gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

Yesoidois M'ha Sedre - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

Publisher: Yesoidois M'ha Sedre - English

Week: Noach (2026-10-12)

Yesoidois M'ha Sedre - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

Open the PDF Download

LESSONS IN HASHKAFA & HALACHA FROM THE PARSHA In memory of R’ Shmuel Shmelka ben HaRav Moshe Kizelnik z”l TORAHKOLLEL.COM From the desk of the Rosh Kollel... ‫תשפ“ז‬ ‫נח‬ Welcome to all our new subscribers! “SEVEN UPPERS” Yomim Noraim through Simchas Torah in the (Kohein) (The parsha begins by reintroducing us to Noach, calling him a tzadik. kollel was uplifting. From the tefilos to the Rashi tells us that Chazal are split on the matter: According to some, Noach was a simchas beis ha’shoeiva and hakafos, it was a tremendous tzadik; despite the fact that he was surrounded by evil, he was very inspiring period of time. The energy should completely righteous, and had he lived in better times, he would have become so spill over into the coming months as the kollel much greater. Others however, contend that Noach’s righteousness was only begins a new winter z’man. relative to his neighbors, and had he lived next door to Avraham Avinu, he wouldn’t have been anything special. R’ Dovid Campbell, who joined the kollel several years ago has assumed a teaching Rav Schwab explains that this letter approach isn’t simply rooted in pessimism. position in yeshiva in Yerushalayim. We wish After all, the Torah testifies that Noach found favor in Hashem’s eyes which him much hatzlacha in his new undertaking. implies something more than ‘just regular’. Rather, he explains, since Noach would become the progenitor of all of mankind, we might wonder how such a The kollel welcomes R’ Aryeh Safra who will be tzadik could be the father of the wicked as well. The answer must be some sort learning in the kollel during morning seder. of shortcoming. This isn’t to say the Noach was bad, just that he could have This year, the Yesodos will feature the “Seven done better, and such mediocrity can give birth to evil. Uppers”, which will recount and summarize Rashi explains the difference between Noach and Avraham Avinu: Regarding the each of the seven aliyah’s, integrating avos, the Torah testifies that they “walked before Hashem”, implying that they did inspiration and lessons in hashkafa at each so on their own. Noach however walked “es ha’Elokim” - with Hashem, meaning juncture. We hope you enjoy this new twist. that Noach needed Hashem’s help to survive his surroundings. In Elul, the kollel began our 18th year! Since its Hashem explains to Noach why He wants to destroy the world and begin anew inception, the kollel has impacted many people and instructs Noach to build a teiva on to which he will bring everything from all walks of life; from the avreichim, to the necessary to rebuild. Its long, time consuming public construction was an local baalei batim, and neighborhood youth. opportunity for the world to find out about Hashem’s plan and mend their ways. Thank you to all those who have supported us Perhaps it was also an opportunity for Noach to become more proactive in his on this journey. To find out how to make a good approach to kiruv, but neither opportunity produced any results. thing even better, email us at info@torahkollel.com (Levi) 120 years later, after the construction of the teivah was complete, Hakadosh Boruch Hu instructed Noach to gather every species of animal and bring them Contact us at info@torahkollel.com for further onto the teivah and it began to rain. However Noach himself, didn’t enter until information or to subscribe to the weekly the flooding began and Chazal criticize him for not entering before he saw that it Yesodos! was really happening. It rained for forty days which the commentaries explain corresponds to the length of time it takes a fetus to develop from conception (Rashi), the number of lashes administered by beis din when punishing with malkus, or the number of days Moshe spent on Har Sinai to receive the Torah (Chizkuni). Although the Torah Sponsored by the Drillman Family would not be given for another two millennia, since the world was Created with ‫לזכות ולברכה‬ the Torah “in mind”, the reality of malkus and matan Torah was an integral part of May the merit of ‫שמירת שבת כהלכתה‬ the world order from its inception. (See Rashi Bereishis 1:31 “Yom Hashishi” that - its halachos, kedushah and proper the entire creation was contingent on kabalas ha’Torah and the world’s very existence in the interim was observance - serve as a ‫ מליץ יושר‬for our family and all (Shlishi) As the torrential rains poured down from above, flood waters began to of Klal Yisrael, for a year filled with shoot out from beneath the earth’s surface as well, destroying all living beings on land, including the birds. Only Noach and his family, and animals who boarded .