HaIchud B'chidud Divrei Torah - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

בס"ד
Shiurim of the Ichud B’chidud are available
on Torah Anytime by R’ Yitzchok Aryeh Epstein
פרשת נח תשפ"ז
This week’s Shiurim can be accessed at 5:58 הדלקת נרות
https://www.torahanytime.com/#/lectures?v=483670 9:20/9:56 סזק"ש
https://www.torahanytime.com/#/lectures?v=483681 זמניםare for Lakewood, NJ
718-298-2077 press 9 483670# or 9 483681#. Volume 28 Issue 3
דברי תורה ~ פרשת נח
'ח-'בראשית ח' ז....וישלח את היונה מאתו לראות הקלו המים...וישלח את העורב ויצא יצוא ושוב
הקב"הcreated many many species of birds. The raven & the dove don’t fly the farthest & definitely don’t fly the fastest, as even
a duck can fly faster than them! So why did נחsend specifically these two birds? And בכלל, who gave נחpermission to send creatures out
of the תיבה, they were in his אחריות, & ' דnever gave him a command to send anyone out yet?
The נצי"בhas a novel approach. With this approach, we can also understand why the raven just returned immediately & the dove
at least tried to do its job!
The נצי"בsays, that these two birds were not from the “pairs” that were brought into the תיבהto assure that they won’t become
extinct as ' דcommanded him. Rather, since נחwas a highly respected individual before the מבול, he acted like such and had pet birds in
his house! He was able to bring them into the תיבה, as ' דsaid !בא אתה וכל ביתךWhile the raven just flew around the house, the dove was
trained to deliver letters & do assorted flying chores! So when נחsent the raven, he was only able to just check out the מצבaround the
תיבה, & as it was full of water, he came right back as he wasn’t מסוגלto fly long distances. The dove, on the other hand did fly far as she
was used to flying long distances. That is also the reason that the first time when the יונהreturned, she didn’t come back directly to נחbut
rather ""אל התיבה, near the תיבה, as the יונהflew around the area but didn’t go back to נחas she did the second time. The reason for this is,
says the נצי"ב, since she didn’t do her job & was embarrassed. Therefore, וישלח ידו ויקחה ויבא אתה אליו, נחhad רחמנותon her & took her in
his hand & warmed her up until she recuperated from her trip!
The נצי"בends by saying, we see from here a יסודin בין אדם לחבירו, that when a שליחfails to do a job by no fault of their own, one
must have רחמנותon them & welcome them back warmly!
בראשית ו' י"ד...שלש מאות אמה ארך התבה חמשים אמה רחבה ושלשים אמה קומתה
One thing is clear, there is no way that על פי דרך הטבעthe תיבהwas able to contain 2 of all the living beings in the world (plus 7
of the )טהורותin its 30,000 sq. ft. middle floor of the אלא מאי !תיבהwe have to conclude that the תיבהcontained everyone !בדרך נסIf so,
why did הקב"הgive נחsuch detailed dimensions on how to build this ark, He should have told נח, to go build an ark & don’t worry about
the size as anyways I’ll get everyone on board (?)בדרך נס
I saw a fabulous מהלך, על פי קבלהin the ברכת יצחק. (I couldn’t resist printing it, למרותit’s not my style) The ספרי קבלהbring בשם
האר"יthat there are 2 כוחות הרשעin the world, !נחש & סמאלThe שורשof the bad in נחשis in the letter ' חwhich is suppressed by a ' נon the
right from the שם אדנות, & with a ' שon the left from the שם שקי. These 2 אותיותon both sides of the ' חcurb the רשעfrom overflowing its
space. (The Vilna Gaon explains the . גמ' סנהדרין ע"חthat says )ארס נחש בין שיניו עומד. The other כח הרשעis סמאל. The שורשof this bad is in
the אותיותof ס"מand the שםof ל- אis at the end, also to contain it from cresting overboard!
But in the תקופת דור המבול, the כוחות הרשעbroke the levies as it says, ותמלא הארץ ח מס, the entire land was full of ' חfrom the נחש
& מסfrom !סמאלIn order for the world to return to an operable livable מצב, the רבש"עhad to put the רשעback into constraints of !קדושה
He therefore told נחvery specific instructions of the size of the !תיבהThe length of 300 אמותwill allude to the ' & שthe width of 50 אמות
will allude to the 'נ, and these 2 אותיותwill once again keep the ' חin check, keeping it as ‘ !’נחשThe height of the תיבהshall be 30 אמות
which will allude to the ' & לthe 1 אמהthat finishes it from above alludes to the 'א, & these 2 אותיותwill once again keep the ס"מin check,
keeping it as '!'סמאל
בראשית ח' כ"א...ויאמר ד' אל לבו לא אסף לקלל עוד את האדמה
Why does it say אל לבו, a לשוןwe כמעטdon’t find in the entire ?תורהWhat is it supposed to imply? Is this whole בריתwith the
rainbow a secret between Hashem & Himself? Also is troubling, the דור הפלגהknew quite well what happened to the דור המבול, so did
they dare rebel against ' ?דWe they not scared of a second showing? And the tower they were building, did they really believe they would
reach ' ?דAnd doesn’t a tower reaching the שמיםneed the entire world as the base? Anything smaller would just topple over? What exactly
were their plans?
ר' יונתן אייבשיץwants to say that even though that הקב"הswore that He would no longer bring another מבולon the world, but He
didn’t tell the people on the world in order that they should behave! If they would be afraid of another מבול, maybe they wouldn’t rebel
in Hashem! Therefore He said it – אל לבוHe didn’t reveal His intentions!
