Kollel Lihoraah - English — Bereishis (2026-10-05)

Parshas Bereshis
5787
Ask the Rav
Beginning Shnayim Mikra V’Echad Targum from Minchah Gedolah or participate in the reading, or whether he must actually daven Minchah and
Only After Davening Minchah hear the Torah reading.
Furthermore, the Ketzos HaShulchan (siman 72), in Badei HaShulchan (se’if
Q: A very common question regarding the halachos of Shnayim Mikra katan 7), writes that according to the Rishonim who maintain that one may
V’Echad Targum is whether one may begin reading Shnayim Mikra for the complete the previous week’s parshah only until Minchah on Shabbos, if he
coming week from the time of Minchah Gedolah on Shabbos, even if he has has already davened Minchah with a minyan and heard Krias HaTorah, or if
not yet heard the Torah reading of the coming parshah, or whether he may there is only one minyan available to him and they have already davened
begin the new parshah only after hearing its reading at Minchah. Minchah, or even if all the batei knessiyos in the city have already davened
Minchah although he himself did not daven with them, he can no longer be
A: The Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 285:3) writes: “From Sunday onward, it is considered as completing the previous parshah im hatzibbur. According to
considered im hatzibbur — together with the congregation” — regarding the this reasoning, in our case as well, under such circumstances one would in-
obligation of Shnayim Mikra V ’Echad Targum. See Mishnah Berurah (se’if deed be considered to be reading the coming parshah im hatzibbur. See also
katan 7), who explains that since at Minchah on Shabbos we already begin Shu”t Minchas Chen, Vol. II (siman 17, os 5), who discusses this matter at
reading the coming week’s parshah, one who begins Shnayim Mikra at that length and rules that one should be stringent and wait until he actually hears
point is once again considered to be reading im hatzibbur. Accordingly, when the coming parshah during Krias HaTorah at Minchah, rather than relying on
the Mechaber writes that one may begin “from Sunday,” this is not meant the arrival of the time of Minchah Gedolah. My rebbi, Rav Avigdor Neben-
specifically. The Mishnah Berurah (se’if katan 8) further cites an opinion that zahl shlit”a, likewise ruled this way for me.
the ideal time to read Shnayim Mikra is on Erev Shabbos. Others, however, I have also heard from several Morei Horaah shlit”a that, in practice, one
maintain that one who reads it from the beginning of the week is also ful- should be stringent and not begin the coming week’s Shnayim Mikra until he
filling the mitzvah in the most ideal manner. The Maaseh Rav likewise rec- has heard Krias HaTorah at Minchah. According to this view, it is not suffi-
ords that the Gra would read a portion of the parshah Shnayim Mikra cient that the tzibbur has already begun hearing the new parshah from the
V’Echad Targum each day immediately after davening, completing it on Erev time of Minchah Gedolah. However, Maran Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv zt”l,
Shabbos. I also personally observed Maran HaGaon Rav Yosef Shalom El- however, ruled that one may read Shnayim Mikra from the time of Minchah
yashiv zt”l, who would read a portion of the parshah each day before daven- Gedolah. Since the tzibbur has already begun the new parshah, this is consid-
ing, continuing in this manner until Erev Shabbos before Minchah. See also ered im hatzibbur, and there is no reason to require one to wait until they have
Shaar HaTziyun (se’if katan 12), who writes that one certainly fulfills his completed the Torah reading. Since the leading poskim differ on this issue, I
obligation if he reads Shnayim Mikra from Minchah onward. generally rule that one who wishes to be lenient certainly has whom to rely
The question, however, is what precisely determines when one may begin upon. Nevertheless, one who is able to wait and follow the more stringent
Shnayim Mikra for the coming week. Is it specifically after he has heard that opinions should preferably do so. Ultimately, it depends upon the individual
parshah read at Minchah on Shabbos, or may he begin once the time of Min- circumstances and whether it appears that he will have sufficient time to com-
chah Gedolah has arrived, even though he has not yet heard Krias HaTorah? plete the parshah during the coming week.
