Horeini - English — Vayeru (2026-10-26)

Parashas Vayera, 5787 לעילוי נשמת מנחם מנדל בן יהושע דב בס”ד
Weekly Torah forum
to deepen halachic
and ideological
knowledge and
to strengthen the
mitzvah of kibbud
Issue no. 148 av va’eim
Dibros
Dibros Kodshecha
Kodshecha
Kibbud Av V’eim in the Parshah
Way of Life 1
In Sefer Yosher Hori, Rabbi Yosef Rappaport brings proof from the
Midrash on the Akeidah regarding an important halacha: even if a father
Behind the forgoes his honor, a child is still not permitted to cause him pain or strike
2
Scene him, and doing so remains a transgression. The Midrash :, which shows
how Yitzchak Avinu took great care to fulfill the mitzvah of honoring
In Our Fathers’ his father during the Akeidah: When Avraham sought to bind his son
Footsteps Yitzchak, he said to him: ‘Father, I’m young, and I fear that my body may
tremble from fear of the knife and cause you pain, and the slaughtering
may thereby be rendered invalid,’ Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer writes a slight
Toras Imecha variation on the wording: “Yitzchak said to his father Avraham: ‘Father,
please bind my hands and feet tightly because of the convulsions, so that
I do not accidentally compromise your honor. .’”
Mussar Avicha The Radal suggests that the correct reading may be “because of the
3
convulsions, coming from the term for kicking out the hands and feet
during spasms. Targum Yonasan translates: “that I should not convulse
V’heishiv Lev because of my pain” — meaning that due to his suffering, he might
reflexively kick out his leg and strike his father. This concept is also hinted
4
at in Tanna Devei Eliyahu Rabbah and Yalkut Shimoni. where the pasuk
“Honor your father” is fulfilled by Yitzchak when he allowed himself to
be bound like a lamb to the slaughter.
Bracha and Hatzlacha Tanna Devei Eliyahu Rabbah (ch. 27) offers a further chiddush: Yitzchak
Aaron ben Sharona said to his father Avraham: ‘Bind me well and place me upon the Mizbeach,
Zivug lest I sin against you and be found liable for two deaths before Hashem.”
Shoshana bas Elisheva Yitzchak feared two sins punishable by death: failing to honor his father
Refuah Shleima properly and invalidating the korban by striking a parent. Because of this,
Moshe ben Chana he was terrified that his convulsions might cause him to kick his father
Zera Shel Kayama
and incur a heavenly capital punishment.
Anonymous R’ Yosef Rappaport says all these Midrashim are difficult to understand.
Iluy Neshama
Yitzchak feared that the natural spasms following shechitah might cause
Menachem Mendel ben him to kick his father or inflict pain. Surely Avraham would have forgiven
Yehoshua Dov him, since he wanted to do the Akeida. From a halachic standpoint, no
forgiveness was required, as the convulsions were caused by Avraham’s
act of shechitah. Why was Yitzchak concerned that he would transgress
(continued on page 2..)
kibbud av and incur a heavenly death penalty? After waives his honor, earthly courts forgive the offense,
all, a father may forgo his honor. but before Hashem one remains liable to death.
This addresses the question: A father can only Yitzchak Avinu therefore feared he might kick his
forgive disrespect, not physical injury or pain. As father, knowing that his father’s forgiveness would
the Sefer Chassidim notes (par. 573), when a father not suffice in this case.
פרשת ואתחנן רמז תת״ל.4 .כההיא דחולין לז.3 , ובפרקי דר”א ל״א. ח׳, מדרש רבא פרשת וירא נ״ו.2 סימן ו’ עמוד קי”ח.1
Just as it is the duty of every Jew to learn the halachos applicable to
Way of Life everyday life, from berachos and Shabbos to shemiras halashon, so
is he obligated to learn and review the laws of kibbud av va’eim, a
Kibbud Av Va’eim in
constant and very serious mitzvah. Neglecting this study is liable to
Halachah and Minhag lead the person to unwittingly violate many halachos.
