Horeini - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

Parashas Noach 5787 לעילוי נשמת מנחם מנדל בן יהושע דב בס”ד
Weekly Torah forum
to deepen halachic
and ideological
knowledge and
to strengthen the
mitzvah of kibbud
Issue no. 146 av va’eim
Dibros
Dibros Kodshecha
Kodshecha
Kibbud Av V’eim in the Parshah
Way of Life
ַוָּיּ ָָמת ֶּּת ַַרח ְּּב ָָח ָָרן
Behind the And Terach died in Charan (11:32)
Scene Rashi notes that Terach died more than sixty years after Avraham left
Charan for Canaan. Yet the Torah records Terach’s death first so that
people would not accuse Avraham of abandoning his elderly father or
In Our Fathers’
failing to honor him. It describes Terach as already dead because the
Footsteps
wicked are considered dead even during their lifetimes.
Rabbi Yonasan Eybeschutz notes in his introduction, regarding
Toras Imecha Avraham leaving his father for Canaan, that according to the Rambam,
while a child is exempt from striking or cursing a wicked father, the
fundamental duty to honor him still remains.
1
Mussar Avicha He cites the Beis Yosef and the Taz on the Rambam’s view, referencing
the Talmudic discussion of a thief who feeds his children stolen food
and gives them stolen goods. The Talmud states that upon the father’s
V’heishiv Lev death, the children are exempt from repayment. However, if one of the
stolen items is clearly recognizable to everyone—such as a garment or
a cow—the children must return it out of respect for their father, as
keeping the item would be a disgrace to their father. The Talmud then
asks why they are obligated to rectify his bad reputation given that he
was a thief and a wicked person.
Bracha and Hatzlacha
Moshe Avraham ben
The Beis Yosef and the Taz raise a question on this Gemara. If the
Ahuva Rambam rules that one must honor even an unrighteous father, why
Zivug does the Gemara question whether children are obligated to return
Nechama bas Shoshana stolen property to fulfill that duty?
Refuah Shleima Rabbi Yonasan Eybeschutz explains that the Rambam holds that one
Nechama Sara bas Katie must honor a wicked father only because of —מראית עיןsince an onlooker
Bracha Fortuna cannot tell whether the father is wicked or righteous, the son is bound
Zera Shel Kayama to honor him. Thus, Rabbi Yonasan Eybeschutz says the Gemara’s
Anonymous difficulty is easy to understand. Rashi comments that the whole basis
Iluy Neshama for requiring the children to return their father’s stolen property is so
Zev Dovid ben Pinchas that people should not say, “This is so-and-so whom he robbed,”.
Menachem Mendel ben
Yehoshua Dov
(continued on page 2..)
Rabbi Yonasan Eybeschutz also explains Avram’s Therefore, Chazal state that it became publicly
departure from his father Terach. Avram wasn’t known that Terach had died; consequently, there
obligated to honor his father, who was wicked and was no longer any concern of מראית עיןrequiring
an idolater. Rather, according to the Rambam, Avram to honor him.
the obligation exists solely because of מראית עין. . ובסוגיא בבא מציעא ס”ב. סי’ ר”מ ס”ק י”ז.1
Just as it is the duty of every Jew to learn the halachos applicable to
Way of Life everyday life, from berachos and Shabbos to shemiras halashon, so
is he obligated to learn and review the laws of kibbud av va’eim, a
Kibbud Av Va’eim in
constant and very serious mitzvah. Neglecting this study is liable to
Halachah and Minhag lead the person to unwittingly violate many halachos.
Based on the sefer Vayevarech David, by the gaon Rabbi Yisrael David Harfenes, moreh
tzedek and rabbi of the “Yisrael VeHazmanim” synagogue and community in Williamsburg
Just as one should not refuse food or a request whenever a father offers his son meat or a similar
when offered by a prominent person, one should delicacy, the son must accept it without hesitation.
not refuse one’s own father. Therefore, when a father This principle is taught in Pesachim (86a): “מסרבין
offers his son food, the son should not refuse. But — ”לקטן ואין מסרבין לגדולone may decline an offering
if he wants his father to eat and enjoy it himself, from a minor but not from an adult. All the more
he may decline once; if his father insists, he must so regarding the Torah obligation to honor one’s
accept. father: a son should never refuse what his parents
If a father asks his son to be the Chazan and the offer.