‫ נחת וישועות‬,‫ בריאות‬,‫ברכה והצלחה‬ the teivah survived. To sponsor an edition of the Yesodos for After forty days, all of this stopped but it took much longer for the waters to only $54 contact us: info@torahkollel.com. 1 evaporate and uncover the land, and eventually, Noach sent out two birds - first a raven, and then a dove - to scout out whether it was safe to disembark. The raven refused to go, citing his concern that if he wouldn’t return safely, his species would become extinct. He also accused Noach of wanting to steal his mate. According to the Netziv, the first argument wasn’t really valid since there were other ravens on board as well, and so the raven had to advance another ‘winning’ argument, as ridiculous as it sounded. Instead, Noach sent out a dove who returned with an olive branch in his mouth. Chazal understand that there was a double message intended here: In addition to letting Noach know that water level was now lower than the trees, but low enough, the yonah was that he would rather rely directly on the Ribono shel Olam, even if his food would be bitter like olives, than have to come on to people. The Nesivos explains that while it is true that this was not the intention of the bird, and while animals do communicate, they don't give musar or even "think" about doing so. However, absolutely EVERYTHING is divinely orchestrated. If hashgacha elyona decreed that Noach greet the dove returning with a olive branch in its mouth, then there was a message in that which his eyes beheld. (Revi’i) After the waters had settled and exposed the dry land, Noach waited for instructions to leave and Hashem told him to exit the teivah. Noach offered korbanos from the extra kosher animals he had brought on board and set out to rebuild the world, as instructed. In addition, Hashem now permitted Noach to partake of the animal kingdom, provided the animals were killed first. This is something which was previously forbidden. R’ Elya Meir Bloch zt”l explains the change: Really, eating animals should be a dilemma of hashkafa, since killing animals for our own purposes borders on cruel behavior. The reason why it is permitted, is because when a person consumes meat, it give him energy and helps him fulfill his purpose in the world and essentially gives the animal a higher purpose as well. However, since Adam had brought destruction to the world when he ate from the eitz ha’daas, he had negated the development and growth of the world as his life’s mission. So, eating meat, remained forbidden to him. Noach, on the other hand, remained a tzadik despite the evil world that surrounded him and Hashem saw him fit to rebuild from destruction. Since he understood his life’s mission, he was granted permission to slaughter animals in order to fulfill it. There is an important lesson here for us as well: Our generation enjoys standards that even kings of yesteryear could only imagine as luxuries. This includes, but is not limited to the food we consume. It behooves us that ultimately, the reason why the Ribono shel Olam grants us these, is to enable us to use our resources to further build His world, both personally to improve ourselves spiritually, and communally, by using everything we have to help others. (Chamishi) Hashem promises that He will never destroy the world again and makes a rainbow as a sign of this promise. R’ S. R. Hirsch zt”l contends that the rainbow was not a new phenomenon, but was rather used as a sign very much like Hashem told Avraham that he would have descendants ‘like the stars’, which clearly existed since Creation. The choice of a rainbow here, he explains, was to convey the message that just as a single white light refracts through a prism and produces seven different colors, so too, while people will follow different paths in life - some more spiritual and some less - every neshama emanates from a pure source, and every life is a projection and revelation of the same spiritual source. (Shishi) In his task to rebuild, Noach planted a vine and ultimately got drunk. The vine was planted from one he took on the teiva. He also took a fig branch on with him and seemingly, that would have been a better choice. His sons found him lying naked and while Sheim and Yefes quickly covered their father, this was only after Cham had taken advantage of his intoxicated state, and it was because of Sheim alacrity in covering his father that his children merited the mitzva of tzitzis, which Chazal relate has the ability to prevent sin, especially in the area of illicit relationships. We are prone to thinking that this has to do with the techeilis component which reminds us of the heavens, however the Taz maintains that we merited techeilis because Avraham Avinu refused to take a single thread from the spoils of war and it is the white strings of tzitzis to which Chazal refer to here. The