Halacha For Today: Week in Review - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

בס'ד
WEEK OF PARASHAS NOACH 5787
When Reading in Shul, DO NOT Read During Davening or Krias HaTorah
CURRENT TOPIC: HALACHOS OF BORER ON SHABBOS
Halachos for Sunday, October 11 2026
1) As we learnt, the prohibition of Borer applies only when the two (or more) items in question
are in a mixture. We will now discuss what criteria are necessary to constitute a mixture.
A serving tray that has on it pieces of two different fish (or even the same species of fish, but
some are cooked and some are broiled, which for borer purposes is considered two different types)
that are laying haphazardly in no organized fashion, is subject to the prohibition of Borer. This
is considered a Ta’aruvos, a mixture, even though each variety is clearly discernible.
Thus, one may choose and remove only the fish that they want to eat, for immediate
consumption. (See Rama Siman 319:3)
2) A plate that has on it a few different foods, each in its own spot on the plate in an organized
fashion, according to many Poskim is not considered a Ta’aruvos, a mixture, even if they are
touching one another, and thus would not be subject to the prohibitions of Borer.
For a final ruling, of course, a Rav must be consulted.
Halachos for Monday, October 12, 2026
1) After the Shabbos meal, when clearing off the table, it is permissible to remove all the
glasses, then all the plates, then all the silverware etc. and doing it is such an order is not a
problem of Borer as these utensils are not considered to be in a mixture.(Ruling of Rav Nisim
Karelitz Zatzal quoted in Orchos Shabbos page 132 footnote 10)
www.HalachaForToday.com
בס'ד
2) A plate that has on it leftover food as well as silverware touching the food is not considered
a mixture as they are totally distinct objects, and the silverware may be removed even if they
are not going to be used immediately.
The exception to the above is if the silverware is totally covered by the leftover food in which
case it will indeed be considered a mixture and may not be removed unless it's for immediate
use.(Ruling of Rav Nisim Karelitz Zatzal quoted in Orchos Shabbos page 133 footnote 12)
If indeed this situation presents itself, it would be permitted to pick up the utensil and use it to
move the leftover food into the garbage, even if the assistance of the utensil was neither
necessary nor originally planned upon (ibid. footnote 13)
Likewise, a utensil that fell into the garbage, and is totally covered may not be removed unless
it will immediately be [washed, if necessary] and used. (ibid.)
Halachos for Tuesday, October 13, 2026
1) Various different sized and shaped pots, bottles and other food containers that are
organized on a shelf in the refrigerator next to one another are not considered "in a mixture"
and there is no prohibition to separate them.
If, however, the containers on the shelf are all of similar shape and size (e.g. a few 2 liter bottles
of different flavored soft drinks) they may indeed be considered "in a mixture" and they shouldn't
be sorted unless it is for immediate consumption.
The above is only if they are on the shelf, but if they are on the refrigerator door in a row, it is
not considered "in a mixture" and may be separated. (Ruling of Rav Shlomo Zalmen Auerbach
Zatzal in Sefer Me'Or Hashabbos Vol. 1 letter 8)
2) If the items in the refrigerator on not organized and are all laying haphazardly on top of
each other (e.g. different fruits in the refrigerator drawer or various different cheeses in the dairy
drawer) they are indeed "in a mixture" and thus may only be removed in the permissible
manner.
Halachos for Wednesday, October 14, 2026
1) It is very common for items in a freezer to be stored in a less organized fashion than in the
refrigerator, and very often many foods are lying on top of each other haphazardly.
These foods are considered "in a mixture" and thus if something needs to be removed, it must
be done in the acceptable manner (i.e. taking the item that is wanted, for immediate use without a
utensil)
2) If the food that is removed from the freezer cannot be used immediately due its needing to
defrost first, it is questionable if it may be removed.
www.HalachaForToday.com
בס'ד
Some Poskim maintain that since it cannot be used right away it may therefore not be
removed from "within the mixture" in the freezer. (Ruling of Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv and Rav
Nissim Karelitz Zichronam L'vracha quoted in Orchos Shabbos page 148 footnote 54)
Other Poskim, however, maintain that if it is common to only remove this particular food from
the freezer and allow it to defrost right before the meal, then it may be removed, and is
considered using it immediately even though it will take a while to defrost. (Ruling of Rav
Shlomo Zalmen Auerbach; ibid.)
However, if the food in question is commonly removed a few hours before the meal, all agree
that it may not be removed from "within the mixture" in the freezer on Shabbos. (ibid.)
