Clarity for Teens - English — Shmini Atzeres - Simchas Torah (2026-09-28)

Fruit shake!
The ִמ ְד ָרׁשin קֹ הֶ לֶת, which we will be reading this Shabbos in shul, brings the following
teaching to explain the פָסּוק: ״. ּולְׂ ִש ְׂמחָ ה מַ ה זֹּ ה עֹּ שָ ה,״לִ ְׂשחֹוק אָ מַ ְׂר ִתי ְׂמהֹולָל
שֶׁ אֻ ּמֹות הָ עֹולָם שֹוחֲקִ ים, מַ ה ְׂמעֹּ ְׂרבָ ב הַ ְׂשחֹוק:״לִ ְׂשחֹוק אָ מַ ְׂר ִתי ְׂמהֹולָל״ — אָ מַ ר ַר ִבי אַ בָ א בַ ר ַכ ֲהנָא
״ּולְׂ ִש ְׂמחָ ה מַ ה זֹּ ה עֹּ שָ ה״ — מַ ה ִטיבֹו שֶׁ ל תַ לְׂ ִמיד חָ כָם לִ ָכנֵּס.ּובבָ תֵּ י תֵּ יאַ ְׂט ִריאֹות שֶׁ לָהֶׁ ם
ְׂ ְׂבבָ תֵּ י קִ ְׂרקְׂ ִסיאֹות
?שָ ם
ַרבִ י אַ בָ א בַ ר ַכ ֲהנָאexplains: “About laughter I said: it is confused and mixed up.” Look at
the laughter of the nations of the world. They laugh and enjoy themselves in their
theatres and circuses, places created simply for entertainment. Then ְׁשֹלמֹ ה הַ מֶ לְֶךsays:
“ — ״ּולְׂ ִש ְׂמחָ ה מַ ה זֹּ ה עֹּ שָ ה״And of happiness, what does this accomplish?” The ִמ ְד ָרׁש
asks: What business does a תַ לְׂ ִמיד חָ כָםhave going in there?
At first glance, this is difficult to understand. What is wrong with laughter and
entertainment? Surely enjoying yourself is meant to make you happy. Yet the ִמ ְד ָרׁש
seems to be telling us that there is a type of laughter which is not real ִש ְמחָ הat all. There
can be a person who is laughing on the outside while still lacking genuine happiness on
the inside. Somehow, entertainment and happiness are not necessarily the same thing.
With this idea, I would like to explain another ִמ ְד ָרׁשthat we find in פ ָָרׁשַ ת אֱמֹורregarding
the ִמצְ וָהof the אַ ְרבָ עָה ִמינִ ים.
ד׳ ִמינִ ין: וְׂ אֵּ לּו הֵּ ן, אֵּ לּו שֶׁ בַ ע ִמ ְׂצוֹות שֶׁ בֶׁ חָ ג. אֶׁ לָא שֶׁ בַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות,קֹורא כֵּן
ֵּ ״שֹּבַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות״ — אַ ל ְׂת ִהי
וְׂ ִאם חֲגִ יגָה לָּמָ ה ִש ְׂמחָ ה?״, ִאם ִש ְׂמחָ ה לָּמָ ה חֲגִ יגָה. חֲגִ יגָה וְׂ ִש ְׂמחָ ה, וְׂ ֻסכָה,שֶׁ בַ לּולָב
The ִמ ְד ָרׁשsays: Do not read it simply as — ״שֹּבַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות״an abundance of happiness,
but rather as — ״שֶׁ בַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות״seven happinesses. These are the seven ִמצְ וֹותof the יֹום
טֹוב: the four חֲגִ יגָה, ֻסכָה, ִמינִ יםand ש ְמחָ ה.
ִ
I think the ִמ ְד ָרׁשis teaching us something much deeper than a play on words. It is not
replacing the simple meaning of שֹּבַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות. It is explaining how to reach it. Everybody
wants an abundance of happiness. The question is: how do you actually get there? The
answer of the ִמ ְד ָרׁשis that the way to reach שֹּבַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹותis through these שֶׁ בַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות.
