The Wall St. Torah Journal — Sukkos (2026-09-21)

’יוצא לאור ע”י כולל ‘משפטי מרום
ניו יורק,בביהמ”ד ‘גבורה’ בעיר מנהטן
Gevurahkollel@gmail.com
The Wall St. Torah JOURNAL
An informative project by the Gevurah Shul Kollel for monetary matters and contemporary Halacha
Year 2| Issue 6
תשרי שנת תשפ”ז לפ”ק
The Yud Gimmel Middos of Rachamim On behalf of the Roshei Kollel, the avreichim, and
all the mispallelim of the Gevurah shul, we extend
our warmest wishes of Mazel Tov to the esteemed
Karfunkel family, on the double simcha in their
Chazal
family
reveal the tremendous he could possibly require—including food
power of the Yud for his family and expenses for his children’s On the engagement of the son of Reb
Gimmel Middos of Rachamim. The Gemara Torah education. Dov Ber Karfunkel to the daughter of
(Rosh Hashanah 17b) teaches that Hashem Reb Yaakov Elbogen
In fact, the poor man gained more by not And on the engagement of the daughter
revealed these Middos to Moshe Rabbeinu
asking. Had he requested money for one of Reb Baruch Karfunkel - Daf Yomi
and established them as a bris kerusah
specific need, the wealthy man might have Maggid Shiur at the Gevurah shul, to
l’sfasayim—a covenant upon our lips:
provided only that. But because he left the the son of Reb Dov Seidenfeld
whenever Klal Yisrael recites the yud gimmel
decision to the wealthy man, he received
middos, their tefillos are accepted. May Hashem bless both couples with a kesher
everything he truly needed. shel kayama, and may they merit to build a Bayis
The Gemara says that “Hakadosh Baruch Hu Ne’eman B’Yisrael, to the pride and nachas of their
wrapped Himself like a shaliach tzibbur and So too, we stand before our Father in families.
taught Moshe how to recite them.” Why would Heaven as the “poor man.” We are limited
Hashem be described as a shaliach tzibbur, for in knowledge and understanding, and we do
which tzibbur was He serving as a shaliach? not even recognize all that we lack. Hashem,
Gevurah Shul extends a heartfelt Mazel Tov to
Furthermore, how can we understand the idea however, knows exactly what we need—even
Reb Hillel Gross
of tefillah in this context, we daven to Hashem, what we do not know to ask for.
upon the completion of the entire Nevi’im
Who is the Source of everything. To whom, Therefore, in His infinite mercy, Hashem and Kesuvim, which was learned at his
then, could Hashem Himself be davening. gave us the yud gimmel middos. Rather than daily shiur over the past five years.
May he be zocheh to continue being marbitz torah
The early commentators explain that the yud limiting ourselves to specific requests, we in good health with lots of nachas and brachah.
gimmel middos correspond to the thirteen praise Him and proclaim His Middos of mercy
middle brachos of Shemoneh Esrei, which are and kindness. In response, He bestows upon us
the brachos of request. Yet when we examine goodness far beyond anything we could have
them, we find no explicit request or tefillah, known to request. Daily Shiurim at the Gevurah
rather expressions of praise about Hashem’s
This explains why Hashem is described as Shul:
mercy and kindness.
a shaliach tzibbur: He Himself fulfills the
Rav Shimshon Pincus זצ”לexplained this with unspoken requests of Klal Yisrael. We praise Shiur in Chok Gemara – Sotah
a beautiful משל. Him, and He filles in the tefillos for us, and L’Yisrael 2:15 PM
answers them in the way He davened for us. 8:00 AM by R. Yosef Cohen
Imagine an impoverished man whose torn
by Reb Dov Ber
clothing makes his situation obvious. He During these precious days, let us strengthen Gemara - Oraysa
Zyskind
comes to the home of a wealthy man, but ourselves in reciting the Yud-Gimmel Middos 5:05 PM
instead of asking for food, money, or help, he with greater kavanah, while striving to emulate Rambam by Reb Dov Ber
begins praising the wealthy man: “Everyone Hashem’s ways—being merciful and willing Following Zyskind
knows what a baal chesed you are. Your home to overlook the faults of others. Shacharis
is open to everyone. You have helped so many by R. Hillel Gross Contemporary
people so generously…” May we merit, through this, a Gmar Chasimah Halacha
Tovah and a year of Geulah. ■ Daf Yomi Every Monday,
The poor man never actually asks for anything.
