Kollel Lihoraah - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

Parshas Noach
5787
Ask the Rav
Common Shabbos Questions When Preparing a Bar Mitzvah Kiddush cup, or is there a concern of boneh?
A: It appears to me that lechatchilah, plastic cups of the type used for cut
Folding Napkins into Decorative Shapes fruit and similar foods, in which the upper cup is attached to a long stem
or base, should be assembled before Shabbos. If, however, one forgot to
Q: Is it permissible to prepare napkins in decorative shapes on Shabbos, prepare them before Shabbos, one who is lenient and assembles them on
and if so, in what manner? Shabbos has whom to rely upon.
The basis for permitting this bedieved can be found in the words of the
A: Regarding the general halachos of folding on Shabbos, see the Mish- Beis Yosef (siman 317), that when a utensil consists of two parts, they
nah in Maseches Shabbos (113a) and Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 302:3). It may be attached without a concern of tikkun mana when they are regu-
emerges that one should refrain from folding paper napkins on Shabbos larly intended to be taken apart. Additionally, some maintain that when
into specific decorative shapes, such as a flower and the like, when the an item is intended only for one-time use, there is no concern of tikkun
folds are made firmly. However, simple folds made merely for decora- mana. Accordingly, these disposable cups, in which the upper portion is
tive purposes, without forming any particular recognizable shape, such attached to the stem that serves as its base, may be assembled on Shab-
as accordion-style folds, are permitted. Even in a case where one should bos. Some question this reasoning based upon the Gemara in Maseches
refrain from making such shapes on Shabbos, if they were prepared be- Beitzah (33b), which states that one who cuts a piece of wood to use as a
fore Shabbos, they may be opened on Shabbos, and there is no concern toothpick is liable, even though he will use it only once and then discard
of soser. In the sefer Shemiras Shabbos Kehilchasah (Chapter 11:41), he it. If the fact that an object will be thrown away after one use is sufficient
writes that making such shapes resembles boneh, even though they are grounds for leniency, why is making such a toothpick prohibited because
intended to be taken apart that same day. See also there (Chapter 16, of tikkun mana? In truth, however, the case of the toothpick is different.
footnote 61), where he distinguishes this from Lego pieces. With Lego, There, one is physically modifying the toothpick itself and thereby creat-
the construction has no significance as a true act of building since it is ing a new utensil. Since a toothpick is by nature made for a single use,
made as a children’s toy, whereas these types of constructions are also preparing it for that use constitutes the complete creation of the utensil.
made by adults. Attaching two parts of an already existing utensil, however, neither re-
Regarding what we wrote that there is no prohibition against making pairs nor alters the actual body of the utensil. The utensil is created
ordinary decorative folds, see Mishnah Berurah (se’if katan 18), who merely through joining its two components. Therefore, when the attach-
explains that since such a fold is not intended to last, it is not included in ment is loose, the assembly is not considered the creation of a utensil
the prohibition of mesaken and is permitted, this seems to be the psak unless the parts are being attached permanently. Those who are lenient
halacha one can rely on and doesn’t need to be stringent like the oppos- therefore rely upon the fact that the connection is not intended to endure,
ing opinions. See also Shu”t Be’er Moshe, Vol. VIII (siman 134), and and consequently it is not considered the final act in creating the utensil.
Shu”t Shevet HaLevi, Vol. V (siman 35). Even if the assembled cup is thrown directly into the garbage after use
Regarding paper napkins that were folded in a simple manner before without actually separating its two components, there is room for lenien-
Shabbos and were subsequently opened, it is permissible to refold them cy, since the person has no interest or need whatsoever for the two parts
on Shabbos in their original manner, since folding paper does not in- to remain attached.
volve tikkun mana. Even with cloth napkins, there is no prohibition of Nevertheless, lechatchilah these cups should certainly be assembled be-
folding garments in this case, since the folding is not being done to im- fore Shabbos. This is particularly so in light of Shu”t Machazeh Eliyahu,
prove the garment but merely for temporary use. The reasoning is that Vol. II (siman 13), who discusses this issue at length and concludes that
when folding clothing, the fold itself serves to improve the garment. the above reasoning is insufficient grounds to permit assembling these
Here, however, the folding is merely for a one-time use, after which the cups. In his opinion, attaching the two parts of the utensil is prohibited
napkin will be washed and the entire fold will disappear. Therefore, no and may even involve an issur d’Oraisa. This is because, in practice, the
significant improvement is being made through the folding. This differs person intends to assemble the utensil permanently, as he has no inten-
from the ruling of Shemiras Shabbos Kehilchasah (Chapter 11:41), who tion of ever separating its two parts. He further writes that even if one
writes that a cloth napkin that was opened should not be refolded. decides that he will separate the two components after finishing his use
of the cup, it should nevertheless be prohibited at least mid’Rabbanan,
Attaching the Bases to Plastic Cups out of concern that he may forget and leave the utensil assembled. How-
ever, a person whose regular practice is always to separate the parts after
Q: Is it permissible on Shabbos to attach the base or stem to a plastic finishing his use may assemble the cup with the intention of subsequent-
ly taking it apart. may be an extraordinary act of piety (Radbaz III:627, also numbered
1052). Contemporary poskim apply this principle to kidney dona-
Cutting a Roll of Plastic Tablecloths Through a tion. Although losing a kidney differs from losing a hand or eye,
Non-Jew since a healthy donor can generally function normally with one kid-
ney, the donor nevertheless permanently loses an organ. Rav Moshe
Q: If one forgot to prepare plastic tablecloths to cover the Sternbuch therefore rules that there is no obligation to donate, alt-
tables for the Shabbos seudah, is it permissible to cut the hough doing so is an extraordinary act of piety (Teshuvos Vehanha-
plastic tablecloth from the roll on Shabbos? gos II:733; III:360; V:388). Rav Chaim Kanievsky likewise rules
that although one is not obligated, donating is a great mitzvah
A: It is prohibited to tear the roll on Shabbos because of the mela- (Derech Sicha, Bereishis, p. 19). The Nishmas Avraham also cites
chah of kore’a. Regarding having a non-Jew cut it, there is room Rav Moshe Feinstein, the Tzitz Eliezer, and Rav Ovadia Yosef, who
for discussion, and one should consult a Rav before doing so. The conclude that kidney donation is not obligatory, but is a tremendous
Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 340, se’if katan 41) writes that one who mitzvah when medically appropriate (Nishmas Avraham, YD 349:3
tears paper into pieces in order to use them for wiping is liable be- (a), p. 554). Thus, although modern medicine has greatly reduced
cause of kore’a, and this constitutes an issur d’Oraisa. Therefore, the danger of kidney donation, the donor still permanently surren-
even if we assume that there is a significant need to tear the plastic, ders an organ and has no obligation to donate. Nevertheless, doing
one generally cannot be lenient regarding having a non-Jew perform so is an exceedingly great mitzvah and an extraordinary act of
an issur d’Oraisa. chesed.
