Kollel Lihoraah - English — Shmini Atzeres - Simchas Torah (2026-09-28)

Chol Hamoed Sukkos
5787
Ask the Rav
Learning the Halachos of Chol HaMoed-Some Basics ever, all melachos necessary for preparing food for the needs of the Moed are
First, we will mention what the Kaf HaChaim (O.C. 429:6) writes in the name of permitted, as explained by the Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 533 s.k. 1). Even a
the Shelah HaKadosh, that it is proper to learn Maseches Moed Katan during Chol meleches uman is permitted when necessary for food, as explained by the Mishnah
HaMoed, and likewise, at every time of year, one should learn the masechta that Berurah (O.C. 530 s.k. 1).
pertains to that time, which contains the relevant halachos of Chol HaMoed. The 2. Something Needed for the Moed Even when it is not a matter of ochel
Kaf HaChaim explains that this is based on the teaching of Chazal (Sanhedrin nefesh, a melachah necessary for the Moed may be performed. In this case, how-
101a), “Whoever recites a pasuk at its proper time brings goodness to the world,” ever, only a meleches hedyot is permitted, while a meleches uman is not.
as it says (Mishlei 15:23), “And a word in its proper time, how good it is.” This is 3. A Matter of Loss In the case of davar ha'avud, even a m eleches um an is
especially important because the halachos of Chol HaMoed are not as well-known permitted, provided that the person did not intentionally arrange for the work to be
and clear to the general public. Therefore, I found it appropriate to present several done on Chol HaMoed, as discussed in the Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 537). Regarding
practical questions that I have been asked in the past and to elaborate somewhat the definition of intentionally arranging one's work for Chol HaMoed, the Sha'ar
on the understanding of some of the halachos of Chol HaMoed. HaTziyun indicates that this refers to someone who deliberately does the work
The Prohibition of Melachah on Chol HaMoed specifically on Chol HaMoed. The Chachamim did not distinguish regarding
Regarding the prohibition of melachah on Chol HaMoed, the Shulchan Aruch davar ha'avud between a small loss and a substantial loss. Any loss that is consid-
(O.C. 530:1) writes that some melachos are prohibited on Chol HaMoed while ered a loss in the eyes of ordinary people is included in the category of davar
others are permitted. The Mishnah Berurah (s.k. 1) writes that there is a dispute ha'avud. This is apparent from the Ramban in Maseches Moed Katan, at the end
among the Rishonim regarding the fundamental nature of the prohibition of mela- of his discussion of the halachos of Yom Tov and Chol HaMoed. As an aside, in
chah on Chol HaMoed. Some maintain that it is Rabbinic, based on the fact that the Piskei Halachos of Maran HaRav Moshe Feinstein zt"l, it is written that one
the Torah refers to these days as mikraei kodesh, and they were a time of bringing may not perform melachah on Chol HaMoed in order to avoid bitul Torah after
the festival offerings in the Beis HaMikdash. Therefore, melachah was prohibited the Moed. Therefore, each situation must be considered individually. Likewise,
so that Chol HaMoed would not be like ordinary weekdays, which have no inher- regarding whether something is considered a davar ha'avud when one has the
ent sanctity. Nevertheless, the Chachamim did not make the prohibition as strin- option of purchasing a new item rather than cleaning the existing one, the Sha'ar
gent as the prohibition of melachah on Yom Tov itself. Many Poskim, however, HaTziyun (O.C. 541 s.k. 16) appears to indicate that it is preferable to purchase
maintain that the prohibition of melachah on Chol HaMoed is of Torah origin. the item rather than rely on the leniency of davar ha'avud. Purchasing a replace-
According to this view, the fact that the Chachamim permitted certain melachos is ment is not considered a davar ha'avud.
based on the authority granted to the Chachamim by the Torah to determine, ac- 4. Public Needs For tzorchei rabbim , a m eleches hedyot is per mitted even
cording to the circumstances, which melachos may be performed on Chol HaMo- when it is not needed for the Moed. A meleches uman, however, is permitted only
ed. when it is needed for the Moed and only when it is for a physical need of a person,
One must be extremely careful not to be more lenient than what the Chachamim as explained in the Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 544) and the Mishnah Berurah there.