These seven ִמצְ וֹותof סֻכֹותshow us how physical enjoyment and celebration can be
turned into something that produces real, lasting ש ְמחָ ה. ִ
But that immediately creates a problem. Among these seven, the ִמ ְד ָרׁשcounts both חֲגִ יגָה
and ש ְׂמחָ ה.ִ Surely the whole point of a חֲגִ יגָהis to create ש ְמחָ ה. ִ We celebrate because we
want to be happy. If so, why are they being counted as two separate things? ״אם ִש ְׂמחָ ה ִ
וְׂ ִאם חֲגִ יגָה לָּמָ ה ִש ְׂמחָ ה?״, לָּמָ ה חֲגִ יגָהIf I already have happiness, what does the celebration
1
add? And if the celebration itself produces happiness, why do I need a separate ִמצְ וָהof
?ש ְמחָ ה
ִ
The question becomes even stronger when we remember the first ִמ ְד ָרׁשin קֹ הֶ לֶת. There
we were told that a person can have plenty of laughter and entertainment and still not
have genuine ש ְמחָ ה.
ִ So how can חֲגִ יגָה, an external celebration, be one of the very things
that leads us to שֹּבַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות, an abundance of true happiness?
And then the ִמ ְד ָרׁשseems to make things even more confusing, because instead of
answering the question directly, it suddenly begins speaking about כְ לַל יִ ְש ָראֵ ל,ר ֹאׁש הַ שָ נָה
and the nations of the world, and the לּולָבthat shows that we have won.
The ִמ ְד ָרׁשcontinues:
אֶׁ לָא מַ אן ְׂדנָסֵּ ב בָ ִאין, ַ וְׂ לֵּית אֲ נַן י ְָׂדעִ ין מַ אן הּוא נָצֹוח, מָ שָ ל לִ ְׂשנַיִ ם שֶׁ נִ כְׂ נְׂ סּו אֵּ צֶׁ ל הַ דַ יָן:אָ מַ ר ַר ִבי אָ ִבין
ּומקַ ְׂט ְׂרגִ ים לִ פְׂ נֵּי הַ קָ דֹוש בָ רּוְך הּוא ְׂבר ֹּאש ְׂ כְָך יִ ְׂש ָראֵּ ל וְׂ אֻ ּמֹות הָ עֹולָם בָ ִאין. ִַבידֵּ יּה אֲ נַן י ְָׂדעִ ין ְׂדהּוא נָצֹוח
יֹוצ ִאין ִמלִ פְׂ נֵּי הַ קָ דֹוש בָ רּוְך הּוא וְׂ לּולְׂ בֵּ יהֶׁ ןְׂ אֶׁ לָא ְׂבמַ ה שֶׁ יִ ְׂש ָראֵּ ל, וְׂ לֵּית אֲ נַן י ְָׂדעִ ין מַ אן נָצַ ח,הַ שָ נָה
: לְׂ פִ יכְָך מֹּ שֶׁ ה מַ ז ְִׂהיר לְׂ יִ ְׂש ָראֵּ ל וְׂ אֹומֵּ ר לָהֶׁ ם.יֹודעִ ין ְׂדיִ ְׂש ָראֵּ ל ִאינּון נָצֹוחַ יָא ְׂ אָ נּו,וְׂ אֶׁ ְׂתרֹוגֵּיהֶׁ ן ִבידֵּ יהֶׁ ן
״.״ּולְׂ קַ ְׂחתֶׁ ם ָלכֶׁם בַ יֹום הָ ִראשֹון
ַרבִ י אָ בִ יןgives a מָ ׁשָ ל. Two people enter before a judge, and we do not know which one
has won. When one of them comes out carrying the sign of victory in his hand, we know
that he is the winner. So too, כְ לַל יִ ְש ָראֵ לand the nations of the world come before הַ קָ דֹוׁש
בָ רּוְך הּואon ר ֹאׁש הַ שָ נָהand argue their case. We do not know who has won, but when כְ לַל
יִ ְש ָראֵ לcome out carrying their לּולָבִ יםand אֶ ְתרֹוגִ ים, we know that כְ לַל יִ ְש ָראֵ לhave won.
