Rebbe Responsa - English — Bereishis (2026-10-05)

REBBE
RESPONSA
The Rebbe's English Letters
The Rebbe and the Physicist
Correspondence with a Jewish scientist on Torah
and science, and the urgent need for clarity
Issue 178
Rebbe Responsa | 2
ב”ה
A Word from the Publishers
We are pleased to present Issue 178 of Rebbe Responsa, a
collection of the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s English letters.
In connection with Parshas Bereishis, which recounts the
creation of the world, this week’s booklet presents a fascinating
correspondence between the Rebbe and Professor Cyril Domb,
a prominent Orthodox Jewish scientist, exploring the
relationship between Torah and science and the urgent need to
dispel the misconceptions surrounding them.
Included at the end of this week’s booklet is a previously
unpublished letter.
All letter titles, summaries, and footnotes were added by the
publisher.
* * *
To enjoy the full collection of the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s
English letters, we encourage you to download the Rebbe
Responsa app. With over 5,000 letters organized by both topic
and date, the app makes finding the Rebbe’s guidance and
worldview on a vast array of topics simple and accessible.
May the study of these letters hasten the coming of
Moshiach speedily in our days.
The Rebbe Responsa Team
Erev Shabbos Parshas Bereishis, 5787
To receive a free digital copy of Rebbe Responsa every week:
Email: Editor@RebbeResponsa.com
WhatsApp: chat.rebberesponsa.com
All previous issues of Rebbe Responsa are available at
booklets.rebberesponsa.com
3 | Bereishis
Table of Contents
Introduction ............................................................................. 4
What Religion Has Over Science ........................................ 7
The mistaken notion that Torah and science are in conflict; the limits
of scientific theories and their inability to challenge the truth of Torah;
the literal age of the world as established by Halacha; addressing the
confusion of young Jews more forthrightly
Professor Domb’s Reply ....................................................... 12
Drop Everything - This Is Urgent! .................................... 14
The urgent need to publish on religion and science; Jewish dating as
a count from Creation; the fallacy of evolutionary cosmology; light and
chronology before the creation of the sun; the apologetic stance of
many toward science
Confusion is Abound, and It’s Getting Dangerous ....... 18
Widespread confusion regarding perceived conflicts between Torah
and science; an incident illustrating how such doubts can prevent
practical mitzvah observance
Newly Released
To Yeshiva Without Delay ................................................... 21
Removing a boy from an environment of temptation and sending him
to Yeshiva; dealing with his parent's objection
Rebbe Responsa | 4
Introduction
The letters presented here record a fascinating correspondence
between the Rebbe and Professor Cyril Domb on the relationship
between Torah and science, and the questions troubling Jews who
perceive a conflict between the two.
Professor Cyril (Yechiel) Domb (5680–5772) was a distinguished
theoretical physicist and a leading Orthodox Jewish scientist. He served
as professor of theoretical physics at King’s College London, and later
at Bar-Ilan University, and as president of the British division of the
Association of Orthodox Jewish Scientists.
Domb’s connection with the Rebbe
began in 1958, during a sabbatical in the
United States. Although not a Lubavitcher,
he had long held Lubavitch in high regard.
At the suggestion of his friend Feivish
Vogel, he and his wife arranged a Yechidus
with the Rebbe shortly before returning to
England.
Domb later recalled the Rebbe’s warm
reception and interest in their activities.
The Rebbe encouraged the couple to
promote Taharas Hamishpachah, advice
Professor Domb they subsequently acted upon through
their involvement in establishing the
Jewish Marriage Education Council in England. The Rebbe also urged
Domb to use his standing in the scientific world to reach Jewish
intellectuals who were not yet observant and encourage their
involvement in Jewish life.
In early 1961, a scientific controversy over two competing theories
of the universe was attracting widespread public attention. The Big
Bang theory proposed that the universe had a beginning, while the
Steady State theory maintained that the universe had always existed in
essentially the same form. New observations in radio astronomy
appeared to favor the Big Bang, prompting discussion about the
implications for religious belief.
