HAVINEINI - English — Chayei Sara (2026-11-02)

Issue
192
English
Shiurim of Harav Shimon Spitzer Chayei Sarah 5787 // Ye a r 3
Havineini
Weekly
Chovos HaLevavos Sha’ar HaBitachon #84 Part 1 Page 5
Bitachon
Weekly
Faith in the Face of Financial
Hardship
Thanking Hashem While How Can We Remain Calm? Torah that we learn in the study hall,
Burdened by Debt A frequently asked question was seeing the way things ought to be, and
a practical one: How can a person then there’s the hard reality of the
Feeling Serenity When the Bills remain calm when he doesn’t have way things are, chas v’shalom…. Then
Pile Up the money to repay debt that he we may begin to think that what the
owes? sefarim tell us is not so practical: “We’re
Previously, we spoke about the human, after all; we get angry sometimes;
necessity of serenity and yishuv hada’as For example, a Yid writes that it happens that we stumble.”
that a Yid must always have. The ba’al he lives in a rented apartment and
bitachon never loses his composure, simply doesn’t have the money to pay
the rent. The landlord is upset that But the truth is that we can fulfill
regardless of the circumstances. Even everything we learn in the Torah. This
if he’s in heavy debt and he knows several months have passed since he
was last paid, and the tenant owes him is not to say that it will be easy, and
that he must do everything within it doesn’t mean we will always be
the parameters of normalcy and a great deal of money! The situation is
not simple; the tenant simply doesn’t successful. But there is a way we can
reason—he nevertheless doesn’t do work to attain it.
anything impulsive or extreme. He have the money. He tries to scrape
doesn’t feel the need to turn over the together the rent money. Sometimes
world because “it’s the last minute.” He he succeeds, but often he does not.
A Calm Heart in a Sea of Debt
remains with the same serenity as The situation becomes more severe
always: doing what he can, being with every passing month, and he is There are many examples of people
joyful in the belief that Hashem threatened with eviction, R”l. How can who struggle with debt and financial
will help him. I remain calm under such circumstances, hardship. There are many people
he wonders. who remain with a mountain of debt
after marrying off a child, unable to
Following this, many people Every Word of Torah Can Be Ful- cover the following months’ expenses.
inquired about the debt and financial filled Then there are people with large
hardship that people experience, Parenthetically, it is important to grocery bills who are unable to afford
and we will endeavor to clarify this note that one of the greatest hazards everyday necessities. Others have high
sugya—how a Yid can remain calm and in learning Torah is when we feel that expenses that they cannot afford, all
serene even under such circumstances, a certain aspect of Torah is difficult to while their numerous creditors are
fulfilling his obligations both to apply in the real world. This thinking accosting them. How can a person
Hashem and to his fellow man. gives us the impression that there’s a remain calm in such a situation?
It should be noted that some the greatest sages were loggers, water second one is more philosophical:
people who remain calm under these carriers, and blacksmiths. These great Is it even moral to be calm when
circumstances are not calm because men engaged in coarse work only to one is withholding someone else’s
of their bitachon in Hashem, but avoid taking from others. money?
rather because they’re apathetic…
they don’t care. The real question is, These words provide us with a Yet others have asked, “What
how can we acquire the true serenity that fundamental outlook: A person must about the other person’s suffering?”
the Torah wants us to feel under these do everything to cover his expenses How can a person be calm when he
circumstances? on his own, meet his obligations to his sees his friend suffering because of
family and to those to whom he owes his delinquency? Sometimes they
Whatever It Takes money, and to fulfill the obligation he may even be friends and family from
undertook in the kesubah. There’s no whom he borrowed. They are now
Another Yid asked the question a
excuse for saying, “I will sit and wait worried and concerned. How can
bit differently: A well-known Chazal
until something respectable comes we remain calm in the face of their
(Pesachim 113a) states, פשוט נבילתא
my way.” This isn’t how it works. suffering?
בשוקא ואל תצטרך לבריות, one should skin
an animal carcass in the streets rather
than rely on others. Bitachon on Someone Else’s Ac- Yissurim Are Always for
count? the Good
When it comes to providing for The questioner added: If a person Clarity Comes First
our families, Chazal tell us not to feel is obligated to skin a carcass in the
A primary reason people become
so self-important… do what we must streets rather than rely on others, how
sad and broken when experiencing a
do! Even if we have always dreamed much more must he do to repay the
challenge stems from a lack of clarity
of having a prominent position; debts that he already owes? Surely, he
about what Hashem expects of us in
we thought we would earn a nice, must do everything in his power to
the moment and what the right thing
respectable income; we thought repay his debts!
to do is in that moment.
people would throw money at us….
These were all dreams. The reality is The pasuk tells us לוה רשע ולא ישלם,
This is why we are taught אין שמחה
that if we do not have money to pay the wicked person borrows and does not
כהתרת הספיקות, there is no joy like
our bills, we must take whatever work repay… (Tehillim 37:21). This means
resolving doubts. Because doubt brings
comes our way, even if we consider it that a borrower who does not collect
sadness and melancholy, and the
beneath our dignity. for himself in shuls is considered a
resolution of those doubts brings joy.
ba’al aveirah, a wrongdoer, for failing
This means that a person must do to pay his debts. Essentially, this
People tend to become confused
everything in his power not to rely on question expresses the sentiment that
and sad when in debt to others. There
others, but rather to cover his own when a person is in debt, it isn’t the
is the humiliation and the uncertainty
expenses. Every person is obligated to time to rely on emunah and bitachon
about whether they can or should do
provide for his family’s needs. concerning his financial obligations,
more… all these feelings are raging
but rather to take concrete action.
inside the nefesh, creating even more
Don’t Sit and Wait When it comes to someone else’s
confusion and uncertainty. And this
money, one must work sixteen hours
The Rambam uses an even stronger is something we must explore.
a day—if necessary—to repay him.
expression: A person should always
exert himself, struggle through The truth is that this phenomenon
hardship, and not become Serenity in the Face of Suffering? does not apply only to people in debt
dependent on others or cast Thus, there are two fundamental but to many other situations people
himself upon the community. We questions regarding the obligation face as well. When a person takes a
must do everything in our power to be serene: The first is a practical ribbing from his friend, he may be
not to rely on handouts, even taking one: How can we expect a person confused: Did I really deserve that? Is
on an undignified occupation. The to be calm and serene in the face there truth to what he’s saying? Should I
Rambam even points out that among of so much pressure? And the feel bad about what he said?
