Lehisvada - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

Taanis Daf Yud Aleph
When Do Residents of Eretz Yisrael Ask For Rain When In the Diaspora?
חמשה עשר יום אחר החג כדי שיגיע אחרון, רבן גמליאל אומר בשבעה בו, בשלשה במרחשון שואלין את הגשמים, במשנה.'בתענית דף י
.שבישראל לנהר פרת
. אמר רב הונא בר חייא אמר שמואל הלכה כחנניה. חנניה אומר ובגולה עד ששים בתקופה, תניא. אמר רבי אלעזר הלכה כרבן גמליאל,ובגמרא
-א-
When it comes to asking for rain, does a person go after his main place of residence?
It depends if he intends to return while it is still winter \ … if he to, like we say concerning keeping a second day of Yom
intends to return that year \ The difference if he has a wife and Tov. [If a resident of Eretz Yisrael is in the Diaspora, he
children in Eretz Yisrael \ It all depends where he is \ A resident will not keep the second day completely, and if a resident
of the Diaspora in Eretz Yisrael \ The decision of the Poskim of the Diaspora is in Eretz Yisrael for Yom Tov he will
הליכות שלמה, הגאון מטשעבין ז"ל, אג"מ, פמ"ג, ברכי יוסף, פרי חדש,רדב"ז keep a second day.] Or, do we say that regarding asking
אRegarding the halachah of asking for rain, which for rain it just depends where one is at that time, and it
begins in Eretz Yisrael on the seventh of Cheshvan makes no difference if he intends to return to his place
and in the Diaspora from the sixtieth day from the tek- of permanent residence or not. The first opinion itself is
ufah (equinox), the question is what should a resident divided into a further two opinions, as will be explained.
of Eretz Yisrael do if he is in the Diaspora during the The Teshuvos Radvaz1 writes that if one came from
interim period, or if a resident of the Diaspora comes Eretz Yisrael to the Diaspora and intends to return still
to Eretz Yisrael. There are many differences of opinion that winter, he should ask for rain like those in Eretz Yis-
regarding this, and since nowadays travel is very com- rael from the seventh of Cheshvan. But if he only intends
mon, it is worth knowing what the Poskim said about it. returning after the winter, he should ask for rain like the
(In practice, one should ask a Rav what one should do.) place where he is, as there is no reason to ask for rain ear-
Generally speaking there are two main opinions lier since he does not need them. Thus, to act like those
about this, which split into three opinions. The Poskim in Eretz Yisrael he must intend returning while they are
argue if regarding asking for rain a person follows his still asking for rain. [1]
place of permanent residence which he intends to return Although the Pri Chadash2 agrees that it depends
Notes
[1] The Radvaz writes there that the source to differentiate a resident of an un-walled town as regards to whether he needs to
between if one returned during the winter or afterwards can read the Megillah on the fourteenth of Adar (for un-walled cities)
be learnt from the laws of reading the Megillah, but he does not or on the fifteenth (for walled cities). In other words, it depends
explain what he means. Perhaps we may say that he was referring where he is on that day. Similarly, regarding the difference between
to the halachah that just as regarding reading the Megillah on the residents of Eretz Yisrael and the Diaspora begin to ask for rain, it
fourteenth or fifteenth of Adar, the Gemara in Megillah15 says that a will depend where a person is during that interim time.
person who is in an un-walled town for the day is considered to be
1
Taanis
ShabbosDaf
Daf Yud
LamedAleph
Ches
on when he intends to return to Eretz Yisrael, he writes does ask for rain. Conversely, a resident of the Diaspora
L’halacha the Rishonim disagree concerning whether we pasken On the other hand, the Biur HaGra there goes to great lengths and
that it does not depend on his returning during the win- who is in Eretz Yisrael at that time will ask for rain, since
like Rebbi Meir or Rebbi Yehudah. The Rif 9 asserts that the halacha concludes like Rebbi Meir. The Mishna Berurah 18 cites this opinion
ter months,
follows but if he
Rebbi Yehudah, andintends
the Ran 10 toexplains
return his that year. Iftohe
reasoning be during
of the Gra that
andperiod
how he he needs
follows thefootsteps
in the rain forofhis temporary
Tosafos and his
intendsRav
because to return
publicly that year, he
darshened should
as such. Thisask beingfor the
raincasefrom the needs. Hewho
colleagues citesall several
pasken like sagesRebbifrom Meir Spain
that evenwhob’mayzid
follow this it is
halacha follows suit. The same is raised by both the Rambam 11 and only assur to eat from food cooked on Shabbos until Motzei Shabbos.
