Rebbe Responsa - English — Sukkos (2026-09-21)

REBBE
RESPONSA
The Rebbe's English Letters
Lulav and Esrog
Issue 176
Rebbe Responsa | 2
ב”ה
A Word from the Publishers
We are pleased to present Issue 176 of Rebbe Responsa, a
collection of the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s English letters on the Yom
Tov of Sukkos, and the Mitzvah of Lulav and Esrog.
Included in this week’s booklet is a previously unpublished
letter. All Titles, Summaries, and Footnotes were added by the
publisher unless otherwise noted.
* * *
To enjoy the full collection of the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s
English letters, we encourage you to download the Rebbe
Responsa app. With over 5,000 letters organized by both topic
and date, the app makes finding the Rebbe’s guidance and
worldview on a vast array of topics simple and accessible.
May the study of these letters hasten the coming of
Moshiach speedily in our days.
The Rebbe Responsa Team
13 Tishrei, 5787
To receive a free digital copy of Rebbe Responsa every week:
Email: Editor@RebbeResponsa.com
WhatsApp: chat.rebberesponsa.com
All previous issues of Rebbe Responsa are available at
booklets.rebberesponsa.com
3 | Sukkos
Table of Contents
The Unity of Sukkos ............................................................... 4
The two movements of Tishrei: the first half uplifting oneself toward
G-dliness through Teshuvah, and the second half drawing G-dliness
into the physical world through the mitzvos of Sukkos; Jewish unity as
the central theme that pervades the entire month, expressed in the
mitzvah of Lulav and Sukkah
An Esrog with a Tradition .................................................... 8
A gift of an Esrog from Eretz Yisrael; the need for a reliable tradition
that the Esrog is not grafted in order for it to be kosher
Why Not from the Holy Land? .......................................... 10
Answering the argument that one must use only Esrogim from Eretz
Yisrael; a parallel from Eretz Yisrael’s own need to purchase foreign
weapons when necessary
Newly Released
The Artist’s Shlichus ............................................................. 12
New Year blessing; spiritual and physical wellbeing; utilizing one’s
artistic talents to promote Yiddishkeit
Rebbe Responsa | 4
1
The Unity of Sukkos
The two movements of Tishrei: the first half uplifting oneself toward
G-dliness through Teshuvah, and the second half drawing G-dliness into the
physical world through the mitzvos of Sukkos; Jewish unity as the central
theme that pervades the entire month, expressed in the mitzvah of
Lulav and Sukkah
FREE RENDITION
By the Grace of G-d*
131–14th of Tishrei
Erev Chag haSuccos,2 5737
Brooklyn, N.Y.
To the Sons and Daughters of
Our People Israel, Everywhere,
G-d bless you all!
Greeting and Blessing:
As we are now coming from the Holy Day (Yom Kippur), which
comes “once a year,”3 marking the conclusion and completion of the
Ten Days of Teshuva; and on the threshold of the Festival of Succos,
the Season of Our Rejoicing, which ushers in the second half of the
month of Tishrei, and which is the conclusion and completion of all
the festivals of chodesh hashvii,
The latter term, in addition to meaning simply the “seventh
month,” also means the “sated month,”4 filled, as it is, with all good
things, both materially and spiritually, as our Sages of blessed
memory explain —
Source: Photocopy of the original.
Note: The English renditions of the Rebbe’s Michtavim Klali’im (circular letters
addressed to every Jew) were edited by the Rebbe. The Rebbe’s original Hebrew
endnotes are published at the end of the letter. The Yiddish version of this letter
(with slight variations) is printed in Likkutei Sichos, vol. 14, pp. 469 ff; Igros
Kodesh, vol. 32, letter 11958 (pp. 2 ff.).
5 | Sukkos
It is well to consider the significance of the coming days in
relation to the first part of the month, and to draw the proper
inference.
In general, the month of Tishrei is divided into two basic parts,5
which differ from one another, yet complete each other, and also
make it into one integral month that serves as an introduction and
start of the new year,
The first part of the month is permeated with the spirit of
Teshuva. Jews experience an impulse to move away from their state
and to uplift6 themselves towards (more) spirituality and G-dliness.
