Masah Vmatan - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

בס"ד
Re s to r ing Th e Pr i mac y O f C h osh e n Mish pat
Business
מכון
לחושן משפט
BUSINE SS HAL ACHA INSTI T U TE
Issue #676
Noach - Lech
Lecha 5787
Oct 16 2026
Weekly
לע״נ הרב יחיאל מיכל בן
ר' משה אהרן אורליאן
Under The
Auspices Of Harav
THE WERDIGER Chaim Kohn, Shlita
EDITION
Case File BHI Hotline
Rabbi Meir Orlian Writer for the Business Halacha Institute
Self-Appointed Agent
and I don't want to take someone else's towel,
Missing Towel even if I'm missing my own.” Q. A real-estate agent saw a listing for a
house for sale in a newspaper, and he offered
Aryeh had a busy Friday afternoon. After The man thought for a moment. “Why don't it to a prospective buyer, who ended up
going to the mikveh, he hurried home to you ask Rabbi Dayan?” he suggested purchasing it.
prepare for Shabbos, accidentally leaving his
towel behind. “That's a good idea," replied Aryeh. He took If this took place in a locale in which the
out his phone and called Rabbi Dayan. seller generally pays part of the realtor’s
He remembered the towel just before commission, is he obligated to pay, or can he
Shabbos, but by then it was too late to return. "I left my towel in the mikveh last week," claim that he deliberately placed an ad in a
“I’ll take it next week,” he thought. Aryeh explained. "Now there's a similar towel, newspaper because he did not want to pay a
but I can't definitively identify it as mine." commission?
The following week, Aryeh returned to the
mikveh. He saw a towel hanging near the place He asked: "Can I take the towel that is Similarly, if the buyer says that he checks
where he left his the previous week. It looked here?” the real estate section of the newspaper daily,
very similar to his—but he couldn't be sure, and he would have seen this listing without
since it was a standard towel, a brand that "Minchas Yitzchak (3:17) addresses this the realtor’s intervention, is he required to pay
many people used. question," replied Rabbi Dayan. a commission?
He took it from the hook and examined it He first refers to the Noda b'Yehuda (E.H. In addition, what if the buyer first heard
carefully. “Is this mine?" he thought. "It looks #46), who discusses whether when something about the house from the realtor, but he then
like it.” is missing and something similar is found at listened to his voice messages and discovered
that place or nearby – do we associate it with that the seller – a close friend of his — had
Someone came out of the mikveh and the missing item? Minchas Yitzchak adds previously left him a message offering to sell
began getting dressed. that when there is no prior contraindicating him that very house, is he required to pay the
halachic chazakah, like lost items that nobody realtor, considering that he could have bought
“Excuse me,” Aryeh said. “Do you know if this
else has monetary possession (chazakah), the house without his help?
towel belongs to anyone here?”
there is more reason to associate it.
“I have no idea,” the man replied. “Why?” A. As a rule, whether a realtor brokered a
However, he recants based on the halachah sale after a buyer and seller approached him
that although identifying the place where as clients, or he found a listing in a newspaper
“I left my towel here last Friday," Aryeh
an item was lost can serve as a siman, a and decided, of his own accord, to find a buyer,
explained. "This one looks like mine, but I can't
riverbank – where many people leave items – he is entitled to a commission.
identify it with certainty.”
is not a siman; just as you left your item there,
The man shrugged. “If you think it's probably someone else may also have left his item there Now, there are poskim who rule that when a
yours, why not take it?” (C.M. 262:9). seller expresses clearly that he does not intend
to pay a commission, he is exempt from paying
Aryeh hesitated. “Because other people Thus, since many people leave towels in the if a realtor decided, of his own accord, to try
leave towels here, too. Maybe someone else mikveh, the place cannot serve as a siman, nor to sell his house (Shu”t Mahriya HaLevi 2:151;
left this one.” can we necessarily associate the existing towel Dovev Meisharim 1:42; cf. Pis’chei Teshuvah
with the one you lost. 264:3 citing Pri Tevuah 58, who writes that
“But isn't it likely that it's the towel you left?” since the seller benefitted from the realtor,
Nonetheless, he concludes – based on Taz he is required to pay). In our case, however,
“It likely is,” Aryeh said. “But it might not be, (C.M. 136:2) – that if you took the towel and
<<<
<<<
THE WERDIGER EDITION | | לע"נ הרה"ח ר' נחמי'ה בן הרה"ח ר' שלמה אלימלך ז"לDEDICATED BY HIS SON R’ SHLOME WERDIGER
Continued Continued There are two separate frameworks under which a
realtor is entitled to payment: neheneh, meaning that
Case File BHI Hotline the parties benefited from the realtor’s work, or po’el,
meaning that he was hired to arrange the sale (Bei’ur
<<< the seller’s listing the house in a newspaper
<<< held it for a long time, you can HaGra, Choshen Mishpat 87:117; 185:13).
