Diamonds, Deals And Deeds - English — Bereishis (2026-10-05)
Chapter Seven
Chapter Seven
Disguised as a Purchase
Harav Aharon Rotter, author of Shaarei Aharon al HaTorah, relat-
ed:
Every year before Sukkos, the esrog dealers would come to Reb
Shmuel’s house and bring him the most mehudar esrogim. They knew
they would receive generous remuneration for the right esrog.
Once, it happened that there were three nice esrogim on the table.
“Tell me which is the most mehudar,” Reb Shmuel requested of me.
I examined the esrogim carefully and said, “Two of the esrogim are
very mehudar, but the third one might be somewhat deficient.”
As I was about to leave
his house, I said, “Don’t
forget to return the im-
perfect esrog to the deal-
er.”
“Return?” Reb Shmuel
gasped. “I won’t use it, of
course, but I can’t give
back the esrog! If I have
a chance to give tzedakah
in a dignified way to an-
other Yid, why should I
Harav Aharon Rotter (standing) honoring Reb Shmuel with not take advantage of the
sheva brachos opportunity?”
72 ◊ Diamonds, Deals And Deeds
Disguised as a Purchase
Lofty Levels!
Reb Baruch Aber, who was a manager in Reb Shmuel’s business for
many years, related this story:
“Do you have work for me?” a diamond polisher once asked Reb
Shmuel.
“Right now I do not need more polishers, but when I do have work
for you, I’ll be happy to contact you,” Reb Shmuel replied.
“I feel bad seeing a Yid looking for work and not being successful,”
Reb Shmuel remarked to me as the man left his office. But from
Above, it was orchestrated that Reb Shmuel would be able to help.
“Reb Shmuel,” a Yid asked him the next day. “I need a lot of money
to marry off my daughter. I have a raw diamond in my possession
and I’m asking $7,000 for it — a sum that will really make all the
difference.”
Reb Shmuel examined the stone, and as a professional, estimat-
ed that after the polishing and finishing, the stone would be worth
$5,000.
The Diamond Bourse in Ramat Gan
Diamonds, Deals And Deeds ◊ 7 3
Chapter Seven
It should be noted that the value of a polished diamond is mea-
sured in four ways: size, cleanliness, color, and the shape into which it
is polished. Any change in the stone, no matter how slight, can alter
the value of the stone significantly, and therefore, only a professional
can assess how much a raw stone will be worth after it’s polished.
However, even experienced professionals are liable to err, since it’s
difficult to predict what the exact size will be after it’s polished, how
clean it will be, and what color and shape it will be.
After examining the stone, I saw that he didn’t know how to answer
the man. Would he be frank about his opinion that the estimated
value of the stone was just $5,000?
After a short moment of deliberation, Reb Shmuel gave the seller
the full $7,000. The man was overjoyed, but we, the managers, could
not comprehend what Reb Shmuel’s motivations were. But then we
realized that he’d thought it through well — he’d be able to do two
mitzvos at once!
“Please call the polisher who was looking for work,” Reb Shmuel
requested of me. “I have a job for him.”
A few minutes later the man appeared in the office.
“Baruch Hashem, I found work for you. Please polish this diamond
for me; it’s very large, and I’ll give you $500 for doing the work.” The
polisher took the stone, clearly very happy with the assignment. Five
hundred dollars was an entire month’s salary for the average worker
in those days!
We were taken aback and asked Reb Shmuel, “Why would you pay
so much for polishing this stone — and after you bought it for such
a high price?”
“It’s worth it. An unemployed Yid is looking for parnassah and I
can help him out in a dignified way. Why should I miss out on this
mitzvah?” he replied sincerely.
When the polisher finished, he received his payment of $500 in
cash. We saw how happy Reb Shmuel was — he had merited to give
tzedakah in a dignified way to two people, and neither of them had
any inkling that they were on the receiving end.
After the polisher left the office, Reb Shmuel took the stone and
74 ◊ Diamonds, Deals And Deeds
Disguised as a Purchase
checked if he had correctly estimated its value at $5,000. He exam-
ined it quickly, and we saw his face light up.
“I was mistaken in my appraisal,” he called to me. “The diamond
came out much better than I’d expected — in size, cleanliness, col-
or, and shape. Now I estimate that it’s worth much more, at least
$12,000.”
A mere few minutes passed, and a buyer entered the office. “Reb
Shmuel, I need a large stone for a very wealthy client. I’ve looked in
several places, but haven’t yet found the right one.”
“How about this one?” Reb Shmuel asked, showing him the stone
that had been finished just a few minutes earlier.