First, it appears obvious to me that even if we assume that one may begin
Shnayim Mikra from the time of Minchah Gedolah before hearing Krias Ha- Bending an Aluminum Pan — Does This Make It Considered a Utensil
Torah, this would only apply if he has already completed the parshah of the Made by a Jew?
current week. This is because we rule that one should not read a later parshah
before completing the earlier one, and doing so would be reading the Q: I know that there are several opinions regarding whether disposable alumi-
parshiyos out of order. num pans require tevilas keilim. According to the Igros Moshe, the issue
The sefer Halichos Chaim (p. 94) cites the opinion of Rav Chaim Kanievsky arises only if one intends to use the pan several times. Some are stringent
zt”l that even if the time for Minchah has arrived, if one has not yet davened after the first use, while others are lenient. My question is whether, in order to
Minchah, it would appear that he may not begin the mitzvah of Shnayim avoid any question of an obligation to tovel the pan, it would help for a Jew
Mikra for the coming week until he hears its reading at Minchah. However, to bend the pan until it is unusable and then straighten it out again. Could this
Shemiras Shabbos Kehilchasah (42:60), in the footnote there, writes that it be considered as though the Jew made the utensil, thereby exempting it from
would seem that according to the Rishonim who maintain that one may com- tevilah even if it will subsequently be used many times?
plete the parshah from the time of Minchah onward, this means from the time
of Minchah Gedolah, since at that point the new parshah is already fit to be A: It appears obvious to me that this is not considered an act of craftsmanship
read. performed by a Jew, and consequently it accomplishes nothing with regard to
The sefer Bikkurei Chaim (Chapter 2) cites the author of Meor HaShabbos tevilas keilim. I have likewise heard this from several leading Morei Horaah
shlit”a as being uncertain whether this depends simply on the arrival of the shlit”a. However, I saw that Shu”t Emek HaTeshuvah, Vol. VIII (siman 92),
time for the Minchah Torah reading, even if the individual himself did not was asked regarding these thin utensils manufactured by a non-Jew whether
there is a basis to permit their use if a Jew Practical Corner: By Rabbi Nesanel Odzer from the Rabba-
bends them and subsequently straightens them out nim of Beis Horaah KLY
again. The reasoning for such a possibility is that the
obligation to tovel a utensil manufactured by a non-Jew When Finding a Blood Spot in an Egg
results from the act of manufacture performed by the non-
Jew. Thus, if the Jew nullifies the non-Jew’s act, perhaps the Q: This is one of the most common questions that people know is a
original manufacture is considered nullified. This could be com- question, but are confused about the basic halachah:
pared to bishul akum: if a non-Jew places a pot on the fire and a If I crack an egg and find a blood spot, must I throw away the entire egg,
Jew subsequently removes it and places it back on the fire, the cook- or can I simply remove the blood? What if I already poured the egg into
ing is no longer considered to have been performed through the act of a cake or other food and only afterward remembered that it contained a
a non-Jew. Perhaps the same principle applies here. blood spot? Must the entire mixture now be discarded?
Furthermore, this halachah is not comparable to tumah, where the sta-
tus depends upon the object’s susceptibility to tumah. If a utensil is A: There is an important distinction between a fertilized egg and an
broken and then repaired, it may once again become fit to receive tu- egg produced without a rooster, which Chazal refer to as safna de’ara.