2 Havineini // Parshas Chayei Sarah
The Pain of Debt and the Power How can I give thanks for yissurim that I The mercy and love the Ribbono
of Acceptance brought upon myself? shel Olam have for a Yid who has
Let us thus compartmentalize the sinned are more than anything we
situation of a person in debt. One Imagine what would happen if this can fathom. Sometimes, we see a
aspect is the doubt whether this person’s creditor heard him giving holy and refined Yid suffering with a
person was correct to place himself thanks for this suffering. “This man problem, and we are aroused to have
into debt. Perhaps he squandered his took his entire family on a lavish rachmanus on them. But Hashem has
money in other places, or used his vacation! He squandered the money far more rachmanus—and it is because
money in ways he shouldn’t have. This I lent him. He made foolish and of this very mercy and compassion
is one question. reckless investments. And now, when that Hashem sends yissurim to cleanse
it’s time to foot the bill and he’s being a person. Yissurim are good for us, and
Then there is another aspect: This yelled at, he remains calm and thanks we must give thanks for them—even
borrower is now experiencing Hashem for the fact that I’m shouting if they came due to our sins.
suffering and pain. He feels pain at him….”
when his creditor accosts him in
This person himself may think, I The Great Purpose of
public. He feels pain because others
know I was wrong. I caused this situation Suffering
are suffering because of him. He feels
humiliation when people talk about with my own two hands. I relied upon my Pain Brings Purification
him behind his back. And he is also own wisdom and might in making these
impulsive investments. Now I see how There are two opinions in the
pained by the uncertainty and doubt Rishonim as to why yissurim are good
regarding what Hashem wants from foolish I was. How can I thank Hashem
for this?! for us:
him.
We Are Always Somewhat at Fault The first is the response of
A Yid who finds himself in debt
The answer is that, of course, it Rabbeinu Yonah, who writes that
is experiencing yissurim. These
is right to thank Hashem even for yissurim are good for us because they
yissurim are no different from any
this type of suffering—and it is no atone for and erase our sins, and for
other form of yissurim that we must
different from any other form of this we must give thanks. The pain
accept with love. The Ribbono shel
accepting suffering. Chazal tell us אין brings tremendous purification.
Olam ordained that every form of
יסורים בלא עון, there’s no suffering without When a person is humiliated and he
suffering a person endures is a
sin (Shabbos 55a). Yes, there is the accepts that humiliation with love
tremendous goodness for him—so
exception of יסורים של אהבה, yissurim and humility, it erases the foolishness
much so that “one is obligated to give
that Hashem sends purely out of love. of the past.
thanks for the bad just as he must
give thanks for the good.” Ribbono shel But in the majority of cases, yissurim
are rooted in the sins that a person Furthermore, when a person
Olam! Thank You for the embarrassment,
has committed, as we learn from the internalizes the idea that his own
for the confusion, for the pain, and for the
Gemara (Berachos 5a) stating that if deeds caused his yissurim, this creates
lack of serenity in my life!
a person sees suffering coming upon in him a deep sense of regret, which,
him, he should make a reckoning of in turn, is a fundamental aspect of
It doesn’t matter how and in what
his deeds, and if he finds nothing, he teshuvah. This deep regret will cause
way the yissurim came to him or what
should attribute the yissurim to bittul him to abandon his old ways, and this
form they took. The first thing he
Torah. itself atones—because he now feels
must do is to thank Hashem for the
terrible pain and regret for what he
yissurim.
And this is no contradiction! Even did.
if a person finds that his yissurim came
Even If We Are at Fault?! because of his own actions, he must Thus, a person can rightfully give
One may wonder, of course, we’re still accept them with love and give thanks for the yissurim, even if he has
obligated to give thanks when yissurim thanks to Hashem for them—because brought them upon himself. The very
are ordained for us from above. But in this Hashem loves a Yid just as much after fact that they hurt him is the greatest
case, maybe I brought them upon myself? he has sinned as before he has sinned. goodness for him. The yissurim erase
Havineini // Parshas Chayei Sarah
3
his aveiros, and soon the resulting person approaches the sugya of debt we must repair it. But this calculation
pain will be removed as well. with the right attitude, he can truly can be made only after we have
become transformed. There are Yidden strengthened ourselves, and we are
In The End, It Will Be Good who have struggled greatly with their joyful and at peace with our situation.
In addition to the mehalech of debt; they endured great humiliation
Rabbeinu Yonah, there’s the opinion of as a result, and everyone looked at
But, as noted, yissurim resulting
the Rambam in Peirush HaMishnayos. them as failures. But they toiled in the
from debt are no different from
There he writes (Berachos 9:5) that one Chovos HaLevavos and thus they were
any other form of yissurim we must
must give thanks for the bad just as he transformed completely. They grew so
embrace. There are yissurim which are
gives thanks for the good, because one much because of these yissurim.
more readily recognized as of heavenly
never knows how it will end. making, and there are those that are
A Yid told me that he has, baruch
apparently of human making. But
Even if a person finds himself Hashem, been able to clear his debt,
the rules of accepting and embracing
currently in a situation which seems but he doesn’t feel that he is growing
yissurim remain the same: We must
terrible for him—he’s being accosted spiritually as he did when he was
give thanks for them, and later we
and persecuted… he gains a reputation weighed down by debt. Back then,
must make a personal reckoning.
as a delinquent, and his situation is he grew internally because of his
only spiraling downward—he can situation!
still never know how things will Clarity Brings Calm
turn out in the end. Everything has a It is difficult to describe how much
beginning and a continuation. What good we can see and feel as a result Thus, we can answer the question
he is experiencing in the moment may of the yissurim we incur from being in originally posed: How can we
be the very catalyst for the good that debt—if only we accept this suffering reasonably expect a person to be calm
is to come. Many things seem good in with love, and we understand that we even as he finds himself heavily in
the beginning, only to turn out very are being cleansed of our sins in the debt?
differently with time, and conversely, process.
many things seem terrible right now,
The answer is: If a Yid does what
but they contain much ultimate good. Recognizing That Everything Is for
the Good Chazal ask of him when yissurim
come to him, he can indeed be
If so, a Yid can certainly give We call the pain a person endures
calm. Such a person understands
thanks to Hashem—even if he is in when in debt “yissurim”! And we
that the yissurim have a purpose: The
great debt, because there is hidden must accept these yissurim with
pain purifies him; the humiliation
good in this situation that will benefit love. The first step is to give thanks
accomplishes something big for
him greatly in due time. for the pain, and within this lies the
him. Recognizing this calms him
understanding that it is Hashem Who
and enables him to do teshuvah with
How Debt Can Become a Path to has designed it, and it is Hashem Who is
serenity.
