gilyoines.com Back to the site · חזרה לאתר

HARAV BARUCH ROSENBLUM — Vayeru (2026-10-26)

Publisher: HARAV BARUCH ROSENBLUM

Week: Vayeru (2026-10-26)

HARAV BARUCH ROSENBLUM — Vayeru (2026-10-26)

Open the PDF Download

‫פרשת וירא תשפ"ז‬ PARSHAT VAYEIRA 5787 ‫אלֹקים אַתָּה‬ ֱ ‫כִּי עַתָּה יָדַעְתִּי כִּי יְרֵא‬ The Final Ingredient Produced from the shiur delivered at Beit Knesset HaGadol Bnei Brak on ‫ י״ז חשון תשע"ט‬/ October 25, 2018. Sponsored in the merit of a refuah shleima for ‫ דניאל בן שרה‬b’toch she’ar cholei Yisrael. The Parsha we will read, B'ezrat Hashem, this Shabbat is He lifted his eyes and saw, and behold, three men standing over Parshat Vayeira. The Parsha deals with the continuation of him; he saw and ran toward them and bowed to the ground. the nisyonot, the trials, of Avraham Avinu which we read about If those men had already been standing over him, or beside last week. The Parsha opens with the words: him, why did he need to run toward them? It is because at first :‫ַוי ֵָּרא אֵ לָיו ה' ְּבאֵ לֹנֵי ַמ ְמ ֵרא וְ הוּא י ֵֹׁשב ֶּפ ַתח הָ אֹהֶ ל ְּכחֹם הַ ּיוֹם‬ they came and stood beside him, but when they saw that he Hashem appeared to him in the plains of Mamre, as he sat at the was in pain, they too said: “It isn’t proper to stand here,” and entrance of the tent in the heat of the day. they too left. Therefore, Avraham needed to run after them. Says Rashi1, Hakadosh Baruch Hu appeared to him, to Who were these three men? The angels Michael, Gavriel and perform bikur cholim. The source of this explanation is the Rafael. Michael came to bring the news to Sarah; Rafael Gemara (Bava Metzia 86b), which explains that it was the third came to heal Avraham; and Gavriel went to overturn Sedom. day after Avraham's circumcision, the day on which a person The Gemara then asks why later we find it written that two is at his weakest, and Hakadosh Baruch Hu came to see how angels went to Sedom: ‫ – ַו ָּיבֹא ּו ְׁשנֵי הַ ַּמלְ אָ כִ ים ְסד ָֹמה ָּבעֶ ֶרב‬The he was doing. ‫ה‬ּ ‫יק‬ ָ ‫ – הוֹצִ יא הַ ָק ָּב"ה חַ ָּמה ִמנ ְַּר ִּת‬Hakadosh Baruch two angels came to Sedom in the evening. It seems as though Hu took the sun out of its sheath and let it shine with force it wasn’t only Gavriel who went to overturn it. The Gemara upon the earth, so that because of the extreme heat there answers that in truth Gavriel is the one who went to overturn would be no travelers and Avraham would not be troubled with Sedom, but Michael went along to rescue Lot. hosting guests. But Avraham exerted himself nonetheless to From here I would like to pose a series of questions, from find them. He sent his servant Eliezer outside to look for which we’ll arrive at a wonderful yesod in our Avodat Hashem. guests, but he found none and reported this back to Avraham. The three angels arrive at Avraham, and the Torah says: Avraham said to him: “I don’t believe you,” and he went out ַ ‫ן־ב ָקר ַר ְך וָטוֹב ַוי ִֵּּתן אֶ ל־הַ נַּעַ ר ַוי‬ ‫ְמהֵ ר‬ ָּ ‫וְ אֶ ל־הַ ָּב ָקר ָרץ אַ ְב ָרהָ ם ַו ִּי ַּקח ֶּב‬ himself to search. He saw Hakadosh Baruch Hu standing at ‫שוֹת אֹתוֹ׃‬ ׂ ‫ַל ֲע‬ the doorway, and this is what is written: ָ‫אַ ל נָא ַת ֲעבֹר ֵמעַ ל עַ ְב ֶּדך‬ – Please do not pass on from before Your servant. When And Avraham ran to the cattle, and took a tender and good calf, Hakadosh Baruch Hu saw Avraham tying and untying his and gave it to the lad, who hurried to prepare it. bandages, He said: “It isn’t proper to stand here.” Something Rashi explains there were three bulls, as Avraham wanted to similar happened with the angels: feed them three tongues with mustard – ‫ג' לְ ׁשוֹנוֹת ְּבחַ ְר ָּדל‬. A ‫אתם‬ ָ ‫ִּשא עֵ ינָיו ַוי ְַּרא וְ ִהנֵּה ְׁשל ָֹׁשה אֲ נ ִָׁשים נִ צ ִָּבים עָ לָיו ַוי ְַּרא ַוי ׇָּרץ לִ ְק ָר‬ ָּׂ ‫ַוי‬ new mustard-based recipe not found anywhere else in the ‫ִּש ַּתח ּו אָ ְרצָה׃‬ ְׁ ‫ִמ ֶּפ ַתח הָ אֹהֶ ל ַוי‬ Torah. Rabbotai, anyone reading this immediately asks: why on earth for he ran after it into the cave. Further, ‫ וְ אֶ ל הַ ָּב ָקר ָרץ‬in did he give each of them a full tongue with mustard?! Each gematria equals ‫ – ָרץ ל ְַּמעָ ָרה‬he ran to the cave. tongue weighs 4 kilograms – why would a single person eat What an amazing thing! At age 99, on the third day after his such a quantity?! At a fancy event where tongue is served, a Brit Milah, he is chasing after an animal! Why does he need guest walks up to the carving station, is handed a few thin to run after it, when we know he was wealthy with silver, gold, slices, and walks away content. What would one person even and livestock too? Let it go, in peace and with a good life! Was do with a full tongue? A talented chef could serve fifty people he lacking other livestock to supply a meal from?! with such a quantity! He would place a single slice on a bed of baby lettuce, surround it with sautéed vegetables, a few Avraham Avinu returns from Me’arat HaMachpelah and tells microgreens, and a drizzle of balsamic reduction – and you Sarah all about the place; it sounds good to her, and she asks would need a jeweler’s loupe, the kind a diamond cutter uses, him to buy it to serve as their burial site. This is what we sing to find the meat! Yet, Avraham gave them each a full tongue. every Friday night: ּ‫ש ֶדה ו ִַּת ָּק ֵחהו‬ ָׂ ‫ – ז ְָמ ָמה‬She considered a field and took it (Mishlei 31:16). This is in reference to Sarah desiring Furthermore, what did Avraham do with the rest of the to be buried there, as the song is Avraham’s eulogy to Sarah 200-kilogram bull that was left over? He had some 600 kgs. Imeinu. of meat and there were no refrigerators or freezers! If there were soup kitchens around, you could split it up and bring Rabbotai, does Hakadosh Baruch Hu have no other time to some to Beersheva, some to Nes Tziona, and some here to show Avraham the site other than the third day after his Brit Bnei Brak. But that’s also when everything is functioning Milah? Wait a couple of weeks until Avraham and Sarah are properly, and not when the sun is out of its sheath and there’s on a tiyul nearby and showcase it then! Why specifically on a chamsin (severe heatwave) that has not a single creature this scorching hot day while he recovers from his Brit Milah? outdoors. Why shecht three cows when there’s nobody And why in this manner, chasing after a bull while angels wait around to feed?! for him in the tent? Additionally, if we look at the pesukim, there’s no mention of To arrive at the core of the matter, let’s enter into the depth of tongues nor mustard; it only says he took butter and milk, the Parsha. It is brought in the name of Rav Yechezkel together with the meat. It would seem this was in fact a mixed Abramsky3: David HaMelech says ֹ‫ש ֶחק בּ ו‬ ַׂ ְ‫ – לִ וְ י ָָתן זֶה ָיצ ְַר ָּת ל‬this meal – dairy and meat together! There’s also no separation Leviatan You formed to play with it. The question is asked: between the words ‫ ֶח ְמאָ ה וְ חָ לָב‬and ‫וּבֶ ן־הַ ָּב ָקר‬, when there could Hakadosh Baruch Hu plays with the Leviatan? Why on earth have been, to indicate a dairy appetizer, followed by a delay would He play with it?! Says Rav Abramsky, the Leviatan has while the main course was being prepared, just like at the a pastime – putting its tail into its mouth, like a baby who puts restaurant. Why did Avraham need to take butter and milk and his foot into his mouth. The Gemara (in Avodah Zarah 3b) teaches cook them together with the meat? Were there no good that the day has twelve hours. In the first three hours kosher recipes to be had? There are some great recipes out Hakadosh Baruch Hu sits and engages in Torah; in the there for cooking meat in wine! Whether an Emerald Resiling second three hours He sits and judges the entire world – when or a red wine like Merlot – the result is a master dish! And we He sees the world is deserving of destruction, He rises from know they ate them together because later at Har Sinai, the the seat of judgment (Din), on which He sat at first, and sits Midrash tells us, the angels asked Hakadosh Baruch Hu what on the seat of mercy (Rachamim). In the third three hours He a human being was going there, and ultimately, why the Torah sits and nourishes the entire world; and in the final three hours was not destined to be given to them. Hakadosh Baruch Hu He sits and plays with the Leviatan. Just as the Leviatan plays fashioned the face of Moshe Rabbeinu to appear like by putting its tail into its mouth, so too Hakadosh Baruch Hu Avraham Avinu and told them: “You were just at this man’s is amused when one “connects tail to head” in Torah. That is, house, and there you ate milk and meat cooked together; the take the letter ‫ ב‬of ‫אשית‬ ִׁ ‫ ְּב ֵר‬and join it with the letter ‫ ל‬of ‫ִש ָראֵ ל‬ ְׂ ‫י‬ Torah prohibits such a meal.” at the end of VeZot HaBracha. Take the beginning of a Masechet and join it to its end. If you do this, you have Rabbotai, what was the purpose of this entire meal? There amused Hakadosh Baruch Hu! seems to be something hidden behind it. In connection with this idea from Rav Abramsky, our Parsha Another question that needs explanation: Chazal say (Pirkei opens with the third day after Avraham Avinu's Brit Milah and DeRabbi Eliezer 36) that Avraham ran to get a calf, and the calf closes with Akeidat Yitzchak. If we search for the connection ran away from him and entered the cave of Me’arat between them, we can find a very simple common HaMachpelah, so Avraham went in after it and found Adam denominator: the opening and the conclusion both deal with and Chava lying on their beds, asleep, with candles burning blood. The beginning deals with the blood of Milah, and the over them, and a good fragrance upon them like the fragrance conclusion deals with the blood of a Korban. of incense. As a result, he desired Me’arat HaMachpelah as a burial estate. Another connection can be found, for Bnei Ashkenaz, in the words of the Selichot recited during the Yamim Nora’im: Says the Ba’al HaTurim2, the letters of ‫ – וְ אֶ ל הַ ָּב ָקר ָרץ‬and he ran to the cattle, spell ‫ – וְ אֶ ל הַ ֶּקבֶ ר ָרץ‬and he ran to the grave, ‫ וְ הו ִֹׁשיעֵ נ ּו‬,‫ וְ הָ ֵׁשב ְׁשבוּת אָ הֳ לֵי ַי ֲעקֹב‬,‫זְ כֹר ְּב ִרית אַ ְב ָרהָ ם ַוע ֲֵק ַדת יִצְ חָ ק‬ .ָ‫לְ ַמעַ ן ְׁש ֶמך‬ ~2~ Remember the covenant of Avraham and the binding of Yitzchak, troubles and decrees upon Avraham Avinu, either from nature and return the captivity of the tents of Yaakov, and save us for or from kings and rulers, and Hakadosh Baruch Hu saved him Your Name's sake. from them. But the trial of the Akeida came by Hakadosh Baruch Hu’s decree to Avraham himself, to slaughter his only The paytan joined the two trials together – the Brit of Avraham son, and afterward the command was nullified. And it appears and Akeidat Yitzchak. Out of all ten trials of Avraham Avinu, this was only to test him, and therefore it is stated explicitly in the paytan chose specifically these two trials, and the this trial, ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬-ֱ‫וְ הָ א‬. question that arises is: why? Meaning, each of the first nine trials was carried out in There is another similar piyyut, by Rabbi Eleazar HaKalir4, practice: ָ‫ֹּאמר ה' אֶ ל אַ ְב ָרם ל ְֶך לְ ך‬ ֶ ‫ – ַוי‬so, he went! When Avraham recited exclusively by Bnei Ashkenaz in Tefillat Geshem on arrived in Eretz Yisrael there was an actual famine to contend the day of Shemini Atzeret. It opens with: with. When they took Sarah to Pharaoh's house, it was real, .‫שו ַֹרת י ַֻּקח נָא ְמעַ ט ַמ ִים‬ ׂ ‫זְ כוֹר הַ ּנ ֹולָד ִּב ְב‬ and so on and so on. But here, in the tenth trial, the Akeida, it Remember the one born through the tidings of "let a little water was a pure trial in itself, without anything happening in be taken.” practice, and therefore it says ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬-ֱ‫וְ הָ א‬. And who was born through those tidings? Yitzchak Avinu! Then the Ibn Ezra6 comes and asks an enormous question. ‫ זִ הֵ ר גַּם הוּא לִ ְׁש ּפו ְֹך לֵב‬.‫שחֲ ט ֹו לִ ְׁש ּפו ְֹך ָּדמ ֹו ַּכ ַּמ ִים‬ ָׁ ְ‫ש ְח ָּת לְ הוֹר ֹו ל‬ ַׂ ְ‫ו‬ Seemingly, it should have said ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת יִצְ ָחק‬-ֱ‫וְ הָ א‬. The true .‫ ַּבעֲבוּר ֹו אַ ל ִּת ְמנַע ָמ ִים‬.‫ חָ פַ ר ו ָּמצָא ְּבאֵ רוֹת ָמ ִים‬.‫ַּכ ַּמ ִים‬ trial was Yitzchak Avinu's, since he was the one going to be slaughtered! Or perhaps ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת ַא ְב ָרהָ ם וְ ֶאת יִצְ ָחק‬-ֱ‫וְ הָ א‬. And You spoke to his father to slaughter him, to spill his blood Why is Yitzchak not mentioned here at all? Says the Ibn Ezra, like water. He too was zealous to pour out his heart like water. it would have been fitting for Yitzchak's righteousness to be He dug and found wells of water. For his sake, do not revealed, and his reward would be double the reward of his withhold water. father, since he gave himself over willingly to slaughter, yet Here too we find that the paytan joined our Parsha at two the pasuk says nothing at all about Yitzchak! points: the first, at the notice of Yitzchak's upcoming birth, This is comparable to when a person goes for surgery, chas which is the first part of the Parsha; and the second, at Akeidat v’shalom, he finds out who the surgeon is. "Ah, Dr. Berkowitz. Yitzchak, which is the last part of the Parsha. And what is his nisayon (experience) in the field?" "Listen, it’s To enter into the depth of the matter, let us begin with a very not too bad. He has roughly a 60 percent success rate." Who simple question. Chazal say (Bereishit Rabbah 55:7) that twice we would be willing to be operated on by such a doctor?! You find tests that begin with the words ָ‫ – ל ְֶך לְ ך‬go forth, and we want at least a 99% success rate! In contrast, we don’t find do not know which test is dearer, the first or the second. The this playing out when one enters an airplane. Nobody asks for Midrash adds that from what is written in the second instance the pilot’s name or for his flight log to check how many hours – ‫ – וְ ל ְֶך לְ ָך אֶ ל אֶ ֶרץ הַ מ ִֹּריָּה‬we learn that the second is dearer of experience he has, or whether he was in the Air Force prior. than the first. This is because the pilot is on the plane with you! If it goes If we take note, the first trial begins with mercy (Rachamim), down, he goes down too! However, when the doctor finishes as it says ָ‫ֹּאמר ה' אֶ ל אַ ְב ָרם ל ְֶך לְ ך‬ ֶ ‫ – ַוי‬using the name ‫ה‬--‫ו‬-‫ה‬-‫)ה'( י‬ the operation and goes home to eat dinner, it could very well which signifies mercy. The last trial, however, begins with be that while they’re burying you, he’ll be biting into his judgment (Din), as it says ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬-ֱ‫ – וְ הָ א‬using the schnitzel. Like the surgeon, Avraham, too, goes home after name ‫ל ִֹהים‬-ֱ‫ א‬which signifies judgement. At its surface, this the Akeida, and if so, why is a trial stated only about him and structure should have been the reverse: first judgment and not about Yitzchak?! afterward mercy, just as it was at Creation. And therefore, the The first answer is related to: ‫ִמ ְתהַ ל ְֵּך ְּב ֻת ּמ ֹו צ ִַּדיק אַ ְׁש ֵרי בָ נָיו אַ חֲ ָריו‬ question that arises is: why is the first trial with Rachamim and – A tzaddik walks in his integrity; fortunate are his children the last trial with Din? after him. Writes Rav Chaim Volozhin7 (Ruach Chaim), in Pirkei Another question to ask, from the words of the Oznaim Avot (5:3), we’re told Avraham Avinu was tested with ten trials LaTorah5. Until the Akeida, there were nine trials, and in not and the language used is: ּ‫ֲש ָרה נִ ְסיוֹנוֹת נִ ְתנ ַָּסה אַ ְב ָרהָ ם אָ ִבינו‬ ָׂ ‫ע‬. one of them does the word ‫ – נִ ָּסיוֹן‬trial – appear. That is, it Notably, it says Avraham Avinu. However, in the previous does not say ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם ַוי ְִהי ָרעָב ָּבאָ ֶרץ‬-ֱ‫וְ הָ א‬, nor does Mishna it says ‫ֲש ָרה דוֹרוֹת ִמנֹּחַ וְ עַ ד אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬ ָׂ ‫ע‬, with no mention of it say ָ‫ֹּאמר ל ֹו ל ְֶך לְ ך‬ ֶ ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם ַוי‬-ֱ‫וְ הָ א‬. The only time out