Rebbe Responsa - English — Shmini Atzeres - Simchas Torah (2026-09-28)

REBBE
RESPONSA
The Rebbe's English Letters
When Joy Feels Distant
The joy of Shemini Atzeres and Simchas Torah
when life feels far from joyful
Issue 177
Rebbe Responsa | 2
ב”ה
A Word from the Publishers
We are pleased to present Issue 176 of Rebbe Responsa, a
collection of the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s English.
In this week’s booklet, the Rebbe addresses the joy
demanded of every Jew on Shemini Atzeres and Simchas Torah,
even in the darkness of Golus and amid personal hardship, and
how one can carry that joy into everyday life when life itself feels
far from joyful.
* * *
To enjoy the full collection of the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s
English letters, we encourage you to download the Rebbe
Responsa app. With over 5,000 letters organized by both topic
and date, the app makes finding the Rebbe’s guidance and
worldview on a vast array of topics simple and accessible.
May the study of these letters hasten the coming of
Moshiach speedily in our days.
The Rebbe Responsa Team
13 Tishrei, 5787
To receive a free digital copy of Rebbe Responsa every week:
Email: Editor@RebbeResponsa.com
WhatsApp: chat.rebberesponsa.com
All previous issues of Rebbe Responsa are available at
booklets.rebberesponsa.com
3 | Shemini Atzeres
Table of Contents
Rise Above Golus ..................................................................... 4
Michtav Klolli: The darkness of Golus cannot dampen the joy of
Sukkos, for a Jew’s life is illuminated by the light of Torah and Mitzvos;
the deep trust in G-d’s revealed goodness and in the coming of
Moshiach that unites every Jew
When Life is Painful ............................................................... 9
Joy on Shemini Atzeres and Simchas Torah even when there seems to
be little reason for it; drawing G-d’s blessings for revealed reasons to
be happy; trust that G-d cares for one’s own “small world”
Every Reason for Joy ..............................................................11
G-d provides adequate reasons to be joyful on Simchas Torah;
ensuring the joy of Yom Tov lasts for the entire year
Is the Life Conducive to Joy? .............................................. 13
How to carry the joy of Tishrei into one’s life when life itself may not
be conducive to joy; the power to rise above one’s circumstances with
a Bitachon mindset; advice not to leave Eretz Yisrael for an uncertain
fresh start
Rebbe Responsa | 4
1
Rise Above Golus
The darkness of Golus cannot dampen the joy of Sukkos, for a Jew’s life is
illuminated by the light of Torah and Mitzvos; the deep trust in G-d’s
revealed goodness and in the coming of Moshiach that unites every Jew
FREE TRANSLATION
By the Grace of G-d*
Between Yom Kippur and Succos1
Sedra: Brochoh,2 Year: Hakhel
5741. Brooklyn, N.Y.
To the Sons and Daughters of our
People Israel, Everywhere,
G-d bless you all!
Greeting and Blessing:
In these days of preparation for the Festival of Succos,3 Zman
Simchoseinu,4 and coming from The Holy Day,5 unique in the year,6
when all Jews were granted the Chasimo uGmar Chasimo Toivo for
a good and sweet year — good also in our understanding,7 being the
revealed and obvious kind of good, it is appropriate to reflect on the
following thought:
Although we are still in Golus, when “darkness covers the
earth,”8 because the light of Torah-Or,9 the true light that is found
only in Torah (“there is no light but Torah”10), has not irradiated, fully
and pervasively, the world and its everyday affairs, which is
reflected also in its attitude, sometimes even actions, towards Jews;
Source: Photocopy of the original.
Note: The English renditions of the Rebbe’s Michtavim Klali’im (circular letters
addressed to every Jew) were edited by the Rebbe. The Rebbe’s original Hebrew
endnotes are published at the end of the letter.
The Yiddish version of this letter (with slight variations) is printed in Likkutei
Sichos, vol. 19 pp. 564 ff.
5 | Shemini Atzeres
and among some Jews — in their attitude towards Jewishness —
Yiddishkeit.
