BEER HAPARSHA ENGLISH — Sukkos (2026-09-21)

Succos
Table of Contents
Torah Wellsprings - Succos
Succah and the Four Minim Teach Us Temimus and Emunah...............................4
Succah Teaches us Bitachon...........................................................................................5
Erev Succos, and the Importance of Chessed .............................................................6
The Holiness of the Succah ..........................................................................................10
Salvations from the Succah ..........................................................................................12
Salvations from the Four Minim.................................................................................15
Taking Advantage of these Days ................................................................................16
ושמחת בחגך- Simchah ........................................................................................................17
Appropriate Joy ..............................................................................................................20
Luxuries............................................................................................................................21
Unity .................................................................................................................................22
The Mitzvos and their Meaning..................................................................................23
Hoshana Rabbah ............................................................................................................24
The Awesome Judgment ..............................................................................................27
Shemini Atzeres .............................................................................................................27
Simchas Torah ................................................................................................................29
The Importance of Shalom on Simchas Torah .........................................................30
After Simchas Torah ......................................................................................................31
Torah Wellsprings - Succos
Succah and the Four Minim Teach Us Yisrael in succahs when I took them out of
Temimus and Emunah the land of Mitzrayim." Didn’t they build
the succahs and dwell in them on their own?
The Rema m’Pano teaches as follows: The Why does it state ָאל
ֵ ׂר
ֹש ְב ִּתי ֶאת ְּבנֵי ִי ְש
ׁ ּ ִּכי ַבס,
ַ ֻּכוֹת הו
size of a small succah is 7 x 7 tefachim, which that Hashem placed us and had us sit in
is 49 square tefachim. The height of a succos?
minimum succah is ten tefachim high. This
means there are 490 square tefachim in the The answer is that even when a person
succah. 490 is the gematria of תמים. In (Devarim builds a hut and lives in it, he must know
18:13) it says ֹקי ָך ֶ ָּת ִמים ִּת ְהיֶה ִעם ה' ֱאל. The that Hashem did it. Everything is from
measurements of the succah hints to the Hashem. The idea to build a hut, and the
important concept of temimus – which is a strength and ability to do so, are all from
simple and pure belief in Hashem. The Imrei Hashem. This is the temimus we attain from
Noam (' )ג' דסוכות אות דadds that the mitzvah of living in the succah for seven days. We
lulav also hints to temimus because it states discover that everything is from Hashem;
(Vayikra 23:40) ַפֹת ּ אשוֹן ְּפ ִרי ֵעץ ָה ָדר ּכ
ׁ ו ְּל ַק ְח ֶּתם ָלכֶם ַּב ּיוֹם ָה ִר even what we do on our own is from
ַ ְּת ָמ ִרים ַו ֲענַף ֵעץ ָעבֹת ו ְַע ְר ֵבי נ, and Chazal say that
ָחל Hashem. ְל ַמ ַען י ְֵדע ּו דֹר ֵֹתיכֶם, this emunah we
ו ְּל ַק ְח ֶּתםis made of two words, ( לקיחה תמהsee must know, and we must teach it to the
Succah 34b and 37a), which can be translated as future generations. Everything that occurs is
"take temimus". These should be the traits from Hashem.
we seek to develop on this Yom Tov.
The Rashbam explains the reason we
It states (Vayikra 23:42-43), ...ָמים ִ ֻּכֹת ֵּת ְׁשב ּו ִׁש ְב ַעת י
ּ ַּבס must know, in all generations, that Hashem
ָאל ְּבהו ִֹצ ִיאי
ֵ ׂרֹש ְב ִּתי ֶאת ְּבנֵי ִי ְש
ׁ
ַ ֻּכוֹת הו
ּ ְל ַמ ַען י ְֵדע ּו דֹר ֵֹתיכֶם ִּכי ַבס placed us in succos. It is to learn to appreciate
או ָֹתם ֵמ ֶארֶץ ִמ ְצ ָריִם, "For seven days you shall live what we have now. He writes, "I placed Bnei
in succos…. in order that your ensuing Yisrael in succahs in the desert for forty
generations should know that I placed Bnei years, a place where there was no civilization
Yisrael in succos when I took them out of or portions of land. Thereby, you will praise
the land of Mitzrayim." Hashem for giving you a portion of land,
houses filled with goodness. You won't say
The Gemara (Succah 11b) states a machlokes: in your hearts that your strength and the
Reb Eliezer says that the succos we might of your hand granted you your
commemorate are the ענני כבוד, clouds of wealth." We understand from the Rashbam's
glory, which surrounded and protected Bnei holy words that sitting in the succah helps
Yisrael in the desert. These are called the us recognize the goodness we have today, in
"succos" that Hashem placed Bnei Yisrael in comparison to what was in the past. In the
when they were in the desert. Reb Akiva past, we lived in a desert, without civilization
says סוכות ממש עשו להם, Klal Yisrael made and a regular home. Today, we live so
actual succahs, like the ones we build on our differently. Furthermore, the succah reminds
porches and backyards for Succos. They us that everything we have today is from
were the temporary houses the Jewish people Hashem. Let us not think we attained it with
lived in during the forty years they were in the strength of our hands.
the desert, after leaving Mitzrayim.
Chizkuni (ibid.) writes, "The Yom Tov is in
According to Reb Akiva, we must the time when we gather in the crops. Lest
understand the pasuk ֻּכוֹת ּ ְל ַמ ַען י ְֵדע ּו דֹר ֵֹתיכֶם ִּכי ַבס people's hearts will become proud due to
ָאל
ֵ ׂר ַ הו, "in order that your ensuing
ֹש ְב ִּתי ֶאת ְּבנֵי ִי ְש
ׁ their homes that are filled with all types of
generations should know that I placed Bnei goodness, and they might say that they
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 5
earned all this wealth by the strength of the field was given to him with Hashem's
their hand. From sitting in the succah, they will. He should remember that the protection
will praise Hashem Who gave them a land for his life, and everything he has, is from
and houses filled with all good." Once again, Hashem yisbarach, and he shouldn't trust in
the lesson of succah is to know that the goods that he already has."
everything we have is from Hashem.
Sfas Emes (5645 )ד"ה מצותwrites, "The mitzvah
The Rambam (Morah Nevuchim vol.3, ch.43, quoted of succah is about bitachon in Hashem
in the Ksav Sofer )ד"ה ולקחתםexplains the reason for yisbarach, as Chazal say, צא מדירת קבע, 'Go out
the mitzvah of the four minim: "After the from your permanent home'. [Go out of the
harvest, and after gathering in the crops, mindset that you can rely on your wealth
every person will praise Hashem, and they and your home.] Don't trust in your wealth
won't say that they earned all of this due to or your property, only in Hashem."
their strong hand."
Chazal (Succah 9b) say, העושה סוכתו תחת האילן
כאילו עשאה בתוך הבית, "If a person builds his
Succah Teaches us Bitachon succah under a tree, it is [pasul, just] as if he
made the succah in his home." Some explain
It states (Vayikra 23:42) ָמים ּ ַּבס,
ִ ֻּכֹת ֵּת ְׁשב ּו ִׁש ְב ַעת י
that there is a similarity between a succah
"Live in succahs for seven days." The Gemara
built under a tree and a succah built in a
(Succah 2a) explains, "אמרה תורה כל שבעת הימים צא
home. A succah must be built under the
מדירת קבע ושב בדירת עראי, "For all seven days,
heavens, without interference, so a person will
leave your permanent home and dwell in a
know that he is dependent on Hashem,
temporary abode." Why do we leave the
alone, Who dwells in heaven. He shouldn’t
strong walls of our home and live in a succah
trust in any person, and he shouldn't seek
for seven days?
the protection of a home or a tree. He should
Menoras HaMaor ( )נר ג' כלל ד' ח"ו פ"אexplains, rely on Hashem alone.
"The mitzvah of succah tells us that a person Some explain (quoting Reb Shamshon Refael Hirsh
shouldn’t trust in his tall and sturdy home, zt'l) that this is the reason – מחוברwhen the
even if it is filled with a lot of good. He also schach that covers the succah is attached to
shouldn't trust in the aid of a human, even the ground – is pasul. The schach must be
if he is a powerful ruler of the land. One detached from the earth. Generally, people
should trust in the One Who spoke and the are very "attached" and dependent on their
world came into being… The mitzvah of assets and money. Therefore, we tell him,
succah teaches us this lesson. The mitzvah is "For seven days, leave your permanent
performed after we finish gathering the home, cleanse your mind from trusting in
crops of Eretz Yisrael, including the vineyard. others, and dwell for seven days in a
This is a time of [ בעיטהkicking, rebellion, temporary abode, under the צילא דמיהמנותא,
when a person tends to rebel against Hashem shade of emunah. Train yourself to be
because he feels he can manage on his own]. "detached" from this world, and to trust in
His treasures are filled with wealth; he has Hashem.
already returned from the field to his home
in the city; he has put pitch on his roof, and Chazal (Succah 28b) says, "When a child still
he has closed all openings of his home, so needs his mother, he is exempt from sitting
the rain of the winter won't come in. Neither in the succah." The Gemara asks, "Who is a
the wind nor any other elements will bother child who needs his mother? It is a child
him. Therefore, Hashem commanded that who, when he awakens from his sleep, calls
one should leave his sturdy home and dwell Mother, Mother. The Gemara explains that
in the succah. This will train him to trust in if he calls "Mother" once, it is natural. Older
Hashem yisbarach, and to place upon his heart children also do that when they wake up in
that all the good that he has received from the morning. But if he repeats "Mother!
6 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
Mother!" the child is very young and very explains that when the walls of the succah
dependent on his mother, and is therefore are so high, one will be sitting in the shade
patur from sitting in the succah. Some explain of the walls and won't receive shade from
( )אתה בחרתנו עמ' ק"בthat the purpose of the succah the schach. Therefore, the succah is pasul.
is to train us to trust in Hashem. If the child The Aruch l'Ner ( נדפס בסוף המסכתא,)סיום למסכת סוכה
calls "Mother! Mother!" he is trusting in explains the problem. The walls of the succah
human beings. He isn't prepared for the represent this world. The schach represents
mitzvah and lesson of succah: to trust in Hashem's hashgachah pratis, Who gives him
Hashem alone. all his needs at every moment. "Schach
higher than twenty amos is pasul because
Succos is called חג האסיף, "the Yom Tov of
then he sits in the shadow generated from
gathering." This is because Succos is
the walls and not from the schach. This
celebrated in the season when the new crops
represents a person who trusts in matters of
are brought into the home. The Sfas Emes
this world to help him and is pasul, and not
(5645 )ד"ה מצותteaches that just as the new crops
desired by Hashem." A person must trust in
are the source of food for the entire year, so,
Hashem Who watches over him with
too, brachos come down from heaven on
hashgachah pratis and gives him all his
Succos, which will be with us the entire year.
needs, at every moment. Knowing this is the
Succos teaches us to trust in Hashem, and
primary mitzvah of succah.
when we trust in Hashem, Hashem will
bestow His blessings upon us.
Shulchan Aruch (631:3) states, ֶך ַה ִס ּכו ְּך ִל ְהיוֹת ְ ֶּדר
The Kli Yakar (Vayikra 23:42) writes, "After ָבים ַה ְּגדו ִֹלים ֶ ְּכ ֵדי, ַקל, "It is the way of
ִ ׁשֵּירָא ּו ִמ ֶּמ ּנ ּו ַה ּכוֹכ
people harvest their crops, they want to go schach that one should be able to see through
home and live in a permanent dwelling. The them the large stars." Pri Megadim (א"א תרל"א
Torah is concerned that this might lead to )סק"בexplains that the reason is so he can see
arrogance. Therefore, the Torah says כל האזרח, the heaven, as it states (Yeshayah 40:26) ׂא ּו ָמרוֹם ְש
whoever has plans to live in this world as a ֵעינֵיכֶם ו ְּרא ּו ִמי ָברָא ֵא ֶּלה, "Lift up your eyes on high
permanent resident, ישבו בסוכות, he must first and see Who created these." He will
dwell in the temporary succah. This will understand that Hakadosh Baruch Hu
remind him to be humble and to know that created the entire world and leads it.
he is a stranger in this world. He isn't a
permanent resident here. With this
Erev Succos, and the Importance of
realization, he won't place his trust in the
Chessed
walls of his home. He will trust in Hashem
alone… This is what our forefathers did
The Shaarei Teshuvah (625) writes, "It is
when they left Mitzrayim. They didn't live
proper to give a lot of tzedakah on Erev
in high-class homes. They were surrounded
Succos. Reb Chaim Vital would distribute
by the seven clouds, where Hashem's honor
the entire tzedakah pushka to the poor on this
was among them. They were י-ד-בצל ש, in the
day." Rebbe Chaim of Sanz zt’l would give
shadow of Hashem, and not in the shadow
a lot of tzedakah on erev succos. He would
of their homes, made from good wood."
say that there is no nicer נוי סוכה, succah
The Gemara (Succah 2a) tells us that a succah decoration, than the tzedakah one gives on
higher than twenty amos is pasul. The Gemara erev Succos.1
1. The Tzanzer Rav was renowned for his extraordinary tzedakah and generosity, but he would say that
he wasn’t born that way. He worked on himself until he changed his nature and transformed himself into
a giver. He added that once he had reshaped his middos, if he met a poor person whom he couldn’t help,
he felt as though his skin was being torn from him. That is how deeply it pained him when he was unable
to assist another Yid.
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 7
Yesod VeShoresh HaAvodah writes, with us. When they arrive, they check to see
"Erev Succos is a special day to give tzedakah. if there are guests at the seudah. If guests
It is also the day to find proper guests, poor are present, they remain in the succah and
b'nei Torah, for all the days of the Yom Tov." they bless everyone. But if there are no
guests, they leave.3
The importance of having guests on
Succos is discussed in the Zohar. The Zohar "My brothers and friends, holy to Hashem,
teaches that the seven ushpizin: Avraham,2 friends of the Above, and loved ones of my
Yitzchok, Yaakov, Moshe, Aharon, Yosef, soul, think about your greatness when you
and Dovid, come to our succos to celebrate perform this mitzvah [of having guests on
2. On the first day of succos, Rebbe Eliezer of Dzikov zt’l was especially careful to have guests, since it is
the ushpizen of Avraham Avinu, who excelled in hachnasas orchim. One year, he had no guests, so he
asked his son, the Imrei Noam zt’l, to go outside and find someone who needed a meal. His son walked
through the streets until he found a homeless man and invited him into his father’s succah.
The Dzikover Rebbe was very pleased. He said, “Avraham Avinu’s guests weren’t any better. Avraham
cared so deeply for people that he was eager to bring anyone who desired a meal into his home. At least
on this day, we should emulate the ways of Avraham Avinu.”
