TORAS AVIGDOR - ENGLISH — Noach (2026-10-12)

פרשת נח
PARSHAS NOACH
TOWER OF BAVEL
RAV AVIGDOR MILLER Part I. The Power of Unity - 1
BASED ON HIS BOOKS, TAPES & WRITINGS OF TALMIDIM Part II. The Danger of Unity - 4
Part III. The Power of Disunity - 7
The Opportunity of Unity
Part I. The Power of Unity
Remember; the people who had come out of the
teivah of Noach were all one family, and even though
The Post-Mabul Plan they intended to repopulate the world, the original
plan was to remain together.
Today, we discuss a mysterious episode in the It was an opportunity for something remarkable
Torah, and that’s the building of the Tower of Bavel. because we know that י˜ים ֲהנָ ָ‡ה ָל ∆הן ַו ֲהנָ ָ‡ה
ƒ ּ„ƒ ˆּ ַ ּכנּ וּס ַלƒ
It’s something that took place in the dim antiquity of – ָלעוֹ ָלםwhen good people come together, it’s a benefit
mankind’s history and it is reported only briefly in for them, and it’s also a benefit for the world (Sanhedrin
the Torah. But despite the brevity, we see that great 71b). First of all, it’s a benefit for them. A community
emphasis is put on this event because ˙‡∆ ˙ֹ‡ל ¿רƒ ַו ≈ ּי ∆ר„ ה׳ of tzaddikim is the most comfortable kind of
מ‚¿ ָ„ּ לƒּ עיר ¿ו ∆‡˙ ַהƒ – ָהHashem came down to view the city community. You’ll always have the best neighbors.
and the tower that they were building (Bereishis 11:5). Everybody is polite, is righteous to each other, and
Of course, when it states that “Hashem came down so it’s good for them. In addition, it’s good for the
to see,” it’s only a form of speech, but such a form of world because when the tzaddikim are a united
speech denotes an especial interest: Hashem was force, that can accomplish things for the world —
very much interested in what was doing there. things that could mold the entire history of mankind.
And so, Noach’s family had no intention of
Now, what did He see? So it states there, הי ָכלƒ ¿ַוי breaking off from each other. Of course, as the
˙ ָ˘ׂ ָפה ∆‡ ָחı – ָה ָ‡ ∆רthe whole land — it means all of population would swell, automatically they would
mankind — had one language. Not only everybody push outwards; it would become a bigger
spoke one language but „יםƒ רים ֲ‡ ָחƒ – ו ¿ּ„ ָבthey all had circumference. It would have been a small family,
common interests (ibid. 1). It means that there were closely knit at the beginning, and later a big family
as yet no national distinctions in diet, in habits, in also closely knit, and later a very big family. But it
manners. Everybody liked similar food, similar would still be the same one family. A wonderful
pursuits and ideals. arrangement; all of mankind should be united.
CHESHVAN SPONSOR
לזכות נתן יוסף בן שהלה תמר חיה
ודבורה בת מלכה
EasyPrint Sponsor
An aliyos neshama for our dear parents
R' Yitzchak ben Chaim & Frimsche bas Shraga Faivish z"l
Mark & Phil Halpern Toronto, Canada
WEALTHinsurance.com
Settling the Great Plains ל ¿˘ׂ ≈ר ָפהƒ – We’ll burn the clay in a kiln, הי ָל ∆הם ַה ּ¿ל ≈בנָ הƒ ˙¿ּ ַו
That’s why after the Mabul it states, הי ¿ ּבנָ ¿ס ָﬠםƒ ¿ַוי – ¿ל ָ‡ ∆בןand we’ll have bricks as artificial stones” (ibid.).
מ ∆ּ˜ ∆„םƒ – they traveled from the east (ibid. 2). It means The Torah emphasizes this because it was a new
the ark stopped on Mount Ararat, somewhere in step in their plan to keep everyone together.
Eastern Turkey, near Armenia, and so when the And now, with this invention in hand, everybody
family exited the teivah, they headed west because got busy and said, “This is the place! A big open plain
they were looking for a suitable spot where the and we have the building materials to make
family would settle and propagate. permanent homes!” ‡מר ּו ¿ – ַו ּ ֹיAnd they said, ¿בנ∆ הƒָה ָבה נ
עירƒ “ – ָּלנ ּוLet’s build for ourselves a city” (ibid. 4). It
˘נ¿ ָﬠרƒ ׁ ıב ¿˜ ָﬠה ¿ ּב ∆‡ ∆רƒ ּי ¿מ ¿ˆ‡ ּוƒ – ַוAnd they found a lowland,
means, “Before we end up scattering, let’s build one
a plain in the land of Shinar, – ַו ≈ ּי ׁ ¿˘ב ּו ׁ ָ˘םand they
big town, a megalopolis.” The city would become
settled there (ibid.). Some of the earliest known
bigger and bigger, and finally, in the course of time,
settlements of mankind are in Iraq. It was called
it would cover the earth; but it would be one city.
