Clarity for Teens - English — Rosh Hashana (2026-09-07)

Our Father, our King - Elul
The first Avinu Malkeinu reads: ‘Our Father, our King, we have sinned before You.’
Let’s dissect this. Let’s understand.
The 10-minute Jew
R’ Avigdor Miller used to talk about the ’10-minute Jew’ in his Shul. This Yid was rich,
influential and successful. The only time he would show up in Shul was for 10 minutes
before Neilah, when he would go up to the Aron Kodesh, open it and daven for 10
minutes before leaving. He would never otherwise come to Shul, but due to his power
and influence, no one would disturb him from his 10-minute annual Tefilla.
Once, R’ Avigdor Miller was collecting money for a Tzedakah, and he decided to
approach this Yid who was affiliated with his Shul, albeit for only 10 minutes a year.
But he didn’t receive a warm welcome. “I don’t see Rabbi’s” the man said. R’ Avigdor
Miller asked if he could just ask him one question. After making it clear that there
would be no money involved, he agreed.
“I want to ask you one thing: For years, I have been the Rav of the Shul that you come
to each Yom Kippur. What’s the meaning of coming for 10 minutes? If you don’t believe,
why do you come at all? And if you do, then why only for 10 minutes?”
The Yid looked and R’ Avigdor Miller. “I’ll explain, as long as you don’t ask me any
questions afterwards. Every year, I go to the Aron Kodesh and say ‘Hashem, I want you
to know – my finances are in great shape. I am well-liked socially. I get along with my
wife just fine. I am proud of my kids. It's all going great, just please, don’t mix in.’”
Understanding Elul
Now, obviously none of us are there. We all have a connection. But how much of what
we do around Elul is simply to assuage our guilt? Or because of social pressures? For
many, there is a certain tenseness around Elul. Am I good? Am I bad? What am I?
Before we look for the answers, here’s another question: We approach Elul year after
year. We try to do Teshuva, to cry, but then we often fall. And then the next year, we
try again. What’s the point?
1
Why we wash our clothes
The basic answer to this question is: We keep on washing our clothes even though we
know that they will get dirty again. We have to continue washing them, otherwise they
will get so dirty, and smell so bad, that we won’t be able to live with them.
The Satmar Rebbe says that there is an element of this in Elul. Once a year, we clean
ourselves. We reconnect. Without this, we would fall so far away, eventually there
would be nothing connecting us to Yiddishkeit.
The fact that you will fall doesn’t matter. On Motzai Simchas Torah, you start with a
clean slate. A new beginning.
The underwater swimmer
It's like an underwater swimmer who comes up for breath every few minutes. What’s
the point of that if he is going to dunk his head underwater a second later? Why can’t
he just stay underwater?
Well, if he does, then he will be going much further down…
So too, the Jewish year has points when we ‘come up for breath.’ Elul. Sukkos. Chanuka.
All the Yamim Tovim.
And even if we might not be able to maintain that level every day of the year, it is vital
that we keep coming up for breath; that we keep the connection.
We do have to keep trying – genuinely. We have to make our changes real.
But ‘coming up for breath’ every Elul is not being fake. Just like the swimmer who
comes up every few minutes is not being fake.
The Tax collector
In the olden days, there was no HMRC. There was only a tax collector who would come
to the Shtetl once a year and collect everyone’s tax. When he showed up, some people
would hide what they had. They would be on their best behaviour. He would collect
the tax, leave, and the townspeople would heave a collective sigh of relief.
Some of us frame Elul in this way. A time where we are on our best behaviour. When
we try hide the things we are doing wrong. When we ‘pay our tax’ by doing better. And
then let out a sigh of relief when it is over…
It's time for us to grow up. To live through the Yamim Noraim in a positive way. To
get all we can from Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur.
2
Applying for a mortgage
At one point, you are going to want to buy a house. Imagine sitting down with a
mortgage broker to plan your mortgage. Before the broker can open his mouth, you
jump in. “I just want to tell you that my business has failed, I never pay back my debts
on time, I love gambling and I am extremely dishonest.”
You would never say that. The broker would send you packing before you know what
hit you.
But it seems like that is exactly what we are doing in the Avinu Malkeinu’s – we start of
with a kind of disclaimer: ‘Our Father, our King, we have sinned’.
Why? When we are beseeching before Hashem for health, success and Bracha, why
do we start with mentioning that we sinned? At least wait until the end…!
Our Father, our King
We have one issue when we look at the Avinu Malkeinu’s, and really at all of Elul. We
skip out the first two words and go straight to ‘Chatanu Lefanecha - we have sinned
before You.’
But those first two words – ‘Avinu, Malkeinu’, are crucial.
