Uz Yivka — Sukkos (2026-09-21)

בס"ד should force it to confront and possess absolute humility.
– סוכות תשפ"זCloud Cover This selflessness eliminates the ego entirely, elevating the
The מדרשon פרשת אמר- when the ‘Four Species’ first ערבהto a point where it’s true, intrinsic identity is explicitly
appear - explains1 that each of the ד' מיניםrefers to Hashem revealed and named by the Torah. The other three species
Himself. This מדרשis actually brought in the בית יוסףin require Rabbinic interpretation to define exactly which fruit
!הלכות לולבThe בית יוסףbrings down2 from the great or leaf is intended. For instance, a ""פ ִרי עֵ ץ הָ דָ ר
ְּ - "the fruit of
Kabbalist, the רקנטי, that ' 'על פי קבלהthe הלכהis that the 'ד a majestic tree" could theoretically be many things before
מיניםmust be held together. חז"לspecify the אתרוג. The ערבה, however, is so
This was revealed to the רקנטיone year, on the first straightforward and accessible that even the simplest
night of Succos in a dream. Staying at his house was a pious person recognizes it by name. No elaborate interpretation is
needed.
Yid called Reb Yitzchok. In the dream he saw his guest
writing Hashem’s Name, yet he distanced the final letter ''הא The ערבהis of in itself nothing of note, yet for it to be
from the ו-ה-י. In the dream he challenged this practice counted it must humbly allow itself to be placed amongst
which Reb Yitzchok said was the normal practice in his place. ‘the great’ – the אתרוג לולבand הדס.
The רקנטיawoke not knowing what to make of this dream The ' גמtells us3 that when כלל ישראלproclaim a fast day and
until the next morning he watched how Reb Yitzchok shook pray, they will only be answered by Hashem if צדיקיםand
his ד' מיניםwith the לולבbundle in his right hand and the רשעיםdaven together. Only as a unit - where even a רשע
אתרוגin his left hand but not bringing his hands together so has his contribution of his few מצות- can we be considered
they could touch. Now he understood the meaning of the the unit that is judged in the special capacity of a ציבור.
dream, and he alerted his guest to hold his ד' מיניםtouching Many have noted that the word ציבורitself is made up of the
each other. three letters ר, ב, צ- standing for בינוני, צדיקand רשע. All
The בית יוסףthen brings the מדרשto further understand this levels of the spectrum are present and part of a ציבור.
dream. The אתרוג, called in the תורה, ""פ ִרי עֵ ץ הָ ָדר ְּ is also the The ' גמderives this from the fact that in the ingredients of
expression used to describe Hashem, " ָ“ – "הֹוד וְּהָ ָדר לָבָ ְּשתYou the – קטרתthat which is used in the special יום כיפורservice
are clothed in glory and majesty”. The לולב, called in the and was taken ' – 'לפני ולפניםinside the – קודש הקדשיםwas
תורה, " – "כַּפֹּ ת ְּתמָ ִריםrefers to Hashem as it says, "צַּ ִדיק כַּ תָ מָ ר something called ( חלבנהgalbanum). This חלבנהcreates a
"“ – י ְִּפ ָרחThe Righteous blossom like a date palm”. The הדס foul-smelling odour yet is included in the קטרת-mix. So too
refers to Hashem about whom it says, ""וְּהּוא עֹּמֵ ד בֵ ין הַּ הֲ ַּד ִסים when we get together to daven, we are to include even the
– “and He was standing between the myrtles”. Finally, the רשעים.
ערבות, called in the תורה, " – "עַּ ְּרבֵ י נָחַּ לis the same expression Perhaps we may suggest the following משל. Take a look at a
used regarding Hashem, who is described "– "רֹּכֵב בָ ע ֲָרבֹות nice bouquet of flowers. There will be ‘Focal Flowers’. These
“He who rides on the clouds”. are the showstoppers and the largest blooms in the
Two points caught my attention. Firstly, unlike the other arrangement. They draw the eye immediately and dictate
three species where the name the Torah gives them is the the overall colour palette and style. Then there is the
same as the description of Hashem, the ערבהmeaning ‘Secondary & Filler Flowers’. They consist of smaller or
‘willow’ seemingly has no connection other than sharing the clustered heads that hug the focal blooms. They soften harsh
same letters as the word ' – 'ערבהmeaning cloud. lines, hide empty spaces, and bridge gaps between layers.
Secondly, I note that the ערבהis the only species that is Thirdly there will normally be some ‘Line & Spike Flowers’.
actually called the name the Torah gives it. The other three They provide height, vertical movement, and a sense of
are called by the תורה: ""כַּפֹּ ת ְּתמָ ִרים, ""פ ִרי עֵ ץ הָ דָ ר
ְּ and " ֲענַּף architectural wildness. They draw the eyes outward and
" עֵ ץ עָ בֹּתwhich חז"לinterpret to mean אתרוג, לולבand הדסים. establish the silhouette of the bouquet. Lastly one needs
That the ערבהis singled out by its actual name further ‘Foliage & Greenery’. Greenery forms the skeletal frame of
highlights something unique about it. the bouquet. It frames the colourful blooms, adds organic
texture, and hides the mechanics like floral wire or rubber
There is another quite famous מדרש: The ד' מיניםrepresent
bands.
four types of people. The אתרוגhas both taste and smell.
