Chikei Chaim - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

Dinim of
Animals
Request: To Donate To Subscribe:
Please send to as many paskenshtibel@gmail.com
people as possible, with
that, having a hand in ''''חוקי חיים
spreading Torah and Click To Download
relevant Halochos to previous Gilyonos
people everywhwere Archives
153
Please do not
read during
Davening or
Krias Hatorah
Halochos Pertaining to Animals | Parshas Noach 5787
It used to be very common for Jews to have animals such as horses, 9. Harmful animals. One may kill animals which cause humans distress
donkeys, sheep, chickens, ducks, etc., in their houses or yards, and such as snakes, mad cats ()שו"ע חו"מ סי' רס"ו ס"ד, mad dogs ( מהרש"ל
the relevant halochos were very applicable. Although they are not )הובא בט"ז יו"ד סי' קט"ז סוף סק"ו, bees, mosquitos, and the like. Even
as relevant today, there are still halochos that are applicable; e.g creatures that are just bothersome, e.g., ants, flies, cockroaches, etc.
for those who house pets; we will discuss the more common ones. may be killed ()שו"ת הרדב"ז ח"ב סי' תשכ"ז. Still, if possible, it is better to
Tzaar Baalei Chayim avoid directly killing them with one’s body, and instead use
something else, such as poison ()שו"ת אג"מ חו"ח ח"ב סי' מ"ז.
Deoraiso or Derabonon? 10. Midas chassidus. The Arizal did not cause pain to any of Hashem’s
1. The Tannoim (.)ב"מ ל"ב, Amoroim ( ועוד. שבת קי"ז,)שם, and poskim creations, including insects, and he instructed his talmid not to kill
debate whether the issur of tzaar baalei chayim is deoraiso or even a louse. This conduct befits a tzaddik and holy person of his
derabonon. Most rishonim hold it is deoraiso ( כס"מ בדעת,הרי"ף stature ()תשוה"נ שם. Still, no one should cause pain to any creature
,' רמב"ן עה"ת בראשית א,: רמב"ן שבת קנ"ד,הרמב"ם ורמב"ם בפיה"מ ביצה פ"ג מ"ד just for fun. Thus, children should be stopped from pulling off an
. רשב"א ב"מ ל"ג,)כ"ט.
insect’s legs or wings for example ()שו"ת תולדות יעקב י"ד סי' ל"ג דף ע"ד.
2. Others say the issur is only derabonon ( פנ"י ב"מ שם,יראים סי' שנ"ב
Also, if a fly or bug is slowly dying, one should kill it so that it does
וביאור הגר"א שו"ע חו"מ סי' רע"ב סקי"א אור שמח פכ"ה שבת הכ"ו ורוב פוסקים
)בדעת הרמב"ם פי"ג הל' רוצח ושמירת הנפש.
not suffer longer ( דינים והנהגות חזו"א ח"ב עמ' מ' ס"ד,)חזו"א.
3. Non-Jew’s animal. An important ramification of whether tzaar Select Hilchos Shabbos
baalei chayim is deoraiso or derabonon pertains to a non-Jew’s Feeding Animals
animal. That is, if it is deoraiso, the issur also applies to a non-Jew’s 11. Responsible to feed it. One may feed an animal on Shabbos if he
animal, whereas if it is only derabonon, it does not. is responsible for its sustenance, i.e., it does not have food other
4. Mechaber, Ramo. The Mechaber ( )חו"מ סי' רע"ב ס"טunderstands than what is given to it ()שו"ע סי' שכ"ד סי"א. Thus, if someone has an
from the Rambam’s wording that the only reason one must help a
animal such as a cat, rabbit, bird, parrot, etc., in his home, since he
non-Jew’s animal with its load is to prevent animosity [eivoh]. This
is responsible for its sustenance, he may feed it on Shabbos. Still,
seems to show that he holds tzaar baalei chayim is not deoraiso. The
Ramo comments on this that, “Some hold one must help unload the if possible, it is better to give them enough food on Erev Shabbos
animal even if the non-Jewish owner is not there because of tzaar to last until Motzei Shabbos ( דולה ומשקה עמ' ק"ע,)הגר"ח קנייבסקי.
baalei chayim, which is deoraiso. Even when a person is potur from 12. Also, they should only be fed what they are usually fed during the
unloading, he must still help because of tzaar baalei chayim.” It is week. One should not add unnecessary treats, e.g., sunflower seeds
clear from this that the Ramo holds tzaar baalei chayim is deoraiso. for a parrot in addition to its regular food, even lechovod Shabbos..