This, in substance, is the general aspect7 of the Ten Days of
Teshuva, in line with our Sages’ explanation8 that the admonition
and plea, “Seek G-d when He is found, call on Him when He is
near,”9 refers to the Ten Days of Teshuva. Also the subsequent four
days come under the impact9* of Teshuva; so that the 15th day of
the month is designated as the “first day” – the first day of a new
accounting.
The second part of the month of Tishrei stands under the
influence of a movement which is directed towards bringing G-
dliness down to earth by means of making the material things of the
world things of holiness and Mitzvos, and to such an extent as to
call forth joy, singing, and dancing – which is the point of the festival
of Succos, the Season of Our Rejoicing. The Mitzva consists in
having one’s daily meals, etc. in the Succah. The eating becomes a
Mitzva, a reminder10 of the miracles attending the Exodus from
Egypt, etc.
This joy finds particular expression in the Four Kinds, which
have to be taken together right from the first day of the festival
(except on Shabbos), as the Torah says: “And11 you shall take unto
yourselves on the first day a beautiful tree-fruit” (with emphasis on
the fruit’s beauty) – together with three other kinds, which are
made into a Mitzva, with a Brochoh praising G-d “Who has
sanctified us with His commandments and commanded us”; and to
do this with the kind of joy described by the words, “And11 you shall
rejoice before G-d, your G-d,”
The said two aspects of the month of Tishrei, in the form of
movements “from below – upwards” and “from above –
Rebbe Responsa | 6
downwards,” complete each other and create one integral whole, as
stated earlier.
***
In addition, there is an essential point common to both parts of
the month. It also serves as an introduction into the month and
pervades all aspects of the month. It is the unity of the Jewish
people.
Before the month begins,12 namely, on the Shabbos before Rosh
Hashanah, the Torah reading for the assembled congregation is:
“You13 are standing firmly this day, all of you, before G-d, your G-d.”
Jews stand firmly all together before G-d; “all of you” – “all
individuals as one,”14 “as one complete unit” – like one body.
In like manner is the second part of the month ushered in with
the Mitzva of Succah, which embraces15 and unifies all who are in it,
regardless of station, from the highest to the most ordinary; indeed,
it has been declared that “All Jews are worthy to dwell in one
Succah.”16
Even more emphatically17 is the unity of the Jewish people
expressed in the Mitzva of the Four Kinds – Esrog, Lulav, Myrtle,
and Willow – which, as is well known reflect18 the four kinds of Jews,
from those who have both “taste” and “fragrance” (Torah and
Mitzvos) to those who (as yet) have neither taste nor fragrance. And
only when all four kinds are united together19 it is possible to fulfil
the Mitzva.
***
As in all matters of Torah, so also in the above-mentioned topics,
are many pertinent instructions and inferences. A most simple and
clear instruction, one that relates to actual deed, which is the
essential thing, has to do with the Mitzva of Veohavto Ire’acho
komocho.20 As emphasized in many sources, this means to love a
Jew, every Jew, however he is and wherever he is; and komocho –
“like yourself,” as a part of yourself, as explained in Talmud
Yerushalmi,21 the other Jew is to be regarded as “a bone of my bones
and flesh of my flesh” – as part of the very same body.
Also komocho in this sense: Just as a person, while aware of his
own failings, will disregard them, because (by reason of self-love) it
is a case of “Love covers all sins,”22 and despite his failings he will
7 | Sukkos
strive with the utmost effort to provide all his needs, material and
spiritual, and he does it with vitality – so must be his attitude
towards another Jew.
Especially considering that in regard to one’s own failings one
surely knows the truth, whereas in regard to somebody else’s, “no
person knows what is in the heart of another person”;23 hence a
person can easily err in his estimation and judgment of another
individual.
***
May G-d grant that it be the Season of Our Rejoicing in the
fullest measure; and, in accordance with the purpose of every
festival, which requires that the “content” of the festival should
influence and vitalize24 the days that follow the festival, so be it also
with the Season of Our Rejoicing: that the joy of the festival should
inspire and animate all the days of the year, in keeping with the
;)words in Tehillim: “And I will for ever declare (the wonders of G-d
I will sing unto the G-d of Jacob.”25
With esteem and blessing for
a Happy Yom Tov,
*/Signed: Menachem Schneerson/
(2להעיר (1 1יום הילולא של אדמו”ר מהר”ש )בשנת תרמ”ג( ,ראה ס’ התולדות – אדמו”ר מהר”ש.