the ּ‫אָ ִבינו‬. Rav Chaim Volozhin writes: There are many traits of all ten trials that the word appears was at the Akeida, and that the tzaddik (Avraham) labored and toiled to attain, which the question is: why? for his children after him are like an implanted nature, and with a little effort they arrive at them. As we see plainly that many Says the Oznaim LaTorah, ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬-ֱ‫– וְ הָ א‬ of the unlearned among the Jewish people give themselves Hakadosh Baruch Hu tested Avraham Avinu with ten trials to over for the sanctification of Hashem's Name, and this is atone for the ten trials with which his children would in the implanted in us from Avraham Avinu, who gave over his soul future test Hashem in the wilderness. And the trial of the in Ur Kasdim for his faith. All ten trials were to straighten the Akeida is the greatest of them all. All the trials came as path before us. So too the sudden awakening in a person to ~3~ go to the Holy Land comes from the trial of ָ‫ל ְֶך לְ ך‬. And the Says Rav Chaim Shmuelevitz11, in Sichot Mussar, Shlomo acceptance of ‫ – כָּל ְּדעַ ְב ִּדין ִמ ְּׁש ַמיָּא לְ טָ ב‬everything the Merciful understood that Shimi would certainly break out. It is a great One does is for the good, comes from the trial of the famine, difficulty for a person to be forced, and Yerushalayim in which Avraham did not question the traits of Hashem. The becomes a dungeon and prison cell for one who is forced to pasuk says: ‫שע י ִּפוֹל ְּבאַ חַ ת‬ ָׁ ‫ – ִּכי ֶׁשבַ ע י ִּפוֹל צ ִַּדיק ָו ָקם וְ ָר‬For seven remain in it. The warning that he would die if he left was not times a tzaddik falls and rises, but a wicked man falls with one. meant to deter him but to tighten the compulsion and craving. That is, the tzaddik, even if he falls, does not think at all that The heavier the chains, the stronger the desire to break them, he has fallen, but rather that he rises and stands in his place. and when any pretext came, he would risk his life to escape. And the wicked man falls with one, for he considers it a And so it happened: his two servants fled, Shimi went out after downfall, and does not consider it a rising that will make him them, and he became liable with his life. The Maharsha12 better in his end. says the same about the Torah’s fences (Sanhedrin 37a) on the The meaning of Reb Chaim Volozhiner’s words is that words ‫ֹש ִּנים‬ ַׁ ‫ – סֻ גָּה ַּב ּׁשו‬hedged about with roses. A person Avraham Avinu implanted in us the strength to withstand trials, desires the hedge itself, to breach it and enjoy the fragrance and therefore for Yitzchak Avinu it was no longer a trial. of the roses. The sefer Birkat Avraham8 comes and provides a beautiful That was the Panim Yafot’s first answer. One who is idea. The moment a person says that he is ready for a trial, it commanded is greater, because the command itself awakens is no longer a trial. If a person tells you that he has no problem the yetzer hara. He gives a second answer as well. A jumping out of the window, and you say to him, "Fine, let's see descendant of Noach is not commanded regarding Kiddush you jump!", is that a trial or not? Says the Birkat Avraham, Hashem – the sanctification of Hakadosh Baruch Hu’s Name. Yitzchak is not mentioned in the command of the trial, Therefore, in Ur Kasdim, Avraham was not commanded, because it came after his own words that he was ready to give whereas at the Akeida he was commanded and did. And with his life. Rashi brings from the Gemara (Sanhedrin 89b) an this it is also understood that Avraham's trial was greater than explanation of the words ‫ – אַ חַ ר הַ ְּדבָ ִרים הָ אֵ לֶּה‬after these Yitzchak's trial, for Yitzchak was not commanded. matters – that preface Akeidat Yitzchak. It was after the words Chazal also said (Bereishit Rabbah 56:10) that Avraham could of Yishmael, who was boasting over Yitzchak that he had have asked: “Yesterday, You said ‫ – ִּכי ְביִצְ חָ ק ִי ָּק ֵרא לְ ָך ז ַָרע‬for been circumcised at age thirteen and did not protest. Yitzchak through Yitzchak will offspring be called for you, and now You said to him: “You frighten me over one limb? Had Hakadosh say ‫שם לְ עֹלָה‬ ָׁ ‫ – וְ הַ ֲעלֵה ּו‬and bring him up there as an offering?!” Baruch Hu said, ‘Offer yourself before Me,’ I would not hold But he did not ask. This was his trial, as Chazal said (Shabbat back.” Targum Yonatan ben Uziel9 comments that these 88a) at the time when Bnei Yisrael said ‫מע‬ ָ ‫ֲשה וְ נִ ְׁש‬ ֶׂ ‫ ַנע‬Hakadosh words were heard before Hakadosh Baruch Hu and Baruch Hu said: “‫ – ִמי ִּגילָּה ָרז זֶה לְ בָ נַי‬who revealed this secret immediately He tested Avraham. And with this, the question to My children?” A person should do first and ask for the is resolved. Yitzchak is not mentioned because he was ready reasons afterward. Avraham Avinu, who was likened to the to go and be slaughtered, and that is not called a trial. angels, put “we will do” before “we will hear,” even when the The Panim Yafot10 gives a series of answers. The Gemara in command appeared to contradict the promise. And Yitzchak Kiddushin (31a) says: Greater is one who is commanded and did not know that the promise ran through him, and therefore does than one who is not commanded and does. The moment the trial was Avraham’s and not Yitzchak’s. a person receives the command, the yetzer hara begins to There is another way to understand why this was Avraham’s work. But until then, it has nothing to work on. If Hakadosh test, and it begins with a distinction: there is suffering that has Baruch Hu tells you to do, the yetzer hara comes from the a kitzva – a limit – and suffering that has none. A person can opposite side and tells you not to, and vice versa. That is to withstand the first kind. If someone is told he will be killed for say, when they tell you no, the yetzer hara will want to turn it Hashem’s sake, how much time passes between the for you into a yes. And the proof for this is from Shlomo statement and the end? Lo aleinu, it is over in an instant, or at HaMelech, the wisest of all men. most a minute. The test has an end date. But losing a child is In his final testament, David HaMelech asks his son Shlomo yisurim bli kitzva – suffering without limit. It is on your to deal with Shimi ben Gera and tells him to do it with wisdom. shoulders, in front of your eyes, and in your heart. His picture Shlomo summons Shimi and tells him: “Build yourself a house sits with you at the breakfast table, at work, and when you go in Yerushalayim and dwell there. The day you leave, you will to sleep; time does not help. That is why this was Avraham’s surely die.” The pasuk says: ‫שם אָ נֶה וָאָ נָה‬ ָּׁ ‫ – ל ֹא ֵתצֵא ִמ‬Do not go test and not Yitzchak’s. out from there to this side or that. The Netivot Da’at13 finds reference to this in the Shema: The question arises: what was the wisdom in that? How many ָ‫יך ְּבכָל לְ בָ ְב ָך ו ְּבכָל נַפְ ְׁש ָך ו ְּבכָל ְמא ֶֹדך‬ ָ ֶ‫ל ֹה‬-ֱ‫ – וְ אָ הַ ְב ָּת אֵ ת ה' א‬And you people live their whole lives without ever leaving shall love Hashem your G-d with all your heart, with all your Yerushalayim? We are speaking of Yerushalayim when the soul, and with all your might. In the Gemara (Berachot 61b), Beit Hamikdash stood, the pinnacle of beauty and holiness. Rabbi Akiva explains ָ‫ ו ְּבכָל נַפְ ְׁשך‬to mean even if Hashem takes Who would even want to leave?! your soul: if they tell you to bow to an idol or be killed, you are ready to give your life. Then why, asks the Gemara, does the ~4~ Torah add ָ‫ – ו ְּבכָל ְמא ֶֹדך‬with all your might? Giving up your life that is spiritual mesirut nefesh. Avraham recognized that by is surely harder than giving up your money! Rabbi Eliezer fulfilling this command, and sacrificing his son, he would answers that it depends on the person. If his body is dearer to contradict and nullify with his own hands everything he had him than his property, the Torah says with all your soul, give accomplished in the spiritual realm in his life! He had your life for the sanctification