[Parenthetically, it is important to be careful with frozen foods as many of them are Muktzeh
(e.g. frozen raw chicken, frozen uncooked French fries etc.) and moving them to get to the
permissible items (e.g. a frozen Challah or ice cream) may pose a Halachic problem.
Halachos for Thursday, October 15, 2026
1) Seforim or books that are neatly lined on a shelf, in a way that each one is easily
recognizable, are not considered "in a mixture" and thus any one may be removed from the
shelf even if there is no intent to use that Sefer immediately.
However, if the books are laying on the shelf in an unorganized fashion, and the titles are not
easily discernable and they are otherwise not recognizable, they may indeed be considered "a
mixture" and be subject to the prohibition of Borer, and according to many Poskim may only
be removed if all the criteria of permissible Borer are present. (See Orchos Shabbos page 134
footnote 17 )
2) If Seforim or books are lying on a pile on the table, it is considered "in a mixture" even if
they are easily discernable (as this is inherently a mixture, unlike when they are on the shelf), and
thus they should not be sorted into piles nor should a Sefer be pulled out of the pile unless it
is being used immediately. (See Rama Siman 319:3)
If one must remove a Sefer from an unorganized bookshelf or from a pile on the table on
Friday night for use on Shabbos day, the best thing to do is to learn something from it
immediately for a moment and thus it will have been a Borer for immediate use which is
permitted.
Halachos for Erev Shabbos Kodesh, October 16, 2026 Double Portion L'Kavod Shabbos Kodesh
Halachos for Erev Shabbos Kodesh
www.HalachaForToday.com
בס'ד
1) A solid that is large enough to be distinctly recognizable when submerged in a liquid,
according to many Poskim, is not considered to be "in a mixture" and thus the unwanted
liquid may be removed or poured off in order to get to the solid.
Some examples of this: a) A pot of hard boiled eggs in water, where the water may be spilled
out in order to reach the eggs. b) A jar of pickles in brine, where the pickle juice may be spilled
out in order to reach the pickles. c) A pitcher of water that contains slices of lemon may be
poured even if the spout of the pitcher will prevent the lemons from leaving the pitcher. (Some
Poskim are stringent even in the aforementioned cases and a Rav should be consulted for Halacha
L'ma'aseh. See K'tzos HaShulchan 125:14 and Shu"t Az Nidberu Vol. 4 Siman 21)
2) A large quantity of olives (or similar small item) that are submerged in a pitcher of water is
considered to be "in a mixture" and thus the water may not be poured off in order to get to the
olives.
Likewise, a slotted spoon may not be used to retrieve the olives from within the water, and
surely a sieve may not be used to do this.
A single olive, however, that is in a pitcher of liquid is not considered "in a mixture" and may
be removed even with a utensil and even if not being eaten immediately.
Halachos for Shabbos Kodesh
1) It is very common when opening a can of vegetables, tuna fish or sardines, or similar items
that come in a sealed can, to drain the liquid from the can before removing the food.
This is forbidden to do on Shabbos as removing the liquid (which is P'soles, the unwanted
item) from the food (the Ochel, the desired item) is a classic example of prohibited Borer.
Very often when opening a cup of yogurt or leben, a small layer of water is present on the top
and is intertwined into the yogurt/leben. This water is usually stirred into the yogurt/ leben or,
alternatively, is spilled out.
If the water and the leben/yogurt are already joining with one another, it is considered "a
mixture" and the water may not be spilled out on Shabbos, as doing so is a prohibited Borer. If
the yogurt/leben is solid and the water on top is not seeping into the leben/yogurt, then it may
be spilled out.
2) A fly, or another unwanted small item, that fell into a drink may not be removed by itself;
rather it must be removed together with some of the liquid from the cup. (See Mishna Berura
Siman 319:61. We shall B'Ezras Hashem discuss this Halacha of taking some of the good with the
bad in more detail as we progress in this topic
A pot of soup that contains in it pieces of chicken, vegetables and other items is divided into
two categories as follows:
www.HalachaForToday.com
בס'ד
a) The top layer of the pot which contains only liquid is not considered "in a mixture" and the
liquid may be poured out or otherwise removed from there even if it is being removed in order
to get to the other items in the pot.
b) The bottom half of the pot, where all the chicken, vegetables etc. is laying is considered "in
a mixture" and thus the soup and/or the other items may only be removed if all the criteria of
permissible Borer are present (i.e. the good is taken from the bad, for immediate use and it is done
without specialized utensils).
