Lehisvada - English — Lech Lechu (2026-10-19)

דרשו
Bechoros Daf 29
Taking payment for judging
. מימיו מי מערה אפרו אפר מקלה, להזות ולקדש. עדותיו בטילין, להעיד. דיניו בטילים, הנוטל שכרו לדון, במשנה.בבכורות דף כ"ט
. מה אני בחנם אף אתם בחנם,' דאמר קרא ראה למדתי אתכם וגו, אמר רב יהודה אמר רב, מנהני מילי,'ובגמ
ומנין שלא. תלמוד לומר אמת קנה, ומנין שאם לא מצא בחנם שילמד בשכר. מה אני בחנם אף אתם בחנם, כאשר צוני ה' אלהי,תניא נמי הכי
. תלמוד לומר אמת קנה ואל תמכור,יאמר כשם שלמדתיה בשכר כך אלמדנה בשכר
-א-
Whether the dayan must return the money he took for judging
The issur to accept payment for judging is min haTorah and the Similarly, one may not take payment for performing a
Chachamim penalized him that his rulings are void / A man mitzvah for the benefit of another person. Therefore,
cannot be mekadesh a woman with the payment for haza’ah one may not take payment for giving testimony for the
since she did not receive anything from him / Whether the dayan benefit of another person, and likewise one may not take
must return the money he accepted / Whether the payment
payment for sprinkling mei chatas to purify a person
is considered having been given in error / The nature of the
from his tumah. Therefore, the Chachamim said that if
Chachamim’s k’nas that his rulings are void
one transgressed and took payment to judge, his rulings
, שער משפט, מחנה אפרים, משנה למלך, ב"ח, ריטב"א,רמב"ן
אמרי בינה
are void. If he took payment to testify, his eidus is invalid.
And if he took payment to sprinkle mei chatas, the water
א.Our gemara teaches that we learn from the pasuk is considered mei me’arah (simple unconsecrated water),
that one may not take payment for teaching Torah to
and the person is not purified from his tumah. [1]
others, and likewise one may not take payment for adju-
dicating a din Torah between one person and another. The Chiddushei Ha’Ramban1 explains that this is a
Notes
Taking payment after having judged difference in this whether the ba’al din gave him payment before
he judged the case or where he gave him payment after he judged
ברכי יוסף, מוצל מאש,מעדני יום טוב
the case. Even if he gave him payment after he had already judged
[1] The Maadanei Yom Tov2 writes that the issur to take pay - the case, his ruling is void.
ment is not only where the dayan stipulated beforehand that
However, the Birkei Yosef23 writes that it seems logical that
the ba’al din should pay him. Rather, even s’char me’uchar, where
there is no machlokes in this matter. For what the Shu”t Mutzal
the ba’al din gives him payment after the judgment, the dayan is
Me’Eish writes, that his ruling is invalid even if he got the payment
assur to accept it. However, in the case of s’char me’uchar, if he
after he judged the case, refers to where they stipulated before-
transgressed and accepted the payment, the ruling is not voided
hand that he would judge the case with the understanding that
retroactively.
he would be paid. In such a case, his ruling is invalid even though
Now, in Shu”t Mutzal Me’Eish22 he writes that there is no the payment was given to him only after he had already rendered
1
דרשו
k’nas which the Chachamim imposed upon one who
L’halacha the Rishonim disagree concerning whether we pasken
takes payment, that his actions are invalidated because
Taking
like Rebbi Meir or Rebbi Yehudah. The Rif 9 asserts that the halacha
“Mah
payment
Shabbos
Bechoros Daf 29
for judging
Daf Lamed Ches
Therefore, he has nothing with which to be mekadesh
her.On the other hand, the Biur HaGra there goes to great lengths and
concludes like Rebbi Meir. The Mishna Berurah 18 cites this opinion
he transgresses
follows whatand
Rebbi Yehudah, thetheTorah Ran 10said,
explains his ani b’chinam,
reasoning to be of theNow,
Gra the
and how Bachhe3 writes
follows in thattheone whooftook
footsteps Tosafospayment
and his
af atemRav
because b’chinam”
publicly – “Just asasI such.
darshened teachThis without
being the payment,
case the colleagues
to judge is not obligated to return the payment thatithe
who all pasken like Rebbi Meir that even b’mayzid is
halacha follows suit. The same is raised by both the Rambam 11 and only assur to eat from food cooked on Shabbos until Motzei Shabbos.
so too must you teach without payment.” The Ramban
Ramban 12 as well. Additionally, the Beis Yosef 13 writes that the
took.
