. Aruch (Y.D. 112:2) permits commercially baked pas palter when Pas Yisra-
Similarly, regarding a cockroach or other insects that enter a home, even el is unavailable, while the Rema brings the more lenient opinion permit-
when they cause panic or anxiety among the members of the household, ting it even where Pas Yisrael is available. The Shach (ibid. s.k. 9) writes
their trapping was not permitted. Only where there is bodily discomfort, that although the accepted practice follows this leniency, it is preferable to
such as with a flea that bites when it is on one's body, does the Shulchan be machmir where Pas Yisrael is available, unless the pas palter is of signif-
Aruch permit trapping it. Where there is no bodily discomfort, trapping icantly better quality.
is not permitted, and it is likewise forbidden to kill the insect for this The question, then, is whether a deep-fried donut is halachically considered
reason, as explained in the Biur Halachah (s.v. Mutar). The only case in bread at all. This depends on a major machlokes Rishonim regarding thick
which killing was permitted is a louse, since there is both bodily dis- dough that is subsequently cooked or fried. Rabbeinu Tam, together with
comfort and ma'us—disgust—when it is generated by human sweat. many other Rishonim, maintains that thick dough (blilah avah) retains the
In such a case, Chazal permitted killing it. A cockroach and other status of bread even when it is later cooked or fried (Tosafos, Berachos 37b,
insects, however, may not be killed for this reason. Similarly, in such s.v. Lechem ha’asui l’kutach; Tosafos, Pesachim 37b, s.v. d’kulei alma).
a case, even a bee flying around the house may not be trapped mere- Rabbeinu Shimshon, together with many other Rishonim, disagrees and
ly because there is a concern that it may sting. Regarding a flea, the maintains that when dough was made from the outset with the intention that
halachic permission to trap it applies only when it is on one's body it be cooked or fried, it does not receive the halachic status of bread. The
or inside one's clothing, not when it is simply flying around the Tur discusses this broad machlokes both in Hilchos Challah (Y.D. 329) and
house. in Hilchos Brachos (O.C. 168).
Nevertheless, in the case under discussion, wher e a mosquito Regarding challah, the Shulchan Aruch (Y.D. 329:3) rules that such dough
is present in the house on Friday night and the person knows is exempt. The Shach (ibid. s.k. 4), however, writes that because many
that one of his children will be bitten—and certainly in a case Rishonim disagree, it is proper to separate challah without a brachah.
where it appears almost certain that someone in the house We find the same basic issue regarding brachos. The Shulchan Aruch (O.C.
will be bitten, causing them genuine discomfort based on 168:13) brings both opinions regarding thick dough that was cooked or
past experience—it would seem that there is room to permit fried. According to one opinion its brachah is Mezonos, while according to
trapping it. The Shulchan Aruch (316:9) rules that if a flea the other it remains Hamotzi. The accepted practice is to be lenient and
is on one's flesh and biting him, it is permissible to trap it, recite Mezonos, although the Shulchan Aruch writes that a yerei Shamayim
although it is forbidden to kill it. The poskim, as brought should satisfy both opinions by eating it only after making Hamotzi on
in the Mishnah Berurah there, explain that because of the ordinary bread. Accordingly, although this is a significant machlokes
discomfort caused by the bite, Chazal did not impose Rishonim, me'ikar hadin fried dough is not treated as bread.
the rabbinic prohibition of trapping, since the creature It would therefore seem that one who relies on pas palter during the year
is not generally trapped for use. Therefore, one may may rely on this accepted lenient ruling regarding fried dough during
trap it and dispose of it. The Taz (316:8) permits trap- Aseres Yimei Teshuvah as well. Being that avoiding pas palter during these
ping the flea even when it is inside one's garment, days is itself an added chumrah, while a deep-fried donut me'ikar hadin is
since it is likely to come to bite him. From this, we not considered bread, there is a basis to eat such a donut even if it is not Pas
can derive the halachah in our case: if a person Yisrael. Indeed, Rav Avigdor Nebenzahl ruled to us that one who is meikel
knows that when there is a mosquito in his house at regarding pas palter throughout the year may also be meikel regarding such
night, one of his children will wake up in the morn- donuts during Aseres Yimei Teshuvah.
ing having been bitten, this is comparable to a flea One final point: a dairy donut may present a separate question regarding
that is on one's flesh, for which trapping is permit- cholov akum. That is an entirely separate halachic discussion and is beyond
ted. The difference is that in the case of a flea, it is the scope of this Dvar Torah. The above addresses only Pas Yisrael and
only when it is on one's body or inside his clothing assumes that the particular product bears a reliable hechsher and meets all
that it is likely to bite him. Regarding a mosquito, other applicable kashrus requirements.
however, even when it is flying around the house,
Take a part in spreading the light!
Email info@kollellihoraah.org for sponsorship opportunities.
To receive this weekly publication via email, Click here or email info@kollellihoraah.org.
We are having our Annual Slichos Campaign!
Please help us reach our goal of building Klal Yisroel through
Limud Hatorah.
Donate here: https://causematch.com/kl2026
