gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

Living Appreciation — Sukkos (2026-09-21)

Publisher: Living Appreciation

Week: Sukkos (2026-09-21)

Living Appreciation — Sukkos (2026-09-21)

Open the PDF Download

Contents ❧ Why Sukkos? ................................................................ 1 ❧ Zeman Simchasainu....................................................... 7 ❧ Simchas Beis Hashoevah. ............................................. 11 ❧ A Time Of Unity. ........................................................ 16 ❧ Inspiring quotes. .................................................. 22 ❧ Why Sukkos? Many of the Moadim have a clear reason why we celebrate them. For example, on Pesach we commemorate the Exodus from Egypt and Shavuos, the giving of the Torah. Yet, Sukkos seems more difficult to understand what we are actually celebrating. The verse tells us, "You shall dwell in Sukkos for seven days."1 Yet, what is the underlying reason behind leaving our houses for a week and living in wooden structures? Chazal2 cite a dispute between Rabbi Eliezer and Rabbi Akiva. Rabbi Eliezer explains that Sukkos commemorates the Ananei HaKavod, the Clouds of Glory that surrounded Klal Yisrael in the wilderness and protected them in miraculous ways. Rabbi Akiva, however, holds that Sukkos commemorates the simple wooden huts that Klal Yisrael lived in. Let us first explore the reason behind Rabbi Eliezer’s opinion. The Ananei HaKavod were a miracle beyond our comprehension. Klal Yisrael did not need to worry about their feet becoming sore from walking through the desert in the scorching heat. Instead, they were able to glide upon these clouds effortlessly. Also, the clouds actually laundered their clothing. It was a Divine laundry service. Their clothes always remained pristine and clean. Furthermore, the Ananei HaKavod provided protection from our enemies. For example, when the evil Amalekites came and attacked 1 23:42 2 Sukkah 11b 1 our camp, the arrows that were shot through the air were absorbed by these clouds. So, according to Rabbi Eliezer, when we sit in the Sukkah, we are remembering the incredible protection that Hashem provided for Klal Yisrael in the Midbar. We might ask according to Rabbi Eliezer: Why is Sukkos on the 15th of Tishrei? The Ananei HaKavod surrounded Klal Yisrael in Nissan, so why should Sukkos be celebrated in Tishrei? The Gra3 explains that after the terrible sin of the Golden Calf, the Ananei HaKavod were removed. Moshe Rabbeinu pleaded with Hashem on behalf of Klal Yisrael, and he ascended to Shamayim. Moshe remained there until Yom Kippur, when Klal Yisrael received their atonement. After Yom Kippur, Moshe Rabbeinu commanded Klal Yisrael to begin working on the Mishkan. They immediately began their work, and this started on the 15th of Tishrei. At that time, the Ananei HaKavod miraculously returned. This is why Sukkos is celebrated specifically on the 15th of Tishrei. We are not commemorating the original appearance of the Ananei HaKavod when Klal Yisrael left Mitzrayim. We are commemorating their return after Yom Kippur, after Klal Yisrael received forgiveness and began building the Mishkan. There is another question we can ask according to Rabbi Eliezer. If a Sukkah is supposed to represent the Ananei HaKavod, why shouldn’t we try to resemble them in as many ways as possible? For example, the Ananei HaKavod completely surrounded Klal Yisrael, including underneath their feet. Yet the floor of a Sukkah is not part of the mitzvah of Sukkah. Why not? 3 Kol Eliyahu, Emor 84 2 The Bach4 explains that the Sukkah is a zecher for the protection that Hashem gave Klal Yisrael. We do not need to completely replicate the Ananei HaKavod. Rather, we need to remember the incredible protection that Hashem provided for us. Therefore, a key aspect of the Sukkah is the schach, which must cover most of the roof and provide us with shade and protection from the elements. This symbolizes the Ananei HaKavod, the miraculous Clouds of Glory that surrounded and protected Klal Yisrael in the wilderness. As we sit beneath the schach, we can reflect not only on these clouds, but on all the extraordinary miracles through which Hashem cared for and protected us in the barren desert. This is also reflected in the seven days of Sukkos, corresponding to the seven clouds of the Ananei HaKavod.5 Every year, when we enter the Sukkah, we are reminded of those miraculous clouds that surrounded Klal Yisrael and protected them in the Midbar. We leave the security of our homes and enter the Sukkah, sitting under the sechach and remembering that Hashem has always been there to protect His children. However, the opinion of Rabbi Akiva seems much more difficult to understand. The moadim generally commemorate the extraordinary miracles that Hashem performed for our nation. Why, then, would we need a Chag for all generations to commemorate the fact that Klal Yisrael lived in simple, temporary huts in the desert? Unlike the miraculous Clouds of Glory, building shelters seems entirely natural and practical—a basic necessity for people living in the wilderness. 