Therefore מֹ ׁשֶ ה ַרבֵ נּוwarns them: ״.״ּולְׂ קַ ְׂחתֶׁ ם ָלכֶׁם בַ יֹום הָ ִראשֹון
Now the question is very clear. The ִמ ְד ָרׁשbegan by asking us to understand the
difference between חֲגִ יגָהand ש ְׂמחָ ה,
ִ and how the two together can produce שֹּבַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות.
Why is the answer a story about the לּולָבproving that כְ לַל יִ ְש ָראֵ לwon on ?ר ֹאׁש הַ שָ נָהWhat
does one thing have to do with the other?
I think the answer is that the לּולָבis not a separate subject at all. The לּולָבis the answer.
It teaches us how a חֲגִ יגָהcan become genuine ש ְמחָ ה.
ִ
The ּתֹורה ָ in פ ָָרׁשַ ת ְראֵ הsays: ״וְׂ שָ מַ ְׂחתָ ְׂבחַ גֶָׁך״, and later: ָ וְׂ הָ יִ ית...״ש ְׂבעַ ת י ִָמים תָ חֹּ ג לַה׳ אֱֹלקֶׁ יָך
ִ
״. ַאַ ְך שָ מֵּ ח
The ִדבְ ֵרי ׁשָ אּולbrings a ֶרמֶ זin the words ״אַ ְך שָ מֵּ חַ ״. The word אַ ְךusually comes to exclude
something. Here it is teaching us that there is a type of ִש ְמחָ הin which nothing else
should be mixed in.
2
He brings the גְ מָ ָראin בְ ָרכֹותwhere one מֹורא
ָ ָ אasks another why he is so happy. The other
מֹורא
ָ ָ אanswers that he had put on ּתפִ לִ ין. ְ Normally, even when a person is doing a ִמצְ וָה
and experiencing ש ְׂמחַ ת הַ ִּמ ְׂצוָה,
ִ there is still a danger. A person can become so caught
up in the pleasure and excitement surrounding the ִמצְ וָהthat slowly the physical
enjoyment itself becomes the main thing. The ִש ְמחָ הbecomes connected to the ג ְַׁש ִמּיּות
rather than to Hashem.
But ְּתפִ לִ יןare different. There is no delicious meal involved, no comfortable chair, no
party and no special atmosphere. The happiness comes simply from the fact that the
person is connected to Hashem. That is a much purer form of ש ְמחָ ה. ִ The last day of יֹום
ְׁש ִמינִ י עֲצֶ ֶרת,טֹוב, represents this type of ש ְמחָ ה.
ִ There comes a point where a Yid is simply
spending time with Hashem. There does not have to be anything else involved. He can
simply be happy to be with Him.
The word אַ ְךremoves the עַצְ בּותand everything else that interferes with that pure ש ְמחָ ה. ִ
As the פֹורנֹוְ ְסexplains on the words ״אַ ְך שָ מֵּ חַ ״: ּוב ִש ְׂמחָ ְׂתָך ל ֹּא יִ ְׂתעָ ֵּרב
ְׂ ,״ת ְׂהיֶׁה שָ מֵּ חַ ִבלְׂ בַ ד
ִ
״. עִ צָ בֹוןBe happy alone, without sadness becoming mixed into your happiness.
This helps us understand an important difference. חֲגִ יגָהmeans celebration. ִש ְׂמחָ ה
means happiness. They are not the same thing. You can celebrate without being
genuinely happy, and you can be genuinely happy without having any celebration at all.
Take a birthday as a simple example. The fact that today is your birthday gives you a
reason to celebrate. There is a cake, presents, music, people around you and perhaps a
party. All of those things are external. They create an atmosphere that is supposed to
make you happy. But real ִש ְמחָ הis internal.
