TORAS AVIGDOR - ENGLISH — Sukkos (2026-09-21)

SUKKOS
RAV AVIGDOR MILLER ZT"L
BASED ON HIS BOOKS, TAPES & WRITINGS OF TALMIDIM
T H E YO M TOV O F H U M I L I T Y
RAV AVIGDOR MILLER ZT"L
CONTENTS
Part I. Bowing in Humility - 1
Part II. The Sukkah of Humility - 4
Part III. Practicing Humility - 7
bigger. After a while, the road was mobbed with
Part I. Bowing in Humility people, everyone singing shiros v’sishbachos to
Hakadosh Baruch Hu. A beautiful sight!
The Yom Tov Bow
And finally they arrived in Yerushalayim and
One of the glorious experiences of the Yom Tov came into the Mikdash to fulfill the mitzvah of י≈ ָר ∆‡ה
of old was when the Jew came into the Beis ( ָּכל ¿זכו ¿ּר ָךShemos 34:23). Ah, to visit the Beis
Hamikdash and bowed down before Hakadosh Hamikdash and see the ˘ ָירםƒ ׁ ּיים ¿ ּבƒ וƒ ים ַ ּב ֲﬠבוֹ ָ„ ָ˙ם ו ¿ּלƒּכ ֲֹהנ
Baruch Hu. Every male was obligated to be oleh ז ¿מ ָרםƒ !ו ¿ּבWhen people came and saw the avodas Beis
regel, to travel up to Yerushalayim and be seen in Hamikdash, they were transformed from head to
the azarah and bring certain korbanos; but included foot. And all that is included in what we’re missing
in the procedure was to bow down to Hakadosh out on: ˙ ֹלים ַל ֲﬠלוֹ ˙ ¿ו ≈ל ָר‡וƒ ֹו ≈‡ין ֲ‡נַ ¿חנ ּו י¿ כו.¿
Baruch Hu. That was part of the old-time system of
celebrating a Yom Tov — to fall down on the ground. Coming to Bow
And it’s so important that we mention it every But we shouldn’t forget the next part in the
day in the Yom Tov Mussaf. We’re describing the davening. We’re looking forward to all of that but
we mention also יךָ ∆ה ׁ ¿˘ ַּ˙ ֲחווֹ ˙ ¿ל ָפנƒ – ו ¿ּלthat we used to
various things that went lost with the Beis
Hamikdash and we say, ˙ ֹלים ַל ֲﬠלוֹ ˙ ¿ו ≈ל ָר‡וƒ ֹ¿ו ≈‡ין ֲ‡נַ ¿חנ ּו י¿ כו bow down in front of You. “Hashem, please rebuild
– We can’t go up today to fulfill the mitzvah of re’iyah. for us the Beis Hamikdash so that once again we’ll
We’re sad about that because it was a tremendous be able to bow down to You.”
experience! We don’t realize what we’re missing. It’s an interesting thing because on our own we
Three times a year, the nation went up to might not have realized how important that is. It’s
Yerushalayim. They packed what they needed and an adjunct, an accessory to the experience, but is it
they forsook their homes and began marching on so important that it should be one of the few things
the road to the Mikdash. And as they went down we specify in our tefillos? The Anshei Knesses
the road, from every village new groups came down Hagedolah who instituted the words of davening
to meet them and the crowd became bigger and were very wise men and if they included these
CHODESH TISHRE
Lowenthal - לעילוי נשמות מרת פאגלא בת מורינו ר' ישראל ע"ה
Steif - ומרת בראנדל בת ר' משה דוד ע"ה
EasyPrint Sponsor
An aliyos neshama for our dear parents
R' Yitzchak ben Chaim & Frimsche bas Shraga Faivish z"l
Mark & Phil Halpern Toronto, Canada
WEALTHinsurance.com
words in the Mussaf we must say that bowing down hishtachavah is hispael; it’s reflexive – to make
is considered a very important form of avodah. yourself low. You don't say “bow” in lashon kodesh;
you “make yourself low to Hashem.”
Elkanah Makes Aliyah
And I’ll prove it to you. You remember how Aliyah L’tzorech Yeridah
Elkanah, the father of Shmuel, went up every year
Lehishtachavos means to put your face on the
to the Mishkan in Shiloh for Yom Tov? So the Navi
ground and lie there because you want to lower
says he had three purposes in mind (Shmuel I 1:3):
yourself before Hashem. And so Elkanah threw
One of them was 'ל ¿ז ּב ַֹח ַלהƒ – to bring korbanos. himself onto the floor and he didn't get up right
You couldn’t bring them anywhere else; in those away. He wasn’t in a hurry. He took his time and he
days, it was ossur to bring korbanos on a bamah was thinking, “I'm bowing down lifnei Melech
because Shiloh was the Mishkan and so you wouldn't Malchei Hamelachim, Hakadosh Baruch Hu. He
be yotzei your obligation anywhere else — you had rules the entire universe, as far as space goes and
to bring the Yom Tov offerings to the Mishkan (see beyond! He created it and ל‚¿ ֻ„ ָּל˙וֹ ≈‡ין ≈ח ∆˜רƒ ו,¿ there's no
Zevachim 112b). A very important reason for Elkanah searching out His greatness (Tehillim 145:3). And I,
to travel. what am I? A little man, a tiny speck of protoplasm
Another reason was ּפנ¿ ָחסƒ י וƒלי ָח ¿פנƒ ¿ו ׁ ָ˘ם ׁ ¿˘נ≈ י ¿בנ≈ י ≈ﬠ that He created.”
