Horeini - English — Lech Lechu (2026-10-19)

Parashas Lech Lecha, 5787 לעילוי נשמת מנחם מנדל בן יהושע דב בס”ד
Weekly Torah forum
to deepen halachic
and ideological
knowledge and
to strengthen the
mitzvah of kibbud
Issue no. 147 av va’eim
Dibros
Dibros Kodshecha
Kodshecha
Kibbud Av V’eim in the Parshah
Way of Life
”ָּוִמ ֵֵּבית ָָא ִִביָך ֶֶאל ָָה ָָא ֶֶרץ ֲֲא ֶֶׁשר ֶֶא ְְר ֶֶאָּך
ִ ּוִמּמֹוַלַ ְְד ְְּתָך
ִ “ְלְ ָך ְלְ ָך ֵֵמ ַַא ְְר ְְצָך
Behind the — Go forth from your land, from your birthplace, and from your father’s
Scene house, to the land that I will show you. (12:1)
1
0The Midrash says Avraham Avinu worried that leaving would desec0rate
Hashem’s name, since people might say he abandoned his elderly father.
In Our Fathers’
Hashem reassured him, saying, ‘Go forth for your own sake. For you, I am
Footsteps
setting aside the mitzvah of kibbud av va’eim, but I am not exempting anyone
else.’
Toras Imecha The Pnei Yafos offers a powerful insight. Ordinarily, if a father lives in
Chutz la’aretz, a son’s aspiration to move to Eretz Yisrael cannot override
the obligation to honor his father. Hashem told Avraham, “Only in your
Mussar Avicha specific case—because Terach’s path was not aligned with yours—am I lifting
the requirement of kibbud av va’eim for the sake of going to Eretz Yisrael. But
for anyone else, even if they are a righteous person, moving to Eretz Yisrael
V’heishiv Lev does not override their duty to honor their father.” Because moving to Eretz
Yisrael is such a monumental mitzvah, a father telling his son to stay with
him would be seen as standing in the way of Torah observance; one might
mistakenly assume the son wouldn’t need to listen to his father. That is why
the pasuk specifies, “For you I grant an exemption”—Consequently, even
for a mitzvah as monumental as settling in Eretz Yisrael, only Avraham was
Bracha and Hatzlacha
Ilanit bas Rivka exempt from honoring his father, whereas the rest of us remain bound by
this obligation.
Zivug
Rachel bas Esther The Pnei Yafos cites Yaakov Avinu as proof of this: Yaakov was held accountable
for the twenty-two years he was separated from his parents and unable to
Refuah Shleima 2
Binyamin Yehoshua ben fulfill kibbud av va’eim .He was not held accountable for living outside Eretz
Chana Yisrael. Since both occurred simultaneously, he was judged to have neglected
Zera Shel Kayama
the greater mitzvah—honoring his parents—while the delay in returning to
Anonymous the Land was not punished separately. The rule that moving to Eretz Yisrael
Iluy Neshama
does not override kibbud av va’eim applies only when the son is in Chutz
Menachem Mendel ben la’aretz. If both father and son live in Eretz Yisrael and the father chooses
Yehoshua Dov to move abroad, the son is not required to follow. This is demonstrated by
Machlon and Kilyon, who were punished for leaving Eretz Yisrael, even
(continued on page 2..)
though they were accompanying their father. upon the land. We see that Eretz Yisrael has a special
The Pnei Yafos later found this principle in the quality of longevity. Consequently, if a person yearns
Nachalas Yaakov: even Avraham needed Divine to move to Eretz Yisrael but his father objects, the son
permission to leave his father to go to Eretz Yisrael. is halachically bound to obey. By doing so, he seems
As the text concludes, “One must not leave elderly to sacrifice the unique reward of longevity tied to
parents, not even to go to Eretz Yisrael.” Eretz Yisrael. In order that the son who stays back to
This also explains why the Torah attaches the promise honor his father shouldn’t suffer any loss,
“ ”למען יאריכון ימיךto kibbud av va’eim. The reward for the Torah guarantees the same blessing through
living in Eretz Yisrael is longevity, as it says “למען ירבו kibbud av va’eim, promising “למען יאריכון ימיך,”
— ”ימיכם על האדמהso that your days may be increased
. מגילה י”ז.2 , ילקוט שמעוני רמז סב,’ מדרש רבה בראשית פרשה ל”ט פיסקא ז.1
Just as it is the duty of every Jew to learn the halachos applicable to
Way of Life everyday life, from berachos and Shabbos to shemiras halashon, so
is he obligated to learn and review the laws of kibbud av va’eim, a
Kibbud Av Va’eim in
constant and very serious mitzvah. Neglecting this study is liable to
Halachah and Minhag lead the person to unwittingly violate many halachos.