of Hashem. And if his money is converted converts and shown them how to keep the way of dearer to him than his body, the Torah says with all your Hashem, to do tzedakah and mishpat; he taught the trait of might, with all your assets. chesed and fought against idol worship, which demanded the The Netivot Da’at asks: where do we find such a person? Put sacrifice of human beings; and now he himself was him at gunpoint and he will hand over the bag without a commanded to perform a similar act. This one act contradicts second thought! And he answers: there are people who can all he built during the 136 years of his outreach activity! In our pass the test of dying al Kiddush Hashem, because within own language, this would be like Avraham slaughtering thirty seconds they are in the olam shekulo tov – the world that is or forty-thousand people, and probably much more than that! entirely good. But handing over the money has a lasting effect. But Avraham did not pay attention to this, for he had only one He may be poor for the next fifty years, sleeping in a machsan desire – to fulfill the will of the Boreh Olam, and since it was and eating at a soup kitchen for the rest of his life. There are revealed to him without any doubt that such is His will, he did people who will say: “That I cannot handle!” That test has no not take other things into account at all. limit, and for them the Torah had to add ָ‫ו ְּבכָל ְמא ֶֹדך‬. The final part, and major yesod in this trial, says Rav Dessler, Then the Chatam Sofer14 gives another answer. Avraham’s is that the difficulty was not only in how the outside world trial was harder than Yitzchak’s because he walked for two would see it, but also within Avraham himself. Hakadosh days with the knowledge that he was going to slaughter his Baruch Hu’s conduct was hidden from him, like a riddle with son, whereas Yitzchak knew only on the third day. no solution. Hashem Himself had promised him that he would become a great nation, and ‫כי ְביִצְ חָ ק ִי ָּק ֵרא לְ ָך ז ַָרע‬, ִּ and now the If so, I would like to pose another question, and from it to enter command of the Akeida flatly contradicted all of those into the main topic of our shiur. There is a piyyut that the promises. These are the words of Rav Dessler. Sephardic and Eastern communities say from the second of Elul straight until Yom Kippur. Bnei Ashkenaz recite it only From here I would like to go in a different direction, introduced once in total, on the fourth day of the Aseret Yemei Teshuva, with several new questions. If we take note, the trial of the and many would not even know where it is found, perhaps Akeida was not a command but rather a request, as it says: guessing that it’s in the Kinnot of Tisha B’Av or in the section ‫ֹּאמר ַקח נָא אֶ ת ִּבנְ ָך אֶ ת י ְִח ְיד ָך אֲ ֶׁשר אָ הַ ְב ָּת אֶ ת יִצְ חָ ק‬ ֶ ‫ ַוי‬. The Gemara mumbled by some after reading Megilat Esther. The (Sanhedrin 89b) teaches that the word ‫ נָא‬is exclusively an Sephardim all know, however. It is called ‫אם אָ פֵ ס רֹבַ ע הַ ֵּקן‬: ִ expression of request. It doesn’t say ‫נָא ל ֹא ִּת ְרצָח‬, or ‫נָא ל ֹא ִּתגְ נֹב‬, or ָ‫ת־א ֶּמך‬ ִ ָ ‫נָא ַּכ ֵּבד אֶ ת־אָ ִב‬. ֶ‫יך וְ א‬ ‫ י ֵׁש לָנ ּו‬,‫ֹאב ָדה ִּכי עַ ל ֵּכן‬ ְ ‫ אַ ל נָא נ‬,‫ אֹהֶ ל ִׁש ֵּכן ִאם ִר ֵּקן‬,‫ִאם אָ פֵ ס רֹבַ ע הַ ֵּקן‬ ‫ אָ ִבי או ִֹתי‬.‫ נָאַ ם לְ הוֹר ֹו הַ ְּמנ ֶֻּסה‬.‫ ָראָ ה י ִָחיד ִּכי הוּא הַ ֶֹּשה‬... :‫אָ ב ז ֵָקן‬ To answer this question, the Gemara provides a parable: .‫ לְ בָ ִבי ל ֹו לַחֲ שֹׂף‬.‫ ִּבי חָ פֵ ץ וְ נִ כְ סֹף‬:‫סה‬ֶּ ַ‫ ל ֹא ַת ְחמֹל וְ ל ֹא ְתכ‬.‫ֲשה‬ ֶׂ ‫ש ַּתע‬ ׂ ֶ‫ַּכ ֶּכב‬ there was a king who confronted many wars, and who had :‫ רו ִּחי וְ נִ ְׁש ָמ ִתי אֵ לָיו יֶאֱ סֹף‬.‫ִאם ִּת ְמנָעֵ נִ י סוֹף‬ one warrior who defeated all enemies. Years later, a fierce If the fourth of the nest has ceased, if the tent that dwelled has war was waged against him, and he said to his warrior: been emptied, let us not perish, for therefore we have an aged “Please, stand by me in this war, so that they will not say father. … The only one saw that he is the lamb, the one who ‫ש‬ ׁ ‫אשוֹנוֹת אֵ ין ָּבהֶ ם ַמ ָּמ‬ ׁ ‫ – ִר‬there was no substance in the earlier was tested said to his parent: father, make me like the sheep, victories.” So too Hakadosh Baruch Hu said to Avraham do not pity and do not conceal. He desires and yearns for me, Avinu: “I tested you with several ordeals and you withstood my heart is to lay bare to Him, if in the end you hold me back, them all. Now, stand by me in this trial, so that they will not my spirit and my soul He will gather to Himself. say ‫אשוֹנִ ים‬ ׁ ‫ – אֵ ין ַמ ָּמ ׁש ָּב ִר‬the earlier trials had no substance.” The paytan puts words in Yitzchak’s mouth. Yitzchak looks at Rabbotai, how is it possible to say about the first trials that his father and says: “Father, you are about to make me like they have no substance? Pharaoh's taking of Sarah has no the sheep, so do not pity me and do not hold back. Father, substance?! The famine has no substance?! A Brit Milah at summon courage and slaughter me! Hakadosh Baruch Hu age 99 has no substance?! Going forth from his family and desires me, and my heart is ready to lay itself before Him. If birthplace has no substance?! you do not take me, Hakadosh Baruch Hu will take me! I am Another question that needs explanation is that of the ready and you cannot stop His plan from unfolding!” Arizal16. In the story of the Akeida, the dialogue between Recited for forty straight days, this idea likely never entered Avraham and Yitzchak sounds a little strange. After the Satan anyone’s minds, but Rav Eliyahu Dessler15 (Michtav M’Eliyahu, tells Yitzchak that his father intends to slaughter him, the Rosh Hashanna) elaborates that the trial of Avraham Avinu was Torah says: essentially divided into three parts. The first part is the Akeida ‫ֹּאמר ִהנֵּה‬ ֶ ‫ֹּאמר ִהנ ִֶּּני ְבנִ י ַוי‬ ֶ ‫ֹּאמר אָ ִבי ַוי‬ ֶ ‫ֹּאמר יִצְ חָ ק אֶ ל אַ ְב ָרהָ ם אָ ִביו ַוי‬ ֶ ‫ַוי‬ itself, that a father must take his own son and slaughter him! ‫ל ִֹהים י ְִראֶ ה לּ ֹו‬-ֱ‫ֹּאמר אַ ְב ָרהָ ם א‬ ֶ ‫ ַוי‬:‫הָ אֵ ׁש וְ הָ עֵ צִ ים וְ אַ יֵּה הַ ֶּׂשה לְ עֹלָה‬ But there is a higher level than this, explains Rav Dessler, and :‫הַ ֶּׂשה לְ עֹלָה ְּבנִ י ַויֵּלְ כ ּו ְׁשנֵיהֶ ם י ְַח ָּדו‬ ~5~ Yitzchak said to Avraham his father, and he said, my father; and (Din) and sits on the seat of mercy (Rachamim), as it is he said, here I am, my son; and he said, here are the fire and the written: ‫ל ִֹהים ִּב ְתרוּעָ ה ה' ְּבקוֹל ׁשוֹפָ ר‬-ֱ‫עָ לָה א‬, and He is filled with wood, but where is the lamb for the offering? And Avraham said, mercy toward them and has mercy on them, and He converts G-d will see to the lamb for the offering, my son; and the two the attribute of judgment toward them into mercy. of them walked together. The question arises: what is embedded in the shofar that On the face of it, this looks like a conversation between a causes Hakadosh Baruch Hu to move from the Kiseh HaDin young father, perhaps 27 years old, and his seven-year-old – the seat of judgment, to the Kiseh HaRachamim – the seat son. "Abba, here are the markers and the pages. Abba. Abba, of mercy? where are the colors, Abba?" "Sweetie, Hashem will find you That is the end of our questions and now we can approach the markers. Sweetie!" Asks the Arizal: what kind of dialogue the explanation. is this? What’s hidden here? With regards to ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬-ֱ‫וְ הָ א‬, the Zohar18 says it The Arizal also asks: when Avraham lifts his hand to slaughter should have written ‫אֶ ת יִצְ חָ ק‬, for Yitzchak was thirty-seven his son, the Torah says: ‫ש ַמ ִים‬ ָּׁ ַ‫ – ַו ִּי ְק ָרא אֵ לָיו ַמלְ אַ ְך ה' ִמן ה‬And an years old, and his father was not accountable for him; had angel of Hashem called to him from the heavens. Didn't we Yitzchak said: “No, I do not want to,” his father would not have know that angels come from the heavens? Did we think they been punished on his account. What is the reason that the were up in the trees?! Why did it need