The דּובְ נָא מַ גִ ידexplains that there is external happiness and internal happiness. Any
enjoyment in this world usually works by filling a gap. If I am missing something and
then I receive it, I become happy. The happiness comes because something that was
lacking has now been filled. But that creates a strange problem. The more a person
becomes used to pleasures, the more he needs in order to become excited. If someone
has already experienced everything, basic things no longer impress him. He needs
something more unusual, more expensive or more extreme just to feel the same
excitement he once felt from something simple.
A poor person, on the other hand, may receive tremendous pleasure from something
very basic. In a strange way, he may actually be closer to happiness because he needs
less in order to get there. Which means that when a person spends his life constantly
increasing his physical pleasures, he may actually be creating more sadness for himself.
He has stretched his “pleasure cells” so far that they have become much harder to fill.
3
Last week I was speaking to someone who gives away a large amount of צְ דָ קָ הbefore
יֹום טֹוב. He told me that this year a very respectable person, someone who from the
outside appeared to be wealthy, was collecting on ע ֶֶרב יֹום טֹובfor a needy family in town.
After everyone left shul, the ָרבcame over to him and revealed that the “needy family”
was actually that very man himself.
He was not starving. He had enough for the most basic necessities. But he had nowhere
near enough to maintain the standard of living to which he had become accustomed.
There may be many people who survive happily on far less than he had. But after twenty
years of stretching his expectations higher and higher, he could no longer reach the level
of pleasure that had become normal to him. And that meant that he could actually feel
poorer and more miserable than somebody who owns much less.
The more you stretch your הַ שָ גֹותof what you need, the more you will need in order to
feel satisfied. Eventually you need to import some crazy dish from the other side of the
world just to tickle the pleasure cells. I sometimes joke that I am richer than Elon Musk.
Not because I have more money. Unfortunately, my bank manager has not yet made
that discovery. But perhaps I lack less in order to reach my goal.
For someone with billions, another million may hardly make a dent. For me, a million
pounds would certainly make a difference — whether for the better or for the worse is
up for debate. If I need very little in order to be happy, then in one sense I possess more.
A simple trip to a farm probably does not excite Elon Musk anymore. He needs to
explore space or perhaps Mars. Good luck to him.
Perhaps that is what ְׁשֹלמֹ ה הַ מֶ לְֶךis teaching us when he says: ״.״לִ ְׂשחֹוק אָ מַ ְׂר ִתי ְׂמהֹולָלThere
are theatres, shows and endless forms of entertainment designed to make a person happy
from the outside. But a תַ לְׂ ִמיד חָ כָםwho has trained himself to live with פַ ת בַ ּמֶׁ לַח, water
and a simple life needs far less in order to be content. He has not stretched his pleasure
cells until normal life is no longer enough.
The more a person trains himself to need external excitement, the more external
excitement he will need. True ִש ְמחָ הcomes from serving Hashem. Being connected to
Hashem is happiness itself. The further a person moves away from that internal source,
the more outside things he will need in order to make himself feel happy.
It is a little like an old fish. The less fresh the fish is, the more spices you need to cover
up the smell. When something is fresh, it does not need all the covering. A person who
needs constant entertainment, excitement and people around him simply in order to feel
okay may actually be showing that something is missing internally. Someone who has
genuine ִש ְמחָ הfrom within does not need so much from the outside. That is why a תַ לְׂ ִמיד
4
חָ כָםcan be happy with bread and water. He has a source of happiness that does not
depend upon all the extras.
Now we can come back to סֻכֹות. סֻכֹותwas the time of year when a person brought home
his crops. It was the harvest season, a time of abundance and success. Naturally, a
person would make a חַ ג. He had produce, prosperity and plenty. He had every reason
to celebrate.
But now we return to the original question. If all that happiness is coming from the
crops and the success, is it really ?ש ְׂמחָ ה ִ If true ִש ְמחָ הis supposed to come from serving
Hashem, why are we celebrating all these physical things that we have received? The
ִמ ְד ָרׁשanswers with the מָ ׁשָ לof ר ֹאׁש הַ שָ נָה.