Domb later recalled how the controversy drew him into the public
debate:
5 | Bereishis
“It was generally assumed that religious thinkers would support the
‘big bang’ and secular thinkers ‘steady state.’ I was surprised to receive
an inquiry from the ‘Jewish Chronicle’ as to whether this identification
was correct, and if so whether I should explain why. My reply was to
say unequivocally that Torah thinking could live with either cosmology
... This was the first time which I entered into a public discussion,
although I had previously engaged in discussions largely with religious
groups.”
Domb’s article, “The Bible and Creation,” appeared in the Jewish
Chronicle on February 17, 1961, and attracted considerable attention.
Among those who took notice was the Rebbe, who wrote to Domb on
Rosh Chodesh Sivan, 5721, addressing his arguments in detail.
The Rebbe took issue with several of Domb’s conclusions,
particularly his suggestion that evolutionary cosmology could be
reconciled with the Torah’s account of Creation. More broadly, the
Rebbe stressed the need to address the doubts troubling many Jews,
especially the younger generation, who saw science and Torah as
conflicting accounts of reality.
Recognizing Domb’s standing as both a scientist and an observant
Jew, the Rebbe urged him to write a more comprehensive treatment of
the subject for a wider audience. When Domb replied that he would
consider the suggestion but was occupied with other projects, the
Rebbe wrote again, stressing that the matter was too urgent to
postpone. In a subsequent letter, the Rebbe related an incident
involving a Jew who had declined to begin putting on Tefillin because
of his unresolved questions about the age of the universe. The Rebbe
cited the incident to illustrate how such doubts could stand in the way
of practical mitzvah observance.
The correspondence had a profound effect on Domb. He later
recalled that the Rebbe’s encouragement “generated a positive reaction
in all spheres of my Torah life.” In the years that followed, he lectured
and wrote extensively on questions of Torah and science. Together
with Rabbi Aryeh Carmell, he also edited Challenge: Torah Views on
Science and Its Problems, choosing one of the Rebbe’s letters as its
opening essay.
Years later, reflecting on his relationship with the Rebbe, Domb
wrote:
“I have always spoken of myself not as a Lubavitcher Chossid but as
a Chossid of the Lubavitcher Rebbe.”
Rebbe Responsa | 6
*
Sources: Cyril Domb, B’Or Ha’Torah, vol. 18 (2008), pp. 183–192; Dovid
Zaklikowski, “The Physicist,” in Footprints (2017), pp. 32–43; Nochum Zajack, “The
Rebbe and the AOJS,” Part 3 (digital publication); Professor Cyril Domb’s personal
papers.
Additional letters addressed to ProfessorDomb available on the Rebbe Responsa
app are dated 26 Marcheshvan, 5729; 11 Tishrei, 5741; 4 Teves, 5741; 26 Teves,
5742; and 24 Tammuz, 5742.
7 | Bereishis
1
What Religion Has Over Science
The mistaken notion that Torah and science are in conflict; the limits of
scientific theories and their inability to challenge the truth of Torah; the
literal age of the world as established by Halacha; addressing the
confusion of young Jews more forthrightly
By the Grace of G-d*
Rosh Chodesh Sivan, 5721,
Brooklyn, N.Y.
Professor C. Domb
Kings College,
London
Sholom uBrocho:
Your article, “The Bible and Creation,” in the Jewish Chronicle of
February 17, 1961, has been brought to my attention. I take the liberty of
commenting on it, and I do so on the basis of the Rabbinic saying, “kol
yisroel areivim ze boze,” 1 especially in view of the fact that we had
occasion to exchange correspondence when you wrote to me on a
question connected with Chassidus. This circumstance assumes
particular significance in the light of one of the Chassidic tenets which,
on reflection, is a basic principle of our faith, namely, that everything is
directed by Hashgocho Protis. All the more so when two Jews come into
contact with each other, for Jews enjoy Divine Providence in particular,
especially when such contact is utilized toward the dissemination of
the Torah and Mitzvoth, the embodiment of the Divine Wisdom and
Will.