“Shinar” in ancient times, or “Sumeria.” We call it
“Bavel” as we’ll see later in the Torah. They chose as The No-Scatter Tower
their place a bikah in the area of Iraq.
And then something came up, an additional idea.
Now, bikah sometimes is translated as “valley,” And that was to build that famous tower, the Migdal
but here it means what the Gemara uses the word Bavel. Now, not much is told about the plan. מ‚¿ ָ„ּ לƒ
for. Bikah is what they call a great plain. They found ׁ – ¿ורIt would be a tower whose top should be
םƒֹ‡˘וֹ ַ ּב ּ ׁ ָ˘ ַמי
a large lowland, a level land. That’s what Bavel is; up to the heavens, ı ַﬠל ּ ¿פנ≈ י ָכל ָה ָ‡ ∆רıּ – ּ ∆פן נָ פוlest we
Iraq is a level land without mountains. scatter over the face of the earth. That was their
Now, a plainland has certain advantages. There slogan: ıּ – ּ ∆פן נָ פוLest we scatter!
are no natural barriers, no mountains or deep valleys Because they knew what would happen. Some
that naturally separate communities. And so a city people would scatter to the north, some to the
could expand outward without having to scatter south, and they’ll be different nations; they’ll become
and separate. And that’s why they left the mountains estranged from each other, they’ll become hostile,
of the East and settled in Bavel. and eventually there’ll be big wars. And so the idea
of a tall tower was introduced; a central point that
Affordable Housing for All
would keep the growing population focused on the
Now, they were still using the contraption that ideal of unity.
the children of Kayin had invented — a portable tent
Now, the Medrash (Bereishis Rabbah 38:6) says a
— and they lived a nomadic culture. Any family could
queer thing, that the people said, “Let’s make a tower
easily pack together their tents and then move on
to hold up the sky. The sky shouldn’t cave in.” But
somewhere to greener pastures. And that’s why,
people who learn the Midrashim in a simple way
י˘ ∆‡ל ≈ר ≈ﬠה ּו ¿ – ַו ּיthey began to discuss ways and
ׁ ‡ƒ ֹ‡מר ּו
with their plain meaning are misled. It doesn’t mean
means of remaining together (ibid. 3). And so they
that at all. You have to read something into the
decided that it’s important to build permanent
Medrash. It’s telling us that a theory was proposed.
homes.
But in Shinar, you don’t have mountains, and if The Insurance Policy
you don’t have mountains there’s a dearth of building We’ll see soon who exactly the theoretician was,
stones. And without stones, you cannot build but the theory was promulgated as follows: ַ‡ ַח˙ ¿ל ∆‡ ∆לף
permanent houses. And so at that time they fell ַ ˜ƒ “ – ¿ו˙רנ״ו ׁ ָ˘נָ ה ָה ָרWe have statistics,” he
מ ¿˙מוֹ ≈טטƒ יﬠ
upon the idea of the invention of brick-making. ָה ָבה said, “and we know that at the end of sixteen hundred
יםƒ ¿ל ¿ ּבנָ ה ¿ל ≈בנƒ“ – נLet’s take clay and make bricks. ¿˘ׂ ¿ר ָפהƒ¿ונ and fifty-six years from Creation there was a
2 / TORAS AVIGDOR . PARSHAS NOACH . TOWER OF BAVEL
commotion in nature and a watery catastrophe a tremendous tower, and every great movement can
covered the earth. And so we have to consider the be judged by its leaders. It’s important.
possibility of recurrence. Maybe it’s a natural cycle
And the answer is revealed to us by the Torah
and it’ll happen again.” And therefore, in the language
She’baal Peh, by the Oral Law, but we have hints of it
of the Medrash, “Let’s make a tower to hold up the
in the Written Torah, too. In the Written Torah, in
sky.” It means, if there’s going to be a catastrophe,
the previous chapter, something is told to us about
we have to be ready. Because what’s going to happen
a character named Nimrod. The truth is a good deal
when a big flood comes? People will scatter to seek
is related about this character; and it’s remarkable
safety.
because the Torah speaks so briefly of the ancient
And therefore, in order to keep true to the plan generations, and yet it gives attention to Nimrod.
of Noach and his sons and all of the other great
leaders of the hundreds of years since then, an idea A Mighty Hunter
was put forward to build a tower to demonstrate And here’s what the Torah tells us about this
right here, this is the heart of the city and we have character: “Cush gave birth to Nimrod, and he began
to encircle it. And even if a flood or a different to be a mighty man, a hero, in the world” (Bereishis
natural disaster will wipe out the entire city and no 10:8). You hear that? He was a big politician. And
vestiges remain, at least the tower will still be here, that’s only one of the trappings of his career. He was
and everyone will know where to come back to in a great leader in general.
order to resettle in unity around it.
And he was a „ ƒ ּ‚ ּבוֹ ר ַˆיƒ too. He became a mighty
The Trumped-Up Tower hunter. In those days, a mighty hunter was a leader.