Avinu
I was once driving to the school where I teach, with a Talmid next to me, when I saw a
non-Jewish, middle-aged lady slumped at the side of the road, in obvious pain. She was
with a much older lady, and I decided to go over and see if I could help.
When she told me that her chest and shoulder were hurting her terribly, I realised that
she was having a heart attack and called 999 as well as Hatzolah.
In the few minutes before the ambulance came, the woman with her began CPR – or
at least tried to. She was doing it completely wrong, and the victim was already starting
to change colours and lose conciseness. By the time the ambulance arrived, she was
dead (and I was completely traumatised from watching the whole thing.)
Watching this whole story made a powerful truth hit me very hard: The woman who
was with the victim was extremely composed throughout. I was wondering how she
did it – even as a man, if that would happen to someone I was walking along the road
with, I would be crying!
3
At one point, she called someone, and a few minutes later, a car pulled up. An older
man – obviously her husband, walked out. Literally the second she saw him, she began
bucketing. Tears were streaming down her face.
I realised something very powerful from watching this: In between our friends, we
don’t like being vulnerable. We like keeping our Kavod intact. But part of doing Teshuva
is being vulnerable – it's releasing what we have done onto Hashem and then bringing
it back in a positive way. You have to be completely vulnerable in front of Hashem, and
that can be very hard.
This lady was smart enough to realise that there was no point being vulnerable when
there was no one there to listen. She waited until her husband came, and then
completely released all her feelings – because he was there to pick up the pieces.
The first word we have to internalise before doing Teshuva is ‘Avinu’. Hashem is our
Father, so it's okay to be vulnerable. To cry. To be broken. Because He will pick up the
pieces and make us whole again.
Malkeinu
Imagine you are having a social situation and are crying to your father. He is listening
to you as you cry and let out all your feelings. That’s already a gift – but, now what?
Moving forward, your father will not always be able to actually help you.
Here we come to Malkeinu.
On Rosh Hashana, we are crowning Hashem. It's a constant work to actually
understand what this means as we grow older. What does crowning Hashem as Melech
actually mean for us?
Super fancy – but missing the point
Imagine you want to open a grocery store in your area. Issue is, there is already a
grocery store, albeit an old and run-down one. You speak to a business coach who tells
you that if there is already a grocery store, you need to bring in customers through
making yours the most modern, up-to-date store ever.
You borrow £1,000,000 and invest in making your grocery the nicest one of the
century. The lights are shiny and show welcoming messages. There are AI programmes
personally welcoming each person who walks through the door and directing them to
the aisles they need. There are robots scooting around to help customers shop. You
advertise wildly – everywhere possible.
4
Opening day arrives, and with it a huge queue waiting outside for the ribbon cutting
ceremony. Everyone is completely wowed by the super modern store – but walk out
with only the welcoming gift in their hands. They then walk across the road to the old
store and buy bags of food.
You are super disappointed – and confused. Why are they going to that ancient store
when you have a modern, stunning shopping experience?
You ask this to one of the people walking past, who looks at you strangely. “Your store
is absolutely beautiful – but the shelves are empty! There is nothing to buy!”
“Okay,” you say. “But I have robots! And flashing signs! And AI programmes…! Big deal,
so I don’t have food!”
Off course, you would never say that. Because you understand that the robots,
programmes and lights are all just extras. The only thing you really need is food on the
shelves.
Hakol B’Yedei Shamayim
We know that ‘Hakol B’Yedei Shamayim Chutz MiYiras Shamayim. Your social life,
finances, your health – everything you feel in control of – is actually in the control of
Hashem. Nothing is in your control – besides one thing: Your Yiras Shamayim.
We spend our whole life trying to control all the things we can’t control. But like the
store owner, we forget about the only thing that really matters.
When we come up to Shamayim – what will we have to show for ourselves in the only
area that really matters?
I've always wondered this: Why does a Goy get up in the morning? What does he think
he is here for?
I asked this to a Ger recently and he told me they don’t even think of such stuff. They
are too busy with the rat race of life, technology and AI to even think about what they
are doing here.
In a subtle way, we need to make sure this doesn’t happen to us. We need to make
sure that we aren’t too busy with our money, friends and holidays to miss the point
that we are here for. We need to fill our store with food.
It's very hard to leave go of the illusion of control. To rely totally on Hashem for all our
needs, and turn our focus to Ruchnius. But believe me – it's harder not to.
5
When we wake up in the morning, we can totally relax in Hashems Hands. He is taking
care of everything. All we need to worry about is the important stuff. The Yiras
Shamayim.
Off course, we have to have fun. To enjoy. To take care of ourselves normally. But we
have to make sure that the shelves are getting stocked.
When we give up the illusion of control and put everything into Hashem’s Hands, that
is Malchius. That is crowning Hashem as king. That is understanding Malkeinu.