Your article indicates that you are aware of the difficulties and
conflicts besetting the minds of many Jews, particularly in the ranks of
the younger generation, difficulties arising from the existence – as it
seems to them – of contradictions between religious belief and science.
Though not a new problem, it has become accentuated by the belief
that there are contradictions also from the direction of the so-called
“exact” sciences which are popularly assumed to have been proven
beyond a shadow of doubt. Hence they are faced with the problem of
Source: Photocopy of the original.
1
Shavuos, 39b.
Rebbe Responsa | 8
either remaining in the religious camp in defiance of the scientific
deductions, or having to choose between the two.
Needless to say, the Jew whose faith has, as it should, the power of
unassailable conviction, has no problem in the first place. For to him
the Torah and all that it teaches is the Divine Truth, and he rejects a
priori anything that contradicts it. On the other hand, since all Jews are
required to uphold the Torah and its precepts regardless of the degree
of their religious convictions, it is obviously a matter of obligation to
help them dispel their doubts and conflicts.
As a matter of fact, the whole problem is based on a popular
misconception as to what science is. Where there is a true
understanding of what science really is, there is no room for such
confusion. For, as it is well known but too often overlooked, the
sciences, even the so-called “exact” sciences, are at bottom nothing
more than assumptions, work hypotheses and theories which are only
“probable,” as indeed you pointed out in your article, but all too briefly.
On the other hand, religious truths are definitive and categorical. To
quote our Sages – and it is also self-evident – “bori v’shemo, bori odif.”2
In other words, science cannot, a priori, challenge religion, especially
our religion, for science can never speak in terms of absolute truth. The
best proof for this, as you also mention in passing, is that many
scientific theories of the past which had been accepted as ultimate have
been swept away “absolutely” and categorically, to the extent that
science can be “absolute.” A glaring example is provided by the question
of the geocentricity (of our global earth) in the planetary system, and
better still in the universe, which had been such a bone of contention
between scientists and theologians, and when Copernicus’ theory was
accepted, many theologians hastily began their apologetics by
attempting to reinterpret Biblical passages in the light of the new
scientific “truth,” but not very convincingly so. Now, according to the
theory of relativity, it is held that from the scientific point of view either
theory could be accepted.
I would like to add that the fact that scientific laws are only
probable, and are merely statements of the most likelihood, reflects not
only on future predictions, but also on deductions relating to the past,
which must remain in the realm of probability based on observation.
Where no observation/experiment is possible, deductions are purely
conjectural. Hence science can never challenge the veracity of the
Genesis account from the viewpoint of the evolutionary theory or any
2
Kesubos 12b; et al.
9 | Bereishis
other theory, and it would be just as “scientific” to accept the account
verbally as to reinterpret it allegorically to harmonize it with any
particular cosmological theory.3
With regard to this particular portion of the Torah, however, I must
disagree with the statement you made in the said article to the effect
that from the Torah viewpoint it is possible also to accept the
evolutionary theory, in support of which you cite certain
interpretations of this portion. This is not so, and the test of the matter
is Halachah. Where Halachah is concerned there can be no alternatives,
for the rule of Halachah is the rule of reality. So long as the Halachah is
not infringed, we are at liberty to interpret the Biblical verses on any
level of P’shat, Remez, Drash and Sod. But this prerogative ends where
Halachah has ruled. This rule must be accepted “on top” of all
interpretations. Now, according to the Halachah our world came into
being 5721 years ago, and the age of the world is reaffirmed on such
Torah legal documents as Gittin, and the like; Shabbos is the seventh
day of the week, which the Halachah connects with the six days of
creation that preceded it (T.B. Shabbos 69b), and so on. The literal
acceptance of the Genesis account does not conflict with the doctrine
in Midrash, Kabbalah and the Zohar that G-d “created worlds and
destroyed them,”4 since the latter refers to spiritual worlds as amply
explained in these disciplines, according to the final explanation of the
Ari.5
The purpose of the above fairly lengthy observations is introductory
to the suggestion I wish to make, namely, that in view of the fact that
your article dealt all too briefly with such an important topic, I make so
bold as to suggest that you should elaborate on it. In treating this
subject more fully, you could bring out more forcefully the fact that
science is basically a theory of probable phenomena, and can in no way
challenge religious truths. There is no contradiction between this
correct viewpoint and human daily conduct based on these scientific
assumptions. Here is where religious beliefs and practices have the
3
For a compilation of the Rebbe’s letters on the subject, see Rebbe Responsa,
issue 90 “Geocentrism”.