A similar story is told about Reb Chaim Ozer zt’l. Someone came to his home on succos, and Reb Chaim
invited him to eat in the succah. Reb Chaim excused himself, saying, “I won’t be eating in the succah. It
is very cold outside, and I caught a cold. Chazal (Succah 25b) say, mitzta’er patur min hasuccah — one who
experiences tzaar is exempt from the mitzvah of succah. But you can go up and eat there.”
Shortly after the guest entered the succah, Reb Chaim joined him. He explained, “Chazal say that one who
has tzaar is exempt from succah, but they didn’t say he is exempt from the mitzvah of hachnasas orchim.”
The Beis Yisrael zt’l would often repeat this story, and he added (b’derech tzachus) that perhaps this is why
tzaddikim remained in the succah even when it rained. They had guests — the holy Ushpizin. Rain exempts
a person from succah, but not from hachnasas orchim.
The practical lesson is clear: when it comes to middos, a person cannot excuse himself by saying he has
tzaar. Perhaps he isn’t feeling well, but that does not exempt him from being kind to another Yid.
3. The Gemara (Avodah Zorah 3) teaches that in the future, when Hakadosh Baruch Hu rewards the Jewish
nation, the nations of the world will come forward and demand reward as well. They will claim that they,
too, want another chance to keep the Torah. Hakadosh Baruch Hu will reply, “Fools! It is too late to
perform mitzvos now. You had your opportunity, and you rejected the Torah and its mitzvos. Nevertheless,
I have a simple mitzvah — the mitzvah of succah. Keep this mitzvah, and you will receive reward.”
The Gemara relates that immediately the nations will climb onto their rooftops and build succos there.
Hakadosh Baruch Hu will then cause the sun to blaze intensely, making the heat unbearable. They will
kick their succos and walk away. The Gemara explains that although Yidden also leave the succah when
the heat becomes too great — for the halachah is mitzta’er patur min ha'succah, one who is in distress is
exempt — a Yid would never kick the succah in contempt. The nations of the world will kick the succah,
showing disdain, and therefore they do not deserve reward.
B’derech tzachus, we can understand why the Gemara says the goyim will build their succos on the roof.
They choose the rooftop intentionally — they don’t want anyone knocking on their door asking to be invited
in. Yidden, by contrast, seek guests for succos; they look for opportunities to bring others into their succah.
We can also explain this Chazal more deeply. The burning sun represents the hardships of life, and the
succah represents shelter, trust, and belief in Hashem. Non Jews may have emunah as long as life is
comfortable. But when the sun beats down — when life becomes difficult — they kick the succah; they
abandon their belief. The Jewish nation, however, believes and trusts in Hashem under all circumstances.
Even when it is metaphorically very hot and uncomfortable, the Jewish nation continues to rely on Hashem.
8 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
Succos]. In this merit, you earn redemption seven brachos from the ushpizin. How could
and freedom for your children, in all future a person not be inspired and excited to
generations. Hashem’s honor resides on you perform this mitzvah?!"4
all day long… and the avos hakedoshim dwell The Shlah Hakadosh (Succah, Ner Mitzvah 8)
with you in the succah. They are happy with writes, "One should invite the ushpizin with
you because you gave your bread to very his mouth, and then he should give the
poor talmidei chachamim, and you brought portion of the Ushpizin to the poor who sit
them into your home. The needy eat the around his table. If they aren't around his
portion of the ushpizin. You will receive table, he should send food to their homes…"5
4. One of the tzaddikim of our generation, shlita, asked, "How do we invite the ushpizin to our homes?
How can we say אזמין לסעודי אושפיזין קדישין, 'I invite to my meal the holy ushpizin?' Who are we to invite these
holy guests? However, on Yom Tov Succos, in the beis HaMikdash, we offered seventy korbanos
corresponding to the seventy nations of the world. These korbanos brought goodness and bounty to all
the nations of the world. This means that, on Succos, we do kindness even for goyim, even for those who
don't deserve it. Therefore, we can ask the holy ushpizin that they should extend kindness to us, even if
we don't deserve it – certainly when we have the merit to be in the company of poor guests. The holy
ushpizin will be happy to join us in the succah.
5. During World War One, the Chofetz Chaim was in exile in Sanubask, Russia. They were unable to locate
a fresh esrog, but someone managed to find an esrog from the previous year, and the Chofetz Chaim made
a brachah on it in the morning, before going to beis medresh. However, he didn't take it to beis medresh
for נענעוים, the shaking of the lulav. He explained that the other congregants will be jealous of him because
he has an esrog and not them. Shaking the lulav is a holy custom, but it doesn't permit one to cause pain
and distress to others. ()ח"ח חייו ופועליו חלק ג' עמ' תתכ"ד
The following story happened in Yerushalayim. A family put up their succah, but one of their neighbors
complained that the succah was exactly where he usually parks his car. He asked that they take down the
succah and build it elsewhere. The owner of the succah explained that it is hard for him to move the
succah, and he should please allow him to use the area for eight days, but the neighbor refused to give in.
Having no other choice, the owner of the succah asked his children to take down the succah and to rebuild
it nearby. The children were very upset about this. They said, "The place where the succah stood before
doesn't belong exclusively to the neighbor. The area belongs to all residents of the building." They
encouraged their father not to give in and to leave the succah right where it was.
The father replied, "If you want me to use this succah this year, you must move it. I will not sit in a succah
if the neighbor is upset about it." The children obliged and moved the succah.
On the first night of Succos, some heavy stones came crashing down from the building onto the neighbor’s
car, which was parked in “his” parking spot. Had the succah still been there, the stones would have fallen
on them. They were saved in the merit of being mevater.
In Bnei Brak, someone lived on the fourth floor and wanted to build a porch so he could put up a succah
there. The neighbors from the floors below told him that he couldn't do so, because it would make their
succahs pasul. His other option was to build the succah in the courtyard below. That would mean that
every time he forgot a spoon or needed something from home, he would have to go up and down four
flights of stairs. But what choice did he have?
But then the neighbor from the first floor told him that he allowed him to build over the area where he
generally has his succah. He said, "I am mevater, and I will build my succah on another porch, which is
on the other side of the building."
This vitur saved his life. There were powerful winds that Succos ()תשע"ח, and a roof of a porch from the
third floor fell onto the porch on the first floor, where he previously built his succah. The first-floor neighbor
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 9
Rashi (Devarim 16:11) writes: אם אתה משמח את beginning of the pasuk: ֲמ ֶת ָך
ָ ו ִּב ְנ ָך ו ִּב ֶּת ָך ו ְַע ְב ְּד ָך ַוא,
שלי אני משמח את שלך, "[Hashem says:] If you "Your son, and your daughter, and your
bring joy to Mine, I will bring joy to yours." manservant, and your maidservant." About
This means if you bring people who are this, Rashi writes, אם אתה משמח את שלי אני משמח
suffering to your table, and if you give them את שלך, "[Hashem says:] If you shall bring joy
simchas Yom Tov, Hashem will give to you to Mine, I will bring joy to yours."
and to your family simchas Yom Tov as
The Imrei Emes asks that there is a fifth
well. Rashi is referring to this pasuk (Devarim
category listed in the pasuk, for it states
16:11) ת ָך ֶ ֲמ
ָ ׂ ַמ ְח ָּת ִל ְפנֵי ה' ֱאל ֶֹקי ָך ַא ָּתה ו ִּב ְנ ָך ו ִּב ֶּת ָך ו ְַע ְב ְּד ָך ַוא
ְו ָש
ֲמ ֶת ָך ְו ָש, "You
ָ ׂ ַמ ְח ָּת ִל ְפנֵי ֱאל ֶֹקי ָך ַא ָּתה ו ִּב ְנ ָך ו ִּב ֶּת ָך ו ְַע ְב ְּד ָך ַוא
ֲשר ְּב ִק ְר ֶּב ָך
ׁ
ֶ ֲשר ִּב ְׁש ָערֶי ָך ו ְַה ּגֵר ו ְַה ּיָתוֹם ו ְָה ַא ְל ָמנָה א ֶ ו ְַה ֵּלוִי א, "You
ׁ
shall be happy before Hashem, your G-d,
shall be happy before Hashem, your G-d,
you, and your son, and your daughter, and
you, and your son, and your daughter, and
your manservant, and your maidservant…"
your manservant, and your maidservant,
So, in addition to "Your son, and your
and the Levite who is within your cities, and
daughter, and your manservant, and your
the stranger, and the orphan, and the widow,
maidservant,” which are four categories,
who are among you…" Eight kinds of people
"You" is also mentioned in the pasuk.
are mentioned in this pasuk, and Hashem
calls the four categories listed at the end of The Imrei Emes answers that indeed
the pasuk שלי, "Mine," because they are poor there are five categories of people who will
and alone, and Hashem feels close to them receive joy from Hashem. You will also be
and wants people to help them. These four happy, and you deserve this because you
kinds of people are: ו ְַה ּגֵר ו ְַה ּיָתוֹם ו ְָה ַא ְל ָמנָה...ו ְַה ֵּלוִי gave joy to five! You brought joy to the four
"The Levite (who was often poor)… the stranger, categories we mentioned: the Levi, the
the orphan, and the widow." When we bring stranger, the orphan, and the widow, and
joy to these four categories of people, you also brought joy to Hashem because
Hashem promises that He will bring joy to Hashem is happy when we bring joy to
the four categories of people listed at the those in need.6
thought he was helping his neighbor, but he was saving himself. Due to his vitur, he wasn't there, and his
life, and the lives of his family members, were saved.
6. Many people in Yerushalayim would come annually to show their four minim to Reb Shimon Aharon
Polonski zt’l, the Tepliker Rav, and he would tell them whether the minim were kosher and mehudar, or
if they should buy something else. After paskening, the Tepliker Rav would then ask them to give a
donation for the poor of Yerushalayim.
Once a person told him, "I can't give money to the poor. I need the money to buy the four minim."
The Tepliker Rav disagreed. He said, "You can borrow the four minim from a friend. You aren't obligated
to buy your own set. However, if a poor family is sad on Yom Tov because they couldn't afford a meal,
and they shed just one tear, that creates a kitrug in heaven, which is very hard to silence."
One year, on the first day of Succos, the Tepliker Rav asked someone to lend him his esrog since he didn't
have his own. How did it happen that he didn't have his own esrog? This is the story: On Erev Succos, the
Tepliker Rav heard shouts coming from his neighbor's home. He knew this family. Their father had passed
away; there were young orphans at home. The mother had remarried, but things weren't going so smoothly
there.
The shouts continued, so the Tepliker Rav knocked at their door and asked whether he could help. The
family told him that one of the children had broken the pitom of the stepfather's esrog. "The stepfather is
now in the mikvah, but we are scared of how he will react when he finds out."
The Tepliker Rav told them, "I will give you another esrog. You don't have to tell him what happened. Just
10 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
The Holiness of the Succah Yesod Yosef (ch.77) writes, "When one sits
in the succah and learns and davens there,
The Zohar (103b) states, "Come and see: he is literally in the upper worlds."
When a person sits in this abode, the shade
of emunah, the Shechinah spreads out its Sfas Emes (5643) writes, "Man was created
wings over him from Above." to live in Gan Eden, and this is the place of
true joy, as we say (in the Sheva Brachos of a chasunah),
Reishis Chochmah (Shaar HaKedushah ch.4) ׂ ֵּמ ֲח ָך י ְִצ ְיר ָך ְּבגַן ֵֽע ֶדן ִמ ֶּֽק ֶדם
ְּכ ַש,ֵעים ָהאֲהו ִּבים
ִ ׂ ַּמח ר ַש,
ׂ ַּמח ְּת ַש
writes that his Rebbe, the Remak, would 'Grant abundant joy to these loving friends,
only speak divrei Torah because the holiness as You bestowed gladness upon Your created
of the succah is very great.7 being in the Garden of Eden of old.' Mankind
was banished from Gan Eden, but there are
Mishnah Berurah (632:2) writes, "Since the times when a spark of Gan Eden shines. This
kedushah of the succah is so great, it is is why people are happy when they are in
proper that one shouldn't speak much there, the succah. The succah is Gan Eden…"
other than words of kedushah and divrei
Torah. Certainly, he must be cautious not to It states (Shir HaShirim 1:4) הביאני המלך חדריו,
speak lashon hara, rechilus, or other forbidden "The king brought me into His [innermost]
words in the succah." chambers. נגילה ונשמחה בך, "We will rejoice with
You." When we are in the Succah, we are in
Bikurei Yaakov (639:2) writes, "The Shlah Hashem's innermost chamber, a place of
was very strict that one shouldn't become immense joy. As Chazal (Chagigah 5:) say, after
angry in the succah." the churban Beis HaMikdash, Hashem cries
say that I asked to see his esrog and ruled it was pasul, so I gave you another one." The Tepliker Rav gave
them his own esrog. He could borrow an esrog in beis medresh, but now he had to help this family.
Esrogim used to be very expensive, and Rebbe Mordechai of Neshchiz zt'l would put aside money
throughout the year to have enough funds to buy the four minim. One year, as he was walking with his
package of money to buy an esrog, he encountered a simple Yid, who was crying bitterly. He asked him
what happened.
The man told him that his horse had died, and he couldn’t afford to buy another one. This man needed a
horse for his parnassah. Rebbe Mordechai of Neshchiz handed him his money bag and told him to buy a
horse. With the leftover money, Rebbe Mordechai purchased an esrog. It was a kosher esrog but not a
mehudar. When he came home, he told his family, "This Yom Tov, everyone will make a brachah on a
beautiful esrog. We will make a brachah on a beautiful horse…"
That Succos, Rebbe Mordechai davened in the beis medresh of Rebbe Elimelech of Lizensk zt’l. Rebbe
Elimelech said, "I smell the scent of Gan Eden coming from your esrog." Rebbe Mordechai told him how
he was moser nefesh to help another Jew. That merit brought a scent of Gan Eden on his otherwise simple
esrog.
7. Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 1:1) writes: "The way a person sits, moves about, and acts when he is alone
in his home is different than how he sits, moves about, and acts when he is in the presence of a great king.
[Also], the way he speaks freely with his family is different from how he will speak in the presence of a
king." We must never forget that we stand before Hashem, and that will help us act and speak with yiras
Shamayim at all times. This mindset is especially appropriate when we sit in the succah. We are sitting
before Hashem, and we should act accordingly.
Halachah states that the walls and the schach have kedushah. Therefore, we are forbidden to derive
pleasure from them all seven days of Succos (see Shulchan Aruch 638:1). Furthermore, Chazal (Succah 9a) say,כשם
שחל שם שמים על החגיגה כך חל שם שמים על הסוכה, "Just as Hashem's name is on the korban chagigah, Hashem's name
is on the succah". There are all expresses of the kedushah of the succah.