13. Fish. One may feed fish on Shabbos. Thus, someone who has an
Types of Animals aquarium at home may feed the fish on Shabbos (')ארחות שבת פל"א אות כ.
5. Dogs, cats. Some poskim are unsure whether tzaar baalei chayim
14. Not responsible to feed it. One may not feed an animal on
applies to dogs and cats, being that they find their own food
Shabbos if he is not responsible for its sustenance ()שו"ע שם. Even
()היעב"ץ ח"א סי' י"ז. However, most poskim hold the issur of tzaar
if it belongs to him, if it can find its own food, he should not feed
baalei chayim does apply to dogs and cats ( 'שו"ת שבות יעקב ח"ג סי
it. The reason is because doing so is unnecessary effort ()מ"ב סקכ"ט.
שו"ת משנה הלכות ח"ו סי' רט"ז, שו"ת חבלים בנעימים ח"א סוף סי' מ"ג,)ע"א.
15. Dogs. One may put food before a dog even if it is ownerless
6. Mice. Some poskim write that there is no issur of tzaar baalei
chayim for mice since they do not do work or serve any purpose because dogs require little food and it is somewhat of a mitzvoh to
for humans (')שו"ת זבחי צדק סי' א. However, several poskim write feed them ( מ"ב סקל"א, שו"ע הרב ס"ז,)שו"ע שם.
that the issur does apply, just the reason one may kill mice is 16. Food that will be thrown outside regardless. If a person usually
because they damage people and food (see below, 9) and scare throws his leftover food outside even if there is no animal that
people ()שו"ת אג"מ חו"מ ח"ב סי' מ"ז. [Whether or not the issur of tzaar needs feeding, he may throw the leftovers out in front of an animal
baalei chayim applies to them will affect lab rats..] – even if it is ownerless – since he is doing it for himself, not for the
7. Fish. Some write that there is no issur of tzaar baalei chayim for fish, animal ()א"א בוטשאטש מהדו"ק. Likewise, in a place that has an eiruv,
the proof being that they may be eaten without shechitoh ( יד יהודה one may shake the crumbs out of a tablecloth for the birds to eat
השואל בשו”ת משנה הלכות ח"ו סי' רט"ז,)סי' י''ג. However, most poskim hold since he is doing so for his own purposes ()שש"כ פכ"ז סכ"א.
the issur does apply to fish ( שו"ת משנה הלכות שם,)שו"ת שאילת יעב"ץ שם. 17. Whimpering cat. If a person hears an ownerless cat whimpering
8. Insects, bugs. Since insects do not benefit humans, can cause and it is disturbing his sleep, strictly speaking, he should not feed
aveiros if they are eaten, and even present some danger and it since he is not responsible for its sustenance. However, if the cat
distress to people, there is no basis in the Torah to avoid causing is in distress, one may put milk or food out for it because of tzaar
them pain or killing them ()שו"ת יעב"ץ הנ"ל. Additionally, they have baalei chayim. It is better if this can be done by a child or non-Jew
a weak life force ()תשוה"נ ח"ב סי' תשכ"ו. ()שו"ת אבני ישפה או"ח סי' פ"ח.
“The Cheder Horoah” | 20 Minchas Yitzchok St. Yerushalayim | paskenshtibel@gmail.com
Opening times: Sun. – Thurs. 5:00pm till 8:00pm | Fri. 10:00am till 11:00am and from 1 hour before candle-lighting
Muktzeh 27. The Ramo holds they are subject to the issur of trapping
18. One may not move animals on Shabbos ( ;)שו"ע סי' ש"ח סל"טthey are miderabonon, and all the acharonim follow this psak ( בן איש חי ש"ב
muktzeh just like trees or stones since they are not meant for כפה"ח ס"ק קי"ז ועוד,')וארא אות ח. If one is afraid they will be stolen or
people’s use. Thus, they should not be moved whatsoever ( מ"ב ס"ק get lost, he may be meikel to have a non-Jew return them to their
)קמ"ו. One may not even touch an animal’s surface hair or fur since cage ()מ"ב סקנ"ז. Also, there is no need to stop a child from trapping
doing so moves a part of it ()מ"ב ס"ק קנ"א. them on his own ()מ"ב שם.
