gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

Kollel Lihoraah - English — Lech Lechu (2026-10-19)

Publisher: Kollel Lihoraah - English

Week: Lech Lechu (2026-10-19)

Kollel Lihoraah - English — Lech Lechu (2026-10-19)

Open the PDF Download

Parshas Lech Lecha 5787 Ask the Rav Preparing Toast on Shabbos Using an Inverted Pan stringent and color both sides, as there are several advantages to doing so. One who wishes to be stringent has whom to rely upon, but there is no obli- Q: I was a guest at a family’s home on Shabbos and saw them warming gation. We will briefly explain the reasoning. challah and slices of challah on the hotplate until they became completely The Gemara (Menachos 35a) states that Rav Yitzchak said, “Black straps dry and crispy, like toast. I wondered whether this involves the prohibition are a halachah l’Moshe miSinai.” The Gemara questions this from a Baraisa of bishul or any other Shabbos prohibition. stating that straps may be green, black, or white. The Gemara answers that the requirement for black applies only to the outer side, while the inner side A: According to the basic halachah, several leading poskim permit warm- may be any color. ing challah until it becomes toast, and one who is lenient certainly has The Rambam (Hilchos Tefillin 3:14) writes that since the backs of the straps whom to rely upon. Although some poskim are stringent, the primary ruling are on the inner side, they are kosher even if green or white. Similarly, the follows the lenient opinions. There are two main reasons for permitting this. Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 33:3) rules that the inner side may be any color ex- 1. Some poskim permit making toast by placing bread on top of a pot or cept red. However, the Rambam writes that it is a beautification of the mitz- inverted pan on the hotplate or blech, since bread is a dry food and there is vah for the entire tefillin, including the box and straps, to be black. Never- no bishul after bishul. Even according to those who suggest prohibiting it theless, the Mishnah Berurah cites the Beis Yosef and Darchei Moshe that because of makeh b’patish in food, the Mishnah Berurah in Biur Halachah our custom is not to color the inner side. (O.C. 318, s.v. V’hadachasan) concludes that the prohibition of makeh I would like to explain the Rambam’s opinion and the practice of those who b’patish does not apply to food. There is also no concern of roasting after purchase straps blackened on both sides. The Rambam writes that it is a baking, since the prohibition applies to cooking after roasting or the reverse, beautification for the tefillin to be entirely black, including the ketzitzah and but not to roasting after roasting or baking after baking. Roasting after bak- the entire strap. The Beis Yosef explains that this includes the backs of the ing is likewise permitted, as explained by the Eliyah Rabbah (se’if katan 17) straps, but concludes that this is not our custom. Similarly, the Darchei and Mishnah Berurah (se’if katan 41). Moshe cites the Or Zarua that both sides should be blackened, but also con- 2.Another reason for leniency is found in the Maharsham’s Daas Torah. He cludes that this is not the accepted practice. explains that the Rambam’s ruling prohibiting the hardening of a soft object The Radbaz (Vol. V, siman 1426) explains the Rambam similarly, writing through fire, or softening a hard object, applies specifically to utensils, but that one who wishes to beautify the mitzvah should also blacken the backs not to food, where such changes are part of the normal manner of eating. of the straps, as implied by the Rosh. Since the requirement for black straps This was also the ruling of Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv zt”l and Rav Yis- is a halachah l’Moshe miSinai, black is clearly the preferred color for tefil- roel Yaakov Fisher zt”l, as cited in Meor HaShabbos. Nevertheless, some lin. It therefore stands to reason that having the entire strap black is a beau- poskim are stringent, including the Shoel U’Meishiv (Vol. II, siman 20), tification. How could one suggest that white is preferable to black, to the based upon the Rambam, and Shemiras Shabbos Kehilchasah (Chapter extent that blackening the inner side would be considered a disgrace? 