Kollel Lihoraah - English — Sukkos (2026-09-21)

Sukkos
5787
Ask the Rav
Sukkah Decorations Whose Packaging Says They Are Intended for Their A Jew Who Wishes to Sell Colored Candles
Holiday — May They Be Hung in the Sukkah? Regarding our discussion, another question arises concerning a Jew who sells
these types of candles throughout the year: Is he permitted to sell them to a non
Q: I have been asked by many people about a very common situation. In the -Jew who intends to use them in honor of his holiday?
marketplace there are Sukkah decorations, such as small colorful lights, which In Shu"t Shivtei Yisrael I (siman 23), the question was asked regarding colored
are sold throughout the year to non-Jews for use in honor of their holidays. Is candles that a Jew wishes to sell to storekeepers, when it is known that these
there any prohibition against using them as Sukkah decorations? Is there a con- candles are used for the idolatrous practices of non-Jews, although they are
cern of avodah zarah? sometimes also used for permissible purposes. Is he permitted to sell them, or
should he be concerned that the storekeeper will sell them to houses of wor-
A: Sukkah decorations whose packaging states that they are intended for the ship? He discusses the matter at length with regard to the laws of lifnei d'lefnei
holiday of non-Jews, as well as candles whose packaging states that they are and other considerations, and combines several reasons why even a person who
intended to be lit in their houses of worship, do not pose a concern of decora- wishes to be stringent does not need to do so. See there for the full discussion.
tions of avodah zarah. Since they are manufactured in factories for commercial In Mar'os Y echezkel I (p. 456), Rav Yechezkal Roth zt"l was asked whether a
sale, and the writing on the packaging is merely advertising for sales purposes, Jew may purchase candles intended for avodah zarah from one non-Jew and
it is permissible to hang them in the Sukkah and to use the candles for Shabbos sell them to another non-Jew, as well as whether someone who owns a candle
lights. The reasoning behind this ruling appears to be based on the words of the store may sell such candles when non-Jews come into his store. He ruled that if
Shulchan Aruch, which indicate that even decorations of avodah zarah are not a non-Jew purchases a large quantity from him, making it apparent that he is
prohibited unless they have actually been used as decorations. This also ap- purchasing them for commercial purposes, it is permissible.
pears from the words of the Chasam Sofer, cited in the Mishnah Berurah (O.C. Regarding the second question, he ruled that if a person owns a store where
154:11). various people, including non-Jews, come to purchase candles, and they wish
Furthermore, the Shulchan Aruch later (se'if 13) writes that candles and wax to purchase candles that are known to be intended for their holiday, if he cannot
belonging to avodah zarah, as well as the ornaments of its priests, are prohibit- avoid selling them, he should take a non-Jewish partner into the store and stipu-
ed for a mitzvah because they are ma'us — repulsive. There, the case is one in late with him from the outset that part of the candles belong to the non-Jew. A
which they were already used for avodah zarah but were subsequently nullified, non-Jewish employee should then hand the candles to the non-Jewish customer
so that they are permitted for ordinary use, yet they remain prohibited for a at the time of the sale. See also Shu"t Emek HaTeshuvah VIII (siman 94).
mitzvah because of their repulsive association. See also the Biur HaGra, who
cites the Gemara in Avodah Zarah (43a). However, when they have never actu- Carrying the Arba Minim by Mistake on the First Day of Sukkos When It
ally been used for avodah zarah, there is no prohibition. Falls on Shabbos
In Shu"t Shevet HaLevi II (siman 57), the same ruling is given, explaining that
there is no prohibition unless the object has already been in their house of wor- Q: I was asked about a person who, several years ago, when the first day of
ship. He proves this from the Mordechai. If it was merely designated for Sukkos fell on Shabbos, mistakenly left his home carrying a bag containing his
avodah zarah, it does not become prohibited, since hazmanah l'avodah zarah tallis together with his arba minim. Fortunately, he noticed that nobody else on
lav milsa hi. He adds that one should not be more stringent in this case on the the street was carrying their arba minim, and he immediately realized that it
grounds that the items were manufactured in a factory specifically for avodah was Shabbos and that one may not take the arba minim on Shabbos. He now
zarah, making this more than mere designation. This is because it is well wondered what he should do. Must he put them down immediately in the mid-
known that factories manufacture products for all different purposes, and since dle of the street, even though he might not find them after Shabbos? Or may he
the manufacturing is done by machines, with no human hand directly involved continue carrying them back to his home?