the seventh of Cheshvan, but if he intends to return only opinion.
Ramban 12 as well. Additionally, the Beis Yosef 13 writes that the This applies even to the one who cooked it, and b’shogeig everyone
after aofyear
words the Roshor two,14 seem he toshould
lean this askway liketoo.those in the Dias- He adds
can partake fromthere
5
the food that when we
immediately say thatitself.
on Shabbos a resident
The Mishna of
pora. Eretz Yisrael
Berurah whoinisa in
asserts that time theof Diaspora
need one is should allowed to askrelyforonrainthis
On the other hand, Tosafos in Chullin 15 asserts that the halacha where the food was cooked b’shogeig.
followBesides
Rebbi this Meir,they and argue
his reasoned additionallyis because regarding
this is how if one
Rav like those living there, that is not only when he is in a
has a wifehisand
instructed children
students. in Eretz Yisrael.
Additionally, the BeisThe Yosef Radvaz
16 bringsholdsthis The that
place implication
has aofJewish his words is that it is specifically
community. Rather, even with regards
if he
b’shem both the Smag and Sefer HaTerumah as well. to shogeig that one can rely on Tosafos to pasken like Rebbi Meir.
that then even if he does not intend returning until after On is in a place with no Jewish community, he must act
the other hand, b’mayzid on wouldn’t be allowed to rely on Rebbi
theThe winter,
Shulchan he should
Aruch 17 still ask like
determines likethose in EretzofYisrael,
the opinions the Rif, like the
Meir’s residents
opinion allowingofthe the cookDiaspora
to partakeregarding
from the food asking
on Motzeifor
Rambam, and Rosh to pasken like
since he needs the rain (to provide sustenance for his Rebbi Yehudah (as we have already Shabbos. With regard to a mayzid we
rain. Even though when there are difference in custom must act stringently like Rebbi
mentioned). Yehudah who holds that the food is perpetually assur.
family) and it is not a curse for those in the Diaspora if between two places, the Gemara says in Pesachim6 that
it rains after the seventh of Cheshvan, as it is the time for- ב-one only needs to keep the local custom when one is in a
rain, just that it Maiseh is not considered
Shabbos with a need regard for them.
to a Melacha where place that
nothing has aisJewish
done tocommunity,
the object itself but regarding asking
The Pri Chadash on the other hand, writes that if for rain it does not depend on being in a place which has
Where one was motzi something from one reshus to the speaking, the issur of Maiseh Shabbos is not something specific to
he intends returning only after a year or two he should Bishul a Jewish community. The reason why he follows the cus-
creating an issur for one to eat food cooked on Shabbos. On
other, if such a thing is assur because of Maiseh Shabbos /
ask like those in the Diaspora,
Specifics in thiseven inyanif he has a wife and tomcontrary,
the of the itresidents
applies to of anythe Diaspora
Melacha. is not transgresses
If someone because heany is
children in Eretz Yisrael.