1:71). Accordingly, some poskim maintain that although there is no obligation, An Additional Point Regarding Challah Warmed on a Fleishig Pot there is certainly an advantage to coloring both sides. Besides fulfilling the When challah is placed directly on a pot containing meat, even if the outside Rambam’s opinion, one also satisfies the stringency of the Keses HaSofer, is clean, the principle of nat bar nat applies. Therefore, the outer layer of the who writes that even the edges of the straps must be black, possibly as part challah, to the depth of a klipah, may not be eaten together with dairy foods. of the halachah l’Moshe miSinai. Another advantage relates to the Mishnah However, it may be eaten with fish. Although some are stringent regarding Berurah (33:19), who writes that when the black coloring becomes worn or nat bar nat during cooking, Rav Akiva Eiger (Yoreh Deah 116) writes that faded, it must be renewed. This commonly occurs where the knot is tight- there is no concern in this regard, and the challah may therefore be eaten ened, and the Mishnah Berurah emphasizes the importance of being careful with fish. about this. Several poskim therefore write that coloring both sides provides an additional benefit, and one who does so is deserving of a berachah. How- Coloring the Back and Edges of Tefillin Straps Black ever, other poskim question this practice and explain why the Beis Yosef and Darchei Moshe wrote that the custom is not to color the inner side. Q: Nowadays, I see people in shul wearing tefillin with straps that are The Shevet HaLevi (Vol. IX, siman 16) questions why one should adopt black on both sides. Is this a chumrah, an actual halachic requirement, or is this stringency when the Beis Yosef, Rema, and subsequent poskim did not there no need for it? May one continue following the common practice of recommend it even as a hidur, despite citing the Rambam and Or Zarua. As purchasing straps that are black only on the outside? is evident from the Shulchan Aruch HaRav, they certainly had a reason for not instituting such a simple practice. Why, then, should we change the A: Halachah lemaaseh, the accepted custom is to color the outer side of accepted halachic practice? Although the arguments for coloring both sides the straps black and leave the inner side uncolored. However, some are are valid, the clear implication of the poskim is that even those meticulous in mitzvos did not follow this practice. There- 2: A similar question arose for a Rosh Kollel who traveled to America fore, an individual who wishes to be stringent is to raise funds. He was offered two rental cars, one black and one pink, deserving of a berachah, but there is no reason to with the pink car significantly cheaper. Would driving the pink car pre- establish it as a general ruling. In Shevet HaLevi (Vol. sent a problem of Lo Yilbash? XI, siman 168), he further questions the Rambam. On the one hand, the Rambam rules that only the outer side must be A: Before answering any shaylah, a posek must establish the metzius black, yet he subsequently writes that it is a beautification for accurately. Pink is not automatically a women's color for purposes of the entire tefillin to be black. Since the Rambam generally does halachah. If men also commonly use pink bedding or drive pink cars, not include rulings without a source in the Gemara, where is the there is no issue merely because of the color. As the Maharsha source for this beautification? He therefore suggests another version (Chiddushei Aggados, Nedarim 49b) explains, the prohibition of Lo of the Rambam’s text, which reads, “It is a disgrace for the tefillin to Yilbash applies specifically to items designated for one gender, whereas be entirely black,” rather than, “It is a beautification.” This version is something commonly used by both men and women is permitted. This supported by the Hagahos Maimoniyos and is also quoted by the Ba- is also evident from the Rema (Yoreh Deah 156:2), who rules that alt- ruch She’amar. hough looking in a mirror was originally prohibited for men because it It also corresponds with Tosafos (Menachos 35a, s.v. Birtzuos Shecho- was considered a feminine practice, it is permitted in places where men ros), who mention that some made their tefillin boxes white, since the also commonly use mirrors. Our discussion therefore assumes that requirement for black applies only to the straps. This implies that they these particular sheets, blanket cover, or car are the type that are gener- specifically preferred white boxes to avoid a disgrace. However, the ally only used by women. Rosh writes that having the entire tefillin black is a beautification, cor- At first glance, one might argue that sleeping under a blanket or driving responding with our version of the Rambam. a car cannot be prohibited because neither involves actually wearing Furthermore, even according to the version describing it as a beautifi- women's clothing. However, Lo Yilbash is not restricted to an actual act cation, the Rambam’s words “the ketzitzah and the entire strap” may of dressing. Onkelos (Devarim 22:5) refers to men's weaponry being refer not to the back of the strap, but to its entire length on the outer upon a woman, and the Gemara (Nazir 59a) discusses going to battle side, including the portion beyond the