in the production, there is no disqualifying intent. Likewise, the boxes printed
with pictures or statements indicating that they are intended for their avodah A: In short and just regarding the practical ruling, based on the words of the
zarah are simply designed for advertising and sales purposes. See also Shu"t Sha'ar HaTziyun (O.C. 654 s.k. 3), in the name of the Pri Megadim and Bikurei
Shevet HaKehati II (siman 215) and III (siman 196, os 4), and Simchas Y israel, Yaakov, if a person has already taken the arba minim with him, even though
Hilchos Sukkah (ch. 16, note 860). Rav Yosef Belsky zt"l ruled regarding sell- they are muktzeh, he does not have to put them down immediately. Rather, he
ing these types of lights, Christmas trees, and similar items that nowadays they may continue walking with them to wherever he needs to go in order to return
are not actually worshipped and are merely a remembrance of the old practice. them to a safe place.
See more on the topic in the Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 154:11), Mishnah Berurah
(s.k. 44-45). Therefore, lights such as these, which are purchased in a store and Placing an Esrog Between Apples on Shabbos to Help It Turn Yellow
have never actually been used for avodah zarah, are permitted according to the
strict halachah to be hung in the Sukkah. Nevertheless, it appears that when it is Q: When the first day of Sukkos falls on Shabbos, there is a question whether
apparent that they were specifically made for the holiday of those who worship one may intentionally place an esrog between apples on Friday night so that it
avodah zarah, it is not appropriate to use them to decorate one's Sukkah. will become more yellow by Sunday morning, when he will fulfill the mitzvah.
A: The question is whether this involves a con- Practical Corner: By Rabbi Nesanel Odzer from the Rabba-
cern of tzove'a (coloring), tikkun mana (fixing an nim of Beis Horaah KLY:
object), muktzeh, or hachana (preparing on Shabbos
for after Shabbos). In Shu"t Mishnas Yosef (VII, siman A Clean Esrog Without a Pitum or a Scratched Esrog With One?
77 s.k. 5), it is written that although we rule that there is no
prohibition of tzove'a with regard to food, nevertheless, since Q: Which is preferable: a clean esrog without a pitum, or a kosher esrog
the esrog has been set aside for the mitzvah, it is difficult to say with a pitum that has numerous blettlach (surface marks)?
that it is considered ordinary food. Furthermore, this is not really an
act of coloring, but rather the ripening of a green fruit that has not yet A: To answer this question, we must first understand the halachic issues
fully ripened. According to this, however, it would seemingly be pro- concerning a missing pitum and blettlach.
hibited because of tikkun mana, unless the esrog is not green like a leek A Missing Pitum: One of the pesulim of an esrog is chaser, meaning that
and one merely wishes to return it between the apples in order to allow part of the esrog is missing. The Shulchan Aruch rules that an esrog whose
it to ripen further, in which case it presumably would not be considered pitum was removed is pasul (O.C. 648:7). The Rema adds that if the esrog
tikkun mana. never had a pitum, it is kosher. The Mishnah Berurah explains that this is
Rav Yom Tov Zanger Shlit”a in his sefer Madanei Zahav writes, It seems because such esrogim naturally grow without a pitum, which is considered
to me that there is a difficulty with his initial reasoning. The possibility derech gideilosson, their normal manner of growth (M.B. 648:32). The
that this should be permitted because there is no tzove'a with food is very question is whether this leniency applies only to an esrog that never had a
difficult, because if the purpose is to improve the appearance of the food, pitum, or whether it extends to one whose pitum fell off naturally during
it is prohibited, as the Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 320 s.k. 56) writes in the its growth.
name of the Pri Megadim (ibid., Eishel Avraham s.k. 25) regarding adding Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv zatzal understood the Rema literally. The
color to whiskey intended for sale (see also Kehillos Yaakov, Shabbos, leniency applies only when the pitum fell off at such an early stage that the
siman 40). As for his stringency based on the fact that the esrog has been fruit had not yet attained the relevant halachic status of an esrog. If it fell
set aside for the mitzvah, this too is difficult, because we are discussing off later, the esrog may be pasul because of chaser (He'aros, Sukkah 35b).
the period before Sukkos, when it cannot be said that the esrog has already Rav Elyashiv therefore ruled that it is better to take the esrog with the
been designated for the mitzvah, since we rule that hazmanah lav milsa hi pitum, even if it is not as aesthetically nice.
