Ohr Yosef - English — Vayeru (2026-10-26)

Ohr Yosef The Prayer That Failed Vayeira p1
A Habit He Never Had
Two angels arrive in Sodom in the evening, and Lot is sitting at the
city gate. What happens next looks like a page out of Avraham’s
house: אתם
ָּ ַוי ְַרא לֹוט ַוי ָָּּקם ל ְִק ָּר: Lot saw them and rose to greet them.
He bows, he invites them home, and when they decline he does not
take no for an answer: ַויִפְ צַ ר בָּ ם ְמאֹד, he urged them very strongly.
He brings them in, bakes for them, and serves them a meal. In
Sodom, of all places, where taking in a stranger was not merely
unfashionable but dangerous.
Rashi tells us where this came from: Lot learned to go looking for
guests in the house of Avraham.
That makes sense, until we read a little further. When Lot asks his
wife for a bit of salt for the guests, she answers him, as Rashi
records, “This evil custom too you want to introduce here?” That is
not how anyone talks about a habit of long standing. She is
objecting to something new. Whatever Lot learned in Avraham’s
house, he had evidently not been practicing it in Sodom; otherwise,
there would have been nothing to object to.
So, the question is simple. Lot lived in Sodom for years without
taking in a guest. What changed on this one evening?
Three Things About That Day
The Torah and Chazal tell us three things about that day, and each
one is part of the answer.
© 5787 Yosi Rabinowicz. This weekly can be obtained by email from
gilyonOhrYosef@gmail.com or downloaded from www.ladaat.info
Translations are loose, and based upon The Living Torah by Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan
Ohr Yosef The Prayer That Failed Vayeira p2
First, Lot was sitting at the gate because, Rashi says, that very day
the people of Sodom had appointed him a judge. A person who
rises to a position is not quite the same person as before. Chazal
say that someone who rises to greatness is forgiven all their sins
(Sanhedrin 14a), and the Maharal explains why: that person has, in a
sense, become someone new. Lot that evening was a man who had
just been lifted up, and a man who has just been lifted up wants to
do something worthy of it.
Second, it was Pesach. Rashi notes that Lot baked matzos for his
guests because it was Pesach, the same day the same angels had
eaten matzos at Avraham’s table. And Pesach is a day with a
particular character. It is the day Hashem reaches toward us before
we have done anything to deserve it. In Mitzrayim, the Mechilta
says, we were וְ ַא ְת עֵ רֹם וְ עֶ ְריָּה, naked and bare: bare of any mitzvah,
with nothing in hand to be redeemed by. So, Hashem gave us two
mitzvos, the Pesach offering and milah, so that we would have
something. Even the mitzvos came from Him. There is a saying in
my family, from my ancestor Rebbe Baruch of Mezhibuzh, that
ּופָּסַ ח ה׳ עַ ל הַ פ ֶַתחmeans that Hashem skipped over the “opening”:
ordinarily we must open a door the width of a needle before He
opens the rest, but on Pesach He asks for no opening at all. On a
night when Hashem stirs people toward mitzvos they have not yet
earned, Lot was stirred.
Pesach is also, the Tur tells us, the festival that corresponds to
Avraham, the pillar of chesed. If there is one night a year on which
a man raised in Avraham’s house would feel the pull of Avraham’s
Ohr Yosef The Prayer That Failed Vayeira p3
mitzvah, this was it.
Third, and this is the one that holds the others together: just before
the angels came to Sodom, Avraham had been praying for it.
The Prayer That Failed
Avraham’s prayer for Sodom is one of the most moving passages in
the Torah. He bargains, he pleads, he apologizes for pleading and
pleads again: fifty righteous people, forty-five, forty, thirty, twenty,
אּולַי יִמָּ צְ אּון שָּ ם עֲשָּ ָּרה, perhaps ten will be found there. And by every
visible measure the prayer failed. There were not ten. Sodom was
destroyed the next morning.
But Chazal teach that a prayer poured out at length does not come
back empty (Berachos 32b). Avraham’s prayer did not save Sodom,
because Sodom could not be saved. So, what did it do?
Look at what happened that evening. Of all days, that was the day
Lot was made a judge. Of all nights, that night was Pesach. And of
all the people in Sodom, the one who had grown up in Avraham’s
house suddenly, for the first time in years, did what Avraham would
have done. None of that was coincidence. Avraham’s prayer
arranged it. It could not make Sodom worthy, but it could put the
one salvageable person in Sodom in the right frame of mind, on the
right night, to do the one mitzvah that would save his life. When
the angels came to the gate, Lot was ready for them, and because
he took them in, he and his daughters walked out of the city before
the fire fell.
The Torah says this almost in so many words: ַויִזְ כֹר אֱ ֹל ִקים ֶאת ַאבְ ָּרהָּ ם
Ohr Yosef The Prayer That Failed Vayeira p4
ַויְשַ לַח ֶאת לֹוט ִמתֹוְך הַ הֲ ֵפכָּה: God remembered Avraham, and He sent
Lot out of the upheaval. Lot was not saved on his own account. He
was saved because Hashem remembered Avraham, and what
Hashem remembered was a prayer that, as far as Avraham knew,
had been refused.
Avraham asked for all of Sodom and was told no. What his prayer
actually accomplished was to save everything in Sodom that could
be salvaged.
What We Do Not See
We are a few weeks past the Yamim Noraim. We prayed for a great
deal, and some of it seems like we did not get: the recovery that
did not come, the shidduch, the parnassah. It is very natural to
conclude that those prayers went nowhere.
Avraham’s prayer for Sodom says otherwise. A prayer that is not
answered as asked is not a prayer that went unanswered. It goes
where it can go and does what it can do, and many times, the
person who prayed never finds out what that was. Avraham went
home from that conversation having lost the argument. He had no
idea that somewhere in the city, a man who had not hosted a guest
in years was at that moment running toward two strangers at the
gate.
May we merit to see our prayers answered openly, and until then,
to keep praying the way Avraham did, at length and without giving
up, trusting that none of it is wasted, במהרה בימינו, amen.