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 11
in His outer chambers and is happy in His resemble the Shulchan of the Beis HaMikdash,
innermost chambers.8 which had four legs.10 Chazal consider a
succah to be built on Har HaBayis, next to
Yaaras Dvash (vol.1 drush 6) writes, the Beis HaMikdash. The Gemara disproves
"Hashem's cloud hovers over the succah. this in the end. Nevertheless, a הוא אמינא, an
Although we don't see it, it is certain that initial thought of Chazal, also has significance
whoever sits in the succah l’shem shamayim and is indicative of the kedushah of the
and learns Torah there and is happy with succah. Its holiness is like that of the Beis
the Yom Tov and the mitzvos, Hashem's HaMikdash, which is built on the Har
cloud hovers above him."9 HaBayis.
The Pri Megadim states: One mustn't use
a succah as a shortcut, and it is certainly When Succos falls on Friday night, some
forbidden to spit there because the succah is people don't say "Shalom Aleichem" (which is
holy and its laws are similar to those of the said before kiddush). Shem MiShmuel explains
Beis HaMikdash. Arizal teaches that one's that the kedushah of the succah is so great
table in the succah should have four legs to that malachim cannot go there.11
8. Rashi learns the opposite: that Hashem cries in the inner chambers and is happy in the outer chambers.
Perhaps this can be compared to the Chovos HaLevavos (Prishus 4) הפרוש צהלתו בפניו ואבלו בלבו, that a tzaddik,
"Joy is on his face, while he mours in his heart." Our explanation above follows Rabbeinu Chananel, who
says that Hashem's joy is in the inner quarters, and the distress of the Churban is expressed in the outer
chambers. This is why the judgment is limited to Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, but when Succos
arrives, we enter the inner chamber, the place of Hashem's joy.
9. Keren l'Dovid writes, "When one sits in the succah l’shem shamayim, he feels the holiness with hislahavus.
He experiences the light of the mitzvah and knows that it is true that the ענני כבודsurrounded us. This
sensation cannot be explained in words, but someone who experienced it knows it's true."
One of the laws of the succah is that it must be at least ten tefachim high. The Gemara (Succah 4:) explains
that this is because the Shechinah never descended below ten tefachim. The Chesed L'Avraham and the
Sfas Emes ( )תרמ"ב ד"ה כתיבsay that this hints at the holiness of the succah. It tells us that the Shechinah resides
above it.
According to halachah, a succah must be made of at least two full walls and one smaller wall, the length
of a tefach. The holy sefarim explain that this represents an arm. An arm has three parts: The two larger
parts of the arm and the palm. The succah, with its two large walls and one small wall, represents an arm.
Keviyachol, when we sit in the succah, it is like Hashem is hugging us.
Some tzaddikim were careful that a goy shouldn’t enter the succah because of its immense kedushah.
The Chiddushei HaRim zt'l teaches that Hashem cares for us in the same manner as a mother cares for
her child. On Rosh Hashanah, בלאזט מען אונז אפ, Hashem blows on us and blows away our impurities. On
Yom Kippur וואשט מען אונז אפ, Hashem rinses us off, as it says, וזרקתי עליכם מים טהורים, "I will throw onto you
purifying waters" (Yechezkel 36). And on Succos, דעקט מען אונז צו, Hashem covers and swaddles us.
Similarly, the Ohev Yisrael (Likutim) says that a chicken first feeds its chicks and then covers them under
its wings. This is how the Shechinah interacts with us during these days. On Rosh Hashanah, Hashem
gives us parnassah, and on Succos, Hashem takes us under His wings.
10. We repeat this not necessarily so that people should go out and buy a table with four legs, but rather
to highlight the holiness of the succah, which resembles the Beis HaMikdash.
11. Before each meal, there is a custom to invite the Ushpizin to the succah ודוד, יוסף, אהרן, משה, יעקב, יצחק,אברהם.
The question was raised (for those who say Shalom Aleichem in the succah on Friday night) which should be recited first:
Should we first invite the Ushpizin, or should we first greet the malachim and begin with Shalom Aleichem?
12 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
When we say Hoshanos we call out in a means shadow, not shade. The Gemara
loud voice )אום אני חומה( הושענא שואגים הושע נא, (Succah 2a) states אדם יושב בצל סוכה, "A person sits
"Hashem should save those who shout out in the shadow of the succah." Also, the Zohar
Hosha Na." Rosh Hashanah and Yom HaKadosh (vol.3 103b) calls a succah צילא
Kippur, prayers are said in a silent voice, as דמיהמנותא, "The shadow of emunah." However,
we say, וכל מאמינים שהוא עונה לחש, "Everyone this expression is difficult, because when
believes that Hashem answers silent tefillos." one sits under the schach, he sits under the
Reb Shalom of Belz zt'l explains that on Rosh shade of the succah, not in its shadow. When
Hashanah and Yom Kippur, we should there is a tall tree that gives off a shadow,
daven silently to hide our tefillos from the one can sit in that shadow, but when one
malachim, the mikatrigim, who wish to sits directly under the tree, he isn't under the
prevent them from ascending to heaven. But shadow. He is in the shade of the tree. So,
on Succos, when we sit in the succah under why is sitting in the succah called sitting in
the shade of the Shechinah, we are shielded the צל, shadow?
from all the mikatrigim. Therefore, we can
pray in a loud voice. We can shout הושע נא, The Ropshitzer Rav answers with the
and our tefillos will go up and be answered. renowned Midrash (see Shlah Hakadosh, ,תולדות אדם
' )שער הגדול אות הto explain the pasuk (Tehillim 121:8) 'ה
When Yaakov Avinu escaped from Eisav, צלך, "Hashem is your shadow". The midrash
where did he go? The Zohar (vol.3 p.100:) states explains that Hashem is called צלך, our
that he ran to a succah. The Bnei Yissaschar shadow, because just as all movements of
(Tishrei 10:7) writes, "With the or makif, the holy man are seen in his shadow, so, too, the way
light of the succah, all tumah flee from him." a person acts, Hashem does the same in
It is a place of holiness and protection from heaven. When a person has compassion on
all bad and from all tzaros. his fellow man, Heaven will act with
compassion. When one is kind, Heaven
performs kindness, etc. This explains the
Salvations from the Succah
reason the shade of the succah is called צל,
We say in Neilah, יחביאנו צל ידו תחת כפני shadow. When we sit in our succah made of
השכינה. The Ateres Tzvi zt'l says that צל ידו wood and stone, Hashem protects Bnei
refers to the shade of the succah. We daven Yisrael in His succah in heaven. There is a
on Yom Kippur that in the merit of the shadow effect. The Ropshitzer writes, הגם
mitzvah succah, יחביאנו, Hashem should שאין ערך ודמיון כלל עם כל זה מוכרח לומר כן, "Although
protect us. there is no comparison at all…" There is no
comparison between our succos, made from
The Zera Kodesh (first night of Succos) from stone and wood, to the holy succah in
Rebbe Naftali of Ropshitz zt'l says that צל heaven, "nevertheless, we must say so."12
Someone told the Satmar Rebbe zt'l that he thinks we should invite the malachim first because the rule is
תדיר ושאינו תדיר תדיר קודם, whatever is more frequent comes first. Shalom Aleichem is recited every Friday night
and should, therefore, be said first.
The Satmar Rebbe replied that although Shalom Aleichem is said each week, different malachim come each
week. This is because the level of malachim that accompany us on Shabbos night depends on the person’s
deeds during the week and on the amount he prepared himself during the week for Shabbos. Therefore,
said the Satmar Rebbe, the ushpizin and the malachim are equally תדיר. The question thus remains which
one should be invited into the succah first: the malachim or the Ushpizin?
The Satmar Rebbe said, "In my opinion, the Ushpizin should be invited first because the Ushpizin are
tzaddikim, and tzaddikim are greater than malachim."
12. The Zohar (vol.3, 100b, which some say before the tekiyos on Rosh Hashanah) states that Yaakov escaped from
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 13
Chazal say מצטער פטור מן הסוכה. The Tiferes The end of the pasuk is ירננו על משכבותם,בכבוד,
Shlomo translated it: מצטער פטור, one becomes "…they will sing praises on their beds." The
freed from all his tzaros, מן הסוכה, in the merit Sfas Emes (5653) says that this pasuk alludes
of performing the mitzvah of succah.13 to the mitzvah of sleeping in succah, the
only mitzvah one performs while sleeping.
The Yeitav Lev zt'l said that even if the The word כבודin this pasuk also hints at
decree on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur succah because the succah commemorates
was חייב, chalilah (that he is guilty and undeserving of the ענני הכבוד, clouds of glory that protected
a good year) on Succos, חיי"בturns around and
Bnei Yisrael in the desert. This mitzvah
becomes the roshei teivos for (Tehillim 149:5) results in יעלזו חסידים, a lot of joy, because the
יעלזו חסידים בכבוד ירננו, "The righteous will exult mitzvah of succah brings many salvations.
in Hashem's honor; they will sing praises…"
They will praise Hashem for His kindness The mitzvah of succah is mesugal for a
that will come to them. long life. The Ropshitzer Rav zt'l learned
Eisav by hiding in a succah. Shaar HaKavanos (' )ענין סוכה דרוש דfrom the Arizal teaches, "The concept of succah
is that we, Yisrael, children of kings, build a succah and sit in the shade of Hashem's encompassing light
()אור מקיף, which surrounds us like a succah. By sitting in the succah, we draw onto ourselves this encompassing
light. The Bnei Yissaschar (Tishrei 10:7) teaches that this light banishes all tumah, kelipos, and chitzonim,
which seek to harm us. He notes that this is hinted at in the pasuk (Devarim 28:10) ׁשם ה' נ ְִקרָא ֵ ְורָא ּו ּכָל ַע ֵּמי ָה ָארֶץ ִּכי
ָ "All the peoples of the earth will see that Hashem's name is called upon you, and they will
ע ֶלי ָך ְוי ְָרא ּו ִמ ֶּמ ָּך,
fear you." The Bnei Yissaschar explains that a key word in this pasuk is ע ֶלי ָך, ָ "upon you." This refers to the
אור מקיף, the light that surrounds us. This holy light protects us, for it banishes all tumos and all kelipos and
all harm. The Bnei Yissaschar explains that tumah is afraid of this encompassing light because the tumah
doesn't possess this light. As it states (Bereishis 3:1) ָחׁש ָהיָה ָערוּם ָ ו ְַה ּנ, the snake was naked; it didn't have clothing
encompassing it. When we sit in succah, this gives us the encompassing light ( )אור מקיףthat protects us from
all harm.
The Imrei Noam (Or Ropshitz, ' )אושפיזא דיעקב אות אzt'l teaches that סכ"ךis roshei teivos of (Tehillim 22:17) ְּל ִבים ָ כִּי ְס ָבב ּונִי כ,
"For dogs [Eisav], have surrounded me." Also, it states (Shemos 15:7) ָו ְּברֹב ְּגאוֹנְךָ ַּת ֲהרֹס ָק ֶמיך, "With Your great pride,
You tear down those who rise up against You". The סופי תיבות, final letters spell סכ"ך. These sources hint that
with the mitzvah of succah, we tear down our enemies, and we are protected from all harm.
Shem MiShmuel ( )תער"ד ד"ה בזוה"קwrites, "I heard from my father [the Avnei Nezer zt'l] that when one says
קריאת שמע שעל המטהin the succah, he should say only the first parashah of Shema, as we do on the night of
ליל שמורים, after the seder." The explanation is as follows: Every night of the year, it is recommended that
one read the entire Shema, with all its three parshiyos. This protects us from the tumah and chitzonim,
who seek to harm us. However, the night of the seder is called ליל שמורים, the night that is protected. We
aren't afraid of the tumah on this night, and therefore, there is no need to say all three parshiyos of Shema.
The Avnei Nezer says that the same is when one says Shema in the succah before going to sleep. In the
succah, we aren't afraid of the chitzonim, and therefore, it is sufficient to read the first parashah of Shema.
People asked the Vilna Gaon zt'l whether it is permitted to sleep alone in the succah. (The question relates to
the precaution many people practice, not to sleep in a room alone, because they are afraid of chitzonim.) The Vilna Gaon
replied, שומר מצוה לא ידע דבר רע, when one performs a mitzvah, nothing bad will happen to him. ()מעשה רב אות רכ"א.
It states (Bereishis 33:17) ֻכוֹת
ּ ׁשם ַה ָּמקוֹם ס
ֵ ַעל ּכֵן ָקרָא...ֻכ ָֹתה ַו ּי ִֶבן לוֹ ָּביִת ַ ְוַי ֲעקֹב נ, "Yaakov traveled to Succos and built
ּ ָסע ס
himself a house… Therefore he named the place Succos." The Zohar HaKadosh (vol.3 101a) states that this
pasuk tells us that the mitzvah of succah protects Bnei Yisrael from the kitrug (prosecuting malachim), and
Hakadosh Baruch Hu is happy with His children.
13. The Gemara (Succah 25:) says, מצטער פטור מן הסוכה, one who has tzaar, is exempt from the succah. The
Kotzker zt'l explains this Gemara in a mussar fashion. It teaches us that one shouldn't feel any tzaar or
pain when he is in the holy succah, under Hashem's wings. If he feels distress in the succah, פטור מן הסוכה,
this demonstrates that he hasn't attached himself to the essence and holiness of the succah.
14 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
this from the pasuk (Vayikra 23:42) כל האזרח בישראל אם בגבורות שמונים שנה, that the mighty live up
ישבו בסוכות, "Every resident of Yisrael shall until eighty. So, there is an indication in the
dwell in succahs." The word אזרחis gematria pasuk that for keeping the mitzvah of succah,
גבורה, mighty, and the pasuk says (Tehillim 90:10) one will merit to live long.14
14. The Tzelemer Rav zt'l was in a nursing home visiting a friend when an elderly person approached him
and said that he was 116 years old. He asked the Tzelemer Rav to daven for him that he should die.
The Tzelemer Rav said, "You appear healthy, and your mind is sound; why do you want to die?"
The old man replied, "It is because of my ninety-year-old son, who is also in this facility. He suffers terribly,
and I can't bear to watch his suffering so much. That's the reason I want to leave this world."
The Tzelemer Rav went to visit his son. He was lying in bed, in terrible pain. The son said, "I am certain
that I will live four more years."
The Tzelemer Rav asked how he knew that, but the son didn't have the strength to answer. So, the Tzelemer
Rav returned to the old father and asked him how his son knew that he would live for another four years.
The old man said, "In my youth, I lived in Kalamaya. When I turned twenty, I worked in the Kalamaya
post office, and my job was to deliver letters. When my manager noticed how strong I was, they began
sending me to deliver the heavy packages to the intended addresses.