' ים ַלהƒ – ּכ ֲֹהנthe two sons of Eili, Chofni and Pinchas,
And for that alone it was worth making a big
were there. Eili, their father, was the kohen gadol
journey to the Sanctuary — just to fall down on the
and a shofet, too — the leader of Sanhedrin — and
ground on your face and feel that you are low before
his two sons were very important talmidei
Hashem.
chachomim. And therefore, Elkanah went up in
order to talk things over with them. Maybe they Who, Me? Yes, You!
spoke in learning. Maybe Elkanah had certain
questions that came up during the year; he wanted “Oh, please,” you say, “Is that really necessary? I
eitzos, counsel. Whatever it was, to go up to talk to don't have to bow down. I know already that Hashem
the kohanei Hashem was a purpose in itself — they is bigger than I am. Who isn't humble to Hashem?
didn’t have telephones in those days. Unless chas v’shalom he's an atheist. But a man who
believes in the Creator certainly is humble before
Aliyah for What? Hashem. Who in the frum world will be arrogant
So you have here two very good reasons; to towards Hashem?”
bring korbanos and to speak with the gedolei hador.
And the answer is: everybody. Every human
Each one by itself is a good enough reason to travel
being is arrogant towards Hashem. And even though
up to Shiloh. But pay attention now. Those were the
with his lips he may say words of pious hypocrisy, in
second and third reasons on the list. You know what
his heart he doesn't back down even before Hashem.
the first reason was? The first on the list, before
That's human nature because actually Hashem
korbanos and before meeting the gedolei hador, was
made man endlessly great. And he knows it;
'ה ׁ ¿˘ ַּ˙ ֲחווֹ ˙ ַלהƒ – ¿לto bow down to Hashem.
naturally he knows, subconsciously, that he has a
It’s a queer thing. Is it so important — the number neshamah, a chelek of Hashem that was breathed
one purpose? into him. Every man is tremendously great! And
Absolutely. Because listen to the word that's why a man must work on himself to be humble
lehishtachavos. The word hishtachavah comes from to Hashem. It takes work, effort, to learn that
the word shachah which means to be low. But attitude.
2 / TORAS AVIGDOR . SUKKOS . THE YOM TOV OF HUMILITY
A Passing Dream Mind Over Motion
It’s so important for a man to realize that without Of course, it matters what’s doing in your head,
Hashem, he is nothing. You cannot do a thing to what you’re thinking. There are all types of good
help yourself. םƒ ּב ≈י„י ׁ ָ˘ ַמיƒ – ַה ּכֹלEverything is in the attitudes that have to be attached to the physical
hands of Heaven! (Brachos 33b). – ¿ּכח ∆ֹמר ¿ ּביַ „ ַה ּיוֹ ≈ˆר act of bowing down. Otherwise, what is it just to
We’re like a piece of clay in Hashem’s hands (Yirmiyah bow? You see that sometimes in the shul, a man
18:6). People are born and they die and nothing is jerks down, he jerks up, like a robot. He’s not
remembered of them. What are we? – ַּכ ֲחלוֹ ם יָ עוּף thinking at all. No, we are humbled in gratitude. So
We’re like a dream that goes away (Iyov 20:8). much You are giving me! הי ָﬠ ַליƒ ֹ˘יב ַלה' ָּכל ַּ˙‚¿ מוּלוƒ ׁ ‡ָ ַמה
And that’s why the bowing down of hishtachavah – What can I pay You back, all that You did for me?
is so important. Because we have to take action to (Tehillim 116:12).
realize the greatness of Hakadosh Baruch Hu, that Of course, if you don’t think, so it’s nothing. He
it shouldn’t be – ¿ו ָרם ¿ל ָב ∆ב ָךYou shouldn’t feel elevated says, “I bow down to You Hashem,” but in his heart
in your heart (Devarim 8:14). – רוֹ ¿ממ ּו ה' ¡‡ל ≈ֹ˜ינ ּוOnly he is bowing down only to himself. He thinks he’s
Hashem we elevate! (Tehillim 99:5). And how? the one who helps himself. He imagines himself a
ֹה ׁ ¿˘ ַּ˙ ֲחו ּו ¿ל ַהר ָ˜ ¿„ ׁ˘וƒ – ¿וWe bow down to Him (ibid. 99:9). self-made man.
Hishtachavu is the opposite of rommemu. You make No; the one who bows is “making himself low.”
Hashem high in your mind when you make yourself “I’m helpless,” he says. “I’m on the receiving end and
low in front of Him. I can’t pay back anything. One thing I can do and
that is to generate this feeling of humility.”
A Modest Beginning
It’s so important to humiliate yourself before
That's why one of the most important functions
Hashem, to acknowledge your littleness, your
in our prayers is something that most people
nothingness, that merely to bow down is an
overlook. You're beginning to say Shemoneh Esrei
achievement of the first magnitude! Isn't it a pity
so you give a prefatory bow. You think it’s not so
people don't understand that? You’re lowering
important. Baruch Atah Hashem; the words you’re
yourself before the Master. You’re acknowledging
going to say, that’s important — but the bow? That’s
Him as the King.
just the signal that you’re starting now.