son is a baal tefillah, he should not refuse. Even if However, the situation differs when the meat was
he is not a baal tefillah, he should do so on week- originally brought out specifically for the father,
days when no special chazanus is needed, provided and only upon seeing his son did he decide to pass it
it would not distract his concentration during his along out of love for his son. In that case, the son is
1
davening. The Chut Shani states that if a father asks permitted to decline once, since he wants his father
his son to say a Dvar Torah at the Shabbos table, to enjoy the meat.
the son is obligated to do so because his father de- His attempt to refuse shows his deep love for his
rives pleasure from it. This is what constitutes the father, echoing the pasuk, “The son’s love for his fa-
mitzvah of honoring one’s father; the son fulfills the ther is a form of honor.” Even so, he should decline
Torah commandment of Kibbud Av Va’eim simply only once, briefly, so his father and everyone watch-
by bringing his father joy. ing understand that he wants his father to enjoy the
In Yosher Hori, the author elaborates on the idea food himself. If his father insists and gives it to him
of “a father offering his son some food” and offers anyway, he must accept it and eat it, because true
the following example. A CEO was being served honor means fulfilling whatever his father desires.
meat at a public gathering when his son entered the
room, and upon seeing him, the father offered the
meat to him instead. What should the son do? May “ — ”ארור כנען עבד עבדים יהיה לאחיוCursed is
he politely refuse so his father can have the meat Canaan; a servant of servants shall he be to
himself, or—even though he declines for his father’s his brothers. (9:25). What brought this curse
sake—is it strictly forbidden to refuse, requiring upon him? That he degraded his father’s hon-
him instead to accept and eat it immediately? or. (Midrash Tanchuma, section 15)
He answered: At first glance, one might assume that
1. יו”ט ע’ ער”ב
Parashas Noach 5787 // Issue no.146 // pg 2
V’heishiv Lev
Questions and Answers from the
Desk of Rabbanim and Therapists
Questions submitted on the “Lema’an
Yitav Lach” hotline (972-79-6077179)
?casual—and wants to hear our reaction. Should we
A parent shares an opinion—even about something
agree with them, or can we gently share our honest
opinion since they genuinely want to know what we
think?
>
If that is what they want, then doing so is an act
of honor, and agreeing with them does not violate
the prohibition against “omed bimkomo” standing in
their place. If one disagrees, they should always do so Behind the Scene
respectfully. Instead of saying, “I don’t agree with you,”
A maamar Chazal or
one can express disagreement more gently by saying, “I halachah related to
have different thoughts about it.” kibbud av va’eim is
concealed in the picture. Send in
the solution, and you’ll be entered
?something that conflicts with a personal kabbalah
What should you do if your mother requests
to win a prize!
you have taken upon yourself? For example, suppose
you have committed to davening Maariv at 8:00 every Solutions may be sent by
evening so you don’t forget. At 7:45, she asks you email to: riddle@horeinu.org
to run an errand or help with a task, thus making it fax to: 077-602-1640
impossible to keep your commitment. How should you
balance your personal commitment with the mitzvah of
honoring your parents?
You respectfully told your mother that this is your
kabbalah and that the timing doesn’t work for you, but
she didn’t agree with you davening then. She insists you
do whatever task she wants, even though she knows how
Solution to Behind the Scenes –
important your kabbalah is. When a personal kabbalah If a father is in a wheelchair, a child must stand
when he enters the room. This is because the
clashes with kibbud av va’eim, which takes precedence? halacha dictates that someone riding is regarded as
>
When dealing with a personal kabbalah—such as a walking; therefore, a person sitting in a wheelchair is
considered to be walking, obligating the children to
self-imposed schedule for Maariv—you are not facing stand out of respect (based on Shulchan 242)
a strict Torah obligation for that exact hour. Therefore,
kibbud av va’eim, a full d’Oraisa command, takes The raffle winners were informed of their win.
precedence over your voluntary routine. You should
adjust your schedule to fulfill your mother’s request and
adjust your kabbalah. When a parent’s request conflicts
with a mandatory mitzvah, such as Birchas Hamazon,
if you can still fulfill the mitzvah afterward, you should
honor your mother’s request first. But if helping her
would cause you to miss the obligation entirely (such as
missing the window of time permitted for bentching),
you are not required to listen to your mother, as you are
considered oseik b’mitzvah—busy doing another mitzvah
and cannot do both.
’ תנחומא האזינו סי’ ד.2 ירושלמי חגיגה פ”ב ה”א.1
Parashas Noach 5787 // Issue no.146 // pg 3
In Our Fathers’
Footsteps
True Stories of Kibbud Horim
Shlomo Hamelech Heeds His Mother’s every length to bring peace between his father and
Rebuke mother (within the permitted boundaries).