1:20 PM 2:15–2:30 PM
Yet the wealthy man sees his condition and Excerpted and adopted from a shiur delivered by
by Reb Baruch by Rabbi Levi
understands what he needs. Moved by the HaGaon Rav Dov Kahana shlit”a on the first day of Karfunkel Yitzchak Osdoba
man’s words, he gives him everything he feels Selichos before the avreichim of the Kollel.
1
Halachos of Mekach U’memkar Aveiros for Sale - An Halachic Analysis
on Chol Hamoed
By: Rav Shaya Lichtenstien By: Rav Yisroel Yitzchak Meisels
You may have heard of people selling their But there is a much more fundamental
1. Melachah on Chol Hamoed chometz before Pesach to get rid of it, making question: Does a person even have the ability to
Work forbidden on Yom Tov is generally a Pruzbul before Shemitah, or using a Heter transfer his aveiros to someone else?
forbidden on Chol Hamoed, although Chazal Mechirah for a business that is open on Shabbos. The Machaneh Chaim points out that the
permitted certain melachos under specific But how about selling your aveiros before Yom Ramban, in his commentary on Chumash,
circumstances (Shulchan Aruch and Rema, O.C. 530). Kippur to get rid of them? explains that the punishment of kareis results
2. The Seriousness of the Issur Before dismissing this as too ridiculous to even from the spiritual damage caused by the aveirah
Chazal say that one who disgraces Yom Tov is discuss, such sales actually happened. The status remaining within a person’s soul. If so, perhaps
compared to one who serves avodah zarah. of these sales was subsequently brought before the aveirah is not merely an obligation or
Rashi explains this includes performing an great rabbonim of the time, who addressed the liability that can be transferred to someone else.
issur melachah on Chol Hamoed (Pesachim 118a; matter. In fact, this happened more than once, as It is something that has actually happened to the
Magen Avraham 530:1).
is evident from the Maharsham, )§3:151(, as well person and has affected his very soul.
3. Melachah Through a Non-Jew as another story recorded in a teshuvah of the On the other hand, we do find the concept
A prohibited melachah may not be done even Machaneh Chaim, from Rav Chaim Sofer, Dayan of one person accepting upon himself the
through a non-Jew. For a tzorech mitzvah, in Munkatch (C. M. §2:20). punishment that was destined for someone else.
however, one may instruct a non-Jew to
The Maharsham was asked the following The Gemara in Kiddushin (31b) discusses the
perform it (Shulchan Aruch 543:1; Magen Avraham ibid.).
question: Someone sold his aveiros to another Yid practice of a son saying Hareni kaparas mishkavo
Mekach U’memkar for a substantial sum of money. Is the transaction when mentioning his deceased father. Rashi
valid or not? explains that the son is saying, in effect, that he
4. Buying and Selling
Buying, selling, renting, or leasing is generally Let us examine this sale from two perspectives: wishes to accept upon himself the punishment
assur, even for a small transaction, whether in a first, from a technical perspective, according to that would otherwise have come upon his father.
store, at home, by phone, or online (Shulchan Aruch the principles of Choshen Mishpat, and then from This halachah is brought down in the Shulchan
539:1; Magen Avraham ibid. 16). the spiritual perspective. Aruch, (Y. D. 240:9).
5. Purchases Not Needed for Yom Tov The sale gets off to a rocky start on both counts: Furthermore, both the Maharsham and the
One may not purchase items not needed for What exactly is being sold, and how is it being Machaneh Chaim cite the Gemara in Maseches
Yom Tov, such as sefarim for the next zman, sold? Firstly, the seller is the one receiving money Shabbos, where Yitzchak Avinu says to Hakadosh
clothing or shoes for a later season, or groceries for the buyer to take his aveiros. Normally, of Baruch Hu, in effect, “Half of the Yidden’s aveiros
for after Yom Tov. course, the buyer pays money to acquire an item; I take upon myself.”