שאז “צריך לפזר מעות לעניים” )סידור ש’ הסוכות רנז ,ג( .ועד”ז בשע”ת לשו”ע או”ח סתרכ”ה
(4ויק”ר פכ”ט ,ח. (3להעיר מתוד”ה עד )מנחות יח ,א(. )ומפרע”ח ש’ חה”ס בסופו(.
(5שמאלו תחת לראשי )עשי”ת( וימינו תחבקני )חה”ס( – זח”ג ריד ,ב )אוה”ת ראה ע’ תרצז .ובכ”מ(.
בנוגע הימים שבין יוהכ”פ וחה”ס – הם ימי שמחה )מהרי”ל הובא באחרונים לשו”ע או”ח סו”ס תרכ”ד(.
וראה פע”ח ש’ חה”ס פ”א )ושה”כ וסי’ האריז”ל במקומם( .לקו”ת סוכות )עט ,א( .פתגם אדנ”ע שאז
“דארפן ערשט תשובה טאן” )סה”מ חש”ט ע’ .(42ימים שלאחרי החג – שאין אומרים בהם החנון כו’
)סידור אדה”ז .וראה מג”א סו”ס תרס”ט( .אין מתענין כו’ מפני שהחודש מרובה במועדות )ב”י או”ח
(6כמרז”ל כל ימיו בתשובה )שבת קנג ,א( וראה רמב”ם הל’ תשובה פ”ב ה”ח סתצ”ב( .ואכ”מ.
בסופה .תניא פכ”ט )לו ,ב( .לקו”ת ר”פ האזינו (7 .וישנה תשובה מיוחדה לר”ה ותק”ש )רמב”ם הל’
תשובה פ”ג ה”ד( ,ליוהכ”פ )רמב”ם שם פ”ב ה”ז( ועוד .וראה תורת הבעש”ט עה”פ כי לולא התמהמנו
(9ישעי’ נה ,ו. (8ר’’ה יח ,א .במכתב דוא”ו תשרי בארוכה. )כתר ש”ט .הוספות סי”ג(.
(10ובפרט * (9מאו”ח סתקפ״א שאז “עוסקים במצות סוכה ולולב ואין עושין עונות” וראה ט”ז שם.
להפס”ד דבסוכות הושבתי היינו ענני הכבוד )שו”ע או”ח סתרכ”ה .וכ”פ רש”י ויקרא כג ,מג( .וראה שו”ע
(11ויקרא כג ,מ. אדה”ז שם שזהו חלק בקיום המצוה )ועפי”ז יובן מה שהובא זה בשו”ע הב”י(.
(15להעיר מענין האושפיזין )והזמנת (14לקו”ת שם. (13ר”פ נצבים. (12טאו”ח סתכ”ח.
עניים( דבסוכה )זח”ג קג ,ב )ועיי”ש צד ,ב(( .ובסי’ ש’ הסוכות .וראה או”ת ס”פ בהר – .ל’ אושפיזא ראה
(16סוכה כז ,ב .וראה ד”ה בסוכות תשבו תרצ”ד לקוטי לוי”צ לזוהר )ח”א ע’ רסו .ח”ב ע’ שו(.
(17להעיר שע”י הלולב כו’ נמשך הגילוי דסוכה בפנימיות )סד”ה לולב וערבה )בסה”מ תשי”א(.
Rebbe Responsa | 8
2
An Esrog with a Tradition
A gift of an Esrog from Eretz Yisrael; the need for a reliable tradition
that the Esrog is not grafted in order for it to be kosher
By the Grace of G-d*
20th of Elul, 5720
Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mr. Zalmon Jaffe
105. Cavendish Road
Salford, 8, Lancs.