And in fact the people were indeed afraid of another מבולbut instead of behaving, they searched for ways to protect themselves
from a מבול. This was the reasoning behind the building of the !מגדלThere were 3 groups there, each to address their own needs.(See
. )סנהדרין ק"טThe 1st כתthought, the מבולconsisted of rain & rain comes from clouds that collect the evaporation from the oceans. Since
above the clouds there is no rain, & the highest clouds are only 20,000 feet high (Besides noctilucent clouds that are 50 miles high &
are visible only after שקיעהin certain areas). So they figured they would build a מגדלwhose top is higher than the clouds, & they’ll stay
there during the duration of the & מבולthey will be saved. ( וראשו מגיע השמימהis a גוזמא, but extremely high! The WTC buildings were less
than 1370 feet)! The 2nd כתthought that without gravity, everything would be able to soar until the שמים, but gravity pulls it back to the
ground! But this is only true in the earth’s atmosphere, once one breaks out of the earth’s atmosphere, there is no gravity containing your
movement! So if they built a מגדלwith the top outside the earth’s atmosphere, and from there they would build a ‘ship’ (or as we would
call it a rocket) & everyone would board the ‘ship’ would go up onto the moon & live on the moon during the duration of the ( !מבולI’m
not making this up! See the תפארת יהונתןinside yourself!) The 3rd כתthought that the entire space of the world is full of & רוחות ושדיםthe
עיקר חטאof the דור המבולwas that they were מקריב קרבנותto these רוחות ושדיםin order that they should follow their orders.
However after the מבול, the רוחות ושדיםrefused to listen to the people as they were scared that ' דwould bring upon them a new מבול. But
the people figured that only the שדים ורוחותin the lower atmosphere are scared & aren’t complying, but if they build a מגדלand begin to
communicate with the שדים ורוחותin the upper atmosphere, they will cooperate as they have no problem with a !מבול
But from all the groups we see, that the people were scared of ' דbringing another !מבולSo it must be that ' דdidn’t reveal to
mankind his )וצ"ע מה בדיוק אמר אלקים לנח בפ"ט פסוק י"ז( !שבועה
אבי מלכה ואבי יסכה......שם אשת אברם שרי
ושהכל סוכין ביפיה, על שם שסוכה ברוח הקודש,יסכה זו שרה:פרש"י
רש"יtells us that one of the reasons that שריwas called יסכהwas because everyone would gaze at her beauty. What kind of an
excuse is that for a name? לכאורהthe other reason that she saw with רוח הקודש, she actually is listed in the . גמ' מגילה דף י"דas one of the
7 נביאותthat כלל ישראלhad, that is a great attribute worthy of a name, but that she was gazed at due to her beauty, does that warrant a
name change? Also, it seems from רש"יthat both reasons are intertwined, what is the connection between the two?
ר' יוסף חייםSonnonfeld זצ"לanswers beautifully! By לאהthe תורהsays ועיני לאה רכות. רש"יexplains that לאהthought that she
would end up with עשו. The whole world was saying that רבקהhas two sons, and לבןhas two daughters, the oldest boy to the oldest
girl…and לאהcried until her eyelashes fell out.
He says that by שריwas a very similar situation. The world said, תרחhas two sons נחור & אברם. הרןhas two daughters, & שרי
מלכה. the oldest אברםwill take מלכה, and the younger, נחור, will take שרי. If שריwas going to take these words to heart, she too would
probably cry until her eyelashes would fall out like לאה, and would inevitably scar her beauty. But, since שריwas a נביאה, she was able
to see with her רוח הקודשthat her lot was with אברם, and not with נחור. So, due to her powers of prophecy, she held onto her beauty,
which now took on new meaning, causing everyone to gaze! Thus a name change is of merit!! !! ונמצא שני פשטים ברש"י עולים בקנה אחד
'בראשית י"א ג....ותהי להם הלבנה לאבן
The ילקוט שמעוניsays on this פסוקthat !מלאכתם צלחה בידםThey were very successful in their work! They put down one אבןand
it became the width of two! From where did חז"לknow this?
The חנוכת התורהsays that the משנהin ב"בbegins with בונין את הכותל באמצע, !השותפין שרצו לעשות מחיצה בחצרIf they built walls from
אבן, ()גויל, its thickness is 6 טפחיםand each שותףcontributes 3 טפחיםof his own. If they used לבניםto build the כותל, since a לבנהis only
3 טפחיםwide, each שותףcontributes 1.5 טפחים. We see from here that a לבנהis half the width of an !אבן3= לבנהand =אבן6! The פסוקtells
us ...ותהי להם הלבנה לאבן. They put down a לבנהand it turned into an אבןwhich is twice the size! Now that is !מלאכתם צלחה בידם
בראשית ו' ט"ז......צהר תעשה לתיבה
רש"יtells us that either he made a window or he installed an אבן טובה. This was to illuminate the תיבה. However, רש"יtells us
( )ח' כ"בthat during the time of the מבול, the zodiac was not in operation. (( לא שמשו המזלות ולא היה ניכר בין יום ובין לילהOne couldn’t
even tell between day & night. If so, asks the רא"םwhat was the purpose of installing a window if there was no light? Also, how then
was נחable to keep a calendar as it says ... ?ויהי מקץ ארבעים יום ויפתחHe also asks, that on ראש השנה, he looked out the window to see if
the water was drying up, did he have night vision equipment? Finally, how did he send a bird out into the night without being able to see
or on what to land, it was a יונה, not an ?עטלף
The שפתי חכמיםanswers that that that רש"יsays לא שמשו המזלותdoesn’t mean it wasn’t operational, rather it was illuminating but in its
place. It stopped rotating. So half the world was light for 12 months and half the world was dark for 12 months! This is מדוייקas it says
לא שמשוand not לא האירו. The " "לא הכיר בין יום ובין לילהmeans in one area was total יום, and in the other area was total לילה.