כְ לַל יִ ְש ָראֵ לand the nations of the world come before Hashem, and we do not know who
has won. Then כְ לַל יִ ְש ָראֵ לemerge holding their לּולָבand אֶ ְתרֹוג, and that demonstrates that
they are the winners. But why? Because we take the very things that grow from the
ground, the very produce that could have become the source of our physical pride and
pleasure, and we turn them into a מצְ וָה. ִ We take the אַ ְׂרבָ עָה ִמינִ יםand lift them up to
Hashem.
We do not eat the fruit. We shake it. A non-Jew may not understand that. In fact, what
made me think of this explanation in the ִמ ְד ָרׁשwas something that happened to me about
a week and a half ago. I was taking an אֶ ְתרֹוגto America for a friend. As seems to be my
personal מנְ הָ ג,
ִ my bags always create some sort of excitement when they go through
airport security. This time the problem was a tin of tuna.
As the security officer emptied my bag, he found the box containing the אֶ ְתרֹוג. “What’s
in here?” he asked. Without thinking, I replied, “It’s a religious fruit.” As soon as the
words came out of my mouth, I realised how strange they sounded. I quickly corrected
myself. “It is a fruit that we use for a religious custom.”
He looked fascinated. “What do you do with it? Do you eat it?” “No,” I replied. “We
shake it.” He looked at me as if the tin of tuna was no longer the strangest thing in my
bag. But perhaps that is precisely the point.
The natural use of fruit is to eat it. The natural reaction to a successful harvest is to
enjoy it. But when the nations of the world come before Hashem and claim that we do
not deserve both this world and the next, כְ לַל יִ ְש ָראֵ לanswer by holding up our fruit. We
say: Yes, you gave us a world. Yes, you gave us produce. And look what we do with
it. We shake it for You. We take ג ְַׁש ִמּיּותand turn it into רּוחָ נִ ּיּות.
5
That changes the entire meaning of the celebration. We are not saying, “Look how much
produce we have. Look how successful we are.” We are saying, “Hashem gave us all
this — and we are going to use it to serve Him.”
Perhaps this also explains why the ִמ ְד ָרׁשsays that מֹ ׁשֶ הwarns כְ לַל יִ ְש ָראֵ לto take the אַ ְרבָ עָה
מינִ ים.
ִ Why use the language of a warning? Why not simply say that he commands them?
Perhaps מֹ ׁשֶ ה ַרבֵ נּוis warning us about the danger hidden inside the celebration.
You are bringing home your crops. You have been successful. You have every reason
to make a חֲגִ יגָה. But be careful. Do not allow the חֲגִ יגָהitself to become the source of
your ש ְׂמחָ ה.
ִ Do not allow all the produce, money, success and pleasure to become the
things that give your life meaning. Take those very same things and turn them into a
מצְ וָה.
ִ Use your produce to serve Hashem.
Then חֲגִ יגָהand ִש ְׂמחָ הcan finally come together. The celebration remains external, but
the happiness comes from within. The crops can give you something to celebrate, but
they are no longer the source of your happiness. Your real ִש ְׂמחָ הcomes from Hashem.
And once the celebration itself is being used to serve Hashem, you can celebrate fully
and still remain genuinely happy.
Now we can understand the פְ סּוקִ יםregarding the ִמצְ וָהof סֻכֹות. ״חַ ג הַ סֻכֹּ ת תַ עֲשֶׁ ה לְׂ ָך ִש ְׂבעַ ת
״.ּומיִ קְׂ בֶׁ ָך
ִ ְׂבאָ ְׂספְׂ ָך ִמג ְָׂרנְׂ ָך,י ִָמיםFirst there is חַ ג. You have gathered in your produce. Hashem
has blessed your work, and naturally there is a celebration.