The Biur Halachah there (se’if 13, s.v. ein) writes, according to the Bone-marrow donation is somewhat different, since the marrow or
Rambam, that kore’a is prohibited min haTorah only when there is a stem cells regenerate and the donor does not permanently lose an
constructive benefit to both pieces that result from the tearing. Nev- organ. Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach rules that a suitable donor
ertheless, in our case there is a constructive benefit to both portions. should be strongly encouraged to donate, but may not be pressured if
The roll itself is intended to be cut into individual pieces, and cutting he is scared of the slight danger involved. However, he explicitly
off the present piece also improves the remaining roll, since the next states that if the only concern were pain or discomfort, one could be
piece will now need to be torn only from its other side. obligated to endure it to save another when nobody else can do so
The sefer Shoshanas Yisrael — Hilchos Nisuin (p. 56) cites Rav (Nishmas Avraham IV, EH 80:1). Rav Sternbuch likewise rules that
Shlomo Miller shlit”a, who noted that bedieved there is room to because danger cannot be entirely excluded, donation cannot be re-
rely upon the ruling of the Shulchan Aruch HaRav, cited in the quired, although it is a tremendous mitzvah (Assia 91–92, pp. 5–10).
Biur Halachah, that the melachah of kore’a does not apply to Regarding ordinary blood donation, the Shevet HaLevi rules that
leather, since it is a single solid material. According to this ap- where there is no real element of danger, temporary weakness or
proach, the same would apply to cutting plastic from a roll, and illness does not necessarily exempt one from the obligation to save
it would not constitute an issur d’Oraisa. He further adds that if another (V:219). However, this is not exactly the same as bone-
the non-Jew was responsible for preparing the plastic before marrow donation, which Rav Shlomo Zalman and Rav Sternbuch
Shabbos, then by cutting it on Shabbos he is acting for his specifically address without imposing an obligation.
own benefit — to rectify what he himself neglected to do The recipient's lack of observance does not change the conclusion,
beforehand. It would therefore be permissible to benefit since even if he were completely observant, donation would not be
from his action. See Biur Halachah (O.C. 276, s.v. obligatory. As for the mitzvah itself, although the poskim discuss
letzorko). whether nonobservant Jews have the status of a tinok shenishbah,
even if we adopt the position that they are not considered a tinok
Practical Corner: By Rabbi Nesanel Odzer from the Rab- shenishbah, there is still an important consideration. Experience
banim of Beis Horaah KLY shows that being saved through such an extraordinary act of kind-
ness, especially by the Rav of a shul one attends, often brings a per-
Is There an Obligation to Donate a Kidney? son closer to Torah observance. Rav Sternbuch makes a similar
point regarding saving a "chiloni" Jew on Shabbos. He explains that
Q: I was informed that my kidney is a match for a even according to those who do not consider such a person a tinok
seriously ill person who occasionally attends my shenishbah, experience shows that many eventually return to Torah
shul. Although he has some connection to the shul, observance, and this possibility is itself a significant consideration
he is not observant. As the Rav of the shul, am I (Teshuvos Vehanhagos VI:90).
obligated to donate my kidney, or is it simply a In summary: Kidney donation is not obligatory, although it is an
great mitzvah? Would the halacha differ regarding exceptionally great mitzvah. The same applies to bone-marrow do-
bone-marrow donation? nation when the donor is concerned about the slight danger in-
volved. This great mitzvah would seemingly apply even when the
A: Two questions arise: Is kidney or bone- recipient is not observant, particularly where there is a strong possi-
marrow donation obligatory, and does the recip- bility that an extraordinary act of chesed by his Rav will inspire him
ient's lack of observance affect the halacha? to become observant.
The Radbaz rules that even if removing a limb
poses no danger, one need not surrender part of
his body to save another, although doing so
Take a part in spreading the light!
Email info@kollellihoraah.org for sponsorship opportunities.
To receive this weekly publication via email, Click here or email info@kollellihoraah.org.
Mazel Tov to the Rosh Kollel Rabbi and Rebbetzin Skoczylas on the Bar
Mitzvah of their son Yosef Shalom this Shabbos Parshas Noach. May he
continue to grow in Torah and Yiras Shamayim and be a source of nachas
to Klal Yisroel!