4
Bereishis Rabba 3:7; Koheles Rabba 3:11; Zohar vol. 1 262b. See also Sefer HaBahir
1:2. For a comprehensive resource on this subject see Torah Shleima, vol. 1, pp.
84-89.
5
See Ariza”l’s Sha’ar Ma’amorei Rashb”i to Idra Rabba 44b; Sefer HaLikutim,
Parshas Ki Sisa; Parshas Kedoshim; See also Sefer HaMa’amarim 5768, p. 47. See
Torah Ohr, 51d; Toras Chaim 53b; Igros Kodesh, vol. 14, letter 5134 and references
there.
Rebbe Responsa | 10
“advantage” over science, for it is only the Torah, Toras Chayyim, that
gives certitude to human deductions arrived at in the proper way,
giving them the stamp of truth not only within the rational and sensible
world, but also in a transcending way. Thus, as above, Shabbos is
evidence of the creation of the world ex nihilo as a fact, etc. etc.
I trust that as you reflect on the above observations, and on the
opportuneness of the hour, when so many of our young people
experience a religious reawakening and a desire to return to our Torah
and traditions, yet they are confused and held back by the
misconceived doubts and conflicts mentioned earlier, you will respond
to the urgent need of bringing some clarity and light into those
confused minds, a task for which your position eminently qualifies you.
At this time before Shovuoth, the Season of our Receiving the Torah,
which is called Toras Chayyim and Torah Emes, I send you my good
wishes for an inspiring Yom Tov and, in the words of my father-in-law
of saintly memory, “to receive the Torah with joy and inwardness.”
With blessing,
M. Schneerson
11 | Bereishis
Note the Rebbe’s handwritten edits and additions in black ink.
The annotations in red ink were made by Professor Domb.
Rebbe Responsa | 12
Professor Domb’s Reply
25th Menachem Av, 5721
Dear Rabbi Schneerson, שליט”א
Thank you for your letter of Rosh Chodesh Sivan. It is a source of
great encouragement to me that you should have felt it worthwhile to
write so fully about my article in the “Jewish Chronicle”. I must apologise
for my delay in replying – this is not due to lack of appreciation of the
significance of your letter; on the contrary I felt I must have some time
to think clearly before composing a suitable reply. I have been
exceptionally busy in the past few months with the “Hovevey Torah”
organization of which I am Chairman, and whose activities you may have
heard of. Also I have taken an active part in attempting to raise the
standard of the “Jewish Review” to make it a vehicle of intelligent
orthodox opinion which is very badly needed in Anglo-Jewry at the
present time.
I should first explain the background to my article in the “Jewish
Chronicle”. The non-Jewish press had featured prominently a
controversy between two eminent scientists, Hoyle and Ryle, on some
experimental results and their cosmological implications. Several
newspapers published articles naively assuming that religious beliefs
might stand or fall with the results of such scientific experiments. The
Editor of the “Jewish Chronicle” telephoned me on Monday morning to
ask my opinion, and to invite me to suggest somebody, or to undertake
myself, to write an article presenting the Jewish point of view. The
article must be produced within two days, was limited to 1000 words,
and should largely base itself on the current controversy. Hence the
reason for the terseness and lack of amplification of the arguments as
you so rightly point out. I have on other occasions used some of the
further [ideas] which you suggest in your letter. (I am sending under
separate cover copies of other articles which have appeared in various
places.) Requests reach me frequently to talk about “Science and
Religion” and I try to vary the approach according to the background of
the audience.