This Although
applies even to he one who cooked “Mah
the transgressed it, and ani b’chinam,
b’shogeig af
everyone
adds, based on the words of
words of the Rosh seem to lean this way too.
14 the Tosefta, that when the atem
can b’chinam,”
partake from thenevertheless,
food immediately heonis Shabbos
not required to return
itself. The Mishna
Mishnah says that one who takes payment to judge ‘his Berurah asserts that in a time of need
the money. This is not comparable to taking shochad one is allowed to rely on this
On the other hand, Tosafos in Chullin 15 asserts that the halacha where the food was cooked b’shogeig.
rulings’
follow are Meir,
Rebbi void, and
andhis onereasoned
who takes payment
is because this istohowtestify
Rav (bribes), where if he transgressed and took shochad, he
‘his testimonies’
instructed areAdditionally,
his students. invalid, thethemishnah Beis Yosef is saying
16 bringsthat
this The implication of his words is that it is specifically with regards
is shogeig
to
obligated to return it, because there, since the Torah
that one can rely on Tosafos to pasken like Rebbi Meir.
b’shem
not only bothisthe Smag
this and Seferruling
particular HaTerumahor thisas well.
particular testi- On the“Loi
says, othersikach shochad,on- wouldn’t
hand, b’mayzid “You shall not take
be allowed shochad,”
to rely on Rebbiif
monyThe for whichAruch
Shulchan he took payment
17 determines likevoid; rather,ofsothelong
the opinions Rif, Meir’s opinion allowing the cook to partake
he took it, the money is considered stolen property in his from the food on Motzei
as he is and
Rambam, Rosh to pasken
suspected of taking like Rebbi Yehudahall
payment, (asofwehishaverulings
already Shabbos. With regard to a mayzid we must act stringently like Rebbi
possession. However, the fact that he transgressed “Mah
mentioned). Yehudah who holds that the food is perpetually assur.
and all of his testimonies are void, unless it is known that ani b’chinam” is not a reason to obligate him to return it.
he did not take payment for this particular ruling or this- ב- However, the Mishneh LaMelech4 writes that the
particular eidus.Maiseh See notes. Shabbos [2] with regard to a Melacha where wordsnothing
of the Ritva is done to thethat
indicate object
oneitself who takes payment
Now, the gemara in Maseches Kiddushin teaches 2
to judge is obligated to return to the ba’al din what he
Where one was motzi something from one reshus to the speaking, the issur of Maiseh Shabbos is not something specific to
thatother,
if one was amekadesh
if such thing is assur a womanbecausewith the payment
of Maiseh Shabbos /for took from
Bishul creatinghim, because
an issur for onesince
to eathisfood
ruling is not
cooked on a valid rul-
Shabbos. On
haza’as mei chatas, Specifics
she is not in mekudeshes,
this inyan since his water the contrary, it applies to any Melacha.
ing, he has nothing for which to take payment from him.If someone transgresses any
is mei me’arah and of the Melachos Shabbos it is then forbidden for him to benefit from
רבנוhaza’ah
- יונהhis ,' תוס,חיי אדם is,רמ"א
not ,טור
considered
- a valid Thisheis contrary to the inwords of the Bach.
what did. Additionally, the Shulchan Aruch 19 the Mechaber
[sprinkling.