That’s why the kings of India became famous for
Now, what glamour will this tower have as a
their prowess in hunting lions. In those days, a lion
symbol of the center of the city if there’s nothing
wasn’t an ornamental creature; they weren’t yet in
divine about it? So you can be sure that they put on
the zoos. They were a big nuisance, a menace to
top some kind of a symbol of divinity, some kind of a
mankind. Lions and tigers were man-eaters
sacred object. After all, people can’t be atheists.
sometimes. So the Indian rulers — the people were
They have to worship something.
grateful to them when they destroyed a certain
Now, exactly what it was, it wasn’t as crass, it man-eater who used to attack villages. They were
wasn’t as simple as idolatry in the way we understand. grateful to the king who had prowess.
There’s no question it was more sublimated; they
put an image there as a representative of the Most A Mighty Builder
High, like Shem said, “Kel Elyon.” That’s all; quite And we know that he was involved in building
innocent. In the course of time, there were people big cities. He was a beneficiary of mankind. You
who worshipped it and bowed down to it, but it’s need that, someone who’s a doer, an accomplisher.
quite possible that it wasn’t presented in that way. He built Erech and Akkad and Kalneh. Akkad is
The purpose was to unify the world. Akkadia, one of the big cities of antiquity. Kalneh is
in the land of Shinar. And from that land he went
The Unity Leaders
forth to Ashur and he built Nineveh. Nineveh! A
Now, it pays to discover who was the leading famous city. And he built Rechovos Ir. And he built
spirit of this plan to keep the people unified by Kalach and Resen, an ancient city called Ctesiphon
means of building a tower. After all, this ideal of — Aktisfon in the Gemara (Yoma 10a). These are
unity had been developed over hundreds of years by famous cities from the earliest antiquity, and the
great people, but this was a new development now, Torah wants us to know this about this Nimrod; he
3 / TORAS AVIGDOR . PARSHAS NOACH . TOWER OF BAVEL
began to organize society around his good proclaimed it as a banner to rally around. Because
endeavors. it’s a legitimate motive: We shouldn’t scatter; we
Now, in this story of the Migdal he’s not should remain one family.
mentioned by name, but we understand he was the But the next idea — that they didn’t proclaim:
one who was interested in promoting the scheme. “ – ¿ונַ ֲﬠ ָ˘ׂ ה ָלנ ּו ׁ ≈˘םand we’ll make for ourselves a name.”
We can prove it from the Written Torah too, from This was said by some of the organizers inside of
clues, but we don’t have to because that’s what our their minds. Because ֹ‡מר ∆ ַו ּיin lashon kodesh many
Sages tell us, that the leading spirit in the plan of times means to think. I can prove that by citations
building a city and the tower was this person, from elsewhere, but to save time, maybe you’ll take
Nimrod. my word for it. The words “Let’s make for ourselves a
name,” they didn’t publicize.
Keeping an Eye Out
The Power Tower
He was the most capable because he was famous
as a great and mighty hunter, a hero, a builder of Which means that they were promoting this
cities, and a big politician. – ַﬠל ≈ּכן י≈ ָ‡ ַמרAnd therefore, scheme because they wanted glory and power. They
it was said, „ֹ ¿מרƒ – ¿ּכנif you want to compare somebody, said, “Lest we scatter,” but you have to put those
a big k’nocker, you’d say, “He’s like Nimrod, „ ƒ ּ‚ ּבוֹ ר ַˆיƒ – words into his mouth, “ – ¿ונַ ֲﬠ ָ˘ׂ ה ָלנ ּו ׁ ≈˘םwe’ll make for
He is a great and mighty hunter” (Bereishis 10:9). ourselves a name.” It means we’ll gain control.
But then the possuk adds, 'ל ¿פנ≈ י הƒ – in the presence Of course Nimrod used good words. ıּפן נָ פו, ∆ ּ holy
of Hashem. What does “in the presence of Hashem” words. Achdus! Togetherness! Don’t you see the
mean? Isn’t everything in Hashem’s presence? It liberal Marxists today using smooth words:
means Hashem had an eye on him already. Hashem “Equality!” “Workers of the world unite!” “We’re all
was looking at this man. Because when a man is brothers!” “Social justice!” Beautiful. But the truth is
becoming important, you have to keep an eye on that all these reformers who ride in on white steeds
him because he has two great potentials: for good or and claim that they came to unite humanity, their
for evil. words are as hollow as could be. They’re posturing
for the press, for the public, money and glory. Only
that they come with expressions of nobility to trap
Part II. The Danger of Unity
the masses. And so there’s no question that the
proposers of the tower did it with beautiful words.