Midrash Rabbah (Naso, chapter 10) relates that on
the very night Shlomo Hamelech completed the
The Immediate Cash Reward!
construction of the Beis HaMikdash, he married
Letter to the editor:
Pharaoh’s daughter. The night was filled with joyous
We live in Yerushalayim, and during the second
celebration. As morning dawned, he overslept.
day of Yom Tov, we had the privilege of hosting
The people grew deeply distressed. It was the
my dear mother. On erev Yom Tov, late in the
morning of the dedication, yet the daily Korban
afternoon, we realized we had forgotten to buy a
Tamid could not be brought because Shlomo
box of the special chocolates she loves to distribute
Hamelech was asleep, and the keys to the Beis
to the grandchildren. As a rule, we don’t usually
HaMikdash lay beneath his head. Out of reverence
purchase such items because they are expensive. We
for the monarchy, no one dared wake him. Instead,
live frugally: my husband learns in the Mir Yeshiva,
they turned to his mother, Batsheva, who went in,
and I work in education. Baruch Hashem, we have
roused him from his sleep, and gently rebuked him.
what we need but no luxuries. Yet kibbud av va’eim is
Midrash Rabbah (Shemini, chapter 12) relates
not a luxury. My husband decided that even though
that his mother struck him with her shoes from
it was late on erev Yom Tov—and despite our usual
every direction to discipline and rebuke him. The
effort to finish shopping early to avoid the last-
Nechmad LeMar’eh explains that even though
minute rush—this mitzvah is precious. He headed
he was a king, he patiently endured his mother’s
to the nearby mall to buy the chocolates.
humiliation without a word of anger. He quietly
As he left the store and headed toward the bus
bore his mother’s disgrace without a word. Because
stop, an unfamiliar man—a well-to-do visitor from
of this, his fame spread throughout the world.
abroad—approached him and asked whether he
was learning in Kollel. When he answered yes, the
Bridging the Gap: Fostering Peace man pulled out an envelope with 2,000 shekels in
Between Parents cash and pressed it into my husband’s hand. “This
The Gemara (Yevamos 63) relates that the wife of is in honor of Yom Tov,” he said and walked away.
the great Amora Rav often distressed him. When We were zocheh to witness this special hug from
he asked her to prepare lentil stew, she would Hashem, who sent His messenger at that exact
deliberately make a legume stew instead, and vice moment, all because we refused to compromise on
versa. As their son, Rav Chiya, matured, Rav began the mitzvah of honoring my mother.
sending him to relay his requests to his mother. Rav
Chiya cleverly asked her for the opposite of what
his father had actually requested, so that she would
unknowingly prepare the right dish and thereby Get Horeinu
bring peace to the home.
Delivered to
Unaware of his son’s actions, Rav remarked that the
mother had finally become more considerate. Rav Your Inbox!
Chiya then revealed that he had been reversing the Horeinu’s weekly newsletter is
requests to fulfill his father’s wishes. Rav told his
available by email in English,
son that a child can sometimes be wiser than his
Hebrew, and Yiddish.
father, but instructed him not to do so any more,
quoting the pasuk: “They have trained their tongues To join our email list, write to
to speak falsehood”—one must not make a habit of us at: office@horeinu.org
telling untruths. As the Meah Shearim (Sha’ar 18) (Please specify English, Hebrew or Yiddish).
notes, this Gemara teaches that a child must go to
Parashas Noach 5787 // Issue no.146 // pg 4
written by Y. Binyamin
Mendy shares a story about Tatty and Mommy
and the mitzvah of kibbud av va’eim
I Am Not Cold at All
I love the shift toward cooler months as evenings “We aren’t living in Ramot anymore. Up there it’s
arrive earlier. The days still feel quite warm, but cold, but here in Beit Shemesh? I’m walking to
after sunset, a gentle crispness starts to blow. We shul, not to Siberia,” he said with a smile. Ima didn’t
close the windows, take out the blankets, and the argue. She replied, “All right.” And Abba stepped
familiar household debate begins over whether it out.
is actually cold yet. I was sitting in the living room reading a book. Chani
Then, out of nowhere, comes sat at the table doing her high
the day Ima decides summer school homework; Roni wasn’t
is over. It does not matter home yet; Leiby was busy
what the calendar says or that playing with lego on the floor;
the midday sun is still warm! and Nechama was trying to
Ima steps out onto the porch grab just about everything she
in the evening, stands there wasn’t supposed to touch—just
for about five seconds, walks a regular evening at home.
back inside, and declares, Then Ima opened the window,
“It’s starting to get chilly.” And and cool air drifted inside. “It
just like that, fall has officially really has become cold,” she
arrived. remarked. “Ima, if you ask
This week, it finally happened. me, it’s really not that cold.”