4 OC 625:2 5 The Mabit 3 What was so remarkable about these huts that they deserve to be remembered and celebrated every year? The Rashbam offers a powerful explanation. Sukkos is referred to as "Chag Ha'asif" the time of our gathering. It occurs after the harvest season when Klal Yisrael reaps the fruits of their labor. It is a time when a person’s home is full, when there is plenty, and when life feels secure and comfortable. Specifically, at that moment, the Torah commands us to leave our sturdy homes and sit in a temporary Sukkah. This is to remind us that our sense of security is not something we created on our own. There was a time when our ancestors wandered in the wilderness with no permanent homes, living in simple and fragile structures. By stepping into the Sukkah, we remind ourselves that everything we have—our homes, our comfort, and our stability—is a gift from Hashem. The Rashbam notes that this idea is so fundamental that we follow the opinion of Rabbi Akiva. Therefore, he maintains that the main reason why we celebrate Sukkos is to commemorate the fact that we dwelled in wooden booths. Although Sukkos lasts for only seven days, its message applies to the entire year. Our secure homes are such a tremendous gift and significantly enhance our lives. We must try our best not to take this for granted. Rav Avigdor Miller suggests the following exercise. Let us picture a man who lived without a home, never knowing where he would sleep at night, with no shelter, no stability, and no place to call his own. Then one day, someone gives him a house. The appreciation he would feel would be overwhelming. He would speak about it 4 constantly, and every time he walked through the door he would be filled with gratitude to his benefactor. How much more so, Rabbi Miller explains, should we thank Hashem Who graciously gives us a roof over our heads, such an essential need. After all, can we imagine life without a safe and comfortable home? Without a roof and walls to protect us from the elements and intruders. Where would we rest after a long day? It would be so difficult without a kitchen to prepare our meals and without a warm bed to sleep in at night. Our houses and shelters are more than just structures, they are daily miracles that provide safety, comfort, and a sense of peace. Furthermore, in our times, this gift is even greater. Our homes are more comfortable and advanced than ever before. We have running water at the turn of a faucet—something that for generations people could hardly imagine. Cooking, cleaning, and bathing are all made simple. Similarly, electricity transforms our lives in countless ways. Without it, there would be no lights at night, no heating in the winter, no air conditioning in the summer, and none of the many appliances that make daily life so much easier. It is also worth thinking about how different our homes are today compared to the past. In previous generations, entire families often lived in a single room, where everything—eating, sleeping, and living—took place in the same small space. This actually has halachic ramifications. Chazal 6 teach that Bedikas Chametz should be performed on the night before Pesach. This was in the days where houses were much smaller and people had much less. 6 Pesachim 2b 5 It was sufficient to light a candle on the evening before Pesach and go around the house looking for Chametz. Yet considering the sizes of our houses nowadays and how many possessions we have, one night is no longer enough and we need days to search properly. A key message of the Sukkah is to encourage us to appreciate this. A man spent a long time planning a vacation. Things in his life had been very stressful, and he was looking forward to having a few days to unwind. However, when he arrived at his destination, it rained for five days straight. He wasn’t able to visit the parks or enjoy the outdoor activities he had been looking forward to, and the vacation could easily have become a miserable experience. Instead, he decided to remain positive and use the time indoors to focus on all the good in his life. He thought about how fortunate he was to have a roof over his head and what an enormous gift that was. How would he manage without shelter? He began appreciating the food and drink he had, his family and friends, and even the simple gifts of being able to breathe and see. By the time it was time to go home, he said that it had been the best vacation he had ever had. He had spent the entire time appreciating the many blessings in his life that he normally took for granted.7 7 A Life of Bitachon 6 ❧ Zeman Simchasainu Every Yom Tov is a time of joy. Yet, there is something unique about the simchah of Sukkos. In fact, Sukkos is referred to as Zeman Simchaseinu — the Time of Our Rejoicing. The mitzvah of rejoicing is mentioned more in connection with Sukkos than with any other Yom Tov. The Torah tells us, “U’smachtem lifnei Hashem Elokeichem shiv’as yamim — You shall rejoice before Hashem, your G-d, for seven days.”8 It also says, “Vesamachta bechagecha — You shall rejoice on your festival,”9 and concludes, “Vehayisa ach same’ach — and you shall be completely joyful.” 