No; you're missing the whole point. It's a law in Taking a Bow
the Gemara (Brachos 34a) you must bow down at That’s what the first word of Shemoneh Esrei is
the beginning of the Amidah because that's the first telling you: Baruch. What does that mean “we bless
lesson. That’s number one; the most important Hashem”? Now, no matter what others will tell you,
thing is the bowing down and acknowledging that the real meaning is that it stems from the word
there's Somebody higher than you are. berech, a knee, and baruch Atah means “You are the
One to Whom the knees are bent.”
And so, don't be in a hurry. While you're bowing,
take your time and get the full benefit of that. The And therefore, it shouldn't be a genuflection, a
bending of the knee is only a motion of the body, jerk bending down. No. Utilize that first bending of
but its purpose is in order to influence the mind; the knee. It’s a great service of Hashem. We don’t
you bend your knee in order to bend your mind. stand up straight in front of You; we kneel to You.
And therefore it pays when you bow down to utilize We don’t kneel today; we bend our knees, however.
the opportunity, “I'm humbling myself to You. I’m That’s a sign of hachna’ah.
bowing before the greatness of the King of the Not for Him, by the way. Our humility is
universe.” meaningless to Hakadosh Baruch Hu. He doesn’t
3 / TORAS AVIGDOR . SUKKOS . THE YOM TOV OF HUMILITY
need it. He doesn't feel elevated or honored if we mitzvos are intended to refine our minds and our
weak little human beings demonstrate our humility characters (Bereishis Rabbah 44:1). It means if you
to Him. It’s for us, for our perfection to generate go into a sukkah and you’re happy — it’s a Yom Tov
this feeling of humility. So don't be in a hurry when atmosphere, ornaments are hanging in the sukkah,
you bend over. Remain for a little while. Make use of your family is there and they’re serving a nice meal
the opportunity every day. also, so you make a bracha leishev basukkah because
you’re fulfilling the mitzvah — very good! But there
Yom Tov Humility
are purposes there, too, and if you’ll think about
But in the ancient days, it was something much them, that’s the best way to sit in the sukkah. And
bigger, much more. Yom Tov meant that מיםƒ ׁ˘ ּ ¿פ ָﬠúֹ ˘ָ ׁ the more you put into it, the more you’ll achieve,
– ַ ּב ּ ׁ ָ˘נָ ה י≈ ָר ∆‡ה ׇּכל ¿זכו ¿ּר ָךthree times a year we present the more you’ll be refined.
ourselves – ∆‡˙ ּ ¿פנ≈ י ָה ָ‡„וֹ ןbefore the Master, Hashem
(Shemos 34:23). That word ָ‡„וֹ ןis remarkable; it’s The Proud Nation
not used ordinarily on Hashem. But it is used here The purpose of the sukkos, it says openly, is ¿ל ַמ ַﬠן
to emphasize that basic function of Yom Tov, that יכם ∆ ˙≈ ֹ – י≈ ¿„ע ּו „ּ וֹ רוthat your generations should know ּכיƒ
we come to the Beis Hamikdash to demonstrate םƒמ ¿ˆ ָריƒ ıי‡י ‡וֹ ָ˙ם ≈מ ∆‡ ∆רƒ ˆƒ ֹ ¿˘ׂ ָר ≈‡ל ¿ ּבהוƒ˙י ∆‡˙ ¿ ּבנ≈ י יƒּ – ַב ֻּס ּכוֹ ˙ הוֹ ׁ ַ˘ ¿ב
that we are nichna to a Master. A nation left their that I caused your forefathers to dwell in sukkos
homes to trek along the byroads and main roads when I took them out of Egypt (Vayikra 23:43). And
until they reached Yerushalayim, traveling up for one of the reasons why Hashem did that was so we
miles in order to come into His Home. And for what should learn to be humble. After all, they were going
purpose? 'ה ׁ ¿˘ ַּ˙ ֲחווֹ ˙ ַלהƒ – ¿לTo make themselves low to into Eretz Yisroel where they would live like
Him. aristocrats, in big stone homes on their own land,
That’s the avodah that was reinforced every and that would be dangerous.
year on Yom Tov. Of course, each Yom Tov has some Dangerous to what? To their character. Because
more purposes. If it’s the chag of Chag Hamatzos or there’s a warning in the Torah: Hashem says that
if it’s Zman Matan Toraseinu, whatever it is, each when you come into Eretz Canaan and you’ll
one its own avodah. But this certainly is a function disinherit the previous inhabitants and dwell in
of every chag; we reinforce this feeling of humility batim tovim, nice homes — an emphasis on good
by lowering ourselves before Hakadosh Baruch Hu. homes, strong and secure — so you must beware of
ו ָרם ¿ל ָב ∆ב ָך,¿ that your heart might become proud
Part II. The Sukkah of Humility (Devarim 8:14).