Based on the sefer Vayevarech David, by the illustrious Rabbi Yisrael David Harfenes, moreh
tzedek and rabbi of the Yisrael VeHazmanim Synagogue and Community, Williamsburg
Caring for elderly parents routine tasks, such as shopping or errands, to
Ideally, a son should host and care for his father others.
in his own home. If his wife objects to having her When parents age, their children face unique
father-in-law live with them to the point that it challenges—Yet these years offer a profound
threatens their shalom bayis, Rav Shmuel Halevi opportunity to honor them—a true privilege, like
1
Wosner ruled that the son may place his father in a gathering real diamonds. The Tanna Devei Eliyahu
nursing home, even if he knows the care there may writes: “Even if his father’s saliva drips onto his
not be quite as good. beard, he must listen and obey him immediately.”
However, if there is a genuine concern that not Midrash Tanchuma also warns that mocking
personally caring for the father could shorten the parents parents who are no longer fully aware is
father’s life, rabbanim have ruled that he must find equally severe as engaging in Avoda Zara.
a way to care for him personally. If the situation Hashem has equated His honor with the honor
requires physical intervention—such as preventing a of hte parents, so that one who demeans them
parent from pulling out essential oxygen equipment ultimately demeans Hashem’s honor. Rav Chaim
2
or an IV—the son should not take physical action; Palaggi writes , that a person who honors his
instead, he should hire or appoint someone to do parents, even when their minds are are not clear
whatever is necessary. d and caring for them becomes a heavy burden,
Some authorities hold that kibbud av va’eim can be will merit
fulfilled through a shaliach. According to this view,
if a son cannot assist his parents personally, he may
send someone to attend to their needs, even a non- The author of Vayoel Moshe once made a
Jew. Other poskim disagree, stating that this does sharp observation: It is normal when young
not apply because it is a “—”מצווה שבגופוa personal people consider themselves “wiser” than their
obligation that must be performed by the child. parents—but it is totally unacceptable when
If the father specifically requests his son’s direct they consider themselves more “mature.”...
service, the son must comply. This applies only to (from Tiv HaMa’asiyos, Vayeishev)
personal, hands-on care. The child may delegate
והביא סייעתא מספר. וע״ע מש״כ בעניין הורים חולים. שבט הלוי חלק ט’ סי’ קצ”ז.1
Parashas Lech Lecha, 5787 // Issue no.147 // pg 2 ’ ספר קול החיים אות ו.2 חסידים סי׳ תקס”ג
On a Personal Note
A Fresh Look at an Old
Challenge — Written by a child
whose parents remarried.
When a parent shares that they are about to
remarry, the child’s heart is pulled in many
different directions. Some feel a quiet joy, while
others ache with a deep longing for the parent
who is no longer there. It can be painful to watch
someone step into a familiar place, and sometimes
an inexpressible anger stirs beneath the surface.
These are entirely human emotions, and there is
no shame in feeling them. Behind the Scene
A maamar Chazal or
Yet it is precisely here that the mitzvah of kibbud halachah related to
av va’eim is truly tested. Honoring parents goes kibbud av va’eim is
far beyond tending to their practical needs; it also concealed in the picture. Send in
means Sharing in their joy and embracing their the solution, and you’ll be entered
renewed happiness . After years of loneliness or to win a prize!
loss, a parent deserves to begin a new chapter
and find a faithful companion. They need their
Solutions may be sent by
children to walk alongside them, not away from email to: riddle@horeinu.org
them. A warm smile beneath the chuppah, a kind, fax to: 077-602-1640
encouraging word, and a heartfelt blessing—these
gestures are the living essence of kibbud av va’eim,
and at times, the most precious gift a child can
give to their parents.