]בAlthough Theboth Ritva
our Mishnathereand explains
Gemarathat onlysince
makehis actionsto brings
reference The Machaneh Ephraim likewisewhat
this concept of not being able
5 to eat one cooked
disagrees on
with
are void, he is not entitled to take payment for the sprin-
cooking on Shabbos, it is already made known from the Tur that Shabbos,
the Bach and the Rema adds that this
and writes that one who takes payment to is applicable to the other
this concept of Maiseh Shabbos doesn’t differentiate. Practically as well.
kling, because he did not provide her with any benefit. Melachos judge must return the money, because since his ruling
NOTES
If a Maiseh Shabbos is assur b’hana’ah / Two aspects to Maiseh concerning where one toivels vessels on Shabbos. We say there that if done b’shogeig
Shabbos, and the difference between Mevashel and other Melachos /
Notes
he may use them, and b’mayzid not. As such, it is clear that the issur Maiseh Shabbos
the Something cooked on
ruling. However, whatShabbos is given Yom
the Ma’adanei similar
Tovstatus to that
writes, otherthe this case.
applies even” to
Orbenefit
perhaps, once
through they accept
something’s usage,him upon
and not justthemselves, he is
an issur achilah.
forbidden foods / Where one cooked water and it got cold again /
ruling does not become void when the payment is given after the
Where one cooked water for washing and it got cold again
obligated to judge
On the other hand, them without
concerning Bishulpayment.
there is an The Minchas
additional Chinuch
element. When one
25
judgment, refers to where- שלמה he did
מנחתnot שו"תstipulate
- with him before- writesonthat
cooks it isthe
Shabbos clear
meatthat
getsone
a dinwho is pasul
of basar to judge,
tereifah and the
m’drabbanan. As ba’alei
such, it
becomes assur for consumption just like all other forbidden foods. Because of this
hand
[1] Thethat he would
Minchas Shlomo 31be paid for
comments on judging the
this that the Turcase.
writesThe
howBirkei
the din Yosef
Maiseh dinim accepted him upon themselves, since he is not obligated to
the Magen Avraham 34 asserts that even the pot it was cooked in becomes assur as
discusses
Shabbos thistofurther
applies at length.
all Melachos making it assur to benefit from the act performed. judge,
well. Onehe may
then take
needs payment
to do from
hagalah on them.
the pot and it is necessary even if a 24 hour
He points out that according to this the issur Maiseh Shabbos isn’t specifically an
periodHowever,
passes making it no longer a Ben Yomo.
the Imrei Binah concludes
26 Although there
thatwould have logically
although he is
issurAachilah
dayan(eating)
pasul who theanbaalei
but also dinim accepted
issur ha’na’ah upon themselves
(benfit). However, this is difficult
been room to say that after 24 hours the pot should only give off negative tastes
to understand. In Bava Kama 32 we see that even Rebbi Yochanan Hasandler who not obligated to judge them and he may withdraw from
through which one doesn’t benefit, nevertheless we see clearly that the Chachamim
judging
holds/ Maiseh
In a city where
Shabbos there
is assur minishatorah,
an established
neverthelessBeis
this isDin,
onlybut other
an issur achilah theirthecase,
made issurnevertheless,
Maiseh Shabbosifbyhe accepts
Bishul upontohimself
comparable all otherto judge their
forbidden foods.
and not an issur ha’na’ah, and dayanim judged them
it is something learnt out from pesukim. Now, if this
The
din same
Torah,wayhe by must
other issurim
judge the
thempot is also assur
without for use even
payment. when
This not a Ben
is because
is true (that the issur is only an issur achilah and not an issur ha’na’ah) for Rebbi
בינהholds
אמריthat,חינוך מנחתShabbos
,משפטisשער Yomo, so too this follows for Maiseh Shabbos as well.