- יונה רבנו,'תוסHe,אדם holds
חיי,רמ"א that,טורhaving
- a wife and of the it is then forbidden
abiding by the customs of the place that he has come to,
Melachos Shabbos for him to benefit from
what he did. Additionally, in the Shulchan Aruch 19 the Mechaber
children in Eretz Yisrael makes no difference to asking for brings
[ ]בAlthough both our Mishna and Gemara only make reference to
but since now they do not ask for rain in the Diaspora,
this concept of not being able to eat what one cooked on
raincooking
whenonheShabbos, is in theit isDiaspora.
already made known from the Tur that he is likeand
Shabbos, an the
individual
Rema adds in this
that matter, and individuals
this is applicable to the other do
this Theconcept of Maiseh Shabbos 3 doesn’t differentiate. Practically
Pri Megadim there holds like the Pri Chadash Melachos as
not ask for rain. well.
that it depends on whether his intention is to return In practice, there are differences of opinion between
NOTES
within the year or afterwards. He adds that this halachah the more recent Poskim, as follows:
applies also to
If a Maiseh a resident
Shabbos is assurof the Diaspora
b’hana’ah / Two aspects whotocomesMaiseh to concerning Mishnah
The where Brurah
one toivels vessels7on does notWeside
Shabbos. conclusively
say there with
that if done b’shogeig
Shabbos, and the difference between Mevashel and other Melachos / he may use them, and b’mayzid not. As such, it is clear that the issur Maiseh Shabbos
Eretz Yisrael.cooked
Something If heonintends Shabbos to is return
given similar within thetoyear,
status other he any one of the opinions. He cites the view of the Pri Cha-
applies even to benefit through something’s usage, and not just an issur achilah.
will not ask for rain from the seventh of Cheshvan, but
forbidden foods / Where one cooked water and it got cold again / dash that it depends if he intends to return home within
On the other hand, concerning Bishul there is an additional element. When one
Where one cooked water for washing and it got cold again
from the sixtieth day from the tekufah, like those in the cooks
- שו"ת מנחת שלמה-
a year. He also
on Shabbos citesgetsthe
the meat a dinBirkei
of basar Yosef
tereifahin m’drabbanan.
the nameAsofsuch, sev-it
becomes assur for consumption just like all other forbidden foods. Because of this
Diaspora.
[1] The Minchas Shlomo comments on this that the Tur writes how the din Maiseh
31 eral Spanish sages, who say that it does not depend on
the Magen Avraham asserts that even the pot it was cooked in becomes assur as
34
Shabbos applies to all Melachos
4 making it
The Birkei Yosef argues with both the Radvaz and the well.
assur to benefit from the act performed. his One
intention
then needsto return,
to do hagalah andon thedoes
pot andnot come to
it is necessary evena ifconclu-
a 24 hour
He points out that according to this the issur Maiseh Shabbos isn’t specifically an
period passes making it no longer a Ben Yomo. Although there would have logically
Pri Chadash.
issur achilah (eating) He butholds
also an that asking(benfit).
issur ha’na’ah for rain onlythisdepends
However, is difficult sion. But he does not cite the view of the Radvaz that it
been room to say that after 24 hours the pot should only give off negative tastes
on where he is actually then, regardless of whether his through
to understand. In Bava Kama 32 we see that even Rebbi Yochanan Hasandler who depends whichon onehis intention
doesn’t to return
benefit, nevertheless while
we see clearlyit that
is still winter,
the Chachamim
holds Maiseh Shabbos is assur min hatorah, nevertheless this is only an issur achilah
made the issur Maiseh Shabbos by Bishul comparable to all other forbidden foods.
permanent
and residence
not an issur ha’na’ah, and itis in Eretzlearnt
is something Yisrael or pesukim.
out from the Diaspora.