minimum required length. This with weapons. Similarly, the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh Deah 156:2) pro- also explains why the Tur (siman 33) quotes the Rambam but omits the hibits a man from looking in a mirror under Lo Yilbash when that is end of his statement. If blackening the entire strap were a beautifica- exclusively a women's practice. Clearly, the prohibition can extend tion, why would he omit it? However, according to the version that beyond ordinary garments. There is, however, a significant distinction considers it a disgrace, the omission is understandable. regarding the purpose of the activity. The Bach and Taz (Yoreh Deah Halachah Lemaaseh: The Gedolei Yisr ael wer e not par ticular 182:5, Taz 182:4) explain that the prohibition concerns adopting the about coloring both sides, as stated by Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv other gender's appearance for adornment. Where the intention is simply zt”l and Rav Chaim Kanievsky in the name of the Chazon Ish. protection from cold, rain, or sun, and not beautification, they permit it. However, Rav Aharon Yehudah Leib Steinman zt”l said there is an The Chayei Adam, in Binas Adam (Shaar Issur VeHeter 74, [also reffer- advantage to blackening both sides, since the dye penetrates the enced as Chapter 94]), challenges this approach from the Sifri and Ge- entire thickness of the leather and does not wear away easily. mara, which prohibit a woman from wearing weapons to war. Armor is Indeed, nowadays some bachurim purchase straps blackened on clearly worn for protection, not adornment. This clearly implies that Lo both sides. It is important to emphasize that although this fulfills Yilbas is not limited to cases where the object at hand is being used for the Rambam’s opinion and several other hidurim, there is no aesthetic purposes. obligation or established custom to do so. Rav Moshe Stern- However, an interesting observation can be made in the Kaf HaChaim buch shlit”a likewise writes in Teshuvos V’Hanhagos (Vol. II, (Orach Chaim 240:13–14), who records the practice of women who, siman 22) that according to the Rambam, both sides should after returning from the mikvah, spread one of their husband's garments be blackened. The writings of the Arizal also mention black- over themselves when their husbands are unable to be with there that ening both sides, and this was the practice of the Maharil night. This suggests that merely covering oneself with another gender's Diskin. Nevertheless, this remains an additional chumrah garment may not constitute Lo Yilbash. Nevertheless, this proof is not and hidur. The accepted custom throughout Klal Yisrael, conclusive. Being that even men do not ordinarily wear such a garment as stated by the Beis Yosef, Rema, and Mishnah Beru- in this manner, a woman using it as a covering may not be consid- rah, is that only the outer side must be black. One who ered doing a manly act, and therefore does not necessarily establish a wishes to color both sides may certainly do so and leniency for our case. thereby fulfill several additional opinions. Halacha li'maaseh, Mor i V' Rabbi, Har av Hagaon Rav Yitzchak Berkovitz shlita, was indeed machmir in both situations, ruling that when the bedding or car is of the type specifically associated with Practical Corner: By Rabbi Nesanel women, one should not use it because of the concern of Lo Yilbash. Odzer from the Rabba nim of Beis However, other poskim rule that in a situation of great need, where Horaah KLY there is no reasonable alternative, one may rely on the lenient position of the Bach and Taz, since the person is not intending to adopt a femi- Is sleeping under a pink blanket, or driving a nine appearance or beautify himself, but is merely seeking a place to pink car, a problem of Lo Yilbash? sleep or an affordable means of transportation. Summary: Pink bedding or a pink car does not automatically pre- Q: 1: I am a yeshiva bachur spending Shabbos sent a problem of Lo Yilbash, provided that such items are also com- with cousins in Eretz Yisrael. When I entered the monly used by men. However, when they are distinctly feminine, there room they prepared for me, I noticed that the is a genuine halachic concern. Mori V'Rabbi Harav Hagaon Rav sheets and blanket cover were pink. Is there a Yitzchak Berkovitz shlita ruled stringently in both situations, although problem of Lo Yilbash with sleeping in that other poskim permit relying on the lenient opinions in cases of great bed? need where no reasonable alternative is available. Take a part in spreading the light! Email info@kollellihoraah.org for sponsorship opportunities. To receive this weekly publication via email, Click here or email info@kollellihoraah.org. Have an interesting Shayla? Ask the Rav at info@kollellihoraah.org