Now what does it mean “your heart will become
The Sukkah Academy proud”? Does it mean you’ll walk around boasting of
Now, as much as every Yom Tov has this function, your home? It could be, but that’s not what it really
when we come to the Yom Tov of Sukkos, we have means. If somebody has a nice home, to some
to understand that these seven days are especially extent it may contribute to his arrogance, it might
dedicated to this principle. Because on Sukkos we make him conceited, but that’s not the point here at
have the mitzvah of living in a sukkah and one of the all. – ¿ו ָרם ¿ל ָב ∆ב ָךYour heart will become proud, ˙ָּ ¿ו ׁ ָ˘ ַכ ¿ח
fundamental lessons that the sukkah is trying to ' – ∆‡˙ הyou’ll forget about Hashem.
teach us is humility. Forget Hashem?! That’s impossible! They’re not
All the mitzvos, you have to know, are a form of going to forget Hashem in Eretz Yisroel! They’ll
teaching. Besides for just fulfilling the command of continue to do mitzvos. They’ll separate terumah
Hashem, ˙ ֹר ּיוƒ מ ¿ˆווֹ ˙ ∆‡ ָּל‡ ¿ל ָˆ ≈רף ָ ּב ∆הן ∆‡˙ ַה ¿ ּבƒּ ּ¿˙נ ּו ַהƒ – ל ֹ‡ נthe and ma’aser from their grain. They’ll keep kashrus
4 / TORAS AVIGDOR . SUKKOS . THE YOM TOV OF HUMILITY
and taharas hamishpacha. Even the dinim of tumah And that’s why we go into the sukkah — to be
v’taharah and everything else they’ll keep. So what humbled before Hakadosh Baruch Hu. We leave our
does it mean they’ll forget Hashem? nice homes, our carpets and our chandeliers, our
brick walls and sturdy roof, and for seven days we
Feeling Too Secure
go into a flimsy little hut, a weak kind of protection.
It means that you won’t think about Him as your
Benefactor, as your security. It’s possible to do all The Revoked Citizenship
these mitzvos and still to forget that you have a That’s what the possuk says, ˘ ָר ≈‡ל ׂ ¿ ƒׇּכל ָה ∆‡ ¿ז ָרח ¿ ּבי
Master over you. Because if you’re not busy with ˙ – י≈ ׁ ¿˘ב ּו ַ ּב ֻּס ֹּכevery citizen of Yisroel should dwell in
humility, you'll begin to imagine that you’re good sukkos (Vayikra 23:42). That’s a queer word to use,
without Him. Of course, you won’t say that — you ezrach. You don’t find it in other places. It doesn’t
won’t even think it — but your character will change. say “every ezrach should eat kosher” or “every
When you live in a beautiful, comfortable home, ezrach should keep Shabbos.” It doesn’t say “every
you tend to forget that there’s Somebody over you. ezrach should refrain from shaving with a razor
In the desert, you didn’t have any permanent blade.” Only when it comes to the sukkah, the possuk
dwellings; you only had tents, temporary makeshift says ezrach. What’s that about?
huts that at any moment when you heard the
And the answer is ezrach means a bona fide
trumpets blow you had to put them together quickly
citizen. You’re established. You have a nice home
on the back of a donkey and set out on the trek in
and it’s not even stucco; it’s brick. You think you’re
the desert to some other place, so you couldn’t feel
pretty important. You feel that you’re an ezrach, a
too arrogant. You turned around and looked back
permanent burgher, an important fellow? Then you
where you had encamped for some time and you
need a reminder: „ ַיר˙ ֲﬠ ַר‡יƒ „ּ ַיר˙ ∆˜ ַבע ¿ו ׁ ≈˘ב ¿ ּבƒ מƒ ‡ˆ≈ – Move
see there’s nothing left except a little bit of garbage,
out of your nice home into a temporary dwelling
and you’re traveling again, so you didn’t feel a
(Sukkah 2a).
permanence at all.
But when they came to Eretz Yisroel and they A Humbling Hut
settled in, it was a different story. Not only they That’s why the sukkah has to be built in such a
settled permanently, but they were living in way that it’s not a permanent type of home. You
beautiful dwellings — houses that they didn’t have can’t make it so high a construction that you’re
to take apart and transport on the back of an animal forced to have sturdy walls. No. It has to be flimsy.
to someplace else. And so, naturally, people tend to That’s a halacha of sukkah. Also, the Torah insists
forget that really they’re not so important. that the schach cannot be a regular roof. Even
though the roof will be of things that grow from the
Deflating the Proud
ground, if it’s made in such a way that it is a
And therefore, in order to prepare for that test,
ָ ˜ֹ∆ יכ ָך ה' ¡‡ל permanent construction, then it’s possul.
