Alei Deshe — Sukkos (2026-09-21)

Volume
268 Sukkos 5787
לעילוי נשמת
מרת עקא עדנה
צפורה ע”ה וסרטל
בת משה מנחם הלוי ז”ל
The Exemption of a Slave The Sukkah of Dovid
The Mishnah at the beginning of the second which women are exempt, such as wearing On Sukkos, when reciting Birchas Hamazon, we
perek of Sukkah (20b) relates an incident tefillin and reciting Kerias Shema. Since it add the request: הרחמן הוא יקים לנו את סוכת דוד
involving Tevi, Rabban Gamliel’s slave. The is well known that women are exempt from —הנופלתMay the Compassionate One erect for us
Chachamim gathered in Rabban Gamliel’s sukkah, every slave should have known that the fallen sukkah of Dovid.
sukkah, while Tevi slept beneath the bed. he is exempt as well. The phrase the fallen sukkah of Dovid is based on
Rabban Gamliel said to them: Did you see We can offer the following lomdisheh answer: the pasuk:ָאקים אֶ ת סֻ ַּכת ָּדוִ יד הַ ּנֹ פֶ לֶת ִ ּבַ ּיוֹם הַ הּוא
my slave Tevi? He is a talmid chacham, and Although women and slaves are generally יתיהָ ּכִ ימֵ י
ִ ִָאקים ּובְ נ
ִ וְ ג ַָד ְר ִּתי אֶ ת ּפִ ְרצֵ יהֶ ן וַ הֲ ִרס ָֹתיו
he knows that a slave is exempt from the exempt from time-bound mitzvos, the —ע ֹולָםOn that day I will raise up the fallen sukkah
mitzvah of sukkah; that is why he sleeps Gemara (Sukkah 28a) still requires a specific of Dovid, repair its breaches, restore its ruins, and
under the bed. source to exempt women from sukkah. This rebuild it as in days of old (Amos 9:11).
From Rabban Gamliel’s statement, the is learned from the extra letter hei in the The Targum translates סוכת דודas מלכותא דבית
word —האזרחthe native, which limits the דוד. Accordingly, this Harachaman is a tefillah
To serve Hashem obligation and excludes women. for the restoration of the monarchy of Dovid
The Gemara gives two reasons why the Hamelech’s descendants.
properly, we cannot general exemption of women from time- Malchus Beis Dovid is central to the geulah.
simply copy others. bound mitzvos is insufficient here. Abaye Describing the future redemption, the pasuk
says: ֹלקיהֶ ם וְ אֵ ת ֵ ֱַאחַ ר יָׁשֻ בּו ּבְ נֵי ִי ְׂש ָראֵ ל ּובִ ְקׁשּו את ד’ א
explains that we might have thought the
We must reflect on pasuk תשבו, which implies —כעין תדורו —ּדוִ יד מַ לְ ָּכםAfterward
ָ Bnei Yisrael will return
and seek Hashem their G-d and Dovid their king
why they act that way dwelling as one normally lives, teaches that
just as ordinary dwelling involves a man (Hoshea 3:5).
and then consider and his wife, the mitzvah of sukkah should Why is seeking Dovid mentioned together
include both men and women. Rava explains with seeking Hashem? We await Moshiach and
whether their conduct that we might have learned from the the day when the entire nation will be united
is appropriate for us. gezeirah shaveh of ’טו’ טוfrom Pesach that under a righteous king. We know that Hashem
promised Melech Hamoshiach will descend
just as women are obligated to eat matzah,
so too they should be obligated in sukkah. from Dovid. But why should it matter to us
The Mishnah L’melech1 writes that slaves whom Hashem chooses as the future king?
Chachamim learned that one does not
are exempt from time-bound mitzvos just The Baal Shem Tov4 explains that every king is
fulfill the mitzvah of sukkah while under a
as women are. However, when women are concerned with his own honor and the honor
bed. However, his words seem to imply that
exempt because of a specific gezeiras hakasuv, of his dynasty. What makes malchus Beis Dovid
there was a chiddush in a slave’s exemption
that exemption does not automatically unique is that its concern is for the honor of the
from sukkah, and that Tevi’s awareness of
apply to slaves. King of Kings, Hakadosh Baruch Hu.
this showed his knowledge of halachah.
This explains why women’s exemption from Rav Chaim Vital5 explains Dovid Hamelech’s
Why is this a chiddush? Every slave knows
sukkah did not make it obvious that slaves words: את פניך ד’ אבקש,לך אמר לבי בקשו פני.
that he is exempt from mitzvos from
are exempt as well. Still, this approach 4 Degel Machanh Ephraim, Voe’schanan.
Bsh”t al haTorah, Lech Lecha 31.