Greeting and Blessing:
I received your two letters of August 22nd and 26th…
…Hoping to hear good news from you, and wishing you again a
Ksivo vachasimo, toivo, including, of course, a greater improvement
in your business affairs,
With blessing,
M. Schneerson
I want to thank you also for your good will to send me an Esrog
which you yourself plucked from the tree on your recent visit to
המשך וככה.( וגם שבכאו”א אחדות )סי’ ש’ הלולב19 . יב,( ויק”ר פ”ל18 .( ובכ”מ.תרס”ו
. וראה קונטרס אהבת ישראל בארוכה. יח,( קדושים יט20 .( צג ואילך,תרל”ז – פפ”ז
ולהעיר שהשווה. ב,( פסחים נד23 .( סהמ”צ להצ”צ מצות אהבת ישראל22 . ה”ד,( נדרים פ”ט21
( תהלים25 . ב,( לקו”ת ברכה צח24 .(זה שם לידיעת מלכות ב”ד מתי תחזור )ראה אגה”ק סכ”ב
. יו”ד ובתרגום,עה
Source: Photocopy of the original.
Mr. Shneur Zalmon Jaffe (5673–5760/1913–2000) was a businessman in
Manchester, England. In the early 1950s, he was drawn to Lubavitch and
developed a close and unique personal relationship with the Rebbe. Over time,
he became one of the foremost supporters and activists of Lubavitch in England.
For additional biographical information and over 200 letters he received from
the Rebbe, see letter dated 20 Iyar, 5713, and as referenced there; Mr. Manchester
(England, 2003).
9 | Sukkos
Eretz Yisroel. However, you surely know that an Esrog must be one
that is not murkov, that is to say, that grows on a tree which had not
been crossed with another species, and we use Esrogim concerning
which we have a tradition that they meet this requirement. So the
first qualification of an Esrog is not so much where it comes from,
but the certainty that it is not a murkov. Unfortunately, the place
you mention is one of which I never heard that it should have that
tradition, and even in Eretz Yisroel itself the Esrogim usually come
from other places, but not the one you mention. Obviously, where
this essential matter is in doubt, there is the question of making a
blessing in vain, and above all, the doubt whether the Mitzvah of
Esrog will be fulfilled. I trust that you, too, have ordered for yourself
an Esrog which is definitely not murkov, and Anash surely know how
and where to get such Esrogim.
Rebbe Responsa | 10
3
Why Not from the Holy Land?
Answering the argument that one must use only Esrogim from Eretz
Yisrael; a parallel from Eretz Yisrael’s own need to purchase foreign
weapons when necessary
[5724]*
Mr. …
Brooklyn, New York
Greeting and Blessing:
Your letter reached me with some delay, and my reply was
further delayed because of pressure of duties.
In your letter you link the question of help to Eretz Yisrael with
the mitzvah of etrog, and you argue that one should use etrogim
from Eretz Yisrael exclusively.
Judging by your background, as reflected in your letter, I trust it
is unnecessary to emphasize to you at length that there is no
connection between the mitzvah of Etrog Bentshen and support of
Eretz Yisrael from the viewpoint of the Shulchan Aruch, or even that
of common sense. A simple illustration of this point would be the
case of parents and their devotion to their children. Regardless of
the level of that devotion, if the parents need some advice or require
a certain article, surely they are not obliged to patronize their
children’s business if their children are not in a position to supply
that need. It is evident from your letter that you know the reason
why those who obtain their etrogim from another country, and not
from Eretz Yisrael, do so. The reason is not because they have a
particular attitude towards that particular country, but because an
Published: The Letter and the Spirit, vol. 1, p. 237.
Note: Letters printed in The Letter and the Spirit are from the archives of Rabbi
Nissan Mindel, the secretary entrusted with transcribing the Rebbe’s orally
dictated responses. The archive consists of secretarial copies that may not
include the Rebbe’s final edits, as well as drafts and unsent letters, and may have
been published with slight editorial changes.