I shall consider seriously your suggestion of putting all the
arguments together in more comprehensive form. At the moment I am
still very much involved in a number of projects - including a new Daf-
Hashavua adaptation of the Daf-Yomi which we are trying to launch in
Hovevey Torah - but perhaps I may be able to find time בע”הon a future
occasion.
13 | Bereishis
Regarding the criticism you make of my defence of the “evolutionary
Theory”, I should first point out that I was talking of evolutionary
cosmology (a creation ex nihilo followed by a steady evolution) and not
Darwinian evolution. Generally on all matters of Halacha I do not rely
on my own knowledge, but I consult with Rabbi E. Wiesenberg whom I
consider to be a great Talmid Chacham and Yerei Shamayim. He has told
me that our date 5721 A.M. is only binding on Jewish legal documents in
conjunction with the phrase במנין שאנו מונים כאן, and there is a responsum
from Rav Hai Gaon which says that our reasons for accepting precisely
this date are not too clear. (Quoted in Sefer HaIbbur by Rabbi Abraham
bar Hiyya p. 97 השער השביעי הוי יודע כי החשבון הזה אשר בידינו לא מאדם הראשון
)ירשנו אותו ואין אנו יודעין בימי אדם הראשון איך נעשה
In regard to the six days of creation I have always maintained that
the Torah does not give us the key to an understanding of P’shat. How
are we, for example, to measure the passage of the day before the
creation of the sun? And if we are to accept the interpretation of a
Midrash which says that soon after creation the period of the rotation
of the sun was very slow, our whole basis of timing may have to be
changed. I have therefore always taken the attitude of the Mishnah in
Hagigah אין דורשין במעשה בראשיתi.e. the ultimate secrets of creation are
beyond normal human understanding. Any scientific theories are only
temporary structures, and as long as their limitations are fully
appreciated they may help in technical progress….
With best wishes for [5722]
Yours sincerely
C. Domb
Rebbe Responsa | 14
2
Drop Everything – This Is Urgent!
The urgent need to publish on religion and science; Jewish dating as a
count from Creation; the fallacy of evolutionary cosmology; light and
chronology before the creation of the sun; the apologetic stance of many
toward science.
By the Grace of G-d*
29th of Tishrei, 5722
Brooklyn, N.Y.
Professor C. Domb
37 Green Lane
Hendon, London N.W.4
Sholom uBrocho:
This is to acknowledge with thanks receipt of your letter of 25th
Menachem Av, in reply to my suggestion that you publish a series of
articles, or a comprehensive monograph, on the subject of “Religion
and Science.” Pressure of my duties and the intervention of Tishrei
compelled me to postpone my reply to your letter.
You mention your preoccupation with other Torah projects at this
time, and express the hope that you may perhaps find time on some
future occasion to act on my suggestion.
Permit me, therefore, to observe that while the public dissemination
of Torah merits a high priority, as the first Mishnah of Peah states, I
cannot share your view that this applies to the present instance. My
authority for this view is the Gemara (Moed-kattan 9 a/b) which rules
that “A Mitzvah which cannot be performed by others takes precedence
over all else.”
As I pointed out in my previous letter, and as you well know, the
present state of confusion besetting the minds of so many of our
brethren, a confusion which is not limited to theoretical issues, but
which touches upon fundamental principles and attitudes, down to the
very observance of the Mitzvoth in the daily life, urgently calls for an
authoritative clarification by a recognized authority in the field of
science. I am confident that if the cobwebs of misconception attending
Source: Photocopy of the original.