Now, if this which implies that he does not hold like him. [2]
The same way by other issurim the pot is also assur for use even when not a Ben
Therefore, a resident of Eretz Yisrael who is in the Dias- Yomo,The
is true (that the issur is only an issur achilah and not an issur ha’na’ah) for Rebbi
so tooTeshuvos
this follows forIgros
Maiseh Moshe 8
Shabbos as says
well. that regarding the
Yochanan Hasandler who holds that Maiseh Shabbos is assur min hatorah, then it
poracertainly
must between should be the the seventh
case for bothof Cheshvan
Rebbi Meir and Rebbi andYehuda
sixtywhodays hold basic
Withargument
this in mind we between the Radvaz,
can now explain what is said Pri in BavaChadash
Kama thatand even
from the tekufah will not ask for rain, since the place
the issur is merely m’drabbanan. As such, it is difficult to understand how we can Birkei Yosef one should follow the Pri Chadash who says
according to Rebbi Yochanan Hasandler the issur is only an issur achilah and not an
say it is assur to benefit from all types of Maiseh Shabbos. issur ha’na’ah. What this means to say is that although the food get the status of a
where he is does not ask for rain, and an individual maichal that itassur,
depends on this
nevertheless whether
only makes heit intends
forbidden for toconsumption
return within and not
To answer he asserts that in truth there are two forms of the issur Maiseh
benefit. It doesn’t become like Arlah, Klayim, or Hekdesh where benefit is also
Shabbos. Therefore, although by all the Melachos one does on Shabbos there is an
forbidden. However, this is said specifically with regard to benefit that one could
issur to benefit from them, nevertheless this doesn’t pose a contradiction to what the Notes
have enjoyed even before the Maiseh was performed. This is because it isn’t caused
Gemara in Bava Kama says concerning how a Maiseh Shabbos is only assur for
by the forbidden Melacha such as where one benefits through giving the food to his
[2] The Mishnah
consumption Brurah
and not benefit. Wethere
will nowwrites
bring that
a briefit account
seemsoffrom the Beer
his words. However, when the Birkei Yosef quotes them, he writes explic-
friend as a gift, or to his animal to eat. As long as these things are done in a way
Heitev that the Chachmei Sfard who wrote that a person
The first thing to know is that by all Melachos Shabbos whenever the Melacha should wherethat
itly one they dobenefit
doesn’t not agree
from with the Radvaz
the Bishul Pri say
itself, weorthen Chadash. He says
that although the
act according to where he is, were talking about when he does not
actually activates the object for benefit, then it most certainly is assur to benefit from that the Chachmei Sfard say that even if he intends to return ittoassur
Chachamim gave it the status of forbidden food, nevertheless this only makes his
the Maiseh Shabbos. Examples would include where one heats up water for bathing for his consumption
native country, and not benefit. On the
he nevertheless other hand,
follows the there is alsowhere
country benefit he
which
is
intend to return. If so, there is no argument between them and the
purposes, or launders clothing to wear. In such cases it is assur to benefit from the one is only capable of having through the act of Bishul that was performed. Such
PriofChadash,
act sincein ifboth
issur although he situations
does intend to return
the issur is purelytobenefit
his country evenis
related. This presently.
benefit is most definitely assur being that it is only had through the act of issur, and
because it is assur to use something if the usage only comes
the Chachmei Sfard will agree to the Pri Chadash that he follows his through benefitting from this is clear from what the Mishna teaches that one may not use vessels which he
one of the Melachos Shabbos. The source for this is from the Mishna in Terumos 33 toiveled on Shabbos.
place of permanent residence.
2
Taanis
ShabbosDaf
Daf Yud
LamedAleph
Ches
the year or not, since the Pri Megadim cites the Pri Cha- return within the year, it makes no difference whether
On the other hand, from the Poskim it isn’t so cut and dry that which happened on Yom Tov. His point is to show that there truly is
dash. Therefore, residents of Eretz Yisrael who are staying he has a wife and children in Eretz Yisrael. However, he
the issur Maiseh Shabbos applies to all of the 39 Melachos. It no issur Hotza’ah applicable. On Yom Tov such an act is completely
in the Diaspora
becomes clear from them andthatintend
there isreturning
a possibilitywithin
some arethe year,
excluded, does write
muttar. He eventhat
addssince
that ofthey areit not
course wouldasking forto rain
be assur eat theyet in
fruits
should
and asknow
we will forgorain on from the seventh of Cheshvan. [3]
to elaborate. ifthe
theyDiaspora, heremoved
were actually shouldintoaska public
for rain in the
domain brachahitself
on Shabbos of
just like the din by Mevashel. The Magen Avraham 25 cites the words
The Gaon Adam
The Chayei of Tshibin
20asserts would
that the go issuraccording
Maiseh Shabbos to theis shome’a tefillah, as opposed to barech aleinu.