Words and Thoughts
Now, the question is, what could be the evil The One Rebel
here? It sounds like something wonderful, to keep Now, at that time there was a young man who
people united! So we have to realize when the Torah lived there whose name was Avram. And while
reports a certain episode, it doesn’t mean all of the everybody was enthusiastic over this new
things that are put in their mouths were said by development in this plan of unity — everyone was
them. Some things they say for themselves but some speaking about all the benefits that this national
things were only thoughts. We have to try to discover plan would bring to mankind and all the important
which are the things that they said, and which are people and all the patriots joined in — Avraham
the things that are attributed to them. Avinu didn’t jump on the bandwagon. Everybody
Now, Nimrod and his cohorts said why they followed the crowd except this young fellow.
wanted to do this. And ostensibly the reason was “ּ ∆פן Like it says (Bereishis 14:13), “Avraham HaIvri.”
ıּ – נָ פוlest we scatter over the face of the earth.” And Why is he called “Ivri”? Ivri means a man who’s only
we understand that they said those words; they on one side. – ׁ ∆˘ ָּכל ָהעוֹ ָלם ≈מ ≈ﬠ ∆בר ָל ∆זהThe whole world
4 / TORAS AVIGDOR . PARSHAS NOACH . TOWER OF BAVEL
was on one side, – ¿ו ַ‡ ¿ב ָר ָהם ≈מ ≈ﬠ ∆בר ַה ּ∆זהand Avraham was he grabbed people by the lapel and he said to them,
on the other side (Bereishis Rabbah 42:8). One man “Don’t listen to Nimrod. He’s the wrong uniter-in-
against the whole world. That’s how it was in the chief.”
beginning and that’s how it will always be until the They said, “Shh! Don’t talk loud. Come in the
end. The Jews are on their own; all alone they stand alley and tell us about it.” But it was too important to
against the world. That’s their job. They don’t follow hush it up.
the crowd.
Nimrod the Bulldozer
And so our Sages (Avodah Zarah 18b) tell us on
the first verse in Tehillim, ˙ˆַ י˘ ֲ‡ ׁ ∆˘ר ל ֹ‡ ָה ַל ¿ך ַ ּב ֲﬠ ׁ ‡ƒ ַ‡ ׁ ¿˘ ≈רי ָה Now, Nimrod wasn’t the kind of man to let a
עיםƒ ˘ָ ׁ — ¿רhow fortunate is the man who did not walk nincompoop, a little nobody, stand in his way. He
in the plan of the wicked ones, that ‡ֹבינ ּו ׁ ∆˘ ּלƒ ‡ָ ∆זה ַ‡ ¿ב ָר ָהם would bulldoze anyone who would oppose him. And
– ָה ַל ¿ך ַ ּב ֲﬠ ַˆ˙ ַ‡נ¿ ׁ ≈˘י „ּ וֹ ר ַה ¿פ ָל‚ָ הit’s speaking about Avraham so when he heard people speaking about this young
who did not go in the plan of his generation who fellow he got irritated and tried to get rid of him.
wanted to build the tower. Because when he saw That’s the story of Ur Kasdim, the fire-furnace.
what the idea was and who the leader was, he saw You know, when Avraham was finally thrown
what the results might be of misutilizing the ideal of into the fire, it’s not as simple as you think — that
unity and he expressed his opposition. Nimrod said, “Worship my gods,” and Avraham said,
“No.” It was this plan of Nimrod that was the catalyst.
Now, if Avraham Avinu would be the president,
Nimrod already heard people speaking about this
the ruler of that new metropolis, yes. He would
troublemaker and he warned Avraham, “I’m giving
influence the people to yiras Hashem, to seeing
you one last chance to get on board with the plan. I
Hashem in the briyah, to the service of Hashem. But
won’t let you ruin happiness for everyone because
Nimrod? Instead of the influence that people are
of your stubbornness. If you can’t join us, I’ll put you
supposed to gain from Hakadosh Baruch Hu, he
in a hot seat.”
would influence his own personality on them. And
so Avraham spoke up. And even though Avraham escaped that danger,
but how long could a young man persist like that?
The Disuniter How long could he last if everybody would carry out
It wasn’t easy because he was considered a that unity plan to fruition? A monolithic society
lunatic by his neighbors. Like in some communities ruled by a tyrant? They’d crush him! He’s only one
today if you express doubts about the value of the man, after all. Hakadosh Baruch Hu saw it would be
State of Israel, so they’re shocked. They open a pair impossible for Avraham to do anything in such a
of big eyes: “You don’t believe in the State of Israel? society, but Avraham was a gem; and therefore, to
You mean you’re not a Zionist? What kind of a Jew save that gem, He came down. That was the purpose:
are you?” ' – ַו ≈ ּי ∆ר„ הHashem came down to rescue the truth, to
rescue the future Jewish nation that was there in
And that’s how they looked at Avraham when he
the person of Avraham.