19. Pets. Animals that people commonly have in their homes and 28. If an animal of this sort got out of its cage into the room, and within
often pick up, move, and pet during the week, such as dogs, cats, the room, one needs to run after it to catch it, he may lock the
rabbits, turtles, birds, and the like are also muktzeh and should not room's door to minimize the space the animal can flee to since even
be moved on Shabbos. This is because Chazal did not differentiate when they are within a room, they are not considered trapped.
within their decree ( הג' רע"א, שו"ת מהר"ח או"ז סי' פ"ב בשם תשו' הרא"ש29. Potential damage. If an animal of this sort is in a big, fenced area
דעת תורה שם,)שו"ע שם סקי"ז. and is likely to cause damage, break things, etc., one may be meikel
20. For health purposes. A pet needed for a person’s health, such as a to get it into its cage and lock the door. This is because his goal is
seeing eye dog ( שש"כ פי"ח הע' ס"ב,)הגרשז"א, may be walked on to prevent damage, not to trap it, as the area is fenced and anyway
Shabbos, e.g., to shul ()שו"ת אג"מ ח"א סי' מ"ה. The owner should try to the animal will return to its cage at night ()מ"ב שם.
move it as little as possible though. Also, if someone has an
emotional disorder and a doctor said that stroking a pet can benefit Feeding Animals First
his health, he may do so on Shabbos since it is designated for that Eating, Tasting, Drinking
even during the week, and he may rely on the opinions that allow 30. Eating. One may not eat before giving his animal food (.)ברכות מ.
moving it ( שו"ת אז נדברו ח"ח סי' ל"ו,)שו"ת אג"מ ח"ה סי' כ"ב אות כ"א. Some say this is deoraiso ( מג"א סי' רע"א,שו"ת מהר"ם מרוטנבורג ח"ד סי' ש"ב
21. Where there is tzaar baalei chayim. In a situation of tzaar baalei שו"ת אבני צדק או"ח סי' ק"ט בדעת הט"ז, ;)סקי"בothers hold it is derabonon
chayim, one may move an animal on Shabbos as much as he needs ( ביה"ל סי' קס"ז ד"ה ומ"מ בשם כמה אחרונים, ;)פר"ח או"ח סי' ס"ו ס"טyet others
to remove the animal’s pain. Thus, if an animal in a yard is unable hold it is merely a midas chassidus ()רמב"ם פ"ט עבדים ה"ח.
to walk on its own, one may hold it by the neck or wings and walk 31. Tasting. Some poskim hold only a significant amount of food may
it ()שו"ע סי' ש"ח ס"מ. If an animal fell into a water ditch on Shabbos not be eaten before one feeds his animal, but he may taste some
and it might die, the poskim argue whether one may lift it out ( מ"ב food, i.e., less than a kebeitzoh ()ט"ז סי' קס"ז סק"ז. However, most
)סי' ש"ה סק"ע. If it cannot be assisted by putting pillows or blankets poskim hold one may not even eat less than a kebeitzoh before
under it for it to climb up by itself, one may lift it with his hands feeding his animal ( מ"ב סי' קס"ז סק"מ, שו"ת שבות יעקב ח"ג סי' י"ג,)ב"י.
since we hold tzaar baalei chayim is deoraiso (above, 1) and Tasting something just on the tongue is mutar ()שו"ת אבני צדק שם.
overrides the issur of muktzeh ()מ"ב שם. 32. Drinking. Some hold even when it comes to drinking, one must
22. One Shabbos, someone saw a cat stick its head in an empty yogurt give his animal first ( אור החיים הק' חיי שרה,שו"ת כתב סופר או"ח סי' ל"ב
container to lick up the remains. Lo and behold, its whole face got י"ט,)כ"ד. However, most poskim hold one may drink before his
stuck, and it was walking around like a crazy cat with a container animal ( מ"ב שם, א"ר,)מג"א סי' קס"ז סקי"ח בשם ספר חסידים.
that it could not get off its face. He asked, if he was allowed to help Who Has This Chiyuv?
the cat with its plight. Since it was in distress, we ruled he could 33. The owner. The chiyuv to feed an animal before eating is only
move the cat around in place as much as necessary to get the incumbent on the animal's owner. Thus, one may give his wife and
container off its face, but he could not lift it at all since it was in a children food before feeding his animal since they are not the ones
reshus horabim. with the chiyuv ()טהרת השלחן הג' סוף השו"ע.