"One Erev Succos, I came to the post office, as I did every day, and I saw a package of sefarim for Reb
Hillel Kalamaya zt'l. I understood that Reb Hillel might want to study from these sefarim over Succos, so
I made sure to deliver the sefarim to Reb Hillel before Yom Tov. When I got to Reb Hillel's home, I saw
that he was sad. I was surprised to see him in this state, since it was erev Succos, זמן שמחתנו, a happy time!
His succah was standing and decorated; he had the four minim, so I asked Reb Hillel why he was sad. He
replied that he was worried that he wouldn't be able to sleep in the succah. He explained that the goyim
who lived near his home were lately becoming rowdy and drunk at night. Reb Hillel lived on a central
street, and many people would pass his succah. He feared that the goyim might break into his succah in
the middle of the night and harm him…
"I said, 'Reb Hillel! I am strong. I will stay with you in your succah, and I will protect you from the goyim.'
Reb Hillel was delighted with this arrangement.
"I stayed in his succah the entire Yom Tov. At night, I kept a stick near me in case there was trouble. On
the first night of Succos, after we went to sleep, the goyim came to the succah. I chased them away. They
returned the next night, and the night after that, but they received a beating from me each time, until they
realized they would be better off not coming back. There was peace for the second half of Succos.
"At the end of Yom Tov, Reb Hillel gave me a brachah that I should live until 120 years with good health,
and that none of my children should die in my lifetime. As you can see, the brachah has come to fruition.
My son apparently understood from this story that he has another four years to live. I am 116, I will live
until 120, and none of my children will die in my lifetime. Therefore, my son knows that he will live for
another four years."
The Tzelemer Rav was very inspired by this story and told the old man not to daven to die. He should
instead daven that his son should have a refuah sheleimah.
Before leaving the nursing home, the Tzelemer Rav spoke to the staff and asked them to contact him if
anything changed regarding the old man’s health. Additionally, from time to time, he would come by to
visit this old man.
Four years later, the home administration contacted the Tzelemer Rav to tell him that the old man was
niftar. He was 120 years old. An hour afterward, they informed him that the son was also niftar.
We learn from this story that (a) if you help others keep the mitzvah of succah, you can merit long life. (b)
Have hakaras hatov for those who help you, especially those who help you perform the mitzvah of succah.
(c) We also see from this story the power of brachos from tzaddikim.
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 15
Yesod HoAvodah says (Devarim 32:39) מחצתי Sfas Emes (5658) explains the brachah of
ואני ארפא, that with the מחיצות, the walls of the Shemoneh Esrei, מלך ממית ומחיה ומצמיח ישועה, as
succah, there will be refuah. follows: מלך ממית ומחיה, "a King Who gives life
and death," this occurs on Rosh Hashanah
The Kaf HaChaim (siman 621:6) teaches, and Yom Kippur. ומצמיח ישועה, "He sprouts
"Whoever is cautious with the mitzvah of salvations," this happens on Succos because
succah, to keep it properly, is guaranteed on Succos, salvations come, and the harsh
that there won't be disputes in his home gezeiros are ripped up.
throughout the year." Segulas Yisrael ('מערכת מ
)אות י"חwrites that learning masechta Succah,
Salvations from the Four Minim
any day of the year, is mesugal to be saved
from machlokes. The hint is (Tehillim 31:21) תצפנם There are many segulos in the merit of
בסוכה מריב לשונות, "Protect them in a succah taking the four minim.
from the disputes of tongues." Reb Naftoli of
Ropshitz zt'l would study masechta Succah
The Yerushalmi (quoted in the Rosh סוכה פ"ג כ"ו, and
throughout the year. He said that it is
see also Maharsha, Succah 38a) writes that when we
mesugal for shalom bayis.
shake the lulav during Hallel, it shakes up
and weakens the מקטרג, the malachim who
The mitzvah of succah is mesugal for speak against us.15
parnassah. Tiferes Shlomo says that this is
hinted at in the Mishnah (Succah 28.) מי שהיה Reb Mendel of Riminov zt'l ( האזינו, )מנחם ציוןsays,
ראשו ורובו בסוכה ושלחנו בתוך הבית, "A person whose "During Succos, we take the four minim, like
head and most of his body are in the succah brooms. With them we sweep away all the
and his table is in the home." Alluded to in resha'im of the world. For, in every
these words is that, from this mitzvah, he generation, the seventy nations of the world
brings parnassah to his table. Another are mikatreg against us. This is so true; it is
indication is the Gemara (Succah 29), מנא מיכלא like I see it with my eyes. Every Yid creates
חוץ לסוכה, that also when the Yom Tov passes, the seventy nations himself [with his aveiros],
and he is חוץ לסוכה, outside the succah, he will and we must overcome them and negate
receive מיכלא, food, and parnassah because them. Therefore, we take the four minim,
he performed the mitzvah of succah. and we fight with the mikatrigim who cause
us tzaros. The four minim are our weapons,
Sfas Emes (5637) says, "The mitzvah of as the Tikunei Zohar (29a) tells us. We wave
succah brings blessings and a light of the four minim back and forth, so that
kedushah to the person's home." wherever there is a mikatreg who speaks
15. Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur have passed, and people think that the days of judgment are over,
but it isn't so. As we will explain, Hoshana Rabba is still an integral part of the days of judgment. Our
lives, successes, parnassah etc. are still being determined, even if we are unaware of it. Therefore, Hashem
gave us the mitzvah to shake the lulav on Succos, as that silences the mikatrigim, and they won't speak
against us on Hoshana Rabba. With this mitzvah, we prepare and protect ourselves from a harsh judgment.
People perform this mitzvah, and often have no idea that they are being judged.
We can compare this to a child who is blissfully playing on a rooftop, unaware that there is no gate there,
and that he is in great danger. But people below are aware. They place cushions on the ground, around
the house, and call Hatzalah to save the child. Similarly, many people are unaware that we are still in the
judgment, and that our lives, our parnassah, our health, etc. are on the line. It is a critical time, but many
aren't aware of it. Hashem gave us a mitzvah to shake the lulav to silence the mikatrigim so that we will
have a good judgment. With this mitzvah, Hashem protects all of us, including those who aren't aware of
what is at stake.
16 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
against Yisrael, they will fall under our feet, Taking Advantage of these Days
and they will have no ability to stand.
The Midrash (Shemos Rabbah 47:7) tells the
The Beis Aharon (p.138) writes that ערבהis following mashal: A king said to someone
gematria ( זרע277). This tells us that the aravos
i
he loved, "Measure as many gold coins as
that are in the lulav, and the Hoshanos on you want and keep them for yourself." The
Hoshana Rabba, are mesugal for bearing Midrash says that this person didn’t eat or
children. (The source is 'פרי עץ חיים שער הלולב פרק ג. Imrei sleep. We are certain about that because he
Pinchas השלם תס"הtells a story about someone who told his wanted to take as many coins as he could.
wife to cook the aravos as a segulah for bearing children; see Similarly, the Midrash says that during the
there). forty days that Moshe Rabbeinu was on Har
Sinai receiving the Torah, he didn't eat,
Chazal (Taanis 2a) tell us that the key for drink, or sleep.
bearing children is in HaKadosh Baruch
Hu's hands, and He doesn't give it over to a Chazal (Succah 53.) tells us, "When we were
shaliach. The aravah (and all the four minim) are in the Beis HaMikdash, celebrating the
similar, because they are entirely in Hashem's Simchas Beis HaShoeivah, our eyes didn't
hands. As the Bnei Yissaschar (Tishrei 10:24) get tired." The Sfas Emes (5634) explains that
writes, quoting from early kabbalah sefarim, they didn't want to sleep. The joy and the
that although all plants have a malach kedushah were available, and they didn't
appointed over them to hit them and to tell want to lose it by sleeping. Like the mashal
them to grow (see Bereishis Rabba 10:6), the four of the Midrash (stated above), when a person
species (esrog, lulav, hadasim, aravos) are entirely can take a lot of good, he doesn't think about
under Hashem's hashgachah, and no malach is eating and sleeping.
involved. We are obligated to take the four The Beis Yisrael zt'l said that the same
minim. This shows that we too are entirely applies to Yom Tov. It should be so precious
under Hashem's hashgachah. We aren't to us that we don't want to miss a moment.
under the influence of malachim. With this
information, we can explain the reason the Wasting time is the worst of all. This was
aravos are mesugal for bearing children. taught by Reb Yechezkel of Kuzmir zt'l, and
Chazal (Taanis 2a) say that bearing children is he proved it from hilchos succah. It states in
entirely in Hashem's hands, and He didn't hilchos succah that if there is space in the
give it over to the malachim. Thus, bearing schach (called )אוירor if there is ( סכך פסולnot kosher
children has a similarity to the four minim schach) on the roof of the succah, the succah
and to the aravos, as they are both entirely is pasul (see Shulchan Aruch 632:1-2). But there is a
under Hashem's hashgachah. difference between a space and when there
is non-kosher schach. Four tefachim of non-
The ( מהרי"לHilchos Lulav) writes that לולבis kosher schach disqualify the succah. An
gematria חיים, life. This hints that when one empty spot in the schach disqualifies the
buys a beautiful lulav and esrog, he merits schach when there are three tefachim of air,
life in Olam HaZeh and in Olam Haba. emptiness. Reb Yechezkel of Kuzmir zt'l said
that we can learn from this the great fault of
Eliyahu Rabba ( )תרמ"ה אwrites that לולב emptiness, of not doing anything at all.
spells לו לב. ל"וis gematria thirty-six, which
i
Therefore, let us not be idle, especially
represents the thirty-six tzaddikim who are during the holy days of Succos.
in each generation and the thirty-six masechtos
in Shas. ל"בstands for the Torah, which Shem MiShmuel (Shabbos Chol HaMoed Pesach
begins with the letter ( ב' )בראשיתand ends with 5673) writes, "Every moment of the holiday
the letter לולב.( ל' )ישראלis gematria חיים, which [chol-hamoed], one should be prepared and
is Torah. He will merit children tzaddikim ready to receive the holiness that is coming
who have a לב, a heart for Torah. down, non-stop."16
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 17
The Mishnah (Avos 3:11) states, המבזה את But this lesson tells us of the great kedushah
אף על פי שיש בידו תורה ומעשים טובים אין לו...המועדות of the Shabbos of Shemini Atzeres.
חלק לעולם הבא, "Someone who disgraces the
Yomim Tovim… even if he knows Torah
ושמחת בחגך- Simchah
and he has good deeds, he doesn't have a
portion in Olam HaBa." Rabbeinu Yonah The Rambam writes, "There is a mitzvah
says that מועדותrefers to Chol Hamoed. We to be happy on all holidays, but it is especially
must honor these days, to be very cautious important to be happy on Succos, as it states
not to desecrate them or to dishonor them in (Vayikra 23), ושמחת לפני ה' אלקיך שבעת ימים, 'rejoice
any way. Rabbeinu Yonah writes, "The before Hashem your G-d for seven days'".
Mishnah doesn't need to discuss Yom Tov Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 529:2) states, "A
because it is like Shabbos [and everyone person is obligated to be happy and in a
understands that we must honor Yom Tov]. good mood on Yom Tov together with his
Rather, the Mishnah is talking about Chol wife and children. How does he make the
Hamoed, when one says that Chol HaMoed family happy? He should give children nuts
doesn’t have kedushah like the first days." and roasted grains [and other foods children
Thinking that way is a desecration of chol enjoy], and for women, he should buy them
hamoed. clothing and jewelry, according to his
abilities."17
The Chiddushei HaRim zt'l teaches that
there is special kedushah on Shabbos Chol We take the four minim every day of
Hamoed. He explains that throughout the Succos (aside from on Shabbos); however, for most
year, the kedushah of Shabbos comes and is of the days, the obligation is d'Rabbanan.
created from our avodas Hashem that we From the Torah, the mitzvah of lulav is only
performed during the weekdays before on the first day of Succos. The mitzvah of
Shabbos. Shabbos Chol Hamoed is a very simchah, to be happy on the holiday, is for
high time because its holiness is formed all eight days of Succos. The Imrei Noam zt'l
from the avodas Hashem that was done on says that this tells us the importance of
Yom Tov and chol hamoed. This year, happiness on Yom Tov. Hashem loves it
Succos, there is no Shabbos chol hamoed. when His nation is happy.18
16. Pele Yoetz (Chol HaMoed) writes, "Chazal (Yerushalmi Shabbos 15:3) say, לא נתנו שבתות וימים טובים לישראל אלא לעסוק
בתורה, Hashem gave Shabbos and Yom Tov to Yisrael so they could study Torah. Some people say they
can't learn Torah because they are busy earning a living. If such a person uses his time well on chol
hamoed, as well as the other times when he is off from work, and devotes himself to studying Torah, he
will receive reward even for the times he was working. [Because by studying at every free moment and
every opportunity he proves that if he didn't have to work, he would study Torah then as well.] He should
be especially cautious to study Torah on chol hamoed, because chol hamoed are days of judgment. On
Pesach, there is a judgment on the תבואה, the grain crop, and on Succos the judgment is for water (see Rosh
Hashanah 16a), and the gmar din is on Hoshana Rabba…"
17. On the weeks leading up to Succos, someone in Yerushalayim opened a four-minim store right next
door to a jewelry shop. A talmid chacham entered the jewelry store, and a simple Yid went to the four-
minim shop. They met outside, each holding in their hands their purchases. The simple person commented,
"My purchase is superior to yours because I bought a mitzvah. I bought the four minim!"
The scholar responded, "You bought a mitzvah ( דרבנןthat year, the first day of Succos fell on Shabbos) and I bought
a mitzvah דאורייתא. I purchased jewelry for my wife, fulfilling the Torah's obligation to bring happiness to
one's wife on Yom Tov."
18. Think about how much you are ready to invest to purchase a kosher set of the four-minim. That should
help you understand how much effort you should invest in being happy on Succos.
18 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
Sfas Emes ( )תרמ"ג ד"ה ימיzt'l writes, "When the Succos. His face should be beaming with joy
Jewish nation becomes pure from all their because the holy Ushpizin dwell with him."
aveiros on Yom Kippur, there is immense
joy in heaven. We should join Hashem in In Hilchos Lulav (8:15), the Rambam writes,
His happiness." "The joy that one has when he performs
mitzvos is a great service, and whoever
refrains from that joy deserves to be
The Alshich (Emor) writes, "From the day
punished."
the world was created, Hashem was never
as happy with His creation as the day the Reb Chaim Vital (Hakdamah l'Shaar HaMitzvos)
Mishkan was built. And in every generation, zt'l writes, "Do not view mitzvos as a burden,
Hashem is extremely happy on Succos, for as something you wish to quickly 'get over
then Bnei Yisrael are cleansed from their with them.' Instead, think that you will earn
sins. The succah is our sign that we attained many thousands of gold coins with every
this purity." mitzvah you perform. With this thought,
you will have boundless joy when you
The Shlah HaKadosh ( )סוכה נר מצוה סוף אות טwrites, perform the mitzvos, as happy as someone
"A person must be happy every day of who received millions of gold coins…"19
It states (Avos 2:15), ובעל הבית דוחק, "The baal habayis is pushing…" We can explain these words with a mashal:
Customers trying on shoes in the shoe store often have difficulty returning the shoes to the box. When
they try putting the shoes in side by side, they find the box isn't wide enough. When they try placing one
on the other, the box isn't tall enough. But the baal habayis of the store can slip the shoes into the box with
ease. The baal habayis knows how to push the shoes together in a way that they fit perfectly into the box.
