HaIchud B'chidud - English — Lech Lechu (2026-10-19)

בס"ד
Shiurim of the Ichud B’chidud are available פרשת לך לך תשפ"ז
on Torah Anytime by R’ Yitzchok Aryeh Epstein
5:48 הדלקת נרות
This week’s Shiurim can be accessed at
https://www.torahanytime.com/#/lectures?v=485256
sushj c - sujht v 9:23/9:59 סזק"ש
https://www.torahanytime.com/#/lectures?v=485260 זמניםare for Lakewood, NJ
718-298-2077 press 9 485256# or 9 485260#. Volume 28 Issue 4
k"mz ihhyapg (khshhz) cegh ovrct wr d"vrv ic vsuvh iugna crv b"zk
LAST WEEK’S RIDDLE
How is it שייךthat a woman is not מחוייבתto perform a certain מצוהyet may make a ברכהover it if
she so desires, and at that time may be מוציאa man with the ברכה.
ANSWER
It is well known that women are not required to learn תורה. This is learned from the פסוקof ולמדתם אותם את
בניכםwhich the חז"לinterpret בניבם ולא בנותיכם- your sons not your daughters. Yet the מחברin או"ח סי' מ"ז סי"דsays
נשים מברכות ברכת התורה- women say ברכת התורהwhich seems to say, although not conclusively, that they are required
to say ברכות התורה.
The בית יוסףand the מגן אברהםexplain that they are, indeed, required to say ברכת התורהbecause they are
required to learn the דיניםpertaining to the מצוותthat they must fulfill and, similar to other מצוותwhen someone is
required to perform a מצוה, a ברכהbeforehand Is mandatory.
However, the Vilna Gaon disagrees strongly with this and says that they may say ברכת התורהfor a different
reason. There is a well known מחלוקת ראשוניםconcerning whether women who are פטורותfrom מצוות עשה שהזמן גרמא
– from מצוותwhich must be performed within a certain time frame – may make a ברכהon the performance of the מצוה
if they wish to perform the מצוהdespite not being required to. For instance, may they make a ברכהof לישב בסוכהif they
sit in the סוכהdespite not being required. The רמב"םsays that they cannot make the ברכהand so rules the מחבר )או"ח
('סי' י"ז ב. However, תוס' ר"ה ל"ג. rules that they can say the ברכהand so rules the רמ"א.
One reason given to explain why the רמב"םsays that women can’t make the ברכהis that they can’t say וצונוsince
they are not commanded to do the מצוה. However, תוספותholds that the ברכהmay, indeed, be said because וצונוdoesn’t
mean that she herself was commanded to perform the מצוהbut rather that כלל ישראלwas commanded to perform the
מצוהand she, as part of כלל ישראל, can say we were commanded to do this מצוה.
The גר"אagrees that women may say the ברכת התורהbut not because of the reason given by the בית יוסףand
מג"אbut because it is no worse than saying a ברכהover a מצות עשה שהזמן גרמאwhere there, too, they were not required
to do the מצוהbut make a ברכהover it when they do perform the מצוה.
Summing up, according to the בית יוסףand the מג"א, women are required to say the ברכת התורהand according
to the גר"אwomen may say the ברכת התורה. The ביאור הלכה סי' מ"ז ד"הpoints out that there is a big difference between
the two. According to the ב"יa woman could even be מוציאa man with the ברכותsince they are both required to say
them. The פרי מגדיםsays so specifically. But, according to the גר"אa woman could not be מוציאa man since she is not
required to say the ברכהand an אינו בר חיובאcannot be מוציאa בר חיובא.
So, according to the פמ"ג, and this is the answer to our riddle, a woman who only needs to learn about the מצוות
she is required to fulfill but not תורהin general says ברכת התורהand can be מוציאa man with her ברכות. However,
according to the גר"אthis is not true because she can’t be מוציאa man.
And then there is a third explanation for why women say ברכת התורה. The בריסקער רב זצ"לbrings from his father,
ר' חיים זצ"ל, that the reason why ברכת התורהis said is because, as long as תורהis being learned a ברכהmust be said. So,
even if there is no requirement to learn תורה, as long as תורהis being learned a ברכהmust be said. It would seem,
therefore, that a woman could be מוציאa man even if she doesn’t have the same requirement that he does because the
תורהbeing learned by anyone, male or female, requires a ברכה.
דבר תורה
'בראשית י"ג ג...ֲשׁר הָ יָה ָשׁם אׇ הֳ �ה בַּ ְתּ ִחלָּה בֵּ ין בֵּ ית אֵ ל וּבֵ ין הָ ﬠָ י
ֶ ַו ֵיּלֶ� לְ מַ סָּ ﬠָ יו ִמ ֶנּגֶב וְﬠַ ד בֵּ ית אֵ ל ﬠַ ד הַ מָּ קוֹם א
In the beginning of the פרשה, when אברהם אבינוcame to where he was eventually going to live, it says,
'שׁם דֵ ְשׁם ִמזְ בֵּ חַ ַלד' וַיִּ ְק ָרא בּ
ָ שּׁם הָ הָ ָרה ִמ ֶקּדֶ ם לְ בֵ ית אֵ ל ַויֵּט אׇ הֳ �ה בֵּ ית אֵ ל ִמיָּם וְהָ ﬠַ י ִמ ֶקּדֶ ם וַיִּ בֶ ן
ָ ַויּ ְַﬠ ֵתּק ִמ. First, he pitched
his tent, then he built a מזבח, and he called 'בשם ד. Afterwards he went to מצריםbecause of the hunger, and
eventually, he found his way back to ארץ ישראל, to the place were he pitched his tent, and had built a מזבחand
where he called ' !בשם דThis is a very long פסוקwhich seems to have many extra words in it! It wouldn’t suffice
to say, to the place where he originally had pitched his tent?