Based on the sefer Vayevarech David, by the illustrious Rabbi Yisrael David Harfenes, moreh
tzedek and rabbi of the Yisrael VeHazmanim Synagogue and Community, Williamsburg
1
Sitting in One’s Parents’ Place When They Are In the sefer Ohel Yaakov citing Meshiv Nevunim
Absent — Part I
(vol. 6), it explains that, if that intention existed at
One may not sit in his father’s seat in shul or beis the time of purchase, the seat is considered jointly
midrash, nor in his mother’s seat in the women’s designated for both father and sons. Even though
section—even when they are not present— the father was the primary purchaser, the sons may
unless they have waived their rights and granted use the seat whenever he is absent. Furthermore,
permission. The poskim debate whether this if he explicitly stipulated at purchase that they
prohibition applies to a seat reserved exclusively could use it in his absence, it is not considered his
for Shabbos, for weekdays only, for Shacharis but designated place at all, and they may sit there freely.
not Minchah and Maariv, or vice versa. (Siman 6, The halacha of “a designated seat” for one’s father or
p. 108) mother applies not only to a fixed place in shul, but
Some poskim maintain that if one’s father has a fixed also to a fixed seat in the car, as well as to a regular
place to daven only for Shacharis, but does not sit armchair at home, etc. Unless they explicitly say
there for Minchah and Maariv, the prohibition everyone may sit there whenever the parents are
against sitting in one’s father’s place still applies. absent, one must avoid sitting in their seat.
Rabbi Shalom Elyashiv z”l ruled accordingly.
However, if the father prays there only for Minchah
and Maariv, the son may sit in the seat when his
father is absent, as a fixed place for those prayers is When the Torah states, “So that your days
not considered a designated seat. In practice, Rabbi may be prolonged,” it is not simply a prom-
Azriel Auerbach said that it is preferable for the ise of reward. Rather, it tells a person: after
father to waive his right in such a case. (Notes of all, your own days will also be prolonged in
Rabbi Y. Shuv shlita) the land; you too will become a parent, and
If a father purchased a seat with the explicit intent you too will reach an age when you will need
that his sons could use it in his absence, this is your children. If you honor your father and
entirely permissible and does not constitute a mother, your children will likewise honor you
deficiency in honoring or revering one’s father. in your old age. (Abarbanel)
על שו"ע ר"מ הל' כיבוד אב ואם.1
Parashas Vayera, 5787 // Issue no.148 // pg 2
In Our Fathers’
Footsteps
True Stories of Kibbud Horim
One never distances oneself from
Father.
A man once came to see the Chozeh of Lublin. He asked for
a Bracha and went on to elaborate at length on how they
were related to get a warm bracha! The Chozeh of Lublin
replied dismissively, “It’s a distant relationship.” The man later
related these words to the great R’ Naftali Tzvi of Ropshitz,
who advised him to stand near the Chozeh of Lublin while
he said the chazaras ha-shatz. He advised him that when the
Chozeh of Lublin says, “אלוקי אברהם אלוקי יצחק ואלוקי יעקב,” he
should humbly whisper, “This is a distant relationship,” for Behind the Scene
we are removed from them by many generations; how, then,
can we ask that their merit protect us? A maamar Chazal or
The man followed Rabbi Naftali’s advice, and indeed, the halachah related to
Chozeh heard his words. After davening, he graciously kibbud av va’eim is
received the man. concealed in the picture. Send in
When the Brisker Rov heard this story, he very much the solution, and you’ll be entered
enjoyed it and added, “One is never distant from a father.” to win a prize!