permitted, since Chazal say (Pesachim 118a) that one who disgraces the festivals 5. A Worker Who Has Nothing to Eat A per son who has no food to eat is
is considered as though he worships avodah zarah. See the Biur Halachah there, permitted to perform melachah even when it is not for the needs of the Moed, as
which discusses this at length. Although the Shulchan Aruch appears to follow the explained in O.C. 542:2 and the Mishnah Berurah (s.k. 6). There are also certain
more lenient opinion that the fundamental prohibition is Rabbinic, it is possible activities that Chazal prohibited on Chol HaMoed as a gezeirah, even though
that he did not see all of the Rishonim cited there. In any event, one should not based purely on the laws of melachah on Chol HaMoed they could potentially
rush to be lenient except when there is a significant need. have been permitted. These include shaving and taking a haircut, cutting one's
nails, and laundering clothing. The reason for these prohibitions is so that people
Which Melachos Are Prohibited on Chol HaMoed and Which Are Permitted? will take care of these matters before the Moed rather than deliberately leaving
Generally, most of the melachos that are prohibited on Shabbos and Yom Tov are them for Chol HaMoed and entering Yom Tov in an unkempt state.
also prohibited on Chol HaMoed. However, the Poskim identify five general cate-
gories in which melachah is permitted. When it is not clear that a particular situa- Standing During Hakafos on Simchas Torah
tion falls into one of these categories, one should be stringent and treat it as a
prohibited melachah on Chol HaMoed. The reason that there is room for leniency Q: During the hakafos on Simchas Torah, is one required to stand while the con-
when necessary is that some Rishonim maintain that the prohibition itself is only gregation is dancing with the Sifrei Torah?
Rabbinic. A: The basic halachah is that one should stand when the Sifrei Torah are being
1. Melachah for Food On Yom Tov, the melachah necessar y for ochel nefesh carried around the bimah. Even between the hakafos, one should stand if there are
was only permitted from the melachah of lishah onward. On Chol HaMoed, how-
people holding and walking around with the Torah are actually standing in one place between the hakafos and the people
Sifrei Torah. However, if it is difficult for someone are not walking around with them, it is certainly permissible to sit. However,
to stand the entire time, there are several grounds upon in reality, there are many times when those holding the Sifrei Torah walk
which one can find a limud zechus to permit sitting. with them from place to place even between the hakafos. In such a situation,
The Aruch HaShulchan (se'if 5) discusses this question and it is not really proper to be lenient. Nevertheless, if the Sefer Torah cannot be
writes that he is uncertain regarding Simchas Torah, when all the clearly seen, one may be lenient.
Sifrei Torah are taken out of the aron during the hakafos and are
not returned until all the hakafos have been completed, but rather are Practical Corner: By Rabbi Nesanel Odzer from the Rabbanim of
passed from person to person. Seemingly, one should not be permitted Beis Horaah KLY
to sit until the Sifrei Torah are returned to the aron, yet this is not the
common practice. Furthermore, this would be a great difficulty, since the Q: I plan on going with my family to Six F lags on Chol Hamoed Sukkos,
hakafos sometimes take as long as a few hours. He therefore explains that and we have a two- or three-hour drive. May we eat bread, cake, or cookies
while the Sefer Torah is being carried around the bimah, one is obligated to in the car, or must these foods be eaten in a sukkah?
stand, since this is comparable to a Sefer Torah passing by. Between one
hakafah and the next, however, when the Sefer Torah is being held in A: The Shulchan Aruch writes that one may not eat more than a kebeitzah
someone's hands but is not being carried around, one is not required to stand. (the volume of an egg) of bread outside the sukkah. However, a kebeitzah or
At that point, it is considered as though the Sefer Torah is in its place, and less is considered a temporary eating and may be eaten outside the sukkah
when a Sefer Torah is resting in its place, there is certainly no obligation to (Shulchan Aruch O.C. 639:2). Regarding cake, cookies, and other pas
stand before it. The Kaf HaChaim (O.C. 669 s.k. 32) cites that according to haba’ah b’kisnin, when eaten as a meal they r equir e a sukkah. Even
Kabbalah, there is a great inyan for one person to stand beside the bimah when eaten only as a snack, there is a dispute regarding eating more than a
throughout the entire time of the hakafos while holding a Sefer Torah, with kebeitzah, and the Mishnah Berurah records the prevalent practice to be strin-
the rest of the people and the other Sifrei Torah dancing around him. Never- gent (Mishnah Berurah 639:15-16). There is, however, an exemption for
theless, the Poskim have provided a limud zechus for those who sit during holchei derachim (tr aveler s). The Shulchan Ar uch exempts daytime
the hakafos. See Shu"t BeTzel HaChochmah V (siman 139) and Shu"t travelers from sukkah (O.C. 640:8). This is based on the halachic principle of
Teshuvos V'Hanhagos II (siman 319), who present additional grounds for teishvu k’ein taduru: one should live in the sukkah in the same manner
leniency. They explain that the obligation to stand applies specifically when as he ordinarily lives in his home. Just as during the year a person leaves his
the Sefer Torah is being carried along its path. Once it has reached its place, home to travel, the Torah did not require him to remain near his sukkah
however, even if people are dancing around it by the bimah, that location is throughout Sukkos. A traveler therefore need not remain hungry until he
considered its place and there is no obligation to stand. This is especially reaches a sukkah (Mishnah Berurah 640:39-40).
