Clarity for Teens - English — Noach (2026-10-12)

WEEKLY THOUGHTS • PARSHAS NOACH
PARSHAS NOACH
SAME JOB, SAME GOAL
— ❦ —
The Medrash
ר ִּבי תַ נְ חּומָ א ְבשֵׁ ם ַר ִּבי יְ הּודָ ה.ַ יָשָ ר ֶיחֱזּו פָ נֵׁימֹו״, ״כִּ י צַ ִּדיק ה׳ ְצדָ קֹות אָ הֵׁ ב: כְ ִּתיב, ״ב ֹּא אַ תָ ה וְ גֹו׳״, דָ בָ ר אַ חֵׁ ר
אֲ בָ ל הֶ חָ כָם אֹוהֵׁ ב בֶ ן, אֵׁ ין לְ ָך אָ דָ ם אֹוהֵׁ ב בֶ ן אֻ מָ נּותֹו: ר ִּבי ְמנ ְַחמָ א ְבשֵׁ ם ַר ִּבי אֱ לִּ יעֶ זֶר בַ ר יֹוסֵׁ י אָ ְמרּו,ַ בַ ר ִּסימֹון
, וְ הַ קָ דֹוש בָ רּוְך הּוא אֹוהֵׁ ב אֶ ת בֶ ן אֻ מָ נּותֹו. וְ ַר ִּבי הֹושַ עְ יָא ְד ַר ִּבי ִּחיָיא, כְ גֹון ַר ִּבי ִּחיָיא ְד ַר ִּבי הֹושַ עְ יָא, אֻ מָ נּותֹו
״ ַוי ֹּאמֶ ר ה׳ אֶ ל נֹּ חַַ ב ֹּא אַ תָ ה וְ גֹו׳״: שֶ נֶאֱ מַ ר, ַַזֶה נֹּ ח. יָשָ ר ֶיחֱזּו פָ נֵׁימֹו״, ״כִּ י צַ ִּדיק ה׳ ְצדָ קֹות אָ הֵׁ ב: שֶ נֶאֱ מַ ר.
The Medrash tells us something very interesting.
Normally, a person does not particularly like someone who has the same profession, as
himself. Why? Because he is his competition! If I am a builder and you are also a builder,
every job you get is potentially a job that I lose.
But there is an exception. A talmid chochom loves another talmid chochom. Reb Chiya
and Reb Hoshaya appreciated one another’s Torah.
And the Medrash tells us that the Ribbono Shel Olam is also different. Hashem loves
someone who has the same umanus as Himself! Hashem’s umanus is tzedek, doing
what is right. Therefore, when a person lives with tzedek, Hashem loves him for
following in His ways.
And who is the Medrash talking about? Noach. As the possuk says, ת אָ הֵׁ ב ַ״
ַ ״כִּ י צַ ִּדיק הַ׳ ְצדָ קֹו
— Hashem is a Tzaddik, and He loves tzedokos.
And Noach was an ״איש צַ ִּדיק״
ִּ .
— ❦ —
Last year, Parshas Noach, I was on the train on the way to London to give a speech in a
yeshiva. I was sitting at a table preparing my notes. Opposite me were two men who were
also on the way to London to give a presentation. They had some sort of business course,
and they were going to give a one-hour taster session so that people could see what they
were about and hopefully sign up afterwards for the full course.
They spent almost the entire two-hour train journey discussing how to give an impressive
one-hour presentation without giving away any of their trade secrets. They wanted
everyone to leave thinking, “Wow, these guys know what they are talking about. I need to
join their course,” while making sure that nobody actually learned too much for free.
I was sitting opposite them trying to do the exact opposite.
1
WEEKLY THOUGHTS • PARSHAS NOACH
I was also preparing an hour-long presentation, but I was trying to work out how I could
squeeze in as much as possible and give over as much as I possibly could in the time I had.
When I came home and saw this Medrash, it struck me that perhaps this is exactly what the
Medrash is teaching us.
Those two men had come up with some sort of model that they could make money from.
Their real business was not teaching. Their business was selling knowledge. The teaching
was the way they made their money.
Someone teaching Torah is almost the opposite. His real business is teaching Torah. He may
need to charge because he also has to make a living, but the money is not the product. The
Torah is the product.
So what is really the difference between the two?
I would suggest explaining it with something that happened to me seven years ago — also
on Parshas Noach.
I was sitting in the beis hamedrash preparing my Chumash lesson before the boys came up
from their lesson. There were two engineers there fixing an air-conditioning unit that was
leaking. One of the workers looked around at all the seforim and asked me what on earth all
these books were about.