15 | Bereishis
the advancement of modern technology could be cleared away,
numerous misguided individuals would be induced to re-examine their
position, while others still clinging to their beliefs and traditions, yet
are troubled by doubts, would have their confidence restored.
I realize, of course, that the undertaking which I am suggesting
requires time and attention. Nevertheless, I feel that the encroachment
on other important projects would not be so drastic, and in the longer
run, perhaps, it might even turn out to be a contribution rather than an
encroachment, in the light of the Mishnah, “one Mitzvah brings another
in its train,”6 especially a Mitzvah that cannot be performed by others,
and where there can be no fear of duplication or excess.
Now to refer to some points raised in your letter.
Regarding our date, namely, the present year 5722 since Creation,
you write that you were told by a Rov that this date is somewhat
arbitrary, and its use in Jewish legal documents is qualified by the
phrase – במנין שאנו מונין כאן.
I am surprised that the Rov did not mention the fact that the very
same phrase contains the unequivocal words – לבריאת עולם. In other
words, this dating is not conventional, as, for example, in the case of
“Minyan Shtorot,” which was adopted and ordered to a certain
convenient date in the past. Our annual dating is historic, beginning
with the Creation of the world, and its use in legal documents explicitly
substantiates its authenticity.
You cite certain Rishonim in this connection, but since I have not at
hand these sources, I must withhold comment. However you surely
know that there is general agreement among our authorities of the
essential point that this dating is based on the Creation. Whatever
reservations have been made by some authorities (on account of the
Flood, or other adjustments – )שנת תוהו שנת המבולthe whole difference in
the date would not exceed 3 years. (The Machlokes whether it was in
Nissan or Tishrei that the world was created represents only a
difference of six months.) The basic fact that our dating is related to the
Creation of the world is not challenged by our authorities.
With reference to the view of “evolutionary cosmology,” i.e. an
evolution preceded by creatio ex nihilo, it is “difficult” to reconcile this
view with the evolutionary theory, since it is impossible to cram within
a period of 5722 years a process of evolution as conjectured by the
6
Avos 4:2.
Rebbe Responsa | 16
evolutionists which, if it be true at all, would require millions and
billions of years.
You mention the difficulty of understanding the account of creation
literally, specifically how it is possible to define days before the sun was
created. But I do not see the difficulty at all. The literal meaning of the
words “And it was day and it was night”7 is inescapable, for the very
same words are used in the text before as well as after the sun was
created, i.e. in each of the six days of Creation. It would surely be
illogical to assume that the very same expression, used in identical
context and in the very same section, should have different meanings!
This still leaves the question, how is the passage of a day to be measured
before the sun was created? But this question, too, has no basis insofar
as the text is concerned. For we are told at the outset that G-d created
light, and separated between light and darkness, that is to say, the
Creator at once set the limits of the day and night. As for the source of
this light, surely no one will claim that the sun is the only possible
source of cosmic light, especially if we accept the view of science that
light has to do with electro-magnetic waves, surely there could be
other sources of light and energy besides the sun. Whether we accept
the corpuscular theory of light, or the wave theory, or the theory
combining the two, our position is not affected thereby.
One final remark, apropos of your mentioning that in these matters
you do not rely on your own judgment but consult with Rabbonim, etc.
Unfortunately, the majority of Rabbonim stand too much in awe of
scientific theories, for they still adhere to the attitude of bygone
generations, when science was regarded as an absolute truth, as
something apart from human intelligence and speculation, in other
words, that scientific laws are not produced, but merely “discovered”
by the scientist, and are infallible and immutable. This attitude was
fostered even by the Moreh Nevuchim and subsequent philosophers
and theologians who followed the line that where “science” appears to
contradict statements in the Torah or Talmud, the latter must be
reinterpreted to conform to the scientific “truth.” So deeprooted is this
attitude, having received the sanction of such eminent authorities in
the past, that even now, when scientists themselves recognize that they
are dealing not with independent “truths” and immutable laws, but
merely with theories, formulated only for the convenience of
systematization, classification and research advancement, — many a
7
Bereishis 1:5, 1:8, 1:13; 1:19; 1:23; 1:31.