11 | Sukkos
etrog, according to the poskim, requires certain qualities, and they
are particular to obtain the etrog that has all these qualities. As to
why the poskim require those qualities in an etrog, there is ample
literature on the subject that you will find referred to in the
appropriate sources.1
Incidentally, you surely know that the Government of Eretz
Yisrael buys weapons from foreign countries, and does not insist
upon using only its own domestically produced weapons for the
simple reason that they do not satisfy its requirements.2
As for your questions relating to particular dinim connected
with the laws of etrog, any qualified Rav can answer your questions
in detail, and also give you the sources and references in the
poskim.
Although you do not mention it explicitly, I trust that you have
regular appointed times for the study of the Torah every day, and
that your daily conduct is in harmony with the teachings of the
Torah. About the essential need of both there can surely be no
question, since they are frequently emphasized in Chumash.
With blessing,
1
See Shu"t Chasam Sofer, Orach Chayim, Siman 207; Sha'ar Hakolel, chapter 37;
Sedei Chemed, Asifas Dinim, s.v. Esrog; ibid., Kelalim, s.v. Lulav UMinav.
2
In a handwritten answer addressing the question of why Lubavitch uses
Esrogim specifically from Calabria, Italy, and not from Eretz Yisrael, the Rebbe
makes the same point and elaborates with a more detailed comparison (Igros
Kodesh, vol. 26, letter 9983. See A Chassidsiher Derher, Issue 135 (Tishrei, 5784),
p. 19, for an English translation).
Rebbe Responsa | 12
– Newly Released –
4
The Artist’s Shlichus
New Year blessing; spiritual and physical wellbeing; utilizing one’s
artistic talents to promote Yiddishkeit
By the Grace of G-d*
In the days of Selichoth,
5742. Brooklyn. N. Y.
Mr. Shevach Michel Schwartz
14 Clover Drive
Great Neck, N. Y. 11021
Greeting and Blessing:
With the approach of Rosh Hashono, the beginning of the New
Year, may it bring blessing to us all, I send you and all yours my
prayerful wishes for a good and happy year, materially and
spiritually.
With the traditional blessing of,
כתיבה וחתימה טובה
Cordially, M. Schneerson
P.S. I take this opportunity to acknowledge receipt of your letter
of April 21st (and encl. many thanks), which, for various reasons,
Source: Photocopy of the original, courtesy of Hassidic Archives.
Mr. Shevach Michel Schwartz (1926–2011) was an acclaimed Jewish artist,
graphic designer, and Hebrew calligrapher. While attending the Lubavitch
yeshivah in Brooklyn in the 1940s, he was hired by the Rebbe, then director of
Merkos L’Inyonei Chinuch, to illustrate Talks and Tales and other educational
publications. He later designed the emblems of Merkos L’Inyonei Chinuch and
Tzivos Hashem.
13 | Sukkos
mainly due to pressure of duties, has not been acknowledged
previously.
I want to assure you, first of all, that I was very gratified to read
the good news about your well-being and the well-being of your
family, both spiritually and materially, thank G-d. Although this
should not be surprising, in view of your association with Lubavitch
for many years, as I recall, it is good to have it confirmed by yourself.
May G-d grant that you should continue to be "a contented
person," both spiritually and physically, and in a growing measure,
and that you should have growing Hatzlocho in utilizing your
talents in the fullest measure, not only as a source of ample
Parnosso, but also as a vehicle to promote Yiddishkeit, Torah and
Mitzvoth.
( תניא3) sent separately
Rebbe Responsa | 14
Dedicated in honor of the birthdays of
Yoel שי׳Vichnin
יואל בן רחל חינקה
6 Tishrei
Chaya Mushka שתחי׳Vichnin
חיה מושקא בת רחל חינקה
13 Tishrei
Ari שי׳Nemes
אהרן מאיר בן עטיל
15 Tishrei
Meir שי׳Friedman
מאיר ישראל איסר הכהן בן צביה
16 Tishrei
Yitzchok שי׳Nemes
יצחק בן תמר
16 Tishrei
Distribution of the Rebbe Responsa booklet has been made possible by
the generous support of the Baal Shem Tov Path Foundation
אימ˙י ˜א˙י מר לכ˘יפוˆו מעיינו˙יך חוצה
Reach out to dedicate an upcoming issue and help inspire countless Yidden worldwide:
Editor@RebbeResponsa.com | +1 (347) 788 1304