Both aspects being interrelated. For, as has often been pointed
out, when Jews, as individuals or as a group, proudly adhere to their
Jewishness11 and show it — that is also the way that earns them the
respect of the Gentile world and a friendly and helpful attitude,
In addition to the essential thing, that by adhering to Yiddishkeit
in actual practice of learning Torah and doing Mitzvos, thus
diminishing till to completely eliminate the only cause of the Golus
(as we clearly affirm in our prayer — “Because of our sins we have
been exiled from our land”12) — the Golus is shortened and
eventually brought to an end by the true and complete Geulo
through Moshiach Tzidkeinu, —
Nevertheless, the fact of still being in Golus must not, and does
not, dampen the joyful preparations for Succos, much less the
actual joy of Yom Tov, particularly the Festival of Succos (including
Chol-hamo’ed, Shemini Atzeres, and Simchas Torah13) which has
been singled out and designated as “The Season of Our Rejoicing”;14
For, as in the case of Golus Mitzrayim,15 when at the height of the
surrounding darkness “there was light for all the children of Israel
in their dwellings,”16 a Jew’s life, wherever he may dwell, is
illuminated in all its aspects by the light of the Torah and Mitzvos.
And by intensifying this light in his daily life, the Jew is also
hastening the Geulo and sooner to welcome Moshiach Tzidkeinu
***
And here comes in the additional factor, which is also one of our
fundamental beliefs and basic principles of our Torah — Bitochon
(trust) in G-d,17 the true and absolute Bitochon in Him who is the
Master of all the universe, whose Divine Providence extends to each
and everyone individually,18 and specifically, and in detail —
The Bitochon, first of all, that He surely granted the Chasimo
uGmar Chasimo Toivo19 in everything and in every detail, including
also, indeed — especially the fulfillment in our own very days of the
hope, heartfelt yearning, and most fervent daily expectation,
namely, the “coming of Moshiach, for whose coming I wait every
day.”20
***
Rebbe Responsa | 6
The Bitochon, the basis of which is the simple belief21 of every
Jew — since all Jews are “believers the sons of believers”22 who
inherited this belief from our Father Abraham, the Father of
Believers23 — unites and unifies all Jews. Moreover, — this belief is
the very same in all Jews, in all the ten categories into which Jews
are classified by the Torah,24 from “heads” to the “drawer of water,”
though in all other aspects they differ and to the extreme.
It is this Bitochon that makes a spiritual Hakhel of the people25 a
reality, unifying all Jews into one kohol,26 one entity — since their
common simple belief also pervades and moves everything in which
they differ (as indicated in the verse): listening to, learning, keeping
and doing all the words of the Torah.
This is also reflected in the “essence of The Day (Yom-Kippur)”27
— the unique and only day in the year,28 which of all the festivals
ordained in the Torah, is celebrated for one day only, both in and
outside of Eretz Yisroel.
The day which all Jews conclude on the same culminating
“resume” and proclaim it with profound inspiration and in a loud
voice:29 Shema Yisroel — Hear, O Israel, Hashem is our G-d, Hashem
is One, Blessed be the name of His glorious Kingdom forever and
ever; Hashem He is G-d!”30
The same unifying principle is reflected also in the Festival of
Succos, in combining together the “Four Kinds” (Esrog, Lulav,
Myrtle, and Willow), symbolizing all different types of Jews,31 into
one Mitzvah,32 which is created by virtue of a Jew unifying them,
And also in the Succah itself, concerning which the Torah says:33
“It is possible for all Jews to sit in one Succah.”
***
May G-d grant that Just as on Yom Kippur, after the many
prayers and the culminating resume (followed by the recital of
Kaddish — “Exalted and hallowed be His great Name,” etc.), one
Tekiah34 is sounded35 — a Tekiah Gedolah, according to custom,
followed by the loud proclamation: L’shanah haba’ah biYerushalaim!
—
So may every Jew in the midst of Klal Yisroel, after the many
prayers throughout the long Golus, including (five times during the
day of Yom Kippur36) the daily prayer, “May our eyes behold Your
7 | Shemini Atzeres
return to Zion in mercy,” and, while still in Golus, Jews
demonstrating that “We Your people and sheep of Your pasture, we
will constantly pray thanking You,”37
(Repeat, may every Jew, man and woman) very soon indeed hear
the sound of G-d’s Shofar Gadol38 announcing our liberation,
followed immediately by — “Bring us... to Jerusalem39 Your Holy
”House with everlasting joy.