Great Spiritual Growth running my life—עשה ועושה ויעשה לכל
When we learn this Rambam, we המעשים. It’s not because of this person,
may ask: What good can possibly come and it isn’t because of myself, either. Most of us have already experienced
out of this situation? The answer is that The Ribbono shel Olam led me here, the taste of embracing pain with love.
many good things can indeed come and everything that happened needed to We have likely experienced the state
from it; most importantly, kirvas happen. The Ribbono shel Olam does only of remaining joyful and thanking
Elokim! what is best for me. I am enduring this Hashem for suffering. We already
challenge because Hashem has designed it know what this is. We must apply this
Aside from the atonement and for me, and I thank Him for this. experience to when we are in debt
purification that a person gains and experiencing pain as a result, and
from his yissurim, he will gain a In addition, there is the aspect of we must remember that these are also
renewed closeness to Hashem and making a reckoning of our deeds. If yissurim that must be embraced with
new humility before Hashem. If a we did something we should not have, love.
4 Havineini // Parshas Chayei Sarah
Havineini
Weekly
פרשת חיי שרה The Torah Attitude to Shidduchim
Tefillah and Efforts That Chase The Torah Perspective on a Delay in has created the entire world and He
Away Negative Forces Shefah continues to give it life at every moment.
What difficulty would there be for Him
Drawing Down Shefah We know that when there is, chas to split the sea? The difficulty was due
v’shalom, a blockage in the shefah— to the מקטרגים, the Prosecutors, who
This parashah discusses the incredibly something that prevents it from complained that הללו עובדי עבודה זרה
important issue of shidduchim, and this coming down to us—it means that the והללו עובדי ע"ז, they [the Egyptians]
is an opportune time to see what we Heavenly prosecutors are standing worship false idols, and they [the
can do to help the matzav…. Yiddishe in the way and are blocking the Jewish People] worship false idols—
kinder need great yeshu’os. Thus, we shefah or otherwise preventing it there is no difference between them.
must look to Chazal for insights, eitzos, from coming down. Therefore, when The מקטרגיםsought to stymie the
and understanding that will illuminate a person engages in Torah, tefillah, and shefah, the yeshuah, and hence it was
this sensitive topic that is so close to all mitzvos—the three pillars that bring “difficult” to split the sea.
our hearts. shefah to the world—and the shefah
still doesn’t arrive, he can conclude that The same takes place when it comes
One of the yesodos we know is he isn’t properly carrying out his Torah, to shidduchim—when two neshamos
that when it comes to drawing down tefillah, and mitzvos, and the מקטרגים attempt to come together, to find each
a yeshuah—every yeshuah comes are able to interfere with his shefah, other and create a tremendous yichud,
from Above. A yeshuah doesn’t come R”l. This is how a Yid views the matter. a holy union, a kiddush Hashem, and the
simply because a person decided that it fulfillment of the purpose of creation.
should occur. This is because a yeshuah He doesn’t attribute it to a lack Since it involves a shefah of great benefit
is a matter of shefah—and shefah of wisdom or talent, and he doesn’t to the Shechinah, the מקטרגיםhave every
comes only from Above. However, ascribe the delay in shidduchim to the interest in thwarting it.
no shefah can come from Above fact that he doesn’t have enough money
without first being aroused by us to promise to a prospective chassan or The event of קריעת ים סוףwas the
below. Therefore, in order to draw to the fact that someone gave negative greatest kiddush Hashem through which
down shefah, we must first engage in information. He ignores all this noise— the entire world saw the wonders of
a spiritual arousal of that shefah, such for they are not the true reasons for Hashem and spoke about it. It brought
as learning Torah, reciting tefillah, or the delay in the shefah. These reasons Klal Yisrael to a level of prophecy of זה
performing a mitzvah action. may sometimes be the outer levush for לי ואנוהו-א, to be able to literally point to
the blockage in shefah. But the true Hashem… and this is why the קטרוגwas
As it relates to shidduchim, the reason for the hindrance in shefah so strong. The same occurs regarding
action of the mitzvah is to engage in the is the מקטרגיםwho prevent it from shidduchim.
parashah of shidduchim and assist people coming down.
in finding their zivug. The Gemara tells Battling the “Other Side” for Shiddu-
us (Shabbos 31a) that one of the questions Like the Splitting of the Yam Suf chim
a person will be asked when he comes
before the Heavenly Court is, “Did you Chazal discuss this concept A person must look at this matter
engage in ”?פריה ורביהMaharsha (ibid.) extensively, stating that every time as a great battle between the side
explains that this refers to shidduchim; it comes to making a shidduch, the of kedushah and the side of the Sitra
that is, whether a person engaged מקטרגיםhave a special interest in Achara. The side of kedushah wishes
in making shidduchim. And through thwarting it. Chazal (Sotah 2a) tell to make more shidduchim, to establish
engagement in this mitzvah, a person us, קשה זיווגו של אדם כקריעת ים סוף, the new homes in Klal Yisrael—as Chazal
is mevatel himself to the Ribbono shel zivug of a person is as difficult as liken the building of a Jewish home to
Olam who commanded us to do this the splitting of the Yam Suf. Now, rebuilding the ruins of Yerushalayim.