17 | Bereishis
well-meaning Rov still finds it difficult to change his attitude in regard
to science.
That is why I consider it so necessary in the present day and age to
clear away these widespread misconceptions not only from the minds
of religious sceptics, but also from the minds of believers.
I trust you will take the lead in this important task.
With blessing,
M. Schneerson
Rebbe Responsa | 18
3
Confusion is Abound, and It’s
Getting Dangerous
Widespread confusion regarding perceived conflicts between Torah and
science; an incident illustrating how such doubts can prevent practical
mitzvah observance
By the Grace of G-d*
4th of Teveth, 5722
Brooklyn, N.Y.
Prof. C. Domb
37 Green Lane
Hendon
London N.W.4
Greeting and Blessing:
With further reference to my previous letter to you, to which,
incidentally, I have not received your reply as yet, I want to bring a
recent episode to your attention which has a bearing on the subject
matter.
It is related to one of our activities, whereby some of our young men
visit various communities and university campuses, where they
speak on the matters of practical interest from the point of view of
traditional Yiddishkeit. Where possible, they also speak about
Chassidus. Such visits are often arranged in response to invitations
which are timed to coincide with special occasions, such as Yom
Tov and the like. Thus, recently, in connection with Yud Tes Kislev
and Chanukah, a number of such lectures had been arranged in
various parts of the country. On the last day of Chanukah, a similar
lecture had been arranged in a certain college town, at the invitation
of communal and campus leaders, who participated, and which was
generally very well attended, including a goodly number of Jews
who are not as yet observers of the Torah and Mitzvoth in the fullest
sense. But all were equally impressed by the fact that American-
born young men, including Ph.D’s, and professionals belonging to
the Chabad movement, took time out to visit them and bring them
Source: Photocopy of the original.
19 | Bereishis
“The Word of G-d,” with the emphasis on the practical aspects of
the Jewish way of life. For however highly we value the principle that
“G-d desires the heart,”8 the important thing ultimately is the actual
deed and practice.9
One of the speakers who addressed the gathering was a person
occupying a prominent position in the field of metallurgical
engineering, who, only a few years ago, began to take an interest in
Jewish life and knowledge, and is now a very enthusiastic מקיים מצוות
and exponent of Yiddishkeit.
After this lengthy introduction, I come to the point, namely, the episode
which I want to bring to your attention. When the speaker concluded
his address, in which he also referred to his own experiences, as well as
his discussions with me, one of the leaders of the community arose and
mentioned the fact that he, too, had had an opportunity to speak with
me some two years ago, when I strongly urged him – as a start – to
begin putting on Tefillin immediately. Without committing himself one
way or another, out of respect for me, this gentleman went on to say
that he, in fact, had not accepted my suggestion. A further question by
the engineer as to the reason why he had not accepted my suggestion,
elicited the reply that one of the problems which had not been solved
in his mind was the discrepancy between the scientific point of view
and that of the traditional Jewish point of view regarding the age of the
world.10 In fact, the gentleman quoted the Rabbinic saying שית אלפי שנה
הוה עלמא כו׳,11 since, at one time, he had been learning Gemoro. So much
for the episode.
I will not go into the question of how logical this gentleman was in his
reply that because of a certain problem he was unwilling to put on
Tefillin. But the episode does illustrate the fact that there are (and —
numerous) Jews who still ignore the fact that their souls, too, were
present at Mt. Sinai, and a question of doubt, which can and should be
dispelled, still prevents them from, or at least provides them with the
pretext or excuse to, disregard the actual observance of the Torah and
Mitzvoth.
8
See Sanhedrin 106b; Rashi ad loc.; Zohar, vol. 2, 162b; vol. 3, 281b.
9
See Avos 1:17.
10
The Rebbe penned a lengthy response to this individual, dated 18 Teves, 5722,
and subsequently sent it to Professor Domb. See further in Rebbe Responsa, issue
76.