The nimshal is that we are the baal habayis over our joy; therefore, בעל הבית דוחק, the baal habayis knows
how to push simchah into his life. Chazal say, הבא לטהר מסייעין אותו, when a person desires to be pure, Heaven
helps him. Similarly, when one tries to be happy, Hashem will help him succeed.
Chazal (Succah 48.) say that we must also be happy on the final night of Yom Tov (the night of Shemini Atzeres).
The Sfas Emes taught that "the final night" hints at the hardships of the dark galus, in the final generation.
Even during these challenging times, we are obligated to be happy.
A man once shared his troubles with Reb Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, zt'l. Reb Shlomo Zalman assured him
that despite his problems, happiness was within reach. The man replied, "It is impossible for a person who
suffers as much as I do to be happy."
Reb Shlomo Zalman replied, "I know someone who is a widower, deaf in one ear, and three of his children
are childless. Nevertheless, he is always happy."
The man said, "It can't be. How can he be happy? The story can't be true."
Upon that, Reb Shlomo Zalman releaved that he was referring to himself.
The Alter of Slabodka, zt’l, taught: When the Rambam omits a halachah from his sefer, talmidei chachamim
don't assume that the Rambam accidentally overlooked this halachah and forgot to put it in. They are
certain that the Rambam intentionally left out the halachah, and they study the topic in depth to understand
the reason the Rambam omitted it. So, when something is lacking and missing in your life, why do you
think it happened by chance or by accident? Everything is from Hashem, and if you lack something, there
is a reason for it, and it is for your good.
The Yiddish expression, מיטן פיטום אראפ, "with the pitom facing down," is said when one suffers a lot, and
everything seems to be going in the wrong direction. But notice that we make the brachah on an esrog
specifically when it is מיטן פיטם אראפ, the pittim facing downwards. This is a reminder that we should praise
Hashem in all situations because everything is for the good.
19. In military training, soldiers do not use real bullets and live ammunition. It would be a waste of money
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 19
Reb Mordechai of Chernobyl zy'a said Rashi (Bamidbar 29:18) teaches that ninety-
that Succos is called זמן שמחתינו, because זמן eight sheep were sacrificed on Succos.21 The
means prepare (להזמין, to prepare, to order). On 98 sheep annul the 98 curses written in
Succos, we prepare and store up simchah for parashas Ki Savo.
the entire year (see Magen Avraham, Trisk, Shabbos
Chol HaMoed Succos).
Avnei Nezer says that we serve Hashem
with joy on Succos, and this annuls the klalos,
Rebbe Shmuel of Lubavitch (The Maharash – curses, written in parashas Ki Savo, which
Maamarim, 5655) teaches, "Joy [throughout the come because (Devarim 28:47) תחת אשר לא עבדת את
year] comes from our happiness on Succos." ה' אלקיך בשמחה, "you didn't serve Hashem with
joy."
It states, והיית אך שמח...ושמחת בחגיך. The
Abarbanel writes, "This pasuk is a guarantee Beis Aharon (p.156.) writes, "During the
that if you will be happy on Succos, you will yomim nora'im [Rosh Hashanah and Yom
be happy the entire year." Similarly, the Ibn Kippur], we draw down the bounty with
Ezra on the pasuk ( ושמחת בחגיךDevarim 16: 14-16) fear, and on Succos, we open the treasuries
writes that if we are happy on Succos, we of bounty with our joy."22
are blessed to be happy forever.
The Chozeh of Lublin zt'l was at a
Pele Yoetz zt'l writes, "We are commanded chasunah, performing the mitzvah of
to be happy, and this becomes a good omen simchas chasan v'kalah. Someone asked him,
(siman) for the entire year. The Arizal's "No one is happier than a chassan and kallah.
students write that someone who is joyous Wouldn't you use your time more wisely if
and has a happy heart, without any distress, you brought joy to those who are suffering?
on this holy holiday, it is certain that he will Why do you bring simchah to the chassan
have a good and happy year."20 and kalah, who are anyway happy?"
to do so. However, in battle, they must use live ammunition. If they fail to do so, the enemy will capture
them and laugh at their incompetence. The Kedushas Levi (Likutim, Avos, )ד"ה אם למדתutilizes this analogy to
illustrate what happens when a person serves Hashem without passion and without joy. "The extent of his
enthusiasm determines how far he can distance himself from materialism and the level of awareness of
Hashem he can achieve. However, performing mitzvos mechanically, without passion, is akin to a soldier
who neglects to load his weapons with live ammunition during battle."
20. About Yom Kippur it states (Vayikra 23:27) ...אך בעשר לחודש השביעי יום הכפורים הוא. The word אךis also mentioned
in reference to Succos, as it states (ibid. 23:39) ' תחוגו את חג ה...אך בחמשה עשר יום לחודש השביעי.
The Meshech Chachmah ( (אמור ד"ה אךexplains that אךcan be translated as "even so." If one didn't do teshuvah,
perhaps he shouldn’t fast on Yom Kippur? The Torah tells us that, even so, he must fast. Succos, we
celebrate the atonement. But what if he didn't do teshuvah and didn’t achieve atonement? Perhaps he
shouldn’t keep Succos? So the Torah writes ,אךthat even so, he should rejoice on Succos.
21. (Bamidbar 29:13-32) כבשים בני שנה ארבע עשר תמימים יהיו, "Sheep, within the first year, fourteen perfect ones they
shall be." This was brought all seven days of Succos. 7 x 14 = 98.
22. Once, during Succos, Reb Meir of Premishlan zt'l was informed that a close relative of his was sick and
his life was in danger. Reb Meir replied, "Hakadosh Baruch Hu commanded us to blow shofar on Rosh
Hashanah, and Meir'l did so. Hakadosh Baruch Hu commanded us to fast on Yom Kippur, and Meir'l did
so. Hakadosh Baruch Hu requires us to be happy on Succos, and I want to do so. But Chazal say, אין מערבין
שמחה בשמחה, one mustn't mix two joys. [On Yom Tov, we are happy because it is Yom Tov, ושמחת בחגך, and
we shouldn't be happy for other reasons.] If something bad happens, I will be required to accept the sad
news with joy, as Chazal say, that one must bless Hashem with joy for bad tidings, and then I will have
another joy in addition to the joy of Yom Tov. We mustn't mix two joys. Therefore, I request Hashem that
my relative remain alive, so I will be able to focus my joy on the Yom Tov alone."
20 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
The Chozeh answered that Chazal (see hashgachah pratis, we will always be happy
Yerushalmi Bikurim 3:3) say that all one's aveiros with our lot.23
are forgiven on the day of his chasunah. The
chassan and kallah are concerned: They are Appropriate Joy
pure now, but how can they be sure they
will remain pure and clean from sin for the Shulchan Aruch (529:3) writes, "One should
rest of their lives? This is the reason we eat, drink, and be joyous on Yom Tov, but
dance before them. We are telling them, "If the focus should not be on the meat, wine,
you are happy, you will remain clean from laughter, and lightheadedness, as they are
sin. Your joy will protect you from falling not true joy. They are levity and foolishness.
into sin." This can be one of the reasons we We are not obligated to engage in silliness
have a mitzvah to be happy on Succos. It and foolishness, but rather in the joy of
helps us maintain our purity, which we serving Hashem."
attained on Yom Kippur, throughout the The Rambam (Hilchos Lulav 8:14) writes, "The
year. dancing at the simchas beis hashoeivah [in the
Beis HaMikdash] wasn't performed by amei
One counsel for attaining happiness (taught ha'aretz or by whoever wanted to dance.
by the Tzemach Tzedek of Lubavitch, zt’l) is to daven Only the gedolim, chachmei Yisrael, roshei
for it. This is what Dovid HaMelech did, as yeshivos, the heads of the Sanhedrin,
it states (Tehillim 86:4): שמח נפש עבדך, "Gladden chassidim, elders, and anshei ma'aseh were
Your servant's soul." worthy to dance there. They danced, clapped
their hands, played music, and were happy
Another counsel is to believe that in the Beis HaMikdash during Succos, and
everything that happens to you is from the rest of the nation, the men and the
Hashem and for your benefit. When one women, came to watch and listen."
believes this, he will be happy in any The Ritva (Bava Basra 121.) explains that the
situation. This might be the reason there is a average person wasn't permitted to dance
special mitzvah to be happy on Succos. and perform stunts. This was to ensure that
When we sit in Succah, we remember the joy remained holy and that it didn’t turn
Hashem, and we remember the miracles into הוללות, levity.
Hashem performed for us in the desert. As
it states (Vayikra 23:42-43), ...בסוכות תשבו שבעת ימים Sfas Emes zt'l suggests that this concept
למען ידעו דרתיכם כי בסוכות הושבתי את בני ישראל בהוציאי is hinted at in the word ' 'אךfrom the verse
אותם מארץ מצרים אני ה' אלקיכם, "You should dwell 'והיית אך שמח.’ ' 'אךis a term that expresses
i
in succahs for seven days… so you will know limitation. The Torah instructs us 'והיית אך
that I had Bnei Yisrael dwell in succahs 'שמח, to be exceedingly joyful, but with
when I took them from the land of Mitzrayim, limitations. Not all forms of happiness are
I am Hashem, your G-d." When we know beneficial. We should only seek the joy that
Hashem and His wonders and His will result in a connection with Hashem.24
23. Rebbe Hirsh Riminover zt'l said that the schach hints that Hashem watches over us with hashgachah
pratis. He watches over us through the cracks in the schach. Perhaps this is alluded to in the pasuk (Shir
HaShirim 2:9): מציץ מן החרכים,משגיח מן החלונות, "Observing through the windows, peering through the lattices." We
are constantly under Hashem's protection.
24. People sing ושמחת בחגיך והיית אך שמחwith a tune that repeats the word אךseveral times. Bederech tzachus,
Reb Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld zt'l said that this is based on the Chazal, אין מיעוט אחר מיעוט אלא לרבות, that
whenever there is more than one מיעוט, limitation, expressed in the Torah, it means that we should increase
rather than decrease. Therefore, we repeat the word אך, to increase our joy, and not to decrease it. This
reminds us to be extra happy on Yom Tov.
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 21
The Chidushei HaRim zt'l teaches that It states (Bereishis 25:8): ויגוע וימת אברהם בשיבה
we read Koheles on Succos to remind us that טובה זקן ושבע, "Avraham passed away at an
joy isn't the product of hevel havalim, or old age, old and satisfied." The Siforno
frivolity. True simchah is when it is connected translates ושבעas "He was satisfied with
to Hashem, to His Torah, and His mitzvos. everything he desired to see and to do in his
lifetime." This is a great and rare level.
Rabbeinu b'Chayei writes:
Luxuries
"This pasuk reveals Avraham's good
It states, וה' ברך את אברהם בכל, "Hashem middos. He left this world feeling fulfilled.
blessed Avraham with everything." The He didn't need more. This is unlike most
Midrash says that בכל, "everything," refers to people about whom it states (Koheles 5:9), אוהב
the mitzvah of succah. This means Hashem כסף לא ישבע כסף, 'One who desires money will
blessed Avraham with the mitzvah of succah, never have enough money.' And Chazal
which is בכל, "everything." How is this (Koheles Rabbah 1:32) say, 'When a person leaves
mitzvah everything? the world, he hasn’t attained half of what he
wanted. If he has one hundred, he wants
The Chozeh of Lublin (Avnei Zikaron 662) zt’l two hundred. If he has two hundred, he
explains that the succah reminds us of the wants four hundred.'" But Avraham was
vainness of luxuries. During Succos, we live satisfied and happy with his lot, and that is
in a temporary hut for seven days, and all is a wonderful and unique level. He attained
fine and well. We discover that luxuries are this level because he was blessed בכל, with
not as essential as we thought they were. everything, which means he was satisfied
And when we know this, we have everything. with his portion.
Even if we have fewer physical possessions,
we can be satisfied with our lot. Rebbe Yonason Eibshitz (Yaaras Dvash 6:1)
writes, "For the person who fears Hashem,
When we think we can't live without this idea doesn’t only apply to Succos.
luxuries, we are never satisfied. Whatever Throughout the year, he will remember that
we have, we need more. It is never enough. life is temporary and that he's a guest in this
We need a renovated kitchen and a new car. world. And, therefore, he shouldn't build
When we make a simchah, we need to copy expensive houses decorated with gems and
the wealthy, or it won't be good enough. We diamonds for his pleasure. This will cause
think that vacations must cost a lot of money, him to desire more money and to sin, and
or they aren't enjoyable. This results in he will become a baal gaavah and forget
financial debt, and then with hard work to Hashem Who created him. Remember
cover the expenses, which means less time Yonadav ben Rechav's precious, ethical will
for Torah and mitzvos, for things that truly (see Yirmiyahu 35:6). He instructed his children
matter. We are always unhappy because we not to live in houses, only in tents, one day
feel that we don't have enough, yet. Succah here and the next day somewhere else. Our
is בכל, "everything." We attain awareness forefathers, Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov
that we can have little, and yet have a lot in did that. They dwelt in tents, and they had
life. long lives.25 They didn’t have to worry about
Or, it can be explained this way: אךis a מיעוט, implying that we must know that even a tiny amount of joy
is already a great accomplishment.
Another approach is that אךis a limitation, which refers to when things aren't going well for a person. The
Torah instructs us, ;היית אך שמחeven then, one must be happy.
