Vayomer Eliyahu - English — Vayeru (2026-10-26)

ערב שב"ק פרשת
By Rabbi Eli Meyer Smith Shlit”a
Rosh Hakollel of Bais Ulfana Lehoroa »
שנת תשפ "ז
«Email rabbi@yeshivasrebchaim ozer.com
בס"ד
When Things Go Your Way, Know That Hashem Was the One Who
Orchestrated it All!
›› Avrohom Avinu’s Lesson for His Guests on killing him, and it was safe for him to go home. If,
however, he would tell the lad that the arrows are
The pasuk in this week’s Parshah (Bereishis 18:5) states “beyond him”, it would be a sign that Shaul wanted to kill
that Avrohom Avinu told his guests: “And I will take a him, and he should “go because Hashem has sent you.”
morsel of bread, and sustain your hearts. Afterwards, you
shall pass, because you have passed by your servant." The Rav Eliyahu Meir Bloch zt”l, Rosh Yeshivas Telshe, asks
Shem M’Shmuel zt”l explains this pasuk as follows: why it says that he should “go because Hashem has sent
you.” Why doesn’t it simply say that he should flee
It is stated in Tehillim (37:23): “M’Hashem m’tzaadei because Shaul wants to kill him?
gaver. From Hashem are established the steps of a mighty
man.” This means that Hashem guides every step that a He answers that there are times when it appears like a
man takes as part of His Master Plan. It may look like a person must run away to escape danger. However, the
person is going where he wants to go; however, the truth truth is that whatever danger he is facing is not the real
is that every step is Divinely orchestrated, and Hashem is reason he needs to flee. In truth, Hashem has decreed
the one deciding where his feet should take him. that he must leave his place to fulfill some mission
elsewhere, and that is the real reason he has to move.
This is the meaning of the next words in the pasuk:
“For a person delights in his ways.” This means that even The Gemara relates (Sukkah 53A) that Shlomo Hamelech
if a person thinks he is going in the way that he desires, once met the Malach Hamaves, and he saw that he
Hashem is really the one determining where he is going. looked sad. He asked him what was wrong, and the Angel
of Death replied, “It has been decreed by Hashem that I
This was Avrohom’s message to his guests – whom he must kill the king’s two scribes, Elicharaf and Achiyah.”
thought were Arab travelers. He told them that they may
have thought that they came to this place because that’s Shlomo immediately summoned sheidim and told
where they decided to go. In truth, however, their entire them to grab these two men and take them to the city of
journey was orchestrated by Hashem. He instilled in them Luz, where the Malach Hamaves was not allowed to
the desire to pass by this area so that Avrohom could enter. However, when they reached the gates of the city,
fulfill the mitzvah of hachnasas orchim, as He saw how the Malach Hamaves snatched them and took their souls.
pained Avrohom was since he had no guests. The next day, Shlomo met the Angel of Death again.
He told them, “Sustain your hearts… because you This time, he looked very happy. He asked him why he
have passed.” In other words, the entire reason you was so joyous, and the Malach Hamaves said, “It had
passed this place was so that he could fulfill the mitzvah been decreed that I must kill them specifically in that
of sustaining their hearts. place – next to the gates of Luz – and I didn’t know how I
would get them there until you sent them for me.”
›› The Cure for Depression
Shlomo then declared, “The feet of a person are
The pasuk states (1 Shmuel 20:20-22) that when Dovid responsible for him. To the place where he is needed,
Hamelech was fleeing from Shaul Hamelech, he made a there they lead him.”
sign with his beloved friend, Shaul’s son Yonason, to
know if Shaul was so angry with him that he We can ask two questions about this
needed to run for his life. The sign was that story:
Yonason should shoot arrows, and then send 1. We can understand why the
a lad to collect them. If he would tell the lad Angel of Death appeared to Shlomo the first
that the arrows are “on the side of him”, it time, as he wanted to trick him into sending
would be a sign that Shaul was not planning
}{א
those two men to the gates of Luz. But why did he appear “ovrei derech”, passersby on the road, rather than the
to him the second time? word “holchei derech”, people who walk on the road, as
he began by saying that he once was “mehalech
2. Why did Shlomo say that the men’s feet led them ba’derech” walking on the road.
to where they were needed? They didn’t travel there on
foot; rather, the sheidim carried them. He answers that there are two distinct types of people
who travel on the road. There is one category of people
The answer seems to be that the Malach Hamaves who are called “holchei derech”, those who travel on the
came to Shlomo the second time in an attempt to break
road, which indicates that they have pure faith and
his spirit. He wanted him to feel guilty for sending the two
recognize that their travelling is all part of Hashem’s
men to the place of their demise.