mah, and one can say that it has returned to its original status. With re- When an egg is fertilized, a blood spot can potentially be connected to
gard to tevilas keilim, however, the matter depends upon the act through the beginning of development. The Shulchan Aruch therefore distin-
which the utensil was made. Once it has subsequently been made into a guishes between where in the egg the blood is found. In certain locations,
utensil through the act of a Jew, the obligation of tevilah should no long- only the blood must be removed and the rest of the egg remains permit-
er apply. He therefore concludes that, halachah lemaaseh, with such a ted, while in other locations the blood prohibits the entire egg. The Rema
utensil it is effective to nullify the original act of the non-Jew by bending writes that the accepted custom is to be stringent whenever blood is
it and subsequently straightening it. This is considered a repair or com- found and to prohibit the entire egg, without distinguishing between the
pletion performed by a Jew, and the utensil would therefore be exempt different locations of the blood spot (Yoreh Deah 66:3). An egg pro-
from tevilah. duced without a rooster is different. Since it can never develop, a blood
However, see Shu”t Cheshev HaEphod, Vol. III (siman 70), who writes spot does not have the same status. The Shulchan Aruch rules that such
that a prominent Rav ruled that if one bends such a utensil and subse- an egg remains permitted, although the blood itself must be removed
quently straightens it, its original status as a utensil manufactured by a (YD 66:7; see Shach 66:14). The Pischei Teshuvah likewise writes that
non-Jew is nullified, and it becomes considered a Jewish-made utensil in a safna de’ara egg, only the blood is prohibited, while the egg itself
that is exempt from tevilah. The author himself, however, writes that remains permitted (Pischei Teshuvah 66:2). Nevertheless, Rav Moshe
he finds this difficult to accept. Pressing the sides of such a pan in- Feinstein writes that when a blood spot is found in an individual egg, the
ward, even to a minor degree, can hardly be viewed as nullifying its accepted practice is to discard the entire egg. Although the basic hala-
status as a utensil. The very nature of these utensils is that they can be chah of an unfertilized egg would permit the egg after removing the
bent and then straightened again without any concern. This can hap- blood, since an individual egg is inexpensive, the custom is to be strin-
pen even to brand-new pans at the time of purchase. The accepted gent and throw it away (Igros Moshe, Yoreh Deah I:36). That is all when
practice has already become that if one purchases these pans for the egg is still by itself. Once it has already been mixed into other food,
disposable, one-time use, they are not toveled, based upon the rul- the halachah is different. If the egg was actually fertilized and the blood
ing of the Gaon, the author of Igros Moshe. However, if one in- was of the type that prohibits the entire egg, the prohibited egg would
tends to use such a pan repeatedly, the accepted practice is to require sixty times its volume in the mixture in order to be nullified.
tovel it. The author concludes that he sees no reason to disagree However, if it was a safna de’ara egg, the egg itself was never prohibit-
with this practice. ed. The Shulchan Aruch rules that when the blood is of a type that does
I subsequently found that in the same work (siman 115), in the not prohibit the egg, and one forgot to remove it before mixing the egg
notes of the author’s son zt”l, os 3, he cites his father’s posi- into other food, the mixture is permitted (YD 66:5). The Pischei Teshu-
tion that bending the utensil does not nullify its status as a vah specifically applies this to safna de’ara: once the egg and its blood
utensil at all. He further adds that the Pri Megadim (O.C. have been mixed in, the mixture is permitted.
451, Mishbetzos Zahav, se’if katan 6) writes that one who Rav Moshe goes even further. He writes that in such a case one does not
purchases a sheet of metal from a non-Jew, makes a hole in even require a majority of permitted food against the egg. He explains
it, and turns it into a rib eizen, should tovel it without a that the overwhelming majority of commercial eggs are produced with-
berachah. Only when one purchases raw silver from a out roosters, and therefore, according to the basic halachah, we follow
non-Jew and fashions it into a goblet is it exempt from the majority and assume that an ordinary egg is safna de’ara. One need
tevilah, because an entirely new entity has come into not be concerned that this particular egg was fertilized unless there is
existence. Changing a sheet of metal into a rib eizen, some reason to know otherwise (Igros Moshe, YD I:36). That commer-
however, is not considered a sufficiently significant cial reality remains the norm today: the vast majority of ordinary super-
transformation, and it therefore still requires tevilah. market eggs are produced from laying flocks in which roosters are gener-
Accordingly, if even such a change is not sufficiently ally not present. Therefore, if a blood-spotted ordinary commercial egg
significant to exempt a utensil from tevilah, then was accidentally poured into a cake or other food before the mistake was
certainly merely bending an aluminum pan cannot remembered, the mixture is permitted and does not need to be discarded.
be considered a sufficient transformation to exempt Summary: An individual commer cial egg with a blood spot should
it from tevilah — even if we were to assume that be discarded in accordance with the accepted practice. However, if it was
while it is bent it temporarily loses its halachic already accidentally mixed into other food, we rely on the fact that ordi-
status as a utensil. This follows the reasoning of nary commercial eggs are overwhelmingly safna de’ara. The mixture is
the Pri Megadim cited above. therefore permitted, even without sixty, and Rav Moshe rules that one
does not even require a majority against the egg.
Take a part in spreading the light!
Email info@kollellihoraah.org for sponsorship opportunities.
To receive this weekly publication via email, Click here or email info@kollellihoraah.org.
Have an interesting Shayla?
Ask the Rav at info@kollellihoraah.org