25. Reb Yonason Eibshitz also notes that the Mishkan, made from יריעות, skins, and woven cloth, wasn't a
22 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
fires burning down their castles. They didn’t tells us, "All Yidden can dwell in the same
live with the fear of enemies, hunger, or succah." This means there is unity among
plague. They could quickly undo the ropes them, and the unity comes from the mitzvah
of their tents and travel elsewhere. of succah. It is mesugal for annulling all
machlokes and for attaining unity among
"When Bilaam saw the Jewish nation Yidden.
dwelling in tents, he said, מה טובו אהליך יעקב,
'How good are your tents.' 'Tents', in this
This unity began on Yom Kippur. Sfas
pasuk, is intentional because we are a nation
Emes (Yom Kippur 7651) writes, "On Yom Kippur,
that dwells in tents… and that is good for us
Bnei Yisrael become united. We are always
in this world and the next. But when we
united in the realm of the soul, and it is sin
build houses of lime and stone, the stones
that divides us. On Yom Kippur, when our
will shout out all the sins of theft, pride,
aveiros are forgiven, we become one." This
temptation, and desire. This is the lesson of
oneness is experienced on Succos.
the mitzvah of succah…"
The Midrash (Vayikra Rabbah 30:12) teaches that
Unity the esrog, lulav, hadasim, and aravos represent
One of the segulos of succah and the four all Bnei Yisrael, from the tzaddikim (represented
by the esrog) to those who are at low spiritual
minim is that they are mesugal for אחדות,
that there be unity among Yidden, and that levels (represented by the aravos) and all Yidden in
there shouldn't be any machlokes. between. They are tied together. This means
the aravos (the lower Yidden) must be close to the
The Gemara (Succah 27) says, "All Yidden esrog (to the tzaddikim). Their connection with
can dwell in the same succah." There are the tzaddikim grants them atonement. The
halachic lessons that are learned from this tzaddikim also gain from their connection
phrase.26 Nevertheless, there is also a hinted with all Yidden, including those who are at
message. It tells us that Klal Yisrael will levels far beneath them. As the Beer Heitev
have the attribute of unity. Where there isn't (645:9) writes, " אתרוגis gematria 610. When
unity, or chalilah, if there is machlokes, combined with the other three species, the
people aren't able to sit under the same roof gematria is 613." Perfection is achieved when
or to eat at the same table. Yet, the Torah all four categories of Yidden unite.27
permanent structure. Yet, it lasted 480 years. The Beis HaMikdash that Shlomo HaMelech built was made
of stone and gold, and it stood for less time – 410 years. The second Beis HaMikdash lasted 420 years, and
during the 420 years, the Greeks ruled part of the time, and the Beis HaMikdash was destroyed several
times. So, we see that a דירת ארעי, a temporary dwelling, can last longer than permanent structures. Similarly,
he writes, the avos owned few luxuries, and therefore, they lived long.
26. The Gemara explains that "All Yidden can dwell in the same succah" teaches us that a succah isn’t
required to be לכם, owned by the person performing the mitzvah. The mitzvah can also be performed with
a borrowed succah.
27. A rasha said to Reb Meir of Premishlan zt'l, "The Rebbe is like an esrog, and I am like the aravos. Both
of us are needed. If someone buys the most precious esrog but doesn't have aravos, he cannot perform the
mitzvah. So, what makes you better than me? We both need each other, and we are both lacking when we
are alone!"
Rebbe Meir of Premishlan replied, "Certainly, we should unite together. That is ideal, and that is what we
do on Succos. However, when reshaim group together and distance themselves from the tzaddikim, this
is like a bunch of aravos on Hoshana Rabah; we hit and bang them until their souls depart…"
The Chofetz Chaim zt'l notes that the esrog, which represents the tzaddikim, isn’t tied together with the
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 23
The Mitzvos and their Meaning On its most basic level, the mitzvah of
succah is so that we will know and remember
The Meiri writes, "A person who eats the miracles Hashem performed for us when
matzah on Pesach and sits in a succah on He took us out of Mitzrayim and led us with
Succos is like a donkey that carries wheat His miracles and care for forty years in the
during the wheat harvest and grapes during desert. As it states (Vayikra 33:42-43), בסוכות תשבו
the grape harvest season…" In other words, כי בסוכות הושבתי את בני ישראל... למען ידעו...שבעת ימים
the "time" shouldn’t be the only reason we בהוציאי אותם מארץ מצרים, "For seven days you
perform the mitzvos. We should utilize our shall sit in the succah… so you will know that
minds and understand the reasons for the I had Bnei Yisrael sit in succos when I took
mitzvos, to the best of our abilities, and to them out of the land of Mitzrayim."
perform the mitzvos with heart and soul.
This is one of the few times the Torah
The Meiri says that those who keep the explicitly tells us the reason for a mitzvah.
mitzvos solely because the "time" arrived, Hashem obligates us to sit in a succah, למען
and they don't have any other thoughts, , ידעוso we will know that we sat in succos
about this it states (Tehillim 119): עת לעשות לה' הפרו when we left Mitzrayim. And since the
תורתיך עבדך אני הבינני, "A time to do for Hashem; Torah tells us the reason for the mitzvah, the
they have voided Your Torah." The Meiri Bach says we must think about the reason
explains: 'עת לעשות לד, when one keeps the when we perform the mitzvah. According to
mitzvos solely because the time has arrived the Bach, when sitting in the succah, one
for the mitzvah, הפרו תורתיך, he transgressed must think about yetzias Mitzrayim, the
the Torah, chalilah. עבדך אני, I am Your servant; miracles Hashem performed for us in the
therefore, הבנניteach me the reasons behind desert, and in particular, the miracle of the
the mitzvos so that I can perform them ענני הכבוד, clouds of glory that surrounded
correctly.28 and protected us in the desert.
other species. They are held together for the mitzvah, and then they part ways. This hints that although
tzaddikim should connect to others to elevate them, they should limit their interactions with people of
lower spiritual levels, so that they won't learn from their ways.
28. Reb Eliyahu Lopian zt'l related a story that happened in his hometown:
A gentile child was murdered, and false witnesses testified that a Yid killed the child to use his blood to
bake matzos.
The Yidden explained to the judge that these were false witnesses. The judge believed them, but even after
cross-examining the witnesses, the witnesses stuck to their narrative. Without proof that the witnesses were
lying, the lives of all Yidden in the area were in danger.
One wise Yid told the judge, "Nowadays, there is a new method to identify murderers. Modern courts use
trained bloodhounds. The dog smells the victim’s blood and can afterward determine who the murderer
was."
The judge agreed to use this test. The judge ordered all townspeople to gather in the town square. Everyone
came, and the Yidden were also there, Tehillims in their hands. The judge had the dog smell the blood-
stained clothing, and the dog immediately went to the murderer, who was present.
No one was surprised by the revelation because the murderer the dog went to was renowned for his
cruelty and dishonesty. This is how the Yidden of this town were saved from the blood libel.
Reb Eliyah Lopian concluded, "The dog didn't know it was saving the Jewish community. It only knew
how to smell the blood and go to the person with the same scent. However, when we perform mitzvos
(succah, lulav, etc.), we should know what we're doing."
24 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
Mishnah Berurah (625:1) writes, "When one that the success of Hoshana Rabba is
sits in the succah, he should think that this is dependent on the tefillos of Bnei Yisrael.31
to remind us of yetzias Mitzrayim and to
remember the ענני הכבוד, the clouds of glory, The Rokeach (Hilchos Succos, 221) writes that
in which Hashem surrounded us in the in the past, when beis din would determine
desert to protect us from the elements. One when rosh chodesh is, they were cautious
should think about these thoughts, and in that Hoshana Rabba should never fall on a
this manner, he will keep the mitzvah Shabbos. The Rokeach explains, כי היו בוכים
properly. However, b’dieved, one fulfilled the ומתחננים על המים לכך ולא יתכן בשבת, this is because
mitzvah even if he only had in mind that he they would cry and pray for rain. Therefore,
is performing Hashem’s mitzvah."29 this day can't be on Shabbos."
Chazal (Succah 3) say, ראשו ורובו ושולחנו בתוך When we think about this lesson from
הסוכה, one's head, most of his body, and his the Rokeach, we are astounded by the
table must be inside the succah. One cannot importance of tefillah on this day. Rosh
sit partially in the succah and mostly out of Hashanah can be on Shabbos, although we
the succah. Even his table must be in the aren't able to blow shofar. Yom Kippur can
succah. The Sfas Emes says this halachah also be on Shabbos, but Hoshana Rabba can't
means we must be totally immersed in the be on Shabbos because we need the tefillos
mitzvah. One shouldn't merely place his of Bnei Yisrael on this day.
physical body in the succah, while his head The Sifsei Tzaddik (Hoshana Rabba 32) writes,
and heart are elsewhere. Even his table quoting his grandfather, the Chiddushei
should be in the succah.30 HaRim zt'l, that the Torah gives a punishment
to the נערה המאורסהbecause (Devarim 22:24) ַעל ְּד ַבר
Hoshana Rabbah ֲקה ָב ִעיר ֶ א, " because she did not shout
ָ ֲשר לֹא ָצע
ׁ
[even though she was] in the city…" We see
Hoshana Rabba is called in Chazal יום that when a person can shout and pray, and
ערבה, the day of aravah, because the kohanim he doesn't do so, he is held responsible for
went around the mizbeiach with long aravos, what occurred. Therefore, we should shout
and they would place the aravos near the out to Hashem on Hoshana Rabba. If we
mizbeiach. don't, it is like we agree to the harsh decrees,
if they will occur. Furthermore, it seems that
The Zohar (vol.3, 32a) states, "The aravah if we shout out to Hashem, salvation will
looks like lips. It is certainly so, because this certainly come. Everyone should shout out
day is dependent on one's lips." This means to Hashem, even if he doesn't know what he
29. Yesod VeShoresh HaAvodah writes, "When a person learns about the greatness of this mitzvah of
succah and its great reward and about the seven exalted Ushpizin who visit him in the succah, he will yearn
with all his heart for this mitzvah… because the mitzvah of succah is very great."
30. The table represents the family. The head of the family should create a joyous atmosphere in the succah
so that his wife and children too should be delighted with the Yom Tov and its mitzvos.
31. The Sfas Emes ( )תר"נ ד"ה ליוםwrites, "It is called Hoshana Rabba, the great salvation, because even people
at low levels, and also the generations of low levels – people who can be compared to an aravah – which
doesn't have a taste or a smell, they can receive their salvation. What is their specialty [to receive salvation]?
It is because it states (Tehillim 116:6) יע
ַ ֹש ַּ "When I was poor, He saved me." This means that when
ִׁ ד ּלו ִֹתי ו ְִלי יְהו,
people know that they are poor [spiritually] and that they are in dire straits, that is when their salvation
comes. Therefore, Chazal say, 'Although I am poor, לי נאה להושיע, it is beautiful to save me.' This is because
the primary salvation goes to the poor. This is why Moshiach Tzidkeinu will come specifically to the low
generation."
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 25
needs and what he lacks. Nevertheless, he Hoshana means "save" and Rabba means
should shout out הושע נא, that Hashem should "great." What does Hoshana Rabba mean?
save him.32 The Divrei Chaim of Sanz zt'l said that
32. A group of yungerleit came to Reb Elyah Roth zt'l (from the tzaddikim of Yerushalayim, and the gabbai of Rebbe
Shlomke of Zvhil zt'l) on Hoshana Rabba night, and they asked him to tell them some words of chizuk. He
replied, "Now isn't the right time for such conversation. Quickly, grab a Tehillim, and begin davening. We
have to take full advantage of this time."
It is told about Reb Shlomo Zalman Aurbach zt'l (Halichos Shlomo, Succos, p.241) that "from the beginning of
Hoshana Rabba night, Rabbeinu was very afraid, as he was during the Yomim Noraim (Rosh Hashanah and
Yom Kippur). He spent most of the night of Hoshana Rabba saying Tehillim with hislahavus. Even when he
was old, he would get out of bed several times during the night to continue saying Tehillim. He also
encouraged his family members to say a lot of Tehillim on Hoshana Rabba. He didn't appreciate it when
people visited him on the night of Hoshana Rabba. If someone came, he would speak with him briefly,
and as soon as the conversation was over, he returned to his Tehillim. For many years, he davened Shacharis
כותקין.
In the tefillos of Hoshana Rabba we say אנא הושיעא נא. Then we say it more lengthily, אנא א"ל נא הושע נא והושיע נא,
and in the end, we say אנא א"ל נא הושע נא והושיעה נא אבינו אתה. The Divrei Shmuel explains this with a mashal:
A king banished his son from his palace, and with the passage of time, the prince's clothes tore and were
ruined. He was now dressed in dirty, ripped rags. He wanted to return to the king, but he was embarrassed
to tell the king that he was his son. How could he tell that to the king, appearing as he did? Therefore, he
came to the king and asked for tzedakah. The king gave him the amount he generally gave to people who
appeared that way. The king's son didn't accept this small amount. He asked for a larger donation. The
king wanted to give him more, but the son didn't accept that either. The king asked him, "Why don't you
accept what I give you?" The son replied, "I am related to the king, and therefore, I should receive what
is generally given to a relative of the king." The king gave a larger gift, something appropriate for a relative
of the king, but still the son refused to accept it. He explained that he is a very close relative of the king,
and he deserves more. He shouldn't get the amount that is given to a distant relative. Then the son couldn't
contain himself any longer, and he shouted from the depths of his heart, אבינו אתה, you are my father.
Similarly, when we begin davening, since we are dirty and in rags (metaphorically) due to our sins, we are
embarrassed to admit that we are the King's children. We begin asking for Hashem's salvation, and then
we ask for more, and then finally we shout the truth, – אנא א"ל נא הושע נא והושיעה נא אבינו אתהwe are Your children,
and therefore, please give to us as the King gives to His children.
The Kedushas Yom Tov zy'a said the following mashal:
A king banished his wayward son from his palace. The son came to a city and told them that he is the
king's son. However, they didn't treat him properly. They made him wear dirty clothes and caused him a
lot of tzaar.
One day, they heard that the king planned to visit their city. The people of the city were afraid. What
would happen to them when the king discovered how they had treated the king's son? They immediately
began to treat the king's son well, and they dressed him in beautiful clothes.
When the king saw his son and how kindly he was being treated, he figured that it would be beneficial
for his son to remain there. The people will train his son to act properly.
The son became very worried when he heard the king say this and took counsel from local wise people.
They advised him to dress in the clothes he usually wears, and he should tell the king that this is what he
wears all year long. He did that. The king was shocked to see his son in the dirty clothes. The son told the
king that the people were nice to him only recently, when they heard that the king was coming, but they
generally treat him cruelly, and they force him to wear these dirty clothes.
Hearing the truth, the king took his son back to the palace.
26 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
Hoshana Rabbah can be translated in three The people of a certain city committed a
ways, and they are all correct. (a) הושענא רבה grave offense against the king, and they
means "The great Hashem should save us." were all sentenced to death. They knew that
(b) הושענא רבהmeans Hashem should save the the king annually visited a garden in this
great Jewish nation.33 And (c) הושענא רבהmeans city. The elders of the city decided that they
that Hashem should save us with a great would go to the garden on that day and
salvation.34 meet with the king and plead for his mercy
and that he should forgive them.