Halacha For Today sends a FREE daily email received by thousands of Yidden across the world, which contains practical Halacha
and Chizuk for everyday life. To subscribe, send a request to Ben@HalachaForToday.com or sign up via the website
www.HalachaForToday.com. To sponsor the daily email or this Week In Review Sheet please email Ben@HalachaForToday.com. The
Halachos are based on my personal understanding of the Halachic texts quoted, and are for learning purposes only, NOT for Psak
Halacha. If you have questions or require further source information, please email Ben@HalachaForToday.com and I will try to
respond as soon as I can. For a Halacha L’Ma’aseh Psak, please contact your local Orthodox Rabbi
Note: All Halachos were written from an Ashkenazic perspective and follow the rulings of Ashkenazic Poskim. Though I
endeavor to point out whenever Sephardic rulings and customs differ from what I write, by no means have I adequately
researched the Sephardic point of view of any Halachos that I write and my dear Sephardic readers should please review all
rulings with their own Chachamim.
www.HalachaForToday.com
בס'ד
Some Interesting Q&A Related to Parashas Noach
Questions were submitted by readers over the years and posted on
www.HalachaForToday.com
Reader's Question:
How can the rainbow be a bad sign? It was given to Noach as a covenant! Please explain.
Answer:
The rainbow was given to Noach as a sign that Hashem will never destroy the world again…BUT, it will be
displayed in the heaven at such a time that Hashem really wants to destroy the world for its sins, yet doesnt
do so based on the promise to Noach.
Hence, the Talmud (Chagiga 16a) says that one may not gaze at a rainbow as it is a bad sign that the world
is steeped in sin, and one who gazes at a rainbow transgresses a sin.
Reader's Question:
You wrote “Hence, the Gemara (Chagiga 16a) says that one may not look at a rainbow as it is a bad sign that
the world is steeped in sin, and one who gazes at a rainbow transgresses a sin.” – what about the bracha of
Zocher Habris? we say a bracha when performing an aveira?!
Answer:
The Bracha is recited after “seeing” a rainbow. The Bracha is thanking Hashem for for remembering his
covenant (not to destroy the world) and for keeping His promise not to destroy the world.. Any further
“gazing” at the rainbow is the aveirah, not the initial seeing on which we recite the Bracha.
See also Sefer Michtav M’Eliyahu from Rav Eliyahu Eliezer Dessler Zatzal, Vol. 4 page 10 for another
approach regarding not gazing at the rainbow.
Reader's Question:
What is the Halacha regarding the rainbow that is visible many times over Niagara Falls? Do we recite a
Brocha? Is it an Aveira to look at it?
www.HalachaForToday.com
בס'ד
Answer:
From the Poskim it seems that only a rainbow in the clouds in the sky is a “sign” and would require a
bracha, and not a rainbow that is formed from the sun’s shining on the water and causing a prism effect
etc., which isn't in the sky.
It is not an Aveira to look at that either as that isn't a “rainbow” rather something that looks
“rainbowlike”. (See Shu"t Rivevos Ephraim Vol. 6 Siman 103 and Sefer Chavos Yair Perek 8 S"K 22. Some
Poskim say to recite the bracha without Shem U'Malchus. Each person should consult his Rav for a psak halacha
L'Ma'seh. See also Drashos HaRan, Drush 1 Dibur Hamaschil V’Zeh Hu Inyan HaKeshes where the great Rishon
Rabbeinu Nissim discusses at length the nature of the rainbow and discusses some of the questions as to its origin
etc.)
Reader's Question:
As I was growing up, I remember people would say that you’re not supposed to look at the moon. Is there
any truth to this?
Answer:
Yes, there is a lot of truth to this!
The Sefer Chareidim, written by one of the holy Mekubalim in Tzfas in the the times of the Bais Yosef and
the Arizal, writes (Perek 45:5) “It is prohibited to gaze at a rainbow…It is likewise prohibited to gaze at the
moon. Rabbeinu Meir used to be extremely stringent with this…as it is quoted in Sefer Shoshan sodos”
In the Sefer Taamei HaMinhagim (Kuntres Achron to Siman 464:22) he quotes the Sefer Shevet HaMussar that
Al Pi Kabala it is just as bad to gaze at the moon as it is to gaze at a rainbow.
In the long Nusach of Vidui from Rabbeinu Avraham, father of the Shla HaKadosh, where he enumerates
hundreds of possible sins that a person needs to do Teshuva for, he lists as one of the sins ” Gazing at
the [new] moon”
The Mishna Berura Siman 426:13 brings this as well, and says that by Kidush Levana when we must look at
the moon before commencing the Bracha, according to some opinions the moon should be glanced at for a
moment and that’s all, and according to others it can be looked at for the duration of the Bracha, but it
seems clear that any extra gazing at the moon is indeed something that should be avoided at best and may
even be considered a sin!