However, this only answers the light issue, what about the keeping time & calendar issue? He answers either through the animals noises
as donkeys bray the first משמורה, and roosters wake us up at dawn or he had some type of סגולת אבן טובהlike משה רבינוhad, or שהיה לו
שעון בתיבה. He had a clock, which in those days was a sundial, in the !תיבהHe ends !!וד' יראני נפלאות מתורתו
Fregt der Munkatcher in שו"ת מנחת אלעזר ח"ד ס' מ"ג, his פשטof a sundial is laughable,""מביא לידי גיחוך, if the sun is stationary, a sundial
is “obsolete”, as the shade doesn’t move along the clock? He answers that one must say that נחhad a “watch” ( מסתמאah goldeneh tash
Zeiger) like ours (in the Munkatcher’s days, there were no battery watches) and when 24 hours went by, they kept a calendar. "דאין כל
!!חדש תחת השמש" מוסב גם על המכונות ותחבולות המתחדשות שכלם היו לעולמיםThis would make a great riddle!
בראשית י"א י"א....ויולד בנים ובנות...ויחי שם אחרי...אלה תולדות שם
By שםand by all his descendants, it says ויולד בנים ובנותbut it does not say וימת. This differs from ’שםs grandparents and
ancestors where it says וימתby each one! Why?
The ( ספר בית יצחקBlue, printed by )ספרייתיbrings from a ספר זכרון שמואלthat asks this קשיאand answers this question with a
very interesting שם בן נח !ילקוטusing the powers of שמות הקדושיםentered גן עדן התחתוןand ate from the !!!!!!!עץ החייםWhen it came
his time to die, he was מרגישthis and wanted to see what would now be his fate, so he went out into the מדברto see. He didn’t die, but
couldn’t really live. He was stuck & couldn’t move, & no one knew of his plight! Until שלמה המלךruled, & was told about his situation.
He immediately set out to search for שםas he knew that this situation was very painful for שםas he doesn’t have his complete !תיקוןBut
he couldn’t find him until he realized that one of the mountains was shaped as a person but covered with grass & other vegetation. שלמה
approached the mountain and asked, Are you ?שם בן נחHe answered yes and told him this whole story. He asked שלמהto bury him so
he could have a תיקון, & while שלמהwas doing this, שםasked him what was all the noise & why was the world shaking so in year 2448?
שלמהtold him, that was !מתן תורהHe took שםto ארץ ישראלand buried him there!
So, now we can understand why it didn’t say by שםthe word וימתas he never died till way later! But he really wasn’t living,
therefore it only counts the years he lived until he was supposed to die! The rest was !!לא מת ולא חיOnce the תורהstarted this style by
שם, it continued it until !!!!סוף הפרשה
בראשית ט' י"ג...את קשתי נתתי בענן והיתה לאות ברית ביני ובין הארץ
The וועלטis bothered by the wisdom of using a rainbow for a ‘sign’ as a rainbow is a natural phenomenon as whenever
there is a sun shower or the sun shines through thin clouds there is a rainbow! Also, is הקב"הintroducing the rainbow? Was it never
shown in the world before?
ר' יונתן אייבשיץis מתרץin his יערות דבש ח"א דרוש י"בin the name of the זוהרthat there are 2 types of rainbows. There
is the famous colorful rainbow & there is the special תכלתrainbow! This blue rainbow is the אותthat ' דswore He will show when He
wants to bring a תכלת !מבולis from the לשוןof כליהsignaling that the דורis ראויfor !כליון ח"וAnd there is a תכליתin showing this rainbow
as a sign in order to arouse !תשובהAnd one must be a מומחהto discern which rainbow is being shown & if there is a need to do תשובה.
לפי ר' יהונתן, says the בן איש חי, one would only make the special ברכהon the blue & קשתsince we aren’t מומחה, we should only make
the ברכהwithout שם ומלכותwhich is not the !מנהג העולם
רש"יin אבות פ"ה מ"וsays that the קשתwas created in the days of נחafter the !מבולSo too learns the אבן עזרא. This
לכאורהis Shver from the משנהthat says ..והקשת.. ?עשרה דברים נבראו בערב שבת בין השמשותOne must answer that of course it was created
in ששת ימי בראשיתbut only the potential like the פי האתוןetc.
& רב סעדיה גאוןthe ספר הברית & רמב"ןall learn that of course there was a קשתfrom ששת ימי בראשיתbut it wasn’t used
as an !אות ומופתThe ראיהis it says נתתי בענן-I already put it in the cloud!
So what was the חידושof the קשתnow? The אבן עזרא ט' י"דsays that after the מבול, the sun got stronger & was able to
shine through the clouds producing a much sharper rainbow! The ' דרשת הר"ן אsays that לפני המבול, it was in the air & after the מבולit
was in the !ענן
But what I wanted to share with you, our חשובעreader, is the !הייליגע רמ"אThe רמ"אwrites in his ס' תורת העולה ח"ב
פ"דthat of course the Rainbow was created during ששת ימי בראשיתbut in order to have a rainbow, it must rain during the day. But if it
rains at night, then you’ll never have a rainbow! חז"לtold us ( )ב"ר פל"ה ס"בon the פסוקof ונתתי מטר ארצכם בעתו, that בעתוmeans the
correct time which is לילי רביעיות ולילי שבתות. So when the חז"לtell us that no one saw a קשתduring the days of ר' שמעון בר יוחאי, it
doesn’t mean that it didn’t rain all the years that רשב"יlived but rather it rained during his time, only at night! This was the sign! When
people are חוטא, it will rain by day which is not & בעתוyou’ll see the !קשתIn other words, before the מבול, it only rained at night, so they
never saw a rainbow! But now if the דורis חוטא, it will rain in the day & you’ll get to see the rainbow!