to state that the angel pasuk only mentions Avraham and not that Hakadosh Baruch came from the heavens? Furthermore, we are told: Hu tested Yitzchak? ‫ש ל ֹו ְמאו ָּמה ִּכי עַ ָּתה י ַָד ְע ִּתי‬ ׂ ַ‫ֹּאמר אַ ל ִּת ְׁשלַח י ְָד ָך אֶ ל הַ נַּעַ ר וְ אַ ל ַּתע‬ ֶ ‫ַוי‬ The Zohar then provides a truly foundational answer. It is :‫שכְ ָּת אֶ ת ִּבנְ ָך אֶ ת י ְִח ְיד ָך ִמ ֶּמ ִּני‬ ַׂ ָ‫ל ִֹהים אַ ָּתה וְ ל ֹא ח‬-ֱ‫ִּכי י ְֵרא א‬ Avraham who is mentioned as being tested because And he said, do not send your hand to the lad, and do not do Hakadosh Baruch Hu wanted Avraham to take in the attribute anything to him, for now I know that you are G-d-fearing, and you of Din – judgement. Until now Avraham had none of this midah have not withheld your son, your only one, from Me. in him; he was entirely chesed. Chesed is alluded to in ‫ַמ ִים‬ Is it only now that we know that Avraham is G-d-fearing?! He (water) and Din is alluded to in ‫ש‬ ׁ ֵ‫( א‬fire), and for the first time, had already passed nine trials. Even Iyov, the model of a G-d at the Akeida, water was joined with fire. Avraham was not fearing man, was told by Chazal that Avraham surpassed him, shalem, or complete, before this occurred – as a person for Iyov said he did not look at another woman, whereas cannot be complete unless he possesses both chesed and Avraham did not look even at his own wife. gevurah. Avraham became whole only now, when he enhanced himself to carry out Din and set this attribute of And further, the Vilna Gaon17 asks: why does the Torah tell gevurah within him. us ‫שכְ ָּת אֶ ת ִּבנְ ָך אֶ ת י ְִח ְיד ָך ִמ ֶּמ ִּני‬ ַׂ ָ‫ – וְ ל ֹא ח‬and you have not withheld your son, your only one, from Me? It was Hakadosh Baruch All his days Avraham was lacking, until the moment when Hu who told Avraham to slaughter, and on the face of it, given water was joined with fire and fire with water. That is why the that this is the angel speaking, the pasuk should have said Torah tells us ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬-ֱ‫וְ הָ א‬, with the Name Elokim ּ‫ – ִמ ֶּמנּו‬from Him – and not ‫ – ִמ ֶּמ ִּני‬from Me. After all, it was not that signifies Din, and not ‫ ַוה' נִ ָּסה אֶ ת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬with the Name of from the angel that Avraham was not withholding his son. Hashem that signifies Rachamim. The trial was meant to draw Avraham into the attribute of Din; and once he went through And one may further ask: why did Hakadosh Baruch Hu send it, fire entered together with water, and each was completed an angel to tell Avraham to halt rather than tell him Himself? by the other. Avraham Avinu needed to join to himself both ‫ – וְ אֵ לֶּה ּתוֹלְ דֹת ִיצְ חָ ק ֶּבן אַ ְב ָרהָ ם אַ ְב ָרהָ ם הוֹלִ יד אֶ ת ִיצְ חָ ק‬In Parshat attributes – chesed and gevurah – because until now he was Toldot we read: And these are the generations of Yitzchak, entirely chesed alone. son of Avraham; Avraham fathered Yitzchak. Says Rashi, it The Zohar continues: come and see the secret of the matter. was necessary to add ‫ אַ ְב ָרהָ ם הוֹלִ יד אֶ ת יִצְ חָ ק‬because writing Although the pasuk mentions Avraham and not Yitzchak, ‫ יִצְ חָ ק ֶּבן אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬on its own is not enough. This is because the Yitzchak too is included in it. Look at the wording. It does not scoffers of the generation were saying: “How many years did say ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה לְ אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬-ֱ‫וְ הָ א‬, but ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה ֶאת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬-ֱ‫וְ הָ א‬, and she live with Avraham and did not conceive from him? Sarah the extra word ‫ אֶ ת‬is meant to be inclusive, alluding to became pregnant from Avimelech!” Hakadosh Baruch Hu Yitzchak. For Yitzchak is the attribute of gevurah, and at that therefore fashioned Yitzchak's facial features to resemble hour it was resting upon him. When he was bound, and Avraham, and everyone testified: “Avraham fathered Avraham prepared him for judgment, Yitzchak’s gevurah took Yitzchak.” its place beside Avraham’s chesed. Fire and water were Rabbotai, is that really what would stop the scoffers from joined and rose together – water and fire standing opposite continuing to laugh?! each other. Now, here is the final question in our set. About a month and If so, says the Arizal, we can understand the matter very well a half ago we blew the shofar. Chazal say (Vayikra Rabbah 29:3), through a closer look at the pesukim and dialogue of the at the time when Yisrael take their shofars and blow before Akeida. Avraham Avinu takes the fire and the wood and goes Hakadosh Baruch Hu, He rises from the seat of judgment out to the Akeida, without saying a word to Yitzchak. The ~6~ Satan comes to Yitzchak and asks him: "Do you know who mountain, and he was ready to die for the fulfillment of the offering is?!" Yitzchak responds: "No, I haven’t a clue. My Hashem’s word. So, when Hakadosh Baruch Hu said to offer father said that Hashem will provide the offering." The Satan him on the altar, Yitzchak would not question it. On the then informs him: "No, you’re mistaken. The offering is you!" contrary, this was his desire and his salvation. Avraham, Yitzchak responds: "Fine, I may be the korban, but who is however, was being told to turn to judgment; to take the knife going to slaughter me?!" The Satan once again informs him: in his own hand and slaughter his only son. That went against "Your father! Because Hakadosh Baruch Hu wants the his very nature, and he did it without even asking questions. attribute of gevurah to enter him!" That is why it is a great trial for Avraham. ?‫ֹּאמר | אָ ִבי‬ ֶ ‫ ַוי‬,‫ֹּאמר יִצְ חָ ק אֶ ל אַ ְב ָרהָ ם אָ ִביו‬ ֶ ‫ – ַוי‬Shocked, Yitzchak The Alsheich reads the pasuk this way: ‫ל ִֹהים‬-ֱ‫ וְ הָ א‬is the turns to Avraham and asks: “Abba, is it true that you are going attribute of Yitzchak, and it tested Avraham to act against his to slaughter me?! How are you able to do that? You couldn’t own trait. But for the same attribute to test Yitzchak would not even harm a fly! You even davened and negotiated for the be a trial at all, because being cruel toward everything in order wicked people of Sedom! So, how will you be capable of to fulfill Hashem’s word is his trait and his nature. taking my life?!" We can find proof for these words in the Gemara (Shabbat 89b). !‫ֹּאמר | ִהנ ִֶּּני ְבנִ י‬ ֶ ‫ – ַוי‬Avraham provides him with the answer: In the future, Hakadosh Baruch Hu will say to Avraham: “Your "Here and now, at the Akeida, I am going to receive the power children have sinned against Me,” and Avraham will respond: of my son – the attribute of gevurah!” “ָ‫ִמח ּו עַ ל ִקדּ ו ּׁש ְׁש ֶמך‬ ָּ ‫ – י‬let them be wiped out for the sanctification ‫ֹּאמר ִהנֵּה הָ אֵ ׁש וְ הָ עֵ צִ ים וְ אַ יֵּה הַ ֶּׂשה לְ עֹלָה‬ ֶ ‫ – ַוי‬Yitzchak again of Your Name.” That is, carry out judgment on those who questions where the lamb is for the offering. transgress Your word! Hakadosh Baruch will then turn to Yaakov who knew the suffering of raising children and !