refused to follow the crowd. Everybody was
shouting, “Join! Follow Nimrod, the great benefactor! Nipping It in the Bud
Everybody together! One family! One nation! One ∆ – ַו ּיHashem said, „“ – ≈הן ַﬠם ∆‡ ָחThey are one
'ֹ‡מר ה
world!” But Avraham said, “Nothing doing. Don’t people.” – ¿ו ָ˘ׂ ָפה ַ‡ ַח˙ ¿ל ֻכ ָּלםAnd they all have one
join,” he said. “It’s too dangerous. The wrong man is language, ˙ ֹח ָּלם ַל ֲﬠ˘ׂ וƒ – ¿ו ∆זה ַהand this they’re beginning
in power.” to do. It means it’s not what they did that’s so
And Avraham wasn’t the kind of fellow to keep blameworthy. It’s what they’re going to do in the
his ideas to himself. He went out on the street and future. “I just recently made a cleaning of the world
5 / TORAS AVIGDOR . PARSHAS NOACH . TOWER OF BAVEL
with the Mabul. I washed the world clean of all the of developing their own languages. It was considered
sinners, and now I see there's something new, a plan by them a chochmah and because they lived very
to consolidate all of humanity into one family under long lives they had the opportunity to do it. When
the wrong people. – ¿ו ַﬠ ָּ˙הTherefore now, ָ ּב ≈ˆר ≈מ ∆הםƒלֹ‡ י people live for hundreds of years and they don’t age
˙ ֹ – ּכֹל ֲ‡ ׁ ∆˘ר יָ ¿זמ ּו ַל ֲﬠ˘ׂ וthere wouldn’t be withheld from until the end, they can accomplish tremendous
them anything that they desire to do (Bereishis 11:6). things that are far beyond what the greatest men of
When you’re united, you can do anything. the subsequent times could do. Because after a
And therefore, Hakadosh Baruch Hu had to certain stage, you begin to go faster; you pick up
break it up. עים ֲהנָ ָ‡ה ָל ∆הן ַו ֲהנָ ָ‡ה ָלעוֹ ָלםƒ ˘ָ ׁ פ ּזוּר ָל ¿רƒ ּ – For momentum. Today, a person grows old, and before
wicked people, it’s better that they should be scattered he can accomplish tremendous things, he’s senile,
(Sanhedrin 71b). Like a gang of crooks who want to and he’s finished. But if you can live 400 years, you
make a holdup, but before they come to the bank, can really go someplace with your wisdom. And
they get in a fight among themselves and they all go these men who were men of genius, people with
home and remain alive. The fight was good for them abilities far beyond what existed in mankind
because otherwise the bank guards might have shot subsequently, they put their wisdom to work and
them down. And it’s good for the bank guards and over hundreds of years they began fashioning new
the bank customers, too. languages.
So disunity among the wicked is good for They weren’t operative, however; they were
everyone. And therefore, Hashem said, “Let Me now theoretical languages like Esperanto. They were
come down and rescue the future of mankind by developed but nobody would actually use them
confusing their languages.” because they all understood it was imperative to be
together; they didn’t want to do anything that might
The Mystery of Languages
crack the human family into sections. But it was
Now, how it happened is a mystery because there, lurking in the background, for Hashem to use
languages don’t develop overnight. Even a hundred when it would be needed.
years is not time enough to develop any language.
But according to the pashtus of the possuk, something Dissension Begins
happened — somehow their languages became Now, as long as they were together, it didn’t
diversified and because of that, their unity was come to a head. But when Nimrod was finally making
broken up and the whole plan came to naught. They the plans to keep all mankind together forever, then
gave up the plan to build the city and scattered over Hakadosh Baruch Hu put it into their minds that
the face of the earth. each one should say, “Why not my language?” At
Now, the following is my own idea, and nobody that time Hashem caused these people to come
has to accept it. And if you’ll prove to me you have a forward and say, “You want to make one nation?
better idea or that it’s wrong, I withdraw it without Let’s adopt my language as the language of the
any hesitation. But in the meantime, this is what I nation.”
think is pshat: The people in those generations lived
But somebody else said, “Look, Nimrod, I’m all
very long lives. And during these ten generations
for your idea. Certainly, we should build the tower
when people still lived very long Hashem had done
and be one family. But what about my language?”
something; He had planted a seed.
Each innovator had reasons for preferring his
The Seed Sprouts own invention. After all, each language has its own
Hakadosh Baruch Hu put an idea into the heads beauty. Aramaic has certain beautiful overtones.
of some of the wise men to think of ambitious plans The Gemara says for elegy, Aramaic is beautiful. For
6 / TORAS AVIGDOR . PARSHAS NOACH . TOWER OF BAVEL
certain forms of poetry, the Gemara says that Greek But actually you were prophesying what’s going to
is more beautiful (Yerushalmi Megillah 1:9). happen, that I’m going to bring confusion in that
place.” And I tell you, – ַﬠל ≈ּכןthat’s why, ָ˜ ָר‡ ׁ ¿˘מוֹ ָ ּב ∆בל
Scattering Begins
– I motivated you to give that name Bavel. It should
And therefore, those people who had perfected be a memorial forever. Bav-Bel, that’s nothing; that’s
their own languages over ten generations, each one for the dumb archeologists. But actually – ַﬠל ≈ּכןit’s
wanted his language. And at that time a squabble because of this. It’s of the greatest importance to
arose, and there became a disunity, and the plan know that when wicked people get together, it’s a
broke up. The dissension between the various danger for the world and it’s vital to frustrate that
proposers caused the plan to fall apart and the union.
people began to separate. “My way or the highway,”
A leader, a king, is a wonderful thing — if he’s
they said.
good. Everybody is united. One leader with power.