10 Here, the mitzvah of simchah is mentioned three times as opposed to the other Moadim. Why does Sukkos have such a unique emphasis on simchah? After the soul-searching of Elul, Rosh Hashanah, and Yom Kippur, we have been given an incredible gift. We have reflected on our mistakes, asked Hashem for forgiveness, and been given the opportunity to renew our relationship with Hashem. What greater reason could there be to rejoice? That itself is a tremendous source of simchah. So, this is why Sukkos is a unique time of joy.11 There is also another dimension to the joy of Sukkos. The Chida explains that when we look at the Sukkah and recognize how temporary this world truly is, that realization itself can bring us happiness. When we stop investing all of our energy into chasing temporary things and instead turn towards what is eternal — Torah, 8 Vayikra 23:40 9 Devarim 16:14 10 Devarim 16:15 11Alshich 23:34 7 mitzvos, and a relationship with Hashem — we discover a deeper and more lasting happiness.12 Adding to this idea, the Sfas Emes explains that the mitzvah of Sukkah teaches us bitachon — trust in Hashem. We leave our permanent dwelling and recognize that our ultimate security does not come from our homes, possessions, and wealth. It comes from Hashem alone. That is why Sukkos is Zeman Simchaseinu. There is no happiness like the happiness of someone who truly trusts in Hashem and can throw his burden upon Him.13 Our joy on Sukkos is also very much connected to when it falls out in the agricultural cycle. Sukkos is called Chag Ha'asif "The time of our gathering" since it is when the crops have been gathered. The Abarbanel explains that Sukkos comes at the time when people naturally feel joy. The crops have been gathered, the produce has been brought in, and a person sees the blessing Hashem has given him. Naturally, there is a desire to celebrate. The Torah teaches us to take that natural happiness and elevate it. Do not simply celebrate your success for yourself. Turn that celebration into something higher. Share your joy with your family and with those around you, including those who may have less.14 When we are happy on Sukkos, it has an incredible impact on the year ahead. The Abarbanel explains this based on the words of the Torah: “And you shall rejoice on your festival, you and your son and your daughter, your male servant and your female servant, and the Levi, the 12 Simchas HaRegel, Limud 1 13 Sfas Emes, Sukkos 644 14 Abarbanel, Devarim 16:13–15 8 convert, the orphan, and the widow who are within your cities. Seven days you shall celebrate for Hashem, your G-D, in the place that Hashem will choose, for Hashem, your G-D, will bless you in all your produce and in all the work of your hands, and you shall be only happy.” The Abarbanel points out that the final words, “Vehayisa ach same’ach”—“and you shall be only happy”—are not merely another command to rejoice. They are a promise and a guarantee of the result of the simchah of Sukkos. The Torah first tells us that Hashem will bless us in all the work of our hands, and then concludes, “Vehayisa ach same’ach”—you will be truly happy. The Abarbanel explains that this happiness can continue beyond Sukkos and accompany a person throughout the year. The joy with which we celebrate Sukkos can have an effect on the entire year that follows. This gives us a beautiful perspective on the importance of simchah during Sukkos. The way we begin the year can have a tremendous effect on what follows. When we enter the new year with gratitude, happiness, and appreciation for the many blessings Hashem has given us, we can carry that attitude with us into the months ahead. This is also alluded to in the words Zeman Simchaseinu. The word zeman means a designated time or period, and, as explained by the Trisker Maggid, it is connected to the concept of preparation. The simchah we experience during these seven days is therefore not simply a temporary happiness. It is a preparation for the year ahead, giving us the opportunity to enter the coming months with a greater appreciation for the blessings Hashem has given us.15 15 Magen Avraham, Sukkos 9 The influence of Sukkos on the year ahead is not limited to simchah. The mitzvos of these precious days also bring tremendous blessing for the coming year. Sukkos therefore gives us something to carry far beyond the festival itself: not only its joy, but also its blessing.16 This brings us to a fascinating story. A Jewish man who lived in a skyscraper in Manhattan wanted to fulfil the precious mitzvah of Sukkah. Since he did not have a suitable place to build one, he asked the owner