Samcheinu B'Yeshuosecho Inyan - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

פרשת נח תשפ"ז בס"ד
נכתב לע"נ אבי מורי ר' מנחם מענדל בן ר' מאיר גראססבערגער ז"ל נלב״ע י״ט אדר תשפ״ו
ואמי מורתי מרת מרים בת ר' גדלי'ה ע"ה נלב״ע כ״ג תשרי שמחת תורה תשפ״ב
Written By R’ YZ Grossberger. To comment or receive, please email
sbalhatorah@gmail.com / +447941163001
Noach’s Avoda in the Teivo!
The Parsha begins: ""אלה תולדות נח נח איש צדיק תמים היה בדורותיו. The Targum
translates ... נח איש צדיק תמיםto mean a “ ”גבר זכאי שלים- a person who was
completely meritorious in his generation. The question is, what is the difference
between the two expressions: Tzaddik and Tomim?
The Brisker Rov zt”l answers this with a Gemora in ): ראש השנה (טזwhich says that
a person who has mostly merits is referred to as a Tzaddik – righteous, whereas
someone who has mostly sins is referred to as a Rosho – wicked. Therefore, to be
classed as a Tzaddik, a person doesn’t have to be completely free from sin; rather,
he has to possess mostly merits. The Rambam brings this in )'א,' הלכות תשובה (גand
adds a similar point regarding the countries of the world. He writes that a country
where most people have more merits than sins is considered to be righteous
whereas a country where most people are involved in sin is considered to be wicked.
שמחנו בישועתך על התורה
Two judgements
It’s clear from the Rambam that there are two judgements from Heaven. There is
the judgement on each individual whether he is a Tzaddik or a Rosho, and there is
also a judgement on every country whether the country is righteous or not. As a
result, the following scenario can play out. You can have an individual who is a
Tzaddik because he has mostly merits; however, since he resides in a country
where there are mostly sinners, this Tzaddik will be judged together with the rest of
his country. The fact that he personally has mostly merits won’t save him from being
punished since he is living in a country where most people are sinners.
An Ish Tzaddik
Noach was an Ish Tzaddik; however he was a Tzaddik in a world full of sinners, and
the entire world was to be punished. And so, just being a Tzaddik and having mostly
merits wouldn’t suffice to save him and he would have been judged together with
his generation, and would have died in the Mabul.
A Tomim
Due to this, the Torah adds another word to the description of Noach - the word
Tomim, which the Targum translates - a completely meritorious person. This
underlines something truly remarkable about Noach; that he wasn’t only a Tzaddik.
He was in fact far greater than that, he was actually a Tomim – completely
meritorious - meaning that he had never done any sin at all. And so, the Brisker Rov
explains that as a result, Noach was excluded from the judgement of the Dor
HaMabul. Why? Because there was no judgement on Noach since he had never
sinned, therefore, he merited to be saved even though the rest of the generation
were punished.
1
בס"ד
A powerful question
This brings us to the following question. If, as we have learnt, Noach was on such
a lofty level of righteousness that he was excluded from being punished with his
generation, how do we explain the following Rashi? The posuk )כ"ג,' (זwrites:
“And He wiped out all existence that was on the face of the ground, from man to
animals, to creeping things and to the bird of the heavens; and they were blotted
out from the earth. Only Noach survived, and those with him in the Teivo. Rashi
writes: Only Noach! “This means Noach alone, the Medrash says that Noach was
coughing and retching blood because of the trouble of caring for the animals and
the beasts. Some say that he was injured because he delayed giving food to the
lion and the lion attacked him, as it says in )ל"א,משלי (י"א: “– ”הן צדיק בארץ ישולם
behold the righteous one is paid on earth – which Rashi ( )משליexplains to mean
- the Tzaddik receives punishment for his sin while he is still on earth”, a
reference to Noach.
Which was he?
שמחנו בישועתך על התורה
This seems rather surprising and requires clarification. Noach suffered greatly
while caring for the animals and was even attacked by the lion. Rashi explains
by bringing a Posuk, that this suffering was a result of Noach’s sins, since a
Tzaddik is punished for his sins in this world. But this appears to contradict what
we learnt in the very first Posuk of the Sedra, where Noach is described as a
complete Tzaddik Tomim who had done no sins. If Noach was indeed such a
Tzaddik, why was he being punished, and what sins had he committed?
With what merit?
