Einey Menachem — Ha'azini - Shabbos Tshuva (2026-09-14)

בס"ד
עיני מנחם
לע"נ הרב מנחם מנדל בן הרב אלטר שמואל אהרן זצ"ל
האזינו תשפ"ז- שבת שובה
דברי תורהMy Zeidy used to say:
1. The Lelover Rebbe, ר' משה מרדכי זי"ע, explained the following chazal: We find a difference
between Moshe Rabbeinu and Yeshaya Hanavi. Moshe said האזינו השמים ותשמע הארץ-
whereas Yeshaya said שמעו שמים והאזיני ארץ. Why the flip? The Sifri answers that האזינו
indicates that the listener is close by while שמיעהindicates listening from a distance.
Therefore, Moshe Rabbeinu who was near the שמיםsaid האזינו השמיםand he was far from
the earth so he said ותשמע הארץ, whereas Yeshaya was close to the ארץand far from the
שמים.
Explained the Rebbe, the Sifri does not mean to say that Yeshaya was distant from the שמים
in his abilities and his understanding and stature. Rather, the medrash means that Yeshaya
lived on the ground whereas Moshe lived in the heavens, therefore matters of heaven were
closer to him.
2. The עבודת ישראלexplains the first words of the haftora in the following way: – שובה ישראל
return Yidden ' – עד הuntil the Creator will be אלוקיך- your G-d.
3. The Kotzker Rebbe said a beautiful explanation to a medrash on the posuk in הושע- שובה
ישראל עד ה' אלוקיך כי כשלת בעונך. The medrash says in Breishis: Hashem said [to Reuvain]
“No one has ever sinned לפני- before me and did teshuva, and you Reuvain have done
teshuva, I promise you that your descendent Hoshea will open with "שובה ישראל – תשובה
"עד ה' אלוקיך. Now this is very difficult, didn’t Adom and Kayin also sin and do teshuva?
Exlpains the Rebbe that in the case of Reuvain we find something new i.e. that even an עבירה
that was done לשם שמיםa person should do teshuva for it. Adom and Kayin knew that they
were doing something wrong as they sinned therefore it isn’t a great חידושthat they did
teshuva. Reuvain on the other hand was claiming the embarrassment of his mother
therefore it is a חידושthat he did teshuva.
That then is the meaning of the posuk: כי כשלת בענךthat you have stumbled in your sinning,
meaning, even though you stumbled and at the time you thought that you were doing the
right thing [still you should do teshuva]. Have a wonderful Shabbos!
בס"ד
Parsha Gems a small parsha gem written by lamed shin mem. ו – שבת שובהðפרשת האזי
Where will my soul go?
בע"הin a week’s time we will be leining קהלת. In perek 'ג husband or by the wife. Therefore I show them both honor
posuk כ"אwe find the following: מי יודע רוח בני האדם העלה היא that whomever has it should look after it well.”
– למעלה ורוח הבהמה הירדת היא למטה לארץWho perceives that the
spirit of man is the one that ascends on high, while the spirit The medrash says that Moshe Rabbeinu was asked, “Why are
of the beast is the one that descends down into the earth. you talking to both שמיםand ”?ארץMoshe Rabbeinu answers
Man will be judged for his actions while animals aren’t held based on the previous mashal, “I am going to die and I do not
accountable for the way they act, therefore it is incumbent know where my soul is headed if to heaven if to earth.
upon man to act as though he is aware of this and guard his Therefore I speak to both of them (in order to show both of
actions that they should be in line with his G-d given qualities, them honor) so that wherever my soul ends up it will be
i.e. to use his intellect to follow Hashem and not to simply taken care of. As a מקורfor this doubt the medrash brings our
give in and follow his base instincts. Unfortunately, not posuk in קהלת. “Who knows where his spirit is headed? Is it
everyone is aware of the difference between man and beast; headed to the heaveans like the רוחof בני אדםor to the earth
indeed Koheles wonders who is actually cognizant of this. like the רוחof the ”?בהמהIn response Hashem tells Moshe
This is the simple explanation of this posuk. Rabbeinu “No creator will have control over your soul, rather
it will be placed under my throne (such as what Avigayil told
Thet medrash raba on parshas האזינו, however, gives a Dovid ”)והיתה נפש אדני צרורה בצרור החיים את ה' אלקיך.
different understanding. The medrash is explaining (one
)מהלךas to why Moshe chose to speak to both the heaven We see in this medrash that a person’s soul can be placed in
and the earth [... ותשמע הארץ... ]האזינו השמים. The medrash the heavens if he achieves acting like a בן אדם. If he follows his
gives a mashal of a man who made a deposit with his friend basic desires he will go down like an animal. And then for the
and then the man died. The son of the deceased now comes uniquie individual like Moshe Rabbeinu, who achieved such a
to both the husband and the wife (the ones that his father closeness to Hashem his נפשis placed under the כסא הכבוד.
had deposited by) and shows each of them honor. His friends Even though Moshe Rabbeinu was certainly cognizant of his
asked him, “Why are you showing both of them honor?” He great status he was still in doubt because perhaps according
replied, “I don’t know where my inheritance lies, by the to his greatness his acheivement was so lacking. Hashem
though reassured him that indeed his plan is great!”