of the building for permission to build his Sukkah on the roof. The owner agreed, but there was a catch. He demanded a hefty fee for the use of part of the roof for the week of Sukkos and insisted that a formal contract be drawn up and signed in the presence of a lawyer. The man was surprised. Nobody even used that part of the roof, and he would only be there for a few days. Nevertheless, he was determined to fulfil the mitzvah of Sukkah, so he agreed. When he finally arrived on the roof to prepare his Sukkah, he discovered that the entire area was abandoned and filled with years of rubbish and debris. Before he could begin building, he had a great deal of cleaning to do. As he was clearing the area, something caught his attention. He noticed something protruding from an old pipe. Curious, he took a closer look and discovered a bag hidden inside. When he opened it, he could hardly believe his eyes. Inside were what appeared to be extremely valuable diamonds. Immediately, he contacted the police and reported what he had found so they could try to locate the rightful owner. After investigating, they discovered who the diamonds had belonged to. However, the owner had already passed away. 16 Sfas Emes Sukkah, 660 10 According to the law, because the area of the roof had been legally rented to the Jewish man, the diamonds belonged to him. The owner of the skyscraper was furious. “I own this building!” he protested. “The diamonds were found on my roof. They belong to me!” The matter eventually went to court, yet the judge ruled that because the section of the roof had been formally rented to the Jewish man, with a proper contract signed before a lawyer, the diamonds legally belonged to him. ❧ Simchas Beis Hashoevah. One of the great highlights of Sukkos in the Beis HaMikdash was the Simchas Beis Hashoeivah, literally, “the joy of the water drawing.” On each night of Sukkos enormous vessels of water were drawn and brought to the Beis HaMikdash for the mitzvah of Nissuch HaMayim, the water libations. On each night of Sukkos the drawing of the water was accompanied by a celebration of such extraordinary joy that Chazal tell us, “Whoever has never seen the joy of the Simchas Beis Hashoeivah has never seen joy in his life.”17 From Chazal's description it is hard to comprehend what this celebration must have looked like. The Beis HaMikdash was filled with light. Golden lamps illuminated the courtyard and lit up the darkness of Yerushalayim. The Leviyim played their instruments, sang and praised Hashem, while thousands of people gathered to watch. At the center of the celebration were the Chassidim and Anshei Maaseh, the greatest and most righteous people of the generation. These were 17 Sukkah 51a 11 not entertainers brought in to create a fun atmosphere. They were people whose lives were completely dedicated to Torah and avodas Hashem, and they themselves were overflowing with immense joy. They would dance before the people, sing songs of praise, and perform extraordinary acts of celebration. For example, Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel, the Nasi of Klal Yisrael, would perform extraordinary feats. He would take eight flaming torches and juggle them in the air, throwing one and catching another, with the torches never touching one another. He would then perform an extraordinary bow, placing his thumbs on the ground, bending down to kiss the floor, and then rising again. The celebration continued throughout the night. The people would come after a day filled with avodah, tefillah and learning and remain awake for much of the night. When they became tired, they would rest their heads on one another's shoulders, but the joy continued. Their exhaustion did not extinguish their simchah. This immense joy brought them to extraordinary spiritual heights. In fact, Chazal teach that the name Beis Hashoeivah comes from the word sho’evah, meaning “drawing,” because it was a place where they would draw Ruach Hakodesh. The tzaddikim reached such great levels of joy during the Simchas Beis Hashoeivah that they were able to experience Ruach Hakodesh. Yonah, who later became a navi, reached these spiritual heights through the joy of the Simchas Beis Hashoeivah. Our Rabbis teach us that the Shechinah rests with a person through simchah, rather than through sadness. The joy of Sukkos therefore did more than bring 12 happiness; it helped elevate them to great spiritual heights.18 What was it about the Simchas Beis Hashoeivah that generated such extraordinary joy? The celebration accompanied the mitzvah of Nissuch HaMayim, the pouring of water on the Mizbeach. Why should the drawing and pouring of water bring about such an eruption of happiness? The key to understanding this is found in the very thing they were celebrating: the drawing of the water. Chazal received a tradition from Har Sinai that on Sukkos a large amount of water needs to be poured onto the mizbeach.19 Pouring these large quantities of water reminds