With esteem and blessing for Chag Same’ach — Zman
Simchoseinu
*/Signed: Menachem Schneerson/
(1הן ימי שמחה שבהן היו מחנכין את המזבח בימי שלמה ) שו"ע אדה"ז חאו"ח סו"ס תרכ"ד -ממג"א
מהרי"ל( .וראה פע"ח וסי' האריז"ל במקומו .לקוטי לוי"צ לזח"א ע' יא - .להעיר משיחת כ"ק אדמו"ר
)מהורש"ב( נ"ע )מבוא לפוקח עורים ע' : (8די ד' ימים שבין יום כפור לסוכות ..איז אין די ד' אותיות שם
(2להעיר אשר בקביעות שנה זו היא במשך ג' הוי' וואס אין אדם .וראה גם סה"מ ה'תשי"א ע' .42
(5להעיר (4לשון רבים -ראה לקו"ת שמע"צ פח ,ד ואילך. (3ויק"ר פ"ל ,ז. שבועות.
משבת קי"ט ,א .זח"ב מז ,א .ונת' באוה"ת להצ"צ עה"פ )ישעי' נח ,יג( לקדוש ה' מכובד )נ"ך ע' רעח(.
(7כהמדייקים בפיוט סוף נעילה (6תצוה ל ,י .אחרי טז ,לד. סהמ"צ להצ"צ קעט ,א.
(8ישעי' ס, ודהושענות לחבר "לנו" ל"הטוב" ,משא"כ בקרא )תבוא כח ,יב( דמפרט שהטוב נגלה.
(11להעיר מטושו"ע או"ח בתחלתו :לא יתבייש מפני (10תענית ז ,ב. (9משלי ו ,כג. ב.
(13ראה שו"ע אדה"ז או"ח סתקכ"ט ס"ו. (12נוסח תפלת מוסף דיו"ט. בני אדם המלגעים.
(14ראה יל"ש אמור רמז תרנד בתחילתו :אתה מוצא שלש שמחות כתיב בחג .וראה לקו"ש חי"ד ע' 418
(15שכל המלכיות נקראו ע"ש מצרים ע"ש שהם מצירות לישראל )ב"ר פט"ז ,ה(. ואילך.
(17ראה חובת הלבבות שער הבטחון .עיקרים מאמר רביעי פמ"ו ואילך - .ראה כש"ט (16בא י ,כג.
)הוצאות קה"ת( הוספות אות מא .ביאוה"ז לאדהאמ"צ )וארא לז ,ד ואילך( ולהצ"צ )שם ע' קצ ואילך(.
(19ראה אגה"ת רפי"א. (18ראה כש"ט הוספות אות קיט ואילך .וש"נ. אוה"ת נ"ך ע' רז ואילך.
(21ראה כש"ט הוספות אות קנה .וש"נ לקו"א להמ"מ סקפ"ט (20עיקר הי"ב מהי"ג עיקרים.
)הוצאות קה"ת -מ"ח ,סע"ד ואילך( .וראה תורת אדה"ז ממוצאי יוהכ"פ תקנ"ו )היום יום יא תשרי(.
(23ראה שהש"ר פ"ד ,ח ג - .ועפ"ז יומתק פרש"י לך טו ,ו דרק (22שבת צז ,א. ובכ"מ.
לאברהם נחשבה האמונה לזכות ,דלהשאר בא בירושה .וראה סד"ה תשורי מראש אמנה תרפ"ט )סה"מ
(25וילך לא ,יב .ואפילו (24ר"פ נצבים .לקו"ת כאן )מזח"ב פב ,א(. קונטרסים ח"א נד ,ב(.
(26ראה בארוכה מכתבי עש"ק ח"י אלול וימי קטני קטנים )ראה ירושלמי חגיגה בתחלתה(.
(27ראה רמב"ם הל' תשובה פ"א ה"ג .לקו"ש ח"ד ס"ע 1149ואילך. הסליחות ה'תש"מ.
(30שו"ע אדה"ז או"ח (29מהרי"ל בסדר נעילה. (28ראה תוד"ה עד אחת -מנחות יח ,א.
(32נוסף על שכל אחד מד' מינים אלה מורה על ענין (31ויק"ר פ"ל ,יב. סתרכ"ג ס"י .וש"נ.