Torah then goes on the relate the generations and descendants of Noach who would ultimately form the seventy nations of the world. (Shevi’i) Originally, the whole world spoke only one language, which was most likely lashon ha’kodesh. The Torah relates that humanity decided to build a tower which would reach the heavens, and that would somehow ensure their safety and success. In response, Hashem introduced new languages so they couldn’t communicate effectively and that put a halt to their plans. That is what happened, but from a thorough reading of the pesukim it isn’t clear exactly what they did wrong and how impeding their ability to communicate was a just response. R’ Yosef Leib Bloch explains that there is tremendous power in achdus. It has the ability to protect from harm, disease, and helps people succeed. He posits that as society grew, it was only natural for them to spread out across the globe. Fearing that this would impede their ability to be unified, they devised a plan to keep everyone together by building a skyscraper, so everyone would live on the same block, and while achdus is a tremendous thing, Hashem wanted the world to be settled. Ultimately, they thought that through achdus, they could outsmart Hashem and protect themselves from hashgacha pratis. So the Ribono shel Olam made full achdus a virtual impossibility. The lesson is clear: Achdus is a tremendous thing and something that we must promote, but only when it is in line with the ratzon Hashem. The Torah continues with the genealogy of mankind and concludes the parsha by introducing Avraham Avinu and his wife Sarah, who was his brother’s daughter and was also referred to as ‘Yiskah”. Rashi tells us that she was called such because she saw with ruach ha’kodesh, and others looked at her beauty (‘socheh’ means to look or gaze). Although it would seem that ‘sheker ha’chein v’hevel ha’yofi’ and the fact that Sarah saw with ruach ha’kodesh was the real reason she was called Yiskah, the K’sav Sofer explains that physical beauty is only worthless if it is spiritually ‘ugly’. However, once we know that Sarah experienced ruach ha’kodesh, that only enhanced her physical beauty and the conclusion of that posuk, ‘isha yiras Hashem hi tis’halal’ means that if a woman has yiras shomayim, she is worthy of being praised for her physical beauty as well. Spiritual beauty doesn’t just enhance the physical, it redefines it. 2 SHABBOS RULES Chazal tell us that there are 39 categories of forbidden activities on Shabbos. These were all acts of labor involved in the actual construction of the Mishkan (as opposed to melachos performed as part of the avodah after it was built). Each of these is termed an ‘av (literally father) melacha’. Every av melacha has several subcategories - for example, there is an av melacha called sewing, but one who attached two piece of material together by gluing them is in violation of a toldah (literally offspring) of the melacha of sewing. Both are equally forbidden and carry the same penalties (see further). The only ‘practical’ difference between an av and a toldah is with regards to calculating the number of korbanos one must bring if he is mechalel Shabbos b’shogeig (see further) or, according to some, with regards to the wording of the forewarning issued to one who is about to intentionally desecrate Shabbos. In describing the building of the Mishkan, the Torah (Shemos 35:33) says ‘la’asos b’kol meleches machshavos’. Since ‘machshavos is written without a vav and can be read ‘machsheves’, Chazal derive that one is only liable for a melacha if one intends to do so in its normal way. This includes several exceptions, which we will elaborate on in the coming paragraphs. It is however important to understand that these exceptional cases are forbidden nonetheless, at least by rabbinic enactment. It is also worth mentioning the words of the Meiri who explains that these should really also be forbidden by Torah law, except that the Ribono shel Olam ‘demoted’ them in order to create a system which would be more flexible in cases of medical need or other extenuating circumstances. Melacha sheh’einah tzrichah l’gufah - Every melacha as a specific goal in terms of the construction of the mishkan. For example, if some digs a hole in the ground for the purpose of building a structure there, he is liable for the melacha of boneh (building). One who digs a hole because he needs dirt for some other purpose, has performed a melacha for another reason or one that is ‘einah tzrichah l’gufah’ - not needed for its own (usual) purpose. If one carries a pot of food from his house through the streets to serve it in a different location, he has carried (melacha of hotza’a). If he simply removed the garbage and put it outside because it had a foul order, this is a melacha sheh’eina tzrichah l’gufah. The matter is disputed by the tanaim. Most rishonim rule