'בראשית ו' כ... מהעוף למינהו ומן הבהמה למינה מכל רמש האדמה למינהו שנים מכל יבאו אליך להחיות
The : גמ' סנהדרין ק"חtells us that אליעזר עבד אברהםasked שם בן נח, how in the world were you able to prepare & feed all
the creatures their required foods while in the תיבהduring that year? שםthen told him what they went through, some fed in the day, some
only at night 'וכו' וכו. During their conversation, שםtold him about the אורשינהbird. רש"יtells us the name used in תנ"ךfor this bird is the
& חולit never dies! The גמראtells us why! נחnoticed that this bird was not putting any pressure on נחfor food. So נחasked the bird, why
are you quiet, you don’t need food? The bird answered, I saw that you’re very busy so I didn’t want to bother you! נחwas so touched that
he Bentched the bird, You should never die! This is what it means in איוב כ"ט י"ח, וכחול ארבה ימים, they should have long life like the חול
bird!
However, in ' מדרש רבה פי"ט הwe find a different reason for the חולnot dying! The מדרשsays that not only did חוהfeed
the עץ הדעתto אדם הראשוןbut she also fed all the creatures of the world ( רש"יbrings this on the word גם לאשהto include them), except the
דבי ר' ינאי !חולsay it lives 1000 years & at then a fire erupts in its nest & the bird gets burned & only a size of a כביצאremains & then it
grows new limbs & the cycle continues! ר' יודן בר"שagrees but says it disintegrates in lieu of the fire!
Fregt der מהרש"א, the ' גמseems to say it lives forever due to ’נחs & ברכהthis is contradicted from the מדרשthat says it lives
forever as it never ate from the !?עץ הדעתThe יפה תוארon the מדרשanswers, either they are מדרשות חלוקותor ’נחs ברכהmade it that this
bird doesn’t die even if it’s pierced with an arrow! So לפיthe יפה תוארthe bird got 2 things going for it! It lives forever as it didn’t eat
from the & עץ הדעתit doesn’t die even if it’s shot! The תורת חייםanswers the סתירהthat without the ברכהof נח, it would have died and
been reborn after the fire but with ’נחs ברכה, it never dies!
In the מדרש בראשית רבתי כ"ד ל"דwe find the מדרשtelling us of ‘13’, who didn’t taste מיתהand one of them is ( מלחם העוףanother
name for the )אורשינה. She doesn’t die because when חוהoffered her some fruit of the עץ הדעת, she declined her offer! So הקב"הsaid, I
will let this bird & its children live forever in order that they will be a & דוגמאwill be able to testify לעתיד לבאthe זכותיםof כלל ישראל. And
the bird still lives in the same city in which the מלאך המותbuilt & has all her offspring with her there and renews itself after 1000 years!
לפיthis מדרש, we can understand how this bird was able to withstand ‘not eating’ in the תיבהas it didn’t need food to survive!
The חיד"אin his ( מדבר קדמות )מערכת ח' אות א' ערך חולbrings the ' צמח צדיק פרק לthat says this bird lives only 315 years & when it
is almost out of strength, it makes a new nest out of עצי בשמים, enters it, faces the sun & flaps its wings until the nest goes on fire! It does
this very determined even though it knows it will get burned as it also knows it will be reborn again! Nine days after the fire, a worm
emerges from the ash & at the end of 30 days, it becomes a חולbird once more! AND there is only ONE bird of this מיןin the world!
(')וצ"ע ממדרש רבתי 'ופרין ורבין ככל הבריאות
The ( ס' שרידים מהגניזה עמ' פ"ב )שנת תרפ"בbrings from the גאונים, that this bird is the ''תסיל, a type of & יונהit’s an !עוף טהורIf so,
did נחShecht it for a קרבןafter the לפי ?מבולthe יפה תואר, of course not as it doesn’t die even if you Shecht it! And if the was only one
bird of this מין, also not, as נחonly brought קרבנותfrom those that came ‘7’ into the תיבה, to keep the מיןfrom extinction! This שיטהdoesn’t
work with the יפה תוארas if it’s a יונהone may bring it as a ( קרבןSee . )חולין ס"בso we see a תסילcan die! And it doesn’t work with the
צמח צדיקas he says there is only one in the world & the : גמ' חולין ק"מsays ? יונה על ביצי תסיל מהו,בעי ר' זירא, is the finder מחוייבin ?שילוח הקן
So we see that the תסילlays eggs to hatch so it cannot be the !חול
בראשית ו' ט"ז...צֹ הַ ר תַּ ﬠֲשֶׂ ה לַתֵּ בָ ה
רש"יbrings from the מדרש בראשית רבה ל"א י"אa מחלוקת. One מאן דאמרsays it was a window & the other מאן דאמר
says it was an illuminating stone. We have another מחלוקתin the פרשהon the words צדיק תמים היה בדורותיוwhere the 'מדרש שם ל' ט
says יש דורשין לשבח ויש דורשין לגנאי.