Divine Providence. They realize that Hashem is leading
Shlomo recognized the Angel of Death’s intentions, them on a specific path for a very specific reason, and
and he countered his claim by declaring they travel on the path.
that a person’s feet lead him to where he
The second category of people are
is needed. He was saying that the fact that “ovrei derech”. They do not possess pure
they ended up in that particular place had “…Holchei
faith and cannot see the purpose for their
no connection to him. It was all decreed by
derech will not travels. They can only look at the travels as
Hashem, so even if he hadn’t told the a means to reach a destination. Therefore,
sheidim to take them there, they would be disturbed or they “pass by” the road, meaning they
have gone there on their own two feet.
Therefore, he had no reason to feel guilty. upset when walk by quickly and hurriedly towards a
destination, thinking that if they rush, they
In this vein, the Divrei Yisroel of faced with will get there faster. They fail to see that
Modzhitz zy”a (Parshas Beshalach) writes: “A everything has already been preordained,
obstacles on the and their hurrying is purposeless.
person must believe that there is no such
thing as coincidence in this world; rather, road. They know The difference between them is
everything occurs as part of Hashem’s
Divine Providence, and every small motion that everything “holchei derech” will not be disturbed or
upset when faced with obstacles on the
and gesture, including the number of steps was put there by road. They know that everything was put
a man takes, are decreed from Above. there by Hashem for their own ultimate
Even if one takes tens of thousands of Hashem for their
benefit and have no reason to lose their
steps, every one of them was done with
Hashgachah Pratis. This is as we recite in
own ultimate serenity and peace of mind. “Ovrei
derech”, however, will become upset
the bracha every day: ‘Hameichin m’tzaadei benefit and have whenever they encounter an obstacle
gaver.’ If one possesses this type of
no reason to because they think they are being delayed
emunah, he will be saved from depression from reaching their destination.
and anguish. If one believes that nothing
lose their
occurs in this world if it is not the will of For this reason, Rav Yossi was afraid
Hashem, he will never get angry, be upset, serenity and that “ovrei derech” might interrupt his
or entertain doubts.” prayers, but he was not concerned with
peace of mind. “holchei derech”. “Ovrei derech” would
›› Why Would Rav Chanina ben
Dosa’s Prayer Beat the Prayer of the Ovrei derech, interrupt him if they felt he was blocking
their way because they would see him as
Kohen Gadol on Yom Kippur? however, will an obstacle in their path. “Holchei derech”,
however, would understand that he was
The Gemara relates (Brachos 3A): “Rav become upset…” not an obstacle, as whatever is blocking
Yosi says, I was once walking along the
road, and I entered into one of the ruins of them is sent for their own benefit.
Jerusalem in order to pray. Eliyahu of This is also the explanation of the
blessed memory appeared and waited for me at the door Gemara that states (Taanis 24B): “Rav Chanina ben Dosa
until I finished my prayer. After I finished my prayer, he was traveling along a road when it began to rain. He said
said to me: ‘Peace be with you, my master!’ And I replied: before Hashem: Master of the Universe, the entire world
‘Peace be with you, my master and teacher!’ is comfortable, because they need rain, but Chanina is
“And he said to me: ‘My son, why did you go into this suffering, as he is getting rained on. The rain ceased... Rav
ruin?’ I replied: ‘To pray.’ He said to me: ‘You ought to Yosef said, in reaction to this story: What effect does the
have prayed on the road.’ I replied: ‘I feared lest ‘ovrei prayer of the Kohein Gadol have against that of Rav
derech’, passersby on the road, might interrupt me.’” Chanina ben Dosa?” His intent was that the Kohen Gadol’s
prayer that Hashem should not listen to the prayer of
The Sefer Ben Yehoyada asks why he used the term individual “ovrei derech” to withhold rain while they are
}{ב
traveling was disregarded in the case of Rav Chanina. ›› The Paradox of Free Will and Divine Providence
The Ben Yehoyada explains that the Kohen Gadol Rav Yoel of Satmar zt”l (Divrei Yoel, Maamar Bais, Siman 118)
prayed that the prayers of “ovrei derech” should not be expounds on the topic of Hashgachas Pratis. Based on the
heard by Hashem. Rav Chanina ben Dosa was, of course, Chovos Halevavos (Perek 3 of Shaar Habitachon), he explains
not on this low level of lacking emunah in Hashem. He was that Hashem has many lofty reasons for every decree He
a “holech derech”, and the Kohen Gadol certainly did not enacts. His plans are well beyond our comprehension, as
include people like him in his prayer. is stated (Yeshaya 55): “As the heavens are higher than the
earth, so are My ways higher than your ways and My
›› The Easiest Way to Avoid Getting Upset thoughts higher than your thoughts.” Therefore, all we
In the Haggadah shel Pesach, it is stated: “And he need to know is to recognize that everything is ordained
went down to Egypt, forced by words of Hashem (anus al by Him, and He has many reasons for everything He does.
