Clarity for Teens - English — Ha'azini - Shabbos Tshuva (2026-09-14)

Shabbos Shuva
The 8 most common asked questions about
teshuvah I get asked by Q&As
Q1 Someone who does an Aveira is on a level that he wasn’t on before. If he
watched something he shouldn’t have, it’s now in his mind. So how can we say
that a Yid always intrinsically remains a pure Tzaddik? He has done something that
has affected his Neshama!
A1 there is a story about a yid that went to R’ Yakov Meir Schechter, one of the
Gedolim in Eretz Yisroel, and asked him if he could make a deal with him: he was
guilty over some of the things he had done. If he promised never to do it again,
could he promise him that he would not get punished for what he had already
done? That would help him get out of my guilt and make a real commitment to
stop.
He looked at him with a big smile and said, “Why would you want that?”
“Because I want to turn over a new leaf so I can move forward, and I am finding it
hard to move forward after what happened in the past,” he replied. He looked at
him again and said, “But why would you want that? Do you not realise that those
moments in your life were the best that could have happened to you?”
he looked at him – shocked. Had he heard what he had said? He continued, “If
you are going to do Teshuva from Ahava, then everything you have done turns into
a Mitzvah. And if you do Teshuva from Yirah, then it will also be to your benefit –
because it was this Aveira that put you on a U-turn to change things in your life!
That is the biggest present Hashem could have given you!”
When you use the bad things you did in your youth as stepping stones to move
on, they become part of your journey upwards!
There is no excuse for doing what you want – that’s not growing. But the times you
do fall, don’t get too dragged down – use it as a stepping stone to grow!
Q2 What if someone does have the attitude to “do the Aveira and then do
Teshuva”? Does that mean he can never do Teshuva if he later wants to?
A2 someone asked me this last week, hat he does an aveirah knowing that
one day he will be a good boy, does that make him into a person that says
Echta vushiv? I answered that he is actually much better than a normal guy that
sins because he knows its wrong and wants to stop while doing it he just cannot
1
Shabbos Shuva
control himself. What echta veushiv means is that he does not care sinning
because he will get a kapparah so why not enjoy yourself.
On a similar note, you may ask if teshuvah works at any moment why bother, let’s
wait till you stop having fun?
Imagine you buy a lottery ticket – and it’s the winning one! You’ve won £3 million!
You go to school and show it to everyone, convincing them that it’s actually real.
You show your parents. You show everyone around you.
Your mother offers you a lift to go and claim the prize, and you reply, “No, it’s fine.
I’ve got 12 months. I’ll go tomorrow.”
The next day, your friends come running over. “Let’s do something fun – you are a
millionaire!” “I haven’t picked it up yet,” you answer.
The days go on, and you find yourself desperate to go away with some friends.
You go over to your mother. “Please can I have £200 to go away with friends?”
Your mother looks at you. “You are a millionaire! You can pay for it!” But you beg
and beg, until she relents.
Time marches on until it’s the end of the season. You beg your mother for new
clothes. She turns to you in exasperation. “You have all the money in the world!”
But you beg and beg, until she gives you the money.
Your friends think you have gone insane. Your mother doesn’t know why you
won’t just claim the prize.
Finally, the day before the deadline, you go and get your money.
This story might sound insane, but it actually recently happened in America. A
lottery winner – for the staggering amount of $1.2M – claimed his prize a week
before the deadline. I don’t have the foggiest idea why he would do that.
Doing Teshuva is winning the lottery. Connection to Hashem is Olam Hazeh – not
only Olam Haba! Why wait? Why push it off? You can have it now! You are losing
out with every minute…
But Teshuva is always possible going forward. Wherever you are – you can go
forward from there. Even an hour before death. If you do Teshuva later, you might
not be able to ‘get out of jail scot-free’, but you will be able to move forward from
there.
2
Shabbos Shuva
Q3 Is it wrong to have opposing thoughts? To want to do Teshuva, and at the same
time be pulled to continue doing the Aveira?
A3 Well, it’s not wrong to have opposing thoughts; it’s just human.
Take a teenager who genuinely wants to do Teshuva. Although they truly want to
move up, they might simultaneously want to continue the fun they’ve been
having.
It’s like a kid sucking a lolly on the way to the dentist. She knows she’s going to
have a filling, but she can’t stop herself from licking that lolly.