Taste refers to ‘Torah learning’ and smell refers to 'מעשים The ערבה, the mere ‘Foliage’ is not even part of the price of
'טובים. The אתרוגrepresents the תלמיד חכםwho also is the bouquet yet even it provides the backdrop of the entire
heavily involved in ‘good deeds’. The הדסיםhave no taste bunch. So long as the ''רשע, bereft of ' 'תורה ומעשים טוביםis
but do smell nice. They represent the עם הארץ, the ignorant prepared to be annexed to the rest of – כלל ישראלand
one who still has plenty ''מעשים טובים. The לולבhas taste i.e. crucially we4 are welcoming to him, then we have the unit
the palm tree has dates, but has no smell. This refers to a that makes up a ''ציבור.5
learned person who isn’t involved in the practical side of In fact, the בעל התניאwrites6 that each of these four species
helping others. And then there is the poor ערבהwho has were chosen because they all embody an aspect of unity.
neither ‘Torah learning’ nor ‘Good deeds’ – no smell or The branches of the לולבare all attached; the הדסhas three
taste. leaves growing out of the same point of the stem, the אתרוג
Because the ערבהinherently has ‘nothing of its own’ this grows on its tree for an entire year — thereby uniting the
four disparate seasons — and ערבותgrow in clusters. ‘coming closer’ to share some of His blessing with the
The ערבהitself is called "“ – "עַּ ְּרבֵ י נָחַּ לwillows of the stream". world11. But there must be clouds. There must be a מחיצה
Willows cannot survive without constant access to water. By between us and Hashem’s Presence so that He can come
naming it explicitly alongside its source of life, the Torah closer to us. So too at ‘The Revealtion’ at הר סיני, when
emphasizes that those who feel spiritually empty (lacking Hashem came down it was done under cloud cover, ּומשה ֶ "
"taste and smell") must remain explicitly tied to the water of "ֲשר ָשם הָ אֱֹל ִקים
ֶ “ – נִ גַּש אֶ ל הָ ע ֲָרפֶ ל אand משהapproached the
the Torah to thrive. thick cloud where G-d was”.
With this in hand we can appreciate why the ערבהis called Lastly on יום הכיפוריםwhen the כהן גדולcame into the קודש
so. The root ' 'ערבalways refers to the joining of various הקשיםwe read of the warning not just to come “at all
things together. For example an ' 'ערבis a guarantor. He times” with the death penalty to the one who does. Why?
bridges the gap between the borrower and the lender. An "כַּפֹּרת
ֶ ַּ"כִ י בֶ עָ נָן אֵ ָראֶ ה עַּ ל ה. רש"יin his first פשט- brings the
' 'עירוב חצירותallows the intermingling of people within simple meaning of the פסוק. It is the presence of the שכינה-
certain area. An ' 'עירוב תחומיםallows a person to link his which manifests in a cloud - which causes the death penalty.
current residence with another place further away from him Taking " "כִ יto mean ‘because’, " "בֶ עָ נָןto refer to the cloud of
– outside of his allotted 2000 אמות. We ask every morning the שכינהand " "אֵ ָראֶ הwhich although seems to imply the
that Torah should be ‘sweet’ – ""וְּהַּ ע ֲֶרב נָא. When food is future can also mean the ongoing action the פסוקtranslates,
mixed with various contrasting flavour it becomes sweet. “because with a cloud I constantly appear upon the ark
The plague of ' 'ערובwas the ‘mixture’ of many types of cover”12.
animals. And so, the ערבהis the simple foliage that is the What emerges is that the cloud is what provides the
back drop to the prettier flowers. Its best existence is to be medium for הקב"הto manifest Himself to us. This is why
joined with something else7. ' 'ערבהis the word for cloud. The cloud facilitates the
In fact, on הושענא רבהthe ערבהtakes central stage. The connection and קשר, the closest possible connection
משנהdescribes how they would take long willow branches between us and Hashem. It has the same meaning as all the
and surround the מזבחwith their heads bend over the top above mentioned 'ב-ר- 'עwords.
of the ( מזבחanother reference to the humble nature This brings us very nicely to the סוכה. The שולחן ערוךpaskens
required of the )ערבה. The טwould then proclaim, יֹּפי לְָך ִ " that we sit in the סוכהto commemorate the '– 'ענני הכבוד
" ַּיֹּפי לְָך ִמזְּ בֵ ח
ִ , ַּ“ – ִמזְּ בֵ חBeaty is yours O Altar”. The beauty of the clouds of Glory that surrounded the Yidden during their
the מזבחis highlighted with the ערבהthat joins it - that is sojourning in the desert. We go into the flimsy סוכה. What
exactly what foliage does, it accents the beauty of the the זוהרterms " – "בצלא דמהמנותאin the shade of אמונה.