I explained to him that it all started with the Torah, and that all these seforim were, in one
way or another, explanations and developments of what was already there.
He then said to me, “I’ll tell you something about the Torah that you probably don’t know.”
Obviously, I said, “Go ahead.”
He told me that he had previously worked in boat engineering and had built boats for the
navy. He had read the Bible and noticed the measurements given for Noach’s teivah. He told
me that its proportions were extremely suitable for a vessel whose main purpose was
simply to remain afloat and survive heavy, rough seas. You could make the vessel larger or
smaller, he explained, but the proportions were what gave it that stability.
He was fascinated. “How did God know this thousands of years before scientists worked it
out?”
Now, I know absolutely nothing about boats. But I do know a little about fantasising, and I
was fairly sure this man was dreaming. So I checked it up.
And, to my surprise, I found research discussing the stability of the teivah’s proportions for
exactly that sort of purpose — not a ship trying to get somewhere, but a vessel whose main
job was simply to survive the waves.
I have attached the research for anyone who enjoys reading boring things and somehow still
has energy left after reading this essay.
But I did not tell the engineer what I was really thinking. He was amazed that God knew the
correct proportions before scientists discovered them.
2
WEEKLY THOUGHTS • PARSHAS NOACH
I was thinking: it is not that Hashem looked at the world, discovered how boats work,
and then put the measurements into the Torah.
It is the other way around. The Torah came first.
Hashem looked into the Torah and created the world. The world fits the Torah. The Torah
does not have to fit the world. And perhaps that brings us back to our Medrash.
Hashem does not have all this unbelievable knowledge and then keep it hidden from us until
we pay for His course. He does the exact opposite. He gives us the Torah. He wants us to
learn it. He wants us to discover it. He wants us to understand more and more of it.
And then — as if that were not enough — He actually pays us reward for learning it!
Even more than that, it should make us realise that nothing is really our own discovery.
Whatever true idea a person will ever discover has its roots somewhere in Torah. As Chazal
teach us, whatever a talmid vosik will one day be mechadesh was already given to Moshe
Rabbeinu at Har Sinai.
We are not creating our own product. We are uncovering something that belonged to
Hashem all along.
This week I was in Antwerp and went out with a friend from yeshiva whom I had not
properly seen in years — to the famous Hoffy’s.
He gave me about an hour-long interview. Sorry, if you are reading this — I did enjoy it.
At one point he said to me, “If you want to bring up a point every week and discuss it, why
do you always have to blame it on a Medrash?”
He actually has a strong point.
But perhaps the answer is that every piece of real knowledge I will ever have ultimately
comes from Torah. I am not trying to force my idea into a Medrash. I simply like to find
where the idea I am thinking about already exists in Torah.
And yes, I even managed to tie his question into this week’s Medrash — just to prove the
point to him.
Perhaps now we can understand why people normally do not particularly like someone who
has the same profession, while two talmidei chachomim love one another.
If something is mine, then you are competition. If I invented my own business, discovered
my own secret and developed my own system, then every bit of information I give you
weakens my advantage. If you become better at what I do, perhaps you will take my
customers.
Your gain may genuinely become my loss.
But Torah is not mine. It is Hashem’s Torah.
3
WEEKLY THOUGHTS • PARSHAS NOACH
If another Yid learns more Torah, understands more Torah, teaches more Torah and spreads
more Torah, he has not taken anything away from me. He has helped me. We are working
towards the exact same goal.
That is why two talmidei chachomim can love one another even though they have the same
“profession.” They are not competing for the same customer. They are helping each other do
the same job.
And that is why Hashem loves someone who has the same umanus as Himself.
Hashem is צדק. Hashem wants צדקspread through the world. When a human being acts with
צדק, he is not competing with Hashem. He is helping carry out Hashem’s will.
Same profession. Same goal.
And perhaps this goes much further than Torah.
If we really understood that our purpose in every area of our lives is to spread Hashem’s
Name, make a קידוש השם, and achieve our תכליתin this world, then somebody else having
more than us would not have to threaten us.
If another person has more money and uses it properly, that helps the mission. If another
person has more Torah and teaches it, that helps the mission. If someone has more talent,
more influence, more success, or can reach people that I cannot reach, why should that make
me jealous?
We are not competitors. We are all working for the same Boss. Your gain does not have to
be my loss.
If we are both working towards the same goal, then your gain is my gain, our gain — and
ultimately part of Hashem’s goal.
So why be jealous of another person doing another part of the very same job?
— ❦ —
4