And that’s why Nimrod left Shinar. It says ıמן ָה ָ‡ ∆רƒ It’s efficient. You can accomplish things that you
‡הוƒ – ַהFrom that land, – יָ ָˆ‡ ַ‡ ּ ׁ˘וּרhe went out to couldn’t do otherwise. But when the king goes
Ashur. He forsook Shinar because the plan fell wrong, there’s nothing as harmful, as dangerous, as
through. He went to a different place and there he a bad king.
started a different plan; he built big cities and he
prospered. But his first plan to be a leader of all of Scattered Jews
mankind fell through.
And that’s the reason why we are scattered in
exile today. In Eretz Yisroel, under the righteous
Part III. The Power of Disunity kings, everybody kept the Torah. But when we were
together in Eretz Yisroel and wrong people gained
The True Name of Bavel power and they had power over the entire Jewish
Now, how important was this confusion of nation, it was a disaster.
languages for the future of mankind? How important
In the times of King Menashe, he was corrupting
was it to break up the unity of irresponsible people?
the nation. It says, – ַו ∆ ּי ַ˙ע ¿מנַ ּ ׁ ∆˘ה ∆‡˙ י¿ הו ָּ„הhe caused the
So it’s interesting to note that the end of this story,
nation of Yehudah to go astray (Divrei Hayamim II
it says, – ַﬠל ≈ּכן ָ˜ ָר‡ ׁ ¿˘מוֹ ָ ּב ∆בלAnd therefore — because
33:9). Not everybody, but he had a very bad influence,
of this confusion, the fight over languages — they
however; because the king has power. That’s why
called the place Bavel (Bereishis 11:9). Bavel is from
the kings ceased. Hashem broke up the nation, they
balal, to “mix up” the language.
went into exile, and no more kings. Now the Sages
Now, everyone knows that it’s not that simple regained control.
because Bavel is not balal — Bavel is one word and
balal, to confuse and mix up, is something else. But Breaking Up Unity
listen now to this important rule: When the Torah Same thing in the Second Beis Hamikdash. The
says, “ – ַﬠל ≈ּכןand therefore,” the Torah is telling us it’s Tzedukim, the Sadducees, gained power. The
not like you think. The academicians and the apikorsim, the people who didn’t know Torah, didn’t
historians think they know: Bavel means “Bav-Bel”; want to know Torah, and they despised the Torah
they had an idol called Bel and they called that place Sages — they gained power, and they were corrupting
Bav-Bel, the gateway of Bel. That’s why they gave it the nation. Of course, the nation still was very good
a name. despite them. But the time had come to get rid of
So along comes the Torah and says, “You thought them. And therefore, Hashem broke it all up. The
at that time that’s the reason you’re giving it a name. Romans came. We went away to other countries,
7 / TORAS AVIGDOR . PARSHAS NOACH . TOWER OF BAVEL
and from then on, nobody was able to gain power We can’t afford such a dangerous thing. So
over the entire Jewish nation. therefore, it’s not advisable we should all get
If the Jews had been capable of living together in together. We’ll get together when Moshiach comes,
Eretz Yisroel under pious leaders, under the Sages, when there’ll be a tzaddik, a man who keeps the
they would have remained there to this day. But Torah at the head. Yes. Then we should all stream to
because the wrong people gained power, therefore Eretz Yisroel. But right now, it’s a very big sakanah
Hakadosh Baruch Hu gave the order: “Scatter!” for all Jews to get together under the wrong head.
American Unity
Scattered and Safe
Even here, the American Jewish Congress, it
And now we’re protected. If in one town, in one
seemed like such a good idea; all the Jewish
country, in one continent, wicked people gain power
organizations should unite. It’s not such a good idea,
over the Jews, so there are Jews elsewhere who are
however. Because when Jewish reshaim get together,
safe from wicked leaders. Let’s say when wicked
it’s bad for the Jewish people.
Jews gained power in Russia. There were a lot of
Jews in Russia, three million Jews, but the Communist What did they vote on at their last convention?
Jews, the Yevsektsiya, gained power, and they ruined That they have to fight to not allow the government
the Russian Jews. to give a penny to yeshivas. Lubavitch, other Jews,
sent a petition: “Please, don’t! We need money. We’re
The Russian Jews were once the best Jews in the
saving boys.” Lubavitch is saving boys from the
world. You Sephardic Jews will excuse me for saying
gutter all over America. They’re taking narcotics
that, but it’s true — Russian Jews were once the best
addicts and rehabilitating them, making mentchen
Jews in the world. There was so much Torah, so
out of them. The frum day schools, the Beis Yaakov
much yiras Hashem. Not long ago! And then when
schools, they’re taking in girls and teaching them
the wrong leaders came, they smothered everything
decency. And the Congress was willing to give them
with a blanket.
money! The government was already handing out
But there were other Jews all over the world. the money! But the American Jewish Congress and
Hakadosh Baruch Hu had caused us to scatter and the Anti-Defamation League, and some more of
so there were Syrian Jews and there were Egyptian these big organizations, got together to fight it.