Rashi explains that Yitzchak went to bring Hagar
back to Avraham so he could marry her. Here Solution to Behind the Scenes –
we see a profound lesson in honoring a parent: Esav earned the privilege of having his head buried
in the Mearas HaMachpelah, specifically in the merit
Yitzchak cared deeply that Avraham not remain of his exceptional Kibbud Av Va’eim for his father,
as noted in Aratzos HaChaim (Shaar 1, section 34).
alone, and he actively facilitated his remarriage. The רמ”חlimbs correspond to the רמ”חmitzvos, and the
Some commentators note that, because he cared mitzvah of honoring one’s father corresponds to the
eyes. Therefore, Esav, who fulfilled the mitzvah of
so much about his father’s well-being, he merited honoring his father, merited that his eyes be buried in
the Mearas HaMachpelah (Ateres Moshe on Purim,
marrying Rivkah. Needless to say, children must p. 178).
never create friction between parents through
The raffle winners were informed of their win.
words, hints, or deliberate distance; a parent’s
peace of mind and domestic harmony come first.
You don’t need to suppress painful emotions. You
can carry them quietly, share them with a trusted
confidant, or seek guidance when the weight
feels too heavy. But when the moment of truth
arrives,choose joy. Embracing happiness with
intention, even when it takes real effort, is one of
the most profound ways to tell your parents, “I
love you and support you in all your decisions.”
’ תנחומא האזינו סי’ ד.2 ירושלמי חגיגה פ”ב ה”א.1
Parashas Lech Lecha, 5787 // Issue no.147 // pg 3
In Our Fathers’
Footsteps
True Stories of Kibbud Horim
He treated his unstable mother While he never prepared his own tea—leaving
contemptuously and became insane that for the Rebbetzin a”h to do—he would
The Rashash explains Rav Assi’s famous personally serve his mother rather than having
statement in Kiddushin 31a: “Had I known, I the Rebbetzin do it.
would not have left.” Rav Assi deeply regretted Rabbi Moshe Sternbuch would serve his
leaving his mother to study Torah elsewhere, mother tea on a special silver tray that the
fearing that his absence might have shortened Rebbetzin had purchased. Originally, she had
her life. (See Sefer Kol HaChaim).m, ). intended to use the tray exclusively for Pesach,
Rabbi Avraham Yehoshua Heshel once saw but R’ Moshe felt that honoring his mother
a crowd gathered in the street. Upon asking took precedence over honoring Pesach, and
what was happening, he was told that a woman that it was only fitting to use the finest dishes
in the city who was known to be mentally in the home for her. His righteous wife readily
unstable was having an episode. The Rebbe agreed.
zt”l observed a young man pick up a vessel of After bringing her tea, he wouldn’t immediately
water and pour it directly over her head. When return to learning. Instead, he would sit and chat
he asked who the young man was, he was told with her about everyday matters for extended
this was her son. periods. His sons noted that they had never
The Rebbe angrily opened his window and seen him engage in casual conversation like
warned the young man he would soon suffer this, but honoring his mother took precedence.
the same fate. He explained to bystanders that Yet the moment he stepped out of her room,
kibbud av va’eim is unique in that its reward he hurried straight back to his study, instantly
is promised in this world, as the pasuk states, immersing himself once more in the world of
“”למען יאריכו ימיך ולמען ייטב לך על האדמהChazal Torah. (Rabbi Avraham Fuchs)
teach that this applies to this world. Indeed,
not long after, the young man lost his mind.
(Dor Yesharim [Liner], chapter 5).
Rabbi Moshe Sternbuch’s e kibbud
eim
Get Horeinu
Rabbi Moshe Sternbuch’s sons shared an
amazing glimpse into their father’s profound Delivered to
awe and reverence while fulfilling kibbud eim. Your Inbox!
Whenever his mother visited Eretz Yisrael and
Horeinu’s weekly newsletter is
stayed at his home, he would, in the early hours
before dawn, press his ear to her door to listen available by email in English,
for any sound—checking whether she had Hebrew, and Yiddish.
awakened and whether it was time to attend
To join our email list, write to
to her. The moment he heard a noise inside, us at: office@horeinu.org
he would run to prepare his mother a cup of (Please specify English, Hebrew or Yiddish).
tea so she could immediately make a Bracha.
Parashas Lech Lecha, 5787 // Issue no.147 // pg 4
You can direct questions to Horeinu advisers
via the email address appearing on the last page.
Confidentiality guaranteed
V’heishiv Lev
Questions and Answers from the
Desk of Rabbanim and Therapists
?
We are a binch of siblings, each with our kept in mind.
own families, we are currently caring First, children are not their parents’ teachers,
for our elderly parents who still live nor do they have the right to instruct them on
independently at home. Both have ongoing how to live or conduct themselves. Even when
medical conditions that require frequent a child surpasses their parents in capability,
treatments and doctor visits. We are deeply whether materially or spiritually, the natural
concerned, especially as their desire for hierarchy dictates that the parents’role is to guide
independence is beyond their actual ability.. and educate their offspring, not the opposite.