mitzvah—and he thereby arouses shefah the actual splitting of the sea could not We see from this that there is great
from Above. have been difficult for Hashem, for He השראת השכינהin a Jewish home; thus, it
Havineini // Parshas Chayei Sarah
5
is no wonder that the Sitra Achara does וחנתי את אשר אחן ורחמתי את אשר ארח, I
ם unworthy, the tefillos will be accepted
everything in its power to prevent it. shall show favor when I choose to (and now we will explain why).
show favor, and I shall show mercy
So, what is the eitzah? The eitzah when I choose to show mercy. Davening for Someone Else Chases
is to engage in those things that Chazal tell us (Berachos 7b) that Away the Prosecutors
bring shefah—as mentioned above—to Hashem will show favor and mercy
engage in actions of chessed, tefillah, even to those who aren’t worthy—such In his sefer Imrei Aish, Rav Shmuel
and toil in Torah. The truth is that is the middah of חנון ורחוםto which Eliyahu of Modzitz quotes his
just as people engage in shidduchim to the pasuk refers. (The חנוןexpression grandfather, Rebbe Yechezkel of
help people find their zivug, and just as of Hashem’s kindness is one that goes Kuzmir, who explained why it is that
we understand that tefillah hastens the beyond chessed and rachamim. We when davening for another person,
yeshuah—so too, people should open invoke it over and over, in Selichos and he is answered first. “It is because,
kollelim in which the zechus of the in the Kedushah of Kesser, because when a person davens for himself,
learning will go towards those in need this middah grants favor and mercy there are many מקטרגיםwho seek to
of shidduchim! This is pashut. The even to those who don’t deserve it.) thwart his tefillah.”
Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh and other
sefarim teach us that the more Torah, Says the Tiferes Shlomo: From this We have already learned in the past
the more shefah. Gemara we can infer that Hashem will a famous segment of Me’or Einayim
show favor and answer the tefillos of (Parashas Va’eschanan) containing many
Davening for One Another important yesodos in bitachon and in
one who davens for his fellow, even
if he isn’t worthy—and Hashem will Yiddishkeit. In it, the Me’or Einayim
Now, let us direct our attention to explains that when a person davens,
show mercy towards the one who is
a specific aspect of shidduchim. After he is in essence asking for the shefah
being davened for, even if he isn’t
one engages in the chessed aspect—to to come down to This World from
worthy. There is a special provision
redt and suggest shidduchim without Above. Now, how can such a great
for being heard when davening for
hesitation or embarrassment—and light—the shefah from the Ribbono shel
someone else.
after one engages in tefillah, if we see Olam—come down to our lowly world?
that the yeshuah doesn’t arrive… what Davening for Others Invokes Mercy Only through the process of —צמצום
can we do to weaken the power of contraction or constriction of Hashem’s
the מקטרגיםwho block the tefillos In general, when a person davens light. In order to effect צמצום, we must
and chessed activities for shidduchim? for himself, he may be told, “Who are arouse the מידת הדין, and thus through
After all, we see that, unfortunately, you to even daven before Hashem?” our davening for shefah, we are also
they have some success in this! It is Every time a person davens, he needs arousing the מידת הדין. Therefore,
so painful to see people struggle with siyatta diShmaya to chase away the whenever a person davens, he is in
shidduchim, and we have no choice מקטרגים. We see this from the fact need of siyatta diShmaya that the shefah
but to do everything in our power to that every time we daven, we invest so shouldn’t be stolen by מקטרגים.
weaken the מקטרגים. much avodah into the section of פסוקי
דזמרהin order to cut away the מקטרגים. Who Are These Prosecutors?
And so, there’s a well-known yesod,
a great yesod, but it must be properly
The Beis Aharon of Karlin teaches When we say that there are מקטרגים
understood. Everyone knows the
similarly (Parashas Chayei Sarah) who seek to rob and thwart the tefillos,
Chazal (Bava Kamma 92a) כל המבקש
that we repeat the pesukim of the it means simply—as Chazal have
רחמים על חבירו והוא צריך לאותו דבר הוא נענה
ketores after davening is to once again explained—that the forces of the klipah
תחילה, one who davens for a friend, and
chase away the —מקטרגיםfor it is after come with complaints that a person
he needs that very same thing, he will be
davening that we receive the shefah, did such-and-such and so-and-so… and
answered first—and the Gemara cites
and we need extra protection so that thereby they seek to rob him of the
two sources for this.
they shouldn’t be able to steal it. shefah. These מקטרגיםare aligned both
against the person who davens—so that
When You’re Out of the Picture Explains the Tiferes Shlomo: When his tefillah shouldn’t be accepted—as
Showing Favor to the Unworthy a person davens for his fellow, even if well against the person in need of the
he himself is unworthy, his tefillah will shefah, so that it shouldn’t come to him.
To understand the depth of this nevertheless be accepted—for Hashem
concept, let us learn the holy words says וחנתי את אשר אחן ורחמתי את However, when one person davens
of the Tiferes Shlomo (Parashas Ki ;אשר ארחםwhen you’re davening for for another person, such a kitrug
Sisa) on the pasuk (Shemos 33:19) someone else, even if both of you are does not exist—because there is no
6 Havineini // Parshas Chayei Sarah
one to complain about. The person who and preferable is because a person takes primarily himself, he invites a certain
is davening is not the one in need of the himself out of it… he doesn’t insist on level of judgment and scrutiny to see
shefah, and the one in need of the shefah this shefah coming to him. The more a whether he is worthy of what he is
is not the one who is davening… thus, person places himself and his needs requesting.
kitrug wouldn’t stick in any case. When and desires into his tefillos, the harder
a person davens for himself, however, it is for the shefah to reach him. Thus, Taking Ourselves Out of the Picture
they say to him, “You want shefah, you as noted, tefillos on behalf of another Saves Us from the Prosecutors
want a shidduch, you want money… let’s person will be much more effective.