Also, רש"יtells us that the first time it says אהלה, it is spelled with a ' הinstead of with an 'א, which is a
רמז, to ‘her tent’! אברהםpitched ’שריs tent before he pitched his own tent, as he was מכבדhis wife more than
himself ()רש"י. What is the significance of this? Is it a lesson in ?שלום ביתAlso, why when אברםreturns to his
tent, does it say again אהלהwith a ' ?הWe’re only identifying where he was?
Zugt der (חתם סופר )תורת משה, the : גמ' חולין פ"דsays, לעולם יאכל אדם וישתה פחות ממה שיש לו וילבש
ויתכסה במה שיש לו ויכבד אשתו ובניו יותר ממה שיש לו שהן תלויין בו והוא תלוי במי שאמר והיה העולם. A person should
treat himself בצמצוםbut his wife & children, he should treat lavishly! Why? Because the house is run by him
and he relies on ’הקב"הs רחמיםfor פרנסה. They depend on him! He is the conduit for their פרנסהwhich goes
through the husband! Therefore, since he is the leader of the house in רוחניות, his job is to be מכבדhis wife and
children!
Zugt der חתם סופר, since בענין נבואה, שרהwas greater than אברהם, maybe in such a case, the wife is the
leader and אברהםgets his פרנסהthrough !שרהOn this, the פסוקtells us that אברהם אבינוlistened to the dictate
of the גמראthat ויכבד אשתו ובניו יותר ממה שיש לו. As he understood that No! He is the leader of the family and
they’re getting everything through him! Therefore, the פסוקis emphasizing that אברהםtook care of שרהand
built her אהלbefore he built his own! אהלהwith a ' !הThe words 'שׁם ד ֵ ְשׁם ִמזְ בֵּ חַ ַלד' וַיִּ ְק ָרא בּ ָ וַיִּ בֶ ןis to show that
indeed, אברהםwas the leader in רוחניותof the family and therefore, they got their פרנסהthrough him and he
got his פרנסהthrough הקב"ה.
All this was before אברהםwent down to מצרים. The fact that he went down to מצרים, the רמב"ןsays,
was a mistake! And שרה אמנוhad to go along with her husband’s plan. When אברהםasked her to say that she
was his sister, it’s ייתכן, that she did not agree, she didn’t accept it! She realized that אברהםmust have gone
down in ( מדרגהin his level) and she didn’t feel that she should submit to his leadership. אברהם אבינוwas מרגיש
it and decided that while he is in מצרים, his פרנסהis תלויin her! This is what he meant by saying לְ מַ ﬠַ ן ִייטַ ב לִ י
�ֲֵבוּר� וְחָ יְתָ ה נ ְַפ ִשׁי בִּ גְ ָלל
ֵ בַ ﬠ.
But this did not last. אברהםrecognized that he really should go back to ארץ ישראל, as it says ַויַּﬠַ ל אַ בְ ָרם
מ ִמּצְ ַריִם הוּא ו ְִא ְשׁתּוֹ. ִ The word ויעלteaches us that אברהםwas elevated, he returned to his original מדרגה. Again
it says אהלהwith a 'ה, שׁם אׇ הֳ �ה בַּ ְתּ ִחלָּה ָ ֲשׁר הָ יָה
ֶ א, not only is it identifying, but is also coming back to the מדרגה
of her אהלbeing erected before his! She was תלויin him and he was תלויin the רבש"ע, as he was the leader of
the family. Again, the פסוקsignifies his מדרגהin leadership of קדושהas it says 'שׁם ד ֵ ְשׁם ִמזְ בֵּ חַ ַלד' וַיִּ ְק ָרא בּ
ָ וַיִּ בֶ ן.
RIDDLE OF THE WEEK
How is it שייךfor a person to say the ברכהof המוציאtwice in one meal.
(There was no היסח הדעתin the middle of the meal.)
PARSHA MYSTERY
?האם תרח אבי אברהם סבל בגיהנם או לא
ANSWER
( כל העצים כשרים למערכה חוץ משל זית ושל גפן לפי שמעלים. תני )תמיד כ"ט,('זה לשון המושב זקנים )ויקרא א' ח
מכאן פסק שהבן הטוב מציל. לפיכך מצילין את אביהם מן האש שעל המערכה, שמן למנחות ויין לנסכים,מה שמוציא מהן
כמו אברם שהציל תרח אביו מגיהנם שנאמר ואתה תבא אל אבותיך בשלום,את אביו מדינה של גיהנם
If you have any comments or answers to the riddles or the דבר תורה, please email me at ichudbchidud@gmail.com. If you would like the English
or Hebrew איחוד בחידודemailed to you at no charge, please send us a request at ichudbchidud@gmail.com !!
Riddles of the week & the answers are written by R’ Michoel Levi of Bais Yaakov D’Rav Meir