Yochanan Hasandler who Maiseh assur min hatorah, then it anyone who teaches chukim u’mishpatim must teach them without
must certainly shouldMishpat
The Sha’ar be the caseraises
for both Rebbi Meir and Rebbi Yehuda who hold
a question in the case where the With thisItindoes
payment. mind not
we can
dependnow explain what is said
on whether he isinobligated
Bava Kamato that even
judge
[2] 2
the issur is merely m’drabbanan. As such, it is difficult to understand how we can according to Rebbi Yochanan Hasandler the issur is only an issur achilah and not an
ba’alei dinim accepted upon themselves to be judged by a karov
say it is assur to benefit from all types of Maiseh Shabbos.
them. For this reason, in a city where there is an established Beis
issur ha’na’ah. What this means to say is that although the food get the status of a
oi pasul (a relative or someone who is otherwise pasul to judge), Din, if assur,
maichal the ba’alei dinimthiscome
nevertheless to be itjudged
only makes before
forbidden other dayanim,
for consumption and not
To answer he asserts that in truth there are two forms of the issur Maiseh
and he Therefore,
took payment benefit. It doesn’t become like Arlah, Klayim,
although those dayanim are permitted to refuse to judgeor Hekdesh where benefit
theiriscase
also
Shabbos. although toby judge their case,
all the Melachos whether
one does his ruling
on Shabbos there is is
an
forbidden. However, this is said specifically with regard to benefit that one could
issur not.from
voidtoorbenefit We them,
could say thatthis
nevertheless thedoesn’t
halachah
pose athat one who
contradiction takes
to what the since there is an established Beis Din in the city, nevertheless, it
have enjoyed even before the Maiseh was performed. This is because it isn’t caused
Gemara in Bava saysrulings
Kama his concerningarehow a Maiseh onlyis regarding
Shabbos only assur for certainly
is the
payment to judge void, was said a by forbidden prohibited
Melacha such as forwhere
them one to takethrough
benefits paymentgiving for judging
the food to his
consumption and not benefit. We will now bring a brief account of his words.
qualified dayan who judges as part of a Beis Din of three dayanim. friend
them.asSince
a gift, they
or to his animalthe
accept to eat. As long
ba’alei dinimas these things are
and judge done thereby
them, in a way
The first thing to know is that by all Melachos Shabbos whenever the Melacha where one doesn’t benefit from the Bishul itself, we then say that although the
In such a case, he is obligated to judge without payment, and if he teaching them chukim u’mishpatim, they must teach them without
actually activates the object for benefit, then it most certainly is assur to benefit from Chachamim gave it the status of forbidden food, nevertheless this only makes it assur
transgresses
the andExamples
Maiseh Shabbos. takes payment, his where
would include rulingsoneareheatsvoid. However,
up water for bathinga payment.
for The same
his consumption applies
and not benefit.toOna the
relative or someone
other hand, who
there is also is pasul.
benefit which
relative or
purposes, orlaunders
one who is pasul,
clothing since
to wear. mincases
In such ha’Torah hetoisbenefit
it is assur disqualified
from the Once
one he capable
is only agrees oftohaving
judgethrough
them,theheactmust judge
of Bishul thatwithout payment.
was performed. Such
act of issur although in both situations the issur is purely benefit related. This is benefit is most definitely assur being that it is only had through the act of issur, and
from judging, and it is only because the ba’alei dinim accepted him And if he judges for payment, his rulings are void because of the
because it is assur to use something if the usage only comes through benefitting from this is clear from what the Mishna teaches that one may not use vessels which he
upon
one themselves
of the that heThe
Melachos Shabbos. is able tofor
source judge,
this ishe canthesay,
from “I doinnot
Mishna wish33
Terumos k’nas, just
toiveled as with any dayan who judges for payment, whose rul-
on Shabbos.
to judge your case, since the Torah disqualified me from judging ings are void.
2
given).