The fact that you want to do bad tells you one thing: Congratulations, you’re
human. The fact that you want to do good tells you something else: You’re a Yid.
Do you have a split personality disorder? Do you lead a double life? No – you
don’t have a double life, you have a Yiddishe life.
Your Yetzer Tov is telling you to do Teshuva; your Yetzer Hara is telling you not to.
You aren’t your Yetzer Hara or Yetzer Tov – but you have both of them in you.
You also have to realise a strong point: Your thoughts aren’t you. Of course, you
have to try to build boundaries. You have to try to do what you can. Without going
too deeply into it, I can tell you one thing: You aren’t your thoughts, and when you
do have a bad thought, you should push it aside so it doesn’t become part of you.
(But here’s the funny thing: Really, the Yetzer Hara and Yetzer Tov are taking you
to the same goal – towards Hashem. It’s the Guf that translates the Yetzer Hara’s
pull away from Hashem.)
It’s completely normal to have opposing thoughts. It’s part of having Nisyonos,
and you will always have Nisyonos. But you can keep being Mechazek yourself to
keep going.
Q4 What happens if you do proper Teshuva on an Aveira, but a few weeks later fall
back into that Aveira again? What then?
A4 After Neila, everyone is sure they are never going to sin again. They are sure
they will stay pure for the rest of their lives. Somehow, Purim comes around,
and…
Is it fake? Is it real?
We’ve done this every year on Yom Kippur. But somehow, we do fall.
3
Shabbos Shuva
Sometimes, you are doing something wrong on your computer, and you feel
really guilty. Then and there, you promise yourself – never again. For the next
month, you keep to your word. The month after that, you do the same. But a few
months later, you find yourself in the same situation.
Was the promise real?
First, on a simple level: The Satmar Rebbe tells us that if you never wash your
clothes… you won’t have any friends. When you put your soiled clothes in the
washing machine, you know they will get dirty again. So what’s the point of
washing them?
Because if you don’t continue to clean them, the dirt will get deeper, more
ingrained, and eventually, impossible to remove.
Whenever you do proper Teshuva – whether on Yom Kippur or any other time –
you are going in the washing machine. You come out with a clean slate.
Secondly, whenever you do Teshuva, it’s as if you’ve closed a link in the chain,
and started a new one. You will never have a life without Nisyonos. Compare it to
a computer game: When you do Teshuva, it’s as if you’ve reached level 2. But
there will be new Nisyonos in level 2!
Hashem gives Nisyonos to Tzadikim. Hashem gives Nisyonos to those He wants
to draw close. So having Nisyonos after you have done an Aveira is a good thing –
Hashem wants you to come even closer.
You aren’t a fake. Your Teshuva was real. You said you won’t do it again – and you
won’t – because you won’t do the same Aveira with the same intention as last
time. You might fall. You might do something you don’t want to. But when you
promised yourself that you won’t do it again, you were saying “I don’t want this.”
And you don’t. Hashem gave you the Nisoyon again, and you fell. But your
Teshuva was not in vain. You aren’t back at square one. Even if you fall again,
your Teshuva remains!
R’ Tzadok HaKohen says: When you build a tall building, and at the end, you fall
off, the building doesn’t come down with you! The building stays standing.
Life’s a journey with ups and downs. But the Teshuva you do, the connection you
work on, that stays forever. The good you have done is yours forever.
It’s a normal thing to fall. But you have to remember – you aren’t back at the same
place you were. You are on a higher level, struggling with something else.
4
Shabbos Shuva
When you go swimming underwater, you come up every few minutes to breathe.
Why do you come back up again if you keep going back under? Because if you
want to survive underwater, you have to continue breathing! If you want to survive
in this world, you have to continue doing Teshuva!
Everyone is a Baal Teshuva – if you aren’t one yet, become one! (The Kotzker.)
Q5 How do I stop my past from stopping me from growing? I messed around in high
school, but now I’m going to Yeshivah and want a new start...
A5 If you don’t accept your past, you can’t have a future. Nothing that ever
happened will stop you from growing – unless you don’t accept that it happened.
If you don’t accept it, it will always bog you down. It doesn’t mean you were a
Tzaddik for doing what you did, but now, do Teshuvah and move on.
There is Teshuvah for a reason, and we have to believe in this power of change.
