Vayomer Eliyahu - English — Sukkos (2026-09-21)

ערב
By Rabbi Eli Meyer Smith Shlit”a
Rosh Hakollel of Bais Ulfana Lehoroa »
שנת תשפ "ז
«Email rabbi@yeshivasrebchaim ozer.com
בס"ד
After One Purifies Himself From His Sins, He Can See the Ultimate Truth and
Receive The Inspiration of The Sukkah!
›› Why Do We Begin Building Our Sukkah Right Yom Kippur, when he learned that Esav was approaching
After Yom Kippur? with 400 men, all of whom sought to harm him and rile up
the evil forces against him. He then increased his prayers
The Rama (end of Siman 624, and again in 625) states: and supplications.
“Those who are stringent in mitzvos begin building their
sukkah immediately after Yom Kippur in order to go from Esav then changed tactics and acted as if he wanted
one mitzvah to another mitzvah.” to help Yaakov. Yaakov did not want “neither his sting nor
his honey.” He, therefore, told Esav to travel ahead of him
We may ask: If the reason for this is to go from mitzvah and be separate from him. This occurred at the time of
to another, why should this be done specifically with the Neilah, when Hashem annuls the debt of the nation and
mitzvah of erecting a sukkah? Why can’t someone simply forgives them.
do any mitzvah on Motzoei Yom Kippur?
Since these evil forces separated from Yaakov, and
It would seem from here that there is some deeper separated from Above as well, Hashem desired to hear
connection between the mitzvah of sukkah and Yom Klal Yisroel. The place was, therefore, named Sukkos
Kippur. It is not a “coincidence” that they fall out near because it was there that Yaakov created sukkos to
each other on the calendar. separate himself from Esav, and Hashem rejoiced with
him there.
The Tur (Orech Chaim 417) states: “I heard from my
brother, Rav Yehuda…that the three holidays are From the words of the Zohar, we see that the
symbolic of the three Avos. Pesach is symbolic of “sukkos” Yaakov made represent the battle between
Avrohom Avinu, as it is stated (Bereishis 18:6): “Knead forces of good and forces of evil. The sukkos are where
dough and make cakes” – it was Pesach. Shavuos is Klal Yisroel runs to, in order to escape from impure
symbolic of Yitzchok because the shofar blown at the influences.
giving of the Torah was from the ram of the akeidas
Yitzchok. Sukkos is symbolic of Yaakov, as is stated Sefer Chemdas Yamim uses this Zohar to explain the
(Bereishis 33:17): ‘And for his cattle he made sukkos. custom to begin building one’s sukkah right after Yom
Therefore, he named the place Sukkos.’” Kippur, before one does any other work. He says that
Esav left Yaakov right after Yom Kippur, which is when
We may wonder why Yaakov called the place Yaakov entered the sukkah of purity. Thus, the two are
“Sukkos" after the booths he made for his cattle. Why intimately connected, and it is very appropriate to place
wouldn’t he rather name it “Bayis” after the houses he the two right next to each other.
made for himself and his family, which would seem to be
more appropriate? Furthermore, why does the verse ›› Why is One Especially Joyful on Sukkos?
need to tell us about the booths he made for his cattle at We can further understand the connection between
all? Why is this of interest? Sukkos and the Yomim Noraim by noting the reason for
The Zohar Hakadosh (Raya Mehemnusa 101A) speaks the mitzvah of sukkah.
about the connection the story of Yaakov and Esav has to The pasuk states (Vayikroh 23:42-43): “You shall dwell in
the holidays of Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, and Sukkos. sukkos for seven days, every citizen of Yisroel
To paraphrase the Zohar’s holy words, it shall dwell in them, so that your generations
states that after Esav constantly sought to will know that I had the children of Yisroel live
harm Yaakov, Yaakov fled during the days in sukkos when I took them out of the land of
between Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur. He Egypt. I am Hashem your G-d.”
did teshuva and observed fast days until after
}{א
There are some mitzvos in the Torah that have a possessions and place our trust fully in Him. This is also
specific intention that one must have in mind in order to why Sukkos is called “Zeman Simchaseinu”, the time of
fulfill the mitzvah, while others can be fulfilled even happiness, because there is no greater joy than trusting
without having the reason for the mitzvah in mind. The in Hashem (as is explained in Sefer Chovos Halevavos).