דרשו
is invalid, the payment was a nesinah b’ta’us (mistakenly
However, he writes that there’s no proof from
the issur Maiseh Shabbos applies to all of the 39 Melachos. It
the Ritva
Taking
On the other hand, from the Poskim it isn’t so cut and dry that
payment
Shabbos
Bechoros Daf 29
for judging
Daf Lamed Ches
rulings are void and any admissions and claims made before him
which happened on Yomalso Tov. Hisnopoint
have legalisforce
to show that there truly is
no issur Hotza’ah applicable. On Yom Tov such an act is completely
becomes clearagainst
from them the
thatBach,
there isbecause the
a possibility Ritva
some wrote
are excluded, muttar.בינה אמרי,המשפט
He even adds thatנתיבות ,תומים
of course it ,מהרי"ט
would beבשם הגדולה
assur כנסת
to eat the fruits
and will now gokiddushin,
thisweregarding that the reason she is not
on to elaborate. if they were actually removed into a8 public domain on Shabbos itself
mekudeshes
The Chayeiis Adam
because she that
20asserts did not get any
the issur benefit
Maiseh fromis
Shabbos
ב. The Knesses HaGedolah says in the name of Shu”t
just like the din by Mevashel. The Magen Avraham 25 cites the words
Maharit9 that what they said that one who takes
of Tosafos.
him for which
applicable she where
specifically becomeismekudeshes.
couldsomething But there’s
done to the object itself. A
payment to judge, his rulings are void, was stated only
physical change has to happen such as the result
no proof from there that he must return the money. of cooking food or The Ramban 26 answers Tosafos’s question using a different
anything comparable. On the other hand, when one is Motzi regarding
approach. He awrites
ruling thatthat depends
although upon
all types shudaShabbos
of Maiseh d’dayanaare
Now, from
something the Sha’ar
one domainMishpat 6
concludes
to another that the
where the actual Bach
object isn’t – that
assur is a matter
on Shabbos itself inwhich
order tothe Chachamim
prevent left to
their benefit (such the
as what
physically affected, if done b’shogeig it can be used
is correct, in that he need not return the payment. He on Shabbos itself one cooked, took Ma’aser off from, or anything comparable),
judgment of the dayan to rule according to his under-
and even by the person who committed the act. If done b’mayzid it nevertheless the fruits here are different. They began in the person’s
proves this from several proofs, based on what we find
is assur even to others, but only until Motzei Shabbos. He does standing.
house, In suchtoa acase,
were removed publicthe
area,Chachamim disqualified
and then brought back to the
in several
conclude places
though that that a person
one should is obligated
be stringent with all to perform
Issurei Torah him from
house. acting
As such, there iswhen he totakes
no reason assurpayment.
them. They However,
didn’t come
just like by The 21 cites his words plainly to the house
Mevashel. Biur Halacha
a mitzvah for another person without payment, and where he through issur Shabbostobeing
rules according the that they actually
Torah, originated
the truth, and
without bringing any opposition. there. No benefit is had from a Maiseh Shabbos at all.
nevertheless, if he took payment, he does not return what is just, how can the ruling be invalidated?
theHowever,
moneythe thattruth
heistook
that this
frommatter
him.is already
He writesbroachedthatbywe
the He then adds that of course if they were to remain in the public
Rishonim. It all begins with the Gemara in Eiruvin 22 which teaches The(without
domain Tumim there
being
10
explains
returned thatitthe
to the house) Maharit
would be assur does
to eat
cannot say that he should be obligated to return the
how if fruits were removed from their techum and later returned, even not mean to say that in a matter which does not depend
them. Consuming them there would be to do so through the means of
money
if this wasbecause
done b’mayzid a nesinah
it wasthere b’ta’us
is no loss - aslocation.
to their the Machaneh
What this issur
upon shudaOnd’dayanei
Shabbos. the other hand,
therewhen
is returned
no issurto against
the house taking
one can
Ephraim
means is thatwrote
even ifabove - because
they were min ha’Torah
returned b’mayzid it is stillhis ruling
permissible eat them there being that no benefit is had from a Maiseh Shabbos.
for them to be consumed in their place.
payment. For it is certainly assur to take payment even
is a valid ruling, and it is only that the Chachamim penal-
forWhat become
a ruling clear
that fromnot
does Tosafos,
dependthe Rashba, and Ramban
upon shuda is that
d’dayanei.
izedTosafos
him thattherehis ruling iswhy
23 questions void.
the Therefore,
fruits should the paymentfor
be permissible is concerning where one actually transgresses the issur Hotza’ah
consumption when returned b’mayzid from outside the techum. We
Rather, he means to say that what the Chachamim said,
d’oraisa, there it would be assur for him to benefit through the issur
a valid payment and not a nesinah b’ta’us.
know that one may not eat food which was cooked b’mayzid on that if Shabbos.