like R’ Shimon that one is exempt if he performed a melacha in such a fashion. The Rambam however, disagrees and rules that in this case, we follow R’ Yehuda who (seemingly) doesn’t subscribe to the exemptions of meleches machsheves. It is important to understand however, that even those who follow R’ Shimon understand that the rabbinic prohibition of melacha sheh’einah tzerichah l’gufah is more stringent than the other exemptions which are forbidden by rabbinic decree. Davar sheh’eino miskavein - In order to be liable for a melacha, one must intend to perform that activity. For example, if one performs an innocuous act such as opening a door and this results in the performance of a melacha such as the turning on of a light, there was no desecration of Shabbos. (This is called mis’aseik, not shogeig which is defined as one who had full awareness and intent but simply was unaware or forgot that this activity is a melacha, or thought it wasn’t Shabbos.) It should be noted that while the scenario of opening a fridge door might serve as a good example, R’ Shlomo Zalman Auerbach was of the opinion that opening a fridge door is like turning on the light because that is the way to turn on the fridge light. Furthermore, modern-day fridges have several other Shabbos concerns, some of which may be even more problematic than turning on the light. Mis’aseik is permitted as long as the resulting melacha is not inevitable. This means to say that one may l’chatchila perform a permitted act such as dragging a bench across a field, if it is not clear that it will result in any melacha. If however, the bench is so heavy that it will surely result in softening the ground (which is in effect plowing it), it is prohibited, even though he has no intention or need to plow the ground. This inevitability is known as a ‘psik reishei’, a borrowed term which refers to the fact that one cannot cut off a chicken’s head (p’sik reishei) without it resulting in the death of the chicken. Within the world of ‘psik reishei’ there is a distinction as to whether or not the person wants the benefit of the resulting melacha: If the person who wants the resulting action such as one who drags a very heavy bench through the area is about to plant a vegetable garden in, then he has violated a Torah prohibition of plowing. If however, he drags that bench in the public park, it is forbidden only rabbinically according to most rishonim. The Aruch however argues that it is permitted, and the poskim often consider his opinion in combination with other leniencies under extenuating circumstances. Shinui - One is only liable for performing melacha in the way it is normally done. For example, if a right -handed person writes with his left hand, it is considered a shinui (deviation) and is considered a rabbinic violation. The consensus of the 3 poskim is that the exchange of left hand for right only applies to writing (and perhaps a few other melachos) which are always done with the right hand. Clearly, R’ MEIR SHAPIRO carrying something in one’s left hand isn’t considered a shinui because people carry things in their left hand all 7 Cheshvan 5694 the time. Similarly, while carrying a pen in one’s mouth through a reshus ha’rabim might be considered a shinui, R’ Yehuda Meir Shapiro is known to the world for giving birth to daf yomi, and founding Yeshivas Chachmei Lublin. As if these accomplishments if the object he is carrying in his mouth is a sucking weren’t enough for a man who spent just 46 years in this world, he was the candy, then that is considered normal and not a shinui. father to so many, despite having no biological children of his own. Born in Shotz, Poland, on 7 Adar, 5647 (1887), he was descended from a line of R’ Moshe Feinstein, takes a stricter approach in chasidish leaders; R’ Pinchas of Koritz was his great-great-grandfather, understanding what constitutes a shinui. According to R’ and his grandfather - under whom he studied for a few years - was the rav Moshe, the shinui must be apparent in the results of the in Monastritz, Poland. melacha, and not just the way it is performed. While he was gifted with a great memory an genius understanding, he had Accordingly, while writing with one’s left hand produces difficulty learning alef-beis, but, because he was diligent and persevered, he an inferior quality of script, using his nose to turn on a eventually surpassed the rest of his class and his parents hired a private machine produces the same result and is equally rebbe instead. There was a mix up and the hired melamed was delayed by a prohibited. Most poskim are not considered with this day and little Meir went about his day but the sight of his mother’s tears over a lost day devoid of Torah study made a major impression on him and approach, especially when dealing with medical needs. was one of the impetuses for establishing the daily daf ha’yomi