דברי הרבa short excerpt from the shuirim of Rav Zimmerman שליט"אon the Halachos of Bishul
(Siman Shin Yud Ches).
סעיף י"חcont. from prev. weeks [ האלפס והקדרה שהעבירן מרותחין מעל גבי האור- You took a pot which is hot, and you took it off the fire, אם לא
נתבשל כל צרכו- if it is not fully cooked, אין מוציאין בכף מהם- if it is not fully cooked, you have cholent that is not fully cooked and you take the cholent off the fire
Friday night and it is not fully cooked yet אין מוציאין בכף מהןhe shouldn’t take it out with a spoon, he should pour it out, he shouldn’t take it out with a spoon
because: שנמצא מגיס ואיכא משום מבשל- because when you take it out with a spoon so it is like you are stirring the pot; whenever you take something out of a pot it
just creates a shift in the pot and it is considered like מבשל. Now the לשוןof the Mechaber is: ואיכא משום מבשל. So the Mishna Berura explains that if you do actual
הגסה, that is an issur d’oraysa. If you stir a pot which is not fully cooked that is an issur d’oraysa, if you just take with a כףout of the pot which is not fully cooked
that is a d’rabonon, as it says in the שער הציון ס"ק קל"ז. So the Mechaber is saying that if it is not fully cooked, if you stir it you are over a d’oraysa, if you take it out
with a spoon you are over a d’rabonon. ואם נשבשל כל צרכו- but if it is fully cooked, מותר- then it is mutar. The Mechaber’s shita is, if something is cooked and it is
בס"ד
hot so it is אין בישול אחר בישולthere is nothing you can do wrong with a fully cooked pot. אבל צמר ליורה- but wool which is in a pot which is being dyed, אף על פי
– שקלט העיןeven though the dye was caught already, אסור להגיס בו- to stir it, because you going to make the dye go in deeper and that is a melocho of צובע. על כל
פניםthe Mechaber’s shita is rather simple, that something that is מתבשל כל צרכוthere is no חששof ;בישולsomething which is לא נתשבל כל צרכוyou could do בישול
on it. Therefore, הגסהis being מקרב בשולוand that is an isur d’oraysa, taking it out with a כףwhich is inadvertent מקרב בשולוthat is an אסור דרבנן. That is the
Mechaber’s shita. Comes along the Rema and says " "ולכתחילה יש לזהר- lechatchila you should be careful אף בכל ענין. Now the Rema goes to a total other extreme;
that you should be careful to not take out הוצאה בכףfrom a pot even when it is not on the fire. In other words you should always pour out pots. This is what the
Rema says.This is what the Rema says. So, the Mishna Berura in ס"ק קיזsays that even if it is אינה על האש- the Rema meant even if it is off the fire. Comes along the
Mishna Berura and says: ועין באחרונים דלא נהיגין להחמיר בזה. אלא יהפך הקדרה לקערה ולא יוציא בכף- we don’t keep the minhag of the Rema, דבאמת העיקר כמו
דמבושל כל צרכו אפילו להגיס מותר, שכתבנו מתחילה- really the Mechaber is right, that even if you would stir a מבושל כל צרכוit would be permissible, because אין בישול
אחר בישול. והרוצה להחמיר יחמיר בהגסה ממש... וכמבואר לקמן סימן שכ"א- so if you want to be machmir you should be machmir in הגסהitself. That is the shita of the
כל בוwho says that הגסהthat is מבושל כל צרכוis ossur; you want to be machmir like the כל בו, do so. אבל להוציא בכף אין להחמיר כלל בנתבשל כל צרכו ואינה על האש-
but don’t be machmir on the d’rabonon. However, when he says don’t be machmir on the d’rabonon he is saying don’t be machmir on the d’rabonon when it is אינו
על האשit is mashma when it is על האשyou should be machmir on the d’rabonon, and as a matter of fact, that is what he says in the Mishna Berura at the end of the
Mishna Berura קי"ג: אבל באליה רבה מסיק דיש לאסר בזה, כן משמע בבית יוסף. אפילו עומד על גבי האור מותר להוציא בכף,ובנתבשל כל צרכו. So we come out as follows:
According to the Mechaber there is only one issue, is it מבושל כל צרכוor not; if it is מבושל כל צרכוyou can do whatever you want, if it is אינו מבושל כל צרכוthen הגסה
is a d’oroysa, הוצאה בכףis a d’rabonon. According to the Rema everything is ossur. According to the Mishna Berura where he says that the minhag is that הגסהis
ossur, always ossur. You should not do הגסהthat is possibly an issur d’oraysa according to the כל בו, even if it is מבושל כל צרכו. And to take it out of a pot with a
spoon you shouldn’t do it while it is על גבי האש.]