Letting go - completely
We can let go completely onto Malkeinu, our King.
I was once helping a boy who was struggling mightily. It was very painful to watch. At
one point when speaking to him, I realised that it was R’ Meilich’s Yahrzeit the next
day. Then and there, I found cheap tickets to Lizhensk and asked the boys father if he
could come with me on a visit to the Zion.
Standing at the Kever, I suddenly felt this stuck feeling. I had come here to daven for
this struggling teenager, but what should I actually be davening for? That he shouldn’t
have a phone? But – Nisyonos would be there always! That his father should e more
understanding? But – that was his father’s domain.
And then – a moment of sudden clarity hit. I didn’t need to know the way forward for
this boy. I didn’t need to ‘give Hashem ideas.’ I didn’t need to specify. Just genuinely
daven for the Hatzlacha of this boy and give over the situation to the King of all Kings,
who knew better than I ever would what this boy needed.
That’s Malchius. That’s complete release of control – allowing in the relief, happiness
and tranquillity that will follow.
We could ask: Why does Yom Kippur not come before Rosh Hashana? It would be a
much more complete crowning after we have done Teshuva?
The answer is that we cannot do Teshuva before crowning Hashem. Once we have let
go of control, we can then go on to do Teshuva with an open mind. We are ready to
come back to Hashem.
Putting it all together
Now we can understand the ‘Avinu Malkeinu Chatanu Lefenecha.’
Avinu: We can be completely vulnerable to Hashem. He is our Father who loves us. He
will pick up the pieces when we break down in Teshuva.
6
Malkeinu: We need to let go of control. Put ourselves in Hashems Hands. Stop
focussing on all the things we don’t control anyway.
Then – we are ready to say ‘Chatanu Lefanecha, we have sinned before You.’ We are
ready to do Teshuva.
We are ready to come back.
Growing up
You reach an age where you’ve got to do stuff for yourself. Your parents aren’t watching
every move. Your school, Yeshivah or Sem wont especially know what you are doing.
Just like you reached an age where you could actually have £5 and not use it on nosh,
you reach an age where you can say ‘no’ on your own accord. For yourself.
You can say no to the device. You can say no to the Yetzer Hara. You can start making
choices because this is what you want to do.
Take control of the only thing you can really control – your Yiras Shamayim. And trust
me, you will feel great.
Small and steady self-control
Start small. Pick one area to take control of first. It might be a boundary as small as not
going on to a certain group for the first twenty minutes you are on the device. Once
you have mastered that, you can go on to thirty minutes. Then forty.
The feeling of self control that will fill you will be amazing. Every teenager is desperate
for the feeling of control. Of power. Of freedom. So go for it – go and access the
amazing feeling of being in control of yourself in the areas that really matter!
Remember: It's easier to do the right thing than the wrong thing.
Hashem knows
On your journey, there will always be struggles. You will sometimes fall. But you have
to remember:
The Mishnah is Avos says: ‘Know before Whom you will ultimately give Din
V’Cheshbon… Hashem.’
It doesn’t say your teacher. Or mother-in-law. Or siblings. Hashem is the only One you
need to give Din V’Cheshbon to.
Take a Bachur who grapples with an intense Nisoyon every time he walks past a
smartphone shop. He walks past there on the way to Yeshivah on Sunday. Then on
7
Monday. Then on Tuesday… For twelve days, he overcomes – without a single person
knowing. On the thirteenth day, he can’t control himself. He walks in and buys a
smartphone.
He comes to Yeshivah, gets caught, and is thrown out.
But in Shamayim, they know what really happened: The twelve times he overcame.
The twelve times he walked past and didn’t buy it. Okay, he fell once – he’s only a
human. But he will pick himself back up again and throw the smartphone out!
Even though he fell in the end, those twelve times he overcame will never get lost.
Even though the only One who knows about them is Hashem.
And – one more thing before we take this back to Elul: It's super unhealthy to eat
sweets. But it's super healthy to want to eat sweets. Struggling and temptations are
normal and healthy.
Elul: Reframed
Let’s bring this back to Elul. We said that so many teens feel a tenseness around Elul.
Feel like it's ‘tax collection season.’
We have to reframe. We have to realise that Rosh Hashana is the most precious day.
A day where we can internalise ‘Avinu’ and be completely vulnerable to Hashem.
A day where we utilise ‘Malkeinu’ and let go of every single worry around health,
finances and friends.
A day that we can resolve to take control of the one thing that matters, our Yiras
Shamayim.
By saying ‘Chatanu Lefanecha’, we’re not going in to a mortgage broker and admitting
all our failures. We’re turning to our Father, who will catch us, to our King, who controls
every part of our lives with mercy. We can be totally vulnerable here.
8