6. Passive Sales here, the arrangement is seemingly the opposite.
So there certainly seems to be a concept
A business requiring no action or tircha on Chol The Maharsham points out that since this whereby one person can accept the punishment
Hamoed, such as a vending machine, website, is a “heavenly” matter, perhaps the normal of another.
or stocks, may remain active. Purchases requirements of a formal kinyan do not apply.
through them, however, are assur. On Pesach, Nevertheless, as one might have suspected,
Perhaps a firm commitment is sufficient.
one must be careful regarding chametz. neither the Maharsham nor the Machaneh
There is another problem with the merchandise Chaim concludes that there is an easy way out
7. Discussing Business Matters
itself. Aveiros are not a tangible asset. They are a of one’s aveiros simply by selling them. They
Discussing business is permitted. One may
davar she’ein bo mamash—something without both invalidate a blanket sale of ones aveiros,
arrange for a worker to come after Yom Tov,
physical substance—which ordinarily cannot be Nevertheless we still need to reconcile these
inquire about prices, or look at a property or
sold. conflicting statements we find in Chazal.
product catalog (Shulchan Aruch 543:3; Shu”t Yachin
U’Boaz I:117). This is why the Netziv, in his sefer Meishiv To gain some clarity on this subject, let us
8. Paying Previous Debts Davar, invalidates a similar sale: there is nothing switch gears for a moment to a seemingly related
Some poskim prohibit collecting or paying for tangible being transferred from one person to concept: selling mitzvos.
purchases made before Yom Tov, including another, and therefore there is no conventional
We find a dispute among the poskim as to
regular grocery, electric, gas, telephone, and object upon which a kinyan can take effect.
whether a person can sell his mitzvos.
insurance bills. If delaying payment will cause However, the Maharsham points out that in
a loss, or there is concern the debt will not be The Rema discusses the concept of Yissachar-
his case there was a handshake, which constitutes
paid later, it is permitted (Shulchan Aruch 543:3; Magen Zevulun, in which one partner supports a person
situmta. According to some poskim, even a davar
Avraham ibid. 4; Taz ibid. 1; Mishnah Berurah 11). who learns Torah and receives a share in the
she’ein bo mamash can be acquired through
9. Purchases for Yom Tov
reward for that Torah learning.
situmta.
Purchases needed for Yom Tov are permitted,
But there is a condition for situmta: it must be Yet the Imrei Binah (Shu”t §1:3) points out
including food, drinks, clothing, the Arba
a recognized and accepted business practice. The that there is a teshuvah of the Maharam Alashkar
Minim, hoshanos, and machzorim (Shulchan Aruch (§101), citing Rav Hai Gaon, which seems to
Maharsham notes that this type of transaction is
539:12). indicate otherwise. Although the supporter
certainly not a common form of commerce.
10. Purchases for the Last Days receives reward for enabling the Torah learning,
The Maharsham therefore offers a novel the actual sechar for the Torah learning itself
It is likewise permitted to purchase or rent what
is needed for the last days of Yom Tov (Rema 539:11).
approach to validate the transaction through belongs to the person who toiled in it.
the concept of arvus, or guarantorship. Perhaps,
11. Opening a Store How do we reconcile these seemingly
by accepting the money, the person cannot
A store selling Yom Tov necessities may open, conflicting approaches?
formally transfer the aveiros themselves, but he
but it should be apparent that it is open only
can accept upon himself liability in place of the The Imrei Binah offers a beautiful explanation.
for these needs, such as by opening only one
other person—similar to the concept of accepting Chazal tell us, “Sechar mitzvah mitzvah, u’sechar
entrance or posting a notice (Shulchan Aruch 539:11;
responsibility for someone else’s debt. aveirah aveirah”—the reward of a mitzvah is the
Shu”t Shevet HaLevi VIII:126).