Let’s strengthen the question further. The Medrash in )'ו, תהלים (ל"זbrings the
following: Avrohom Ovinu once asked Malki-Tzedek, Noach’s son, Shem, “With
what merit did you manage to leave the Teivo at the time of such Divine
judgment?” Malki-Tzedek replied, “We performed charitable acts.” Avrohom
asked, “What charity could you give? Only Noach and his family were there, so
upon whom did you bestow charity?” He replied, “We gave charity to the animals,
beasts, and birds. We did not sleep at night, but served food to each creature.
Once we were late, and my father was injured.” At this, Avrohom declared, “Had
they not performed charity to the animals, beasts, and birds, they would not have
come out of the Teivo – and because they were once late, they were punished.
How much more so should we act charitably towards human beings, who are
created in the form of angels, to prevent bad things happening to us.” And so,
Avrohom Ovinu planted a Eishel to act charitably to mankind.
הוציאה ממסגר נפשי
It’s clear from this Medrash that had Noach not looked after the animals, and
acted charitably towards them and suffered tremendously in doing so, he
wouldn’t have been allowed to leave the Teivo. The Meforshim actually point out
another explanation of the posuk: ““ – ”וישאר אך נחNoach was left alone” that
2
בס"ד
Noach came out of the Teivo alone - meaning he escaped literally with just his
Neshoma but physically, his body was completely shattered.
Furthermore, Chazal tell us that whilst in the Teivo, Noach continuously davened
הוציאה ממסגר נפשי- take me out of this prison )'ח,(תהלים קמ"ב. This strengthens our
question further, why did Noach suffer so much whilst in the Teivo, and why was he
attacked by the lion if he was a Tzaddik Tomim who had never sinned! Also why did
he need the merit of the continuous charity to be able to come out of the Teivo after
the Mabul if before the Mabul he had never sinned?
An eternal impact
In fact, there is another point that needs clarification too. The Gaon in Aderes
Eliyohu explains the lasting impact on mankind of the lion’s attack on Noach in the
Teivo. The posuk tells us )כ"ח,'(בראשית א: “And Hashem blessed Odom and Chava,
telling them to be fruitful and multiply, fill the earth and subdue it, and rule over the
fish of the sea, the birds of the sky, and every living thing that moves on earth.” After
the Mabul, the posuk )'ב,' (טstates: The fear of you and the dread of you shall be
שמחנו בישועתך על התורה
upon every beast of the earth…” The Gaon asks, what happened to the ability that
mankind had before the Mabul to actually rule over the animals? When did they lose
it and why was it replaced after the Mabul with the animals only fearing humans and
not being ruled by humans?
שעשה לי כל צרכי
He answers because when the lion attacked Noach in the Teivo, this signified a
fundamental change – that mankind would no longer rule over the animals as before.
Rather, animals would only have a fear of man. The reason the lion specifically
attacked Noach’s foot highlights this too. Because every morning when we put on
our shoes, we make the Brocho " – "שעשה לי כל צרכיthat Hashem has created
everything that we need. The Meforshim explain that we make this Brocho
specifically when we put on our shoes, because wearing leather shoes denotes
mankind’s rulership over the animal kingdom. This is apparent when we take an
animal hide, produce leather from it and wear it on our feet. Noach was kicked on
his leg by the lion to emphasize to him that he had now lost man’s original power of
ruling over the animals due to the delay in serving the lion his food. This requires an
explanation. Why as a result of Noach’s delay did Hashem cause him to be smitten
and mankind lose their power over the animal kingdom?
To summarize, if Noach was such a Tzaddik before the Mabul, what suddenly
changed when he entered the Teivo that he endured such great suffering there, he
felt like he was in prison for twelve months, and he was also attacked by the lion
and lost his ability to rule over the animals? How do we reconcile these points and
understand what is happening here?
כי מי נח זאת לי
Based on the זוהר הקדוש, the ) ספר דברי יושר (י"זgives a powerful answer. The Zohar
writes ('ט,)ישעיה נ"ד: “ – ”כי מי נח זאת ליthat the waters of the Mabul are referred to as
the waters of Noach. Why? Because although Noach was a Tzaddik Tomim,
3
בס"ד
Hashem found him lacking in one area – that he didn’t daven for his generation
to do Teshuva, and so they weren’t saved from the Mabul. As a result, once the
Mabul began and the people of the generation went through terrible suffering in
the waters of the Mabul, Hashem took note of this and Noach wasn’t spared from
judgement.