A grandfather’s watchful eye protects his descendants across
the generations. Solutions may be sent by
email to: riddle@horeinu.org
I wish to hear Havdalah from Father. fax to: 077-602-1640
Rabbi David Heller of Lugano, Switzerland, shared the
following story: When the Belzer Rebbe, Rabbi Aharon,
arrived in Eretz Yisrael, the young Rabbi Meir Halevi—son
of Maran Rabbi Yitzchak Zev— went to greet him while
still single. The Rebbe had a custom to shake hands with
Solution to Behind the Scenes –
bearded men, while greeting clean-shaven youths with a Esav’s descendants fall only at the hands of Rachel’s
towel-wrapped hand. As the beardless young Rabbi Meir descendants.” This may be explained as follows:
Esav’s merit to endure across the generations
stepped forward, those nearby whispered to the Rebbe, stemmed entirely from the profound honor he
“This is the son of the Brisker Rav.” Hearing this, the Rebbe showed Yitzchak, just as Rachel’s descendants
merited survival because they never caused Yaakov
immediately removed the towel and shook his hand directly. pain. The Meshech Chochmah (Shemos 28:9) points
to a profound historical parallel: Every single one
One Shabbos, when the Belzer Rebbe, Rabbi Aharon, was of the Shevatim caused their father pain by selling
leading his Tish, the great Rabbi Meshulam Dovid Halevi Yosef, and Yosef himself did not tell his father where
he was. Only Binyamin remained entirely clear of
joined him. Although it was already Motzaei Shabbos, the causing any grief.
Rebbe was still eating shalos seudos. The raffle winners were informed of their win.
When the Rebbe was told that the son of the Brisker Rav had
come, he offered him a cup of wine. Since Rabbi Meshulam
Dovid Halevi never ate or drank after Shkiah, he explained
that he could not join the l’chaim, as he had already benched
but had not yet made Havdalah. The Rebbe responded, “Nu,
then make Havdalah right now over the cup of wine.” Rabbi
Meshulam Dovid replied, “I have the custom of hearing
Havdalah from Father.” Deeply impressed by this response
and by his dedication to hearing Havdalah specifically from
his father, the Rebbe said, “ זייער גלייך,“ — ”זייער גלייךVery proper,
very proper.”
( Facts and Practices of the House of Brisk, vol. 3, p. 200)
’ תנחומא האזינו סי’ ד.2 ירושלמי חגיגה פ”ב ה”א.1
Parashas Vayera, 5787 // Issue no.148 // pg 3
On a Personal Note
A heartfelt letter received by one of Horeinu’s
facilitators from a young woman navigating the
challenges of kibbud av va’eim
I’m sitting in my room, holding this notepad in I have come to realize one more truth. When
my hands... the one where I’m supposed to write I carry anger, only my own shoulders bear the
down something I appreciate about my father weight. My father goes on with his life, while
daily. But what am I supposed to appreciate about I’m left carrying extra weight in my heart. Yet
my father?! I’m writing this with a heavy heart... I whenever I manage—even for one minute—to
searched everywhere; I truly did. I sat for hours, offer a measure of respect, something inside me
struggling to find something, a single moment, settles. My breathing deepens, and my heart grows
an action, or even one word, I could lean on a little lighter. In my soul, I feel that bitterness
and say: For this I admire him; for this I honor only pulls me under, while honoring frees me.
him. Yet every time, there was nothing, only an Perhaps that is precisely why the mitzvah was
aching void. Not because I don’t want to find it, given this way: not for our parents, but for us!
but because it hurts too much. I do not honor my father because he has earned
My friends talk about their fathers as pillars of it. I honor him because it is Hashem’s will. After
strength; I listen, and I smile while something all, he gave me the gift of life. That does not
inside me tightens. No one teaches you how to mean the pain vanishes, nor does it mean I have
handle such struggles, or how to honor someone to pretend things are not the way they are. One
when your heart tells you otherwise. can show respect while holding the pain in that
Then I remember that the Torah did not write, very same heart. This is my choice. It doesn’t solve
“Honor your father and your mother only if everything, but it gives me strength to move on.
they are worthy of it.” The mitzvah was given
without conditions. When we stood at Har Sinai, To share your story, email:
office@horeinu.org
we received this mitzvah too among the Aseres
HaDibros, without any footnotes. I once thought
that was unfair. Today I understand it carries a
strong message for me: the Torah trusts I can
withstand this, even when it’s difficult.