Reader's Question:
Is there any source that indicates the names of the wives of Noach’s sons?
Answer:
As per Rav Chaim Kanievsky Zatzal in his Sefer L’Mchaseh Atik, here are the various opinions from the
Midrash and the Rishonim
www.HalachaForToday.com
בס'ד
“The wives of Noach’s children were the daughters of Elyakim son of Mesushelach. (Sifri Hayashan)
Some say the wife of Cham was the mother of Sichon [king of the Amorites] (Rabeinu
Bechaye Parshas Chukas, quoting the Medrash)
Some say the wife of Shem was named Machlatyavan, the wife of Cham was named Samantabo and the wife
of Yefes was named Katantanbo (Medrash Ksav Yad)
Some say the wife of Shem was named Machlah bas Beno”
Reader's Question:
What is the shoresh/reason for the minhag of bringing into a new apartment a box of matzos and salt?
Answer:
In the Sefer Mat’amim HaChadash page 5 he writes that the reason for the minhag to bring bread, salt,
candles and honey into a new home before residing there for the first time is because Hashem, before
creating Adam and bringing into his new home [Gan Eden]. prepared for him all sorts of trees with fruits for
him to eat, and also the light that was in Gan Eden allowed Adam to see from one end of the world until the
other end. Also before Noach entered the Teivah he stocked it with food and precious stones that lit up the
Teiva.
In the Sefer Minhagei Belz it is written that Rav Ahron of Belz Zatzal used to tell people to bring in salt and
bread into the home before occupying it, and to then distribute it to poor people. This is a Segulah for
parnasah and Bracha in the new home.
Reader's Question:
I read that the waters at the time of the mabul were scalding hot. How on earth did the fish survive?
Answer:
The Gemara (Sanhedrin 108a) and Midrash Rabbah (Noach, 32:19, according to one opinion) indeed say that
the fish (and possibly all the creatures of the sea) survived, as they did not follow the lead of the people and
animals of that generation and practice immoral mating practices.
Most probably, the waters were only boiling on the surface and not in the depths of the sea.
Another option (as seems from the second opinion in the Midrash) is that there was one ocean that was not
boiling (The Yam Okeanos, the Atlantic ocean) and all the fish went there to survive.
Additionally, according to some opinions, the Mabul did not destroy Eretz Yisroel, and thus the fish could
have survived in the waters of Eretz Yisroel. (See Tal
Reader's Question:
My teacher told us that there were no monkeys on the Teiva. Is that possible?
www.HalachaForToday.com
בס'ד
Answer:
One who sees an elephant or a monkey for the first time recites the Bracha of Baruch Ata Hashem Elokeinu
Melech HaOlam Meshaneh HaBriyos. (Shulchan Aruch Siman 225:8)
The reason these 2 animals are singled out for this Bracha, when apparently all animals in the animal
kingdom have their own unique and often strange appearance, is as follows:
The Talmud (Sanhedrin 109a) tells us that one of the punishments that Hashem meted out to the Dor
Haflaga ,The people who tried to build the tower to heaven and wage war on Hashem, was to turn them into
monkeys. (Unlike the evolutionists who absurdly believe that mankind evolved from monkeys, Chazal tell us
that in fact the opposite is true and monkeys actually evolved from man!)
Thus, according to this Gemara, monkeys were seemingly not created during the 6 days of creation, and
were only “changed” from humans as a punishment. Thus the Bracha of “Meshane HaBriyos- Changes the
creatures” is perfectly understandable!
See Maleches Shlomo to Mishna in K’layim Perek 8:6 Dibur Hamaschil Hapil V’HaKof where he alludes to
the above and also adds that elephants understand the language of man, and thus are “different” and
require this Bracha. See his commentary at length for more on this. See also Meiri to Brachos 58 Dibur
Hamaschil HaRoeh.
According to this, it is possible that there were no monkeys (and possibly no elephants) on the Teiva, as
they were not in existence during the Mabul!
It is, however, possible that there were indeed monkeys and elephants at Creation, and Hashem turned the
sinners into those creations, but not that they didn’t exist before at all. And the bracha of “Meshaneh
HaBriyos” can just mean that these 2 creations underwent a change during the Dor Haflaga.
SIGN UP TODAY @ www.HalachaForToday.com
Every Daily email contains 2 practical Halachos, an interesting Q&A and a Chizuk quote
www.HalachaForToday.com