Then the ּתֹורה ָ says: וְׂ הַ לֵּוִ י וְׂ הַ גֵּר וְׂ הַ יָתֹום וְׂ הָ אַ לְׂ מָ נָה,ּובתֶׁ ָך וְׂ עַ ְׂב ְׂדָך וַאֲ מָ תֶׁ ָך
ִ ּובנְׂ ָך
ִ אַ תָ ה,״וְׂ שָ מַ ְׂחתָ ְׂבחַ גֶָׁך
״.אֲשֶׁ ר ִב ְׂשעָ ֶׁריָךNow comes something deeper. Do not merely celebrate. Be happy. The
ִמ ְד ָרׁשasked us how the two can possibly go together. How can all the external
excitement of a חַ גcoexist with pure internal ?ש ְמחָ ה ִ
The answer comes in the next פָסּוק: כִ י,״ש ְׂבעַ ת י ִָמים תָ חֹּ ג לַה׳ אֱֹלקֶׁ יָך בַ ּמָ קֹום אֲשֶׁ ר יִ ְׂבחַ ר ה׳ ִ
״. ַ וְׂ הָ יִ יתָ אַ ְך שָ מֵּ ח,ּובכֹּ ל מַ עֲשֵּ ה יָדֶׁ יָך
ְׂ יְׂ בָ ֶׁרכְׂ ָך ה׳ אֱ ֹלקֶׁ יָך ְׂבכֹּ ל ְׂתבּואָ ְׂתָךCelebrate — but celebrate לַה׳
אֱ ֹלקֶׁ יָך.
The ּתֹורה
ָ does not tell us to celebrate simply because we are rich or because the harvest
was successful. We celebrate because Hashem gave it to us, and because we now have
another opportunity to use His gifts to serve Him. The physical success becomes an
extra בְ ָרכָה. It does not become the foundation of our happiness.
And now we can return to the opening words of the מ ְד ָרׁש: ִ — ״שֹּבַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות״an
abundance of happiness. How does a person actually reach that abundance? Not by
endlessly adding more pleasures and not by endlessly increasing the חֲגִ יגָה. The ִמ ְד ָרׁש
tells us: ״. אֶׁ לָא שֶׁ בַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות,קֹורא כֵּן
ֵּ ״אַ ל ְׂת ִהי
6
Take all the different parts of — סֻכֹותthe crops, the ֻסכָה, the אַ ְרבָ עָה ִמינִ ים, the — חֲגִ יגָהand
attach every one of them to Hashem. That is how שֶׁ בַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹותcreates שֹּבַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות. The
seven forms of serving Hashem create the fullness of happiness.
When we live that way through the seven days of סֻכֹות, we can eventually reach the
level of — ְׂש ִמינִ י עֲצֶׁ ֶׁרתthe day when there is almost nothing left except ourselves and
Hashem. ״. ַ״וְׂ הָ יִ יתָ אַ ְך שָ מֵּ חJust happy.
Perhaps that is also why we read קֹ הֶ לֶתon חֹ ל הַ מֹועֵד סֻכֹות. At the very moment when we
are celebrating the harvest, enjoying יֹום טֹובand surrounded by everything Hashem has
given us, ְׁשֹלמֹ ה הַ מֶ לְֶךreminds us: ״. הַ כֹּ ל הָ בֶׁ ל,״הֲבֵּ ל הֲבָ לִ ים
All the things of this world are הֶ בֶ לwhen they become an end in themselves. But take
that same world and use it for Hashem, and suddenly the fruit itself can become a מצְ וָה.ִ
You can eat, celebrate and enjoy. You can have a חֲגִ יגָה. But the real question is: Where
does your ִש ְׂמחָ הcome from?
If it comes only from what you own, you will constantly need more. But if it comes
from Who gave it to you and what you can do with it, then even the things of this world
can bring you closer to Hashem. That is the victory of the לּולָב. That is the ִש ְמחָ הof סֻכֹות.
That is how שֶׁ בַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹותbecomes שֹּבַ ע ְׂשמָ חֹות. And perhaps that is what it means to reach:
״. ַ״וְׂ הָ יִ יתָ אַ ְך שָ מֵּ ח
7