(33סוכה כז ,ב .וראה ד"ה בסוכות תשבו האחדות -סידור רסד ,ד ואילך .המשך וככה תרל"ז פפ"ז.
(35שו"ע שם סי"א( (36 .ראה (34והוא מבחי' שופר גדול )לקו"ת ר"ה ס ,ג(. )סה"מ תשי"א(.
(38דוקא -לקבץ גם גופו ולהעלות לדבקה בו בגוף (37תהלים עט ,יג. לקו"ת ס"פ פינחס.
(39ראה לקו"ת שם ס ,ב. ונפש )ד"ה שובה תרמ"א .וראה לקו"ת ר"ה נט ,ואילך(.
Rebbe Responsa | 8
9 | Shemini Atzeres
2
When Life is Painful
Joy on Shemini Atzeres and Simchas Torah even when there seems to be
little reason for it; drawing G-d’s blessings for revealed reasons to be
happy; trust that G-d cares for one’s own “small world”
By the Grace of G-d
2 Cheshvan, 5713
Brooklyn 13, N.Y.
Mr. …*
Greeting and Blessing:
I have received your letter of October 16, 1952. Although you do
not mention it, I trust that you spent Shemini Atzeres and Simchath
Torah in a happy and inspired mood, in accordance with the
precepts of our Torah. Even if there were circumstances which
seemed to interfere with such a happy mood and it was necessary
to feel happy merely by way of resignation because the Torah
commanded it, to be happy, nevertheless the very fact that one is
happy on these festivals, despite interference of reason, brings
G-d's blessings in such improved circumstances that one can also
see good reason for being happy. May the Almighty help this come
about very soon.
You write that you are undergoing a difficult period in your life.
As I told you personally when you were here, you should be strong
in your faith in G-d, Who directs the destinies of the whole great
universe, that He will also take care of your problems connected
with your own small world, in a way that is best for you, for your
wife and children, materially and spiritually.
You mentioned that your children wanted to receive individual
blessings. In my view, children who attend the Yeshiva have to
receive this together with the other Yeshiva boys, and the occasion
Source: Typed copy.
This letter was written to an individual experiencing severe financial difficulties,
as well as medical issues affecting his wife and children.
Rebbe Responsa | 10
for it was Shemini Atzeres and Simchath Torah, about which they
have undoubtedly written to you.1
I am looking forward to hearing good news from you in every
way. With all good wishes,
Cordially yours,
P.S. No doubt you have received the check for $1,000.00. In
accordance with your instruction, your first check for $500.00 was
today deposited.2
Your contribution towards a farbrengen was turned over to
those who take care of these matters, and will be used accordingly.
1
In the early hours of Simchas Torah 5713, the Rebbe conducted additional
Hakafos with the yeshivah students and had every bochur present honored with
reciting a possuk; see Torah Menachem, vol. 7, pp. 103-104; A Chassidisher
Derher, issue 110 (187), pp. 10-11.
2
The Rebbe had previously given the recipient a loan for expenses connected
with his home, to be repaid over the following months.
11 | Shemini Atzeres
3
Every Reason for Joy
G-d provides adequate reasons to be joyful on Simchas Torah; ensuring
the joy of Yom Tov lasts for the entire year
By the Grace of G-d*
27th of Tishrei, 5728
Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mr. Shneur Zalmon Jaffe
105, Cavendish Rd.
Kersal
Salford 7, Lancs.
England
Greeting and Blessing:
I can, of course, fully rely on the One Above that having ordained
for each and every one of us a Zman Simchosenu, including Simchas
Torah, He has certainly provided the adequate reasons for such joy
to be fully expressed by Jews everywhere, including Manchester,
and particularly in your own immediate environment.
Nevertheless, inasmuch as there are different degrees and levels
insofar as Simcha itself is concerned, and the purpose of every Yom
Tov is to carry over the spirit and joy of the Yom Tov into the rest
of the year, which is especially true of the Yom Tov of Simchas
Torah – I will be happy to hear from you explicitly that you and your
family and community at large did indeed have a truly joyous and
inspiring Simchas Torah, so that the joy and inspiration will be felt
throughout the year.
May G-d grant that the joy be even greater than expected, both
in regard to material as well as spiritual matters, including matters
of business and Parnosso.
With blessing,
M. Schneerson
Source: Photocopy of the original.
