Ohr Yosef - English — Bereishis (2026-10-05)

Ohr Yosef The Tree of Knowledge Bereshis p1
The Wrong Tree?
Hashem places Adam in Gan Eden, and the Torah tells us exactly what
grew there: וְעֵ ץ הַ דַ עַ ת טֹוב ו ָָּּרע, וְעֵ ץ הַ חַ יִּ ים ְבתֹוך הַ גָּן: the Tree of Life in the
middle of the garden, and the Tree of Knowledge of good and evil (Bereishis
2:9). Note the geography. The tree in the middle of the garden is the Tree
of Life. Then comes Hashem's commandment: eat from every tree, ּומֵ עֵ ץ
כִּ י ְביֹום ֲאכָּלְ ָך ִּממֶּ ּנּו מֹות תָּ מּות, הַ דַ עַ ת טֹוב ו ָָּּרע ל ֹא ת ֹאכַל ִּממֶּ ּנּו: but from the Tree
of Knowledge of good and evil you may not eat, for on the day you eat
from it you will die (2:16-17).
Now listen to Chava. The snake comes to her and asks about the garden,
and she answers: ֱֹלקים ל ֹא
ִּ ֲשר ְבתֹוך הַ גָּן אָּ מַ ר א
ֶּ ּומ ְפ ִּרי הָּ עֵ ץ א
ִּ . ִּמ ְפ ִּרי עֵ ץ הַ גָּן נ ֹאכֵל
ת ֹאכְ לּו ִּממֶּ ּנּו: we may eat the fruit of the trees of the garden, but of the fruit
of the tree in the middle of the garden, Hashem said, do not eat from it
(3:2-3).
The tree in the middle of the garden? That is the Tree of Life, the one tree
she was never told to avoid. Chava is describing the wrong tree. Did she
confuse the commandment? Did she think the Tree of Life was off limits?
Everything in this story turns on which tree is which, and in the very
conversation that leads to the sin, Chava points to the wrong one. The
snake, who knew exactly which tree he wanted her to eat from, does not
correct her.
A True Lie?
Another difficult part of the story is where the snake tells her ל ֹא מֹות
תמֻ תּון:
ְ you will not die (3:4). Hashem said she would die; the snake said she
would not. That sounds like a plain lie. Yet Chazal's charge against the
snake is a different one: he spoke lashon hara about his Creator (Bereishis
Rabbah 20:1). Lashon hara, not falsehood. And the Ramban goes further. He
© 5787 Yosi Rabinowicz. This weekly can be obtained by email from
gilyonOhrYosef@gmail.com or downloaded from www.ladaat.info
Translations are loose, and based upon The Living Torah by Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan
Ohr Yosef The Tree of Knowledge Bereshis p2
cites the midrash that lists the snake among three who spoke the truth
and were nevertheless lost from the world: the snake, the spies, and
Doeg (Ramban, Bereishis 2:9). Chazal are not saying the snake lied and was
punished for lying. They are saying he told the truth, and was punished
for how he used it. How could "you will not die" be the truth?
And the question everyone asks: if the Tree of Life gives eternal life and
the Tree of Knowledge brings death, why didn't Adam simply eat from
the Tree of Life first?
One Tree
Here is the answer, and it unlocks everything at once. The Tree of Life and
the Tree of Knowledge were really the same tree. There was only one
tree.
What made it the Tree of Life or the Tree of Knowledge was not the fruit.
It was the eating. Eat from it the way Hashem commanded, as a holy act,
and it is the Tree of Life, and you live forever. Eat from it against His word,
for the pleasure of it, and it is the Tree of Knowledge, and death follows.
Same branch, same fruit. The difference was entirely inside the person
reaching for it.
Now go back to Chava. She did not confuse the commandment. She called
the forbidden tree "the tree in the middle of the garden" because that is
exactly what it was. The Tree of Life and the Tree of Knowledge stood in
the same spot, because they were the same tree, and she knew it. She
had been told how to eat from it, and how not to.