does not constitute an absolute declaration that he
assume that it is yours if nobody
is unwilling to pay the commission. Many sellers try Certainly when the sale could have transpired
subsequently inquired about it, since
to list a property in the newspaper in the hopes of
then we can presume yei'ush even if without the realtor — either because the buyer would
finding a buyer and saving the commission, while
it belongs to another. Although Ketzos have seen the listing or heard the seller’s voicemail
simultaneously listing it with a broker (Halichos
(136:2) rejects the Taz – since the yei'ush — then they did not benefit from his services (unless
Yisrael 39). If the seller wrote in the ad, “no agents,”
is only after the other person's item the agent negotiated the terms of the sale between
many poskim would consider it an explicit declaration
came into your hands – here the towel the parties, in which case they were neheneh, and
exempting him from paying a commission, because he
might be yours, so that if nobody seeks
might find a buyer without the realtor’s involvement. should be compensated for the benefit they derived
it, you can presume that it was yours.
or for the work he did for them when they used his
Pischei Choshen (Aveidah 3:[53]), Similarly, if the buyer simply saw the ad in the services to bring the sale to fruition — see Choshen
though, maintains simply that if you newspaper, but did not take any action upon seeing it, Mishpat 375:4).
found a lost item like yours that has no he is not absolved of paying the realtor’s commission.
siman, you can take for yourself, even Since he began to consider buying the house only But even if the parties hired the realtor, they clearly
though you do not know for sure that it once the realtor contacted him, it is evident that it was did not intend to pay him for information they could
is yours. Even if the true owner was not the realtor who brought the deal to fruition and he is have obtained without his assistance; they hired him
yet aware of his loss, so that you cannot therefore entitled to a commission. to find a buyer or property they could not have found
normally take a lost item even when on their own.
But if the buyer checks the real estate listings in
there is no siman, that is only when you
the newspaper daily and would have discovered this
know it is not yours. However, if it might In a case in which the realtor provided the
property on his own, then he is exempt from paying.
be yours – and even if another person information before the ad was placed in the
Since he could have purchased this very property
who lost a similar item would come, he newspaper, the buyer did benefit from the realtor,
without a commission, he is not obligated to pay for
would not be able to claim it, since there because if he had waited until the ad appeared in
the information he received from the realtor (Igros
is no siman – you may take it. Therefore, the paper, another buyer might have purchased the
Moshe 1:49; Pis’chei Choshen, Sechirus 14, fn. 10).
he maintains that you may take towel, property first. He is therefore required to pay the
Certainly, if the seller had already left a message
even though the place cannot serve as
for the buyer before the realtor contacted him, he is broker for the information he provided (see Mishpat
a siman.
exempt. Haneheneh 2:3[6]).
Nonetheless, if there are security
cameras installed and the item is of
substantial value, it is questionable Nonetheless there are several reasons to allow
painting the car.
whether you can take the item.
Moreover, if you see that the towel
Money Matters
First, the primary prohibition is changing the
is not yours, you cannot take it, only Based on writings of Rav Chaim Kohn shlita external appearance to conceal flaws, without
according to the rules of clothing that enhancing the actual value in consonance with the
were exchanged (see Pischei Choshen Ona’as Devarim, Falsehood additional cost. However, painting the car so that the
4:[44] and Hayashar v'Hatov 21 (5776) exterior is in good condition enhances the inherent
pp. 63-65).
and Geneivas Da’as #21 value of the car, and sometimes people choose to
Painting a Used Car paint their cars for this reason (see Sma 228:15;
"Thus," concluded Rabbi Dayan, "if Mishpatecha l'Yaakov 8:30).
the unidentifiable towel may be yours Q: I am selling a used car, whose exterior is
– you can take it, and you may use it, in poor condition. May I paint it to make it more Second, the age of the car is clearly known
certainly after time passes." attractive to buy? from the documentation, regardless of the external
appearance; some poskim allow in this situation (see
A: It is prohibited to portray merchandise in a Igros Moshe Y.D. 1:31).
Verdict: When you lose an item manner that misleads the customer to think that it is
without a siman and later find a better than it is, even when selling at its fair cost. This Third, since it is common to paint cars before
similar item in that place, even if is considered geneivas da'as of the customer, who
thinks that he bought something of higher quality for selling, some maintain that the buyer should expect
the place cannot serve as a siman, this, so that it is not geneivas da'as (see Sma 228:16).
a cheap price.
such as a towel in the mikveh, you
may take it for yourself. Therefore, the seller may not paint an old item to (which is true, due to your concerns about him), rather
make it look new (C.M. 228:9; Sma 228:15). than say that you do not have money.
Elevate your inbox: Subscribe to the For questions on monetary matters, arbitrations, legal
documents, wills, ribbis, & Shabbos, Please contact our
Business Weekly confidential hotline at
Join thousands of readers and gain valuable
weekly insights on navigating life and business מכון לחושן משפט
in accordance with Halacha.
718.233.3845 _ ask@businesshalacha.com
www.businesshalacha.com
1937 Ocean Ave. Brooklyn, NY 11230
Subscribe your Shul, Community, English Business Weekly:
or Neighborhood. subscribe@businesshalacha.com To subscribe send an email to:
Become a distributor: Hebrew Masu Umaton: subscribe@businesshalacha.com
admin@businesshalacha.com mm@businesshalacha.com