Maiseh he transgressed and took payment his rulings are
However,
Shabbos. He answersthe that
Imrei Binah
cooking
7
writesbecause
is different that the correct
it involves the invalid, that is only in a ruling that depends upon shuda
transgression of a Melacha D’oraisa relating to Shabbos. His On the other hand, the Ritvah b’shem Rabbeinu Yonah asserts that
ruling is like the Mishneh LaMelech and the Machaneh d’dayanei.both
concerning Withthethis,
issurtheHotza’ah
Tumimand resolves
techuminthethere
question
is no
intention is to point out how the issur relating to techumin is merely
Ephraim, that a dayan who took payment to judge must
m’drabbanan. In the case discussed nothing was removed from a application
raised byto theMaiseh This is becausethere
Shabbos.HaGedolah
Knesses the issur of Maiseh
against the
returndomain
private what he intotook. Heone,
a public explains thatone
rather from thetechum
entiretobasis of
another. Shabbos is something that was initiated where 11 an actual change
Maharit from the gemara in Kesubos.
happens to the object itself. The term Maiseh refers to a physical
Such an act is assur only m’drabbanan.
what the Chachamim said, that they penalize the dayan change, and this the
However, is dubbed
issurTumim Maiseh
there Shabbos to
concludes thatallude
the towords
areas
eidim that
andThetheChiddushei his rulings
HaRashba there 24and their
explains in testimony
greater detail.are He where physical 12 change happens to an object. However, where all one
writes thatis that is nature
differentofbeing that awith
of the Rema indicate that even in a ruling that does not
invalid, Bishulthe the k’nas Melacharespect to theis does is transgress the issur Hotza’ah and no change happens to the
D’oraisa
transgressed. On the other hand, the Gemara is discussing a case depend upon shuda d’dayanei, his rulings are void, for
dayan and the eid is that since his ruling is not a ruling object itself, as such there is no reason to assur because of Maiseh
the Rema there went to considerable effort to validate
and his testimony is not testimony, he must return the
NOTESa get that was arranged by a Rav who takes payment
money, because his ruling and his testimony accom-NOTES
forNow,arranging the get. Arranging a get is certainly not
plished
Throughnothing.
this he raises how one who cooks on Shabbos makes the food assur for on the surface this is difficult to understand. When the water returns to its
consumption just like other maichalos assuros. As such, the food becomes forbidden something
original cold state,that depends
it comes upon
out that one isn’t shuda d’dayanei,
benefitting from the MaisehandShabbos
nev-
to eatTherefore,
even where onehe concludes
doesn’t benefit fromthat in the
the Bishul suchcase
as in aof mitzvah
a where
case it was at all. As such, it is hard to hear why it should be assur to drink the water then. If
ertheless there was reason to invalidate the get.
already roasted prior to being cooked. Although he would have preferred to eat one warms up water using Arlah oil or Klayim wood and then the water gets cold
which a person performs for another person,
roasted and not cooked meat and there is no real benefit from the Melacha,
where it is again,The Nesivos
the din HaMishpat
isn’t for it to be assur to drink. likewise disagrees with
13 One is allowed to drink it being that
impossible
nevertheless to ofinvalidate
the act the the
Bishul transforms action thatforbidden
meat into he performed,
food just like itall there is no longer any benefit had from the Arlah or Klayim. This being the case the
other maichalos assuros. On the other hand, concerning different forms of benefit the Maharit and writes that in every type of ruling, his
is indeed true that he need not return the money to him, same should apply to Maiseh Shabbos as well.