11
Rosh HaShana 31a.
Rebbe Responsa | 20
I am not unmindful of the fact that there may be some among them who
even after the said question will be satisfactorily answered, will find
other questions in order to justify their present disposition. But that
does not invalidate my position.
I cited the above incident not because it is an unusual one, but on the
contrary, as I indicated in my previous letter to you, I know for a fact
that this and similar problems still confuse many Jews, and to such an
extent that a person, who is prominent in the community, and is of
middle age, finds himself impelled to voice his doubt openly in the
presence of hundreds of other Jews, among whom there wasn’t one to
challenge the statement.
I trust you will forgive me for my persistence in urging you again to
consider my suggestion and request that you take this problem to
heart.
Having just observed the auspicious days of Chanukah, when we light
the Chanukah candles in increasing numbers each night of Chanukah
and in a way that they illuminate not only the home inside but also the
“outside” and especially in the light of the interpretation of Kabbalah on
ב( תרמוד, )שבת כא. ועד כמה וכו’ עד דכליא ריגלא דתרמודאי,עד שתכלה רגל מן השוק
יהי,( היינו שענין נר חנוכה הוא לכלות עד “רגל” )=סוף( המרידה )בהקב״ה,”אותיות “מורדת
.רצון שיהי’ כן בעגלא דידן
With blessing,
M. Schneerson
21 | Bereishis
– Newly Released –
4
To Yeshiva Without Delay
Removing a boy from an environment of temptation and sending him to
Yeshiva; dealing with his parent's objection
By the Grace of G-d*
19th of Tammuz, 5720
Brooklyn, N. Y.
Mr. …
Greeting and Blessing:
I received your letter of the 15th of Tammuz, and the letter from the
student . . ., which is returned herewith.
Judging from the circumstances which he describes in his letter, it
is necessary to try all possible ways and means that he should not get
involved with other places, but should go to Gateshead without delay.
For, it is not only a question of the waste of time which any delay would
involve, but also the fact that he is exposed to temptation in his present
surroundings, and all of us pray daily "Do not bring us to temptation."
Since you know him personally, and perhaps also the
circumstances, I trust you will be able to find the proper way to carry
this out. As for the question of his parents' objections, surely this is a
simple matter and has to be asked of a Rov, like any other Shaala, and
the Rov will surely rule in accordance with the Shulchan Aruch.
May G-d be with you and give you success.
My reply to your previous correspondence you have no doubt
received.
Hoping to hear good news from you,
With blessing,
By Nissan Mindel
Source: Photocopy of the original.
More to Explore
The Rebbe on Torah
and Science
Issue 76
The Age of The Universe
Examining scientific theories of
creation, evolution, and the age of
the universe.
Issue 108
Torah and Science I
The limits of scientific theory and
why Torah need not be
reinterpreted to accommodate it.
Issue 109
Torah and Science II
Exploring apparent conflicts between
Torah and science in the fields of
evolution, astronomy, and medicine.
Issue 90
Geocentrism
Defending the Torah’s view of
the sun’s orbit in light of
modern science and relativity.
Issue 167
The Science of Serving G-d
Spiritual lessons drawn from
modern scientific and
technological advancements.
Browse the Complete Collection
Booklets.RebbeResponsa.com
לע"נ
ר' דוד יוסף ז״ל ב״ר חנניה
אלפסי
שמיני עצרת- נפטר שבת קודש
כ״ב ˙˘רי ה'˙שפ"ז
ה׳˙שפ״ז
'˙'נ'צ'ב'ה
Distribution of the Rebbe Responsa booklet has been made possible by
the generous support of the Baal Shem Tov Path Foundation
אימ˙י ˜א˙י מר לכ˘יפוˆו מעיינו˙יך חוצה
Reach out to dedicate an upcoming issue and help inspire countless Yidden worldwide:
Editor@RebbeResponsa.com | +1 (347) 788 1304