Rebbe Dovid Moshe of Tchortkov zt'l
(whose yahrtzeit is on Hoshana Rabbah) said that
Hoshana Rabba means we will be saved The elders assembled in the garden, and
because we say "Amen yehei shmei rabbah".35 they waited for the king, but the king didn't
come! As the day was about to end, many of
There were tzaddikim who davened very the elders wanted to go home. They said
lengthily on Hoshana Rabba. One year, on their plan had failed. One wise elder said
Hoshana Rabba, which was on Friday, in the
that the king was certainly present, although
beis medresh of the Divrei Yoel of Satmar
they didn't see him. He said, "The king's
zt'l, the Satmar Rebbe told the gabbaim to
custom is to visit the garden today, so he
announce that the women should go home
to light Shabbos lecht. They shouldn't wait must be here. It is just that this time, he came
until the tefillah was over, because it was disguised, appearing like a common citizen.
almost Shabbos. Let's call out to the king and implore him to
save us. We will shout out to the king, whom
On that Hoshana Rabba, the Satmar we can't see, but we know he is present, and
Rebbe told the following mashal: he will surely hear us and forgive us."
The nimshal is that throughout the year, the body incites the neshamah to do aveiros. Then, when Elul
and the yomim noraim approach, the body is afraid of the King, and the body agrees to allow the person
to do teshuvah. The King is pleased, and he wants this situation to continue. We say to Hashem, "This isn't
how it generally is. We suffer immensely, and we are usually very distant from Hashem."
This is expressed on Hoshana Rabba. The rings that bind the lulav represent our connection with Hashem.
We take off those rings on Hoshana Rabba, and we show Hashem how we appear all year long, distant
from Hashem, and we ask Hashem to have compassion on us and to take us back to Him.
33. The Jewish people are called rabbah, great, as it states (Shemos 4:22) בני בכורי ישראל, "My firstborn son,
Yisrael." So, Yisrael is the firstborn, the greater and older son.
34. The Gemara (Shabbos 31a) tells us the questions that are presented to a person after his passing. One of
the questions that the beis din of heaven will ask him is, צפית לישועה, "Did you anticipate salvation?" Literally,
this means, did you wait for Moshiach? The Imrei Emes zt'l explains that צפית לישועהcan mean did you wait
and look forward to ?הושענא רבה
We should look forward to this day because Hashem bestows great salvation on Klal Yisrael on this day.
35. Chazal say, "Whoever answers Amen yehei shmei rabbah with all his might, his judgment is ripped up."
Reb Yochanan says, "Even if one has the sin of avodah zorah, he will be forgiven" (Shabbos 119).
During World War II, the Yidden of Yerushalayim made a kabbalah to improve how they say Amen yehei
shmei rabbah. They began saying it with all their might and with a lot of kavanah. When the Nazi general,
Rommel ym's, was in Mitzrayim, intending to bring his army to Eretz Yisrael, Rebbe Shlomke Zvhiler zt'l
told his gabai, "I sense that the resha'im won't be able to conquer Eretz Yisrael because the Yidden improved
how they recite Amen yehei shmei rabbah." And indeed, the Yidden of Eretz Yisrael were miraculously
spared.
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 27
The Satmar Rebbe cried, "We think the year is judged and determined on Succos
King is not here, but He is certainly present. and on Hoshana Rabba. The Levush writes,
If we cry out to Him, He will listen to our "Therefore, people light more candles in the
tefillos. Let's raise our voices together and beis midrash on Hoshana Rabbah, similar to
cry out, '"'!הושע נא והושיעה נא אבינו אתה Yom Kippur, because it is the final day of
judgment for rain." It was always known
The Awesome Judgment that Hoshana Rabbah was a day of judgment
for rain. In later generations, it became
Hoshana Rabba is a day of judgment. It known that it is also a day of judgment for
is the completion of the judgment of Rosh all areas of life.
Hashanah and of Yom Kippur.36 Shas and
poskim hardly mention the judgment of Reb Shlomo Zalman explains that in the
Hoshana Rabbah, and therefore, many past, rain meant life. If it didn’t rain, people
people aren't aware of it. Especially in the would die from thirst. Today, things have
past, it was concealed from most people. changed because water can be transported if
Those who studied kabbalah knew that needed. (The Chazon Ish ruled that we don't fast for rain
Hoshana Rabba was a day of judgment, but anymore because a lack of rain isn't as tragic as it used to be.)
the vast majority of people didn't know Therefore, years ago, it was sufficient for
about it. people to know that they were being judged
for rain, and this would arouse them to
Why was the judgment of Hoshana Rabba teshuvah, tefillah, and tzedakah. Today, that
unknown in the past? Reb Shlomo Zalman isn’t enough. Therefore, the sefarim revealed
Auerbach zt'l explains that in the past, more details of the awesome judgment of
people were very afraid on a day of judgment. this day. All matters and salvations are
If they knew that Hoshana Rabbah is a day judged and determined on this day.37
of judgment, it would ruin their simchas Yom
Tov, and they wouldn't be able to perform Shemini Atzeres
the mitzvah of ושמחת בחגיך. Therefore, it was
destined that people shouldn’t know about The Midrash says that after seven days of
the judgment, and it was only discussed in Succos, Hakadosh Baruch Hu says, קשה עלי
kabbalah sefarim. In later generations, the פרידתכם, "It is hard for Me when you leave,"
fear of judgment isn't as intense as it used to and Hashem asks us to stay one more day.
be, and therefore, more sefarim reveal to us The Imrei Emes writes that the feeling should
that a tremendous and awesome judgment be mutual. Bnei Yisroel should also feel that
transpires on Hoshana Rabbah. What will it is difficult to part from the Yomim Tovim.
occur this year is largely dependent on this
day. The Rema MiPano teaches that the literal
translation of חגis a circle. All Yomim Tovim
Reb Shlomo Zalman adds that there was are a chag, a circle, surrounding a primary,
one aspect of judgment on Hoshana Rabba focal point. The focal point, he said, is
that was known to the earlier doros. The Shemini Atzeres. This is the reason, according
Mishnah states, בחג נידונים על המים, "Succos we to some opinions and siddurim, Shemini
are judged for rain." The amount of rain this Atzeres isn't referred to as a ( חגsee Shulchan
36. The Chasam Sofer zt'l said in the last year of his life, "I passed the judgment of Rosh Hashanah and
Yom Kippur. But I didn't pass the judgment of Hoshana Rabbah."
37. Two yungerleit were chatting on Hoshana Rabbah night in the beis medresh of Reb Avraham Elimelech
of Karlin zt'l. The Rebbe rebuked them, "I am certain you have something very important to discuss
because otherwise you wouldn't discuss it tonight. However, you would have been better off discussing
this matter during Kol Nidrei than speaking on this holy night."
28 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
Aruch 668).
All Yomim Tovim are a חג, The Zohar states, "On Hoshana Rabbah,
surrounding this special day, which stands the judgment is completed, and the blessings
in the middle.38 begin. On the following day (Shemini Atzeres),
the Jewish nation celebrates with the King
It states in Mishlei עוז והדר לבושה ותשחק ליום
and receives blessings for the entire year. It
אחרון. The Vilna Gaon zt’l explains: עוזis Rosh
is only the Jewish nation that is present at
Hashanah because Hashem judges us with
that celebration. And when one sits alone
His might. והדרis Succos, the day we take a
with the king, whatever he asks will be
פרי עץ הדר. And then comes Shemini Atzeres,
granted."
ותשחק ליום אחרון, the day of immense happiness.
The Gemara (Taanis 7) discusses גדול יום הגשמים Reb Chaim Palagi zt’l teaches, "Be
"How great is the day it rains!" The Avodas extremely careful with the tefillos of Shemini
Yisrael zt’l says that the Gemara is referring Atzeres to say them with immense kavanah…
to the greatness of Shemini Atzeres, the day There is no better day and greater eis ratzon
we daven for rain. (We say )תפילת גשם. than this day, when Hashem desires to hear
our tefillos…. Everything depends on this
The Chasam Sofer zy'a teaches that day."
Shemini Atzeres is greater than Yom Kippur.
Yom Kippur, we love Hashem through The Kotzker zt'l said that on Shemini
afflictions (fasting, etc.). Shemini Atzeres is to Atzeres is the gzar din (the decree) for parnassah.
love Hashem through joy, which is a greater His son, Rebbe Dovid zt'l, used to daven
connection, as it states (Shir HaShirim 7:7) מה יפית b'yichidus (by himself). One year, on Shemini
ומה נעמת אהבה בתענוגים, "How beautiful it is Atzeres, the Kotzker called for his son and
when the love to Hashem is with pleasure told him that on Shemini Atzeres, it is
and joy." important to daven with a minyan because,
on this day, it is decreed how much parnassah
The Chinuch (324) writes that we don't one will receive in the coming year. This is
take the four minim on Shemini Atzeres hinted at in the words והיית אך שמח. The final
because the four minim are to remind us to letters of והיית אך שמחspell חת"ך, the name of
direct the joy we have in our hearts at this the malach appointed over parnassah.
time of year (from gathering in the crops) to Hashem. Chazal tell us that the words והיית אך שמחrefer
On Shemini Atzeres, we don't need any to Shemini Atzeres.
reminders to direct our love to Hashem
because 'יום השמיני כולו לה, "The eighth day is Reb Aharon Chernobyler zt’l said that
solely for Hashem." It is a day we are entirely benching גשםon Shemini Atzeres (said with
with Hashem, and our love and joy are fully Mussaf) is mesugal for parnassah.
with Him.
The Rayatz of Lubavitz zt'l said in the
The Yesod Yosef writes, "The custom is name of his father, the Rebbe Reshab zt'l,
to take all the sifrei Torah out of the aron "We must cherish the forty-eight hours of
kodesh… Because when a father loves his Shemini Atzeres and Simchas Torah. Every
son, he opens all his treasuries for him and moment of these days, we can fill buckets
doesn't withhold anything. Similarly, with ruchniyus and gashmiyus. We receive
Hashem bestows upon us immense this bounty because of the dancing. (Sefer
goodness." Maamarim 5711, p.79).39
38. At a chasunah, there is a chuppah, dancing, and a meal, but the purpose of it all is for the chasan and
kallah to go home and to build a home together. The Sfas Emes says that the yomim tovim represent
various stages of a chasunah. For example, the schach on the succah resembles the chuppah. After the
chuppah is the yichud, which is an even greater unity – that occurs on Shemini Atzeres.
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 29
Simchas Torah and sang with all his strength. Then, on
motzei Yom Tov, he went to several batei
Yesod VeShoresh HaOvadah (ch.16) writes, midrashim to dance with the Torah (called in
"Whoever is happy with the Torah on this Eretz Yisrael )הקפה שניות, and this lasted many
day, he is guaranteed that his children and hours."
descendants will always be Torah scholars."
Shlamei Chagigah (p.292: printed year )תק"נ Maaseh Rav states that the Vilna Gaon
writes, "Fortunate is the person who rejoices zt'l "would go before the sefer Torah with
with the Torah on Simchas Torah, for this immense joy, his face was like a burning
will rectify his soul for the times that he fire, and he would clap and dance with all
disgraced the Torah. Additionally, there's a his might before the Torah."
guarantee from early scholars that whoever
is happy with the Torah on this day will The Satmar Rebbe zt'l danced with all his
have offspring who will always study the strength on Simchas Torah, although he was
Torah. There was a Rav who was very happy weak. When people asked him about this,
on Simchas Torah, and his descendants were he said, "Chazal (Succah 48.) say, שמיני עצרת רגל
renowned scholars for three consecutive 40
בפני עצמה היא." On Shemini Atzeres, everyone
generations. Everyone knew it was because receives another ( רגלfoot) to help him dance.
of his happiness with the Torah on Simchas
Torah. He rejoiced and danced with the
Torah in a way that wasn't done by other Dancing with the Torah on Simchas Torah
rabbanim and gedolei Yisrael. Despite his is mesugal for bearing children. The Yismach
prestigious Rabbinic position, he would Yisrael zt'l learns this from Michal, who was
jump and dance before the Torah and upset with her husband Dovid Hamelech
encourage others to do the same." In this when she saw him dance with all his might
merit, he merited children and grandchildren, before the aron hakodesh (see Shmuel 2, 16:23).
exceptional talmidei chachamim. She was punished that she couldn't bear a
child. We understand from this that when
The Shaar HaKavanos writes, "My teacher one does the opposite and is happy with the
(the Arizal) went around the bimah... danced Torah, he will be rewarded with children.41
39. The Rayatz zt'l of Lubavitz said that during the hakafos, we can ask for great things, and our tefillos
will be answered. When we dance with the Torah, we are demonstrating our love for Hashem and His
Torah, as we say in the Hoshanos, חבוקה ודבוקה בך, "hugging and connected with You". On Succos, one person
holds the sefer Torah, and the congregation, holding the four minim, circles the sefer Torah and the bimah.
On Simchas Torah, we show a higher level of connection to Hashem because people hug the Sefer Torah
and dance with it around the bimah.
When a storeowner trusts his customer to take merchandise and pay later, this is called הקפה. The Rayatz
explains how this alludes to the הקפותof Simchas Torah. He explained that a storekeeper will only extend
credit to customers he trusts and who are able to pay up. If he suspects a customer won't pay, he won't
sell to him on credit. The dancing on Simchas Torah is called הקפותbecause, on Simchas Torah, Hashem
gives us salvation and many brachos on account of our future good deeds. On this day, Hashem trusts us
that we will pay up our debts, so he gives us on loan. [It seems that this is because Simchas Torah is after
the Yomim Noraim, and every Yid was inspired to do teshuvah. We have repaired our credit, and Hashem
gives us salvations and brachos, on account of our good deeds to come throughout the coming year.]
40. Literally, this means Shemini Atzeres is its own holiday, and not a continuation and final day of Succos.
41. It is brought down in Shivchei HaBaal Shem that one Simchas Torah, the students of the Baal Shem
Tov zy'a were dancing joyously, and one of the poorer students left the holy dancing and sat on the side,
disappointed. He couldn't continue dancing because his shoe had ripped. Udel, the Baal Shem Tov's
30 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
The Importance of Shalom on Simchas us of the importance of maintaining peace
Torah on this Yom Tov.
The Heilige Ruzhiner zt'l (Irin Kadishin, The Gemara (Shabbos 31a) tells that someone
Shemini Atzeres) says that very often, disputes came to Hillel and asked that he convert
and machlokes break out on the Yom Tov him while he stands על רגל אחת, on one foot.
Shemini Atzeres – Simchas Torah. One can Hillel told him, "What you hate being done
check this and he will see that this occurs in to you, don't do to others." The holy Ruzhiner
all places. The yetzer hara is certainly explains that רגל אחתalludes to Shemini
investing effort to incite machlokes on this Atzeres, which is called רגל בפני עצמו, its own
day, and that is an indication of the holiday. Therefore, we understand that the
importance of maintaining peace on this ger tzedek asked Hillel to teach him the
day. secret of Shemini Atzeres. Hillel told him to
be cautious with hatred and machlokes.