see if you’re worthy.” And in this way,
the מקטרגיםare awakened. When We Mean Ourselves Let us take an example from life. A
person is waiting for a certain detail
This, explained the Kuzmirer People aren’t used to hearing such in his life to fall into place. He does
Rebbe, is the superiority and words, but this is what the sefarim teach everything he can… he davens, he visits
preference of davening for others as us—and we can all gain by hearing it. kivrei tzaddikim…and yet he waits for
opposed to davening for ourselves. We will explain the concept with the the yeshuah to arrive. Now, in general,
following mashal: when we daven, we’re focused solely
Targeting Our Tefillos on the yeshuah that we want—and
A person approaches a yeshivah’s we daven for our interest. And while
We will explain a bit deeper—for we committee with an overarching the Ribbono shel Olam is a merciful
aren’t talking here about a mere segulah proposal to change the curriculum in Father, there are other calculations that
or a cute vort, but about a major yesod: the yeshivah. He comes with details come into play. If a person has aveiros,
When the tefillah of a person is of and charts, and photographs of other chas v’shalom, the Ribbono shel Olam
a high caliber, the way it should be, yeshivos that have already implemented may help him cleanse his neshamah
there is no doubt that it will bring it, and he provides a truly convincing from them through these yissurim.
shefah to the person. But it is not presentation explaining why this
simple for a person to attain a level change will benefit the bachurim in the It’s not that HaKadosh Baruch Hu
where his tefillah is perfect. yeshivah and change their lives forever. says, “Ah… you’re focused on yourself?
The committee hears him out, and they I will reject your request based on that.
When a person davens, and all his deliberate. They are convinced by what I don’t care about you….” Of course, we
energies in tefillah are invested for him he said, but then they find out one retain all the rules that our mothers
to achieve the thing that he wants, that more detail: the curriculum and the and grandmothers taught us about
alone arouses the —מקטרגיםfor they program he is advocating was authored how Hashem listens to our tefillos—
will say that he’s unworthy. He won’t by him, and implementing it requires a they’re all true. However, many times,
necessarily be denied his request, but set amount of money every month. it is for the ultimate good of the person
the מקטרגיםwill cause the conduits
that his wish not be granted, that he
to be constricted. They will say, “You Understandably, this changes the should have to wait a bit for what he
want to have this or that… what entire picture. wants. You want your personal good?
makes you so sure that you’re
B’seder. This is for your good!
worthy of it?” And the moment a This person is not a liar, and he
person is judged, the matzav is already isn’t dishonest. He didn’t necessarily
not simple…and we need great siyatta misrepresent the case. But the picture is However, the moment that a person
diShmaya in order for the shefah to entirely changed once we know that he takes himself completely out of the
reach us. The less a person dedicates has a vested interest in the program— picture (we know that this is difficult
his tefillos to insisting on the things he and they will now take what he said to impossible, but suppose we could
wants, the power of the מקטרגיםwill with a grain of salt. press a button and all of our biases
be diminished. and personal interests would vanish),
Similarly, when a person approaches then he would daven solely for kevod
We know from the sefarim hakedoshim the Ribbono shel Olam with his tefillah, Shamayim, without any personal
that when a person davens for the with the proposal that he should interest. He would say, “For my part,
sake of the Shechinah—that It should receive this shefah… he says, “It will be I don’t care what happens to me,
be spared from pain—his tefillos are such a tremendous kevod Shamayim, but I am asking for salvation for the
far more potent. The problem is, in it will help bring the Shechinah to Shechinah’s sake.” In such a case, there
most cases we aren’t on the level to feel This World, it will be good for all is no place for any judgment against
the pain of the Shechinah enough. The of us… and it will even hasten the the person—because he’s not in the
reason that such a tefillah is more potent redemption.” If this person means picture.
Havineini // Parshas Chayei Sarah
7
How to Gain Hashem’s Favor Davening with Someone Else in Mind Then there’s a person who approaches
Despite Our Unworthiness with a position of “I may deserve pain,
And this is the point of כל המתפלל and I am not asking due to my pain…
The Attribute of “Chanun” …בעד חבירוone who davens for someone but I am a child of Avraham, Yitzchak,
else and is in need of the same thing will and Yaakov.” This person is taking
be answered first. For when one davens another course; arousing zechus Avos.
Now let us return to the words of for his fellow, there is no place for
the Tiferes Shlomo we learned above. מקטרגים, because he opens a different Opening the Heavenly Chambers
The Ribbono shel Olam has many conduit—the conduit of —חנוןsince
modes of conduct. There’s the conduct his tefillah is of another caliber. It is These attitudes in our tefillos and
of chessed and there’s the conduct of din. about another person. petitions to Hashem aren’t only a matter
There’s an attribute of rachamim, and of what we say—but our thoughts,
there’s a trait of chanun—which dictates Similarly, the Kedushas Levi (Rosh attitudes, and avodah are really the
that a person should receive shefah Hashanah) teaches that when a determining factor in which Heavenly
despite his unworthiness. This is not person davens, he should never daven conduct we will arouse, and which
a contradiction to the person having with the feeling that he is worthy Heichal, which Heavenly Chamber we
aveiros, and it doesn’t contradict the fact and deserving—he shouldn’t even will enter. Whichever chamber he opens
that HaKadosh Baruch Hu is not a ותרן, think about his mitzvos and positive in his heart—through the thoughts and
he doesn’t simply wave away aveiros. attributes—rather, he should speak attitudes in his tefillah—is the heichal
It is simply that in this instance, the with Hashem and say, “I am nobody. I that he will be able to access Above. We
Ribbono shel Olam conducts himself don’t deserve anything… but You are a must keep this in mind.
with the trait of חנון, looking away חנון.”
from the negative, because the person And there are many Heavenly
davening has aroused that conduct. The The explanation is: If you’re
Chambers that a person can open in his
question is which conduit a person approaching with a sense of being
heart. He can open the chamber of joy
opened… and which key did he use deserving, you will be judged on
when he contemplates the goodness of
to open it. whether you are truly deserving. But
Hashem…. He may open the chambers
if you come with the understanding
of Heavenly mercy, and he may access
and the attitude that the Ribbono
the chamber of zechus Avos, as we have
Now, usually, when a person davens, shel Olam is a חנון, the prosecutors
just explained.
he knows the truth that he is davening don’t check whether you’re
with himself in mind. Nevertheless, deserving, because you didn’t come
And when Chazal said that one who
he must daven—because this is what with the attitude of being deserving.
davens for others is answered first… it
we’re commanded to do. It is a mitzvah
Arousing Heavenly Conduct is because he has opened a new and
d’Oraisa to daven when we’re in need.
unique Heavenly Chamber.