they are only assur if made possibly purely through the act of Melacha itself. rulings are void. He resolves what the Maharit points
since ultimately,
However, if one was capable he performed
of having a certain anbenefit
action evenfor thetheother
before act was As a result, we are forced to say that something cooked on Shabbos is given the
committed, then such a thing remains permissible. This applies even to food as the out,ofthat
status howissur
a maichal canfora the
ruling
entire be
day. invalidated
It doesn’t make awhen thethendayan
difference if one
person. However, regarding judging and testimony, since actually benefits from the aveirah or not. Therefore, even where the cooking
forbidden status is only given with regard to it consumption and not benefit. ruled according to the Torah, the truth, and what is just.
theHeChachamim
then continues that said thatwehis
although onlyruling
find this is not a between
difference rulinganand issur
happened through a Goi, since while the water was hot it was assur to drink being
Hetheexplains
that Goi was his that theas such
shaliach, Chachamim
it becomes assur removed from him
the entire Shabbos.
his testimony
achilah is notwithin
and issur ha’na’ah testimony,
the words of the dayan
Rebbi andandthe
Yochanan not wit-
Rebbi
Yehudah, nevertheless it truthfully applies to Rebbi Yehudah as well. theThisstatus
then has dayan.
ofaapractical Therefore,
application where one thecooks
claims
water on the ba’alei
ofShabbos for the
ness did nothing for him. Therefore, he must return the purpose
He then uses this concept to explain what the Beis Yosef asserts b’shem the
35 dinim are considered like claims that they presented
of bathing. Although in doing so he transgresses an out-
issur Torah,
moneyThetoBeis
Rashba. him,Yosefsince hisa case
discusses action wheredid one not
tells atake
Goi toeffect
make a at
fireall.
and nevertheless since bathing is merely a form of benefit, as such it would be muttar
boil water for him on Shabbos. He writes that if the water got cold it would still be
side of Beis Din, which have no legal force. Likewise, an
to use the water as soon as it cools down. When cold again there no longer is any
assurWhether
for him tothe halachah
drink that
it. Not only hisif rulings
that, the waterarehadvoid applies
previously only
been admission
to and benefit
boiled had frommade
the Maiseh the ba’alei
by Shabbos. There dinim is not
isn’t reason to sayconsidered an
that because it was
then reverted to this state, even to those who hold even by liquids that there is no assur while hot it should be assur the entire Shabbos. This is something said
shuda d’dayana or even to rulings that are based on the din / His admission, since he does not have the status of a dayan.
specifically with regard to eating or drinking and not benefit. [See more what he
Bishul after Bishul, nevertheless it would still be assur to drink the water since it was
cooked by a fire on Shabbos. has to say there.]
3
דרשו
his ruling was in accordance with din Torah.
Bechoros Daf 29
Taking payment for judging
Accordingly, the entire proceeding is invalidated, even if later in his discussion he retracts this and writes that
regarding every type of ruling, his rulings are void. He
writes there that eidim who testified before a dayan who
The Imrei Binah14 asks about what the Poskim
bring in the name of the Maharit that in a ruling that receives payment may subsequently return and testify
does not depend upon shuda d’dayanei the ruling is again, and there is no issue of ‘keivan shehigid, shuv einoi
not invalidated, that after all the Maharit himself wrote choizer u’magid’, because he does not have the status of a
this only at the beginning of his discussion. However, dayan.
-ב-
The heter of taking s’char batalah
It must be evident that it’s s’char batalah / Dayanim who do not The Sema there17 explains that there are three differ-
work at all to be available to judge dinei Torah ent cases in this matter:
תומים, רשב"א,' תוס, סמ"ע, טור ושו"ע,'גמ 1] If they come before him while he is engaged in his
ג.The gemara in Maseches Kesubos teaches that 1
work, and he stops his work to judge their case, in this
although it is assur to take payment for adjudicating a case, according to everyone, they must pay him, and he
din Torah, nevertheless, it is mutar to take s’char batalah is mutar l’chatchilah to take this payment.
for what he loses by being unable to engage in his work 2] If he was not engaged in his work at that time, but
while judging the din Torah. And they said there that it it is known that he has work to do, and he stipulated with
must be evident that the payment is s’char batalah. For them to get paid because by judging their case he will
if it is not evident that it is s’char batalah, although his be unable to engage in the work that he wishes to do,
rulings are valid, nevertheless it is improper for a dayan in this case it is improper for him to take the payment.
to take s’char batalah when it is not evident that it is truly However, if he did take it, his ruling is valid.
s’char batalah.