us how fortunate we are to have the priceless gift of water. We are surrounded by an enormous supply of water, and because it is so readily available, it is easy to forget what an incredible gift it is. The large amount of water used for the Nissuch Hamayim is to symbolize our recognition that Hashem has blessed the world with an abundant supply of this precious resource. Each drop of water is a precious gift from Hashem.20 In fact, our Rabbis teach that when there is rain after a drought, we recite “We thank You… for every single drop that You caused to fall for us”21 We stress every drop since each drop is a miracle in its own 18 Yerushalmi Sukkah 5:1 19 Sukkah 34a 20 Rav Shimshon Refael Hirsch, Bamidbar 29:19 21 Berachos 59b 13 right and an undeserved gift from Hashem. Water actually plays a very important role in our lives. Seventy percent of the earth consists of water. Water is a vital life source for the billions of species on the planet. It serves many other useful purposes, such as for washing our hands, cooking, cleaning our dishes and bathing etc. So, a key reason for the immense joy of the Simchas Beis Hashoevah stemmed from our appreciation of this priceless gift. There is another reason for the tremendous happiness. Sukkos comes immediately after Yom Kippur. We have just spent the holiest day of the year standing before Hashem, asking for forgiveness and cleansing ourselves from our sins. Now, only a few days later, we are entering the Sukkah and beginning a new year with a fresh start. This was a source of immense joy. There was an even deeper reason for this happiness. The Chasam Sofer explains that the joy of the tzaddikim during the Simchas Beis Hashoeivah was not only about their own personal teshuvah. We know the principle of Kol Yisrael Areivim Zeh BaZeh — every Jew is responsible for one another. When one Jew does teshuvah, it does not affect only him. His teshuvah has an effect on the entire nation. Furthermore, when we do teshuvah out of love, it could transform our sins into merits. The Tzaddikim therefore rejoiced not only in the spiritual renewal they had experienced themselves, but also in the spiritual gains that happen throughout Klal Yisrael. Unfortunately, nowadays we are without the Beis Hamikdash and can no longer experience the glorious sight of the Simchas Beis Hashoeivah. We are therefore unable to celebrate it as they did in the 14 times of the Beis Hamikdash. Nevertheless, we have a way to keep its memory alive. As the Mishnah Berurah writes: “Chassidim and Anshai Maasah make a remembrance of the Simchas Beis Hashoeivah by staying awake on the nights of Chol HaMoed Sukkos, increasing in songs and praises, and increasing the number of candles in the Sukkah on these nights."22 This practice serves as a zecher for the holy Nisuch HaMayim and the tremendous joy that accompanied it. At the same time, it awakens within us a longing for the Beis Hamikdash and for the day when we will once again experience this special joy in its full glory. Various customs are observed at these celebrations, such as lighting many candles and reciting Tehillim. In Eretz Yisrael, it is customary to recite the chapters of Tehillim beginning with Shir HaMaalos before the celebration begins.23 Our Tzaddikim throughout the generations were particular to celebrate the Simchas Beis HaShoevah with great joy. The Ohr HaChaim would hold a special celebration and many candles were lit in his Shul. Also, the Chasam Sofer would hold a Simchas Beis Hashoevah each night of Chol Hamoed. The Gra would hold a big celebration where many perakim of Tehillim and Mishnayos were recited. The Gra would then repeatedly proclaim the privilege of Klal Yisrael, describing how, when Hashem sees His beloved children set aside their troubles to rejoice in His service, He 22 661:2 23 Piskei Teshuvos 661:3 15 gathers His heavenly entourage and is filled with mercy toward them.24 The Chazon Ish was very particular about holding a Simchas Beis Hashoeivah. On one occasion, when the celebration began, he was asked to address those present. He spoke about the words of Chazal which teach that Yonah HaNavi merited Ruach Hakodesh through the tremendous joy of the Simchas Beis Hashoeivah. The Chazon Ish explained that it was this great simchah that helped Yonah reach such a level of Ruach Hakodesh. As he spoke, the joy of those present grew, until the entire tzibbur erupted into dancing with a level of enthusiasm that was rarely seen.25 On another occasion, he shared the Vilna Gaon’s inspiring words at the Simchas Beis Hashoeivah, describing how Hashem sees His beloved children putting aside their troubles to rejoice with Him and is filled with mercy toward them. He then asked those present to sing this to a niggun. When they remained silent, he said, “If you don’t, I will,” and he himself spontaneously sang these heartfelt words to a niggun. He sang with such powerful emotion that it deeply moved everyone who was there.26 ❧ A