It is not our intention, chas v’shalom,
to say that if a person thinks about When a person davens before
Opening the Chamber in Which They
his own needs during his davening, he Hashem, the question always is, Do Not Judge
shouldn’t even bother davening, because “Where are you coming from?” This
the Ribbono shel Olam will reject his will determine how the tefillah will
tefillos. Chas v’shalom! be viewed On High, and which The Tiferes Shlomo tells us: When
Heavenly conduct he will arouse. a person davens for himself, he arouses
Heavenly conduct of one sort, and when
But he must understand that—when If he comes with the attitude that he davens for his fellow, he arouses
davening for his tzarah—it is possible to he’s entitled, that’s the lowest level— Heavenly conduct of another sort—
daven on a higher level. A person must for they will then open the books וחנותי את אשר אחון, I shall show favor
stop and think, “How can I make my to determine whether he’s indeed when I choose to show favor. It is a
tefillah about more than my personal worthy… and this will not be very different mode of Heavenly behavior
interests and needs?” He will elevate optimal for him. entirely. The chamber that is opened
his tefillah, and it will become a better in Shamayim when a person davens for
tefillah, and when his tefillah is more If he comes from a place of deep his fellow is one in which they don’t
elevated, it opens the conduit of חנון, pain, he is appealing to the attribute of examine the person’s worthiness—
and thus, he will be answered even if he Heavenly mercy, simple rachmanus— because he didn’t approach out of a
isn’t worthy. that’s one way to approach. sense of worthiness.
8 Havineini // Parshas Chayei Sarah
You have a connection to that the pasuk ויעתר יצחק לה' לנוכח אשתו Davening for Your Friend’s Son and
person, because you’re both Yidden. 'כי עקרה היא ויעתר לו ה, and Yitzchak the Pain of the Shechinah
His pain is your pain. And when a entreated Hashem opposite his
person feels the pain of another Yid, wife because she was barren and
it is the closest he can come to the Hashem allowed himself to be As said, when someone davens
level of feeling the Shechinah’s pain. entreated by him. Yitzchak and for his fellow, the potency of his
When a person feels his own pain, it Rivkah each stood in a separate tefillah his much greater, because
means that he simply wants very much corner and davened to Hashem. it is a different sort of tefillah.
to be comfortable. However, when he Yitzchak said, “Ribbono shel And this strongly applies to the
feels the pain of another person—it is Olam! The children that You give issue of nachas from children, so
coming from the same source as feeling me should be from this tzaddekes,” that a person should merit to see
the pain of the Shechinah. A Yid is in and Rivkah said, “The children that his children go on the proper path.
pain… how can I go on as if nothing You give me should be from this Usually, when a person is tested in
happened?! This is a wonderful and tzaddik.” this regard, it’s a very challenging
proper Yiddishe emotion—and when nisayon, and he becomes very
a person davens from such a feeling, pained and embarrassed. His tefillos
he opens a new chamber On High, Perhaps they each foresaw with for his child will be generally be
a chamber in which the מקטרגים ruach hakodesh that they would centered on his own pain and on
cannot be effective. eventually merit children, and they his thoughts about the future of his
davened that the children would come generations. It’s very difficult to
Elevate Your Tefillah from this marriage. This is the Torah’s think about anything but his pain
guidance in this matter. Here they and embarrassment… but this is a
And it’s not only tefillah that is so were, struggling with the terrible pain shame, because the more his tefillos
much more elevated when we daven of childlessness, and this was their will be focused on the Ribbono
for another person rather than for approach: each davened in the merit of shel Olam, the more effective they
ourselves. When we learn Torah as a the other. will be.
zechus for another person, or when we
engage in acts of kindness for another It is easy to fool ourselves in this
person solely because we feel their An Unknown Ailment regard. A person will say, “What?! It
pain—we likewise open these exalted seems to you that I mean myself?! I am
chambers On High. pained over the chillul Shabbos… I can’t
A powerful story that illustrates the
power of davening for another: stand to see a person desecrating the
When a shadchan works on
holy Shabbos in my own home! I mean
shidduchim for his fellow Yidden, not
the Ribbono shel Olam! After all, I am
for the money, but because their pain
The Sfas Emes of Gur left This not asking for money. I am asking for
is his pain (and we can see their pure
World at the age of 56, following my child to be an ehrliche Yid and to
intentions from their conduct and
an illness that was unknown to the establish a Yiddishe home.”
attitudes), these actions have the power
doctors; they didn’t know how to treat
to overcome the מקטרגיםand bring
it. Following this, the Avnei Nezer
about the shefah in its completeness But this isn’t entirely true, for if
of Sochachov, a friend of the Gerer
and entirety. you truly meant kevod Shamayim,
Rebbe, explained. “In his capacity as
you can daven for your friend’s son
As said, it is dependent on the a rebbe of thousands of chassidim,
just as well. To Hashem it doesn’t
heart, which controls the actions— the Rebbe saw hundreds of people
matter which child you’re davening
enabling the mitzvah to be done with every day. So many of them confided
for.
completeness and with pure intentions. to him about their illnesses, sicknesses,
and ailments—and the Rebbe surely
davened on their behalf. Since he Chazal give us an eitzah: Take
The Incredible Power of Daven-
had davened for all these illnesses, your pain—because it is so deep—
ing for Others he could no longer be stricken with and daven for the pain of the
Yitzchak and Rivkah Davened for Each those illnesses. It had to be a sickness Shechinah. And because it is
Other that wasn’t common…that no one ever difficult to focus on Hashem
heard of… and thus, the Rebbe hadn’t while we’re suffering, the eitzah is
The Midrash in Parashas Toldos davened for others who suffered from to daven for another person… for
teaches us an amazing yesod regarding this illness.” your friend’s son.