I found the ילקוט האוריםsays that these two מחלוקתare תלוי הא בהא. לפיthe מאן דאמרthat is דורש לשבח, נחwas a צדיק
גמורyet לפיthe מאן דאמרthat is דורש לגנאי, נחwas not such a big צדיק. When ' דsaves a צדיקfrom a world calamity, the צדיקhas the
right to observe how ' דis destroying the רשעים. The Yidden watched the downfall of the מצריים, as it says (אשר עשה )דברים ד' ל"ד
לכם ד' אלקיכם במצרים לעיניך. If one is not a צדיק גמור, then viewing the punishment is not allowed as we see by אשת לוט, אל תביט אחריך
()בראשית י"ט י"ז. Therefore, the יש דורשין לשבחlearn that נחinstalled a window in order to view the !חורבן המבולHowever, the יש
דורשין לגנאיlearn that it must have been a stone as נחwasn’t a & צדיק גמורwasn’t allowed to watch the destruction. רבי יוחנןwho is
דורש לגנאיis the מאן דאמרin (. )סנהדרין ק"חwho says it was an !אבן טובה
However, I saw from ר' אליהו קלצקין זצ"ל, a תלמידof the מהר"ם אשthat he wants to say it’s תלויin a different מחלוקת
between ריש לקיש & רבי יוחנן. רבי יוחנןholds ריש לקיש & חצי שיעור אסור מן התורהholds !חצי שיעור מותר מן התורה
The : גמ' סנהדרין נ"חsays that a גוי ששבתis חייב מיתהas it says in our פרשה, (יום ולילה לא ישבתו )ח' כ"ב. The מפרשיםask,
the : גמ' יומא כ"חsays that אברהם אבינוwas מקיים כל התורה כולה. If so, how was he ?שומר שבתIt was before & מתן תורהhe had a דיןof
a & גויa גויthat rests on שבתis עוברon a לאו. If so, would אברהםbe ר' עקיבא איגר )השמטה לתשובות ס' קכ"א( ?חייב מיתהanswers that
אברהם אבינוdid a חצי שיעורof מלאכה. Therefore, מצד ישראל, he wasn’t מחלל שבתbut לגביa בן נחresting on שבת, he worked! Therefore,
he was not עוברon the & לאוis not חייב מיתה.
However, this only works if we say like ריש לקישthat חצי שיעורis מותר מן התורה. But לפי ר' יוחנן, doing a חצי שיעור
מלאכהon שבתis also ?אסור מן התורהZugt ר' אליהו קלצקין, let’s answer this with another מחלוקתin our !פרשה
The מדרשsays on the פסוקof אמר ר' יוחנן לא שימשו ;עוד כל ימי הארץ זרע וקציר וקור וחום וקיץ וחורף ויום ולילה לא ישבתו
אמר לו רבי יונתן שימשו אלא שלא היה רישומן ניכר.המזלות כל אותן י"ב חודש. If so, לפי ר' יוחנן, that the מזלותdidn’t work at all during the year
duration of the מבול, he can’t also Darshen גוי ששבת חייב מיתה שנא' יום ולילה לא ישבתוas this פסוקis a promise from ' דthat the מזלות
will never again cease from operating like they did during the !מבולBut לפיthe מ"דthat the מזלותdid operate during the מבולbut
weren’t noticeable (they shined but weren’t moving around), why does it say ?יום ולילה לא ישבתוIt must be coming to tell us that
!גוי ששבת חייב מיתה
If so, ריש לקישwho holds חצי שיעור מותר מן התורהlearns יום ולילה לא ישבתוto teach us גוי ששבת חייב מיתה. And אברהם
אבינוkept שבתby doing a חצי שיעור, which is מותר לישראל ואסור לבן נח. רבי יוחנןwho holds חצי שיעור אסור מן התורהcan’t answer that
אברהםdid a !חצי שיעורHe must learn that לא ישבתוis not a & לאוthere is no איסורfor a גויto rest on לא ישבתו !שבתis just a הבטחה
that the מזלותwill never stop!
Let’s tie it together! ר' יוחנןwho says the מזלות לא שימשוat all, he would say that the צהרcouldn’t mean a window
as there was no light illuminating from the sun moon or stars! אלא מאי, an illuminating stone was installed! ריש לקישwho holds חצי
שיעור מותר מן התורהcan hold that the מזלותdid indeed operate that year & therefore נחinstalled a window which brought in the light
from the מזלותthat were operating! בראשית ז' כ"ג...וַיִ שָּׁ אֶ ר אַ � נֹ חַ ַואֲשֶׁ ר ִאתּוֹ בַּ תֵּ בָ ה
רש"יtells us three מהלכיםin the word אך. Either it means לבד, alone, as since ' דdestroyed everything else in the world, נח
was physically alone. Or the מדרש אגדהsays גונח וכוהה דםpanting & coughing blood from exhaustion of tending to all the animals.
Finally, there is a יש אומריםthat he was bitten by the lion for being tardy with his food. These מהלכיםlearn the word אך, that נחwas
in pain! Physically deficient. But the חתם סופרlearns that it means that נחwas בצער, in mental pain. Once he learns that it means
pain, he wants to say his own מהלךwhy נחwas in pain!