Time Of Unity After days of soul-searching and heartfelt prayer, we are given a priceless gift: the opportunity to cleanse ourselves of our sins and begin anew. This not only transforms our relationship with Hashem; 24 Vezeh Leshoni 14:4 25 Maaseh Ish Vol.1 p.57 26 Maaseh Ish Vol.2 p.59 16 it also has a profound effect on our relationships with one another. The Sfas Emes teaches that, in truth, the souls of Klal Yisrael are naturally close and connected. It is our sins that create distance and separation—both between ourselves and Hashem, and between one person and another. Therefore, the work of Yom Kippur is not complete until we repair both forms of separation. When we seek forgiveness from those we have hurt and return to caring and loving one another, the barriers created by our mistakes begin to fall away. On Yom Kippur, as our sins are forgiven, Klal Yisrael can once again become one. The Sfas Emes explains that this is why we merited receiving the second Luchos on Yom Kippur. The sin of the Golden Calf had damaged our unity, but through forgiveness that unity was restored, preparing us to receive the Torah once again. With this renewed closeness to Hashem and to one another, we can then enter Sukkos together—a Yom Tov with a particularly powerful message of unity.27 This message of unity should accompany us throughout Sukkos. There are many beautiful hiddurim and stringencies through which we can strive to perform the mitzvos of Sukkos in the finest possible way. Yet, at the same time, we must never lose sight of the special spirit of these days—a time when Klal Yisrael comes together as one. Part of preserving that unity is being sensitive to the feelings of those around us. Even when we are striving for the highest standards in 27 Sfas Emes, Yom Kippur 5651 17 our own mitzvah observance, we should be careful that this never creates distance between ourselves and another Jew. Sukkos reminds us that alongside our desire to beautify each mitzvah, we should cherish the precious bond that connects every member of Klal Yisrael. Sometimes, a little thoughtfulness, understanding and sensitivity can help preserve that sense of togetherness. Rav Yankele of Pshevorsk was a revered Chassidic Rebbe who led the Pshevorsk community in Antwerp. His life had taken him through extraordinarily difficult times. During the war years, he suffered imprisonment and forced labor in Siberia, where even under the harshest conditions he remained deeply devoted to the mitzvos. That same devotion remained with him throughout his life. Many years later, during Chol HaMo’eid Sukkos, the Rebbe went to visit an elderly Chasid who lived with his wife on a high floor of an assisted-living facility. His declining health had made it very difficult for him to leave the apartment. When the Rebbe arrived, the Chasid’s wife quietly asked him for a favor. “Please, Rebbe, don’t tell him that it is Sukkos. If he knows, he will insist on going downstairs to the Succah, and it is simply too difficult for him.” The Rebbe agreed and entered without revealing the reason for the visit. The Chasid was overjoyed to see the Rebbe. After warmly greeting him, he immediately turned to his wife and asked her to bring the Rebbe some fruit. Soon, a beautiful platter was brought into the room. The Chasid then turned to the Rebbe with another request: “Please make a brachah on a fruit. It would be a great zechus for me.” 18 The Rebbe was now faced with a difficult dilemma. Throughout his life, he had been extremely careful never to eat or drink outside the Succah during Sukkos. This was no ordinary stringency for him. Even during those challenging years in Siberia, he had refused to give it up. In the bitter conditions of the labor camp, he would preserve his meager food until he could enter a tiny makeshift Succah that he had fashioned in a pit in the frozen ground and covered with twigs. The Rebbe took an apple and began peeling it. He passed it from one hand to the other while continuing to speak with the Chasid, hoping to postpone the moment. The elderly man, however, continued waiting patiently and then pleaded, “Please, Rebbe. I need the Zechus of your Brachah.” Finally, the Rebbe took a very small piece of the apple, which was Halachically permissible, and recited the Brachah aloud. The Chasid immediately responded with a powerful “Amen!” Afterward, the Rebbe’s attendant asked him how he could have eaten outside the Succah when even the hardships of Siberia had not caused him to compromise on this practice. The Rebbe replied, “In Siberia, I was willing to sacrifice myself for the Mitzvah of Succah. Yet, to sacrifice another Yid? That I simply cannot do.” The Rebbe understood that there are times when one must be willing to give up even a cherished stringency for the sake of another Jew. His Mesiras Nefesh was not only for the Mitzvah of Succah; it was also for the dignity and feelings of a fellow Jew. Unity is also a key message of the precious