There’s another factor I can’t ignore. I’m here. Get Horeinu
I can breathe, think, and feel, even if this pain Delivered to
is part of the life I was given. Our Chachamim
Your Inbox!
taught us that a father and mother partner with
Hashem in creating a child. Without my father, Horeinu’s weekly newsletter is
I would not be here. I cannot erase that, nor do available by email in English,
I want to. This is the first and most fundamental Hebrew, and Yiddish.
hakaras hatov a person has to have! One that
needs neither justification nor feelings. It is To join our email list, write to
us at: office@horeinu.org
simply the undeniable truth. (Please specify English, Hebrew or Yiddish).
Parashas Vayera, 5787 // Issue no.148 // pg 4
V’heishiv Lev
Questions and Answers from the
Desk of Rabbanim and Therapists
?
We eagerly look forward to Horeinu’s that encourages estrangement.
weekly newsletter, which continues This generation, so often mislabeled as
to inspire and uplift us week after undisciplined, finds its true strength in its
week! It is so important to strengthen this independence. With renewed awareness,
subject within our community, and b”h, people are starting to recognize the need
your efforts are bearing fruit; educators to reject advice to sever ties with parents,
across the community are becoming more reject this dangerous approach, and insist
aware of this important topic and the on fulfilling the mitzvah we accepted at
tremendous need for Chizuk and guidance. Har Sinai: “ — ”כבד את אביך ואת אמךHonor
Horeinu has become so firmly established your father and your mother.
that various publications now frequently
refer their readers to its newsletters. If this shift is to reach the therapeutic
world—stopping the unfortunate trend
I would like your guidance on finding a where professionals inadvertently drive a
good therapist. —one with Torah haskafos wedge between children and parents—we
who knows the halachos of kibbud av must first recognize a vital truth: honoring
va’eim. My eighteen-year-old daughter parents is a Mitza D’oraysa, and staying
has a very particular challenge in her connected to one’s roots is ultimately in
relationship with her mother. She feels the child’s best interest for his emotional
the current situation has become “very and spiritual well-being, while ensuring
unhealthy.” Until now, she has been very the child’s safety whenever necessary. The
respectful and faced her challenges with public must make a clear, unequivocal
remarkable courage. She is looking for a statement: We will not accept therapists
therapist or mentor who can teach her who foster estrangement in any form.
practical coping skills to help her heal. Only when the public makes this stance
clear from the outset, remains vigilant, and
>
Thank you for your kind words. B”h, resolutely rejects even a single session with
public awareness is growing, and we any therapist who creates distance from
are receiving wonderful feedback. parents, will we see real changes, bs”d.
Many young adults and adult children
are seeking guidance on how to honor
You can direct questions to Hore-
their parents through difficult times.
inu advisers
The question is always how to honor, via the email address appearing
never whether to honor. This is deeply on the last page.
inspiring; it shows that this generation Confidentiality guaranteed
seeks Torah clarity and truth and stands
firm against modern professional advice
Parashas Vayera, 5787 // Issue no.148 // pg 5
written by Y. Binyamin
Mendy shares a story about Tatty and Mommy
and the mitzvah of kibbud av va’eim
Three Eggs and One Cup of Sugar
Ima always seems to know where everything is, I tried to convince her that I had taken care of
whether it’s hunting for Leiby’s shoes after he’s it. I even reminded her that Mrs. Friedman had
turned the entire house upside down, or figuring wished me a Good Shabbos. But Ima had already
out which child left the bathroom light on when pulled eggs from the fridge and measured out a
everyone insists they haven’t touched the switch cup of sugar.
since Rosh Chodesh. Just then, Chani, Roni, and Leiby walked in.
But this week, I discovered Within moments, the family
that even Ima can forget. And started debating whether I
that realization cost me three had returned the eggs or
eggs and a cup of sugar. it was just my overactive
It all began on Thursday imagination. Chani suggested
afternoon. Ima was standing I might be mixed up; Roni
in the kitchen, baking a advised staying out of
chocolate cake for Shabbos. it, though returning the
I hovered nearby—mostly to ingredients anyway couldn’t
help lick the chocolate out of hurt; and Leiby wondered if
the mixing bowl—make sense, maybe the eggs had cracked
since one must be careful on the way down the stairs.