cycle. Mekalkeil - Usually, (although there are some At the age of 19, he married Malka Tova Breitman and moved to Tarnipol, exceptions) one is only liable for performing a where her father supported the couple so R’ Meir could dedicate himself to Torah. Fully supported, he lived a dream life. Yet, he could not rest. constructive melacha. If one destroys while doing so, he is Witnessing the conditions of yeshiva bochurim in war-torn Poland who had exempt. Therefore, although one who tears a seam in no food and often found lodgings in factories overnight, he set out to make order to stitch is together is liable, if he is simply things better for them by establishing a yeshiva with a dormitory, something destroying an item of clothing, it is only forbidden unheard of at the time. mi’derabanan. To further his dream, R’ Meir entered the public sphere, and despite the protests from his in-laws and at the advice of the Chartokover rebbe, he Defining a full melacha - In order to liable, one has accepted the position as rav of Galina (Austria-Hungary). There, he to do a full melacha. This excludes two separate cases: If upgraded the chinuch system and raised money to improve its facilities to one does a full melacha which is insignificant because it compete with the secular winds. lacks the minimum quantity (for example he cooks food When Galina was destroyed by the invading Russian army, R’ Meir fled, measuring less than the size of an olive), he is patur. It is and assumed rabbinic positions in several Polish cities, raising the bar of nevertheless forbidden, and according to most Torah education in each of them. approaches, by Torah law. (Although some argue that In 1922, he addressed a convention of rabbonim and he inspired the masses the concept of chatzi shiur only applies to the consuming so much that he within days he was offered to become Chief Rabbi of of forbidden foods.) Warsaw, a position that had been vacant for forty years. Despite the opportunity, he declined because the offer was contingent on ceasing his Another exemption is if the melacha is done by two involvement with Agudas Yisroel, and so instead, at the behest of the Gerrer people, where either one could have accomplished it on Rebbe, he became the president of the Agudah and their representative in the Polish parliament. their own. For example, if two people transport a pillow through a reshus ha’rabim, they are both exempt. Wanting to united Jews from all over through Torah, R’ Meir created a system which would connect them, but his dream of daf yomi wasn’t without However, f they carry a large heavy bed, they are liable. opposition. However, through the encouragement of the Chofetz Chaim, he This is known as ‘shnayim sheh’asuha’. presented the idea at the Agudah’s convention, and when the Gerrer Rebbe began the cycle one week later, daf yomi became a reality. Gerama - It is forbidden to do a melacha. Causing a A short time later he was granted a plot of land in Lublin, a historic place of melacha to be done however, is not a Torah prohibition. Torah, and R’ Meir began to bring his dream of building a full service Usually, however, it is rabinically forbidden. However in yeshiva (food and lodging) to fruition. This too, was met with opposition, as the case of fire, it is permitted in the following scenario: R’ Meir tried to raise funds from a community that could not sustain its If , for example, one put a towel down too close to the already existing yeshivos. Still, he pressed forward, raising and borrowing, candles and it caught on fire, one could surround the area eventually setting out to America on a three month fundraising tour which with water so that it will be extinguished when the fire lasted over a year. When he returned, he completed the building of the yeshiva and began testing bochurim for acceptance. He connected with the spreads to the water (or place a container of water so that bochurim on multiple levels, including music, dancing to songs he had it will break or melt and the water will then extinguish the composed himself, and personally attending to weak and ill talmidim. fire). Of course where there is imminent danger to life, the Still, there was tremendous debt involved in running the yeshiva and so with fire should be extinguished immediately in the regular no other choice, R’ Meir accepted the position of rav of Lodz; the deal was way. Contemporary poskim debate what exactly that he would split his time between Lodz and Lublin, and that the constitutes gerama in modern day technology and one community would support the yeshiva. should seek guidance from his or her own rav in cases of In October of 1933 he fell ill with pneumonia and on 7 Cheshvan, he died medical need or other extenuating circumstances. at the age of only forty-six. He was buried in Lublin but his kever was moved twenty-five years later to Har Hamenuchos.