‫ל ִֹהים י ְִראֶ ה לּ ֹו הַ ֶּׂשה לְ עֹלָה | ְּבנִ י‬-ֱ‫ א‬,‫ֹּאמר אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬ ֶ ‫ – ַוי‬And Avraham perhaps will request mercy on them. Yaakov responded in the once again informs him: “Do you know who will be offered up? same manner: “ָ‫ִמח ּו עַ ל ִקדּ ו ּׁש ְׁש ֶמך‬ ָּ ‫י‬.” Hakadosh Baruch Hu will The answer is ‫ – ְּבנִ י‬my son!” then say: “There is no reasoning in the old and no counsel in ‫ – ַויֵּלְ כ ּו ְׁשנֵיהֶ ם י ְַח ָּדו‬Now, the Arizal says, gevurah and chesed the young!” Neither the grandfather, Avraham, nor the went forth together! Water with fire, and fire with water. grandson, Yaakov, knows how to teach a defense on behalf Avraham mixed with the gevurah of Yitzchak, and Yitzchak of Klal Yisrael, and He will pose the question to Yitzchak. mixed with the chesed of Avraham! Yitzchak will then respond: “My children and not Your What was the Akeida for Avraham Avinu? In binding Yitzchak, children?! When they put ‫ֲשה‬ ֶׂ ‫ ַנע‬before ‫ נִ ְׁש ָמע‬at Matan Torah, he tied up Yitzchak’s attribute of gevurah and transmitted his You called them ‫ – ְּבנִ י ְבכ ִֹרי‬My firstborn son; and now You say attribute of chesed. that they are my children and not Yours?!” Yitzchak goes on to calculate how many years they sinned and suggests either With that, says the sefer Ori V’Yishi19, we can understand the Hakadosh Baruch Hu bear them all, or ְ‫– ַּפלְ גָא ֲעלַי וּפַ לְ גָא ֲעלָיך‬ two going forth together. The initial letters of ‫ ְׁשנֵיהֶ ם י ְַח ָּדו‬spell half (of the years) upon me and half upon You. ‫ש"י‬, which is the gematria of ‫ – הַ ֶּׂשה‬the lamb. And it is known that ‫ ש"י‬is the initials of ‫ – ְׂשמֹאל י ִָמין‬left, right – which allude to Rabbotai, Avraham Avinu’s answer is incomprehensible. For the attributes of Avraham and Yitzchak, who now walked the wicked people of Sedom he requested mercy, but for his together. The Vilna Gaon writes on this idea in sefer Aderet own children he says to let them be wiped out?! Eliyahu, based on the word ‫ – ַו ִּייצֶר‬and He formed, found in The answer is very simple. The question of Sedom was before Creation. The ‫( ש"י‬310) worlds created are divided into three the Akeida, and thus he answered with chesed. But after the hundred (‫ )ש‬worlds of ‫ – סוּר ֵמ ָרע‬turn from evil, which is the left Akeida, where he received the attribute of gevurah, he side, and ten (‫ )י‬worlds of ‫ֲשה טוֹב‬ ֵׂ ‫ – ע‬do good, the right side. answered in such a way. Yitzchak, who received the attribute ‫ ש"י‬is the aspect of left and right, represented by the initial of chesed at the Akeida, therefore aroused Heavenly mercy attributes of Avraham and Yitzchak, and ‫ ְׁשנֵיהֶ ם י ְַח ָּדו‬alludes to upon his children when he said ְ‫ – ַּפלְ גָא ֲעלַי וּפַ לְ גָא ֲעלָיך‬in those aspects now being mixed together. contrast to he said before: ‫ ִיקֹּב הַ ִּדין אֶ ת הָ הָ ר‬. The Alsheich HaKadosh20 provides a wonderful idea. The Vilna Gaon (Kol Eliyahu) uses this to answer the question Avraham and Yitzchak are not equal in their traits: Avraham of ‫ – עַ ָּתה י ַָד ְע ִּתי‬now I know. The following is said at the Akeida: is chesed and Yitzchak is din. Yitzchak’s nature is to show no ‫ל ִֹהים אַ ָּתה‬-ֱ‫עַ ָּתה י ַָד ְע ִּתי ִּכי י ְֵרא א‬, because until then Avraham had pity to those who transgress Hakadosh Baruch Hu’s word. shown only one side of himself. He was very merciful, hosting Chazal say he told Eisav that if the children of Yaakov guests and doing acts of kindness. But the trait of ‫– אַ כְ ז ִָר ּיוּת‬ transgress the Torah, he should decree destruction upon cruelty or fierceness – and the ability to coerce himself in order them and not pity them. Avraham was the opposite. He to fulfill the Boreh Olam’s commandments – had not yet been desired chesed, and he exerted himself to find merit even in seen in him. So, someone could have said that Avraham the people of Sedom. Avinu was not a complete tzaddik, and that his kindness was This changes how we see the trial, explains the Alsheich. simply due to his nature. That changed at the Akeida. Yitzchak’s attitude was ‫ – ִיקֹּב הַ ִּדין אֶ ת הָ הָ ר‬let the law pierce the Avraham showed cruelty and fierceness too, wanting with all ~7~ the desire of his soul to fulfill Hakadosh Baruch Hu’s carry length of days, since one who keeps both has shown command and slaughter the son on whom his whole life and that he serves Hakadosh Baruch Hu by the Torah’s decree legacy depended. Now he was shalem, and now it was and not by his nature, and that is what marks a tzaddik. recognized that he was a complete tzaddik. The Vilna Gaon then answers the question of ‫ – ִמ ֶּמ ִּני‬namely, The sefer Ori VeYishi adds that Avraham Avinu is complete why the angel said to Avraham that he did not withhold his only when he can serve Hakadosh Baruch Hu with opposite son “from me” instead of “from Him.” If an angel were simply traits – gevurah and chesed – together. That is the meaning speaking for Hashem, he should have said '‫נְ אֻ ם ה‬. But every of ‫עַ ָּתה י ַָד ְע ִּתי‬. Only now was his completeness revealed. A mitzvah creates an angel, and the greater the love, zeal and person who has mastered both is shown to be a true tzaddik, intention behind it, the higher the angel. The angel who came worthy of the reward. to Avraham was the one created by the Akeida itself. So, The Vilna Gaon explains why that is, in his commentary on when he says that you did not withhold your son ‫מ ֶּמ ִּני‬, ִ he Yeshayahu (3:6). Chazal ask (Shabbat 114a): means: “By my own high level I know how great your fear of Hakadosh Baruch Hu was, because I am the result of it.” ‫ידה ִּב ְט ִביעוּת הָ עַ יִן – זֶה הַ ַּמ ְק ִּפיד‬ ָ ֵ‫אֵ יזֶה ּו ַּתלְ ִמיד חָ ָכם ֶׁש ַּמ ְחזִ ִירין ל ֹו אֲ ב‬ .ֹ‫עַ ל חֲ לוּק ֹו לְ הוֹפְ כו‬ These are the facts of the matter and now we can understand the yesod very well. Who is a talmid chacham to whom a lost item is returned on the recognition of his eye? One who is careful to turn his garment In the first “ָ‫ ”ל ְֶך לְ ך‬trial – ָ‫ֹּאמר ה' אֶ ל אַ ְב ָרם ל ְֶך לְ ך‬ ֶ ‫ – ַוי‬Hashem inside out. spoke to Avraham with the attribute of mercy (‫)'ה‬. In the final “ָ‫ ”ל ְֶך לְ ך‬trial – ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם וְ ל ְֶך לְ ָך אֶ ל אֶ ֶרץ הַ מ ִֹּריָּה‬-ֱ‫ – וְ הָ א‬He The Vilna Gaon explains that a person’s traits are his spoke to Avraham with the attribute of judgement (‫ל ִֹהים‬-ֱ‫)וְ הָ א‬, garments, the way he shows himself to the world. The Torah and Avraham had to now stand firm with the attribute of hints at this with the words ‫ – וְ לָבַ ׁש הַ כֹּהֵ ן ִמדּ ֹו בָ ד‬and the Kohen gevurah. And after he successfully stood firm in this, the angel shall wear his linen garment, where ֹ‫מדּ ו‬, ִ his garment, echoes said to him: “‫ל ִֹהים אַ ָּתה‬-ֱ‫ַתה י ַָד ְע ִּתי ִּכי י ְֵרא א‬ ָּ ‫ – ”ע‬using the Name the word for traits – ‫מדּ וֹת‬. ִ A talmid chacham knows how to ‫ל ִֹהים‬-ֱ‫א‬, because now he was complete with the attribute of turn his garment inside out, using opposite traits according to gevurah! what is needed. This is also the meaning of the statement (Yoma 23a): ‫כם‬ ָ ָ‫ש אֵינ ֹו ַּתלְ ִמיד ח‬ ׁ ָ‫ׇּכל ַּתלְ ִמיד חָ ָכם ֶׁשאֵ ינ ֹו נו ֵֹקם וְ נו ֵֹטר ְּכנָח‬ When the angel called out to Avraham, who was it? Says the – Any talmid chacham who does not take revenge and bear a ָּׁ ַ‫ אֵ לָיו ַמלְ אַ ְך ה' ִמן ה‬have Ba’al HaTurim, the final letters of ‫ש ָמ ִים‬ grudge like a snake is not a talmid chacham. Revenge is the same numerical value (121) as ‫ – ִמיכָאֵ ל הָ יָה‬it was Michael. generally a bad trait, but a talmid chacham should not uproot Similarly, the Rama MiPano21 points to the pasuk: it entirely. He needs some measure of it in him, so that he can ‫וְ ִהנֵּה אַ יִל אַ חַ ר נֶאֱ חַ ז ַּב ְּסבַ ְך ְּב ַק ְרנָיו ַו ֵּיל ְֶך אַ ְב ָרהָ ם ו ִַּי ַּקח אֶ ת הָ אַ יִל‬ use it when the honor of the Torah demands. The talmid :ֹ‫ַו ַּי ֲעלֵה ּו לְ עֹלָה ַּתחַ ת ְּבנו‬ chacham must rule over his traits and not be bound to them, even the good ones. Completeness is not about having good And behold, a ram afterward was caught in the thicket by its horns; and Avraham went and took the ram and offered it up as traits alone, but in being able to reverse them and use them an offering in place of his son. always for the service of Hakadosh Baruch Hu. The Vilna Gaon (Kol Eliyahu) explains the pasuk (Mishlei 30:17): ‫ ִהנֵּה אַ יִל‬in gematria equals ‫מיכָאֵ ל‬, ִ and the letter vav is auxiliary. And ְ‫ אַ חַ ר נֶאֱ חַ ז ַּב ְּסבַ ך‬in gematria equals ‫שטָ ן‬. ָׂ For :‫ָשר‬ ֶׁ ‫יקהַ ת אֵ ם ִי ְּקרוּהָ ע ְֹרבֵ י נַחַ ל וְ יֹאכְ לוּהָ ְבנֵי נ‬ ֲּ ִ‫עַ יִן ִּתלְ עַ ג לְ אָ ב וְ ָתבוּז ל‬ Michael and the Satan were arguing with each other; the An eye that mocks a father and despises obedience to a mother, Satan said: “Let Yitzchak die,” and Michael said: “Here is the the ravens will pick it out and the young eagles will eat it. ram, his redemption.” The Yerushalmi says this refers to the mitzvah of kibud av, Rashi, in Sefer HaPardes, comments on the pasuk in our honoring one’s parents, and the mitzvah of shiluach hakan, Parsha: ָ‫ֹּאמר ׁשוֹב אָ ׁשוּב אֵ לֶיך‬ ֶ ‫ – ַוי‬and he said, I will surely return sending away the mother bird. These are the only two mitzvot to you. Nowhere else do we find the angel coming back to for which the Torah promises length of days, and that is Avraham to bring him news. The angel announced Yitzchak’s because completeness shows only in a person who has two birth and promised to return, so when did he? He returned at opposite traits: ‫ – ַרחֲ ָמנוּת וְ אַ כְ זָרוּת‬mercy and cruelty. A person Har HaMoriah, when Avraham bound his son and the child with only one trait may simply be acting from his nature. So, needed life. There, the angel called to Avraham – it was the Hakadosh Baruch Hu gave us mitzvot of mercy, such as kibud same angel. He came back to save Yitzchak and thereby av, which is great mercy, since when people grow old and fulfilled ָ‫שוֹב אָ ׁשוּב אֵ לֶיך‬.