gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

Lamdanim Gilyon - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

Publisher: Lamdanim Gilyon - English

Week: Noach (2026-10-12)

Lamdanim Gilyon - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

Open the PDF Download

‫נדבת לז"נ רב גדלי' בן רב שמעון מאקס זצ"ל‬ HASHK AFAH SPONSOR TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SPONSOR Y E A R LY S P O N S O R ‫ דקות בעיון כל יום‬15 ‫הוא היה רגיל לומר צריך כל אדם ללמוד לכה"פ‬ Are you a HASHKAFA FROM HG"R GERSHON RIBNER SHLITA The Modus Operandi of Curious Lamdan? George Is Prevalent Amongst Us QUESTION ? What is the correct hashkafa THIS WEEK'S LIVE SHAILA when it comes to reading your ‫נח תשפ"ז לפ"ק‬ kids books like Curious George? ANSWER PA R S H A H S P O N S O R Sponsored by Chavra D’Hilchisa I do believe the Mashgiach Rav Matisyahu Salomon zt”l used to speak against these books. He believed that the messages these books Can I Have My Money Back? A Lender’s Dilemma (Mishmeres Chaim) conveyed and the midos they portrayed were not appropriate for our children. I assume he was familiar with Curious George, even though In a case where an individual is Toveiah money from someone who it’s not as widespread in England. does not have the ability to pay the loan back (and the lender is His reasoning was that in every story, Curious George does the wrong aware of this), the Halacha is that the lender violates the Lav of “Lo thing and gets away with it because of his charm. You’d be surprised Sihyeh Lo Kanoshe”- “You should not be an oppressor to him”. how many adults do exactly this and have been doing it their entire What is unclear is that the primary Halachic commentators lives. They use their charm to get away with doing the wrong thing, not the ugly things, and it really does work. (Chinuch; Rambam; S.A.) do not discuss a case where the lender is in doubt whether or not the borrower has the requisite funds to However, even without accepting that hashkafa, these days we have a pay back the loan. This would seemingly indicate that a lender world of children’s books, rich in content, in every Judaica store. There are endless options for every age and every level. There is no reason to would not violate the Lav of “Lo Sihyeh” if he is Toveiah the turn to the monkey and the Man with the Yellow Hat. There is so much borrower in such a scenario. The question then becomes, that entertainment for children out there, transmitting true Torah ideals, seemingly such a situation of Safek should be deemed as a Safek that I don’t see why someone would want to turn to Curious George. Deoraisah L’Chumrah situation, since there is a definite possibility that the borrower does not have the money to pay back. So why then does the Shulchan Aruch not clarify the ruling in such a case and Paskin L’Chumrah that the Malveh can’t be Toveiah from the Halacha Loveh? Highlights .‫רמב"ם הל' מלוה ולוה פ"א ה"ב–ג' שו"ע חו"מ סי' צ"ז ס"ב‬ .‫ב"מ ע"ה ע"ב‬ One does not need to repeat Motzei Shabbos Maariv Shemoneh Esrei for omitting Ata Chonantanu. However, if one omitted it and ate before Havdalah, there is a knas requiring one to repeat Shemoneh Esrei. Chavra D'Hilchisa Raffle! ‫א מ"ב ס"ק ד‬:‫'שו"ע או"ח סימן רצד‬ Mazal Tov to Dovid Roth from Queens, NY on winning the inscribed Sefer Chazon Ish! Zechus Harabbim! Sponsor this week’s Lamdanim Inc newsletter or HaRav Gershon Ribner’s Hashkafa and connect to thousands of Lomdei Torah. Dedicate L’iluy Nishmas, L’kovod a Simcha, or to share in the Zechus of the tremendous Rischa d’Oraisa. Reserve your sponsorship today! (646) 598-4703 FOR COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS ON THE HASHKAFA MIMEON KODESH, TEXT 848-216-6466 TO HEAR THE SHAILA EXPLAINED CALL 917.810.2517 WANT TO BE MEHANEH YOUR OILAM WITH THIS NEWSLETTER? TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SUBSCRIBE TEXT "START" TO 917.810.2517 | HAVE A MEHALECH? SUBMIT IT TO "646-598-4703" BEFORE SUNDAY 1:30 P. M. EST SEFER SPONSOR SEFER SHEMOS IS SPONSORED ‫ר' חיים צבי בן ר' משה‬ Haaros • The Rosh in Berachos only says that a woman cannot be Motzi someone else in a case like Birchas hamazon, where her own Chiyuv may only be D’rabbanan while the Recent week's question & answer man’s Chiyuv is D’Oraisa. Since she never accepted Arvus in the same way, she cannot carry his greater obligation. But a man did accept Arvus, and his Arvus includes women as well. Therefore, even if he was already Yotzei Kiddush in Maariv, HaRav Yechezkel Hartman Shlit"a, Rav of the Guttman Beis Medrash, he can still be Motzi his wife, because his acceptance of Arvus was also for her. - Asks This Week’s Mishmar Shailah B’Inyan Arvus! - Sponsored by Chavra D’Hilchisa- Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Koss QUESTION • The Dagul Merevavah’s Safek is really how to understand the Rosh’s statement The Rosh in Maseches Berachos discusses the concept of Arvus, Kol Yisrael that women are not included in Arvus. Does it mean only that women are excluded Areivim Zeh LaZeh, which allows one who has already fulfilled a Mitzvah to be from being Areivim for others, because they were not the primary focus of the Motzi someone else. This is the basis of Yatza Motzi: even after a person has acceptance at Har Gerizim and Har Eival, but men can still be Areivim for women? Or already made Kiddush for himself, he may repeat it for another person who still does it mean that women are also excluded from receiving the benefit of Arvus, so needs to fulfill the Mitzvah. However, the Rosh writes that women are not that a man cannot be Motzi them through Arvus after he was already Yotzei? It included in this Din Arvus, and therefore cannot be Motzi others through the seems that the Dagul Merevavah is Mesupak l’halacha in exactly this Chakirah. - S. mechanism of Arvus. The Dagul Merevavah raises a fascinating question from Yachnes Kiddush. According to many Rishonim, the Torah obligation of Kiddush does not • The Rosh may only mean that women are not included in Arvus regarding a require wine. A man who davens Maariv on Friday night and says the Berachah of Mitzvah where their own obligation is uncertain or weaker, such as Birchas Mekadesh HaShabbos may already have fulfilled his Kiddush Mid’Oraisa. When he hamazon, where they may not have a full Chiyuv d’Oraisa. But by Kiddush, women comes home, however, his wife is still obligated in Kiddush Mid’Oraisa. The certainly have a Chiyuv d’Oraisa, because Zachor and Shamor are connected. husband himself is now only obligated in the Rabbinic requirement of Kiddush Al Therefore, even according to the Rosh, there can be Arvus for women regarding HaKos. If women are not included in Arvus, how can the husband be Motzi his wife Kiddush. This is how Rav Akiva Eiger answers the question. - Avi Stochel in her Torah obligation of Kiddush after he has already fulfilled his own? • Rav Akiva Eiger in Shulchan Aruch 271 and in Teshuvos Siman 7 explains that men Ordinarily, the ability of one who is already Yotzei to be Motzi another person do have Arvus for women. The lack of Arvus is only regarding a Mitzvah from which depends on Arvus. According to the Rosh, that mechanism should not apply here. women are exempt. Additionally, even according to the Dagul Merevavah’s concern, How, then, can a husband who already davened Maariv make Kiddush for his the Mishnah Berurah says that since one is supposed to make Kiddush on wine, it is wife? as though the husband has in mind not to be Yotzei with Maariv, but rather with ANSWER Kiddush al hakos at home. - R’ Spiegel The first answer is based on Rabbi Akiva Eiger’s understanding of the Rosh. When • Since Chazal taught that Kiddush should be recited on a cup of wine, a person does the Rosh writes that women are not included in Arvus, he does not mean that not intend to be Yotzei through Davening. His opposite Kavanah shows that