flower it surrounds. Comfortable with ‘belief’, or better but ‘the steadfastness’
Now we can perhaps suggest how the word ' 'ערבהcan also to the knowledge that Hashem is in control. We are not
mean ‘cloud’. R’ Shimshon Pinkus writes8 that we may think protected by our solid houses but our flimsy סוכה-roof. Just
that a מחיצהprovides separation between people. In truth it like the Yidden were protected from the elements in the
is quite the opposite. If not for the מחיצהthen the men and desert. We should imagine that each of the walls and the
women could not possibly daven or dance in the same roof is the cloud of Hashem. It is His closest manifestation
room. possible to us. We have the אמונה, and the humbleness like
the ערבה-branch that He, who is described "– "רֹּכֵב בָ ע ֲָרבֹות
The ' גמtells us9 that one who dreams of a ‘pot’ can look
“He who rides on the clouds”, is right there just behind the
forward to peace. A pot is designed to prepare food by
cloud a.k.a. the ערבהthat obscures Him13.
using the combined talents of water and fire. Water alone
would ruin the food through soaking. It would also Good Yom Tov, Yaakov
To receive this weekly or for comments please email me on yshibbert@gmail.com
extinguish the fire. Fire alone would burn the food. But
through the mediatory effect of the pot, an environment מ:ט הובא ג"כ ברמב"ן ויקרא כג: ויקרא רבה ל1
proper for cooking is created. The pot makes peace יא: בית יוסף אוה"ח תרנא2
.לד והוא ממשיך להסביר שזה ענין של ערבות בתוך הד' מינים: וע' רבנו בחיי שמות ל: כריתות ו3
between fire and water by separating between the fire and לד "וחלבנה ריחה רע ואף על פי כן הכניסה הכתוב בכלל הבשמים החשובים ובא לרמוז שאין: וז"ל הרבינו בחיי שמות ל4
וכמו שאמרו חז"ל (כריתות ו ע"ב) כל אגודה שאין בה,לנו להקל ברשעים פושעי ישראל שלא יהיו בכלל תעניותינו ותפילתינו
the food. This can be applied to almost any interpersonal וביאור זה כי שם שמים מתעלה ומתקדש בשעה שהרשעים חוזרים בתשובה ונמנין בכלל,מפושעי ישראל אינה אגודה
ומטעם זה נצטוינו במצות.הצדיקים שאם לא כן הצדיקים נתפשים עליהם מפני הערבות שהרי כל ישראל ערבים זה לזה
situation be it marriage or the office. If jobs are not specific, לולב ליקח ארבעה מינים באגודה אחת ולתת ערבה שאין לה טעם וריח רמז לרשעי ישראל שאין להם תורה ומצוות בכלל
if lines are not drawn regrading who does what, to separate ."האתרוג שיש בו טעם וריח ובכלל הלולב שיש בו אוכל וההדס שיש בו ריח ואנו מרצים להקב"ה בכולם כאחד" עכ
" לבאר הרשע "לפי שהוציא את עצמו מן הכלל כפר בעיקר,The Wicked Son - ע' מה שכתבתי לביתי פרשת בא תשעו5
different people, then there will be no harmony in marriage 6
....?איזו עיקר
Sefer HaMaamarim 5568, p. 447
or the office. Each and every person in any relationship Raving Ravens - ע' מה שתכבתי לביתי פרשת פרשת נח תשע"ט7
needs to know his or her boundaries, what is and isn’t ????? 8
This paragraph is adapted from the marriage book, “The River, The Kettle and the Bird” From : ברכות נו9
expected of them. Just like placing a metal utensil between Aharon Feldman
Blurred Boundaries - ע' מה שכתבתי לביתי פרשת כי תצא תשפב10
the fire and the water allows them to work together so too מים ראשונים כדי להיות,' והתקדשתםMelech Mantra' - ולזה צריך להכין ע' מה שכתבתי לביתי ראש השנה תשפז11
understanding the different of roles – of man and woman10, .ראוי לקבל השפעתו
ע' מה שכתבתי לביתי12
or of CEO and secretary – will ensure a harmonious 13
Perhaps to add: – ענני הכבודseparate us from goyim – we get 6 sided ‘view’ ‘exposure’ to HAhsem they
get one ‘view’.
outcome. ורבא לא התפלל."מד "סַּ כֹותָ ה בֶ עָ נָן לְָך מֵ עֲבֹור ְּתפִ לָה: ואיכה ג.ד "שֹּמֵ ר רּוחַּ ל ֹּא יִזְּ ָרע ְּורֹּאֶ ה בֶ עָ בִ ים ל ֹּא י ְִּקצֹור:ע"ע קהלת יא
...בתענית אם יש עבים
Rain at the right time is ''גשמי ברכה. Hashem כביכולis