So, from a purely technical perspective, we mitzvah itself, and the punishment of an aveirah
12. Stores Selling Fresh Goods
have found a possible mechanism through which is the aveirah itself.
Stores selling regularly purchased fresh goods,
such as groceries, fruit, fish, and meat, may such a transaction might have validity. This can be understood to mean >page 3
2
Greeting One’s Rebbe on Yom Tov remain open normally, since it is evident that
the purchases are for Yom Tov (Shulchan Aruch
539:10).
By: Rav Yosef Samet 13. Preventing a Loss – Davar Ha’aved
Mekach U’memkar is permitted where waiting
will cause a loss, such as losing merchandise,
The Gemara (Rosh Hashanah 16b) states: “Rabbi The Iyun Yaakov (Sukkah) cites the Radak and
a customer, or a job. Returning an item is also
Yitzchak said: A person is obligated to greet his Abarbanel, who had a version of the Gemara reading
permitted if the return policy will expire after
teacher on Yom Tov,” deriving this from the incident that one is obligated to greet his Rebbe on “Shabbos
Chol Hamoed (Shulchan Aruch 539:4, 13; Shu”t Be’er Moshe
of the Shunamite woman and Elisha. When Elisha and Yom Tov.” They explain that the Rosh Chodesh VII:77).
asked her, “Why are you going to him today? It is mentioned in the verse can itself be understood as
14. A Possible Loss – Safek Davar Ha’aved
neither Rosh Chodesh nor Shabbos,” the implication referring to Yom Tov, since for the Shunamite woman,
Even where there is a significant concern of
is that on Rosh Chodesh and Shabbos she would have Rosh Chodesh had the status of a Yom Tov, as women
loss, it may be permitted. Thus, one may sell
gone to him. The Rambam (Hilchos Talmud Torah traditionally refrained from work on Rosh Chodesh. stocks if he is concerned that their value will
5:7) and the Rosh likewise rule that one is obligated The Turei Even (Rosh Hashanah) explains that drop and cause a loss (Magen Avraham 539:7; Biur
to greet his Rebbe on Yom Tov. “Shabbos” refers to Yom Tov, while “Rosh Chodesh” Halachah 537:1).
refers specifically to Rosh Hashanah. The Panim
15. An Unusual Profit Opportunity
The commentators question Rabbi Yitzchak’s Yafos (end of Parshas Re’eh) similarly explains that One may not do business merely for profit.
derivation. He establishes an obligation specifically “Rosh Chodesh” refers to Rosh Hashanah, while However, an unusual opportunity that will not
on Yom Tov, yet his proof comes from a verse that “Shabbos” refers to Yom Kippur. be available after Yom Tov, such as a rare major
mentions Shabbos and Rosh Chodesh as well. The
The Pnei Yehoshua offers a fundamentally different sale, may be taken advantage of (Shulchan Aruch
Ritva explains that the frequency with which one 539:5).
approach. In principle, a person should be obligated
must visit his Rebbe depends upon the distance
to greet his Rebbe whenever the opportunity arises. 16. An Uncertain Profit Opportunity
between them. If the Rebbe lives in the same city,
However, such an obligation cannot apply constantly, This heter applies only when it is clear that the
the student is obligated to visit him every day. If he
since it would interfere with a person’s livelihood. On opportunity will be lost after Yom Tov. If one is
lives nearby but outside the city, he should visit once merely unsure, it is not permitted (Daas Torah 533).
Shabbos and Yom Tov, when a person is not occupied
a week or once a month, while someone who lives
with work, the obligation applies. Since women were 17. For One’s Personal Needs
far away is obligated to visit him once each Yom
accustomed to refrain from work on Rosh Chodesh, A special opportunity to purchase products
Tov. Rabbi Yitzchak therefore emphasizes that even
Rosh Chodesh likewise takes on the status of Shabbos needed during the year, which will not be
one who lives far from his Rebbe should not become readily available later, is permitted. The same
and Yom Tov in this regard.