Bach (Orech Chaim 525) writes that everyone agrees that in
order to fulfill the mitzvah of sitting in a sukkah, one must This is also why we recite special tefillos and Hoshanos
on this yomtov in which we daven for goodness for the
have in mind the reason for the mitzvah, as the pasuk
clearly says that future generations should know its entire year. This is meant to instill within us the
knowledge that all the blessings of the year are
reason. Accordingly, it is very important for us to clearly
understand what the reason for this mitzvah is. dependent on Hashem’s will and to encourage us to rely
on Him alone, rather than on our own efforts.
The root and main focus of this mitzvah is to bring a
person to have strong emunah in Hashem
This concept is also hinted at in the
avodah of nisuch hamayim, the water
and to know that He is the creator and
pouring ceremony in the Bais Hamikdosh,
sustainer of the world. It was His will that
which was performed on Sukkos. This
we be enslaved in Egypt, and it was His will “…The Jewish
ceremony symbolizes that one should
that we be freed. In this way, He has led
and guided us until today, and everything soul yearns to pour out his heart to Hashem like water
whenever he needs His help. And this is
He has done and continues to do at all connect to why Hashem covers us with his “schach”
times is for our benefit.
Hashem, but the on this yomtov, as we place our trust in
The Rashbam writes: “So that your Him.
generations will know that I had the vanities of this
children of Yisroel live in sukkos for 40
This explains why we are commanded
years, with no set homes and no
world block the to sit in a sukkah specifically during the
season when we gather in our crops
encampment. From this recognition, we love of the heart. (Shemos 34:22). At the time when we gather
will come to give thanks to the One who
provides us with a place to live and houses After Yom our crops, there is room to suspect that
full of goodness, and we will not think that one may come to think that he earned his
Kippur, when our living on his own and that he can put his
we acquired what we own through our
faith in his own abilities. He may come to
own strengths and talents.” souls are
forget that Hashem is the One who
The Gemara says a rule that a sukkah purified, and we sustains him. Therefore, we are
may not be taller than 20 amos. The commanded at this time to enter the
Gemara explains that the reason for this is afflict ourselves sukkah and improve our bitachon.
that if the walls are too tall, a person will by avoiding
not be sitting in the shade of the schach; The Kli Yakar ((Vayikroh 23:42) dwells on
this point and explains that when one
rather, he will be sitting in the shade of the physical desires,
sukkah’s walls. harvests the crops of his field, it is common
love of Hashem for people to wish to return home from
The Aruch Laner explains that the walls the fields to their “permanent homes”.
of a sukkah represent earthly entities that is awakened and The Torah was concerned that people
surround us on all sides. The schach, we merit the would forget that even their houses are
however, is symbolic of Hashem. When merely temporary homes. Therefore, the
one lifts his eyes and recognizes that the mitzvah of verse (ibid) states: “Every citizen in Yisroel
schach, i.e., what is above him, is the main shall dwell in sukkos.” This indicates that
thing, he will realize that Hashem is
sukkah…” everyone who sees himself as a “citizen”,
constantly guiding him and will know that a permanent resident of the land, is
He is providing for him at all times. commanded to leave his home and dwell
in a temporary abode, as a reminder that no home in this
Thus, the purpose of the mitzvah of sukkah is to world is permanent.
remember that Hashem is in control of every aspect of
our lives. For this reason, one must dwell in the shade of When one recognizes this, he will no longer rely on his
the schach, and not in the shade of the walls. own abilities. Rather, he will trust fully in Hashem, just like
the Jewish people when they left Egypt and were
For this reason, we are commanded to leave our surrounded by His clouds of glory and provided for
permanent dwelling and live in a temporary dwelling directly by Him.
(Sukkah 2A). The Sefas Emes zy”a (5645) writes that the
mitzvah of sukkah is meant to teach us to have bitachon The Michtav M’Eliyahu (Chelek Daled) quotes the Sefas
in Hashem. Therefore, we leave our homes and Emes who explains the verse (ibid 23:41): “The holiday of
}{ב
Sukkos…seven days in the year” as follows: realize that it is only temporary. If one is busy with his
physical feelings while in a sukkah, it is a sign that he has
Why does it say “of the year”? What is added with not reached that level.
these seemingly superfluous words? This teaches us that
these seven days should influence our entire year so that Similarly, the Kotzker explains the Gemara that says
we internalize the fact that our homes are merely that rainfall on sukkos is a bad sign because rain is a
temporary. The same idea is seen in the verse (ibid 34:22): symbol of the physical world. If we are forced to deal with
“The holiday of the harvest, a time period of the year.” the physical aspects of this world on sukkos, it is a bad
This also shows that sukkos is meant to influence the sign.
entire year.