Jews. There were some Jews in England and also in They said, “If we’ll allow that, church and state won’t
America who were keeping the Torah. Oh, that saved be separated anymore. It’ll be a wedge.”
us! Now, our Sages, the great Torah leaders, they
And that’s why breaking up the wicked is good. know all about church and state. You assimilated
When Communist Russia broke up, it was a very Jews, don’t worry about it. The Torah leaders know
great benefit for the world. Like it states in Mizmor all about it and they said, “Don’t worry about church
Shir L’Yom HaShabbos: ' – ¿ו ַ‡ ָּ˙ה ָמרוֹ ם ¿לע ָֹלם הWhen are and state. It’s still America.”
You, Hashem, elevated? ¿˙ ּ ָפ ¿ר„ ּו ָּכל ּפ ֲֹﬠ ≈לי ָ‡ ∆וןƒ – יWhen all And the American Congress was willing to give
those who do wickedness scatter. the yeshivas money. They voted already! But these
“tzaddikim,” they want to defend the Constitution.
United for Torah
They want to be more constitutional than the
To come together like the plan of the Zionists Americans are.
now — all Jews should come to Israel — and who
should be the president? An atheist. A man who United We Close
doesn’t put on tefillin, who doesn’t eat kosher, he עיםƒ ˘ָ ׁ ּכנּ וּס ָל ¿רƒ – When the wrong people get together,
should be a leader of Jews. – ַרע ָל ∆הם ¿ו ַרע ָלעוֹ ָלםit’s a terrible thing for everyone!
8 / TORAS AVIGDOR . PARSHAS NOACH . TOWER OF BAVEL
They have prestige, they have power, they can hire I’m afraid even some Modern Orthodox Rabbis,
the biggest lawyers. They went to the Supreme too, they tell their congregations when they come
Court and won. And now if a poor boy wants to go to together, they say, “It’s togetherness that counts.”
yeshiva, the principal says, “How can I take in more That’s a word that they all like; achdus, togetherness.
boys? I can’t even pay my regular teachers. I’m a So they’re sitting together, the ladies and the men,
half-year behind in salaries now, so how can you and they’re munching, they’re eating. There’s a
expect me to take you in? You can’t fit in a regular church supper, a synagogue supper. And they’re
class. I need another teacher.” What can he do? enjoying themselves.
And when the boy goes away, so people think the Once, in a certain city where I used to be, I was
yeshiva is hard-hearted, that they’re selfish for invited to come and represent my congregation in a
money. But they don’t realize that the teachers union of all the congregations of the city. So I said I
haven’t been paid for six months! They’re idealists. can’t; a union would be good if it would be under the
But even idealists have to pay rent, they have to pay right people, but since it’s not under the right
the grocer. people, we’re better off without union.
And they’re turning away children. There’s so And that’s the lesson we have to learn: Don’t join
many classes that could have been organized for unless you know that tzaddikim are at the head of it.
children that start to learn late. All we need is a few Otherwise, union is the greatest disaster.
more pennies from the government. “Oh no,” they
Coming Down for Avraham
said. “It’s dangerous.”
And now we come back to that significant
And therefore, we see the great principle: that
statement in our sedrah: ˙ ֹל ¿ר‡וƒ – ַו ≈ ּי ∆ר„ ה׳Hashem came
we’d be much better off without such unity. All these
down to see. Hashem didn’t have to come down. He
organizations, the best thing would be if they united
could see from a big distance. But the Torah writes
together and closed their offices. It would be the
it anyhow to let you know that this was not an
biggest favor to the world. When the wicked break
unimportant event.
up their organizations, their unity, so it's ¿ו ַ‡ ָּ˙ה ָמרוֹ ם
The fact is, at Matan Torah, on that great day, a
' – הit’s a kavod for Hashem because now the good
similar expression is used. It states, סינַ יƒ ַו ≈ ּי ∆ר„ ה׳ ַﬠל ַהר
ones can accomplish more.
– Hashem came down on Har Sinai (Shemos 19:20).
Synagogue Unity And if we have here a similar expression, you
Unity is a great thing! But it depends who says it. understand that the Torah wants you to know that it
And all these beautiful words, we have to watch out was something of very big importance, something
who is saying them and why he’s saying them. like סינַ יƒ ( ַו ≈ ּי ∆ר„ ה׳ ַﬠל ַהרsee Avos D’Rabi Nosson 34:6).