1 Hilchos Melachim 10:7. 5 Eitz Hadaas Tov.
Cont. on page 2 Cont. on page 3
1
The Exemption of a Slave
Cont. from page 1
would require assuming that other slaves knew imitate others without considering why those nature remains enslaved to his passions, with
the Mishnah L’melech’s principle, while only people act as they do, or whether they themselves his actions guided by self-interest.
Tevi understood why it did not obligate slaves should do the same. To serve Hashem properly, The deeper meaning of living in a sukkah is to
in sukkah. we cannot simply copy others. We must reflect abandon self-centered pursuits and enter a life
The sefer Berachah Mishuleshes2 raises this on why they act that way and then consider centered on closeness to Hashem. This idea is
question and answers that although women whether their conduct is appropriate for us. expressed in Chazal’s metaphor (Sukkah 28b) of a
are exempt, they commonly ate in the sukkah This is part of the avodah of Sukkos. The pasuk servant who comes to pour wine for his master.
together with the men. Most slaves, seeing says: —למען ידעו דורותיכםso that your generations One who is enslaved to self-centeredness cannot
women eat there, assumed that women were will know. The Bach3 maintains that one must attain closeness to Hashem. To truly fulfill the
obligated and that they themselves were as have kavanah for the lesson of the sukkah in mitzvah of sukkah, we must first rise above
well. Tevi was a talmid chacham because he order to fulfill the mitzvah. This teaches that a our natural enslavement to our interests and
understood that women ate in the sukkah only person should not merely act, but should think passions.
to join the men, not because they were obligated; about why he is acting. שבת חוה”מ סוכות תשפ”ו מאמר א
therefore, his own exemption remained clear. There is also a deeper message in the halachah
There is a lesson here as well. Simple people that slaves are exempt from sukkah. A person
often do not analyze what they see; they merely who does not think, strive, and overcome his
2 Sukkah 2:1.
3 Siman 625.
Yericho
The Hoshanos of Shabbos mention the virtues Why is Yericho’s downfall on Shabbos counted as that the timing was not coincidental; Hashem
of Shabbos and praise those who prepare for a praise of Shabbos? On the contrary, the battle intended Yericho to be conquered on Shabbos.
it, honor it, and carefully observe its many involved acts that would normally desecrate The explanation is that Yericho was the key
halachos. Shabbos. Although halachah permits such acts to conquering Eretz Yisrael, and its conquest
The Hoshanah of Kihoshatah Adam includes the for a required war, how does a victory achieved therefore required the power of Shabbos. The
following phrase: ,כהושעת פקדו יריחו שבע להקף on Shabbos demonstrate Shabbos’s greatness? kedushah of Shabbos gave Klal Yisrael the
כן הושע נא.—צרו עד רדתה בשבת לתקףAs You When we examine the pesukim in Sefer strength to take possession of the holy land. We
saved those commanded at Yericho to encircle it Yehoshua (6:3–15), we find that Yehoshua was can now understand why Yericho’s conquest on
seven times; they besieged it until its downfall on commanded to bring about Yericho’s downfall Shabbos expresses the greatness of Shabbos.
Shabbos, to strengthen them; so save us now. specifically on Shabbos. The Midrash6 indicates שלום זכר שבת חוה”מ סוכות תשפ”ו
6 Bereishis Rabbah 47:10, Bamidbar Rabbah 23:6, Tanchuma, Masai 5.
Mechitzos Nikaros
The Gemara in Sukkah (4b) records Abaye and the shelter of the Shechinah, but on Sukkos we own home. He must instill in his family a love
Rava’s dispute about a sukkah built on a platform create a space upon which the Shem Shamayim for ruchniyus and make his home a protected
ten tefachim high, with no visible walls above its rests and live within it, so this truth can enter space infused with warmth for kedushah and
surface. Abaye rules that it is kosher because of our minds and hearts. This is why Rava requires avodas Hashem.
gud asik mechitztah: since the platform’s sides mechitzos hanikaros: the walls themselves must The walls of a home are meant to be mechitzos
have the status of mechitzos, we view them as make the message of the sukkah visible and felt. hanikaros, protecting those inside from the
extending upward. Rava disagrees, holding that The Gemara later discusses whether gud asik winds and storms outside. Such mechitzos can
a sukkah requires mechitzos hanikaros—visible mechitztah applies to a sukkah built on the extend upward, enclosing a person within the
partitions—and therefore gud asik mechitztah roof of a house. The Rishonim explain that shelter of the sukkah.
alone cannot satisfy the requirement for sukkah Rava’s objection does not apply there, because A home may also allude to a person’s private
walls. The halachah follows Rava. although the house’s walls are not visible from thoughts and feelings. A person must sanctify
This halachah contain a deep inner message. the rooftop sukkah, they are visible below, his inner world and make it a place of holiness.