he women have no Arvus at all. Rather, a woman is not an Areivah for a Mitzvah in wants to fulfill the real Chiyuv Kiddush at home over wine. Therefore, when he which she herself is not obligated. That is why, regarding Birchas HaMazon, she comes home and makes Kiddush, he is still fulfilling his own obligation, and he can cannot be Motzi someone whose obligation is greater than hers. However, for a also have in mind to be Motzi the women who did not daven Maariv. - Yaakov Mitzvah in which she is fully obligated, she is included in Arvus. Since women are • One can say that “there is no Arvus for Nashim” means that Nashim cannot be obligated in Kiddush just like men, the Din Arvus applies, and a husband who was Motzi anashim, but Anashim do have Arvus for Nashim, even if women themselves already Yotzei can still be Motzi his wife. A second approach, also brought by are exempt from that general responsibility. See the Maharitz Chiyus in Kiddushin, Rabbi Akiva Eiger, is that the husband should have in mind during Maariv not to where the issue depends on whether it is B’yadan limchos, and see also L’horos fulfill his Mitzvas Kiddush through Tefillah, but rather to fulfill it later at home Nasan. Additionally, the Chasam Sofer in Teshuvos, Orach Chaim 17, says that it is as over a cup of wine. The Chasam Sofer presents this even more strongly: since though the husband has Kavanah not to be Yotzei in Maariv, since Lev chachamim Chazal established that Kiddush should be recited Al HaKos, a person naturally masneh al hadavar. - D. W., NJ intends to fulfill the Mitzvah in its proper form at home. According to this, when • Perhaps the Tachlis of Arvus is only to allow the one being Motzi to make the the husband comes home, he is still fulfilling his own Kiddush Mid’Oraisa. He Bracha even though he is not presently obligated. But the actual mechanism by therefore does not need Arvus at all in order to be Motzi his wife, since he is which the listener is Yotzei is Shomea k’oneh. If so, when the husband still has a full simultaneously being Yotzei himself. A third possibility depends on a broader Chiyuv d’rabbanan of Kiddush al hakos, he is considered a real Mechuyav and does question: can a person fulfill the same Mitzvah more than once? There are not need Arvus merely to allow him to recite Kiddush. Once he can make the Bracha opinions among the Rishonim and Acharonim that even after one has already as a Mechuyav, his wife can be Yotzei through Shomea k’oneh, and on her side it been Yotzei, he may perform the Mitzvah again in a more complete manner. One counts as a Kiddush d’Oraisa, because it is as if she herself said the words. - Talmid example is the discussion regarding reciting Krias Shema before Davening when in Yeshivah Heichal Eliyahu there is concern that the proper Zman will pass, and then reciting it again later together with its Berachos. According to this approach, even if the husband • The Halacha is Ein kiddush ela b’makom se’udah, that a person should make technically fulfilled Kiddush during Maariv, he can fulfill the Mitzvah again at Kiddush in the place of his meal. Although the husband may have fulfilled some home in the preferred form of Kiddush Al HaKos. If he is once again performing level of Kiddush in shul through Maariv, he still has to make Kiddush at home before the Mitzvah for himself, he can certainly be Motzi his wife at the same time, the Se’udah. While he is reciting that Kiddush, his wife can listen and be Yotzei without needing to rely on the mechanism of Yatza Motzi through Arvus. through Shomea k’oneh. - Sh. Y. R., Cedarhurst ‫רא"ש ברכות פ"ג סי' י"ג‬ Mussar '‫דגול מרבבה או"ח סי' רע"א על מג"א ס"ק ב‬ TEXT 646-598-4703 TO SPONSOR Moment LOMDUS SPONSOR THE Are you a FOLLOW US "It is easier to learn through all of ‫ ש"ס‬than to correct a single ‫"מידה‬ Lamdan? ‫א מ"ב ס"ק ד‬:‫'שו"ע או"ח סימן רצד‬- TO SPONSOR A SHAILA LIELUEY NISHMAS OR REFUAH SHELEIMA TEXT 646.598.4703