Hashem said, יך ∆זה ֲ ֹלƒ ¿ו ָז ַכ ¿ר ָּ˙ ∆‡˙ ָּכל ַה ∆„ּ ∆ר ¿ך ֲ‡ ׁ ∆˘ר ה
מ ¿„ ָ ּבר ¿ל ַמ ַﬠן ַﬠ ּנ ¿ֹ˙ ָךƒּ עים ׁ ָ˘נָ ה ַ ּבƒ – ַ‡ ¿ר ָ ּבI took you into the And so you see the insistence on the theme of
Midbar for forty years to humble you, to prepare you something that is temporary, something which
(Devarim 8:2). In the Midbar, they were always humbles the one who dwells there. It’s a very weak
reminded that they were entirely dependent on kind of protection. Some sticks, some schach;
Hashem. They were secure, yes, but you can’t feel sometimes it rains into your soup.
like a big shot when you’re living in a desert in a A goy can even heave a brick into the schach,
tent. And that was the purpose. That was the chas v’shalom, and it will fall through. You know
intention. sometimes your neighbor, a gentile, makes trouble
5 / TORAS AVIGDOR . SUKKOS . THE YOM TOV OF HUMILITY
for you on Sukkos? He wants to call the city Now, a wealthy man could have built himself a
inspector because you’re making an illegal structure. beautiful home. He could buy a plot and build a
Or he makes other trouble. I once was visiting a brick house surrounded by gardens and orchards.
rabbi of a certain shul in East Flatbush and he was That’s what we would have done. Even if you’re a
making his sukkah. He had a Puerto Rican neighbor tzaddik, so you’re not going to build a palace maybe,
who liked making trouble for him. And this rabbi but at least a home, something. It’s interesting,
went next door to him and he said, “Please, please,” however, that Avraham always dwelt in a tent.
he said, “don’t break down my sukkah.” He was Now, you could say, there was a reason for the
begging him. “Please don’t break down my sukkah.” tent. Avraham was always traveling: – ָהלוֹ ¿ך ¿ונָ סוֹ ַﬠHe
In his house, this rabbi was an important fellow was always on the move (Bereishis 12:9). Because he
— and he was, by the way — but outside on Sukkos had a purpose and that was to preach to everybody
he didn’t feel so important any longer. I was that there is a Master of the World. Wherever he
comforting him; I told him that he should be happy went, that was his business – ּי ¿˜ ָר‡ ¿ ּב ׁ ≈˘ם ה' ≈˜ל עוֹ ָלםƒ ַו
that he was fulfilling one of the purposes of the (Bereishis 21:33). There’s a Ribono Shel Olam! That
sukkah. You go into the sukkah to remind yourself was Avraham’s business; he went around from place
that you’re not as important as you thought. You’re to place preaching that. So you might say that he
insecure, unprotected. Without Hashem, you’re couldn’t build a palace for that reason.
nothing.
Practice What You Preach
Homeless Citizens
But that wasn’t the only reason. It was a principle:
And that’s why the ezrach is emphasized. That
he should never become arrogant. He should always
weak kind of construction is for the purpose of
remind himself that he’s not so secure, that he’s
teaching the one living there that he’s not so
bowed down before Hashem. It wasn’t only that he
important. Even if you’re a permanent, real bona
preached about it — he practiced it. And living in a
fide Jew, you should also move out because you
flimsy structure helped.
have to be reminded that you’re not as important as
It was only Lot who finally broke with his rebbe,
you imagine. You look up and see overhead nothing
Avraham, and went away to Sedom. At first it says
but schach. The people passing by won’t give you
– ַו ∆ ּי ¡‡ ַהלhe pitched his tent (ibid. 13:12). But finally, he
much privacy there. You can’t sit like a melech when
gave up Avraham’s way of life and he moved into a
you’re in a place that has two walls and a tefach. “I’m
house. It says openly that he lived in a house in
like a homeless man, chas v’shalom.”
Sedom (ibid. 19:2). So he gave up the ways of his
Now, you don’t see a homeless person who’s
rebbe.
arrogant. How can he be arrogant if he’s living on a
park bench? Maybe he’s rude, he never learned any But Avraham and Yitzchak, they dwelt in tents.
manners; he’s bitter — but arrogant he’s surely not. Even Yaakov, who built a house, moved out soon
And in a small way, that’s what you’re doing in the and went back to the tents. They lived in tents
sukkah. It’s for the purpose of humbling you. always. And so we see that it was a principle of the
Avos that they should never forget this great
The Great Unhoused principle: to live with the attitude of hishtachavah,
And now we understand something puzzling to make yourself low before Hashem.
about the practices of Avraham, our father. ¿ו ַ‡ ¿ב ָרם
„ֹ‡ – ָּכ ≈ב„ ¿מHe was very heavy with wealth, מ ¿˜נ∆ ה ַ ּב ∆ּכ ∆סףƒּ ַ ּב Emulating Our Forefathers
– ו ַּב ָּז ָהבwith huge herds, huge flocks, and trunks full Now, we don’t do that. We’re not as great as our
of silver and gold (Bereishis 13:2). forefathers. And Hakadosh Baruch Hu doesn’t
6 / TORAS AVIGDOR . SUKKOS . THE YOM TOV OF HUMILITY
require it either. “Live in a nice home,” He says. “I Superfluous Speech
want you to be happy and comfortable. But once a Of course, – ּ≈˙ ׁ ¿˘ב ּו ¿ּכ ≈ﬠין ָּ˙„וּר ּוYou have to live
year, for seven days, I want you to be like the Avos normally in the sukkah (Sukkah 26a). But you have
and like your forefathers in the Midbar. And to be careful, too. A makom kadosh like a sukkah
therefore, on Sukkos, „ ַיר˙ ֲﬠ ַר‡יƒ „ּ ַיר˙ ∆˜ ַבע ¿ו ׁ ≈˘ב ¿ ּבƒ מƒ ‡ˆ,
≈ requires more vigilance; you can’t talk leitzanus,
and practice up on this great middah of humility.” lashon hara, in such a place.