And the snake did not lie either. Of that very tree he said "you will not
die," and it was true: one who eats from it in the right way lives forever.
He left out the one thing that mattered, and that is lashon hara: a true
statement, told to destroy. That is why he stands in the list with the spies,
who also described the land accurately and were also lost.
Ohr Yosef The Tree of Knowledge Bereshis p3
As for eating from the Tree of Life first: there was no "first." There was
one tree, and one choice about how to eat from it.
What the Two Ways Are
So, what is the difference between the two ways of eating? Why is one
called "life" and the other called "knowledge"?
In the Torah's language, knowing is not collecting information; it is
connecting. וְהָּ אָּ דָּ ם יָּדַ ע אֶּ ת חַ ּוָּה ִּא ְשתֹו: Adam knew his wife (4:1). To know
something is to be bound to it. So a tree of knowing good and evil is a
tree that binds you to good and to evil, both at once. The snake said as
much: ֵאֹלקים יֹ ְדעֵ י טֹוב ו ָָּּרע
ִּ ( ו ְִּהיִּיתֶּ ם כ3:5). After eating that way, a person is
attached to good, and also attached to evil. He loves what is right, and he
also finds that נּובים י ְִּמתָּ קּו
ִּ ְמַ יִּם ג: stolen waters are sweet (Mishlei 9:17). That
is us. Even a fine person has some part of him that is drawn to the wrong
thing. The work of a lifetime is to let the soul rule the body, until a person
reaches ( אֹהֲ בֵ י ה ' ִּשנְ אּו ָּרעTehillim 97:10): not merely resisting evil, but actually
finding it abhorrent.
Adam stood before that choice in its purest form. He could eat as Hashem
said and stay bound only to good, so that even if his body were pulled
toward something wrong, he would recoil from it the way we recoil from
poison, no matter how enticing it may look or smell. Or he could reach
for the fruit for the pleasure of it, through his body and its desires, and
be tied to good and evil together. That was the Tree of Life and the Tree
of Knowledge, and he chose the second.
Why Death?
Once you see it this way, "on the day you eat from it you will die" is not a
penalty stapled to a rule. It is cause and effect. Evil has no staying power;
by its nature it decays and falls apart. What keeps the world standing is
good. A person who binds himself to evil has bound himself to something
Ohr Yosef The Tree of Knowledge Bereshis p4
that is already breaking down, and so death followed, not as a fine but as
a consequence. The reason not to eat was simply that Hashem said no.
The death was what the eating did.
The Grape
The Gemara records a debate about what the tree was: Rabbi Meir says
it was a grapevine (Sanhedrin 70a). Think of what wine does. One person
drinks at a simcha and is lifted; he sings, words of Torah pour out of him,
he feels close to Hashem. Another person drinks the very same wine and
ends the night in the gutter, saying things he will regret in the morning.
It is the same grape. What it becomes depends entirely on how one drinks
it. That is what Rabbi Meir means, and that is the choice Adam faced.
Our Tree
That choice did not end with Adam. The Shulchan Aruch (O"C 231:1) codifies
it: in everything a person enjoys in this world, he should aim not at the
enjoyment itself but at serving his Creator, and even the voluntary things,
eating, drinking, walking, sitting, sleeping, conversation, should all be for
the service of his Creator or for something that leads to it. One who is
tired and sleeps for his health, so that his mind is clear for Torah, has
eaten from the Tree of Life. The same meal, the same nap, taken purely
for the pleasure of it, is the other tree. Nothing on the outside has
changed. Everything on the inside has.
This week is Shabbos Bereishis. The Yomim Tovim are behind us, and
Cheshvan, with no Yom Tov in it at all, begins this week. The year ahead
is mostly ordinary days of eating, working and sleeping. The question is
not whether we will eat from the tree. We will. The question is which tree
it will be.
May we merit to eat from the Tree of Life, and to see the world restored
to the garden it was meant to be, במהרה בימינו, amen.