ׁ have no place to rest, it is right that they should be shown Rabbotai, we’re told the angel called out ‫ש ַמ ִים‬ ָּׁ ַ‫ – ִמן ה‬from the mercy. And He gave us mitzvot that require some cruelty. In heavens. Why are the heavens called ‫?ש ַמ ִים‬ ָּׁ Says Rashi, the shiluach hakan one takes the young and sends away the word ‫ש ַמ ִים‬ ָּׁ consists of ‫ – אֵ ׁש ו ַּמ ִים‬fire and water. Hakadosh mother, and the Yerushalmi states that sometimes she flies Baruch Hu mixed them one into the other and from them, He off in distress and drowns in water. This is surely great cruelty, made the heavens. Therefore, a person who is a tzaddik is and it is no mercy. Both mitzvot are therefore the ones that called a ‫ש ַמ ִים‬ ָׁ ‫ – י ְֵרא‬a G-d-fearing person, but literally: one who ~8~ fears the heavens. Why? Because he has within him the However, this does not make sense, as earlier we brought that combination of fire and water, chesed and gevurah together. Michael was made of water, so how is fire now in the mix?! Another question: what are the angels in the heavens made The answer is very simple. At the Akeida, the angel said to of? Is it fire or water? Chazal say (Tanchuma, Vayigash 6), this is Avraham: ‫ל ִֹהים אַ ָּתה‬-ֱ‫;כי עַ ָּתה י ַָד ְע ִּתי ִּכי י ְֵרא א‬ִּ and how does he what the pasuk says: ‫שלוֹם ִּב ְמרו ָֹמיו‬ ָׁ ‫– הַ ְמ ֵׁשל וָפַ חַ ד ִע ּמ ֹו ע ֶֹׂשה‬ know Avraham is G-d-fearing?! ‫יד ָך ִמ ֶּמ ִּני‬ ֶ ‫שכְ ָּת אֶ ת ִּבנְ ָך אֶ ת י ְִח‬ ַׂ ָ‫וְ ל ֹא ח‬ Dominion and dread are with Him; He makes peace in His – the angel says: "I was created from your deeds!" heights. ‫ַמ ֵׁשל‬ ְ ‫ – ה‬this is Michael; ‫ – וָפַ חַ ד‬this is Gavriel. Michael What does it mean that he was created from Avraham’s is from water and Gavriel is from fire, and they stand before deeds? Did Michael not exist before the Akeida, such as when the Shechinah and do not harm one another. As a result, it he came to bring the good news to Sarah? This too is very says: ‫שלוֹם ִּב ְמרו ָֹמיו‬ ָׁ ‫ע ֶֹׂשה‬. simple to answer. Until the Akeida, Michael was made only of Similarly, another Midrash (Devarim Rabbah 5:12) teaches on this water, but from the Akeida onward, fire also became mixed in pasuk of ‫שלוֹם ִּב ְמרו ָֹמיו‬ ָׁ ‫ ע ֶֹׂשה‬that Michael is entirely snow and him – the same attribute of gevurah that was combined in Gavriel is entirely fire, and they stand next to each other and ָּׁ ַ‫ ַו ִּי ְק ָרא אֵ לָיו ַמלְ אַ ְך ה' ִמן ה‬, Avraham. Therefore, it is stated ‫ש ַמיִם‬ do not harm one another. from the heavens, where there is a mixture of fire and water! From where is the proof that Gavriel is entirely of fire? Says If so, we can now understand why Hakadosh Baruch Hu said the Gemara (Pesachim 118a): At the time when Nimrod the to Avraham: "Stand by me in this trial, so that they will not say wicked threw Avraham Avinu into the fiery furnace, Gavriel that the earlier ones had no substance." Why would they say said before Hakadosh Baruch Hu: “Ribbono Shel Olam, let me this?! Because all of the first nine trials were of "water," only descend and cool it, and rescue the tzaddik from the fiery in the attribute of mercy. But the tenth trial is in the attribute of furnace.” Hakadosh Baruch Hu said to him: “I am unique in gevurah, as it is stated ‫ל ִֹהים נִ ָּסה אֶ ת אַ ְב ָרהָ ם‬-ֱ‫וְ הָ א‬, and this is the My world, and he is unique in his world; it is fitting for the perfect trial, in which fire and water are mixed: chesed and Unique One to rescue the unique one.” And since Hakadosh gevurah! Baruch Hu does not withhold the reward of any creature, We brought the pasuk ‫מ ְתהַ ל ְֵּך ְּב ֻת ּמ ֹו צ ִַּדיק אַ ְׁש ֵרי בָ נָיו אַ חֲ ָריו‬. ִ The Hakadosh Baruch Hu said to Gavriel: “You will merit to rescue scoffers of the generation came and asked a very simple three of his descendants – Chananya, Mishael and Azarya.” question: "How can it be that to Avraham was born a child, At the time when Nevuchadnezzar the wicked threw Yitzchak, whose trait is gevurah, while Avraham himself is the Chananya, Mishael and Azarya into the fiery furnace, ‫יורקמ"ו‬, trait of chesed? It must be that he is not his father, but rather the minister of hail, stood before Hakadosh Baruch Hu and Sarah became pregnant through Avimelech! It cannot be that said before Him: “Master of the universe, let me descend and the father is chesed and the son is gevurah." Therefore, the cool the furnace and rescue these tzaddikim from the fiery Torah says: ‫– וְ אֵ לֶּה ּתוֹלְ דֹת יִצְ חָ ק ֶּבן אַ ְב ָרהָ ם ַא ְב ָרהָ ם הוֹלִ יד אֶ ת יִצְ חָ ק‬ furnace.” Gavriel said to him: “The might of Hakadosh Baruch Avraham and not Avram. Avram fathered Yishmael before his Hu would not be demonstrated in this, for you are the minister Brit Milah, which he performed on his own. With his Brit Milah, of hail, and everyone knows that water extinguishes fire. Avraham began his attribute of gevurah. A man who Rather, I am the minister of fire; I will descend and cool from circumcises himself, this is the beginning of cruelty! within and heat from without, and I will make a miracle within a miracle.” Hakadosh Baruch Hu said to him: “Descend.” At According to these words, we can understand something that moment, Gavriel opened and said: “‫ – וֶ אֱ ֶמת ה' לְ ע ֹולָם‬And wonderful. We brought up at the beginning of the shiur the the truth of Hashem is forever.” matter of the Leviatan, and how it amuses, or pleases, Hakadosh Baruch Hu when the tail is connected to the head. In the piyyut of Tefillat Geshem we referenced earlier, we say: If so, how do we connect the tail to the head – meaning, the ,‫ יִחַ ד לֵב וְ גָל אֶ בֶ ן ִמ ִּפי ְבאֵ ר ַמ ִים‬,‫זְ כור טָ עַ ן ַמ ְקלו וְ עָ בַ ר י ְַר ֵּדן ַמ ִים‬ beginning of our Parsha to its end? ‫ לָכֵ ן ִה ְבטַ ְח ּתו הֱ יות ִע ּמו ָּבאֵ ׁש‬,‫ְּכנֶאֱ בַ ק לו שר ָּבלוּל ֵמ ֵא ׁש ו ִּמ ַּמיִם‬ .