And therefore, isn’t it a rachmanus when people But it’s an interesting thing the sefarim say that
sit in the sukkah and don’t think about what the even superfluous words you shouldn’t speak in the
sukkah is about? To walk into the sukkah after sukkah (see Mateh Efraim 625:65). A remarkable
making all preparations and the mind should be idea; it’s a good practice to be careful not to say
blank? A very great loss. unnecessary words in the sukkah. And it pays to
understand why that’s so.
When you sit in the sukkah, immediately the
Healthy for Body and Soul
first result should be you’re nichna, you’re humbled
before Hashem. It’s very important to keep that in Now, we have to know that there are various
mind when you come into the sukkah. At least for benefits of silence. One is that you’ll sin less — ָּכל
seven days, to go through the motions, to practice ‡בי‡ ≈ח ¿טƒ רים ≈מƒ ּב ¿„ ָבƒ ( ַה ַּמ ¿ר ∆ ּבהAvos 1:17). If you have any
this ideal of 'ה ׁ ¿˘ ַּ˙ ֲחווֹ ˙ ַלהƒ ל,
¿ to make yourself low kind of long conversation, you're certain to do some
before Hashem. sin in order to continue the run of the conversation.
You'll look for other things to say, and you'll bring in
names of people and you'll find some faults in them.
Part III. Practicing Humility Or you might say some leitzanus against something
that's kodesh. That's how it is in the course of time;
Raising the Bar רים ל ֹ‡ י∆ ¿ח ַ„ּ ל ּ ָפ ׁ ַ˘עƒ – ¿ ּברֹב ¿„ּ ָבin a multitude of words you
cannot avoid a sin (Mishlei 10:19). Even a person
Now, we’ll take it one step further. How do you who is a lamdan who studied the Chofetz Chaim's
work on this avodah of humility in the sukkah? So sefarim will be nichshal if he talks at length. And
we said that when you come into the sukkah, those who didn’t learn, no question about it. So
immediately try to remind yourself of this purpose: that’s enough of a reason to keep your mouth
“I’m here now because I want to practice being closed.
nichna, humbled before Hashem.” It’s a good idea to
It’s also healthier. י˜ה ƒ ˆָ – ל ֹ‡ ָמI
ָ ˙ƒ ˘¿ ׁ ּ מƒ ‡˙י ַל‚ּ וּף טוֹ ב
keep that in mind anytime you walk into the sukkah.
found nothing better for your health than silence
Even if you do it a little bit you're successful because
(Avos 1:17). There are a lot of things you can do to
you're superior to anybody else.
protect your health. Exercise is important. Proper
But let’s climb the ladder of anivus to Hakadosh sleep is important. Eating properly is important.
Baruch Hu, another rung. Here, you’re sitting in the But this Tanna examined them all and he found that
sukkah and everyone is talking. Wonderful! It’s silence is the best thing for your health.
simchas Yom Tov. But you have to remember what By the way, people will like you more, too.
the sefarim say, that you have to be careful what Absolutely. People who don’t speak much gain
you say in the sukkah (Mishnah Berurah 639:2). You friends. It’s a fact that quiet people are well-liked. I
can’t fool around. You can’t make jokes. The sukkah myself know a number of quiet people who are
is no place for leitzanus. A moshav leitzim in the quite popular; people are happy to be in their
sukkah is entirely contradictory to the purpose. company.
7 / TORAS AVIGDOR . SUKKOS . THE YOM TOV OF HUMILITY
Displaying Your Insides practice. Share the limelight. Let other people
But there’s something else in shtikah that is chatter; you just listen. Nod your head, smile, be
more than all of that: Silence is a sign of a humble friendly, but keep your mouth closed. It’s a
person. And we’ll explain that in two ways. tremendous training of character.
Number one: In Mishlei (18:2) it states, ıֹל ֹ‡ יַ ¿ח ּפ
Here’s a man, he likes to stop me on the street
ּב ¿˙בוּנָ הƒ סילƒ – ¿ּכa fool does not desire understanding, ּכיƒ
to tell me his vertlach, his pshetlach. So I’m quiet. I
ֹל ּבוƒ ˙ ֹה ¿˙ ַ ּ‚ ּלוƒ ‡ם ¿ ּבƒ – he desires to reveal his own mind. It
nod and listen. Now, actually I have a hundred times
means that the foolish fellow is not interested in
as much as he has to say, and better things — I
listening. He wants to talk. Why does he want to
listened to my rebbeim for years in Slabodka and
talk? He has an instinct of turning himself inside-
they had very good things to say. But I keep quiet. I
out to people, of displaying his emotions and
don't say anything of my own. I just listen. I’m
demonstrating his thoughts.
practicing.