›› How Can One Feel His Impermanence in This
The Sefas Emes on the Torah adds: “The main light of World?
the year is from these seven days. The vessel to hold it in
is to accept it with joy.” It seems that the joy he refers to It is certain that in order to reach the level of
from these days is the feeling that we are in this world recognizing that our entire existence in this world is only
only temporarily and, therefore, we lack nothing that we temporary, one must first remove the impurities of the
need. All we need to do is rejoice that we are the Chosen heart that are caused by sins. As long as one is connected
Nation. to sin, and his heart remains impure, he most definitely
will be unable to accept these feelings.
The Sefas Emes states further that “the mitzvah of
sukkah provides blessing and holy light to a person’s After Yom Kippur, when we are cleansed of sin and
dwelling place.” He seems to be saying that the mitzvah our hearts are made pure, we can recognize the concept
of sukkah brings a person to realize this life is temporary, of our temporary status in this world, which is the
and his entire life is simply a means to rise spiritually. Once foundation of the mitzvah of sukkah.
one recognizes this, his home will be blessed and holy all In this manner, the Sefas Emes writes (Sukkos 5651):
year long “During these days of Sukkos, bnei Yisroel strive to cover
The Shulchan Aruch (Orech Chaim 629:13) states the rule themselves in the shade of Hashem Yisborach. The truth
that one may not use anything connected to the ground is that the Jewish soul always yearns to connect to
as schach. Early sources explain that this is because the Hashem, but the vanities of this world block the love of
purpose of the mitzvah of sukkah is to feel that we are the heart. After Yom Kippur, when our souls are purified,
only in this world temporarily. For this reason, we may not and we afflict ourselves by avoiding physical desires, the
use schach that is attached to the ground, as the entire love of Hashem is awakened, and we merit the mitzvah of
purpose of the mitzvah is to detach ourselves from the sukkah.”
earth of this world and remove ourselves from the Having said all this, we can understand why the
ground. sukkah should be built immediately after Yom Kippur,
On the aforementioned verse (Bereishis 33:18) that says before we do any other work.
that Yaakov named the city Sukkos after the booths that The way to ingrain enduring and lasting emunah within
he made for his cattle, Targum Yonason writes: “He built our hearts is explained by the Ramban, who says as
a bais medrash for himself and for his cattle he made follows:
booths.” This can be understood to mean that for his
spiritual needs, he made a bais medrash, and for “his The verse in Shir Hashirim (2:7) states: “You either
cattle”, i.e., for his physical needs, he made temporary awaken or arouse the love while it is desirous.” The
booths. He made a strong, permanent structure for his Ramban (in his sefer Ha’Emunah Veha’Bitachon, Perek 19) explains
ruchnius, while only making a temporary structure for his that this verse hints at a lesson that when one receives
gashmius. inspiration from Heaven, he must actualize this spiritual
arousal by doing a physical action to bring it to practicality
This represents the purpose of the yomtov of Sukkos. and ensure that this inspiration does not merely fade
It teaches us that our physical lives are temporary, while away.
our neshamos are eternal. We leave our physical homes to
dwell in Hashem’s permanent shade for seven days and Therefore, in order to ensure that we do not lose the
to draw closer to Him. level of inspiration that we reached on the day of Yom
Kippur – the level of recognizing that this world is only
In this vein, it is said in the name of the Admor of Kotzk temporary and is a mere hallway to the World to Come –
zt”l that the reason why a “mitz’taer”, one who is in pain, one must immediately do a practical action of building a
is exempt from the mitzvah of sukkah is that if one feels sukkah. This physical action will then serve as the vessel
physical pain from sitting in a sukkah, it is a sign that he is to hold the inspiration that will continue to be with us and
not fully connected to the point of the mitzvah. The entire instill within us the lesson of living in this world in a
point of the mitzvah of sukkah is to detach oneself from temporary way.
the physical aspects of this temporary world and to
}{ג