Havineini // Parshas Chayei Sarah
9
When the Binyan David Davened same way a person who understands However, from a letter by Rav
the pain will daven. He will never Akiva Eiger, we learn that even
The truth is that it goes even approach with that brokenness… with davening on the lower level can be
further. In the past, we have told the that humility before the Ribbono shel effective in producing a yeshuah. He
story of Rav Dovid Dov Meisels of Olam, the way a person who has been writes, “I see from your letter that
Uhel (1875-1944), author of Binyan tested will come. you’re not in the best of health,
David, who was in danger of being and I too, sadly, find myself in this
drafted into the army. He came to He doesn’t mind davening for situation, and I advise you, if it’s not
his rebbe, the Shinover Rav, and the others. Sure! What’s his name? I’ll too difficult, to keep me in mind
Rebbe told him, “Know that min daven for him. Often, people go in your tefillos, and thus it will be
haShamayim, they decreed this gezeirah to mekomos hakedoshim, and they fulfilled ‘one who davens for another
on you because so many Jewish boys publicize that people should send person will be answered first.’”
are suffering from the same fate, and names. It’s wonderful…. But they
are in great need of a yeshuah—and don’t get the pain that others are Really Meaning It
when you will daven, and your tefillah going through. They don’t have the
will be accepted in the merit of your brokenness, the humility, and the The commentaries on the Shelah
illustrious ancestors, they, too, will dependence on the Ribbono shel HaKadosh teach us that, ideally, כל
be helped. Go and pour out your Olam the way someone who has המתפלל בעד חבירוmeans that he shouldn’t
heart for a yeshuah, and youall will experienced that pain does. think about himself at all. But one must
be helped!” And, of course, that is know that there are levels in this. As we
indeed what happened: The Binyan But when someone is in the same have seen in the Tiferes Shlomo, this is
David davened for a yeshuah, and he matzav and he knows the pain, his not a game… it is dependent upon the
was freed along with a number of understanding is very different— heart, and the better one does in this
other bachurim. and he has the power to open wide the regard, the better the quality of his
chambers in his heart, and by extension tefillah will be.
A Deeper Understanding of Pain the corresponding chambers Above
that others cannot. One must understand that the
This incredible yesod is not only
more he takes himself out of the
for people from illustrious stock. For this reason, it is incumbent upon picture, the more his tefillah will
A person must view the situation us to utilize this opportunity of the be effective. One may say, “I know
in the following way: HaKadosh experience to daven for others in this myself, and I know that I will think
Baruch Hu gave me this pain, situation.
about my own needs.” B’seder. But he
and because I have this pain, I
should at least try to do his best
possess keys that not everyone We find that when Sarah Imeinu to think about others as much as
else has. Through my experience, became expectant, all other barren possible. A person should never give
I can daven for this yeshuah in a women were likewise helped. Why is up (the perfect is the enemy of the
way that few others can—because this? Because once the conduit for the good). He shouldn’t say, “Because I
my understanding of it is so much yeshuah was opened, it was opened for know that it can benefit me, I will
deeper. My pain… my yearning for everyone. Thus, we find that when a no longer merit the benefit of כל
the tzarah to go away… is felt by person is in need of a yeshuah, it is a המתפלל בעד חבירו.” No. It’s not “yes
me more than by anyone else. And marvelous opportunity to daven for or no.” It depends on the heart…
why did the Ribbono shel Olam give another person. meaning that one should care about
it to me? Aside from the individual
another person.
calculation for a tzarah, there is
Two Levels in Davening for Others
another cheshbon: Now I can daven
An Emissary for Others
for this as no one else can, and
I have the keys to chambers that But the truth is that even in
others do not. davening for others, there are various When we see that there’s a burning
levels. One way to do it is as a segulah; need in Klal Yisrael, and Klal Yisrael
Utilizing the Opportunity to intentionally daven for others so is in need of zechuyos in a given area—
that he will merit a yeshuah, but namely shidduchim—the Yiddishe
Sometimes, we tell a person to the more altruistic way is to daven perspective is to conclude that the
daven for a certain inyan. This person for others solely for them to merit מקטרגיםobviously have a hold on this
will never be able to daven for that the a yeshuah. issue. But how is this possible? There is
10 Havineini // Parshas Chayei Sarah
so much tefillah and so much chessed in on a greater level of l’shem Shamayim, to daven for them—because his tefillah
this area! our actions have more power—and will have so much more meaning and
Chazal constantly exhort us to daven power.
The truth is, the experts tell us that for others.
much more chessed is needed in this
As a result of these tefillos, the
regard—we must do much better in When a person finds himself in a
caring about other people’s shidduchim, state of pain, he should see himself as a Ribbono shel Olam will surely have
to think about shidduchim, and to shaliach tzibur, a messenger to daven on rachmanus and send yeshuos and refuos
suggest shidduchim. When we operate behalf of others—to do for them and for all Klal Yisrael.
him and benefit him in certain ways— He heads to the hospital chapel to
Point to Ponder daven with the minyan at nine o’clock,
what is he to do? He may say, “Of course,
it’s important to fulfill my obligations to and his davening is permeated with such
<<< Continued from page 12
Hashem…. But let’s be practical; this person warmth and feeling.
with the father. He accepted the gig only can help me! In fact, his assistance may even
As he reaches Nishmas, he notices
because the father told him how much lead to a kiddush Hashem!”
his friend davening alongside him. “May
joy it would bring him! Hashem help that everything should go well
Who Has Your Heart? for him as well….” His mind is consumed
Now, when the bachurim bombard
The Chovos HaLevavos is teaching us with gratitude, focused on the Ribbono
him with their requests, he doesn’t even
a basic idea: When we do something, shel Olam’s kindness. It doesn’t enter his
consider for a moment disappointing
we become emotionally connected to mind to think about how others perceive
his close friend. He’s incapable of doing
someone. The question is only to whom? him, or how others see him daven. Such
so—no matter what it may mean for his
thoughts may come at other times, but
career! His heart tells him, “You must If our hearts were empty before this,
not now.
satisfy the one who has done all this good if we didn’t begin with an endeavor
for you; you need to bring joy to your friend, to bring pleasure to the Ribbono shel Now, he’s consumed and overcome
who will remain a friend long after this Olam, we will have a struggle when faced with thoughts about Hashem. He’s
evening. He’s my friend, and I don’t want with a choice of whom to please. But emotionally connected to Hashem—and
to disappoint him. Not because I can’t, but if our hearts lie with Hashem, and we when a person is in such a state, there’s
because my heart won’t allow me to!” constantly think about all the good that simply no room for any other thoughts
Hashem has done for us, we will not or allegiances.