relevant for someone who is somewhat weak. Does this apply to a recreational Chol Hamoed outing? Rav Moshe Feinstein
In Tzedakah U'Mishpat (ch. 16, note 37), the author cites Rav Shlomo rules that it does not. In his view, holchei derachim refers to travel for busi-
Zalman Auerbach zt"l that perhaps the obligation to stand applies specifi- ness or another genuine need, not a pleasure trip scheduled during Sukkos
cally during the first hakafah, which is the primary hakafah according to (Igros Moshe O.C. III:93; E.H. IV:32:8). He compares this to one who folds
halachah. The Shemiras Shabbos Kehilchasa (ch. 24, note 118) provides over a corner of his garment to avoid an obligation of tzitzis: one should not
a limud zechus in a situation of necessity based on the concept of a deliberately create circumstances that remove a mitzvah obligation. Rav
human partition. If people stand around each other with less than three Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, however, is quoted as being more lenient. Since
tefachim between them, forming an outer circle around an inner circle people ordinarily leave home for recreational outings during the year, teishvu
in which people are holding the Sifrei Torah, the people in the outer k’ein taduru can apply her e as well (Zman Simchaseinu 2:2:4; He’aros,
circle can be considered a mechitzah. If so, one sitting outside the Sukkah 26a). He is also quoted as distinguishing the comparison: folding
circle would be permitted to sit, since the Sefer Torah is separated one’s garment can become a regular method of avoiding the mitzvah, while a
from him by the human mechitzah. See also Shu"t Teshuvos Chol Hamoed outing is temporary; moreover, the purpose of the trip is not to
V'Hanhagos there regarding a mechitzah formed by people, as well avoid sukkah, and the exemption arises automatically. Rav Elyashiv is fur-
as Shu"t Igros Moshe, Yoreh Deah I (siman 175). ther cited as saying that when Chol Hamoed is the family’s only realistic
In Kovetz Halachos of Rav Shmuel Kamenetzky shlit"a, Hilchos opportunity for such an outing because there is no school, work, or kollel,
Sukkah (ch. 44, se'if 5), he rules that lechatchilah one should not there is substantial room for leniency.
sit while a Sefer Torah is outside the aron and in the hands of A second question is whether a relatively short trip qualifies as holchei dera-
those holding it. However, he notes that the common practice chim. Does a two- or three-hour trip suffice? Rav Chaim Kanievsky is quot-
is to be lenient. There is room to be lenient between the ed as maintaining that a short, one-day outing does not necessarily qualify
hakafos when the Sefer Torah is standing in one place and merely because one has left the city (Hilchos Chag BeChag, ch. 17, n.29).
the people are not walking around with it. Likewise, during Rav Nissim Karelitz is cited as being more lenient: if one is traveling and
the hakafos themselves, there is room for leniency when the wishes to eat while on the road, the exemption can apply (Chut Shani, Suk-
Sefer Torah is within the inner circle of dancers or in a kos, ch. 12, se’if katan 9). The widespread custom appears to follow the leni-
place where it is not clearly visible to the person who is ent approach on this latter issue. Rav Avigdor Nebenzahl also ruled to us that
sitting. In any event, when there is a need — for example, one may be lenient and consider such a person a holeich derech. One who
when a person is tired and finds it difficult to stand — wishes to be stringent in accordance with the position attributed to Rav
one may be lenient in accordance with the common Chaim Kanievsky is certainly praiseworthy.
practice. In his note (note 5), he adds that although one Summary: Or dinar ily, one may not eat mor e than a kebeitzah of br ead
could potentially rely on Rav Shlomo Zalman Auer- outside a sukkah, and one should likewise be careful with significant
bach's reasoning regarding a human mechitzah, it is amounts of cake or cookies. Regarding a recreational Chol Hamoed outing,
nevertheless preferable lechatchilah not to sit, since it Rav Moshe Feinstein is stringent, while Rav Elyashiv is quoted as permitting
is not always the case that all the Sifrei Torah will reliance on holchei derachim, particularly when Chol Hamoed is the family’s
remain within the inner circle for an extended period realistic opportunity to take an outing together. Although there is an addition-
of time. Therefore, one should still be careful. At the al dispute as to whether a relatively short, couple-hour trip is called holchei
conclusion of his discussion, he cites that Rav derachim, ther e is substantial basis for the pr evalent pr actice to be leni-
Shmuel Kamenetzky shlit"a ruled that if the Sifrei ent.
Take a part in spreading the light!
Email info@kollellihoraah.org for sponsorship opportunities.
To receive this weekly publication via email, Click here or email info@kollellihoraah.org.
Have an interesting Shayla?
Ask the Rav at info@kollellihoraah.org