23. Ants, other insects. On Shabbos, one may gently sweep ants, other 34. His animals. This chiyuv only applies to animals one is responsible
insects, and the like that are bothering him into a dustpan in a way to feed. Although it is good to feed any hungry or thirsty animal
that will not definitely kill them. Then he can lift the dustpan and because of tzaar baalei chayim; and anyone who is merciful toward
drop them into the garbage. This is not a problem of muktzeh since Hashem's creations receives Heavenly mercy; and Hashem Himself
he is moving them indirectly. If they are very repulsive, one may is merciful toward all His creations; one does not need to feed an
remove them due to the heter of "geref shel re'i" ( פמ"ג סי' שט"ז animal he is not responsible for specifically before he himself eats
תהלה לדוד שם סקי"א,)משב"ז סק"ח. ( שלחן הטהור,)פמ"ג סי' קס"ז משב"ז סק"ז.
35. Fish. The chiyuv to feed animals first applies to fish too ( מו"ר בשו"ת
Trapping [Tzeidoh] )שבט הקהתי ח"ו סי' קי"ב.
24. There is an issur to trap animals on Shabbos ()שו"ע סי' שט"ז, which
36. Shliach, appointee. One may appoint a shliach or make someone in
sometimes applies to animals in a house. We will therefore go the house in charge of feeding the animals. If he does this, he is potur
through some important halochos. from this chiyuv ()יד אפרים בהג' שו"ע, and the shliach or appointee may
25. Dogs, cats by their owner. Animals that grew up in someone's not eat before feeding the animals ( ספר צער בעלי חיים בהלכה ואגדה פט"ז
possession, are naturally tame, and do not run away from people, 1053 ')הע. Even if an animal owner appointed someone else to feed
e.g., goats, sheep, and dogs or cats in relation to their owners ( א"א his animals right before he was about to eat, he may go ahead and
)בוטשאטש, are not subject to the issur of trapping whatsoever. One eat even before his shliach feeds the animals ( 'משמעות שו"ע או"ח סי
may therefore push and direct them to enter their pen or cage and מו"ר בשו"ת שבט הקהתי ח"א סי' שע"ג, כפה"ח סקנ"ב,)קס"ז ס"ו.
close the door behind them ( )מ"ב סי' שט"ז סקנ"טunless they disobey 37. Thus, if one has a pet in his home, he may appoint a family member
their owner. In such a case, the issur of trapping is in force, and one to be in charge of feeding it, and then everyone else in the home is
may not return them to their cage and lock the door. potur from this chiyuv. It could be one may even appoint a child
26. Rabbits, hares, hamsters. Some animals grow up in a person's [who is old enough to be responsible] to be in charge of feeding the
possession but naturally run away when someone tries to hold pet since this is not typical halachic shlichus and does not need a
them, but then return to their cage in the evening, for example "chalois" – it's just a task that must be done by someone responsible.
rabbits, hares, hamsters, dogs and cats that belong to someone else, 38. On Shabbos or Yom Tov. Some poskim are unsure if the chiyuv to
coloured birds, and parrots. Regarding these animals, the Mechaber feed one's animals first applies on Shabbos; perhaps the chiyuv to
( )סי' שט"ז סי"בrules there is no issur of trapping, and one may push eat on Shabbos and Yom Tov overrides the chiyuv to feed the
them into their cage and lock the door. They shouldn't be moved animals first. Still, one should be machmir ( שו"ת כתב סופר או"ח
with the hands, though, because they are muktzeh (above, 18). שו"ת קרן לדוד סי' מ"ז ססק"ב,' שו"ת משנה הלכות ח"ז סי' מ,)סי' ל"ב.
ברכת מזל טוב שגורה לידידנו הרב הגליון נתרם לע''נ ידידנו 'לז''נ הרה''ח ר לע''נ האשה החשובה
שליט''א זרחיה שיקער גרשון מתתיהו 'ר אברהם זאב דבורה קריינער ע''ה
המתרגם הגליון לאנגלית מדי שבוע ב''ר ברוך מנדלסון ז''ל ז''ל ב''ר שאול בת הצדיק הר''ר
במסירות ובצורה נפלאה
נלב''ע א' מרחשון תשפ''א ז''ל שמאהל חיים אהרן ראזענבורג
'לרגל לידת בתו עדינה שתחי
שיזכה לגדלה לתורה לחופה שיזכה התורם לס''ד והצלחה ח' מרחשון תשל''ב נפטרה ח' מרחשון תש''א
ולמעש''ט ולהמשיך בהרבצת התורה מרובה בכל ענינים ונחת באדען – לונדון מנו''כ בווייטצען