How Deep Is Our Relationship even be tempted to deviate from our
with Hashem? Ultimately, this is the yesod that the
allegiance to Him.
Chovos HaLevavos teaches us. The question
The Chovos HaLevavos (Sha’ar Yichud
Even if we aren’t yet on the loftiest is not merely whom we are supposed to
HaMa’aseh) teaches us this yesod: There’s
please, but to whom we are emotionally
a person who has no connection with madreigah—we have much work and
connected. When our relationship with
the Ribbono shel Olam. Yes, he serves meditation to do in recognizing Hashem’s
the Ribbono shel Olam is real, and we
Hashem, but he doesn’t have the closeness wisdom and kindness, and in developing live with an awareness of the countless
and the relationship of desiring to satisfy deeper gratitude to Hashem—however, if kindnesses He shows us, pleasing Him is
Him and please Him. He doesn’t walk we’re now moved by the goodness that
around with a feeling of deep gratitude no longer just an obligation. It becomes
Hashem has done for us, we will daven a desire of the heart. Just as the musician
for all the goodness that Hashem has
differently, and we won’t be so easily who truly loves his friend cannot bear to
done for him.
swayed. disappoint him, a person whose heart is
In fact, he even has some complaints. filled with gratitude to Hashem will find
“If you’re going to talk to me about Hashem, Nishmas in the Hospital himself far less vulnerable to the pull
it’s better that you do not… I’ve been of other people’s approval. We may not
Let us give a mashal for this: Imagine
struggling with my parnassah for seven years yet be great ba’alei madreigah, but every
a person who hasn’t yet fully developed time we stop to recognize a kindness
already….”
his sense of gratitude to Hashem but Hashem has done for us, we deepen
When this person is about to engage now finds himself filled with praise and that connection. And the deeper that
in a matter of avodas Hashem, but gratitude to Him. It’s Shabbos morning, connection becomes, the less room there
then another person walks in—and it’s and he’s at the hospital because his wife is in our hearts for anything that would
someone who has the potential to help just delivered a healthy baby. take us away from Him.
Havineini // Parshas Chayei Sarah
11
Point to Ponder The Power of a Personal Connection
When Everyone Wants Some- dead over here…. We can’t dance this to himself, “Listen, he’s from the old
thing Different way. Maybe you can play something generation… he doesn’t get it. I know that
we like….” he’s the one who hired me, but I’ll reconcile
It often happens that when a
with him later. If he asks for the money
musician arrives at a wedding, and
Whose Approval Matters Most? back, we’ll deal with it then. Anyway,
the parents of the chassan/kallah, the
he surely won’t ask for all the money
people who hired him, are specific The musician is now in a difficult back, because, after all, I played very
about the type of music they want position. warmly and emotionally at the chuppah….
that evening. “Please don’t play the
I need to think about the long term…
trendy and modern music… if it can On the one hand, he’s desperate to my own musical career. Right now, these
even be called music,” they may say. enter the market. He’s a bit new to the boys are standing here, itching to dance.”
industry, and he would really like the These are some of the thoughts going
The chassan’s father may say, “A bachurim to approve of his abilities. through his mind, if he doesn’t have
chasunah is a holy and exalted affair, Word gets around, and getting a good any particular allegiance to the father.
and I’m hiring you on condition that name will help him break into the field
you will play normal music…. It’s and make a good living. He simply
my child’s wedding, and I want to needs the parnassah! As he stands at
When the Mechutan Is a Close
rejoice and give thanks to Hashem the wedding, he has a serious dilemma: Friend
for a wonderful simchah…. Wild and Which way will he go? What will happen, however, if the
modern music will rob me of this mechutan is a close friend? The musician
ability, and it will only create noise The answer is very simple. The has known him for years, and he’s now
and distraction…. Please….” determining factor will be: How about to bring joy to the wedding of
deep is his connection to the chassan’s his friend’s child. In fact, initially he
At the wedding itself, the chassan’s father? didn’t want to take the job, because
friends who have already arrived are he wanted to rejoice at the wedding
raring to go. They frequently approach If there is no connection, the properly. He even abandoned his post
the musician, saying, “Come on, it’s musician will dismiss him, saying during the dancing so he could dance
Continued on page 11 >>>
Our Sponsors
אדר שבט טבת כסלו
חשון
חשון תשרי
תשרי
Akiva Akiva
Garfinkel
Dovid Dovid
Tzvi Reifer Jake Willner Eli Levine Shmuli Feiler
- Garfinkel
Seitler-
Chicago Seitler
אלול אב תמוז סיון אייר ניסן
Mayer Cohen
Aveeshi Lev Akiva Yanky Shimmy
Tzvi Ray לע"נ בן ציון ב"ר
לע"נ גבריאל ב"ר Garfinkel Feiler Webster אברהם יעקב
צבי הלוי ע"ה הכהן ז"ל
Havinieni Hotline U.S. 718.686.8300 E.Y. 072.257.7726 U.K. 0333.070.6585 B.E. 0480.20.16.18
Our Gilyon can be obtained at the following places
Khal Chasidim, Khal Zidochov
Chodorov, Khal Zichron Yoel, Khal KMH, Hachaim
Boro Park Kosher Discount, Monsey Rodoshitz - Airmont, Williamsburg Central Market Chicago Chesed, L’ Avrohom Zidochov, Beis Five Towns V'Hashalom, Aish
The Winery 18 Ave Scheiner's
Medrash Mekor Hachayim kodesh
H a v i n e i n i O ffi c e - 7 1 8 -3 87- 1 1 2 2 // S i g n u p to re c e i v e d a i l y S h i u r i m a n d w e e k l y p u b l i c a t i o n s - I n f o @ m a c h o n h a v i n e i n i . c o m
12 Havineini // Parshas Chayei Sarah