Suppose a Reform rabbi is telling his people, “We Coming Down for Am Yisroel
need unity,” he says. “And here I see lately a man And if we’ll understand it properly, we shall see
with a beard in this town of ours, and he’s trying to that one couldn’t be without the other. There would
organize a minyan. That’s disunity. It’s not harmony. never have been a Torah — there wouldn’t have been
We have to see that we don’t allow him to do that. a סינַ יƒ — ַו ≈ ּי ∆ר„ ה׳ ַﬠל ַהרif there hadn’t been ˙ ֹל ¿ר‡וƒ ַו ≈ ּי ∆ר„ ה׳
We want everybody united in our Reform – Hashem came down to take a look at this tower. And
congregation.” so this 'ו ≈ ּי ∆ר„ ה,ַ that’s the preface to סינַ יƒ ו ≈ ּי ∆ר„ ה׳ ַﬠל ַהר.ַ
Oh, it depends what kind of unity you want. You Hakadosh Baruch Hu came down to take a look
know, the wolf says to the lamb, “Let’s have unity. I’ll because He understood that union under the wrong
eat you up and we’ll be one.” So it depends what your leaders is very dangerous. There never would have
idea of unity was. been a Torah if this affair would have been carried
9 / TORAS AVIGDOR . PARSHAS NOACH . TOWER OF BAVEL
out successfully — because there never would have
been an Avraham.
It’s one of the great lessons of this ancient story
of the Dor Haflagah. עיםƒ ˘ָ ׁ ּכנּ וּס ָל ¿רƒ – When the wrong
people get together, it’s a terrible thing! The kiyum, QUESTION
the existence of the Holy Nation depends very much There’s a halacha that we’re not allowed to think
Torah thoughts when we’re using the bathroom.
on being united only under the influence and control
So what should we think?
of the Torah Sages. י˜ים ֲהנָ ָ‡ה ָל ∆הן ַו ֲהנָ ָ‡ה ָלעוֹ ָלם
ƒ ּ„ƒ ˆּ ַ ּכנּ וּס ַלƒ
– when good people come together, it’s a benefit for ANSWER
them, and it’s also a benefit for the world. And
You should think what a chessed it is that you’re
anything else, any other unity, is dangerous for the able to go to the bathroom. Think about that. Think
future of the Am Yisroel. about the chasdei Hashem, yes. It’s a tremendous
chessed what takes place in your body.
Have a Wonderful Shabbos
Your kidneys are miracle laboratories. Your
kidneys are able to take a small amount of blood and
Feeling inspired & uplifted? continually cleanse it. When people, chalilah, don’t
Help spread that feeling to Jews everywhere! have kidneys, they have to go for dialysis a few times
a week on artificial kidneys for hours and hours.
Toras Avigdor strives to spread Rav Miller's Torah &
What the kidneys do in a few minutes, you need
hashkafah freely around the world, supported only
by idealists like YOU who are looking to bring yidden artificial kidneys to work for hours and hours on
closer to Hashem. you. And those people who don’t have kidneys are
so jealous of you. “Oooh — if I only had one kidney,”
Join this movement NOW!
they say, “Just one kidney!” And they’re trying hard
torasavigdor.org/give 732-844-3670 to get a kidney. There are thousands of people lined
up for spare kidneys.
And it’s miraculous, too. ˙ ֹלי‡ ַל ֲﬠ˘ׂ וƒ ַמ ¿פmeans that
Let’s Get Practical it’s miraculous, the process of the body eliminating
wastes. The mefarshim sometimes didn’t understand
Unite and Untie it and so there are all kinds of peirushim on ‡ליƒ ַמ ¿פ
In this week’s parsha, Hakadosh Baruch Hu ˙ ֹ( ַל ֲﬠ˘ׂ וsee Tur, Orach Chaim 6) but today we know
the process of elimination, pshuto k’mashmao, is
“descends” to foil the plans of Nimrod and his
simply miracles of miracles.
followers, thereby ensuring that the world would
If you would study how the body is able to absorb
not end up being unified under the banner of
all the essential parts of the food through the lining
anything other than Hashem. This week, bli neder,
of the tubes of the intestines, and leave over only
when reciting the words v’kabetzeinu yachad in the waste material, you’d see it’s a miracle as clear
Shemoneh Esrei, I will have in mind that we yearn to as day. And as your body absorbs the food it
be drawn together only in the service of our Creator. transforms it into thousands of different materials.
And so in the bathroom we’re so happy Hakadosh
Baruch Hu is doing this miracle for us. “Ah! What an
This week’s booklet is based on tapes: operation He’s performing on me right now.”
1 - Singing in the World | 94 - The Jesters | 145 - Tower of Bavel And that way, when you get out and make the
526 - Avraham Appears | Pirkei Avos - 69
bracha, you’ll put all the thoughts that you had in
the bathroom now into the words. That’s called
Listen to the original lectures of Rav Miller zatzal
going to the bathroom successfully.
on the Mipihu Phone Line
USA: 718-400-7220 | Israel: 778509304 | UK: 3303505768 September 7, 2000
Mipihu is a project of Yeshiva Gedolah Beis Yisroel - Rav Miller’s Yeshivah
10 / TORAS AVIGDOR . PARSHAS NOACH . TOWER OF BAVEL