accustomed to neglecting this mitzvah; he must visit applies when such products are unavailable in
him at least once on Yom Tov. The Rach similarly The Pnei Yehoshua further explains why the one’s hometown (Shulchan Aruch 539:9).
explains that one who lives nearby visits his Rebbe Gemara derives the halachah specifically from the
18. For Yom Tov Expenses
on Rosh Chodesh and Shabbos, while one who lives Shunamite woman. Although women are generally One who lacks sufficient funds for Yom Tov
farther away is obligated on Yom Tov. exempt from Talmud Torah, the >page 4 expenses may conduct business to obtain the
necessary money, provided it is done discreetly
(Shulchan Aruch 539:4; Rema ibid.; Taz 539:2).
<page 2 that when a person performs a assumed by another person. But the damage
mitzvah, he does not merely earn that the aveirah itself caused remains with the 19. Planning Ahead for Chol Hamoed
an external reward. The mitzvah sinner and must be repaired through the darchei These heterim do not apply when one
deliberately planned before Yom Tov to do the
itself has a spiritual effect upon him. It changes hateshuvah—the proper paths of repentance.
work on Chol Hamoed. One may not arrange his
the person, purifies his soul, connects him to In conclusion, will the sale be valid? According affairs in advance to take advantage of a Chol
ruchniyus, and brings him closer to Hashem. to this approach, the seller would still bear the full Hamoed heter (Magen Avraham 539:2).
Likewise, an aveirah does not merely create a consequence of the aveirah, but it could potentially 20. Loans and Repaying Debts
future punishment. The aveirah itself damages the affect some minor aspect of the punishment. While Although regular business is assur, lending
person spiritually. according to the Machaneh Chaim’s approach, the and borrowing money or objects is permitted,
According to the Imrei Binah, there are sale is completely null and void. even not for Chol Hamoed purposes. One may
therefore two aspects to the reward of a mitzvah. And there is an additional problem: the sale therefore repay a debt, including a credit-card
There is the reward that a person receives for itself may be an aveirah. bill or mortgage payment, provided no other
having performed the mitzvah, and there is the melachah is involved (Shulchan Aruch 539:2).
The Maharsham points out that someone
mitzvah itself—the spiritual transformation and who agrees to purchase another person’s aveiros 21. Banking Transactions
connection to ruchniyus that resulted from his gives the appearance that he does not take the Ordinary banking transactions, such as cashing
own actions. a check or depositing or withdrawing money
consequences of aveiros seriously. If he truly
not for Chol Hamoed purposes, are considered
The first aspect can be transferred. This is the understood the gravity of sin and its punishment,
business and are assur. Depositing money to
aspect of reward that the Rema is discussing in why would he be willing to “buy” someone else’s
prevent a check from bouncing or withdrawing
Yissachar-Zevulun. aveiros? money needed for Yom Tov is permitted (Shulchan
But the actual spiritual effect of the mitzvah— And for the seller, the Machaneh Chaim raises Aruch 539:14; Mishnah Berurah 47; Shu”t Be’er Moshe VII:53).
the purification and elevation that resulted from an additional concern. Trying to arrange for 22. Working for Payment
the person’s own avodah—cannot simply be someone else to suffer in one’s place is wrong in Even permitted melachos generally may not be
transferred to someone else. This is what the its own right, and besides, the idea of selling one’s done for payment. If no one is available to do
Maharam Alashkar, in the name of Rav Hai Gaon, sins can resemble practices found among other the work for free, payment is permitted. For a
is expressing. religions, in which people would pay religious davar ha’aved, payment is permitted, although
In light of this, we can perhaps understand figures to take away or absolve their sins. By l’chatchilah one should hire a non-Jewish worker
doing so, one gives the appearance, chalilah, (Shulchan Aruch 542:1; Mishnah Berurah 2, 5; Rema ibid.).