Chazal (Sukkah 2a) teach that the essence of separating the house’s interior from the outside. He cannot rely solely on his surroundings; even
the mitzvah of sukkah is צא מדירת קבע ושב The idea expressed by this halachah is that when if he lives in a strong environment, learns in a
—בדירת עראיLeave your permanent dwelling and a sukkah is built atop a home with mechitzos yeshivah, and belongs to a good social circle,
live in a temporary one. The sukkah impresses hanikaros, those walls can extend upward to he must still build his own private inner space.
upon us that Olam Hazeh and all it contains enclose the sukkah. This too carries a deeper The mechitzos around that inner self become
are temporary; true permanence exists only message. To shelter beneath the shade of the mechitzos hanikaros, extending upward to
beneath the schach, which represents the shade Shechinah, a person must separate himself from protect him from outside influences.
of the Shechinah. Throughout the year we seek the temptations around him, beginning in his יו”ט א דסוכות תשפ”א מאמר א
2
The Sukkah of Dovid
Cont. from page 1
Dovid said to Hashem: To You it is know that as in days of old. It is this restoration that we —כי ד’ הוא האלקים אין עודso that all the peoples
when I said to Bnei Yisrael, Seek my presence— daven for in the special Harachaman of Sukkos. of the earth will know that Hashem is G-d; there
meaning that they should come see my royalty We may add that the pasuk continues: וַ הֲ ִרס ָֹתיו is no other.
and honor me—I did so only because I seek יתיהָ ּכִ ימֵ י ע ֹולָם
ִ ִ—ָאקים ּובְ נI
ִ will restore its ruins The emphasis is on the phrase there is no other.
Your presence; I seek to to inspire them to fear and rebuild it as in days of old. Once Hashem has Many people acknowledge the Creator but see
You and honor the King of Kings. promised to restore malchus Beis Dovid, what Him only as the greatest power, not the only
This is the unique quality of malchus Beis Dovid: is added by the end of the pasuk? power. They do not recognize that Hashem is
its purpose is to lead Klal Yisrael to serve The word הריסותיוalludes to the הרסwithin intimately involved in every detail of life. We
Hashem. The power and glory of a mortal Hashem’s name as written with a yud and a therefore declare that a time will come when
king help people grasp, in some measure, the hei. In Parshas Beshalach (17:15), the pasuk says: everyone will know that Hashem is G-d and that
power and glory of Hashem. When we seek ה-כי יד על כס י. Rashi explains that Hashem’s there is no other.
Hashem, we seek the greatest perception of name is not complete until the evil of Amalek Sukkos is an auspicious time to attain this
His majesty that we can attain. The majesty is eradicated. emunah. We leave our homes and dwell
of malchus Beis Dovid is a means toward that Moshiach will wage the battles of Hashem and beneath the —צלא דמהימונתאthe shade of
ultimate perception. Therefore, seeking “Dovid His people, ultimately eradicating evil from emunah. Sitting in the holy sukkah, we can feel
their king” is mentioned together with seeking the world. At that time, Hashem’s name will be Hashem’s protection and grasp that there is
Hashem their G-d. restored to its fullness. truly nothing besides Him.
This is the meaning of Hashem’s promise to This idea is reflected in the concluding שבת חוה”מ סוכות תשפ”ו מאמר ב
raise up the fallen sukkah of Dovid and rebuild it declaration of Hoshanos: למען דעת כל עמי הארץ
The Lovely Shoes
The Gemara in Sukkah (49b) explains the then, does the pasuk emphasize your steps a deep sense of accomplishment. Yet there
pasuk, —מַ ה ּיָפּו פְ עָ מַ ִיְך ּבַ ּנְ עָ לִ ים ּבַ ת נ ִָדיבHow in shoes? is a unique beauty in the difficult journey
lovely are your steps in shoes, daughter of the It must be that the pasuk refers specifically itself. With each step, he draws closer to
noble (Shir Hashirim 7:2), as referring to the to the steps taken on the journey to the Yerushalayim; his anticipation grows, and
beautiful steps of Yisrael when they are Beis Hamikdash, rather than to the arrival his heart fills with longing to reach the
oleh regel. and entry to the Beis Hamikdash. Beis Hamikdash. This is the beauty of the
The halachah is that one may not enter When a person reaches his destination, steps taken while still wearing shoes.
the Beis Hamikdash wearing shoes. Why, enters the Beis Hamikdash, and fulfills the ס”ג בחוקותי תשפ”ד מאמר א
mitzvah of aliyah l’regel, he certainly feels
A Goy in the Sukkah
וְ הָ יָה ּכׇל הַ ּנו ָֹתר ִמּכׇל הַ ּג ֹו ִים הַ ּבָ ִאים עַ ל of Moshiach and come to Yerushalayim on the sun to beat down with summer-like heat,
וְ עָ לּו ִמּדֵ י ָׁשנָה בְ ָׁשנָה לְ ִה ְׁש ַּתחֲ וֺת,רּוׁש ִ ָלם
ָ ְי Sukkos to bring korbanos. Rashi, however, cites and they will kick their sukkos and leave.