(see Biur Halachah, O.C. 665 s.v. v'harei). Nevertheless, even according to Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach zatzal, however, understood that the deter-
his approach, there is room to be lenient when the esrog is not green like a mining factor is derech gideilosson. If an esrog naturally loses its pitum
leek. The Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 648 s.k. 65) writes that if the esrog has during growth, it is not considered chaser, even if this occurs at a later
already begun, to some degree, to return to the normal color of an esrog, stage (Halichos Shlomo, Sukkos, ch. 10, sec. 18). According to Rav Shlo-
it is kosher. Therefore, in such a case, it would seemingly not be consid- mo Zalman, one should therefore choose the cleaner esrog without a pi-
ered tikkun mana. tum. This was also the ruling of Rav Avigdor Nebenzahl shlita when we
We can also add the opinion of Rashi in Shabbos (74b), who explains asked him halacha lemaaseh.
that one who places a barrel into a kiln in order to harden it does not Blettlach: The Rema discusses the common marks caused by leaves rub-
violate makeh b'patish, since the process is completed on its own. bing against an esrog as it grows and rules that, within certain parameters,
Perhaps the same reasoning can be applied to our esrog, which is they do not invalidate it (O.C. 648:13). Nevertheless, an esrog covered
simply placed between apples and ripens on its own. However, the with blettlach is less mehudar than a clean esrog, in keeping with the prin-
Minchas Chinuch (mitzvah 32, Melaches Ofeh, melachah 11, os 7) ciple of Zeh Keili Veanveihu, which teaches us to perform mitzvos in a
cites the Rosh in Beitzah (34a), who disagrees with Rashi on this mehudar manner (Shabbos 133b). Mori v'Rabbi Rav Yitzchok Berkowitz
point, and he remains with a tzarich iyun. shlita suggested a compromise between the two opinions. If the esrog with
In Shu"t Machazeh Eliyahu (I, siman 65, s.k. 24), it is written that the pitum has only a few blettlach and is still attractive, it is preferable to
it has not been clearly established whether the melachah of satisfy Rav Elyashiv's stringency. However, if it is heavily scratched, the
tzove'a applies when no color is actually being placed onto the clean esrog without a pitum is preferable.
object, but rather the color changes only through a chemical Why This Year Provides an Additional Reason to Rely on Rav Shlomo
process. He writes that this has practical relevance to our case, Zalman: The psul of chaser applies only on the fir st day of Sukkos,
where a person performs an action in order to cause an esrog since nowadays, without the Beis Hamikdash, that is the only day on
to become yellow. He compares this to a person intentional- which taking the daled minim is mid'oraisa. Throughout the rest of Suk-
ly sitting in the sun so that the heat of the sun will cause his kos, when the obligation is mid'rabbanan, an esrog that is missing part of
skin to become somewhat darker, or wearing sunglasses its body is kosher. The Rema rules that an esrog whose pitum was re-
that turn dark when exposed to sunlight. moved has the same status (O.C. 649:5). Therefore, since this year the first
There is also a concern of hachana, since the esrog will day of Sukkos falls on Shabbos, when we do not take the daled minim,
not be used on Shabbos. In Shu"t Shevet HaKehati (IV, there would be room to say that the entire issue of chaser does not apply
siman 176), it is written that there is no prohibition of this year. However, for bnei Chutz La'aretz, the poskim disagree whether
hachana, since one may place the esrog wherever he Yom Tov Sheini has the stringencies of the first day or the more lenient
wishes. I subsequently saw that Maran HaRav Elyash- status of the remaining days. Accordingly, the Shulchan Aruch rules that
iv zt"l permitted placing an esrog between apples on one who has only an esrog with a first-day disqualification should take it
Shabbos. He explained that this is not considered on Yom Tov Sheini without a bracha (O.C. 649:5; M.B. s.k. 50).
tikkun, since the esrog is kosher even without this Thus, although the concern is not entirely eliminated, this year provides an
process, and it is not considered tzove'a, since noth- additional snif l'hakel to rely on Rav Shlomo Zalman's ruling and choose a
ing new is being added; rather, the green color is clean, mehudar esrog without a pitum over a less mehudar esrog with a
being removed. pitum.
Take a part in spreading the light!
Email info@kollellihoraah.org for sponsorship opportunities.
To receive this weekly publication via email, Click here or email info@kollellihoraah.org.
Our Annual Slichos Campaign is still going!
ONLY 5K left to go!!
Donate here: https://causematch.com/kl2026