Sometimes you watch a man sitting on a park
bench; he’s talking for hours. You might even envy Silent Awareness
him; he’s a fountain of speech while you’d fall short
of words. Or maybe you see people sitting in shul But there’s something much more. Because you
talking and talking from Mah Tovu until Aleinu. can add the thought: why am I quiet? You have to
What do they have to talk about so much? Why is it listen to what Shlomo Hamelech says in the
that the k’sil is so interested in telling people so beginning of Chapter 5 of Sefer Koheles, a very
many things? important function of keeping quiet:
The answer is, he’s talking about himself — what ָ פƒ ּ – ַ‡ל ּ¿˙ ַב ≈הל ַﬠלDo not be hasty with your mouth,
יך
he saw, what he heard, what he thinks. It’s the
ˆי‡ ָ„ ָברƒ ֹל ¿ ּב ָך ַ‡ל י¿ ַמ ≈הר ¿להוƒ – ¿וand your heart should not be
middah of egoism. He’s interested in himself and he
in a hurry to utter a word, ֹ˜יםƒ ל ¿פנ≈ י ָה ¡‡לƒ – before
wants to show himself to others. Now, the truth is
Hashem. Whatever you say, you’re saying in the
that often it doesn’t compliment him too much
Presence of Hashem. םƒֹ˜ים ַ ּב ּ ׁ ָ˘ ַמיƒ ּכי ָה ¡‡לƒ – Hashem is in
when he starts taking off his clothes and displaying
Heaven, ı – ¿ו ַ‡ ָּ˙ה ַﬠל ָה ָ‡ ∆רyou’re down here on earth,
himself to other people. He empties out the contents ָ ¿הי ּו ¿„ ָב ∆רƒַﬠל ≈ּכן י
you’re standing in front of Him, טיםƒּ יך ¿מ ַﬠ
of his mind and he doesn’t realize that people
– Therefore, your words should be few.
ridicule him for that. But that’s what his instinct is;
his ego drives him to talk as much as he can. And so he’s introducing to us a new motivation,
And to a certain extent, it applies to everyone. why you should be quiet: because you're in the
It’s an effort to be silent. You’re fighting against this Presence of Hashem.
animal within you that wants to bark or meow or
make noises, to show that it’s there, to demonstrate So now we begin to understand that silence is
anochi, that “I am here.” And therefore, when a man not merely a good quality that keeps you away from
is able to keep his mouth closed, he is forcing that sin. It’s not merely something that will keep you
quality to be repressed. healthy and will cause you to be more appreciated
by people. Silence makes you humble! Hashem is
The Silent Treatment greater than you are! םƒֹ˜ים ַ ּב ּ ׁ ָ˘ ַמיƒ ּכי ָה ¡‡לƒ – Hashem is
Especially if you have what to say. Let’s say here above you. He’s looking at you. Where do you
somebody talks to you about a certain subject get the authority to open your mouth in the
which you know a good deal about, but you keep Presence of the King? You need silence in order to
your mouth closed and listen to him; that’s good be humble to Hakadosh Baruch Hu.
8 / TORAS AVIGDOR . SUKKOS . THE YOM TOV OF HUMILITY
Silent Humility He walks into the sukkah and starts talking, and
And this is based on the principle of ָֹח ָכם ≈‡ינו you’re very polite, of course. “How are you, Jake?
מ ּ∆מנּ ּוƒ מי ׁ ∆˘ ָ ּ‚„וֹ לƒ ּב ¿פנ≈ יƒ – ¿מ ַ„ ≈ ּברa wise man does not speak in Long time no see! How’s the family?” Whatever it is,
the presence of somebody bigger than him (Avos 5:7). you say something — but then you stop because
Silence means that you know you are standing in you’re standing in front of Hashem. You might have
the presence of someone. to open your mouth here and there to say a word or
Let’s say Governor Cuomo would be visiting two, but that’s it. You smile pleasantly but you can’t
here. I wouldn’t open my mouth. Now, Cuomo is a talk much when you’re in the Presence of the Melech
nobody. He’s a shlemazel; a shlepper and a bum, a Malchei Hamelachim, Hakadosh Baruch Hu.
low character. But if he was here, I’d keep quiet. Of course, he shouldn't know. If he’s here at the
After all, Hashem gave him authority for the time lecture, so practice on someone else. But whoever
being. Let’s hope he’ll lose the next election, but for it is, it’s a wonderful training in anavah; it’s a very
the time being he’s the governor and so a wise big achievement to practice humility in the sukkah.
person keeps quiet in the presence of that tramp.
A normal person feels humility before someone Practice Makes Perfect
in authority. Even when I visit a doctor, I have so
Now, actually you're not an anav yet. But just by
much respect for him so I keep quiet. He knows so
keeping your mouth closed, you're influencing
much in that field of which I know nothing at all. I'm
yourself toward the middah of anavah. That’s a big
humbly quiet. That's old-fashionality; that's how we
principle in the Torah psychology which the Sages
were brought up. We're supposed to find it difficult
teach us. It’s the famous principle: ˙ ּיוּ˙ ¿מעוֹ ∆ר ∆רƒחיˆוֹ נƒ ַה
to talk in the presence of someone bigger than us.
˙ ֹימ ּיו
ƒ ƒ – ∆‡˙ ַה ּ ¿פנyour outwardliness stirs up your
It's only a fool, an idiot, who will prattle in the
inwardliness (see Mesillas Yesharim, Ch. 7).
presence of מ ּ∆מנּ ּוƒ מי ׁ ∆˘ ָ ּ‚„וֹ ל.