about bal tashchis, of course. It’s good to know that, in
Suddenly, Ima realized she times of need, I have only
was short of three eggs and one person I can count on
a cup of sugar. She asked myself!!
me to run down to the The truth is that I was a little
Friedmans to borrow the hurt. I’m nine years old, not
missing ingredients. The next two. I’m totally capable of
morning, Ima handed me remembering walking down
three eggs and a cup of sugar to return. I trotted a flight of stairs carrying three eggs and a cup of
back down, handed them to Mrs. Friedman, who sugar! If someone asked what I had for lunch on
wished me a warm “Good Shabbos,” and headed Friday, I might have to think twice. But three eggs
back upstairs. Until then, everything had been and a cup of sugar? That’s practically an historic
simple. The problem began on Monday. event.
Ima suddenly remembered she hadn’t returned I was about to explain exactly when I went and
the borrowed ingredients to the Friedmans. “But what the neighbor said, and maybe even invite Mrs.
Ima, I returned them on Friday!” I said, but Ima Friedman to testify before the family’s investigative
was convinced I was mixing up the trip I made to committee. But then I held myself back.
borrow them with the one I made to return them. I thought about my mother. She wasn’t trying to
(continued on page 7..)
Parashas Vayera, 5787 // Issue no.148 // pg 6
upset me. She had forgotten, and she wanted to asked if I had returned the borrowed ingredients,
make sure we didn’t owe the neighbors anything. If and I said yes. Ima looked relieved that it was all
I kept arguing with her in front of everyone, I might sorted out, thanked me, and we all went back to
prove I was right, but Ima would feel uncomfortable. what we had been doing.
So, I kept quiet, took the ingredients, and went No one applauded me. Chani didn’t admit she
downstairs. made a mistake. Roni didn’t retract his halachic
Mrs. Friedman opened the door and smiled when ruling. And Leiby didn’t apologize for suspecting I
she saw me. “Mendy, you already brought those had broken the eggs.
back on Friday!” she said. I explained that Ima just But that night, as I lay in bed, I thought of something
wanted to make sure we didn’t owe them anything. interesting.
Mrs. Friedman told me to tell Ima everything was I know that kibbud av va’eim means listening
fine—as far as she was concerned, we didn’t owe to one’s parents, speaking respectfully, and not
them anything! contradicting them. But this week I discovered
I ran back upstairs carrying the eggs and sugar. something deeper: sometimes honoring a parent
With every step, I pictured walking into the living means safeguarding their dignity, holding back
room and making a statement: “Well! I told you so!” from proving we were right, to avoid causing them
Honestly, it would have been a glorious moment, discomfort.
especially seeing Chani’s face. Leiby might have And that’s not easy. Sometimes it is far harder to
been impressed (even though you can never really bite your tongue and skip saying, “I told you so!”
know with him)/ than to give up your favorite snack—especially when
But then I thought: What for? So that Ima should you know you’re right and even have witnesses.
feel embarrassed for forgetting? The next morning, Ima thanked me again for my
I quietly slipped into the kitchen, put the eggs and help. I just smiled. She had no idea what I had given
sugar back where they belonged, then went to the up for her sake—but I knew. And that was enough.
living room, where everyone was hanging out. Ima
Partner with us in publishing the Horeinu newsletter >>
Quickpay/zelle
Email us Donate via our website dedications@horeinu.org.
at newsletter@horeinu.org pay.banquest.com/horeinu Specify “Weekly Newsletter” in the memo.
To receive the weekly newsletter via email, simply write “Add
me” in the subject line and send to newsletter@horeinu.org
Created by the Worldwide Horeinu organization. Our goal is to
spread awareness and help Klal Yisroel strengthen the mitzvah of
kibbud av va’eim with the guidance of gedolei Yisroel Registered
organization #580780617
We welcome your feedback! Email newsletter@horeinu.org or fax: 077-602-1640 for
opportunities to dedicate or sponsor an issue l’iluy nishmas or l’zechus a parent or a loved one,
or for a zechus for children, zivugim, refuah shleimah, and hatzlachah.
You can also send us your personal stories to help inspire others.
www.horeinu.com / REQUIRES GENIZAH /