Our biggest concern is their driving. They Therefore, children maykindlysuggest that their
continue to drive despite being involved in two parents move closer or consider assisted living,
minor accidents this year, both caused by loss of but nothing can be done unless the parents
control. Thankfully, no one was hurt, but we fear agree.
a more serious incident could occur. They insist Second, parents are Autonomous individuals
everything is fine and dismiss the accidents as who retain every right to choose how they
coincidences. spend their later years. Even if it appears to
We tried discussing the idea of moving to an you that their choices might, chalilah, lead to
assisted living facility, where they would be
difficulties, hardship, or physical decline, the
safer, with help on hand and close medical
decision remains entirely their own. Naturally,
supervision. They refuse. Our father said he was
this principle holds only as long as their choices
“not prepared to spend the end of his life among
do not threaten others’ safety. You can address
strangers,” while our mother insisted they were
this concern by encouraging a professional
managing perfectly well on their own and that
we worry too much. driving evaluation to ensure no one else is
We are torn. We very much respect our parents put at risk. Furthermore, forcing them into an
and want them to live with dignity, yet we worry assisted living facility against their will could
that inaction could lead to problems. We wish cause such profound emotional distress that
we knew how to protect them better. the psychological toll would far outweigh any
Is there a point at which it becomes permissible— physical benefit. In their current home, they are
and perhaps even obligatory—to gently step in content and may enjoy many more years ahead,
and act on their behalf, even if against their even as they manage medical challenges.
better judgment ? If so, how will we know that Lastly, if they remain reluctant to relocate or
we have reached that stage, and what steps transition to an assisted living facility, consider
should we take before making such a move? whether one of you who lives nearby can provide
hands-on assistance on a rotating or permanent
schedule. While this is undeniably a significant
>
When elderly parents begindepending
undertaking, the immense zchus of kibbud av
on their children’s assistance, tension
va’eim, particularly during these delicate years
can naturally arise between the parents’
established way of life and the reality of their when they need their children’s assistance, will
children’s involvement. In navigating such bring the profound blessings of אריכות ימיםand
moments, several vital principles should be !למען ייטב לך
Parashas Lech Lecha, 5787 // Issue no.147 // pg 5
written by Y. Binyamin
Mendy shares a story about Tatty and Mommy
and the mitzvah of kibbud av va’eim
Two Pairs of Bicycles and Two Homes
I have a good friend named Shloimy. I may have down the hill. “That’s what my father said.” I thought
mentioned him before. We get along so well mostly for a moment. Perhaps I should call Ima and tell her
because we see agree almost about everything. We both that Shloimy’s parents had better rules? But I already
agree that recess in yeshiva is way too short, that riding knew what she would say...
a bike is fun and that homework is not necessary! We set off. The air was crisp, the breeze felt wonderful,
On Tuesday afternoon, on our way home from yeshiva, and as I flew down the long block past the garden,
Shloimy asked if I wanted to go for a bike ride around I felt like I was zooming as fast as a bus. We looped
the neighborhood. I really wanted to go, but there around the buildings, kept going down the bike path,
was one catch: I had and stopped by a little
to ask Ima. Usually, the park to grab a drink. “Tell
moment I ask to go me,” I asked Shloimy,
out, she reminds me of “do your parents really
everything I’m supposed let you stay out till six-
to take care of first— thirty? And they let you
straightening up my ride all the way out to
room, putting away the the big development?”
seforim I left out or the “Yeah, but only if I’m with
shoesIt’s like there’s an a friend.” He answered.
invisible rule connecting “I’m not allowed to go
“Ma, can I please go near the development
out?” directly to “First at all” I said.
tidy up and take out the Shloimy thought for a
garbage.” Honestly, that moment. “But at your
phenomenon deserves house you’re allowed to
serious investigation. ride your bike on Erev
Today, I experienced a Shabbos after yeshiva,
true miracle: Ima said yes right away! “Just stay on right?” “Yeah, if I’m done helping out at home.” “At
the sidewalks around the block, don’t go down to the my house,” Shloimy said, “Tatty doesn’t allow bikes on
main road, and be back by six.” “But Ima, it’s already Erev Shabbos at all. He says Erev Shabbos is a time to
5:00!!” “Exactly,” Ima told me. “You have a whole hour.” prepare. That made a lot of sense to me, but it doesn’t
I didn’t argue; I didn’t want to waste time when I could mean I like the idea.” “We have our own house rules
be on the bike. I grabbed a helmet, went downstairs, too, even the ones I’m not so fond of. ” I said. “Like
and found Shloimy already waiting for me in front of what?” Shloimy asked. “Like going to sleep!” “What’s
the building. “That took you long enough!” he said. “My reasonable about that...?” “Exactly!” We both laughed.