ƒ
And therefore, Koheles is saying we can measure Each one of us aspires to gain more humility; we
the extent of your humility to Hashem by the want to feel the Presence of Hashem more and
looseness of your mouth. If you actually felt you more as the days and the years go by. And now
were standing in the Presence of Hashem, you Koheles tells us how to get it. The more you keep
couldn't talk that much. If you could open your your mouth shut thinking that you're standing in
mouth and talk freely, it's the clearest proof that the Presence of Hashem, the greater you become.
your belief is only a superficial stereotype. It’s not
Try it once. There's a kick to it. It's like taking
real.
vitamins. Try and you'll see. I suggest doing it a few
Sukkah Silence times a day in the sukkah. With chaveirim, your
Now, this middah is something especially good wife, your father-in-law, whoever. “I’m going to try
to practice up in the sukkah. It’s the little humble to keep my mouth closed because I’m standing in
hut teaching you humility, that you’re not the ezrach front of Hashem. Even if I have to say something, I’ll
you imagined yourself to be. And so this is an count my words.” Chop short your sentence.
excellent place to train yourself. That’s an achievement. That's vitamins for your
So imagine Cousin Jake comes over on Chol soul. It puts into you such an awareness that you're
Hamoed to visit. “Aha!” you’re thinking, “A chance to standing in the Presence of Somebody bigger.
remind myself that I’m standing in the Presence of That's a good exercise. It's externality but ˙ּ ּיוƒחיˆוֹ נƒ ַה
Hashem. I’ll keep my mouth closed as much as ˙ ֹימ ּיו ¿ It will stir up in you such a wave
ƒ ƒמעוֹ ∆ר ∆ר˙ ∆‡˙ ַה ּ ¿פנ.
possible.” of emunah.
9 / TORAS AVIGDOR . SUKKOS . THE YOM TOV OF HUMILITY
That’s how you learn humility. It’s like bowing
down to Hashem. In your mind, you're laid out flat,
prostrated in front of Him.
The Secret of the Sukkah QUESTION
And so it’s something you can do always — if you
do it all year long once a day you’re a very wise What should we think when we shake lulav
person — but the sukkah, that’s the place made for by Hodu in Hallel?
that. You’re exposed to the sky, to Hashem; you’re
not such an ezrach when it’s two walls and a tefach, ANSWER
and therefore don’t waste the opportunity.
Here you built a sukkah already. It was a big job So when you do the na’anuim tomorrow by
— maybe it was a big expense, too. But finally, the Hallel and you say, “ּכי טוֹ בƒ ' – הוֹ „ ּו ַלהWe thank You
sukkah is standing. You even asked the rabbi to Hashem for all of the good You’ve done to us,” you
have to be prepared to thank for something.
come down and inspect it and he gave his hechsher
You’ll go into Hodu with a blank head, with
— everything is kasher v’yashar; the schach is
nothing?
sufficient, the walls were made to the din.
So maybe you think you can lean back and relax So you’ll think, let's say, like this: “Didn’t I
now. No, you can't relax. Now you have to get busy marry off my daughters well?” Did you ever think
utilizing the sukkah to produce from yourself what about that when you say Hodu? It wouldn’t be a
the sukkah was built to produce. bad idea to make one na’anuim for each son-in-
law. “Ay-yah-yay! I’m thanking You, Hashem, for
Have a Wonderful Sukkos this son-in-law.” And by the next na’anuim, הוֹ „ ּו
ַ “I’m thanking You, Hashem, for the next
ּכי טוֹ בƒ 'לה,
Let’s Get Practical son-in-law.” That’s how to work it. It’s such a very
big thing to have married off your children well
Put Yourself On Mute that you can never thank enough for a good son-
in-law or for a good daughter-in-law. And that’s
Sukkos is the Yom Tov of humility, a time when we
how you should think when you make the
forgo the comforts of our homes and dwell in a
na’anuim. It shouldn’t just be a mechanical thing.
humble hut for one week.
This Sukkos, bli neder, I am going to make a You think it’s silly! It’s not silly at all. I do it.
conscious effort for at least ten minutes each day Many times I think like this: One na’anuim is for
to zip my lips in the sukkah. I will maintain cordiality, my oldest son-in-law. “Baruch Hashem, I have a
letting others have the spotlight, while keeping in good eidim! Baruch Hashem!” And then, “Baruch
Hashem, I have a good second son-in-law. And
mind that I am basking in the Presence of Hakadosh
baruch Hashem for the next eidim. Baruch
Baruch Hu.
Hashem, there’s no trouble there. I never hear
any machlokes. My daughters live in shalom with
This week’s booklet is based on tapes: my eidim. Baruch Hashem, I’m happy. Such good
R-53 - Great by Silence | 271 - Tenants in This World | 614 - The eidims.”
Sukkah | 664 - Perfection of Humility | 776 - Service by Silence
That’s why we make na’anuim. That’s what it
Listen to the original lectures of Rav Miller zatzal
on the Mipihu Phone Line means Hodu: “I’m thanking You for what You’ve
USA: 718-400-7220 | Israel: 778509304 | UK: 3303505768 given to me.” September 1989
Mipihu is a project of Yeshiva Gedolah Beis Yisroel - Rav Miller’s Yeshivah
10 / TORAS AVIGDOR . SUKKOS . THE YOM TOV OF HUMILITY