of Tosafos.
applicable of the Radvaz,
opinion specifically who saidisthat
where something done itto depends if oneA
the object itself. However, regarding a resident of the Diaspora who is
physical change has to happen such as the
intends to return while it is still winter, as quoted in result of cooking food or
the in Eretz Yisrael26atanswers
The Ramban Tosafos’s of
the beginning question
the winter,using he a different
writes
anything comparable. On the9 other hand, when one is Motzi approach. He writes that although all types of Maiseh Shabbos are
Teshuvos Mishnah Shlomo where he ruled that students
something from one domain to another where the actual object isn’t
there that it depends if he intends to return to the Dias-
11
assur on Shabbos itself in order to prevent their benefit (such as what
from Chutz
physically La’aretz
affected, who areit learning
if done b’shogeig can be usedin on yeshivah
Shabbos itselfin poracooked,
one beforetook
the sixtieth
Ma’aser day off from or tekufah
from, the anything or not. If he
comparable),
and
Eretz Yisrael who intend to return home before Pesach,it
even by the person who committed the act. If done b’mayzid nevertheless the fruits here are different. They began
intends to stay until after the sixtieth day he should in the person’s
ask
is assur even to others, but only until Motzei Shabbos. He does house, were removed to a public area, and then brought back to the
which is still during the winter, should act like resi-
conclude though that one should be stringent with all Issurei Torah
for rain from the seventh of Cheshvan like residents of
house. As such, there is no reason to assur them. They didn’t come
dents
just likeofbythe Diaspora
Mevashel. The and
Biur not ask21forcites
Halacha rain hisbefore sixty
words plainly Eretz
to Yisrael.
the house Butissur
through if heShabbos
intends to return
being that theybefore
actuallythe sixti-
originated
without bringing any opposition.
days from the tekufah. And if they only go home after there. No benefit is had from a Maiseh Shabbos at all.
eth day, while he is in Eretz Yisrael he should ask for rain
Pesach, theythe
However, should
truth isaskthatfor rain
this likeisthe
matter residents
already broached of Eretz
by the in the brachah
He then of shome’a
adds that of coursetefillah. [Thistoisremain
if they were a novella
in thewhich
public
Yisrael.
Rishonim. It all begins with the Gemara in Eiruvin 22 which teaches
he bases on the opinion of the Pri Megadim.]
domain (without being returned to the house) it would be assur to eat
how if fruits were removed from their and later returned, even them. Consuming them there would 12
The sefer Halichos Shlomo10 techum (by Rav Shlomo Zalman The Teshuvos Shevet Levi beisto inclined
do so through the means of
to follow the
if this was done b’mayzid there is no loss to their location. What this issur Shabbos. On the other hand, when returned to the house one can
Auerbach)
means writes
is that even thatwere
if they if areturned
resident of Eretz
b’mayzid Yisrael
it is still trav-
permissible opinion
eat of the
them there Birkei
being that Yosef whoissays
no benefit had that
from it all depends
a Maiseh on
Shabbos.
elled
for them totothe Diasporainand
be consumed their was
place.there on the seventh of where a person is. Thus, a resident of Eretz Yisrael who
What become clear from Tosafos, the Rashba, and Ramban is that
Cheshvan, if he23intends
Tosafos there questionstowhy return to Eretz
the fruits shouldYisrael that win-
be permissible for is in the Diaspora
concerning where onefrom before
actually the seventh
transgresses of Cheshvan
the issur Hotza’ah
ter he should
consumption whenbegin asking
returned for rain
b’mayzid fromthen. It does
outside not make
the techum. We should not
d’oraisa, thereask for rain
it would evenforif he
be assur himintends
to benefittothrough
returnthehome
issur
know that one may
any difference if henotintends
eat foodtowhich
returnwas cooked
before or b’mayzid
after sixty on Maiseh Shabbos.
while it is still winter. And he should not even ask for
Shabbos. He answers that cooking is different because it involves the
days from the
transgression of tekufah.
a Melacha Similarly,
D’oraisaif relating
he doestonot intend His
Shabbos. to rainOnin
thethe brachah
other shome’a
hand, theofRitvah b’shemtefillah. [4]Yonah asserts that
Rabbeinu
intention is to point out how the issur relating to techumin is merely concerning both the issur Hotza’ah and techumin there is no
m’drabbanan. In the case discussed nothing was removed from a application to Maiseh Shabbos. This is because the issur of Maiseh
Notes
Shabbos is something that was initiated where an actual change
private domain into a public one, rather from one techum to another.