And so, the time Noach spent in the Teivo was changed to a time of suffering for
him, and as the Medrash points out, if not for the fact that Noach spent his time
in the Teivo continuously doing Chesed with the animals, he wouldn’t have been
spared and would have remained forever in the Teivo!
This also clarifies why Rashi brings the Posuk from Mishlei referring to Noach
and explains that the righteous receive punishment for their sins while still on
earth. What was the sin of Noach for which he suffered in the Teivo? The answer
is, that he didn’t daven for his generation!
An entire year of judgement
Based on this, we can now answer the following question. The pesukim bring
שמחנו בישועתך על התורה
that after forty days of the Mabul, all living things perished. However, Chazal
)'י,' עדיות (בnote that the judgement of the Dor HaMabul lasted an entire year. But
who was actually on the receiving end of this judgement for an entire year if the
people had all already perished? The answer is that it refers to Noach who had
to endure the difficult situation in the Teivo for those twelve months because he
didn’t daven for the people!
The new Avoda of Noach
This teaches that when there is judgment in this world, even the greatest
Tzaddikim are looked at and their deeds investigated, and so, despite Noach
being a Tzaddik Tomim before the Mabul with no sins, once it actually began and
the cry of the people rose up to Hashem, Noach was found to be lacking and the
waters are referred to as “Mei Noach” since he should have davened for his
generation. As a result, Noach had no choice but to learn this Middoh of being
Nosei B’ol through the burden of caring for all the animals. By doing so, he was
reminded how he should have involved himself in being Nosei B’ol with the
people of his generation. Therefore, this now became his central Avoda in the
Teivo, to be Nosei B’ol with all the animals.
The difference in a moment
We can now understand why Noach was punished when he delayed giving food
to the lion. Because those moments of delay highlighted a lack of caring for
others and feeling for them and so he was immediately punished by being smitten
by the lion. It also had the greater ramification that as a result, mankind lost the
power to rule over the animal kingdom which further illustrated to Noach how vital
the Middoh of Nosei B’ol is and that it cannot be ignored even for a moment!
Perhaps we can suggest that the reason why a lack of Nesi’us Ol on Noach’s
part resulted in mankind losing their ability to rule over the animals was because
4
בס"ד
mankind can only rule over the animals when they are on the greatest level of
Shleimus. However here, since Noach displayed a lack of Nesi’us Ol, which resulted
in a deficiency in his Shleimus, as a result, mankind lost the capacity to rule over
the animal kingdom.
Recreating the world
In truth, through Noach sharing in the burden in the Teivo and spending his time
looking after the animals, this actually had a powerful impact on the new world after
the Mabul. The Meforshim explain that the corruption of the Dor HaMabul happened
as a result of people focusing only on their own needs and desires instead of helping
others. Through Noach constantly thinking of others during his time in the Teivo, he
succeeded in bringing the concept of Chesed – “thinking of others” back into the
world. And so, the world after the Mabul was once again established on a firm
platform of Chesed where people put others before themselves and lived together
in harmony!
I can’t sleep!
שמחנו בישועתך על התורה
There is a powerful anecdote which gives new insight into how far Gedolei Yisroel
go in feeling for others, even those who aren’t Jewish, by virtue of the fact that they
are created in the Tzelem Elokim. Rav Moshe Shapira zt”l (Looking into the Sun,
P.116) once travelled to Mexico City to participate in a Siyum. Later that day, he told
his assistant that he wouldn’t be able to sleep that night. He explained that when
the plane was landing, he looked on in horror at the vast sprawling slums of Mexico
City. Having seen human beings suffering this way, he wouldn’t be able to sleep!
Such was the greatness of his Nesi’us Ol with others, even to non-Jews!
Putting others first!
We have learnt from our Parsha that the waters of the Mabul are referred to as “Mei
Noach” since Noach didn’t daven for his generation and he was taken to task for it.
Due to this, he went through much hardship in the Teivo. This clearly demonstrates
how important it is to Hashem that we daven for others and share in their burdens.
Let’s take a Chizuk from this to alleviate the burden of those who are in difficult
situations and bring them some relief, whether it’s through serious davening for
them or by physically helping them. And through caring about others, no doubt, we
too will find special favor in Hashem’s eyes and He will bestow His Chesed and
Rachamim upon us too!
***
5