mitzvah of Arba Minim. Chazal explain that each of the four species represents a different type of Jew. The Esrog has both taste and fragrance, representing those who possess both Torah and good deeds. The Lulav, which 19 comes from the date palm, has taste but no fragrance, representing those who possess Torah but are lacking in good deeds. The hadas has fragrance but no taste, representing those who possess good deeds but are lacking in Torah, while the aravah has neither taste nor fragrance, representing those who are lacking in both. Yet, Hashem does not tell us to take only the esrog. Every one of the four species is needed. Chazal teach, “Let them all be bound together as one agudah, and they will bring atonement for one another.”28 The mitzvah itself teaches us that Klal Yisrael is made up of different people, each on a different level and with different strengths, yet everyone has an important place within the whole. We are not expected to be identical. Just as each of the Four Minim has its own unique qualities, every Jew has his own strengths and qualities that he brings to Klal Yisrael. This is an important perspective when we think about our relationships with other people. It is easy to notice someone's mistakes or weaknesses, especially when they are very different from our own. The mitzvah of the Four Minim reminds us to look deeper and appreciate the good within each person. A remarkable story about Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev brings this idea to life. Sukkos was approaching, and the Jews of Berditchev were facing a serious problem. That year, bringing esrogim to Ukraine had been especially difficult. The roads were dangerous, the weather was poor, and the high costs of transporting the precious fruit made it almost impossible to obtain one. By the time Yom Tov arrived, the entire city of Berditchev had managed to obtain only one esrog. 28 Vayikra Rabbah 30:12 20 The precious esrog was brought to the home of the city's beloved Rebbe, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, where it was kept safely. The plan was that on the first day of Sukkos, the Rebbe would be the first to make the brachah, and afterwards the esrog would be passed around so that the Jews of the city could each have a turn performing the mitzvah. One of the Rebbe's attendants knew that he would probably be among the last people to get a chance to use the esrog. As he thought about it, he became disappointed. He also wanted to perform the mitzvah as early as possible. Then an idea came to him. On the morning of the first day of Sukkos, while the Rebbe was in the mikvah, he would quietly take the lulav and esrog and make the brachah himself. He knew it was not the right thing to do, but his excitement about performing the mitzvah was so great that he decided he could not wait. Early that morning, he entered the Rebbe's room and carefully picked up the lulav and esrog. His heart was beating quickly as he prepared to make the brachah. Suddenly, however, the esrog slipped from his hands and fell to the floor. When he picked it up, he saw to his horror that the pitom had broken off. The one esrog that the entire city had been relying on was now no longer fit to use. He was devastated. He had really wanted to perform a mitzvah, and instead he had ruined the only esrog in Berditchev. He could hardly imagine telling Rabbi Levi Yitzchak what had happened. What would the Rebbe say? How would the people of the city react when they discovered that there was no longer an esrog for them to use? When the Rebbe returned, his attendant finally gathered enough courage to tell him what had happened. He stood before him with his head lowered, expecting to be reprimanded for what he had done. Rabbi Levi Yitzchak listened carefully. Then, instead of becoming angry, his face lit up with 21 emotion. He raised his eyes toward Heaven and exclaimed, “Ribbono Shel Olam, look at Your precious children! Look how much they love Your mitzvos! This simple Jew was so eager to fulfill Your will that he could not even wait for his turn!” The broken esrog was certainly disappointing, but Rabbi Levi Yitzchak looked beyond the mistake. He saw the love for a mitzvah that had caused the man to act as he did. He was able to recognize the good within this Jew even at a moment when the man's actions had caused a serious problem for the entire community. ❧ Inspiring quotes. ❧ The mitzvah of Sukkah represents the trait of trust in Hashem. As Chazal teach, “Leave your permanent dwelling,” so that a person should not place his trust in wealth and possessions, but rather trust in Hashem. This is why Sukkos is called “the time of our joy,” because there is no joy like the joy of one who truly trusts in Hashem. (Sfas Emes Sukkos, 645) ❧ Whoever fulfills the mitzvah of sukkah in this world, the Holy One, blessed be He, will seat him in the Sukkah of the Levyasan in the World to Come. (Yalkut Shimoni 693) ❧ The eight days of this festival