the matter of Yitzchak Avinu as well. Although
Yitzchak could accept upon himself the of following such practices. But that is not the 23. For a Mitzvah or Public Need
punishment that was destined for others, that Torah’s approach. The Torah gives us a different Work done for a tzorech mitzvah or tzorech
does not mean that the spiritual damage caused path: Teshuvah, Tefillah, and Tzedakah. harabim may be performed for payment. The
same applies to food-related needs, such as
by an aveirah could simply be removed from the It is through these that a person cleanses
a cook or someone repairing a refrigerator,
sinner’s soul and transferred elsewhere. himself from his aveiros and removes the spiritual
freezer, or oven (Magen Avraham 544:5; Biur Halachah 542:1,
The punishment may, in some sense, be stain that they have left upon his soul. ■ ;ד״ה אפילוPri Megadim 544:5). ■
3
Is the Tree Owner Obligated to Cut Although there is a big machlokes in the poskim
Neighborly Matters Them? whether chazakah can arise immediately when one
does not object his neighbor’s possesions on his
There is, however, a distinction between the
right to remove the obstruction and an obligation property, or the chazakah will be established only
By: Rav Moshe Rieger upon the tree owner to remove it. after three consecutive years of non-objection. But
in our case, the house was bought with the branches
The tree owner did not actively create the already covering his balcony, the tree owner perhaps
A she’eilah arose concerning a homeowner who
damage. The tree is growing naturally within his can claim he created a chazakah prior to the sale.
wished to build a sukkah on his balcony. An adjacent
property, and its branches merely extend over the
neighbor owned a tree whose branches extended
neighbor’s area. This is not necessarily considered
over the balcony, making it impossible to construct Chazakah through an act
girei dilei, since he did not perform an action directly
a kosher sukkah without removing part of the
causing the damage. However, there is a fundamental reason why such
overhanging branches.
Nevertheless, the affected neighbor may exercise a claim should not apply here. We find in the Yad
The tree owner agreed that the branches could
dina lenafshei and remove the branches that interfere Ramah that chazakah requires an act through which
be cut, but insisted that the work be performed only
with his use of the property. the person is proactive and does something that will
by a licensed tree professional. Such a professional
It would therefore seem that the neighbor may cause damage to the other property, then we say that
would charge considerably more than an ordinary
choose a reasonable method of removing the if the neighbor did not object, the first one establishes
tree cutter, not necessarily because he would do
branches, provided that he does not cause the tree the right to remain, and the neighbor can no longer
the job better, but because of his license, insurance,
owner any damage beyond the necessary cutting object thereafter. Where the situation developed
and the security that comes with hiring a qualified
itself. naturally, without an affirmative act by the person
professional.
seeking the chazakah, the mere passage of time does
The question was whether the neighbor must bear not necessarily create such a right.
this additional expense, or whether he may hire a less
expensive person to remove the branches. This is particularly applicable to a tree. The
branches grow and extend gradually on their own.
The Right to Remove a Damaging Tree The fact that the tree became large and eventually
The Shulchan Aruch (Choshen Mishpat 155:26– extended over the neighbor’s property does not
28) discusses an ilan hamazik—a tree whose branches constitute an affirmative act by the tree owner.
or roots interfere with another person’s property. In
Therefore, even if the tree has stood there for
such cases, the person being affected may cut the
many years, the neighbor’s failure to object does not
problematic portion of the tree.
automatically establish a chazakah permitting the
The examples include a tree that prevents a person branches to continue interfering with his property.
from receiving the sunlight needed for his crops, or
Thus, the tree owner cannot necessarily insist that
branches that prevent him from properly plastering
the neighbor use the most expensive professional Conclusion
or repairing his roof. The underlying principle is that
simply because he prefers that method. If an ordinary
one person cannot allow his property to interfere with The owner of the balcony has a legitimate right to
tree cutter can safely remove the offending branches
another person’s legitimate use of his own property. remove branches that prevent him from constructing
without causing additional damage to the tree, the
This halachah is not limited to actual monetary neighbor should seemingly be permitted to use that a kosher sukkah. Although the tree owner is not
loss. The Shulchan Aruch also discusses trees growing less expensive option. necessarily obligated to cut them himself, since he did
along a public road, where the public may cut branches not actively create the damage, the affected neighbor
that interfere with the passage of people and animals. Does the Tree Owner Have a Chazakah? may remove the obstruction.