Now, what do you do with a pot for the whole yeshiva? What does the Rema want you to do? What even the Mishna
Berura wants you to do? Now, again, what the Mishna Berura would want you to do maybe, is, take it off the fire.
There is a possibility at least what he want you to do, take it off the fire. The problem is, then the laws of חזרהare going
to be very complicated (עודה בידה, if you are going to hold the whole pot, it is going to be very difficult). What the Rema
wants you do is even a bigger question. What are you supposed to do; how are you going to get the cholent out of the
pot? You should just turn it upside down? What are you supposed to do?
A Story: גזירה עבידא דבטלא
It was the fall of 1938 and the tension of hostility between Germany and Poland was on the rise and Germany expelled
all Jews with Polish citizenship from its borders. As a retaliation the Polish government ordered all Yeshiva students who
were German to leave Poland. Rav Mordechai Schwab was a German citizen and learning at the time in the new kollel in
Kamenitz in northern Poland, so he went to his Rebbe, Rav Boruch Ber, to ask him what to do. Rav Boruch Ber
instructed him to travel to Warsaw 240 km away at once. “You must go and see the prime minister,” he insisted, “and
ask him to be מבטלthe גזירה.” With complete faith in his Rebbe’s near impossible request, he travelled to Warsaw and
went to the headquarters of Agudas Yisroel where he met Aguda’s leader and member of the Polish parliment, Rav Itche
Meir Levine. “It so ‘happens’ that I am on my way to meet with the Prime Minister and I will add this matter to the long
list of requests that I have.” Rav Mordechai went to the beis hamedrash and sat down to learn. When Rav Yitzchok Meir
returned, he related that the Prime Minister had told him, “I can’t help you with any of your petitions, however, your
last request that the German yeshiva students be allowed to remain in Poland, that I can take care of.”
A similar incident happened right before the invasion itself. Rav Mordechai was notified by the police to report to them
with his passport and that he had to leave within 24 hours. Rav Mordechai went to the Rosh Yeshiva for guidance. Rav
Baruch Ber, after thinking for a minute, banged with his fist on the table declaring, " – גזירה עבידא דבטלאthis decree will be
anulled!” Indeed, by four o’clock in the afternoon there were no policemen to be seen in the streets of Kamenitz. They
had gone into hiding afraid of the invasion.
Have an uplifting Shabbos!
בס"ד בס"ד
Questions on the Parsha ( )האזינוarranged according to the aleph bais (for leil Shabbos). Questions on the Parsha ( )האזינוarranged according to the aleph bais (for yom Shabbos).
Idols that were not feared by: אבתיכם When Hashem got angry at his children he said I will see what will be their: אחריתם
How does the posuk call Eretz Yisroel? במותי ארץ Who angered Hashem? בניו ובנותיו
Why? Because it is: גבוהה מכל הארצות Hashem said as a punishment He will anger the Yidden with a: גוי נפל
How does the posuk say that even dry figs ooze? דבש מסלע How does Hashem call that generation? דור תהפחת
The idols the Yidden worshipped weren’t worshipped by: האמות With what did Bnei Yisroel anger Hashem? הבליהם
How does the posuk say that the Yidden got rich? וישמן What happened when Hashem saw what his children were doing? וינאץ
The Yidden angered Hashem with [idols]: זרים Something Hashem sends to punish the Yidden: The poison of ______: זוחלי עפר
A word that means the strength of the rock: חלמיש What will Hashem send at the Yidden that will finish? חצי
דם ענבrefers to wine with a choshuve: טעם The Targum of the word ( נבלas in )גוי נבל: טפשא
Another name for ישראל: ישרון The fire of Hashem will consume the land and its: יבול
An expression that describes how big the wheat was: כ ליות חטה Hashem would ח"וlet the nations destroy if not for the ____ of the enemy: כעס
They shechted: לשדים How does the posuk say that the demons will fight against them? לחומי רשף
New Idols that came: מקרב How does the posuk say bloating caused by hunger: מזי רעב
A word that means disgrace and disparage: ניבול What is the Targum of the answer to 'נפיחי כפן ?'מ
A word that means rock: סלע What is the Targum of the answer to 'סופיהן ?'א
“And you became thick”: עבית Klal Yisroel is called a nation that lost its: עצות
What is the Targum of פרקיה ?ישועה What will Hashem hide from the Yidden? פני
A word that means rock: צור How does the posuk say ‘their enemies’? צרימו
When Yidden worship ע"זit causes Hashem to have: קנאה How does the Torah say that they caused Hashem’s anger to burn? קנאוני
מחללךmeans that Hashem takes us out of a: רחם Lest the גויםsay our hands are: רמה
“And you got fat”: שמנת Even this Hashem will send to attack the Yidden: שן בהמות
How does the posuk say we ‘forgot’ Hashem: תשי Klal Yisroel don’t have: תבונה
Hatzlacha! Hatzlacha!