In ז' ט"זthe פסוקsays ויסגור ד' בעדו. רש"יexplains that ' דsealed the תיבהfrom the water entering or He had vicious animals
protecting the תיבהfrom being broken by the דור המבול. The חתם סופרis & מסביר ע"פ פשטwas מכוויןto the חזקוני. נחdidn’t know when
every בריאהthat was supposed to be on the תיבהwas on board, so he left the door open & ' דclosed it as ' דknew when all were on
board. But the חת"סwants to say another מהלךbased on the :'גמ' ברכות י. חזקיהו המלךasked הקב"הto protect ירושליםin his own זכות,
as he felt he deserved it. He said, יתי ִ ְזכָר נָא אֵ ת אֲשֶׁ ר הִ ְתהַ לַּכְ ִתּי לְ ָפנֶי� בֶּ אֱמֶ ת וּבְ לֵב שָׁ לֵם וְ הַ טּוֹב בְּ ﬠֵינֶי� ﬠ ִָשׂbut ' דdisagreed with him, ַנּוֹתי ﬠַל
ִ וְ ג
הוֹשׁיﬠָהּ לְ מַ ֲﬠנִי וּלְ מַ ﬠַן דָּ וִ ד ﬠַבְ דִּ י
ִ ְהָ ﬠִ יר הַ זּ ֹאת ל. Says ריב"ל, אפי' בשעה ששיגר לו הקב"ה שלום מר הוא לו. It was a bitter pill for חזקיהו המלךto
swallow. Why was חזקיהוdisappointed? פשטות, it’s because he felt that he wasn’t on the מדרגהthat was required, for the ישועהto
come in his own !זכותWe see from this גמרא, that when a person gets a חסדfrom ' & דit’s not בזכות עצמוbut rather בזכותothers, it’s
a cause of !צערThe חת"סpoints out in פ' וירא, that there’s a נפקא מינהif one is saved בזכות עצמוor בזכות אחרים. May one see the מפלה
of the others? If it’s בזכות עצמו, that indicates that you are totally different than the others & ממילאyou can watch the מדת הדיןof 'ד
while He punishes them. However, if it’s בזכות אחרים, then you yourself are barely being saved & you’re really part of those being
punished. Then you can’t watch their מפלהsince there is a common denominator between you & them, it becomes much harder to
save you! (The הפלאהsays this is מרומזin שׂנְאָ י ֹ ְתהלים קי"ח ז' – ד' לִ י בְּ עֹ ז ְָרי ַו ֲאנִי אֶ ְראֶ ה ב. If ' דis helping me בזכות עצמי, then & only then
ואני אראה בשנאיcan I look at the destruction of my enemies!)
How was נחsaved? בזכות עצמוor ?בזכות אחריםThe חת"סsays it was בזכות אחרים. He says it’s ( בזכות דודit might be a typo as
he’s talking about דודearlier by חזקיהו- it might have been בזכות דורות הבאיםwhich is what the מדרשsays on the פסוקof ונח מצא חן
')בעיני ד. This is also found in מוסף דר"ה, 'להרבות זרעו וגו...וגם את נח באהבה זכרת. נחleft the door open so he can see out & see the מפלה
of the !רשעיםTo see a מופתof ' כבוד דis a מצוהlike we find by a סוטהthat’s blowing up. However, ' דdisagreed & ויסגור ד' בעדו, 'ד
shut the door as you’re not worthy of seeing as you’re not being saved !בזכות עצמךWhen נחrealized that he was not worthy, he was
full of pain! That is the pain we are referring to in the פסוקof !וישאר אך נחHe was happy that he was being saved but !אךHis שמחה
was not full as he was in pain about his own status! He knew this meant that he was only being saved & בזכות דורות הבאיםnot in his
own תורת משה ב"כ !זכות
בראשית ז' כ"ג...וַיִ שָּׁ אֶ ר אַ � נֹ חַ וַאֲ שֶׁ ר ִאתּוֹ בַּ תֵּ בָ ה
רש"יtells us (2 )מהלךthat נחgot bitten by the lion because he brought him his food late! We must understand נח. He must have
nd
been pretty געשיקטrunning such a large operation. If he knew he was running late, why is he leaving the lion for last? He should have left
the mouse for last, as what could the mouse do to him? But the lion? One bite can handicap him for the next 150 years?
I heard from my uncle, הג"ר משה רבינוביץ זצ"ל, that when נחbegan this whole operation, he realized that in about a half hour, the
animals will organize a mutiny & his head is going to roll. Therefore, he went & befriended the lion, the king of all the animals & ממילא,
when the animals saw that נחwas a friend of their king, they let him run the show! Over the year, נחbecame very chummy with the lion
who became part of his family. The tendency of most people is that they will do חסדfor the whole world while their own family loses
out! They feel that they’re not & מקפידthey are sharing in my & מצוהmany other rationales. The Lion let נחknow that this מהלךis wrong!
Yes, I’m your friend & part of your family. But that doesn’t give you the power to make me suffer! Next time, I’ll be served first!
The Ostrovtze Gaon has a marvelous מהלך. What was the significance of a lion biting נח. The : גמ' יומא כ"אtells us that during בית
ראשון, the smoke of the מזבחwould hover over the מזבחlike a lion. During בית שני, it was like a dog. The ביאורin this גמראis, the אריז"ל
writes that the עשן המערכהprotected כלל ישראלfrom doing !עבירותThe difference of the two protections is, when a lion protects his master,
the lion does all the work! He roars & if the unwanted guest remains, he eats the guest for supper. Yet the dog doesn’t have that power.
Rather, the dog will bark & be מעוררthe master that there is a & סכנהhe should come fend for himself!
This was the חילוקbetween בית ראשון & בית שני. By בית ראשון, the עשן המערכהprotected the Yidden from being חוטאwithout a
פעולהof כלל ישראל. But by בית שני, it was רובץ ככלב, which implies that it was only מעוררus that we should be vigilant, not to sin.