pi hadibbur).” The Sefas Emes zt”l asks why it says that
Similarly to what we have stated, the Baal Shem Tov
Yaakov was forced to go to Egypt, as the pasuk says that zt”l explains the words “Hashem m’tzaadei gaver” by
after Yaakov discovered that Yosef was still alive, he
saying that when a person goes somewhere, he thinks he
willingly went down to Mitzrayim to see him (Bereishis is going for his personal reasons – i.e., to engage in
45:46). It was only after he declared that he wanted to go
business or for pleasure. However, the true reason
to Yosef to see him before he died that Hashem told him Hashem is taking him there may very well be for a
not to be afraid to go to Egypt. If so, why do we say that
completely different reason. He may need to perform a
he was forced to go?
tikkun in that place by learning some Torah there,
Rav Meshulim Dovid Soloveitchik zt”l answers this davening, or reciting a bracha.
question by saying that even when a person thinks he is
We can get a further level of understanding from the
doing something of his own free will, he is really being led
end of the verse: “For a person delights in his ways.” This
and guided by Hashem. Accordingly, the words of the can be understood to mean that if a person wants to go
Haggadah are teaching us that although it looked like somewhere in order to commit a sin, chas v’shalom, he
Yaakov Avinu was going to Mitzrayim of his own accord, has the ability to do so. Hashem gives a person free will
he really was forced to go there by Hashem.
and permits him to make wrong decisions. This is as
On this topic, Rav Moshe Feinstein zt”l once related to Chovos Halevavos states (Shaar Habechina, Perek 5): “Every
Rav Yaakov Moshe Shurkin zt”l that the Russian motion a person makes depends on the will of Hashem…
government once announced that for just one day, it except for the fact that He leaves it in a person’s hands to
would issue visas to anyone wishing to leave Russia. Rav decide whether he will do good or bad.”
Moshe woke up early to go to the place where they were
One certainly has free will. If one didn’t have the ability
issuing the visas. When he arrived, a long line had already to choose to do a mitzvah or to commit an aveirah, there
formed.
would be no concept of reward and punishment. Thus,
Even though it was the middle of winter, he stood in one must have bechirah.
that line in the severe Russian cold, waiting his turn from This concept is seen from the Gemara (Rosh Hashanah
5 in the morning until 11 at night. When there were only
34B): “It is a bigger mitzvah to be among those who sound
two more people ahead of him in line, the visa office the shofar than the mitzvah to be among those who
suddenly closed.
recite the blessings. How so? If there are two towns, in
Two days later, it became known that the government one there are those who know how to sound the shofar,
had sent anyone who had applied for a visa to Siberia. In and in the other there are individuals who know how to
this way, Rav Moshe was saved from a terrible fate. recite the blessings, one should go to the place where
they sound the shofar, and one should not go to the place
The Divrei Yechzekel of Stropkov zt”l (Parshas Vayeitzei) where they know how to recite the blessings.”
explains the words “hamechin m’tzaadei gaver” by saying
that if a person goes to his friend’s office to do a business While Hashem usually guides the steps of man and
deal and doesn’t find him there, he probably thinks that determines where he goes, in this case that is not so. In
he went there for nothing. He believes that he traveled a an instance where one has to choose to do the right thing
long way and gained nothing from it. according to halacha, the choice is his.
This is incorrect. The truth is that he didn’t go on his If, however, one desires to do the will of Hashem, but
own. Hashem planted the idea in his mind to go to his he doesn’t know which is the best path to take in order to
friend’s office, even though He knew he wouldn’t be do that, then He guides his steps. To this end, the pasuk
there and no deal would be made. Hashem is the one who states that “he delights in his ways”, meaning that when
guided his steps, but we don’t know the real reasons one desires to serve Hashem, He puts him on the right
behind it. path and takes him to the right place.
}{ג