This is based on the principle that we can "What you hate being done to you, don't do
learn from the yetzer hara what is important. so to others." That encompasses the secret of
If the yetzer hara places effort to get us into Shemini Atzeres – Simchas Torah. It is a
a machlokes on this holy Yom Tov, this tells Yom Tov of peace.
daughter, noticed what happened and told the student, "If you will guarantee me that I will bear a son
this year, I will get you a pair of new shoes." (She had shoes in her store.) The student gave his word. She
immediately brought him the shoes. That year, she gave birth to the great tzaddik, Rebbe Boruch'l of
Mezhibuzh.
A member of our chaburah didn't have children. One Simchas Torah, he danced with all his might with the
Torah, and nine months later, he had his first child. The following Simchas Torah, he did the same, and
once again, nine months later, he had his second child. He had a friend who also didn't have children.
When he heard that his friend had two children in the merit of dancing with the Torah, he wanted to do
the same. However, he was embarrassed to dance with all his might in the beis medresh where he usually
davens, so he went to an old-age home where no one recognized him, and he danced enthusiastically and
honored the Torah immensely. Nine months later, his first child was born.
Rebbe Yehoshua of Belz zt'l said in his father’s name, Rebbe Shalom of Belz zt'l, "I can't tell you what the
hakafos are about. But I can tell you this: All tefillos that didn't go up the entire year, go up during the
hakafos." This is hinted in the words (see Succah 48a) פז"ר קש"בwhich can mean פז"ר, the tefillos that were
scattered and didn't go up; קש"ב, on Shemini Atzeres, Hashem listens to those tefillos.
The Minchas Elazar zt'l (Shaar Yissaschar, Zman Simchoseinu 17) writes that the Baal Shem Tov zt'l said, quoting
Eliyahu HaNavi, that whoever davens with kavanah on Hoshanah Rabba, Shemini Atzeres, and Simchas
Torah, he will merit to have kavanah the entire year.
The Beis Aharon zt'l (Pesach p.94.) writes, "Dancing on Yom Tov is the highest form of tefillah… for it is a
prayer with כל עצמותי, all one's limbs."
The Ateres Yehoshua ( )ד"ה במאמרםexplains the Mishnah (Negaim 12:1) בית עגול אינו מטמא בנגעים, that due to the עגולים,
our dancing in a circle on Simchas Torah, אינו מטמא בנגעים, all plagues and troubles go away.
The Chida teaches that by dancing on Simchas Torah, we knock down the iron walls that separate us from
Hashem.
On Simchas Torah, we read the Parasha of וזאת הברכה, the brachos Moshe Rabbeinu gave Bnei Yisrael. As
we read them, we receive those brachos again. Rebbe Henoch of Alexander zt'l said this is why birchas
kohanim isn’t performed on Simchas Torah. We are receiving Moshe Rabbeinu's brachos, so we don't need
any other brachos.
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 31
Therefore, during the hakafos, one has to months of the year. The righteous stay home
be extra cautious to honor everyone, and not during these twelve days, and they review
to chas v'shalom cause distress to anyone. what they studied. This is a great segulah to
The reward of the hakafos could be lost due receive Hashem's siyata dishmaya every day
to this severe aveirah.42 of the year – from the beginning of the year
until the end. He will succeed with everything
After Simchas Torah he does, whether in Torah, chassidus, or
business."
Reb Chaim Palagi (Sefer Chaim siman 36) writes,
"It's the custom of chassidim to be cautious In the Yom Tov tefillah we say, 'והנחילנו ה
with their thoughts, speech, and deeds מועדי קדשיך...אלקינו, "Hashem gave us as an
during the twelve days [following Simchas inheritance…the holy Yomim Tovim…" An
Torah], for they correspond to the twelve inheritance, the Sfas Emes said, is something
42. Someone asked the Chofetz Chaim zt'l for the deep meaning and purpose of the hakafos. He replied,
"When you are dancing with the talis over your head, be careful not to step on another person's foot. You
won't even know whose foot you step on to ask him for forgiveness. This is the סוד ההקפות, the deep secret
of the hakafos."
One year, on Simchas Torah, Russian soldiers arrived in Zvhil. Among them were many Jewish soldiers,
and they needed food and drink. Rebbe Shlomke of Zvhil said to the chasid Reb Yosel Koz'lik zt'l, "Take
this sack and go around to the Jewish homes, and collect food for the Jewish soldiers." Reb Yosel agreed,
saying that he would do so immediately after the hakafos.
Rebbe Shlomke replied, "The Torah will rejoice even if you aren't here, but the soldiers are hungry now!"
Reb Yosel followed his rebbe's orders, and he immediately went door-to-door to gather food for the soldiers.
Rebbe Shlomke's face lit up when Reb Yosel returned with the sack filled with food. Rebbe Shlomke took
the sack on his shoulders and danced hakafos around the bimah with it. This expressed his deep love and
care for his fellow man.
One time, after the hakafos were finished in the beis medresh of the Maharil Diskin zt'l, the Maharil Diskin
requested that they conduct another seven hakafos. Everyone was surprised; nothing like this had ever
occurred before. They already did seven hakafos; why should they do another set of seven hakafos?
The Maharil Diskin told his son that there was a talmid chacham in the beis medresh whom they had
forgotten to honor with a hakafah. Therefore, the Maharil Diskin repeated the seven hakafos, and during
the second set of hakafos, he honored this talmid chacham properly. This was a clever solution. Sometimes,
asking forgiveness for not honoring someone only makes matters worse. Without any apologies, he
conducted seven more hakafos and thereby was able to honor the talmid chacham.
Imrei Pinchas (Shaar 4:4) tells: One year, before the hakafos of Simchas Torah, Rebbe Pinchas Koritzer zt'l
told his student, Rebbe Refael of Bershad zt'l, "Until now, we did hakafos with weapons in our hands.
These were the four minim (because on Succos, we circled the bimah with the four minim). The Zohar calls the four
minim weapons. But now we're doing hakafos empty-handed. Although we will be carrying the holy sefer
Torah, it isn't a mitzvah to hold Sifrei Torah, as it was a mitzvah to hold the four minim. Tell me, Refael.
How does it look to perform hakafos empty-handed? How can we do hakafos in this manner? The answer
is that a person should become holy like the four minim. His heart should become like the esrog, his spine
like the lulav, his eyes like the hadasim, his lips like the aravos, and then he can take the sefer Torah and
dance with it."
Rebbe Refael of Barshid cried when he heard this because he felt that he wasn't on this level. Rebbe Pinchas
Koritzer calmed him, "Don’t cry, Refael. I will carry you on my shoulders."
In other words, in Reb Pinchas Koritzer's merit, his student Reb Refael can dance with the Sefer Torah,
and it will be like the four minim are holding the Sefer Torah.
32 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
that remains forever. It isn't something that The Gemara (Gittin 56) defines a בריה קלהas
leaves after a few days. So too, the holidays "an insect that eats but does not produce
should always stay with us, even after the waste". קלהmeans to take in and not give
Yom Tov is over.43 out. The Gemara (Avodah Zorah 3) refers to succah
as a מצוה קלה, a light and easy mitzvah. Reb
There's a tefillah one recites when he Avraham Yehoshua Freund of Nasod zy'a
gezegens (takes leave) from the succah (on Shemini hy'd explained that succah is called מצוה קלה
Atzeres, or in Eretz Yisroel, on Hoshana Rabba). It is because one should take in the light and
printed in many siddurim and machzorim. holiness of the succah and never let it leave
In this prayer, we say, "It shall be Your will him.
that the malachim associated with the succah
and the four minim should come with us The two words בסוכות תשבוare opposites,
into our homes..." We don't leave the mitzvos because סוכותis a temporary dwelling and
behind. We take the blessings and spirituality תשבוmeans to live permanently. Chazal (Succah
28:) answer that this ( הקשjuxtaposition of two ideas)
we gained from these mitzvos to our homes,
and we keep them for the entire year. teaches us, בסוכות, to live in the succah, תשבו,
in a permanent manner. The Gemara
The piyut of Shemini Atzeres ()מערבית לשמ"ע explains, "If he has beautiful vessels or
states, פונים מסוכה לביתם לישב צקון לחשם הקשב, "To beautiful sheets, he should bring them into
those who leave the succah to return to their the succah. He should eat and drink and
homes, listen to their prayers." spend time in the succah…" He should live
in his temporary abode ()בסוכות, in a permanent
The Shinover Rav zt'l asks: Wouldn't it manner ()תשבו.
be more appropriate for the piyut to write, There is a concept called אין הקש למחצה.
"Listen to the tefillos of those who dwelled in This means that when two ideas are
a succah"? Why do we pray that Hashem juxtaposed in the Torah, the drashah should
listen to the tefillos of those who leave the be studied both ways. Therefore, the Satmar
succah? Rebbe zt'l says, the words בסוכות תשבוalso tell
us that we should live in our permanent
The Shinover Rav zt'l answers that we homes with the uplifted spiritual feelings
ask Hashem to listen to the prayers of those and thoughts that we had when we sat in
who take the lessons and kedushah of the the succah. תשבו, live in your homes, בסוכות,
succah with them, and they stay with these as you lived in the succah.
lessons the entire year. The Yom Tov is over,
people leave the succah, but there are those It states (Tehillim 60:8) ועמק סוכות אמדד. The
fortunate ones who remain with the word אמדדmeans measure. Rebbe Yissachar
kedushah and with the messages of succah. Dov of Belz zt'l says that סוכות אמדדrefers to
They bring it with them into their homes the the measurements of a succah, which equal
entire year. 360 tefachim (as we will explain). 360 is also
43. A chassid of the Beis Aharon of Karlin zt'l returned home after spending a Yom Tov with his Rebbe.
People asked him, ווי אזוי איז אריבער די יום טוב, "How did the Yom Tov pass?"
The chassid replied, די יו"ט איז אריין,די יו"ט איז נישט אריבער, "The Yom Tov didn’t pass, it entered." The Yom Tov
became part of him.
Once, after Yom Tov, Rebbe Dovid of Tolna zy'a asked one of his chassidim how he planned to get home.
The chassid replied, "The goy that drove me here will take me back."
The Rebbe said, "You're returning with the same goy?" We shouldn't go back after Yom Tov being "the
same goy" that arrived. The Yom Tov should change us; we should become new people.
Torah Wellsprings - Succos 33
approximately the number of days in a solar these days, we have atonement for all our
year. Therefore, ועמק סוכות אמדדtells us that aveiros, and therefore, these days don't need
the measurements of the succah spread to receive the kedushah from the succah.
holiness to the entire year. Each day of the
year receives sanctity from the mitzvah of These ideas are alluded to in the pasuk
succah. we mentioned. It states אלקים דיבר בקדשו אעלוזה
אחלקה שכם ועמק סוכות אמדד. Rebbe Yissacher
How does a succah have 360 tefachim? Dov of Belz zt'l translates it to mean, אלקים
Also, why does the succah hint at 360 days דיבר בקדשו, Hashem says, 'אעלוז ה, I rejoice with
and not a full year of 365 days? the five days from Yom Kippur until Succos.
Let us first answer the first question. How 'אחלק ה, and I divide these five days שכ"ם,
do we know that a succah is 360 tefachim? from the 360 days of the year. ( שכ"םis gematria
We are calculating the height of the tallest 360.) They are not calculated like the rest of
succah, which is twenty amos high. Each the year, because on these days we are clean
amah is six tefachim, so 20 x 6 = 120. A from all aveiros. עמק סוכות אמדד, I measure the
succah needs three walls, so the equation is measurements of the succah, and they are
20 x 6 x 3 = 360 tefachim, indicating that the 360, indicating that from the succah comes
succah brings kedushah to the 360 days of holiness for the entire year.
the year.
Rebbe Yissacher Dov's son, Rebbe Aharon
Five days are missing from this number of Belz zt'l, added that this is the intention
because five days a year can exist without of the pasuk (Tehillim 39:6), הנה טפחות נתתה ימי, the
the kedushah of succah. These are the five days of the year receive their spirituality
days between Yom Kippur and Succos. On from טפחות, the tefachim of the succah.44
44. The Dubno Magid related the following mashal:
A king had an only daughter, whom he loved immensely. When the time came for the king's daughter to
get married, a matchmaker told the king, "I have a perfect match for your daughter. He lives far away, but
he is a wealthy prince, and his father is a great king. The prince possesses all the qualities one could desire."
The king agreed to the match, and his daughter got married. Not long after the wedding, the groom told
his new wife that he very much wanted to go live in his homeland. His wife didn't want to move so far
away from her father, but when she saw how much it meant to her husband, she consented.
Upon arriving in the foreign land, she discovered that the matchmaker had deceived them. Her husband
was not a king's son. He wasn't wealthy, either. It was all a charade.
To make matters worse, her husband was cruel to her. He didn't conduct himself like a prince who was
raised with good manners. He behaved like the crudest, most unrefined people.
One day, they received a letter from the king. The king wrote, "I miss you very much, and since you aren't
visiting me, I decided to undertake the long journey and visit you." The king wrote the date he expected
to arrive.
The husband knew that he had better make some major changes so that the king, his father-in-law doesn't
discover the truth. He hired a crew of workers to clean and decorate his house to make it appear like the
home of a prince. He also began treating his wife well, so the king wouldn't suspect anything was the
matter between them.
The king arrived and was very happy with what he saw. He felt that he had selected the perfect husband
for his daughter.
As the king prepared to return to his palace, his daughter realized that this was her last chance to reveal
the truth to her father. At a private moment, with tears streaming down her face, she told her father that
34 Torah Wellsprings - Succos
her husband was not a king's son and that he treated her cruelly.
The Dubno Magid explains that when Rosh Chodesh Elul arrives, keviyachol, it is like Hashem announces
that He will visit us during the days of judgment. Throughout Elul, people are busy cleaning up their
deeds, so the King shouldn't realize anything is amiss. The body makes peace with the neshamah, to conceal
from the King what is really going on throughout the year.
But when we reach Ne'ilah, and the King is about to leave, the Yid cries out to Hashem and says, "I suffer
so much from my body. When You visit, the body acts nicely to me, but now that You're about to leave,
I must tell You that the body is cruel to me and tries to draw me to sin…"
The Dubno Magid's mashal and nimshal end here, but some add in one more line:
In the mashal, when the king's daughter complained that her husband isn't nice to her, the king told his
daughter, "I have a solution for you. I will live in this city, close to you. With me nearby, your husband
will always treat you well."
Also, in the nimshal, Hashem answers, "Build a succah, and I will live together with you. In my presence,
the body won't disturb you."
Even after Yom Tov passes, you can take the atmosphere of the yom tov back with you into your homes,
and Hashem will remain with you. In Hashem's presence, the body will not prevent you from serving
Hashem.