Such The Teshuvos
is assurIgros
only Moshe there adds another detail about happens
countriestoother
the object itself.should
than Bavel The term Maiseh
also begin refersthen.
asking to aCertainly,
physical
[3] an act m’drabbanan.
change, and this issur is dubbed Maiseh Shabbos to allude to areas
residents of Eretz Yisrael who are in the Diaspora during the residents of Eretz Yisrael who are temporarily in the Diaspora.
The Chiddushei HaRashba there 24 explains in greater detail. He where physical change happens to an object. However, where all one
time between the seventh of Cheshvan anda the sixtiethD’oraisa
day fromis Accordingly, he concludes that a resident of Eretz Yisrael who
writes that Bishul is different being that Melacha does is transgress the issur Hotza’ah and no change happens to the
the tekufah. The Roshotheris inclined
hand, thetoGemara
say thatiswhen the Gemara objectnot
does intend returning within the year, if he has a wifeofand chil-
16
transgressed. On the discussing a case itself, as such there is no reason to assur because Maiseh
differentiated between Eretz Yisrael and the Diaspora regarding dren in Eretz Yisrael, must begin asking like the residents of Eretz
whether to begin asking for rain on the seventh of Cheshvan or NOTES
Yisrael, like the aforementioned opinion of the Radvaz, since in
NOTES
these places in the Diaspora one should begin asking then.
sixty days from the tekufah, this was only referring to Bavel since
Through this he raises how one who cooks on Shabbos makes the food assur for Now,
As aonconclusion,
the surface this weis would
difficult like
to understand.
to mentionWhenhow the water
oncereturns
the Gaonto its
it is low down
consumption and
just like full
other of moisture,
maichalos assuros. it
Asdoes notfood
such, the need rain forbidden
becomes earlier. [4]
original cold state, it comes out that one isn’t benefitting from the Maiseh Shabbos
to eat even where
of Tshibin was asked by someone who was due to travel during
However, otheronecountries
doesn’t benefit
in thefrom the Bishuldo
Diaspora suchnot
as in a case Bavel,
follow where itand
was at all. As such, it is hard to hear why it should be assur to drink the water then. If
already roasted prior to being cooked. Although he would have preferred to eat thiswarms
one period, if heusing
up water shouldArlahask forKlayim
oil or rain or not.
wood andOne of his
then the waterstudents
gets cold
if they and
roasted neednotrain earlier
cooked they
meat there isEretz
andfollow Yisrael
no real to begin
benefit from theasking on
Melacha, again,
who the isn’t for itthere
wasdinstanding to be interjected
assur to drink.and Oneasked
is allowedthetoGaondrink ifit it
being
wouldthat
the sevenththeofactCheshvan.
nevertheless (See Lehisvaada
of Bishul transforms on daf
the meat into Yud.)food
forbidden Andjustso,like
evenall there is no longer any benefit had from the Arlah or Klayim. This being the case the
be correct for him to say it in the brachah of shome’a tefillah, since if
other maichalos assuros. On the other hand, concerning different forms of benefit same should apply to Maiseh Shabbos as well.
though we do not follow the opinion of the Rosh, and
they are only assur if made possibly purely through the act of Melacha itself.