“It’s magnificent! This is exactly what I’m looking for,” the buyer
replied happily. “And how much is it?”
“You decide,” Reb Shmuel replied.
“I would pay $10,500 for it,” he replied.
“Mazel u’brachah!” Reb Shmuel exclaimed.
The buyer paid and left the office in good spirits, while we were
left literally rubbing our eyes in disbelief. But that’s not the end of
the story!
A few minutes later, Reb Shmuel called me over and said, “Look, I
made $5,000 more than I expected on this stone. I thought I’d be be-
hind more than $2,000 and already considered the money tzedakah.
Then, baruch Hashem I earned $3,000, to make a total of five. I don’t
want to benefit from it, so please give the money to a poor kallah.”
This was Reb Shmuel’s way of thinking.
Tzedakah under the Guise of Esrogim and Eggs
Reb Rachamim Arbel, a factory manager in Shikkun Hey, wrote an
emotional letter:
Our family lived in the same home as my grandfather; nine chil-
dren cramped into a tiny home. Our financial situation was dire.
In the yard of his house, my grandfather cultivated esrog trees. Reb
Shmuel would come to him each year, choose several esrogim, and pay
about five times their worth.
My grandfather also raised chickens, and before Yom Tov, we would
Diamonds, Deals And Deeds ◊ 7 5
Chapter Seven
wait with anticipation
— Reb Shmuel would
come to buy eggs,
which meant we could
buy clothing for Yom
Tov! He would buy
forty(!) trays of eggs
and would pay my fa-
ther five times what
they were worth on the
market, all in order to
give us money in a way
that we would not be
embarrassed.
Free Toys with Dignity
Harav Yaakov Dovid Schreiber, Rosh Kollel in Vizhnitz in Ashdod,
related:
When the Daskal family cleaned for Pesach, there was much joy
in the Neve Achiezer neighborhood. All the neighborhood children
gathered in their courtyard, since the Daskals had an interesting way
of cleaning.
Each time he traveled abroad, Reb Shmuel purchased many gifts
for his children, so his house was always full of expensive toys and
games. Before Pesach, Mrs. Daskal would take many toys out to the
yard, and they were free for the taking. The neighborhood children
rejoiced with the bounty.
This was Reb Shmuel’s way of bringing happiness to the local chil-
dren in a dignified manner — in a way that they wouldn’t feel that
they were receiving a donation, but rather as though they were doing
the Daskals a favor by clearing the yard of the old toys.
Debts Repaid with Groceries and Sukkah Decorations
The Daskal children’s eyes widened in surprise at the sight of cases
76 ◊ Diamonds, Deals And Deeds
Disguised as a Purchase
of beer and boxes of other merchandise piled near the door to their
home. “Have we opened a grocery?” they asked.
An explanation was quickly forthcoming. “The grocery store owner
owes me a large sum of money. He can’t repay me but he wants to
settle his debt. I told him he could pay off the debt with groceries,”
Reb Shmuel related simply.
It was a remarkable idea, generated in the mind of a man who was a
walking, talking chessed factory — not only did he give tzedakah with
respect, he even found a dignified way out for borrowers who did not
have the cash to repay what they owed him.
One day, a person who manufactured sukkah decorations brought
over a huge stock of decorations to Reb Shmuel’s home. “What do we
need so many decorations for?” his children asked. Then they realized
— this was the man’s way of paying off his debt.
Brokerage Fees
Reb Leib Ber Shimonowitz of Kiryat Vizhnitz related:
Often, Reb Shmuel purchased packets of diamonds at the Bourse
even when he didn’t need them, just to provide an agent with parnas-
sah in an honorable way. He wanted to give to people with dignity,
and enable the agent to earn a living through business dealings and
not by being the apparent recipient of chessed.
Often, he sold a packet of diamonds through an agent so that the
agent would make a profit from the sale, even though had he sold it
himself, he would have earned more.
Selling Drawings for Tzedakah
Reb Shmuel’s friend and fellow diamond dealer, Reb Baruch
Greenberger, related:
Reb Shmuel once came over to me and said, “Reb Baruch, I have
a good deal for you. A widowed artist needs parnassah. She came to
sell me some of her drawings and I told her that I’d sell the pictures
at the Bourse. I figured that this way, she could earn parnassah in a
dignified way.”
Diamonds, Deals And Deeds ◊ 7 7
Chapter Seven
Indeed, every so often, Reb Shmuel brought the pictures to sell at
the Bourse. It would have been easier for him to give her the money
without having to sell the pictures, but this way, the widow felt that
she was earning her keep, not being given a handout.
78 ◊ Diamonds, Deals And Deeds