‫ ַּבעֲבוּרו אַ ל ִּת ְמנַע ָמ ִים‬- ‫וּבַ ָּמ ִים‬ The answer is very simple. At the beginning of the Parsha, the Torah deals with the third day after the circumcision, the Remember the one who bore his staff and crossed the Jordan beginning of Avraham Avinu's entry into the attribute of waters; single-hearted, he rolled the stone from the mouth of gevurah. And at the end of the Parsha, the Torah deals with the well of water; when an angel formed of fire and the Akeida, a mixture of fire and water, chesed and gevurah! water wrestled him; You promised him to be with him in That is to say, the beginning of the Parsha was the beginning fire and in water – for his sake, do not withhold water. of the attribute of gevurah, and the end of the Parsha was the Which angel is made of fire and water?! Until now we heard completion of gevurah with chesed. of fire angels and water angels. Who is the mixture? The If so, we can now understand the words of the paytan who Torah says (Vayishlach): ‫שחַ ר‬ ָּׁ ַ‫ – ַויֵּאָ בֵ ק ִא ׁיש ִע ּמ ֹו עַ ד עֲלוֹת ה‬And a writes: ‫שו ַֹרת י ַֻּקח נָא ְמעַ ט ַמ ִים‬ ׂ ‫זְ כוֹר הַ ּנ ֹולָד ִּב ְב‬. Avraham Avinu, on man wrestled with him until the break of dawn. Who was that the third day after the circumcision, was busy hosting guests angel who wrestled with Yaakov? Writes the Rokeach in his in his home and serving them. Is there a greater chesed than sefer Sodei Razaya22, ‫ ַויֵּאָ בֵ ק‬in gematria is ‫מיכָאֵ ל‬. ִ If so, the this? ‫שחֲ ט ֹו לִ ְׁש ּפו ְֹך ָּדמ ֹו ַּכ ַּמ ִים‬ ָׁ ְ‫ש ְח ָּת לְ הוֹר ֹו ל‬ַׂ ְ‫ – ו‬Hakadosh Baruch paytan tells us: ‫שר ָּבלוּל ֵמאֵ ׁש ו ִּמ ַּמ ִים‬ ַׂ ‫ – ְּכנֶאֱ בַ ק ל ֹו‬this is Michael! Hu said to him: "It is not good for you to remain with the ~9~ attribute of chesed alone. You need to know when ‘yes’ and ‫ֵי־שוֹר ֵמהַ ְּׂשמֹאול לְ אַ ְר ַּב ְע ָּתן‬ ׁ ‫וּפְ נ‬. There are 280 judgments, the when ‘no’!" So, what do we do? We mix chesed with gevurah! gematria of ‫פר‬. The word ‫ שו‬represents mercy, and its It follows, then, that in the hospitality of Avraham Avinu, the gematria is 306, the same as ‫ש‬ ׁ ַ‫ – ְּדב‬honey. All this to say that Akeida was born! When the angels arrive at the house of through the blowing of the shofar, the 280 judgments are Avraham Avinu, he cooks them meat in milk. And why meat sweetened! in milk? Says Rabbeinu Bachya23 regarding the reason for Hakadosh Baruch Hu said to Avraham: "You are all chesed. the prohibition of eating meat with milk: milk hints at chesed You need to mix into yourself also the attribute of gevurah!" and meat at din, and therefore one should not mix them. Therefore, Avraham Avinu needed to chase after the ‫פר‬, ַּ Michael, who is the minister of water, comes together with which represents the attribute of gevurah! And where does it Gavriel, who is the minister of fire. Avraham prepares an flee? To Me’arat HaMachpelah, which belonged to Bnei Chet, intentional recipe consisting of meat and milk; giving the milk of the Chiti nation, whose attribute, Chazal say, is ‫– ַּפחַ ד‬ to the minister of water, and the meat to the minister of fire. dread, as it says: ‫ל ִֹהים עַ ל הֶ עָ ִרים‬-ֱ‫ – ַוי ְִהי ִח ַּתת א‬And a dread of All this to reach the completeness of chesed and gevurah, G-d was upon the cities. which would be fulfilled at the Akeida! ‫ימא‬ ָ ‫ – ַרחֲ ָמנָא ִא ְד ַּכר לָן ְקי ֵָמ ּה ְּדאַ ְב ָרהָ ם ְר ִח‬As we say in our Selichot, If so, we can also understand why the bull ran away from may the Merciful One remember for us the covenant of Avraham Avinu. It is brought in the writings of the Arizal that Avraham, and may we merit the complete Geula, speedily in the word shofar – ‫ – ׁשוֹפָ ר‬divides into two words, ‫ שו‬and ‫פר‬. our days, Amen v'Amen! ◊ The word ‫ פר‬represents the left side and dinim, judgment: 1 Rashi - R’ Shlomo Yitzchaki (1040-1105), Troyes, France. "Rabban Shel Yisrael" Talmud, named Chiddushei Halachot, and commentary on the aggadot of the - The great Rishon who wrote commentary on all areas of Torah. Talmud, named Chiddushei Aggadot. Also served as rav in Chelm, Lublin, Tiktin 2 Ba’al HaTurim - Rabbi Jacob ben Asher (1269-1343), Spain; Composer of and Ostroh. 13 Netivot Da’at - Rav Shmuel David Gross shlit”a; Rav of Kehillas Chassidei Gur Arba’ah Turim, tracing Halacha from the Torah through Talmud and early Poskim. 3 Rav Yechezkel Abramsky - (1886-1976), Belarus, London, Yerushalayim; in Ashdod. 14 Chatam Sofer - R’ Moshe Sofer of Pressburg (1762–1839), Frankfurt, Moravia, Prominent Lithuanian rabbi who later headed the London Beth Din for 17 years. Studied in the yeshivas of Telz, Mir, Slabodka and particularly Brisk under Rav Mattersdorf and Pressburg; Studied under R’ Nathan Adler and R’ Pinchas Chaim Soloveitchik. In 1926, while serving as the rabbi of Slutsk, he joined Horowitz (Hafla’ah). In 1807 was appointed as Rabbi of Pressburg (Bratislava), together with Rav Shlomo Yosef Zevin to form the Vaad Harabbonim of the USSR. where he also founded a large Yeshiva that produced many noted rabbis. 15 Rav Eliyahu Dessler - (1892-1953), Lithuania, London, Israel; At age 13, he In 1928, he started a Hebrew magazine, Yagdil Torah, but the Soviet authorities closed it after the first two issues had appeared and he was arrested and was one of the youngest students at the Kelm Yeshiva. Mashgiach Ruchani of sentenced to five years' hard labor in Siberia, where he is said to have composed Gateshead Kollel in England, and Ponevezh in Israel. His shiurim were recorded Talmudic commentaries on translucent cigarette papers. in Michtav Me’Eliyahu, by students R’ Chaim Friedlander and R’ Aryeh Carme. 4 Rabbi Eleazar HaKalir - (c.570-c.640), Near East; One of Judaism’s earliest and 16 Arizal - Ari HaKadosh, Rabbi Isaac Luria (1534-1572), Yerushalayim, Egypt, most prolific liturgical poets. Wrote piyutim for all the main festivals, for special Tzefat; Considered the forefather of modern Kabbalah. Shabbats, and for the fasts, many of which have found their way into Ashkenazi 17 Vilna Gaon - (The Gra) R’ Eliyahu ben Shlomo Zalman (1720-1797), Vilnius, liturgy. Poland, Lithuania. Foremost leader of misnagdic Jewry of the past few centuries. 5 Oznaim LaTorah - R’ Zalman Sorotzkin (1881-1966), Ukraine, Belarus, Considered the father of the stream of Lithuanian Kabbalah, and remembered as Yerushalayim; Leader of Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah. a leader of the opposition to the Hasidic movement. 6 Ibn Ezra - R’ Avraham ben Meir ibn Ezra (1089-1164), Spain; Wrote on grammar, 18 Zohar - Central work of mystical tradition of Kabbalah. Traditionally attributed to philosophy, astronomy, medicine, and mathematics, but most famous for his Torah Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai. First appeared in 13th-century Spain. commentary. 19 Ori V’Yishi - Rav Uri Shraga Jungreis shlit"a, Bait Vegan - Yerushalayim; Ori 7 Rav Chaim Volozhin - Rav Chaim (Ickovits) of Volozhin (1749-1821); Popularly V’Yishi is a series of essays in thought and Aggadah based on the words of the known as Reb Chaim Volozhiner, the foremost disciple of the Vilna Gaon and Maharal, the Vilna Gaon, and their commentaries. founder of the Volozhin Yeshiva. Considered one of the greatest Talmudic scholars 20 Alsheich HaKadosh - Rabbi Moshe Alsheich (1508–1593), Tzefat; Student of of his age. His major work is Nefesh HaChaim, an explication of Jewish belief. Rabbi Yosef Caro; Rebbe of Rav Chaim Vital. 8 Birkat Avraham - Rav Avraham Mordechai Albert (1949-2016), Ashdod; A 21 Rama MiPano - R’ Menachem Azariah da Fano (1548-1620), Italy; Talmudist prominent Torah scholar, researcher, and publisher; specialized in analyzing, and Kabbalist, and disciple of Rabbi Moshe Cordovero. identifying, and reconstructing unedited, rare, or lost Torah manuscripts. 22 Sodei Razaya - The Rokeach - Rabbi Elazar MiGermaiza (1176-1238) Mainz, 9 Targum Yonatan ben Uziel - Aramaic translation to Nevii’im; One of 80 tannaim Worms, Germany; Authored many piyyutim protesting Israel’s suffering and hoping who studied under Hillel HaZaken during era of Roman rule. for redemption and revenge against her tormentors. Sodei Razaya (Secrets of 10 Panim Yafot - Rabbi Pinchas Halevi Horowitz (1730-1805),Galicia, Frankfurt ; Secrets) is a major five-part mystical and esoteric compendium consisting of: Sod Also known as the Baal Hafla'ah. Brother of R' Shmelke of Nikolsburg, both of Ma'aseh Bereshit (The Secret of Genesis), Sod ha-Merkavah (The Secret of the whom were major students of the Maggid of Mezritch. Panim Yafos is a kabbalistic Chariot), Sefer ha-Shem (The Book of the Names of God), and Chochmat ha- commentary on the Torah. Nefesh (The Wisdom of the Soul). 11 Rav Chaim Shmuelevitz - (1902-1979), Poland, Shanghai, Yerushalayim; 23 Rabbeinu Bachya - (Rabbeinu Behaye) R’ Bahya ben Asher (1255-1340), Grandson of the Alter of Novhardok. Member of the faculty of the Mirrer Yeshiva Spain. Torah commentary incorporating the literal meaning along with allegorical, for over 40 years, in Poland, Shanghai and Jerusalem, serving as Rosh yeshiva Midrashic, and Kabbalistic interpretations. during its sojourn in Shanghai from 1941-47, and in Jerusalem from 1965-79. 12 Maharsha - R’ Shmuel Eidels (1555-1631), Poland. Wrote commentary on the ~ 10 ~