The (. זוהר הקדוש )זוה"ח נח כ"טsays that הקב"הresented נחfor not begging & Davening for the people of his דורlike משהDavened
for the דור המדבר. נחjust built the & תיבהwaited for the people to be & נתעוררdo תשובהthemselves. So, his התעוררותwas like the '!'כלב
Therefore, he got a ''הכישו ארי, because he wasn’t בבחינת אריto save his דור. This was his !פגם
בראשית ז' י"ז...ִשׂאוּ אֶ ת הַ תֵּ בָ ה וַתָּ ָרם מֵ ַﬠל הָ אָ ֶרץ
ְ ַו ְיהִ י הַ מַּ בּוּל אַ ְרבָּ ﬠִ ים יוֹם ַﬠל הָ אָ ֶרץ ַויּ ְִרבּוּ הַ מַּ יִם ַויּ
Just a few questions on the story of the מבול. 1. If the rain stopped on כ"ז כסלו, why didn’t נחremove the cover to the תיבהfor the
next 10 months? This is even more Shver after י"ז סיוןwhen the תיבהlanded on the ground? 2. Why did he need to send out the עורבand
יונהto see if there’s still water on the ground, let him take off the cover of the & תיבהsee? 3. More Shver is when he opened the window
to send out the birds, why couldn’t he stick his head out the window & see for himself? 4. If the עורבdidn’t go on his mission, why didn’t
נחsend out the יונהright away? Why did he wait 7 days? 5. When he sent out the יונה, it says לראות 'הקלו המים' מעל פני האדמה, while in the
end, it uses a different לשון, והנה 'חרבו פני האדמה' & חרבו המים מעל הארץ. Why the change in ?לשונות6. Why did נחneed a ציוויto leave the
תיבה, if it was dry outside, why remain jailed in the ?תיבה7. If the purpose of the מבולwas to destroy the רשעים, why did ' דneed so much
water until it rose 15 אמותabove the highest mountain, 3-4 אמותwould have sufficed? It seems that there is a message here! 8. We find
in 'בר"ר ל"ג ז, that חז"לwere very busy calculating how much the תיבהwas immersed below the sea line – 11 אמות. Who cares? What’s the
חילוקif it was 5 אמותor 20 ?אמותWhatever it was, it was! 9. The : גמ' סנהדרין ק"חtells us that תחתיים לזבל אמצעים לבהמה עליונים לאדם. Why
did נחneed to have an entire floor to house the trash? He had a window & could have dumped all the waste in no-man’s land?! And even
if he couldn’t open the window during the rain, but after 40 days, he could have. So technically, he only needed a small trash area for 40
days, why did he have to dedicate an entire floor?
In the brand new ספר ברכת יעקב עה"ת – בראשית, my dear friend ( ר' ברוך יעקב געשטעטנער שליט"אHe has already put out many ספרים
on & מועדיםon a few )פרשיות, has a wonderful חז"ל !מהלךtell us, (' אנדרלמוסיא באה לעולם והורגת טובים ורעים )בר"ר כ"ו ה,כל מקום שיש זנות. As
we find by הפיכת סדום, the four major cities were turned over plus !כל ערי הככרAny one that had a שייכותwith סדוםwas included! If there
is a תפיסת ידwith the רשעים, it is not spared! Therefore, the actual earth of this planet, also had to be destroyed! (3 טפחיםas since that is
the plow’s depth, that is the תפיסת ידof the )אדם. That’s why the destruction was through water as a virus wouldn’t have been able to do
that trick!
Although נחwas a צדיק, he didn’t have enough צדקותto go unscathed in the מבול. He therefore needed to be in a bubble, and not
be able to be connected at all with what was going on outside! And just like by סדום, לוטwas warned not to observe in the actual destruction
as that would tie him to them lest he would be connected to them & suffer the same fate as them. So too, נחcouldn’t observe the מבול, the
destruction & the results, (Everything was washed away leaving no bodies or anything for that matter), until it was totally over & there
was a new planet! That is why it was ויסגור ד' בעדו, as he was now considered totally unconnected with ‘them’! The תיבהwas lifted off
planet earth totally separating נחfrom his generation! Therefore, he was not allowed to take off the cover of the תיבהuntil the ground was
dry & no זכרof the מבולwas left! ממילא, he needed an entire floor to house a year’s worth of debris!
Therefore, the תיבהhad to be lifted to 15 אמותabove the highest mountain, for חז"לfigured out that the bottom of the תיבהwas
immersed in the water 11 אמות, which leaves it 4 אמותabove the mountain. That is the שיעורof תפיסת אדםas a man is 3 & אמותhe can
stretch his hands out, another ( אמה: !)תוס' שבת צ"בNow, נחis considered מובדל ומופרד לגמריfrom his בני דורו, thereby saving him from !כליון
As long as נחhad a ספקif there is still a זכרof pre מבולdays, he wasn’t allowed to look at the earth. He knew that one wrong step
&… (What happened to )?אשת לוטHe therefore was very busy sending out the & עורבthe יונה, as maybe the עורבwould return with a
piece of נבלהin its mouth! When that didn’t work, he waited another week, to let the water disappear more! When the יונהreturned with
an olive branch, נחknew that הקלו המיםbut it’s still not dry! Once the יונהdidn’t return, נחknew that a יונהcan live in a tree, but it needs
to walk around on the ground & it must be that there is no more water on the ground! The ground is finally dry! Off came the cover of
the !תיבהHe can see the world again as the destruction is over & he is no longer in danger!
But he couldn’t walk on the ground as there was a lot of water in the ground (see )רש"י. If he stepped on the ground & מי מבול
came out & touched him, he would have an אחיזהin the & מי המבולcould get hurt from it! Though he could look at the ground as he saw
no water. He waited another 57 days until ' דtold him, it’s totally dry! Get out!