This demonstrates that preventing the ordinary use of One might raise another issue: perhaps the tree Furthermore, the tree owner cannot necessarily
property can itself constitute sufficient hezek. owner has acquired a chazakah, since the branches dictate that the work be performed only by a licensed
Accordingly, preventing a person from had already been growing over the neighbor’s professional if this merely increases the expense
constructing a kosher sukkah should likewise be property when he purchased it and the neighbor did without preventing any additional damage to the tree.
considered a form of hezek. Building a sukkah is a not object, which gives the tree owner a chazakah that
legitimate use of one’s property, and if the branches his neighbor can no longer demand him to get rid of Finally, the natural growth of the tree does not
prevent the construction of a kosher sukkah, the his branches, for we assume that the neighbor was create a chazakah, even after many years, since no
affected homeowner should have the right to remove already mochel and agreed for the branches to remain affirmative act was performed to establish such a
them. there. right, as explained by the Ramah. ■
<page 3 Shunamite woman regularly visited since the Shunamite woman visited Elisha on Rosh there was an obligation of Aliyah L’Regel.
Elisha and recognized through his Chodesh as well. The Noda B’Yehudah therefore concludes that
conduct that he was a holy man. Since she had learned nowadays, when there is no longer a mitzvah of
proper Torah conduct from him, he assumed the status The Position of the Noda B’Yehudah Aliyah L’Regel because the mitzvah of appearing
of her Rebbe, requiring her to greet him. Thus, the It is noteworthy that although the Rambam and in the Beis HaMikdash was connected to bringing
concept of greeting one’s Rebbe is not necessarily Rosh rule explicitly that one must greet his Rebbe the Korban Re’iyah, there is likewise no formal
limited to men who are obligated in Talmud Torah. on Yom Tov, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not cite obligation to greet one’s Rebbe on Yom Tov. This
Rabbi Yitzchak’s statement in this form. The Noda would explain why the Rambam records the halachah,
The Nature of the Obligation B’Yehudah (Mahadura Tinyana, Orach Chaim 94) since he frequently includes laws that apply when
The Rambam’s placement of this halachah is explains this omission based upon a fundamental the Beis HaMikdash is standing, while the Rosh is
significant. He writes the obligation to greet one’s understanding of the obligation. transmitting the teaching of the Gemara. The Tur
Rebbe immediately alongside the obligation to stand and Shulchan Aruch, by contrast, generally focus on
According to the Noda B’Yehudah, the obligation
before him: practical halachos applicable in our times.
to greet one’s Rebbe on Yom Tov is connected to
“A person is obligated to stand before his Rebbe… and the special spiritual nature of Yom Tov. It is a time This approach, however, is difficult. Neither the
afterward he may sit; and a person is obligated to greet his when the Korban Mussaf is brought, and therefore a Gemara nor the Rambam indicates that the obligation
Rebbe on Yom Tov” (Hilchos Talmud Torah 5:7). Rebbe has a special ability to influence his students. applies only while the Beis HaMikdash is standing.
This suggests that greeting one’s Rebbe is There would likewise be reason to greet one’s Rebbe Furthermore, the Rambam places this halachah
fundamentally an aspect of kavod haRav. At first on Shabbos and Rosh Chodesh. Nevertheless, just as together with the other laws of honoring one’s
glance, this would seem to limit the obligation to Chazal teach that a person should not stand before Rebbe, which certainly apply nowadays, without
those who are subject to the laws of honoring a his Rebbe more than twice a day, so that the honor distinguishing between them.
Torah teacher. Nevertheless, as discussed, the Pnei shown to his Rebbe should not exceed the honor due In the next journal we will iy”h examine how other
Yehoshua understands that women can also have to Heaven (Kiddushin 33a), there cannot be a formal poskim do find that this halacha is mentioned in the
such an obligation, and in certain circumstances may obligation to greet one’s Rebbe more than three times Shulchan Aruch, and how the later poskim concluded
even have a greater frequency of visitation than men, a year. This corresponds to the three Regalim, when on this matter. ■
4