Nothing dramatic happened, “Mendy, you’re sitting inside.”
nobody was cold, and the A fair point—though I wasn’t
heavy coats stayed put. But about to admit it.
suddenly, it felt good to close Ima was folding laundry, and I
the window halfway, and the heard her say to herself, “Abba
floor felt cooler underfoot when I got out of bed will be heading back soon, and he’s going to be
in the morning. Leiby got excited and piped up, cold.”
“Yesss! Winter!” “Winter?” I asked. “What winter?” I returned my book. After a minute, I noticed the
“It’s cold.” “But it’s not cold.” “Yes, it is cold.” And scarf Ima had suggested Abba take was still on the
so, the debate began. chair. I imagined Abba walking home from shul, not
That evening, Abba was heading out for Maariv; he freezing, but chilly. At that moment, I had an idea.
put on his suit jacket and stood by the front door. “Ima, what time is Maariv over?” “Soon,” she said,
Ima looked at him and said, “Take something with looking up. “Why?” “Just checking.” I picked up
you.” “What do you mean?” “Maybe a scarf... the the scarf. “Where are you off to?” Ima asked. “To
evenings are getting cool.” Abba looked surprised. bring this to Abba.” Ima gave me a warm smile.
(continued on page 7..)
Parashas Noach 5787 // Issue no.146 // pg 5
“You really don’t have to.” “I don’t have to,” I told Ima even told me I didn’t have to go. But kibbud av
her. “I want to.” va’eim isn’t just about obligations; it means thinking
I stepped outside. It wasn’t quite cold yet, but it of your parents, paying attention, and asking
wasn’t warm either. A light breeze slipped through yourself what small thing might make them smile.
my sleeves, quietly hinting that the weather would When we arrived home, Ima opened the door and
soon demand more of our attention. I walked noticed the scarf wrapped around Abba’s neck.
toward the shul, and when I arrived, the men were “Well?” she asked. Abba smiled and said, “You were
starting to walk out of the shul. Abba spotted me right.”
right away. “Mendy! What are you doing here?” I That night, Ima placed a light blanket over my
held up the scarf. Abba chuckled. “Did Ima send bed. “Ima, I really don’t need it,” I protested. “That’s
you?” fine,” she said quietly. “I’m just leaving it here.” In
“No,” I replied. Abba gave me another look. “You the middle of the night. I awoke to a slight chill and
came on your own?” “Yup.” I handed him the scarf. pulled the blanket up to my chin.
“I’m not sure if you actually need it…?” Abba took I didn’t mention it to Ima the next morning; some
it and wrapped it around his neck. “Now I do.” We things are better left unsaid. Early autumn is an
walked home in silence. After a few minutes, Abba interesting time. It is not cold yet, and winter is not
turned to me and said, “The best part is that you here; the air just feels a little different, and you have
thought of me.” I didn’t say anything, but those to pay attention to notice it.
simple words warmed my heart. Usually, when I
think about kibbud av va’eim, I picture the daily list Kibbud av va’eim is the same way. You don’t always
of things they ask for: “Bring me this, pick that up, need to wait for them to ask you to do things.
straighten this, come here, don’t go there.” Sometimes it is about being observant and attentive,
But this time, no one had asked me for anything. and doing things that make your parents happy.
Partner with us in publishing the Horeinu newsletter >>
Quickpay/zelle
Email us Donate via our website dedications@horeinu.org.
at newsletter@horeinu.org pay.banquest.com/horeinu Specify “Weekly Newsletter” in the memo.
To receive the weekly newsletter via email, simply write “Add
me” in the subject line and send to newsletter@horeinu.org
Created by the Worldwide Horeinu organization. Our goal is to
spread awareness and help Klal Yisroel strengthen the mitzvah of
kibbud av va’eim with the guidance of gedolei Yisroel Registered
organization #580780617
We welcome your feedback! Email newsletter@horeinu.org or fax: 077-602-1640 for
opportunities to dedicate or sponsor an issue l’iluy nishmas or l’zechus a parent or a loved one,
or for a zechus for children, zivugim, refuah shleimah, and hatzlachah.
You can also send us your personal stories to help inspire others.
www.horeinu.com / REQUIRES GENIZAH /