Q6 I want to do Teshuvah, but honestly, I’ve watched really bad stuff, and the
images won’t leave me alone. I feel like I haven’t moved forward because my head
can’t seem to move on even though I want to…
A6 When boys speak about this, it’s often because they can’t learn after they
watch. Girls don’t need to learn. But their past can keep haunting them still.
Firstly, as we’ve said, scientists say it takes approximately 3–6 months – but I
would say more likely six months – to clear the brain. That’s a long time. But how
long was Yosef Hatzadik in prison, after doing the right thing?
When you take the plunge and stop doing something bad, you have to know that
it might take time. You will struggle. The images will drive you crazy in your mind.
You will feel like you are falling anyway, so you might as well watch.
But you have to know that there isn’t only light at the end of the tunnel – there is
light in the tunnel. When you are struggling through and overcoming these
thoughts, that is your point of connection with Hashem.
You’ve dug yourself a pit. But you want to get out of it. No one would say, “I have
so many more steps to take that I might as well fall back down right now.” You
want to get out.
Take those 6 months as a growth journey. The images will come back to you. You
will struggle. But you will grow.
5
Shabbos Shuva
The Gemara says that true Teshuva is when you come to the exact same
scenario, and overcome it. When the images and videos play in your mind, you
are overcoming them and doing real Teshuva.
Eventually, you will be so proud of yourself, and the connection you gained during
this struggle will remain with you always.
R’ Tzadok HaKohen says: When you build a building, and then fall, the building
doesn’t come down with you.
Even if you fall two months in, the two clean months will be yours forever! You
won’t need to start again.
These six months of struggle will be incredibly cleansing to your soul. And
remember: There is an end to the struggle – and a purpose to the struggle.
Q7 Can someone who fell, but did Teshuva, ever be on the same level as someone
who never fell?
A7 No – the one who did Teshuva will always be higher. ‘B’Makom Sh’Baalei
Teshuva Omdim, Ein Tzadikim Gemurim Ycholim Laamod’ – ‘In a place where
Baalei Teshuva stand, even complete Tzadikim can’t stand.’
‘It’s not fair,’ you might think. ‘The Baal Teshuva did the Aveira, how come he is
higher than the Tzadik who didn’t?’
The Pri Megadim explains: The Baal Teshuva has a harder time – he struggles
harder.
Take a Baal Teshuva who used to eat in McDonald’s. Every time he goes past one
of the big, yellow ‘M’ signs, he struggles. Or take a Baal Teshuva who used to be
addicted to gambling. Every time he goes past a casino, there’s an internal
struggle in his heart.
I don’t struggle when I go past a McDonald’s. I don’t struggle when I go past a
casino.
He gets Schar for overcoming these constant Nisyonos – I won’t get that amount
of Schar. It’s not as hard for me.
But we have to remember the most important point – we can ALL become Baalei
Teshuva in our own lives.
6
Shabbos Shuva
Q8 Are my successes still counted if I fall afterwards?
A8 We all know of the famous fight Yaakov Avinu had with the Malach. We are
called Klal Yisroel, Bnei Yisroel, after the name Yaakov Avinu received after this
fight.
I want to ask you something: Imagine you witnessed a fight. You would see one
man emerge strong, unaffected, uninjured. You would see the other man emerge
injured, with a black eye. Who won?
Yaakov Avinu walked out of the fight with the Malach limping. So, it would seem
like the Malach won! How can we say that Yaakov won?
And if we look closely in the Psukim, we will see that the Malach said to Yaakov
Avinu, “I fought with you the whole night, and I didn’t manage. Let me at least do
something…” And he struck Yaakov Avinu in the Gid Hanasher. Why did he not do
this earlier? If he was going to manage to do something to Yaakov Avinu, why not
do it at the beginning of the fight?
The answer is very simple: Our aim with the Yetzer Hara is not to win the fight. It’s
to continue fighting. The Malach can win if he wants to. But your job is to continue
fighting.
If the Malach had not hit Yaakov Avinu’s hip, we would not have known that the
Malach could have done this all along. We would not have gotten this message –
that all we need to do is continue fighting, not worry about winning.
The name Yisroel represents not victory, but the fight. ‘Ki Sarisa Im Elokim’ – ‘you
fought with the Malach.’ We are not winners – we are warriors.
It’s a fight. You will win some, you will lose some. If you can’t accept your lows,
you won’t have highs. If you catch yourself in a low, remember – you aren’t dead.
You’ve fallen, but now get up and continue fighting. Then you’ve won.
7