all the Dias- he was meant to ask for rain, he would fulfil his obligation this way,
pora begin
However, asking
if one for rainofon
was capable the sixtieth
having day from
a certain benefit eventhe tekufah,
before the actthis
was andAsif aheresult,
waswe not are forced to say that something cooked on Shabbos is given the
meant to he would not disqualify his tefillah. The
committed, then such a thing remains permissible. This applies even to food as the status of a maichal issur for the entire day. It doesn’t make a difference then if one
was accepted by the residents of the Diaspora, but not by residents Gaon answered
actually benefits from thatthethisaveirah
person or had
not. come to ask
Therefore, evena question
where theand not
cooking
forbidden status is only given with regard to it consumption and not benefit.
of Eretz Yisrael who travel to the Diaspora. Thus, residents of Eretz just for advice. What you are suggesting to say it in shome’a tefillah
happened through a Goi, since while the water was hot it was assur to drink being
He then continues that although we only find this difference between an issur
that the Goi was his shaliach, as such it becomes assur the entire Shabbos.
Yisrael and
achilah whoissur
are ha’na’ah
staying in the Diaspora
within the words of and intend
Rebbi returning
Yochanan and notwithin
Rebbi is called giving advice. The question that he is asking requires us to
the yearnevertheless
Yehudah, should begin it truthfully
askingapplies
for rainto Rebbi
fromYehudah as well.of Cheshvan,
the seventh This then
answer thathas a practical
either he isapplication
obligatedwhere to askonefor
cooks
rain in barech
water on Shabbos aleinu
for the
or
He then uses this concept to explain what the Beis Yosef 35 asserts b’shem the purpose of bathing. Although in doing so he transgresses an issur Torah,
based on the Rosh who said that even residents of the Diaspora in not. (As heard from Rav Reuvain Krishevsky, shlita)
Rashba. The Beis Yosef discusses a case where one tells a Goi to make a fire and nevertheless since bathing is merely a form of benefit, as such it would be muttar
boil water for him on Shabbos. He writes that if the water got cold it would still be to use the water as soon as it cools down. When cold again there no longer is any
assur for him to drink it. Not only that, if the water had previously been boiled and benefit had from the Maiseh Shabbos. There isn’t reason to say that because it was
then reverted to this state, even to those who hold even by liquids that there is no assur while hot it should be assur the entire Shabbos. This is something said
Bishul after Bishul, nevertheless it would still be assur to drink the water since it was specifically with regard to eating or drinking and not benefit. [See more what he
cooked by a fire on Shabbos. has to say there.]
3
Taanis Daf Yud Aleph
–ב-
A resident of Eretz Yisrael who travels to the Diaspora after the seventh of Cheshvan
An additional reason: that it should not become a farce \ Asking The Teshuvos Shevet Levi14 writes that if he began
in the brachah of shome’a tefillah asking for rain while he was in Eretz Yisrael, and then
– שבט הלוי, ברכי יוסף- travelled to the Diaspora before the sixtieth day from the
בA resident of Eretz Yisrael who began asking for rain tekufah, he should continue asking for rain in the brachah
in Eretz Yisrael on the seventh of Cheshvan, and then of shome’a tefillah, but not in barech aleinu. Because as
travelled to the Diaspora, writes the Birkei Yosef13, even regards that brachah there is no requirement to ask when
though his opinion is that it all depends where he is pres- he is in the Diaspora, but since he is continuing to ask on
ently, nevertheless, since he has already begun asking for behalf of the residents of Eretz Yisrael, the correct place
rain while in Eretz Yisrael, he should continue even when to do so is in the shome’a tefillah.
he is in the Diaspora, since otherwise it will become far-
cical.
מראי מקומות
תפילה פ"ח סעיף י"ט.10 )' סי' ז' (אות ד.9 או"ח ח"ב סי' ק"ב.8 שם סק"ה.7 . דף נ"ב.6 ' אות ז.5 )' סי' קי"ז (אות ה.4 במ"ז סק"א.3 )' סי' קי"ז (אות ב.2 ח"ו סי' ב' אלפים נ"ה.1
' סי' ד.16 . דף י"ט.15 ח"י סי' כ"ג.14 )' שם (אות ו.13 ח"י סי' כ"ב.12 שם סעיף כ"א.11
4