give life to all the days of the year (Sfas Emes 632) ❧ Since the sanctity of the sukkah is very great, it is proper to minimize mundane conversation in the sukkah and to speak there only words of holiness and Torah. Certainly, one should be 22 especially careful not to speak lashon hara, rechilus, or any other forbidden speech. (Mishnah Berurah 639:2) ❧ Whoever dwells beneath the shadow of faith (the Sukkah) inherits freedom for himself and for his children forever, and is blessed with a supernal blessing. (Zohar vol.3 103a) ❧ The Sukkah protects Bnai Yisrael. (Sfas Emes 644) ❧ In every generation, there are no days of joy for Hashem like the days of Sukkos. At that time, Klal Yisrael has been cleansed from the sins they committed, for Yom Kippur has already passed. Since Hashem’s joy comes from our spiritual refinement and the purity of our souls, it is fitting that He established Sukkos as a remembrance and expression of this spiritual achievement that Klal Yisrael has attained. (Alshich, Vayikra 23:34) ❧ The Sukkah is a precious and beloved mitzvah that comes only at its appointed time each year. (Peleh Yoetz Sukkah) ❧ The festival of Sukkos is a semblance of the Mishkan that was given to Bnei Yisrael after the sin, once they had been rectified through teshuvah.” (Sfas Emes, Sukkos 644) ❧ Rabbi Levi said: Whoever fulfills the mitzvah of sukkah in this world, Hashem says, “He fulfilled the mitzvah of sukkah in this world; I will shelter him from the heat of the World to Come. (Yalkut Shimoni Emor 653) ❧ The Name of Heaven rests upon the sukkah, as the verse states, “The festival of Sukkos, seven days for Hashem.” Just as the 23 festival offering is consecrated to Hashem, so too, the sukkah is consecrated to Hashem. (Sukkah 9a) ❧ The sanctity of the sukkah is exceedingly great, and Hashem spreads His sukkah of peace over us. Its spiritual power is very great. One should therefore be careful to build the sukkah in a clean place, free of anything unpleasant, and the area surrounding the sukkah should also be kept clean. (The Tzlach, Derushai Hatzlach Derush 4) ❧ The festival of Sukkos is when HaKadosh Baruch Hu draws Bnei Yisrael close through teshuvah that comes from love and joy.” (Sfas Emes, Devarim, Sukkos 5644) ❧ The meaning of the Sukkah can be understood through the example of a mother hen. At first, she calls to her chicks and places food before them; afterward, she gathers them beneath her wings. In the same way, the holy Shechinah deals with us. On Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, she inscribes for us sustenance and a good life. Once our sustenance has been allotted, she then gathers us beneath her wings. This is the meaning of Sukkos: the holy Mother shelters us beneath her wings. (The Apter Rav, Ohev Yisrael, Sukkah) ❧ The idea behind sitting in the sukkah is to feel that we are in the House of God, b’tzila d’mehemanusa—in the “shadow of faith”— standing constantly under the protection and watchful care of the Holy One, blessed be He. (Rav Chaim Friedlander, Sifsei Chaim vol.1 p.334) ❧ Every single moment that a person remains in the Sukkah, he fulfills this positive mitzvah. It is therefore fitting that while sitting in the Sukkah, a person should train himself to constantly keep in mind, with tremendous joy, that he is fulfilling this mitzvah. (Yesod V’Shoresh HaAvodah, Shaar 11, Chapter 12) 24 ❧ These days are days of Divine mercy, in which judgments are sweetened through the mitzvos that surround us and with which we fill our hands with blessing during these days. (The Gra, Kol Eliyahu Emor 85) ❧ The days of Sukkos are called Zman Simchaseinu, ‘the time of our joy,’ because Hashem has granted us the privilege of dwelling in His shade, which is a semblance of Gan Eden. (Sfas Emes, Devarim, Sukkos 5643) ❧ Therefore, whoever fulfills the mitzvah of Sukkah and enters it, looking toward the schach made to provide shade, should bear in mind that the Holy One, blessed be He, is the shelter of Israel and protects us just as shade protects a person from the sun. (Rabbeinu Bechaya Kad Hakemach, Sukkah.) ❧ The Sukkah is a precious and beloved mitzvah that comes only once a year. (Peleh Yoetz, Sukkah) ❧ In the sukkah, we are meant to bring in all aspects of life: eating, sleeping, and even taking walks. By bringing the entire cycle of our daily lives into the fulfillment of the mitzvah of sukkah, the sukkah protects us from the mekatreg—the accuser, the evil inclination (yetzer hara). (Rav Chaim Freidlander, Sifsei Chaim vol.1 p.334) ❧ On the festival of Sukkos, blessing comes for the entire year. (Sfas Emes Sukkos 660) 25 This booklet is dedicated for a refuah shleimah for Shoshana Emuna Bas Penina Devora and for yeshuos for all of Klal Yisrael. For feedback, or to receive this booklet by email, please contact us at livingappreciation@gmail.com. You can also contact this address to join our inspiring weekly email, exploring the theme of hakaras hatov in the weekly parashah.