3] If it is known that he has no work or business to
Similarly, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch16 write that engage in, but he says that perhaps if he would not be
it is mutar to take s’char batalah. For example, if he has occupied with the din Torah, he would find an opportu-
a specific job to do at the time when he is required to nity to earn money or do some work, in this case, even if
judge, and he says to the ba’alei dinim, “Give me some- he already took the payment and already judged the case,
one who will do my work in my place,” or, “Give me the his rulings are invalid.
wages for that work that I will not be able to do,” then
Now, Tosfos in our sugya18 writes that the practice
it is mutar. Of course, only if he gets equally from both
nowadays to teach Torah for payment, even where the
ba’alei dinim. However, if it is not evident that it is s’char
person does not have another means of support and it
batalah, such as where he does not have a specific job to
is not evident that the payment he takes is s’char bata-
do, but rather says that perhaps he will have an opportu-
lah for the work he could not do, is because it is evident
nity to earn money by buying merchandise or through
that he is setting aside all of his business and commercial
brokerage, and for this reason he asks for payment, it is
activities in order to teach Torah. This is considered an
assur.
even clearer case of s’char batalah.
4
דרשו
in Yerushalayim got their wages from the terumas halish-
Bechoros Daf 29
Taking payment for judging
Similarly, in Kesubos,19 it says that the gozrei gezeiros payment to judge applies to a dayan who does not con-
sistantly withdraw from his other occupations for the
purpose of judging. However, the Rabbanim who sit in
chah. The Shitah Mekubetzes there writes in the name
of the Talmidei HaRashba that they were not paid for judgment nowadays, whose occupation is to adjudicate
judging, but rather, since they refrained from all business disputes between one person and another, and because
activities and were designated specifically for this pur- of this they do not engage in business or other work
pose, they were permitted to get paid. However, another - and if not for this, they would certainly engage in busi-
person before whom a case comes for judgment is not ness, for otherwise where would their livelihood come
permitted to say, “Give me my livelihood for today and from - this is considered as though they have a specific
and identifiable occupation from which they are with-
I will judge your case,” unless the payment is s’char bat-
drawing. For it is known to everyone that it is because
alah.
of their involvement in judging that they refrain from
The Tumim20 writes that the issur against taking engaging in business.
מראי מקומות
סי' ט' [בהגהות הטור.8 )' דיני דיינים סי' י"ח (אות א.7 סי' ט' סק"ב.6 דיני שכירות סי' ט"ז.5 ' הלכות סנהדרין פכ"ג הלכה ה.4 ' חו"מ סי' ט.3 : דף נ"ח.2 : קידושין דף נ"ח.1
' חו"מ סי' ט.16 . דף ק"ה.15 ) דיני דיינים סי' י"ח (אות ב' ד"ה והנה.14 שם סק"ג.13 ' באהע"ז בסדר הגט סעיף ד.12 . דף ק"ה.11 שם סק"ב.10 ח"א סי' ס"ט.9 ]אות י"ז
' סי' ט.24 ) חו"מ סי' ט' (אות י"ט ד"ה עוד.23 ח"א סוף סי' ל"ח.22 )' על הרא"ש פרק ה' (אות מ.21 ) סי' ט' (אורים סק"ט.20 . דף ק"ה.19 סד"ה מה.18 סקט"ז.17 'סעיף ה
) דיני דיינים סי' ט"ז (אות ג' ד"ה ויש.26 )' מצוה פ"ג (אות ח.25 סק"ג
5
דרשו
דרשו