mother gave me until six,” I told him so that he wouldn’t A few minutes later, we reached the turn leading toward
expect too much. “I was given until six-thirty,” Shloimy the large development, and Shloimy slowed down.
said. I stopped. “Why do you have until six-thirty, and “Should we keep going?” he asked. “No. Ima doesn’t
I only have until six?” Shloimy shrugged as we started want me ti ride past here.” “But we’re together,” Shloimy
(continued on page 7..)
Parashas Lech Lecha, 5787 // Issue no.147 // pg 6
argued, “and there are hardly any cars on this path...” no. .” We stood there with our bikes, thinking and smiling.
Truth be told, I really wanted to keep going. It was a Suddenly, I looked at my watch: 5:52. “Oh no, I have to
gorgeous country path, and an amazing downhill stretch go back—and take the bike upstairs, too...” Shloimy e
started right there. But Ima said not to, so I will not go accompanied me back to the building. He said, “Mendy,
there. do you know what is funny? If I lived at your house, I
Shloimy looked at me. “Don’t you ever do something would have to go back now.” I said, “And if I lived at
your mother does not allow you to do?” “Of course I do; your house, I could stay another half hour — but then
I’m a normal kid. But if I already know for a fact that I wouldn’t be me” I said
she doesn’t let, why would I go and do it on purpose?” I ran up the stairs, and Ima was waiting by the door. “You
Shloimy nodded, deep in thought. got back on time! How was it? Where did you bike?” I
We turned back toward the park. Shloimy rode beside told her the whole story, including how we didn’t ride out
me in silence for a little while, then said, “You know, toward the big development. Ima smiled warmly. “Very
sometimes I’m actually jealous of your family. For good, Mendy. I know I can always trust you.”
instance, your mother lets you go outside to play after I headed to my room to put away my helmet and
yeshiva, even when it’s getting late, and your father does thought about my chat with Shloimy. Sometimes I look
not mindit when you stay up a bit later.” Then Shloimy at his home and wonder why he’sallowed to do things
added, “Every set of parents has different rules. What’s we aren’t, while other times he looks at mine and thinks
right for us isn’t always right for you. Once, when I told the exact opposite. But Abba and Ima are my parents,
my father that your parents let you do things he won’t and they have their own rules about what they allow and
let me do, he told me, ‘Shloimy, I’m glad Mendy has what they hold back. Some of it makes sense to me, but
good parents. And you have good parents, too. Still, we I still need to grow up to understand the parts that don’t.
don’t both have to make the same choices...’ I honor them simply because they are my parents, and
I totally understood him. Sometimes I find myself that’s reason enough. Just then, Ima called from the
telling Ima, “But Shloimy can!!” And Ima always replies, kitchen, “Mendy, go wash your hands. Dinner is ready.”
“Shloimy’s parents know what’s best for him. I have to I went to the sink willingly—well, maybe not with a ton
do what’s best for you.” of enthusiasm, but without making a fuss. And honestly,
Shloimy was silent, and then he said, “I love them simply for me, that’s no small achievement.
because they are my parents—whether they say yes or
Partner with us in publishing the Horeinu newsletter >>
Quickpay/zelle
Email us Donate via our website dedications@horeinu.org.
at newsletter@horeinu.org pay.banquest.com/horeinu Specify “Weekly Newsletter” in the memo.
To receive the weekly newsletter via email, simply write “Add
me” in the subject line and send to newsletter@horeinu.org
Created by the Worldwide Horeinu organization. Our goal is to
spread awareness and help Klal Yisroel strengthen the mitzvah of
kibbud av va’eim with the guidance of gedolei Yisroel Registered
organization #580780617
We welcome your feedback! Email newsletter@horeinu.org or fax: 077-602-1640 for
opportunities to dedicate or sponsor an issue l’iluy nishmas or l’zechus a parent or a loved one,
or for a zechus for children, zivugim, refuah shleimah, and hatzlachah.
You can also send us your personal stories to help inspire others.
www.horeinu.com / REQUIRES GENIZAH /