Rebbe Responsa | 12
=
13 | Shemini Atzeres
4
Is the Life Conducive to Joy?
How to carry the joy of Tishrei into one’s life when life itself may not be
conducive to joy; the power to rise above one’s circumstances with a
Bitachon mindset; advice not to leave Eretz Yisrael for an uncertain
fresh start
By the Grace of G-d*
10th of Cheshvan, 5741
Brooklyn, N.Y.
Mr. …
Bnei Brak
Greeting and Blessing:
Your letter reached me with considerable delay. I regret that my
acknowledgement has been further delayed. However, it is timely
nevertheless, and has a bearing on your letter, particularly in
response to your observation regarding certain negative aspects of
places and individuals, etc.
The timeliness that I am alluding to is in the fact that we are
coming from the month of Tishrei, which is so rich in religious
experience, and in the variety of its festivals concluding with the
“Festival of Our Rejoicing,” which itself concludes with Simchas
Torah. And, as in the case of all festivals, their purpose is to have a
lasting inspiration for all days ahead.
At first glance, the question one may ask as it is also evident from
your letter is — how can everyone be expected to carry the Joy of
Zman Simchoseinu and Simchas Torah into the everyday life,
considering that it is an emotion which is affected by conditions
and circumstances of time and place, which are not always
conducive to joy, and, in any case, also affected by the subjective
Published: The Letter and the Spirit, vol. 2, pp. 186 ff.
Note: Letters printed in The Letter and the Spirit are drawn from the archives of
Rabbi Nissan Mindel, the Rebbe’s secretary entrusted with transcribing his orally
dictated letters. The archive includes secretarial copies, some of which may not
contain the Rebbe’s final edits, as well as drafts and unsent letters.
Rebbe Responsa | 14
reactions of individuals who have to cope with them, some of whom
may be more optimistic, or less optimistic by nature?
But since the Torah is both a Toras Chaim and Toras Emes,
providing true instruction and it addresses itself to all Jews – it is
clear that basically it is within the power of every Jew to live up to
it. And it is largely up to the individual to make the most of the
conditions and circumstances in which he lives, as it is written –
(א:ריב )משלי יז-טוב פת חרבה ושלוה בה מבית מלא זבחי.
In other words, it is possible to have a houseful of "feasts”
(riches), yet torn by strife, as it is also possible to have a dry morsel
of bread, yet coupled with tranquility. Such tranquility is the result
of the person's true bitochon in G-d, the Master of the world, whose
benevolent Providence extends to each and everyone individually,
including himself. And this also brings G-d's blessing into the home
that the “dry morsel of bread" should turn into a house full of riches
and tranquility.
Needless to say, this letter is not intended as an admonition,
especially as I do not know you personally. But I am speaking from
observation, knowing of many similar cases which have been turned
around largely by the individuals themselves having the proper
approach. Actually, what has been said here is not new, as the
subject has been adequately discussed and explained in the works
of the Sages and teachers of our people, especially by the Guide for
the Perplexed, the Rambam and those who followed him.
Now in regard to a practical question in your letter, namely, the
idea of leaving Eretz Yisroel in order to make a fresh start
elsewhere. In my opinion, apart from the problems connected with
this idea, as you state in your letter, it should in any case not be
advisable, considering the energy and expense such a move would
entail, as well as the adjustment to new circumstances etc., the
outcome of which is quite uncertain and unforeseeable. Rather
would it be more advisable to put all this effort into a resolute effort
to improve the situation in your present place, which, I trust, would
in a sustainable measure eliminate the negative aspects which now
prompt you to think of moving as the hoped for solution.
With blessing,
Dedicated for the
safety and security of
our brothers and sisters
in the Holy Land
May the miraculous protection
of the Guardian of Israel continue
to shield them, and may we merit
the fulfillment of the promise:
“I will give peace in the land, and
you shall lie down, and none shall
make you afraid…”
By Anonymous
Distribution of the Rebbe Responsa booklet has been made possible by
the generous support of the Baal Shem Tov Path Foundation
אימ˙י ˜א˙י מר לכ˘יפוˆו מעיינו˙יך חוצה
Reach out to dedicate an upcoming issue and help inspire countless Yidden worldwide:
Editor@RebbeResponsa.com | +1 (347) 788 1304