This also explains why the רוקחsays that נחbrought a lot of water into the תיבהas ויעש נח ככל אשר צוה אותוis בגימטריא, אפילו מים.
Couldn’t נחmake a contraption to get water from the outside? The answer is, the water on the outside was heated by נח & גיהנםcouldn’t
afford to have any שייכותwith anything that was part of the !מבולInstead, he was lugging barrels & barrels of water to have a drinking
supply for the next year!
'ז-'בראשית ט' ו...וְ אַ תֶּ ם פְּ רוּ ְוּרבוּ ִשׁ ְרצוּ בָ אָ ֶרץ ְוּרבוּ בָ הּ..שׁ ֵפ� דַּ ם הָ אָ דָ ם בָּ אָ דָ ם דָּ מוֹ יִשָּׁ ֵפ� כִּ י ְבּצֶ לֶם ֱא�הִ ים ﬠָשָׂ ה אֶ ת הָ אָ דָ ם
ֹ
(Heard at a וועדfrom )הג"ר ארון רייך שליט"א. Someone who kills another person, deserves to be killed…and you, be fruitful and
multiply. רש"יsays that although it says previously in 'פסוק א, ויברך אלקים את נח ואת בניו ויאמר להם פרו ורבו, that was a ברכהbut our פסוקis a
ציווי, a commandment. רש"יthen brings a מדרשto explain the juxtaposition between these two verses, להקיש מי שאינו עוסק בפריה ורביה
!לשופך דמיםSimply put, both פסוקיםgive us an understanding of the sanctity of life!
However, ר' מאיר שמחהbrings an astounding פשטin these פסוקים. He brings the גמראat the end of חזקת הבתים, :'ב"ב ס, 'תניא אמר ר
דין הוא שנגזור על עצמנו שלא לישא אשה ולהוליד... ומיום שפשטה מלכות הרשעה שגוזרת עלינו גזירות רעות וקשות ומבטלת ממנו תורה ומצות...ישמעאל בן אלישע
בנים ונמצא זרעו של אברהם אבינו כלה מאליו אלא הנח להם לישראל מוטב שיהיו שוגגין ואל יהיו מזידין. רש"יexplains that it would be better if כלל ישראל
was extinguished naturally than through the barbaric acts of the !גויםInstead of having children, that will get persecuted by the אומות
העולםin terrible ways, it would be better for us to slow the rate of having children, as תוספותsays, just be מקיים פרו ורבו, this would seem
to be the most appropriate way. Zugt ר' מאיר שמחה, that the פסוקיםhere are teaching us that this is not the way to go. The אומות העולםspill
our blood. We’ve gone through so many eras, in which our blood has been spilled like water, ד' ינקום דמם. Says the פסוק, those that murder,
deserve to be killed, כי בצלם אלקים עשה את האדם. But then the פסוקadds a word, ואתם, YOU, you should ignore that! Your approach should
not be that if the אומות העולםare creating such difficulties for us, then let’s just stop having children. No! ואתם פרו ורבו שרצו בארץ ורבו בה.
Leave the punishment to Hashem, and כלל ישראלshould do what’s incumbent upon them, פרו ורבוeven in times of אף בשעה שיש !סכנה
. אין לכם להביט על זה כי אנכי אדרוש את נפש האדם,שפיכת דם הרבה. Hashem will take the proper revenge!
He brings the שאילתית רב אחאי גאוןin פ' וזאת הברכה, that says; How do we know that there’s a מצוהto get married? The שאילתית
brings a פסוקin 'ירמיה כ"ט ו, קְ חוּ נ ִָשׁים וְ הוֹלִ ידוּ בָּ נִים וּבָ נוֹת. This is a פלאas the שאילתיתshould have brought the פסוקof ע"ש העמק שאלה ?פרו ורבו
וכל המפרשים. But the משך חכמהsays, the שאילתיתmeans, how do we know that even in a time of שמד, of persecution, we should still marry
& have children. He then brings from ירמיה, who at the beginning of גלות בבלtold כלל ישראל, to get married & have children. This message
was so powerful, for all the Yidden who came after WWII, who didn’t have the emotional energy to rebuild, remarry & bring up a new
משפחה.
On a personal note, my mother (nee Shternbuch) got married during the war in Southport England, away from London. She had
3 brothers, ר' אלי, ר' משה,ר' דוב. During שבע ברכות, on ליל שבת, Reb אליwas walking with his older brother ר' משה שטערנבוך שליט"א, who
was at the time a בחורin ’ר' משה שניידרs & ישיבהhe spoke to him with great passion, אלי, why are they getting married in such a situation
with bombs falling on all sides? We don’t know if we’ll be alive tomorrow! Who knows where כלל ישראלis headed? The answer is,
because we have !אמונה בהקב"הWe have to do what we have to do!! While the Nazis will do what they want, הקב"הwill give us סייעתא
!דשמיאThis כלה- חתןwill be one of many who will forge ahead, have children and continue !כלל ישראלThis is the message of the משך
!חכמה
באמת, this משך חכמהis פארקערטfrom the גמראwho says that we get married only !משום מוטב שיהיו שוגגיןHe actually brings the
הגהות מיימניתin הל' קדושין, that says that even though we’re נוהגnot like the גמרא, if someone is childless & doesn’t get divorced, we look
away because of this !גמראMaybe the חילוקis that the גמראis talking about גזירת הדתwhile we’re talking about גזירת הריגה & גזירת השמד.
These גזירותnever deterred us from continuing to do !מצוות