.לְ מֶ לְֶך ד' ְצבָ קוֹת וְ ָל ֹחג אֶ ת חַ ג הַ ּסֻ ּכוֹת the Gemara in Avodah Zarah (3a), which says The Gemara appears to describe a one-time
that Hashem will give the nations the mitzvah test that the nations will fail. Yet Rashi seems
All who remain from among the nations that came of sukkah. to understand that some worthy nations
against Yerushalayim will ascend each year to bow The Gemara says that in the future, Hashem will indeed come every year to Yerushalayim
before the King, Hashem, Master of Legions, and will reward those who kept the Torah. The and celebrate sukkos including fulfilling the
to celebrate the festival of Sukkos (Zechariah 14:16). nations will argue that they too deserve mitzvah of sukkah.
This pasuk, read in the Haftorah on the first reward, claiming that they would have fulfilled This raises an interesting hilchesa l’Meshicha:
day of Sukkos, teaches that in the future the the mitzvos had they been commanded. Do halachos such as lavud and gud achis apply to
nations of the world will come to Yerushalayim Hashem will then give them the opportunity the sukkah of a goy? Does the Shem Shamayim
to celebrate Sukkos. to perform the easy mitzvah of sukkah. The rest on such a sukkah? And may a Yid derive
Many mefarashim explain that the pasuk people of the nations will immediately build benefit from it?
refers to nations that will survive in the days themselves sukkos. Hashem will then cause יו”ט א דסוכות תשפ”ו
3
718.377.7777 Customerservice@gutmansinsurance.com
The Time for Decoration
Sukkos First Night Second Night Motzei Y''T
Brooklyn 6:29 7:29 7:27
Lakewood 6:30 7:29 7:28
Baltimore 6:40 7:39 7:37
Chicago 6:22 7:23 7:22
The Gemara (Sukkah 10a) cites a Baraisa: conveys an important lesson in avodas North Miami 6:55 7:48 7:47
Los Angeles 6:27 7:22 7:21
סיככה כהלכתה ועיטרה בקרמין ובסדינין Hashem.
אסור... ותלה בה אגוזין שקדים,המצוירין At times, people take on chumros and
להסתפק מהן עד מוצאי יום טוב האחרון של added acts of piety while neglecting
—חגIf one covered the sukkah with valid the fundamentals of halachah. This is
schach, decorated it with colorful curtains a mistake. Such piety can sometimes
and patterned sheets, and hung nuts, distract a person from shortcomings in
almonds, and similar items in it, one may basic obligations, especially in areas of
not use them until after the final day of the bein adam l’chaveiro.
Chag. The lesson of the Penei Yehoshua’s
The Gemara in Beitzah (30b) explains that chiddush is that the sukkah must first be
this prohibition applies because the Shem built according to halachah before it is
Shamayim rests on the sukkah, including decorated. So too, a person must first be
the items used to beautify it. careful in basic halachah, and only then
The Penei Yehoshua explains why the add chumros and expressions of piety.
Baraisa begins with the phrase, If one
covered it with schach in accordance with
halachah. He suggests that the Shem
Shamayim rests on the decorations only
יו”ט א דסוכות תשפ”א מאמר א
when they are placed after the schach.
If the decorations were put up first and
the schach was added afterward, the
decorations may not become kadosh.
The Penei Yehoshua7 presents this as a
chiddush and remains uncertain about the
practical halachah. Nevertheless, the idea
7 Sukkah 10b.
From the Desk of the Rosh Yeshivah
Strive to cultivate inner joy by fully accepting that Hashem directs your life.
Everything that happens is decreed from Heaven.
Use every available means to overcome depression, whether through
spiritual strengthening by studying works of mussar and developing
bitachon and simchah, or through appropriate physical methods.
Make an effort to be sociable and pleasant with others, and establish fixed
sedarim for Torah learning, which has the power to heal and gladden the
human heart.
Your friend, who prays for your welfare in both gashmiyus and ruchniyus and
awaits good news from you,
Shaul
Copyright © Machon Alei Deshe/ Kol Menachem . Comments and suggestions are welcome . To receive the gilyon by email sign up at subscribe@aleideshe.
4
Published by Machon Alei Deshe of America By Talmidim of Rabeinu, the Rosh Yeshiva of Gur, R’ Shaul Alter Shlit”a, son of the Rebbe, the Pnei Menachem of
